Comments 2014
So long, for now
December 15, 2014
Thank you. Your news pages are eagerly awaited and much appreciated. Look forward to next year.
John Mutsaers, Inverloch
Thanks for your good community news updates over the year. Enjoy your holidays.
Tim Wilson, Wonthaggi
Thank you for the immense amount of time you spend for the enjoyment of others. I look forward to the interesting stories you seem to find about our region. A few years ago, I was one of the few civil marriage celebrants in South Gippsland. We were kept very busy in the years from 1980 to just after 2004. Nowdays there seems to be celebrants everywhere, and their prices charged are considerably more than we charged. Perhaps I won’t say how many weddings I had the honour to perform in South Gippsland, but it was a real privilege to be asked to officiate at one of the important phases in the life of married couples. Enjoy your break for Christmas.
Tom Parsons Leongatha.
Dear Catherine and team for the best local publication in Bass Coast! Through the year, I have been informed about local issues, opinions, I have laughed, cried and been inspired to go walking looking for birds and plants.
If I did not meditate daily, I would have been made angry by some misleading, half-true statements by our environment minister. Wanted to respond to add my little bit but ... load already too heavy. I look forward to joining your talented team after the Kongor Primary School is built...when I retire for the second time.
Have a happy, restful break.
Felicia Di Stefano, Glen Forbes
Bay battle’s not over
December 8, 2014
I agree with Michael Whelan's comments about the future of Westernport. I believe that it should be preserved in legislation and not industrialised into a mega container Port but enhanced not only for Eco-tourism, but for the Eco-systems services Westernport provides the State of Victoria. We need natural environments for human and animal survival
as well as the amenity natural environments provide!
Carmen Bush, Rhyll
December 7, 2014
Thanks to the Preserve Western Port group but I agree the work has just begun.
The Liberal MP for Bass, Brian Paynter, says he expects the Port of Hastings Development Authority to complete the business plan for the Port extension (New MP promises action). It demonstrates the ever-present threat to Western Port. The Port of Hastings Development Authority should be abolished immediately and Preserve Western Port should seek an early meeting with the new Minister to seek this as part of establishing the new Infrastructure Victoria.
I would like to see Preserve Western Port develop a vision for Western Port that puts industrialisation beyond reach. Western Port should become a conservation, tourism and recreational (fishing and boating) mecca. This could be done via legislation that reflects Western Port's special status as a place that celebrates Ramsar wetlands, the diversity of its fauna and wildlife, and protects people's ability to enjoy the bay and to protect it for future generations.
Michael Whelan, Cowes
Street wise
December 7, 2014
Thanks, Tim, for your thought-provoking article on the homogenous big boxes on little blocks that keep pushing out into our “ever-diminishing supply of farmland and bushland”'. And thanks, Natasha, for another cartoon that captures the point so succinctly.
New housing developments have always looked ugly until they become softened with greenery. But when houses cover most of the block, there's no room to grow a tree or even a few shrubs. With no shade in summer, no wonder every house “'needs”' an air-conditioner. Bigger houses cost more (to the occupants and the environment) to heat and cool. As each new cloned housing estate eats into the landscape, it takes another bite out of the uniqueness of our coast.
Linda Cuttriss, Ventnor
December 6, 2014
Yes Tim Shannon; I agree. Considering the ugly small-site development becoming common in South Gippsland, I would add that well designed low-rise apartment buildings (two to four storeys) clearly offer better aesthetic and social values than the small units mushrooming around us on tiny 'unit' blocks.
There is no reason why Bass Coast Council shouldn't create incentives to stimulate appropriate apartment development in towns such as Wonthaggi and Inverloch.
Michelle Nelson, Wonthaggi
December 6, 2014
Tim, I really enjoyed your commentary on the role of different zones of a house on a block and especially the discussion on the ambiguity of a fenceless front garden. Thanks.
Liz Low www.lizsenseofplaces.com
December 6, 2014
I too lament the passing of the typical and unique Australian suburban house with its individuality, privacy, green space, front garden and family friendly back yard. No longer will the streetscape have individuality in housing or front garden design. The welcome sound of healthy children playing back yard touch and run cricket, or footy, is lost, as private open space shrinks to be replaced by the mind and communication destroying addiction to computer games and TV viewing.
Why is it so. One could point to the changing pattern and demands of society. The lack of personal time to create and lovingly tend a garden. The advent of technology replacing the need for creativity in a physical sense. The cost of housing, land and commuting, in our ever expanding cities.
Are these changes forced onto us by circumstances beyond our control, or are they compounded by planning inadequacies, the lack of political will to consider quality of life above the economic demands of development.
Australia is in a unique position with the space to plan urban development to maintain and improve our quality of life. The endless expansion of the major cities is a shortsighted, knee jerk, unconsidered response to population increase, country to city migration, city centric planning and the total lack of Government vision and support for decentralization.
As cities relentlessly expand without restriction, not only does the quality of life and the opportunity for reclaiming our unique Australian suburban house and outdoor lifestyle diminish. the cost of living and commuting increase at the expense of arable farming land being destroyed by the urban sprawl.
The time to reassess our direction, and act, is now.
Ian Samuel, Ventnor-Cowes
Vote of confidence
December 7, 2014
Loved your article and the photo of the old voting booth! It easy to forget what a privilege it is to vote and the freedom we have to talk about about it!! See you next time when I'm handing how to vote cards and thanks for getting the coffee.
Pat Butinar
December 7, 2014
Congratulations on the wisdom to learn from experiences, Catherine. About being "right" or "wrong", though, Shakespeare says "there's nothing right or wrong but thinking makes it so." (cannot remember which play). Oscar Wilde says that "Nothing that ever happened is of the slightest importance.” Professor Peter Singer says that a thing is good if it benefits most people and bad if it hurts people. I agree with all three.
I made some friends this year handing out how to vote cards and sold some Bass Coast calendars.
Felicia Di Stefano, Glen Forbes
December 7, 2014
Thank you for article, Catherine. Both Barbara and I were heavily involved in the handing out of how to vote cards on election day as well as at the pre-polling centres. We were involved mainly at the Cowes and Pakenham pre-polling centres and had some long and wonderful, if frequently interrupted, conversations with people handing out for most of the parties involved.
On the rare occasions that a voter attending the centres decided to get a bit "uppity" with one of the volunteers handing out, another of the volunteers – regardless of political flavour – would be very quickly at their elbow providing collegial support. I stress again that it happened rarely.
A very common theme to the conversations was that of our great fortune that we lived in a country where people of opposing political views could work and talk and laugh together as we helped the process along. We didn’t have to worry about guns, assaults, violence and persecution. Sobering.
With regard to folk not taking any How-To-Vote cards, I would like to point out that many tech-savvy folk had in fact downloaded their chosen How-To-Vote cards onto their mobile ‘phones. It is regrettable therefore to note that the current 5.42 per cent of votes being cast informally is not exceptional for Bass, it is sadly consistent.
I do concur with the feelings expressed regarding first time voters. During the two weeks of voting, few things gave me greater pleasure than shaking the hands of a large number of first-time voters as they left having cast their first vote. This old grey bear had a lump in his throat more than once.
Ross Fairhurst, Greens candidate for Bass
Independent makes her mark
December 5, 2014
Naptime is over. Well done Team(s). After all that hard work we might not have exactly the result we wanted but the people of Bass District have sent a strong message for change.
Now the hard work really starts. If we are to get the schools, hospitals, roads and employment opportunities that we, and our families, deserve, we need to stay active and vocal. The more people attend rallies and complain to their representatives, the more attention we, as a community, will receive.
Analysis of the latest results can support several “what if” scenarios but the obvious lesson to be learnt is that well organised, long-term, grassroots campaigns supporting decent candidates can counter profligate spending on signs and glossy mailouts if voters are engaged.
The issues in this electorate have not changed. The likelihood is that we will receive some more funding but we need to monitor progress and maintain the pressure. Good politicians listen all the time. This time we achieved an 8 per cent swing against the incumbent party. Next state election a 6 per cent swing will unseat the member. A lot of promises have been made; let’s see how many are kept.
At most, there are two years left before the next federal election. Hopefully the MPs for Flinders and McMillan are listening. The “Infrastructure Prime Minister” should know that we don’t support the Hastings development proposals, the $7 co-payment, higher university fees and higher fuel prices.
One thing that occurs to me in regards to “what if” in relation to election results is that over 4 per cent of voters don’t cast a valid vote. That’s more votes than the A.C.A. received. There are also a number of people who deliberately remain unenrolled. That’s a lot of votes to be mined if someone can work out how. Certainly some informal votes are accidental but there seems to be a chasm of disengagement to be overcome. The first step is to make everyone realise how valuable their vote is.
Geoff Ellis, Wattle Bank
December 5, 2014
Dear Sanjay Nathan, further to your comment on 3rd December, you certainly do have to learn a lot more about the preferential voting system. Clare Le Serve ran a very successful campaign because she had excellent knowledge of the Bass electorate and has lived in the electorate for over 40 years. The fact that she ran as an independent meant that she did not have the strong backing and financial support of candidates such as yourself for the Australian Labor Party and Brian Paynter for the Liberals.
In Australia we live in a democracy and our voting system for the State Government elections is NOT about which candidate is first past the post, because if a candidate doesn't get 50% of the primary vote then it is all about preferences - and that is what Phil Wright articulated very well in his letter dated 1st December.
Phyllis Papps, Rhyll
December 3, 2014
I am curious as to how 11 per cent of the primary vote represents a successful campaign.
Sanjay Nathan, ALP candidate for Bass
December 15, 2014
Thank you. Your news pages are eagerly awaited and much appreciated. Look forward to next year.
John Mutsaers, Inverloch
Thanks for your good community news updates over the year. Enjoy your holidays.
Tim Wilson, Wonthaggi
Thank you for the immense amount of time you spend for the enjoyment of others. I look forward to the interesting stories you seem to find about our region. A few years ago, I was one of the few civil marriage celebrants in South Gippsland. We were kept very busy in the years from 1980 to just after 2004. Nowdays there seems to be celebrants everywhere, and their prices charged are considerably more than we charged. Perhaps I won’t say how many weddings I had the honour to perform in South Gippsland, but it was a real privilege to be asked to officiate at one of the important phases in the life of married couples. Enjoy your break for Christmas.
Tom Parsons Leongatha.
Dear Catherine and team for the best local publication in Bass Coast! Through the year, I have been informed about local issues, opinions, I have laughed, cried and been inspired to go walking looking for birds and plants.
If I did not meditate daily, I would have been made angry by some misleading, half-true statements by our environment minister. Wanted to respond to add my little bit but ... load already too heavy. I look forward to joining your talented team after the Kongor Primary School is built...when I retire for the second time.
Have a happy, restful break.
Felicia Di Stefano, Glen Forbes
Bay battle’s not over
December 8, 2014
I agree with Michael Whelan's comments about the future of Westernport. I believe that it should be preserved in legislation and not industrialised into a mega container Port but enhanced not only for Eco-tourism, but for the Eco-systems services Westernport provides the State of Victoria. We need natural environments for human and animal survival
as well as the amenity natural environments provide!
Carmen Bush, Rhyll
December 7, 2014
Thanks to the Preserve Western Port group but I agree the work has just begun.
The Liberal MP for Bass, Brian Paynter, says he expects the Port of Hastings Development Authority to complete the business plan for the Port extension (New MP promises action). It demonstrates the ever-present threat to Western Port. The Port of Hastings Development Authority should be abolished immediately and Preserve Western Port should seek an early meeting with the new Minister to seek this as part of establishing the new Infrastructure Victoria.
I would like to see Preserve Western Port develop a vision for Western Port that puts industrialisation beyond reach. Western Port should become a conservation, tourism and recreational (fishing and boating) mecca. This could be done via legislation that reflects Western Port's special status as a place that celebrates Ramsar wetlands, the diversity of its fauna and wildlife, and protects people's ability to enjoy the bay and to protect it for future generations.
Michael Whelan, Cowes
Street wise
December 7, 2014
Thanks, Tim, for your thought-provoking article on the homogenous big boxes on little blocks that keep pushing out into our “ever-diminishing supply of farmland and bushland”'. And thanks, Natasha, for another cartoon that captures the point so succinctly.
New housing developments have always looked ugly until they become softened with greenery. But when houses cover most of the block, there's no room to grow a tree or even a few shrubs. With no shade in summer, no wonder every house “'needs”' an air-conditioner. Bigger houses cost more (to the occupants and the environment) to heat and cool. As each new cloned housing estate eats into the landscape, it takes another bite out of the uniqueness of our coast.
Linda Cuttriss, Ventnor
December 6, 2014
Yes Tim Shannon; I agree. Considering the ugly small-site development becoming common in South Gippsland, I would add that well designed low-rise apartment buildings (two to four storeys) clearly offer better aesthetic and social values than the small units mushrooming around us on tiny 'unit' blocks.
There is no reason why Bass Coast Council shouldn't create incentives to stimulate appropriate apartment development in towns such as Wonthaggi and Inverloch.
Michelle Nelson, Wonthaggi
December 6, 2014
Tim, I really enjoyed your commentary on the role of different zones of a house on a block and especially the discussion on the ambiguity of a fenceless front garden. Thanks.
Liz Low www.lizsenseofplaces.com
December 6, 2014
I too lament the passing of the typical and unique Australian suburban house with its individuality, privacy, green space, front garden and family friendly back yard. No longer will the streetscape have individuality in housing or front garden design. The welcome sound of healthy children playing back yard touch and run cricket, or footy, is lost, as private open space shrinks to be replaced by the mind and communication destroying addiction to computer games and TV viewing.
Why is it so. One could point to the changing pattern and demands of society. The lack of personal time to create and lovingly tend a garden. The advent of technology replacing the need for creativity in a physical sense. The cost of housing, land and commuting, in our ever expanding cities.
Are these changes forced onto us by circumstances beyond our control, or are they compounded by planning inadequacies, the lack of political will to consider quality of life above the economic demands of development.
Australia is in a unique position with the space to plan urban development to maintain and improve our quality of life. The endless expansion of the major cities is a shortsighted, knee jerk, unconsidered response to population increase, country to city migration, city centric planning and the total lack of Government vision and support for decentralization.
As cities relentlessly expand without restriction, not only does the quality of life and the opportunity for reclaiming our unique Australian suburban house and outdoor lifestyle diminish. the cost of living and commuting increase at the expense of arable farming land being destroyed by the urban sprawl.
The time to reassess our direction, and act, is now.
Ian Samuel, Ventnor-Cowes
Vote of confidence
December 7, 2014
Loved your article and the photo of the old voting booth! It easy to forget what a privilege it is to vote and the freedom we have to talk about about it!! See you next time when I'm handing how to vote cards and thanks for getting the coffee.
Pat Butinar
December 7, 2014
Congratulations on the wisdom to learn from experiences, Catherine. About being "right" or "wrong", though, Shakespeare says "there's nothing right or wrong but thinking makes it so." (cannot remember which play). Oscar Wilde says that "Nothing that ever happened is of the slightest importance.” Professor Peter Singer says that a thing is good if it benefits most people and bad if it hurts people. I agree with all three.
I made some friends this year handing out how to vote cards and sold some Bass Coast calendars.
Felicia Di Stefano, Glen Forbes
December 7, 2014
Thank you for article, Catherine. Both Barbara and I were heavily involved in the handing out of how to vote cards on election day as well as at the pre-polling centres. We were involved mainly at the Cowes and Pakenham pre-polling centres and had some long and wonderful, if frequently interrupted, conversations with people handing out for most of the parties involved.
On the rare occasions that a voter attending the centres decided to get a bit "uppity" with one of the volunteers handing out, another of the volunteers – regardless of political flavour – would be very quickly at their elbow providing collegial support. I stress again that it happened rarely.
A very common theme to the conversations was that of our great fortune that we lived in a country where people of opposing political views could work and talk and laugh together as we helped the process along. We didn’t have to worry about guns, assaults, violence and persecution. Sobering.
With regard to folk not taking any How-To-Vote cards, I would like to point out that many tech-savvy folk had in fact downloaded their chosen How-To-Vote cards onto their mobile ‘phones. It is regrettable therefore to note that the current 5.42 per cent of votes being cast informally is not exceptional for Bass, it is sadly consistent.
I do concur with the feelings expressed regarding first time voters. During the two weeks of voting, few things gave me greater pleasure than shaking the hands of a large number of first-time voters as they left having cast their first vote. This old grey bear had a lump in his throat more than once.
Ross Fairhurst, Greens candidate for Bass
Independent makes her mark
December 5, 2014
Naptime is over. Well done Team(s). After all that hard work we might not have exactly the result we wanted but the people of Bass District have sent a strong message for change.
Now the hard work really starts. If we are to get the schools, hospitals, roads and employment opportunities that we, and our families, deserve, we need to stay active and vocal. The more people attend rallies and complain to their representatives, the more attention we, as a community, will receive.
Analysis of the latest results can support several “what if” scenarios but the obvious lesson to be learnt is that well organised, long-term, grassroots campaigns supporting decent candidates can counter profligate spending on signs and glossy mailouts if voters are engaged.
The issues in this electorate have not changed. The likelihood is that we will receive some more funding but we need to monitor progress and maintain the pressure. Good politicians listen all the time. This time we achieved an 8 per cent swing against the incumbent party. Next state election a 6 per cent swing will unseat the member. A lot of promises have been made; let’s see how many are kept.
At most, there are two years left before the next federal election. Hopefully the MPs for Flinders and McMillan are listening. The “Infrastructure Prime Minister” should know that we don’t support the Hastings development proposals, the $7 co-payment, higher university fees and higher fuel prices.
One thing that occurs to me in regards to “what if” in relation to election results is that over 4 per cent of voters don’t cast a valid vote. That’s more votes than the A.C.A. received. There are also a number of people who deliberately remain unenrolled. That’s a lot of votes to be mined if someone can work out how. Certainly some informal votes are accidental but there seems to be a chasm of disengagement to be overcome. The first step is to make everyone realise how valuable their vote is.
Geoff Ellis, Wattle Bank
December 5, 2014
Dear Sanjay Nathan, further to your comment on 3rd December, you certainly do have to learn a lot more about the preferential voting system. Clare Le Serve ran a very successful campaign because she had excellent knowledge of the Bass electorate and has lived in the electorate for over 40 years. The fact that she ran as an independent meant that she did not have the strong backing and financial support of candidates such as yourself for the Australian Labor Party and Brian Paynter for the Liberals.
In Australia we live in a democracy and our voting system for the State Government elections is NOT about which candidate is first past the post, because if a candidate doesn't get 50% of the primary vote then it is all about preferences - and that is what Phil Wright articulated very well in his letter dated 1st December.
Phyllis Papps, Rhyll
December 3, 2014
I am curious as to how 11 per cent of the primary vote represents a successful campaign.
Sanjay Nathan, ALP candidate for Bass
December 1, 2014
The only challenger Brian Paynter (Liberal) had is Clare Le Serve (independent). Sanjay Nathan (ALP) never had a chance. Here is an explanation of the numbers from Clare’s perspective. There were a number of criteria for her to win:
She needed 5 per cent of ALP voters and then to beat ALP after Greens distribution. ALP preferences would have gone to Clare and she may have beaten Liberal.
Phil Wright, Surf Beach
November 30, 2014
For those of us who have been involved in Clare Le Serve’s campaign as an independent to represent the electorate of Bass, it has been a wonderful and worthwhile experience.
The objective was, whilst a victory would have been fantastic, to make the electorate marginal and to make it matter. Clare has achieved this !
Whilst Bass remains a safe seat, the electorate will continue to be fed “the crumbs”, as was evident by the token last-minute promises in the twilight of the campaign. Why could this not have happened during the last four years of the former government’s time?
Meanwhile our dreams of better health and education outcomes remain unfilled.
Anne Davie, Ventnor
November 30, 2014
The VEC website shows a swing of 7.2 per ncent in Bass to the ALP, with a campaign fund of just under $2000. Sanjay Nathan impressed many in the electorate and we are grateful he put his time and energy into learning about Bass Coast and working so hard for them over such a short period of time. He could be a rising star.
Veronica Dowman
2014 state election
December 1, 2014
Excellent coverage of the election. Great profiles of the candidates. Fair and inbiased reporting of the issues that matter in Bass.
Well done, Bass Coast Post.
James Archibald, Wonthaggi
November 30, 2014
Thanks for your excellent coverage of the 2014 State election. The profiles, in particular, provided a really good insight into the candidates. Thanks for keeping us up to date with the major parties' responses (or lack thereof) to the key issues in our area and for the local results the day after the election.
Linda Cuttriss, Ventnor
November 28, 2014
Many thanks for your excellent election profiles - and for providing such a high-quality news service.
Murray Griffin, Wonthaggi
It’s my ABC and I’ll cry if I want to
November 30, 2014
While it is true the lose of Poetica on Radio National, for example, may not be top priority or concern for everyone, what worries me is the overall threat to our unique Australian voice.
Our stories, whether they are told through the media of film, literature, poetry or song, support our identity. The power of recent TV such as Redfern Now, Days of our Lives,Healing, to name a few, and our particular brand of humour are important.. It would be impossible to appreciate these stories as their creators intended if they were on commercial TV.
Although sport is a healthy pursuit the does not necessarily extend to being a sports spectator. We surely have progressed beyond the image of being merely a nation of sports fanatics.
A nation grows in all directions and offers enrichment in all fields in which its people participate.
The ABC and SBS offer those alternatives. If we lose our voice we are in danger of becoming a satelite rather than a shining globe.
Heather Tobias, Wonthaggi
November 30, 2014
I'm also mourning the loss of Bush Telegraph because it always makes me feel included in the rural community and I love hearing the stimulating agricultural production ideas people have. I'll be relying more heavily for that input from good ole Bass Coast Post!
Hilary Stuchbery
What a performance!
November 30, 2014
Thank you Linda Cutriss for your astutely observed and well told story of days
in the life of your magpie family.
Though ornithologists tell us that their early morning carolling is a battle cry
warning off would be intruders, it is still the best of wake-up calls.
It always reminds me of Banjo Paterson's poem In Defence of the Bush, which
he wrote in response to a poem by Henry Lawson which criticised the harshness and
hardships of the Aussie bush. In part Paterson's poem reads:
Did you hear no sweeter voices in the music of the bush
Than the roar of trams and buses, and the war-whoop of "the push"?
Did the magpies rouse your slumbers with their carol sweet and strange?
Did you hear the silver chiming of the bell-birds on the range?
Paterson concludes with the cutting remark:
You had better stick to Sydney and make merry with the "push",
For the bush will never suit you, you'll never suit the bush.
Bob Middleton, Jeetho West
Wallaby fight club
November 24, 2014
This afternoon as I welcomed the sound of the rain falling on our roof, I logged on to yourPost. I would like to thank both Linda Cuttriss for her stories and taking me away from everyday life, and also Simon Chipper for his wonderful photos and again taking me to another place that I thought I knew so well.
It was a wonderful escape, I look forward to more.
Glenda Salter, Smiths Beach
Young turk with a difference
November 23, 2014
Thanks for providing even handed coverage of the State Election campaign. The articles about the candidates have been particularly enlightening and present a marked contrast to papers that cost me a $1.40 each week.
The article on Nathan Sanjay was a very good profile of a great candidate working hard to achieve good outcomes for his chosen electorate.
I suspect that his efforts, and the efforts of the Independent Candidate, have given Team Blue real concerns about their stranglehold on this electorate. This has resulted in commitments such as the Liberal Party's promise to rebuild Wonthaggi Secondary College if Mr Not K. Smith is elected.
The extra attention that this area is suddenly receiving from the incumbent party supports the proposition that the only way to get the roads fixed, the schools modernized and the health system upgraded is to make Bass District a marginal electorate by putting the incumbent coalition last.
Keep up the good work!
Geoff Ellis, Wattle Bank
A straight shooter
November 23, 2014
Mr Reid seems to have been able to make choices in his life and yet he is against others having the opportunity to make them. Some choices are governed by more than a temporary curiosity. The best thing a young person can have is respect which builds their self esteem - whatever their choice maybe.
The most despicable behaviour is discrimination: whether it is sexual, racial or based on physical appearance or social standing.
The damage caused by bullying is alive and well at all age levels. It doesn't stop at the school gate. It remains with the victim for life. The fact that schools are now recognising the need to prevent it, should be applauded not maligned.
Another thing, Homosexuality isn't a religion: you can't covert someone into it like you can, for example, Christianity, Islam or Buddhism.
Equality of rights to a fulfilling and rich life is for everyone, even Mr Reid.
Heather Murray Tobias, Wonthaggi
a victim of bullying
because my parents were divorced
because I was poor
because of my physical appearance
because of my very fair skin ...
and in the work place because I was female.
When knowledge is power
November 23, 2014
Welcome Kimberley Brown. We look forward to hearing more from you.
Felicia Di Stefano, Glen Forbes
A cook's journal
November 23, 2014
Thank you, Jan Cheshire, you continue to add to my Boys Only Cookbook. Your no-nonsense and precise recipes are gems.
My kitchen bible is The Presbyterian Cookery Book, born in 1895 though my edition
is a somewhat later model. Even so it is pre-metric which requires calculations
beyond my mental capacity, the preserves all call for pressure cookers which we don't
own and there is the absence of a microwave due to tight kitchen bench space.
The lemon curd will be a challenge but I am sure I will find a way through the maze.
Bob Middleton, Jeetho West
One tough customer
November 19, 2014
Ken Smith's stereotyping of some one as “a nice enough lady” but not tough enough is typical of the gender bias exhibited by the Liberal Party at national and state levels. How many women are in Federal Cabinet? If the ability to deal with undesirable drunks is a prerequisite for potential candidates what kind of social environment is being fostered by the Abbott and Napthine Governments and what sort of Parliament have they created?
Geoff Ellis, Wattle Bank
November 16, 2014
Delightful and helpful background to Independent Clare. Thank you.
Tim Shannon, Ventnor
Wallaby fight club
November 16, 2014
Great photos and a well written piece. Thoroughly enjoyed it. Typical males – all that for nothing!
Jane Denton
The only challenger Brian Paynter (Liberal) had is Clare Le Serve (independent). Sanjay Nathan (ALP) never had a chance. Here is an explanation of the numbers from Clare’s perspective. There were a number of criteria for her to win:
- Paynter could not receive more than 46 per cent. Achieved.
- The lower three parties could not receive more than 6 per cent. After distribution Paynter was on 49.7 per cent. Achieved.
- The preferences from lower 3 to follow the card to less than 80 per cent. Achieved.
- Clare’s vote after bottom 3 distribution to be higher than Green. Achieved
- Clare gets 90 per cent of Green preferences. Achieved.
- After Green distribution, Clare has higher than ALP. Failure – ALP 29 per cent, Clare 22 per cent.
- Clare goes out and 65 per cent of her preferences go to Paynter (Now 65 per cent) Liberal Win
She needed 5 per cent of ALP voters and then to beat ALP after Greens distribution. ALP preferences would have gone to Clare and she may have beaten Liberal.
Phil Wright, Surf Beach
November 30, 2014
For those of us who have been involved in Clare Le Serve’s campaign as an independent to represent the electorate of Bass, it has been a wonderful and worthwhile experience.
The objective was, whilst a victory would have been fantastic, to make the electorate marginal and to make it matter. Clare has achieved this !
Whilst Bass remains a safe seat, the electorate will continue to be fed “the crumbs”, as was evident by the token last-minute promises in the twilight of the campaign. Why could this not have happened during the last four years of the former government’s time?
Meanwhile our dreams of better health and education outcomes remain unfilled.
Anne Davie, Ventnor
November 30, 2014
The VEC website shows a swing of 7.2 per ncent in Bass to the ALP, with a campaign fund of just under $2000. Sanjay Nathan impressed many in the electorate and we are grateful he put his time and energy into learning about Bass Coast and working so hard for them over such a short period of time. He could be a rising star.
Veronica Dowman
2014 state election
December 1, 2014
Excellent coverage of the election. Great profiles of the candidates. Fair and inbiased reporting of the issues that matter in Bass.
Well done, Bass Coast Post.
James Archibald, Wonthaggi
November 30, 2014
Thanks for your excellent coverage of the 2014 State election. The profiles, in particular, provided a really good insight into the candidates. Thanks for keeping us up to date with the major parties' responses (or lack thereof) to the key issues in our area and for the local results the day after the election.
Linda Cuttriss, Ventnor
November 28, 2014
Many thanks for your excellent election profiles - and for providing such a high-quality news service.
Murray Griffin, Wonthaggi
It’s my ABC and I’ll cry if I want to
November 30, 2014
While it is true the lose of Poetica on Radio National, for example, may not be top priority or concern for everyone, what worries me is the overall threat to our unique Australian voice.
Our stories, whether they are told through the media of film, literature, poetry or song, support our identity. The power of recent TV such as Redfern Now, Days of our Lives,Healing, to name a few, and our particular brand of humour are important.. It would be impossible to appreciate these stories as their creators intended if they were on commercial TV.
Although sport is a healthy pursuit the does not necessarily extend to being a sports spectator. We surely have progressed beyond the image of being merely a nation of sports fanatics.
A nation grows in all directions and offers enrichment in all fields in which its people participate.
The ABC and SBS offer those alternatives. If we lose our voice we are in danger of becoming a satelite rather than a shining globe.
Heather Tobias, Wonthaggi
November 30, 2014
I'm also mourning the loss of Bush Telegraph because it always makes me feel included in the rural community and I love hearing the stimulating agricultural production ideas people have. I'll be relying more heavily for that input from good ole Bass Coast Post!
Hilary Stuchbery
What a performance!
November 30, 2014
Thank you Linda Cutriss for your astutely observed and well told story of days
in the life of your magpie family.
Though ornithologists tell us that their early morning carolling is a battle cry
warning off would be intruders, it is still the best of wake-up calls.
It always reminds me of Banjo Paterson's poem In Defence of the Bush, which
he wrote in response to a poem by Henry Lawson which criticised the harshness and
hardships of the Aussie bush. In part Paterson's poem reads:
Did you hear no sweeter voices in the music of the bush
Than the roar of trams and buses, and the war-whoop of "the push"?
Did the magpies rouse your slumbers with their carol sweet and strange?
Did you hear the silver chiming of the bell-birds on the range?
Paterson concludes with the cutting remark:
You had better stick to Sydney and make merry with the "push",
For the bush will never suit you, you'll never suit the bush.
Bob Middleton, Jeetho West
Wallaby fight club
November 24, 2014
This afternoon as I welcomed the sound of the rain falling on our roof, I logged on to yourPost. I would like to thank both Linda Cuttriss for her stories and taking me away from everyday life, and also Simon Chipper for his wonderful photos and again taking me to another place that I thought I knew so well.
It was a wonderful escape, I look forward to more.
Glenda Salter, Smiths Beach
Young turk with a difference
November 23, 2014
Thanks for providing even handed coverage of the State Election campaign. The articles about the candidates have been particularly enlightening and present a marked contrast to papers that cost me a $1.40 each week.
The article on Nathan Sanjay was a very good profile of a great candidate working hard to achieve good outcomes for his chosen electorate.
I suspect that his efforts, and the efforts of the Independent Candidate, have given Team Blue real concerns about their stranglehold on this electorate. This has resulted in commitments such as the Liberal Party's promise to rebuild Wonthaggi Secondary College if Mr Not K. Smith is elected.
The extra attention that this area is suddenly receiving from the incumbent party supports the proposition that the only way to get the roads fixed, the schools modernized and the health system upgraded is to make Bass District a marginal electorate by putting the incumbent coalition last.
Keep up the good work!
Geoff Ellis, Wattle Bank
A straight shooter
November 23, 2014
Mr Reid seems to have been able to make choices in his life and yet he is against others having the opportunity to make them. Some choices are governed by more than a temporary curiosity. The best thing a young person can have is respect which builds their self esteem - whatever their choice maybe.
The most despicable behaviour is discrimination: whether it is sexual, racial or based on physical appearance or social standing.
The damage caused by bullying is alive and well at all age levels. It doesn't stop at the school gate. It remains with the victim for life. The fact that schools are now recognising the need to prevent it, should be applauded not maligned.
Another thing, Homosexuality isn't a religion: you can't covert someone into it like you can, for example, Christianity, Islam or Buddhism.
Equality of rights to a fulfilling and rich life is for everyone, even Mr Reid.
Heather Murray Tobias, Wonthaggi
a victim of bullying
because my parents were divorced
because I was poor
because of my physical appearance
because of my very fair skin ...
and in the work place because I was female.
When knowledge is power
November 23, 2014
Welcome Kimberley Brown. We look forward to hearing more from you.
Felicia Di Stefano, Glen Forbes
A cook's journal
November 23, 2014
Thank you, Jan Cheshire, you continue to add to my Boys Only Cookbook. Your no-nonsense and precise recipes are gems.
My kitchen bible is The Presbyterian Cookery Book, born in 1895 though my edition
is a somewhat later model. Even so it is pre-metric which requires calculations
beyond my mental capacity, the preserves all call for pressure cookers which we don't
own and there is the absence of a microwave due to tight kitchen bench space.
The lemon curd will be a challenge but I am sure I will find a way through the maze.
Bob Middleton, Jeetho West
One tough customer
November 19, 2014
Ken Smith's stereotyping of some one as “a nice enough lady” but not tough enough is typical of the gender bias exhibited by the Liberal Party at national and state levels. How many women are in Federal Cabinet? If the ability to deal with undesirable drunks is a prerequisite for potential candidates what kind of social environment is being fostered by the Abbott and Napthine Governments and what sort of Parliament have they created?
Geoff Ellis, Wattle Bank
November 16, 2014
Delightful and helpful background to Independent Clare. Thank you.
Tim Shannon, Ventnor
Wallaby fight club
November 16, 2014
Great photos and a well written piece. Thoroughly enjoyed it. Typical males – all that for nothing!
Jane Denton
Open letter to Russell Broadbent
November 16, 2014
Congratulations to Linda Gordon on her fine letter to Russell Broadbent, a member of the Liberal Government who has also earned my respect for his stand on asylum seekers. Congratulations too for the article Political prisoners on how hard it must be for idealists to stick to their ideals in politics. Well, Russell Broadbent is one who is trying to!
Best wishes to you and Bass Coast Post. You are doing a magnificent job presenting thoughts, opinions, ideas and news that might otherwise not be aired.
Meryl Tobin
A play about us and them
November 13, 2014
I loved the play Stormy Waters on Sunday. The actors and John Coldebella were wonderful. It was very emotional. Our government is such a disgrace, I don't feel proud to be an Australian at all. I belong to the Refugee Council of Australia, I have belonged to this group for a number of years, they are having a public forum on 'Asylum Seekers and Protection at Sea'. after their AGM on the 24th November, there are some great speakers advertised.
Jan Fleming
November 3, 2014
Thank you so much for the in-depth article on the insightful Gill Heal’s latest project ‘Stormy Waters’. This community has been blessed with Gill’s meticulous, intelligent and compassionate eye looking at our own special history and engaging us with issues through the power of theatre. Her commitment, talent and ability to empower others to forge their talents to create pieces which move, inform and challenge our thinking is a gift which will leave an indelible mark in our hearts and minds for years to come.
Karen Milkins-Hendry
Political prisoners
November 9, 2014
A very interesting article. I have also pondered how someone like Greg Hunt or Malcolm Turnbull, who I believe are true small L liberals can stomach the somewhat extreme policy and mantra of the Abbot government. I have also heard of Mr Hunt’s recognition of global warming; he was considered a bright light on environmental matters in the Howard government.
Others such as Russell Broadbent have taken courageous stands on civil liberty issues and earlier this year Sharman Stone took a strong stand against the Government seeking federal government support for SPC Ardmona, which is based in her north east Victorian electorate.
Outside of what seem trigger issues, however, they go along with Government policy that must quite often appall them. You juxtaposed Greg Hunt and Peter Garrett with photos showing how politics has aged them. There is no doubt in my mind that the parliamentary role diminished Mr Garrett.
I have recently read about Gough Whitlam’s rise to power and the impact he had and is still having through the reforms he drove. His policies didn’t just appear. He thought about and developed them over a number of years. He then proceeded to inspire and push them as solutions to the torpor and inadequacy prevailing in the immediate post-Menzies era.
He had a totally dysfunctional party that he had to bash into shape; he took serious risks and at times played the brinkman’s role. Gough would have scorned the focus groups of today, largely because he believed in getting out and among the people, but also because he realised, and Paul Keating also articulated it, you have to spend political capital to deliver worthwhile policies.
I have been of the view for some time that party politics is broken. Gough wouldn’t agree that there is an alternative and quite frankly I am not sure what it would be. It may well be that we have to await another charismatic and determined leader who will do the hard policy work, kick out the focus group leaders, reform their party and lead them to a government that will once again seek to govern on behalf of the broader Australian community, as Gough did.
Michael Whelan, Phillip Island
November 9, 2014
What a great article Catherine Watson - punchy and yet compassionate
Given his earlier ideas and predictions, Hunt's leadership of the environment portfolio has been disastrous and so disappointing - from both a personal and a global perspective.
As my passion is in Australia's role and responsibility to help eradicate the worst aspects of global hunger and poverty, as a member of his constituency, I write regularly to Hunt, requesting he take action on my behalf. He always does as I ask, for which I'm most grateful.
For the time being, polluters are winning to the detriment of the environment. Maybe we all need to become stronger advocates for the long-term wellbeing of our planet.
Chris Lermanis
November 9, 2014
This is a well observed article. It is right to highlight the visible changes to those who really care about the physical conditions that future generations will face.
Alan Hunt was a man with foresight. He took over from Rupert Hamer in the late sixties in the role of what, I imagine, became the environment minister. He responded with effective speed when I reported a severely contaminated section of bush and the Sassafras Creek. I like to think that the creek is healthy and happy and maybe still has platypuses because of him.
I also believe that there was less openly vicious competition in our society back then. Perhaps people like Dick Hamer and Alan Hunt were able to pursue ideals.
Heather Tobias, Wonthaggi
Red Wonthaggi
November 3, 2014
I too witnessed the slag head spontaneously ignite many times when growing up in Wonthaggi, except for me it was always Kirrak. All the kids would know about it when this heap caught fire because it would smoke during the day and glow red hot by night for weeks at at time. It was easily seen from North Wonthaggi.
Mark Stephenson, Wonthaggi
Election questionnaires
October 27, 2014
Many thanks for giving us the politicians' responses to a comprehensive list of issues that concern our and future lives.
I found it very interesting to read the various responses to the many issues
canvassed. I feel well informed about the candidates' vies on issues that
are important to me.
Felicia Di Stefano
October 27, 2014
Thanks again to the Post for the state election campaign coverage, which probably took the editorial team quite some time to set up and get going. It really helps to focus our minds on local issues, as well as the bigger political picture. Yes, the main players spruik their party's line but that's to be expected. Thankfully we have an alternative voice to make it a bit more interesting.
Linda, Wonthaggi
October 23, 2014 - The Bass electorate is considerably bigger than Bass Coast Shire. Does the circulation of the Post cover the northern end of the electorate? If not, is there anything in place to share the good stuff with some outlet in Pakenham or somewhere? The Liberal candidate has a considerable advantage in coming from that area and 'inheriting' all the networks of the retiring member.
Clare Le Serve, on the other hand, is well known in the Shire but, as an independent, would have a pretty low profile with the rest of the electorate. A big ask in a very short time. Anything we can do to improve the situation via the Post?
Anne Heath Mennell, Tenby Point
Editor's note: A good point, Anne. The other local newspapers will have their own election coverage but it's unlikely to be as in-depth as the Post's. Bass is a very difficult electorate for the candidates because the two ends of the electorate, Pakenham and Bass Coast, have such different interests, in many cases opposing ones.
Class warfare
October 26, 2014
Thanks Frank for your vivid snapshot of the late 60s and early 70s at Wonthaggi Tech-High. Your recollections and vignettes of students and teachers beautifully captured the deeply conservative attitudes that prevailed in Australia and permeated school life, starting with saluting God, Queen and Country at the start of every week. I love the way you allude to the change that is soon to come; a change from a regulated, regimented world to a progressively deregulated one. You reminded me how scary it was that local boys we knew were being sent off to fight in the Vietnam War and how grateful I was when Gough got elected and brought them home. Frank's article is certainly one for the archives.
Linda Cuttriss, Ventnor
October 26, 2014
I enjoyed Frank's latest contribution to the Bass Coast Post. I was wondering if you wouldn't mind sending Frank my email address as I would like to send him a copy of my memoirs from my time at Kooweerup High School. I also started my secondary education in 1966 and so some of the things I covered overlapped Frank's experiences.
Peter Boekel
The gift of seeing
October 23, 2014
An exquisite article regarding an amazing lady. Heather, your photographs are absolutely incredible … the fungi, the Wonthaggi lane, and the wildlife, just beautiful. A wonderful talent. Thank you to Heather and Catherine.
Joy Button, Coronet Bay
October 19, 2014
Thank you Heather Gardner for sharing with us your story and exquisite photos. May your powers of observation, your wonder of nature and photographic skills be with you for
many more years.
Bob Middleton, Jeetho West
November 16, 2014
Congratulations to Linda Gordon on her fine letter to Russell Broadbent, a member of the Liberal Government who has also earned my respect for his stand on asylum seekers. Congratulations too for the article Political prisoners on how hard it must be for idealists to stick to their ideals in politics. Well, Russell Broadbent is one who is trying to!
Best wishes to you and Bass Coast Post. You are doing a magnificent job presenting thoughts, opinions, ideas and news that might otherwise not be aired.
Meryl Tobin
A play about us and them
November 13, 2014
I loved the play Stormy Waters on Sunday. The actors and John Coldebella were wonderful. It was very emotional. Our government is such a disgrace, I don't feel proud to be an Australian at all. I belong to the Refugee Council of Australia, I have belonged to this group for a number of years, they are having a public forum on 'Asylum Seekers and Protection at Sea'. after their AGM on the 24th November, there are some great speakers advertised.
Jan Fleming
November 3, 2014
Thank you so much for the in-depth article on the insightful Gill Heal’s latest project ‘Stormy Waters’. This community has been blessed with Gill’s meticulous, intelligent and compassionate eye looking at our own special history and engaging us with issues through the power of theatre. Her commitment, talent and ability to empower others to forge their talents to create pieces which move, inform and challenge our thinking is a gift which will leave an indelible mark in our hearts and minds for years to come.
Karen Milkins-Hendry
Political prisoners
November 9, 2014
A very interesting article. I have also pondered how someone like Greg Hunt or Malcolm Turnbull, who I believe are true small L liberals can stomach the somewhat extreme policy and mantra of the Abbot government. I have also heard of Mr Hunt’s recognition of global warming; he was considered a bright light on environmental matters in the Howard government.
Others such as Russell Broadbent have taken courageous stands on civil liberty issues and earlier this year Sharman Stone took a strong stand against the Government seeking federal government support for SPC Ardmona, which is based in her north east Victorian electorate.
Outside of what seem trigger issues, however, they go along with Government policy that must quite often appall them. You juxtaposed Greg Hunt and Peter Garrett with photos showing how politics has aged them. There is no doubt in my mind that the parliamentary role diminished Mr Garrett.
I have recently read about Gough Whitlam’s rise to power and the impact he had and is still having through the reforms he drove. His policies didn’t just appear. He thought about and developed them over a number of years. He then proceeded to inspire and push them as solutions to the torpor and inadequacy prevailing in the immediate post-Menzies era.
He had a totally dysfunctional party that he had to bash into shape; he took serious risks and at times played the brinkman’s role. Gough would have scorned the focus groups of today, largely because he believed in getting out and among the people, but also because he realised, and Paul Keating also articulated it, you have to spend political capital to deliver worthwhile policies.
I have been of the view for some time that party politics is broken. Gough wouldn’t agree that there is an alternative and quite frankly I am not sure what it would be. It may well be that we have to await another charismatic and determined leader who will do the hard policy work, kick out the focus group leaders, reform their party and lead them to a government that will once again seek to govern on behalf of the broader Australian community, as Gough did.
Michael Whelan, Phillip Island
November 9, 2014
What a great article Catherine Watson - punchy and yet compassionate
Given his earlier ideas and predictions, Hunt's leadership of the environment portfolio has been disastrous and so disappointing - from both a personal and a global perspective.
As my passion is in Australia's role and responsibility to help eradicate the worst aspects of global hunger and poverty, as a member of his constituency, I write regularly to Hunt, requesting he take action on my behalf. He always does as I ask, for which I'm most grateful.
For the time being, polluters are winning to the detriment of the environment. Maybe we all need to become stronger advocates for the long-term wellbeing of our planet.
Chris Lermanis
November 9, 2014
This is a well observed article. It is right to highlight the visible changes to those who really care about the physical conditions that future generations will face.
Alan Hunt was a man with foresight. He took over from Rupert Hamer in the late sixties in the role of what, I imagine, became the environment minister. He responded with effective speed when I reported a severely contaminated section of bush and the Sassafras Creek. I like to think that the creek is healthy and happy and maybe still has platypuses because of him.
I also believe that there was less openly vicious competition in our society back then. Perhaps people like Dick Hamer and Alan Hunt were able to pursue ideals.
Heather Tobias, Wonthaggi
Red Wonthaggi
November 3, 2014
I too witnessed the slag head spontaneously ignite many times when growing up in Wonthaggi, except for me it was always Kirrak. All the kids would know about it when this heap caught fire because it would smoke during the day and glow red hot by night for weeks at at time. It was easily seen from North Wonthaggi.
Mark Stephenson, Wonthaggi
Election questionnaires
October 27, 2014
Many thanks for giving us the politicians' responses to a comprehensive list of issues that concern our and future lives.
I found it very interesting to read the various responses to the many issues
canvassed. I feel well informed about the candidates' vies on issues that
are important to me.
Felicia Di Stefano
October 27, 2014
Thanks again to the Post for the state election campaign coverage, which probably took the editorial team quite some time to set up and get going. It really helps to focus our minds on local issues, as well as the bigger political picture. Yes, the main players spruik their party's line but that's to be expected. Thankfully we have an alternative voice to make it a bit more interesting.
Linda, Wonthaggi
October 23, 2014 - The Bass electorate is considerably bigger than Bass Coast Shire. Does the circulation of the Post cover the northern end of the electorate? If not, is there anything in place to share the good stuff with some outlet in Pakenham or somewhere? The Liberal candidate has a considerable advantage in coming from that area and 'inheriting' all the networks of the retiring member.
Clare Le Serve, on the other hand, is well known in the Shire but, as an independent, would have a pretty low profile with the rest of the electorate. A big ask in a very short time. Anything we can do to improve the situation via the Post?
Anne Heath Mennell, Tenby Point
Editor's note: A good point, Anne. The other local newspapers will have their own election coverage but it's unlikely to be as in-depth as the Post's. Bass is a very difficult electorate for the candidates because the two ends of the electorate, Pakenham and Bass Coast, have such different interests, in many cases opposing ones.
Class warfare
October 26, 2014
Thanks Frank for your vivid snapshot of the late 60s and early 70s at Wonthaggi Tech-High. Your recollections and vignettes of students and teachers beautifully captured the deeply conservative attitudes that prevailed in Australia and permeated school life, starting with saluting God, Queen and Country at the start of every week. I love the way you allude to the change that is soon to come; a change from a regulated, regimented world to a progressively deregulated one. You reminded me how scary it was that local boys we knew were being sent off to fight in the Vietnam War and how grateful I was when Gough got elected and brought them home. Frank's article is certainly one for the archives.
Linda Cuttriss, Ventnor
October 26, 2014
I enjoyed Frank's latest contribution to the Bass Coast Post. I was wondering if you wouldn't mind sending Frank my email address as I would like to send him a copy of my memoirs from my time at Kooweerup High School. I also started my secondary education in 1966 and so some of the things I covered overlapped Frank's experiences.
Peter Boekel
The gift of seeing
October 23, 2014
An exquisite article regarding an amazing lady. Heather, your photographs are absolutely incredible … the fungi, the Wonthaggi lane, and the wildlife, just beautiful. A wonderful talent. Thank you to Heather and Catherine.
Joy Button, Coronet Bay
October 19, 2014
Thank you Heather Gardner for sharing with us your story and exquisite photos. May your powers of observation, your wonder of nature and photographic skills be with you for
many more years.
Bob Middleton, Jeetho West
Election questionnaire 1
October 8, 2014
Brian, as a qualified accountant, how can you possibly support a major project that is being fast tracked without so much as even a plausible business case?
To state that the Port of Hastings Development Authority is now in the process of developing this goes completely against what you have been taught in your profession as an accountant.
I am a small business owner and if I tried to get a major spending project requiring funding from a bank, I would be told to get lost unless the business case is solid and does not contain rubbery figures like the 7 per cent annual compounding increase in container traffic that the Port of Hastings business case is based on.
Leigh Phillips, Cowes
Bass Coast Post calendar
October 11, 2014
The idea of a calendar is a fantastic one and the photos in the last edition were quite remarkable. I will eagerly await more details of this calendar which will be ideal for overseas Christmas gifts.
Thank you to Bob Middleton for another fantastic story and now I must re-visit Loch to see the delights offered by the Loch Brewery and Distillery and re-visit all that Loch has to offer.
There is no doubt that we are so lucky to live where we live.
Many thanks for the time and effort that you devote to the Bass Coast Post and thank you for the smiles and joy that the articles always give … it is greatly enjoyed and appreciated.
Joy Button, Coronet Bay
October 4, 2014
Thank you Kate Cleeland for a ripper of a suggestion. I know there would be a lot of us in the market for a good quality calendar. The one we use at home is spacious enough to use as a backup diary and functions as an essential reminder for listing forth coming events and appointments. There is always room for a glamorous back up.
Using those wonderful photos taken by Pauline Wilkinson, Lisa Schonberg, Robert Scott et al it would be an absolute winner. And what great Christmas presents they would make.
Put me down for 6 for starters, sight unseen.
Bob Middleton, Jeetho West
A Cook's Journal
October 7, 2014
Please let Jan know that her tea loaf is a mega hit with members at Facebook Group Bowerbirds Journal. I am going to give it a try out today. A recommended tip is to cover it up in the oven for the last 30 mins to ensure a more moist loaf.
Thanks as always for your informative on-line and local rag.
Karen Ellis, Cape Paterson
Banking on a fine single malt
October 4, 2014
Thanks Bob for an absolutely outstanding story, another great read. What a wonderful place Loch is and your story encapsulates its’ beauty very well.
Keep up the good work, can’t wait to read your next article.
Roger Clark, Grantville
Let's talk about the T word
September 28, 2014
Let us hope that James' and Ella's belief and determination is contagious as well as long lasting. Thanks to you both for showing what is possible.
Tim Shannon, Ventnor
How about a calendar?
September 25, 2014
I greatly enjoy The BCP from where I reside in the UK, though I was born on Phillip Island.
During my island sojourns I'm always on the lookout for a good calendar. The ones I have so far encountered are quite honestly not worth a mention let alone a purchase.
I have noticed that BCP seems to attract a very large number of talented artistic souls. Could someone not gather their seriously lovely images into a calendar format? What about a yearly BCP Calendar, or The BCP 2015 Calendar Competition?
Sales would surely benefit The Post, a worthy missive if ever I saw one.
Kate Cleeland, London
Snail trail
September 23, 2014
Thank you for sharing the snail's journey with us, Shelley.
Heather Tobias, Wonthaggi
Ask the candidates
September 25, 2014
When you get elected will you always just vote for the perceived view of the majority of the electors in your seat or will you put the State of Victoria first, then local issues?
Stefan S Borzecki, Yaringa and French Island
September 24, 2014
Thanks for the opportunity to submit election issues that matter to your readers.
One of the areas I would like further clarification and discussion on is the future of tourism in the Bass Coast region - in particular Wonthaggi.
Having previously worked in the Gippsland tourism industry, and as a small business owner servicing visitors and locals alike, I am acutely aware of challenges and issues surrounding tourism in the local area.
There is a common agreement within industry and government that we need to focus on the visitor experience and provide visitors with products and services that are memorable and unique (and also consider our natural environment and wildlife).
Considering the above, my questions to the candidates are:
The Coffee Collective, Wonthaggi
Bass Coast Shire Council/Councillors are responsible for the efficient and effective management of the Wonthaggi Cemetery.
The cemetery is in a state of disrepair due to (among other matters) lack of governance and lack of prudent financial management. The cemetery is subject to flooding which undermines graves and grave sites (given lack of proper drainage systems), and there is an absence of access and inclusion facilities for our senior citizens including veterans and their families, and members of our community and other visitors with a disability (given the Cemetery grounds are unfit for purpose).
To Cr Le Serve: What have you done to remedy the situation in your period as a Bass Coast Shire Councillor and former Mayor, and what will you do to help restore the cemetery to excellent condition in the event you are successful in the upcoming Victorian State election.
To all other candidates: What will you do to help restore the cemetery to excellent condition in the event you are successful in the upcoming Victorian State election?
Les Larke, Wonthaggi
September 23, 2014
All natural wetland habitat surrounding Wonthaggi area is especially vulnerable to neglect and convenient changes to laws that protect these amazingly beautiful and unique areas - and the life within them – which could see these areas wiped out. These areas are extremely important and irreplaceable and areas that our children and children's children will be able to gain so much knowledge and delight from and they will be very grateful to have it all preserved. They can be so quickly cleared and may be lost forever. I would like to ask the candidates just what is their intention with the wetlands along the South Dudley Rd, through to the golf course and Big W?
I have enjoyed taking photos in the Wetlands area between South Dudley Road and the golf course for some years now and have a significant record of the life there, but a photo will never replace the real thing.
One important pleasure I experience is seeing and hearing children playing in this area. They don't realise it yet but they are the future carers of these areas as they make their huts and ride their bikes through. Let's not take this from them.
Thank you for the opportunity to speak up on this subject.
Heather Gardner, Wonthaggi
'I am not Ken Smith'
September 13, 2014
A candidate from a major party believes that we should vote for him because he is not the previous representative of that party? What does this reveal about his view of his party’s record and the intelligence of the voters?
Obviously none of the candidates are Ken Smith. Federally, many people voted Liberal/National because they weren’t Rudd/Gillard/Rudd. How’s that turning out?
People want to vote for candidates and parties that stand for something. They need to be clear and honest about where they want to take us. Most of the issues have been around for many years. The roads haven’t suddenly worsened, they have been this way for decades. Major industries in this area need support to increase employment. Parties need to take a long term view in relation to their agenda and their core values so that we can decide what we are voting for, not who.
The implication of Mr Paynter’s words is that sticking with one major party doesn’t get us the attention we deserve. The reason Mr Smith couldn’t “deliver” was that Governments put money into marginal electorates. If Bass Coast is going to receive increased funding for roads, tourism, employment and the dairy industry the proven way to do this is to elect someone who is in a position to negotiate better outcomes.
In politics the only way to “deliver” is hard bargaining. If we give our vote away for nothing we get what we deserve.
Geoff Ellis, Wattle Bank
A port out of place
September 9, 2014
We simply cannot allow beautiful near pristine Westernport Bay to be destroyed by this ridiculous scheme. No one should have the right to do that.
Kate Pick, Cowes
Excellent Sept. issue. I loved the collaborative piece by Linda and Natasha. Keep up the good work!
Jill Shannon, Ventnor
Introducing our new cartoonist
September 9, 2014
Congratulations on another outstanding issue. Especially loved the bio on Natasha Williams-Novak
Roger Clark
Portrait of a provocateur
September 9, 2014
Another wonderful edition! And your article last week about Patrice told us the part of her story that has never been told. Thanks so much for your Post.
Anne Davie, Ventnor
October 8, 2014
Brian, as a qualified accountant, how can you possibly support a major project that is being fast tracked without so much as even a plausible business case?
To state that the Port of Hastings Development Authority is now in the process of developing this goes completely against what you have been taught in your profession as an accountant.
I am a small business owner and if I tried to get a major spending project requiring funding from a bank, I would be told to get lost unless the business case is solid and does not contain rubbery figures like the 7 per cent annual compounding increase in container traffic that the Port of Hastings business case is based on.
Leigh Phillips, Cowes
Bass Coast Post calendar
October 11, 2014
The idea of a calendar is a fantastic one and the photos in the last edition were quite remarkable. I will eagerly await more details of this calendar which will be ideal for overseas Christmas gifts.
Thank you to Bob Middleton for another fantastic story and now I must re-visit Loch to see the delights offered by the Loch Brewery and Distillery and re-visit all that Loch has to offer.
There is no doubt that we are so lucky to live where we live.
Many thanks for the time and effort that you devote to the Bass Coast Post and thank you for the smiles and joy that the articles always give … it is greatly enjoyed and appreciated.
Joy Button, Coronet Bay
October 4, 2014
Thank you Kate Cleeland for a ripper of a suggestion. I know there would be a lot of us in the market for a good quality calendar. The one we use at home is spacious enough to use as a backup diary and functions as an essential reminder for listing forth coming events and appointments. There is always room for a glamorous back up.
Using those wonderful photos taken by Pauline Wilkinson, Lisa Schonberg, Robert Scott et al it would be an absolute winner. And what great Christmas presents they would make.
Put me down for 6 for starters, sight unseen.
Bob Middleton, Jeetho West
A Cook's Journal
October 7, 2014
Please let Jan know that her tea loaf is a mega hit with members at Facebook Group Bowerbirds Journal. I am going to give it a try out today. A recommended tip is to cover it up in the oven for the last 30 mins to ensure a more moist loaf.
Thanks as always for your informative on-line and local rag.
Karen Ellis, Cape Paterson
Banking on a fine single malt
October 4, 2014
Thanks Bob for an absolutely outstanding story, another great read. What a wonderful place Loch is and your story encapsulates its’ beauty very well.
Keep up the good work, can’t wait to read your next article.
Roger Clark, Grantville
Let's talk about the T word
September 28, 2014
Let us hope that James' and Ella's belief and determination is contagious as well as long lasting. Thanks to you both for showing what is possible.
Tim Shannon, Ventnor
How about a calendar?
September 25, 2014
I greatly enjoy The BCP from where I reside in the UK, though I was born on Phillip Island.
During my island sojourns I'm always on the lookout for a good calendar. The ones I have so far encountered are quite honestly not worth a mention let alone a purchase.
I have noticed that BCP seems to attract a very large number of talented artistic souls. Could someone not gather their seriously lovely images into a calendar format? What about a yearly BCP Calendar, or The BCP 2015 Calendar Competition?
Sales would surely benefit The Post, a worthy missive if ever I saw one.
Kate Cleeland, London
Snail trail
September 23, 2014
Thank you for sharing the snail's journey with us, Shelley.
Heather Tobias, Wonthaggi
Ask the candidates
September 25, 2014
When you get elected will you always just vote for the perceived view of the majority of the electors in your seat or will you put the State of Victoria first, then local issues?
Stefan S Borzecki, Yaringa and French Island
September 24, 2014
Thanks for the opportunity to submit election issues that matter to your readers.
One of the areas I would like further clarification and discussion on is the future of tourism in the Bass Coast region - in particular Wonthaggi.
Having previously worked in the Gippsland tourism industry, and as a small business owner servicing visitors and locals alike, I am acutely aware of challenges and issues surrounding tourism in the local area.
There is a common agreement within industry and government that we need to focus on the visitor experience and provide visitors with products and services that are memorable and unique (and also consider our natural environment and wildlife).
Considering the above, my questions to the candidates are:
- What is the candidate’s position on tourism?
- What is the candidate’s position on the role of Tourism Victoria, regional tourism boards, council and local tourism associations and how will these organisations contribute to increasing regional tourism - in particular regional overnight stay and yield.
- How will the candidate’s party grow tourism numbers in the regions?
- How will the candidate encourage dispersal of visitors so that visitors visiting the Penguin Parade will continue on to areas such as Wonthaggi and Inverloch?
- Does the candidate support the renovation of the Phillip Island Penguin Parade facility?
- Does the candidate support development in National Parks such as a resort in Wilsons Promontory (of which the indirect benefit will influence the Bass Coast region via visitors travelling through the region to access Wilsons Prom)?
- Locally, how will the candidate increase tourism to attractions in Wonthaggi (such as the State Coal Mine) and more importantly how will the candidate support the town of Wonthaggi as a regional shopping hub for visitors and locals alike?
The Coffee Collective, Wonthaggi
Bass Coast Shire Council/Councillors are responsible for the efficient and effective management of the Wonthaggi Cemetery.
The cemetery is in a state of disrepair due to (among other matters) lack of governance and lack of prudent financial management. The cemetery is subject to flooding which undermines graves and grave sites (given lack of proper drainage systems), and there is an absence of access and inclusion facilities for our senior citizens including veterans and their families, and members of our community and other visitors with a disability (given the Cemetery grounds are unfit for purpose).
To Cr Le Serve: What have you done to remedy the situation in your period as a Bass Coast Shire Councillor and former Mayor, and what will you do to help restore the cemetery to excellent condition in the event you are successful in the upcoming Victorian State election.
To all other candidates: What will you do to help restore the cemetery to excellent condition in the event you are successful in the upcoming Victorian State election?
Les Larke, Wonthaggi
September 23, 2014
All natural wetland habitat surrounding Wonthaggi area is especially vulnerable to neglect and convenient changes to laws that protect these amazingly beautiful and unique areas - and the life within them – which could see these areas wiped out. These areas are extremely important and irreplaceable and areas that our children and children's children will be able to gain so much knowledge and delight from and they will be very grateful to have it all preserved. They can be so quickly cleared and may be lost forever. I would like to ask the candidates just what is their intention with the wetlands along the South Dudley Rd, through to the golf course and Big W?
I have enjoyed taking photos in the Wetlands area between South Dudley Road and the golf course for some years now and have a significant record of the life there, but a photo will never replace the real thing.
One important pleasure I experience is seeing and hearing children playing in this area. They don't realise it yet but they are the future carers of these areas as they make their huts and ride their bikes through. Let's not take this from them.
Thank you for the opportunity to speak up on this subject.
Heather Gardner, Wonthaggi
'I am not Ken Smith'
September 13, 2014
A candidate from a major party believes that we should vote for him because he is not the previous representative of that party? What does this reveal about his view of his party’s record and the intelligence of the voters?
Obviously none of the candidates are Ken Smith. Federally, many people voted Liberal/National because they weren’t Rudd/Gillard/Rudd. How’s that turning out?
People want to vote for candidates and parties that stand for something. They need to be clear and honest about where they want to take us. Most of the issues have been around for many years. The roads haven’t suddenly worsened, they have been this way for decades. Major industries in this area need support to increase employment. Parties need to take a long term view in relation to their agenda and their core values so that we can decide what we are voting for, not who.
The implication of Mr Paynter’s words is that sticking with one major party doesn’t get us the attention we deserve. The reason Mr Smith couldn’t “deliver” was that Governments put money into marginal electorates. If Bass Coast is going to receive increased funding for roads, tourism, employment and the dairy industry the proven way to do this is to elect someone who is in a position to negotiate better outcomes.
In politics the only way to “deliver” is hard bargaining. If we give our vote away for nothing we get what we deserve.
Geoff Ellis, Wattle Bank
A port out of place
September 9, 2014
We simply cannot allow beautiful near pristine Westernport Bay to be destroyed by this ridiculous scheme. No one should have the right to do that.
Kate Pick, Cowes
Excellent Sept. issue. I loved the collaborative piece by Linda and Natasha. Keep up the good work!
Jill Shannon, Ventnor
Introducing our new cartoonist
September 9, 2014
Congratulations on another outstanding issue. Especially loved the bio on Natasha Williams-Novak
Roger Clark
Portrait of a provocateur
September 9, 2014
Another wonderful edition! And your article last week about Patrice told us the part of her story that has never been told. Thanks so much for your Post.
Anne Davie, Ventnor
‘Rates too low’
August 29, 2014
Doubling rates and taxes is going a bit too far too fast but in the wright direction. Phil has given us something to aim for. Our local local leaders were once the the most socially progressive in Australia and we should aim to to get back there.
Rates and taxes are the price we pay for a civilised society. If you vote for a reduction in tax, you can’t complain if an ambulance turns up too late or about the state of the road or a long wait in casualty.
I get annoyed when people go off about their rates and then don’t provide an alternative way of paying for essential services and don’t run for council.
Income tax cuts in the Howard and Rudd era cost the general public $170 billion. If we don’t tax pollution or mining companies, do we tax frugal saving? Wages?
The behaviour of Clive, Rupert, Gina and James is evidence that more private wealth is not going to solve your underlying problems. The frontline in the struggle for a more civilised humane society is everyone lifting together, and big things like societies have to be lifted from the bottom.
As for what would be worth funding with higher rates, a bike/walking circuit of the island would benefit everyone from residents to the hundreds of thousands of visitors from polluted Asian cities who would hang around for some clean sea air and magic coastal views.
Frank Coldebella, Wonthaggi
August 28, 2014
On this one I have to totally disagree with Phil. Maybe he should increase the rating valuations only to where the money has been spent over the last 20 years since amalgamation.
It is not just the value of capital works and where it is spent: the biggest driver of economic benefit is employment. For our shire the majority of council employment is concentrated in one town in our shire. It also has been the major beneficiary of all council spending.
L Phillips, CowesAugust 25, 2014
Councillor Wright is wrong to argue for an increase in rates but correct to argue the case for more funding. I would like to see a debate on the priorities for that spending.
I believe he is misguided in his argument that increasing rates does not matter because rates constitute a progressive tax. The burden of increasing rates by around 6% a year is not sustainable for many of the ratepayers in the Shire. This is a compounding rate set above the CPI and ultimately says to people on fixed incomes “Time to sell up and move on.”
Simply our municipal funding system is broken. State and Federal governments are squeezing us and this should be highlighted rather than distracting people onto a debate about rate rises.
I do agree however that we should explore the user pays system and that visitors should pay for the cost of the tourist infrastructure. Ratepayers should not bear this burden."
Michael Whelan, Phillip Island
August 24, 2014
Cr Wright's utopia of what Bass Coast would look like if only $70 million more rates were collected fails to mention that once such projects as he mentions are fulfilled, more tourists than ever will come and the problems of locals carrying them will escalate, until the area is unrecognisable as a destination of quiet and happy occasions.
He hacked a track once from Smiths Beach to Sunderland Bay and that has yet to become part of the coastal walk. Many an intrepid walker forces their way along it. It's the scale of what comes next that is a little off-putting.
As such a joyous occasion as a councillor getting all their dreams at once is not likely to happen, let’s count our small blessings with quiet contemplation.
Joan Woods, Wonthaggi
Rates rise 6%, interest rises 950%
August 29, 2014
I cannot allow the Mayor to continue to misinform the community that Council is spending $1,440,000 more from rates on Capital Works this year.
The facts from the budget prove this claim to be wrong. Council is spending less of its rates on capital works than before.
If the Mayor reads page 46 of the budget he will find that Capital Works funded from Grants and Borrowings are up by $1,964,000.
And, funds allocated to Capital Works from rates and cash are down $1,834,000. That’s not an increase!
And, if he keeps on reading down that page, he will see that total spending on Capital Works this year is down by $889,000 compared to last year.
And, furthermore, Council has access to more rates than ever before. This year rates are up by $3,042,000.
Where has it gone? Not on roads and drains that’s for sure.
Nearly three quarters of it has been gobbled up by a rise of $2,310,000 in salaries.
It’s time for the Mayor to more rigorously interrogate the budget and stop peddling the “spin” and tell the truth.”
Ray McNamara, , San Remo
August 26, 2014
The 22 per cent increase in funds for capital works is council contribution from people’s rates. Ray is referring to the total spend on works which varies a lot depending on what special charge schemes are underway for roads and drains (this has a large contribution from those getting the new roads, and sometimes from government contributions too) also other grants that we get to do specific works like paths, bridges, etc.
It’s Council’s contribution that’s up $1.44m (to $7.844m), and that Council funding for capital works is up 22% - the total spend varies by so many factors each year it doesn’t make much sense to look at that.
We’re making efficiencies, which have saved around $2m this year and we’ve put $1.44m of that into capital.
Bass Coast Mayor, Neil Rankine
August 25, 2014
The Mayor is wrong when he states that expenditure on capital works has risen 22 per cent over last year’s amount.
The council’s own figures show that expenditure has actually fallen 7 per cent on a like-for-like basis. The details are clearly shown on page 44 of the budget:
It’s exasperating that they cannot even quote their own figures accurately and honestly.
Ray McNamara, San Remo
Far from the limelight
August 20, 2014
My father was working for the shire and he and his workmates spent the week before the Union Theatre burned down moving stuff out. Unfortunately all the Miners Union stuff was left. At daybreak, shire trucks and loaders went to work to make the still warm site safe. By the time investigators arrived from Melbourne, it was a warm vacant lot.
Frank Coldebella, Wonthaggi
August 20, 2014
What an interesting article. I hope the Union Theatre keeps on keeping on for a long time yet. It is doubtful if the attention given to personal space in the auditorium by its architects would be repeated today.
It has some great memories. John and Lyn Council and the whole of the Wonthaggi State School end of year musicals were a great experience for those kids in a real theatre.
Heather Tobias, Wonthaggi
A turn for the worse
August 20, 2014
I am a full-time carer for my wife as she suffered a stroke. Transport is quite difficult for us and the trip to Wonthaggi can be difficult at times, plus the cost to see the doctor and the out-of-pocket expense is very restrictive. My wife receives a disability pension and I the carer pension. My wife needs to see the nurse quite often to maintain her health as she is also epileptic and needs regular blood tests. The nurse has been a godsend for our family and our three children. This nurse provides a wonderful service to the community. I for one will fight to keep this service where it belongs, well within reach of the people of the Bass Coast.
Rodney Jones, Corinella
Express post, tide permitting
August 17, 2014
Thanks Bob, I really enjoyed your rare glimpse into French Island through Neil's story. I took the ferry there from Cowes with friends a couple of years ago. We had all lived at Phillip Island for ages and had never been. It was a fabulous day. Surprisingly different from Phillip Island - the landscape, the vegetation, the whole feel of the place. Your story was a happy reminder of how special it is.
Linda Cuttriss, Ventnor
My country
August 16, 2014
Thank you Linda for your vivid reminder of the expanses of natural beauty in Bass Coast that many folk know, share, and have responsibility for its care for future generations. The recent concerns over the plans for a new Port for Melbourne in Western Port are a sharp reminder that many communities are affected by this in a variety of ways, and that solidarity between these communities will be essential for Bass Coast to be able to act in ways which will be in the best interests of all for now and into the future.
I would add, that the recent actions of the Phillip Island Stand Alone element provide an example of raising the alarm, but sadly not in how to galvanise the greater community to work together. There can be no doubting that the challenges of the future will need the solidarity of all communities that are affected. We all have a common interest in ensuring that future generations can write stories as delightful and proud as yours, thank you.
Tim Shannon, Ventnor
Council shakeup to ‘refresh, re-energise and refocus’
August 16, 2014
What a load of croc! does this justify this CEO's quarter mill salary paid by us ratepayers, before he moves on to his next portfolio? Just a load of words & proticol that never adds up to anything. What a joke!!!
Tim Wilson
Here's hoping this council refresh will help us to build a badly needed car park at the Adult Education grounds. We have been negotiating for its construction for about five years. It seems that previous requests were simply put in the too hard basket.
Felicia De Stefano
Good article. let’s ‘watch this space’!
Yvonne McCrae
Running for (senior) beginners
August 10, 2014
Miriam's story is inspirational to everyone. I believe we all have a duty of care to maintain our health as best we can. Miriam has shown how natural, enjoyable and rewarding it is. The body should be treated gently and lovingly. We can all set our own goal. Every bit is a plus. A 100-metre walk is enough to send beautiful fresh oxygen around our body. Especially the air off the Southern Ocean that we are blessed to breathe. With our abundant public land in the area, safe bike riding is very accessible. This of course is low impact on the knees, as is swimming. Everyone should do their best, and not become an unnecessary drain on our health system.
Miriam is "a kid" at 55. Yesterday I rode my bike 10 kilometres and walked a kilometre along the beach. I am 70 and take no medication. Please give your amazing body a chance!
Denise Miller, Wonthaggi
Our sorry refugee saga
August 3, 2014
Great read, nice to read a morally rich article in times of moral bankruptcy.
Karen Sandon
August 3, 2014
For local people who wish to discuss this issue further, Mitchell House will host "Potluck Supper and Politics" on refugees and war at 6.30pm on Thursday August 7. Please bring a plate to share and $2 donation to Mitchell House, 6 Murray Street, Wonthaggi. Inquiries: 0407 307 231.
Jessica Harrison, Wonthaggi
Weathering the storm
August 3, 2014
Thank you Linda, it's a beautiful article. Just what we all need, a bit of sun shining through this wickedlycold spell. So glad it was you out there taking those photos and not me.
Bob Middleton, Jeetho West
August 3, 2014
How wonderful. Well done. Surely one of the great bonuses of living on a surf beach and braving the winter weather must be the eventual sighting of the hooded plover.
Karen Sandon
A delightful illustrated Winter’s Tale! Thank you.
Tim Shannon, Ventnor
Funding facts hard to come by
August 2, 2014
Congratulations on the latest article, which states starkly what most of us already knew intuitively, that we are not doing well here on state government funding.
Mr Smith’s failure to respond to your requests is hardly surprising. Even as Speaker and sitting on a 62 per cent two-party preferred vote he could not persuade the Government to properly address the urgent requirements for investment in Bass.
Bass Coast Shire should be entitled to $9 million in rates annually from the desalination plant but instead the State Government gave into this multinational company and gave away the right to collect rates. The Government should step up and pay that amount in lieu of rates.
Bass Coast has a backlog of hundreds of millions of dollars in infrastructure and services, accentuated by the fact that holiday houses are ignored in calculations to determine the allocation of State Government funds. The existing funding approach fails Bass Coast and we need a new one that recognises its crucial role in the state’s economy and the difficulty of servicing estates that are more spread out than in outer Melbourne municipalities.
A major economic driver in the area is tourism; however, the Government appears to operate in a fog when it comes to funding the necessary development. The recent tourism strategy again fails the area. Phillip Island Nature Parks is the State’s premier natural tourist attraction, yet the well documented bid to upgrade the Penguin Parade has been disregarded. The Island gets some three million visitors a year on roads that are not safe and cannot carry the traffic. Instead of addressing the big issues, two ministers arrived at the Nobbies to announce a $1.2 million contribution to a project labelled a “Major Tourism Expansion for Phillip Island”. While it was for a very worthwhile project it just does not cut it against what is required to maintain Phillip Island’s pre-eminence as a tourist destination.
A safe seat has done nothing for the Bass electorate. It’s time for a new voice, a Voice For Bass.
Clare Le Serve, independent candidate for Bass
July 30, 2014
I have only just read last week's Post. Really solid job on the funding comparisons with neighbouring shires. Quite the eye opener.
Linda Gordon, Wonthaggi
July 27, 2014
Thank you for doing such a comprehensive job of researching government funding for the three local shires. It’s a telling list in terms of the number of projects supported and the dollar amounts received! I’m not a great believer in the ‘what’s in it for me’ approach to politics but changes to the current funding arrangements are obviously long-overdue.
I’d like to have comments from all candidates for the seat of Bass on how they would redress the current disadvantages and how they would make things more equitable. This pre-election period is an excellent time to make clear what we want/need from our representatives at both State and Federal levels.
Anne Heath Mennell, Tenby Point
'The Australian people will judge'
July 28, 2014
Greg Hunt is right, the Australian people voted to get rid of the carbon tax. It is also right that he will be remebered as an Environment minister who did not protect the environment. These two concepts are not mutually exclusive.However if you accept the concept that man has pumped tons and tons of smoke and polution into the atmosphere for over 300 years and that this is having a disastrous effect on our climate, and if you accept the concept that the market is the most efficient means of allocating resources and that people best respond to price signals, then an ETS or price on carbon pollution is the best way to go. if you do not accept these two concepts then you probably believe Mr hunt and his Government did the right thing, I am not sure future generations will believe so.
Stephen Paul
5000 jobs at risk, says independent
July 28, 2014
The marine geotechnical and geophysical survey for the Port of Hastings Container Expansion Project has not been referred under national environment law.
National environment law protects matters of national environmental significance. This
includes nationally listed threatened and migratory species such as southern right whales.
Any action that is likely to have a significant impact on a matter of national environmental
significance must be referred for assessment and approval.
Officers of the Department of the Environment have looked into this matter to determine
whether national environmental law applies. Based on the information available, it is unlikely to result in a significant impact on any matters of national environmental significance.
Greg Hunt, Federal Environment Minister and Flinders MP
Greg Hunt's legacy
July 19, 2014
What a disappointment Greg Hunt turned out to be. Did you see and hear Barnaby Joyce standing in Canberra (freezing day) and commenting re the temperature and the nonsense of climate change? Does not understand the difference between climate change and weather. I have never met anyone yet who admits they voted for Tony and his merry men.
Yvonne McRae, Wonthaggi
July 19, 2014
Thank you for your article, Michael. It is the best one I have read on the tragedy of the loss of the carbon tax. Your article includes the shortsightedness and all the other consequences of the dismantling of a price on carbon.
Felicia Di Stefano
Never mind a bigger slice, we need a bigger pie
July 12, 2014
An excellent article. Well considered, relevant and well written. Keep up the good work Bass Coast Post
James Archibald, Wonthaggi
In the heat of the kitchen
July 7, 2014
I have been there in the milling crowd when Malcolm Bain has prepared his
gourmet delights. What amazes me is how he can concentrate on his craft while
all around the corks are popping and the party decibels are rising. His focus never
wavers. I cannot do one thing at a time, Malcolm juggles many.
If you are lucky enough to be there when he is strutting his stuff, take time out to stand
back and enjoy the show.
Bob Middleton, Loch
The co-op and the bakehouse
July 5, 2014
Just been reading Carolyn Landon's story (June 28, 2014) and getting all nostalgic about the Wonthaggi Co-op. That's where mum worked till she got married. I remember it well as a little girl going shopping on fridays with my mum and grandma. I especially remember the smell of the freshly baked bread on our way home from visiting my grandparents on Sunday nights. Actually, come to think of it, my first job ever was in the haberdashery section of the co-op in summer holidays when I was about 15.
Carolyn writes an excellent story. Thanks again for the memories. I've forwarded it to mum. I'm sure she'll love it too.
Linda Cuttriss, Phillip Island
August 29, 2014
Doubling rates and taxes is going a bit too far too fast but in the wright direction. Phil has given us something to aim for. Our local local leaders were once the the most socially progressive in Australia and we should aim to to get back there.
Rates and taxes are the price we pay for a civilised society. If you vote for a reduction in tax, you can’t complain if an ambulance turns up too late or about the state of the road or a long wait in casualty.
I get annoyed when people go off about their rates and then don’t provide an alternative way of paying for essential services and don’t run for council.
Income tax cuts in the Howard and Rudd era cost the general public $170 billion. If we don’t tax pollution or mining companies, do we tax frugal saving? Wages?
The behaviour of Clive, Rupert, Gina and James is evidence that more private wealth is not going to solve your underlying problems. The frontline in the struggle for a more civilised humane society is everyone lifting together, and big things like societies have to be lifted from the bottom.
As for what would be worth funding with higher rates, a bike/walking circuit of the island would benefit everyone from residents to the hundreds of thousands of visitors from polluted Asian cities who would hang around for some clean sea air and magic coastal views.
Frank Coldebella, Wonthaggi
August 28, 2014
On this one I have to totally disagree with Phil. Maybe he should increase the rating valuations only to where the money has been spent over the last 20 years since amalgamation.
It is not just the value of capital works and where it is spent: the biggest driver of economic benefit is employment. For our shire the majority of council employment is concentrated in one town in our shire. It also has been the major beneficiary of all council spending.
L Phillips, CowesAugust 25, 2014
Councillor Wright is wrong to argue for an increase in rates but correct to argue the case for more funding. I would like to see a debate on the priorities for that spending.
I believe he is misguided in his argument that increasing rates does not matter because rates constitute a progressive tax. The burden of increasing rates by around 6% a year is not sustainable for many of the ratepayers in the Shire. This is a compounding rate set above the CPI and ultimately says to people on fixed incomes “Time to sell up and move on.”
Simply our municipal funding system is broken. State and Federal governments are squeezing us and this should be highlighted rather than distracting people onto a debate about rate rises.
I do agree however that we should explore the user pays system and that visitors should pay for the cost of the tourist infrastructure. Ratepayers should not bear this burden."
Michael Whelan, Phillip Island
August 24, 2014
Cr Wright's utopia of what Bass Coast would look like if only $70 million more rates were collected fails to mention that once such projects as he mentions are fulfilled, more tourists than ever will come and the problems of locals carrying them will escalate, until the area is unrecognisable as a destination of quiet and happy occasions.
He hacked a track once from Smiths Beach to Sunderland Bay and that has yet to become part of the coastal walk. Many an intrepid walker forces their way along it. It's the scale of what comes next that is a little off-putting.
As such a joyous occasion as a councillor getting all their dreams at once is not likely to happen, let’s count our small blessings with quiet contemplation.
Joan Woods, Wonthaggi
Rates rise 6%, interest rises 950%
August 29, 2014
I cannot allow the Mayor to continue to misinform the community that Council is spending $1,440,000 more from rates on Capital Works this year.
The facts from the budget prove this claim to be wrong. Council is spending less of its rates on capital works than before.
If the Mayor reads page 46 of the budget he will find that Capital Works funded from Grants and Borrowings are up by $1,964,000.
And, funds allocated to Capital Works from rates and cash are down $1,834,000. That’s not an increase!
And, if he keeps on reading down that page, he will see that total spending on Capital Works this year is down by $889,000 compared to last year.
And, furthermore, Council has access to more rates than ever before. This year rates are up by $3,042,000.
Where has it gone? Not on roads and drains that’s for sure.
Nearly three quarters of it has been gobbled up by a rise of $2,310,000 in salaries.
It’s time for the Mayor to more rigorously interrogate the budget and stop peddling the “spin” and tell the truth.”
Ray McNamara, , San Remo
August 26, 2014
The 22 per cent increase in funds for capital works is council contribution from people’s rates. Ray is referring to the total spend on works which varies a lot depending on what special charge schemes are underway for roads and drains (this has a large contribution from those getting the new roads, and sometimes from government contributions too) also other grants that we get to do specific works like paths, bridges, etc.
It’s Council’s contribution that’s up $1.44m (to $7.844m), and that Council funding for capital works is up 22% - the total spend varies by so many factors each year it doesn’t make much sense to look at that.
We’re making efficiencies, which have saved around $2m this year and we’ve put $1.44m of that into capital.
Bass Coast Mayor, Neil Rankine
August 25, 2014
The Mayor is wrong when he states that expenditure on capital works has risen 22 per cent over last year’s amount.
The council’s own figures show that expenditure has actually fallen 7 per cent on a like-for-like basis. The details are clearly shown on page 44 of the budget:
- In 2013-14 Council spent $13,062,000 on new works.
- The 2014-15 budget is for $12,173,000 on new works.
It’s exasperating that they cannot even quote their own figures accurately and honestly.
Ray McNamara, San Remo
Far from the limelight
August 20, 2014
My father was working for the shire and he and his workmates spent the week before the Union Theatre burned down moving stuff out. Unfortunately all the Miners Union stuff was left. At daybreak, shire trucks and loaders went to work to make the still warm site safe. By the time investigators arrived from Melbourne, it was a warm vacant lot.
Frank Coldebella, Wonthaggi
August 20, 2014
What an interesting article. I hope the Union Theatre keeps on keeping on for a long time yet. It is doubtful if the attention given to personal space in the auditorium by its architects would be repeated today.
It has some great memories. John and Lyn Council and the whole of the Wonthaggi State School end of year musicals were a great experience for those kids in a real theatre.
Heather Tobias, Wonthaggi
A turn for the worse
August 20, 2014
I am a full-time carer for my wife as she suffered a stroke. Transport is quite difficult for us and the trip to Wonthaggi can be difficult at times, plus the cost to see the doctor and the out-of-pocket expense is very restrictive. My wife receives a disability pension and I the carer pension. My wife needs to see the nurse quite often to maintain her health as she is also epileptic and needs regular blood tests. The nurse has been a godsend for our family and our three children. This nurse provides a wonderful service to the community. I for one will fight to keep this service where it belongs, well within reach of the people of the Bass Coast.
Rodney Jones, Corinella
Express post, tide permitting
August 17, 2014
Thanks Bob, I really enjoyed your rare glimpse into French Island through Neil's story. I took the ferry there from Cowes with friends a couple of years ago. We had all lived at Phillip Island for ages and had never been. It was a fabulous day. Surprisingly different from Phillip Island - the landscape, the vegetation, the whole feel of the place. Your story was a happy reminder of how special it is.
Linda Cuttriss, Ventnor
My country
August 16, 2014
Thank you Linda for your vivid reminder of the expanses of natural beauty in Bass Coast that many folk know, share, and have responsibility for its care for future generations. The recent concerns over the plans for a new Port for Melbourne in Western Port are a sharp reminder that many communities are affected by this in a variety of ways, and that solidarity between these communities will be essential for Bass Coast to be able to act in ways which will be in the best interests of all for now and into the future.
I would add, that the recent actions of the Phillip Island Stand Alone element provide an example of raising the alarm, but sadly not in how to galvanise the greater community to work together. There can be no doubting that the challenges of the future will need the solidarity of all communities that are affected. We all have a common interest in ensuring that future generations can write stories as delightful and proud as yours, thank you.
Tim Shannon, Ventnor
Council shakeup to ‘refresh, re-energise and refocus’
August 16, 2014
What a load of croc! does this justify this CEO's quarter mill salary paid by us ratepayers, before he moves on to his next portfolio? Just a load of words & proticol that never adds up to anything. What a joke!!!
Tim Wilson
Here's hoping this council refresh will help us to build a badly needed car park at the Adult Education grounds. We have been negotiating for its construction for about five years. It seems that previous requests were simply put in the too hard basket.
Felicia De Stefano
Good article. let’s ‘watch this space’!
Yvonne McCrae
Running for (senior) beginners
August 10, 2014
Miriam's story is inspirational to everyone. I believe we all have a duty of care to maintain our health as best we can. Miriam has shown how natural, enjoyable and rewarding it is. The body should be treated gently and lovingly. We can all set our own goal. Every bit is a plus. A 100-metre walk is enough to send beautiful fresh oxygen around our body. Especially the air off the Southern Ocean that we are blessed to breathe. With our abundant public land in the area, safe bike riding is very accessible. This of course is low impact on the knees, as is swimming. Everyone should do their best, and not become an unnecessary drain on our health system.
Miriam is "a kid" at 55. Yesterday I rode my bike 10 kilometres and walked a kilometre along the beach. I am 70 and take no medication. Please give your amazing body a chance!
Denise Miller, Wonthaggi
Our sorry refugee saga
August 3, 2014
Great read, nice to read a morally rich article in times of moral bankruptcy.
Karen Sandon
August 3, 2014
For local people who wish to discuss this issue further, Mitchell House will host "Potluck Supper and Politics" on refugees and war at 6.30pm on Thursday August 7. Please bring a plate to share and $2 donation to Mitchell House, 6 Murray Street, Wonthaggi. Inquiries: 0407 307 231.
Jessica Harrison, Wonthaggi
Weathering the storm
August 3, 2014
Thank you Linda, it's a beautiful article. Just what we all need, a bit of sun shining through this wickedlycold spell. So glad it was you out there taking those photos and not me.
Bob Middleton, Jeetho West
August 3, 2014
How wonderful. Well done. Surely one of the great bonuses of living on a surf beach and braving the winter weather must be the eventual sighting of the hooded plover.
Karen Sandon
A delightful illustrated Winter’s Tale! Thank you.
Tim Shannon, Ventnor
Funding facts hard to come by
August 2, 2014
Congratulations on the latest article, which states starkly what most of us already knew intuitively, that we are not doing well here on state government funding.
Mr Smith’s failure to respond to your requests is hardly surprising. Even as Speaker and sitting on a 62 per cent two-party preferred vote he could not persuade the Government to properly address the urgent requirements for investment in Bass.
Bass Coast Shire should be entitled to $9 million in rates annually from the desalination plant but instead the State Government gave into this multinational company and gave away the right to collect rates. The Government should step up and pay that amount in lieu of rates.
Bass Coast has a backlog of hundreds of millions of dollars in infrastructure and services, accentuated by the fact that holiday houses are ignored in calculations to determine the allocation of State Government funds. The existing funding approach fails Bass Coast and we need a new one that recognises its crucial role in the state’s economy and the difficulty of servicing estates that are more spread out than in outer Melbourne municipalities.
A major economic driver in the area is tourism; however, the Government appears to operate in a fog when it comes to funding the necessary development. The recent tourism strategy again fails the area. Phillip Island Nature Parks is the State’s premier natural tourist attraction, yet the well documented bid to upgrade the Penguin Parade has been disregarded. The Island gets some three million visitors a year on roads that are not safe and cannot carry the traffic. Instead of addressing the big issues, two ministers arrived at the Nobbies to announce a $1.2 million contribution to a project labelled a “Major Tourism Expansion for Phillip Island”. While it was for a very worthwhile project it just does not cut it against what is required to maintain Phillip Island’s pre-eminence as a tourist destination.
A safe seat has done nothing for the Bass electorate. It’s time for a new voice, a Voice For Bass.
Clare Le Serve, independent candidate for Bass
July 30, 2014
I have only just read last week's Post. Really solid job on the funding comparisons with neighbouring shires. Quite the eye opener.
Linda Gordon, Wonthaggi
July 27, 2014
Thank you for doing such a comprehensive job of researching government funding for the three local shires. It’s a telling list in terms of the number of projects supported and the dollar amounts received! I’m not a great believer in the ‘what’s in it for me’ approach to politics but changes to the current funding arrangements are obviously long-overdue.
I’d like to have comments from all candidates for the seat of Bass on how they would redress the current disadvantages and how they would make things more equitable. This pre-election period is an excellent time to make clear what we want/need from our representatives at both State and Federal levels.
Anne Heath Mennell, Tenby Point
'The Australian people will judge'
July 28, 2014
Greg Hunt is right, the Australian people voted to get rid of the carbon tax. It is also right that he will be remebered as an Environment minister who did not protect the environment. These two concepts are not mutually exclusive.However if you accept the concept that man has pumped tons and tons of smoke and polution into the atmosphere for over 300 years and that this is having a disastrous effect on our climate, and if you accept the concept that the market is the most efficient means of allocating resources and that people best respond to price signals, then an ETS or price on carbon pollution is the best way to go. if you do not accept these two concepts then you probably believe Mr hunt and his Government did the right thing, I am not sure future generations will believe so.
Stephen Paul
5000 jobs at risk, says independent
July 28, 2014
The marine geotechnical and geophysical survey for the Port of Hastings Container Expansion Project has not been referred under national environment law.
National environment law protects matters of national environmental significance. This
includes nationally listed threatened and migratory species such as southern right whales.
Any action that is likely to have a significant impact on a matter of national environmental
significance must be referred for assessment and approval.
Officers of the Department of the Environment have looked into this matter to determine
whether national environmental law applies. Based on the information available, it is unlikely to result in a significant impact on any matters of national environmental significance.
Greg Hunt, Federal Environment Minister and Flinders MP
Greg Hunt's legacy
July 19, 2014
What a disappointment Greg Hunt turned out to be. Did you see and hear Barnaby Joyce standing in Canberra (freezing day) and commenting re the temperature and the nonsense of climate change? Does not understand the difference between climate change and weather. I have never met anyone yet who admits they voted for Tony and his merry men.
Yvonne McRae, Wonthaggi
July 19, 2014
Thank you for your article, Michael. It is the best one I have read on the tragedy of the loss of the carbon tax. Your article includes the shortsightedness and all the other consequences of the dismantling of a price on carbon.
Felicia Di Stefano
Never mind a bigger slice, we need a bigger pie
July 12, 2014
An excellent article. Well considered, relevant and well written. Keep up the good work Bass Coast Post
James Archibald, Wonthaggi
In the heat of the kitchen
July 7, 2014
I have been there in the milling crowd when Malcolm Bain has prepared his
gourmet delights. What amazes me is how he can concentrate on his craft while
all around the corks are popping and the party decibels are rising. His focus never
wavers. I cannot do one thing at a time, Malcolm juggles many.
If you are lucky enough to be there when he is strutting his stuff, take time out to stand
back and enjoy the show.
Bob Middleton, Loch
The co-op and the bakehouse
July 5, 2014
Just been reading Carolyn Landon's story (June 28, 2014) and getting all nostalgic about the Wonthaggi Co-op. That's where mum worked till she got married. I remember it well as a little girl going shopping on fridays with my mum and grandma. I especially remember the smell of the freshly baked bread on our way home from visiting my grandparents on Sunday nights. Actually, come to think of it, my first job ever was in the haberdashery section of the co-op in summer holidays when I was about 15.
Carolyn writes an excellent story. Thanks again for the memories. I've forwarded it to mum. I'm sure she'll love it too.
Linda Cuttriss, Phillip Island
Colour in Cowes: the story so far
July 1, 2014
RE Tim Shannon’s true story (June 28, 2014) the highlight is the mesage for success:
Groups or partnerships with this formula survive, those without become just another collection of individuals, looking back /ending up where they started.
Mary Whelan, Phillip Island
Chair, Southern Communities Panning Group and Roads Working Party
Review to probe island complaints
June 27, 2014
Like many Islanders, I have been frustrated for many years by a “Wonthaggi-centric” council.
While understanding the initial need to build a South East Gippsland regional centre in Wonthaggi, it became apparent that under the guidance of our past CEO the specific commercial and community needs and attributes of Phillip Island/San Remo were not appreciated or serviced by successive Bass Coast councils.
This led to a resounding vote for change in the last Bass Coast Council elections with the election of local councilors more attuned to community needs. The introduction of a new Council and CEO has provided the opportunity for improvement that should not be prejudged, but given a full term to demonstrate if changes can be made to accommodate the specific needs of the Islander/San Remo community.
Failing this challenge, I would welcome a review as an opportunity for defining where council policy and direction needs to change for the betterment of all, both Phillip Island/San Remo and Bass Coast. It is an opportunity to not only define the long-held concerns of Islanders, but to analyse the very serious economic and political ramifications of maintaining a small but dedicated municipality dependant on growth and tourism.
In recognition of its unique environment and being the premier tourist destination of Victoria, the Island and surrounds need to be legislated and serviced as a “Tourist Precinct” with an annual allocation of local, State and Federal governments funds specifically for the purposes of maintaining not only a sustainable environment and responsible growth in tourism, but the quality of life for both residents and holiday makers.
Ian Samuel, Ventnor
The proposal for a feasibility study into the separation of Phillip Island from the Bass Coast Shire represents an extraordinary waste of taxpayers’ resources.
The taxpayers of Victoria or the taxpayers of the Bass Coast Shire should object in the strongest of terms.
Spending my hard-earned money on an uneconomic feasibility study is outrageous because the duplication of the resources required to run a separated Phillip Island from the Bass Coast Shire will significantly increase costs. This is basic economies of scale and you don’t need to do a feasibility study.
If the residents of Phillip Island want a feasibility study they should fund it themselves.
Frank Schooneveldt, Wonthaggi
June 27, 2014
Can I confess, I don't much care about the fate of Phillip Island secession. Stay, go, whatever.
Linda Gordon, Wonthaggi
June 19, 2014
Cockies disgruntled too
Perhaps all the farmers could secede from from the shire also as they have been getting a "raw " deal over many many years from the council. The island aren't the only group of ratepayers thinking that they're paying too much for what they receive!! Andy Thomas
June 15, 2014
First taste
I have just discovered A Cook's Journal – I love it!! Thanks everyone, keep those recipes coming
Annie Chisholm, Archie’s Creek
June 13, 2014
Wanted: one brave singer
Last March we asked if anyone knew anything about the jaunty brass band transcription for a piano roll found in a Gippsland home (The Gippsland March, March 8, 2014).
We've had LOTS of replies, the first being from Bruce Armstrong from the Warragul Municipal Band and thereafter from Jay Collins from the Watsonville Community Band in the US who tells us they played it at a 4th of July concert at the White House for former president Bill Clinton. They'd thought it was of NZ, not Australian origin. And driving this international linkup was David Petersen from Arizona via Catherine Watson from the wonderful Bass Coast Post. We thank them both.
The piano roll added a new piece to the puzzle - lyrics that fit (sometimes only-just!) to the score. Now all it needs is a brave person to volunteer to sing it on Gippsland's naming day next March 12. Any takers? Email susanw@ptarmigan.com.au for the lyrics.
Sue Webster, Agribusiness Gippsland
June 11, 2014
Hospital claim misleading and incorrect
The statement in your article Just the facts (June 7 2014) that the Phillip Island Advertiseris running a campaign for a hospital in Cowes is misleading, and incorrect.
So too your assertion that a “very short” letter pointing out some facts, written by Mal McCann, Cowes Ambulance team manager, was “buried” in the Advertiser.
The Advertiser supports the establishment of 24/7 health services in Cowes. That is, the provision of health care after the doctor’s surgery has closed. Not every medical emergency requires an ambulance and the latest proposal, to this end, for employment of an after hours nurse practitioner, appears to have wide support, including from Mr McCann.
The 548 word letter you refer to can hardly be described as “very short” and was published on the letters page (April 24, 2014) precisely as Mr McCann intended it to be.
Had he suggested further editorial, or more focus on his viewpoint, this would have been cheerfully provided.
Your inference that Mr McCann’s letter was deliberately “buried” presumably in order to suppress a view not in accord with that of the Phillip Island Advertiser, is a most unfair one.
Anne Oswin, Phillip Island and San Remo Advertiser
Former mayor to contest Bass
June 9, 2018
Go Clare!!
Heather Gardner
Wonderful news! Thanks for circulating it so promptly. I'm sick of being taken for granted as a safe seat at both state and federal levels.
Anne Heath Mennell
June 8, 2014
Message from Sun City West
Re The Gippsland March (March 8, 2014), if Sue Webster has not found any sheet music for the Gippsland March, I can put her in contact with a marching/concert band, in California, that plays the march to this day.
David Peterson, Sun City West, Arizona
June 8, 2014
Shame on you
Shame on you for republishing the Australian story about Coronet Bay, Family mission a personal journey ... I didn’t read the story (who wants to subscribe to the Australian) but if you had dug a little deeper ... in say Cape Paterson ... you might find a very different story about what David ‘Unwise’ has actually done in previous ‘developments’
Gary Martyn
Fibs, whoppers and beautiful lies
June 8, 2014
Well Bob, If you are told by anyone, especially a Kiwi - "Bob, I tell you for true ..." you know a whopping fib is to follow! Cheers.
Lenice, Papamoa
June 6, 2014
Landcare SOS
With impending budget cuts to the Landcare Program (Rural communities mourn demise of Landcare, May 24, 2014), we need Landcare networks and groups across Australia to be more self-sufficient to be able to continue undertaking Landcare works into the future.
You can support the Bass Coast Landcare Network here. All donations over $2 are tax deductible.
The Bass Coast Landcare Network Public Fund supports the Bass Coast Landcare Network’s core purposes and will focus on supporting essential environmental works that protect and enhance our region’s precious natural asserts.
The Public Fund’s project ‘Bass Coast Arc – community access to public space’ aims to support local community groups to undertake activities such as revegetation work to repair and restore landscapes, develop wildlife corridors linking areas of fragmented bushland and create environmental education opportunities.
You can also make a donation by calling the Bass Coast Landcare Network office on 5678 2335 between 9am and 4pm Monday to Friday.
Sarah Van Stokrom, Bass Coast Landcare Network
June 3, 2014
Reforms put Landcare community back at the helm
Re Rural communities mourn demise of Landcare ( May 24, 2014), in relation to Landcare, this year’s budget delivers more than $2 billion over four years for key Coalition commitments in natural resource management and environmental initiatives across Australia.
The management of our natural resources will be delivered through the National Landcare Program, the Green Army, Reef 2050 Plan, Working on Country, the Land Sector Package and investments in the Great Barrier Reef Foundation.
The National Landcare Program will consist of a national component and a regional component. The national component will deliver on key election commitments including the 20 Million Trees Program, Coastal River Recovery Initiatives, Cumberland Conservation Corridor, Whale and Dolphin Protection Plan, Kimberley Cane Toad Clean Up and Dandenong Ranges Wildlife Recovery.
Reforms to the National Landcare Program will put the Landcare community back at the centre of land management programs that will encourage partnerships with Green Army and Working on Country projects.
This is about merging Caring for Country and Landcare, as was set out prior to the election.
The Green Army represents enormous opportunity for local environment and Landcare groups. Green Army is not a work for the dole program; it is a voluntary program for young people 17-24 to gain training and experience in environmental and heritage conservation fields and explore careers in conservation management.
Greg Hunt, MP for Flinders and Minister for the Environment
June 1, 2014
Port studies just a sham
The Minister for Ports Mr David Hodgett today drove a nail into the coffin of Western Port as we know it. The Minister for Ports has just announced that the project is declared under Major Transport Projects Facilitation Act 2009 that will seek to avoid proper economic, environmental and social scrutiny.
Clearly, assurances from the Port of Hastings Development Authority that the international container project would go ahead “only if the science and economics stacked up”, was just a smoke screen.
The declaration and the Ministers statement confirms the view that the Liberal Government has already made up its mind on this project and that the environmental and economic assessments are just a formality.
It's really disappointing to have lip service paid to Western Port’s beautiful wildlife and Ramsar listed wetlands. He has demonstrated that the Government does not care about the environment and just wants to steam roll this project through”
The Government is spending $110 million of taxpayers’ money on a consultant’s picnic, paying consultants to tell them what the Government what it wants to hear.
The Ports Minister Mr David Hodgett said: “By declaring the Port of Hastings expansion under the Major Transport Projects Facilitation Act, the Coalition Government is sending a clear message that we are committed to developing the project and will get on with seeking the necessary approvals and undertaking critical studies to progress this project through the planning approvals process.”
Jeff Nottle, chairman of Preserve Western Port action group
Them and us
June 3, 2014
Thanks for the good sense and kindness in your story. Outrage has its place but I'm not sure it's always the most useful response. Further to this theme, everyone is welcome to attend a Reconciliation Week lunchtime gathering at the Wonthaggi Community Garden this Wednesday 4/6, from 12.30pm. There will be a chance to meet a diverse group of local people, share some tucker and enjoy the garden. Cheers Bass Coast Post!
Linda, Wonthaggi.
July 1, 2014
RE Tim Shannon’s true story (June 28, 2014) the highlight is the mesage for success:
- Get people together to hear as many ideas as possible.
- Engage with those who have the responsibility for the area.
- Always know or seek the facts.
- Always bring positive ideas /often in the form of fixing the problems you have identified.
- and as Tim’s story demonstrates, it must be based on respect.
Groups or partnerships with this formula survive, those without become just another collection of individuals, looking back /ending up where they started.
Mary Whelan, Phillip Island
Chair, Southern Communities Panning Group and Roads Working Party
Review to probe island complaints
June 27, 2014
Like many Islanders, I have been frustrated for many years by a “Wonthaggi-centric” council.
While understanding the initial need to build a South East Gippsland regional centre in Wonthaggi, it became apparent that under the guidance of our past CEO the specific commercial and community needs and attributes of Phillip Island/San Remo were not appreciated or serviced by successive Bass Coast councils.
This led to a resounding vote for change in the last Bass Coast Council elections with the election of local councilors more attuned to community needs. The introduction of a new Council and CEO has provided the opportunity for improvement that should not be prejudged, but given a full term to demonstrate if changes can be made to accommodate the specific needs of the Islander/San Remo community.
Failing this challenge, I would welcome a review as an opportunity for defining where council policy and direction needs to change for the betterment of all, both Phillip Island/San Remo and Bass Coast. It is an opportunity to not only define the long-held concerns of Islanders, but to analyse the very serious economic and political ramifications of maintaining a small but dedicated municipality dependant on growth and tourism.
In recognition of its unique environment and being the premier tourist destination of Victoria, the Island and surrounds need to be legislated and serviced as a “Tourist Precinct” with an annual allocation of local, State and Federal governments funds specifically for the purposes of maintaining not only a sustainable environment and responsible growth in tourism, but the quality of life for both residents and holiday makers.
Ian Samuel, Ventnor
The proposal for a feasibility study into the separation of Phillip Island from the Bass Coast Shire represents an extraordinary waste of taxpayers’ resources.
The taxpayers of Victoria or the taxpayers of the Bass Coast Shire should object in the strongest of terms.
Spending my hard-earned money on an uneconomic feasibility study is outrageous because the duplication of the resources required to run a separated Phillip Island from the Bass Coast Shire will significantly increase costs. This is basic economies of scale and you don’t need to do a feasibility study.
If the residents of Phillip Island want a feasibility study they should fund it themselves.
Frank Schooneveldt, Wonthaggi
June 27, 2014
Can I confess, I don't much care about the fate of Phillip Island secession. Stay, go, whatever.
Linda Gordon, Wonthaggi
June 19, 2014
Cockies disgruntled too
Perhaps all the farmers could secede from from the shire also as they have been getting a "raw " deal over many many years from the council. The island aren't the only group of ratepayers thinking that they're paying too much for what they receive!! Andy Thomas
June 15, 2014
First taste
I have just discovered A Cook's Journal – I love it!! Thanks everyone, keep those recipes coming
Annie Chisholm, Archie’s Creek
June 13, 2014
Wanted: one brave singer
Last March we asked if anyone knew anything about the jaunty brass band transcription for a piano roll found in a Gippsland home (The Gippsland March, March 8, 2014).
We've had LOTS of replies, the first being from Bruce Armstrong from the Warragul Municipal Band and thereafter from Jay Collins from the Watsonville Community Band in the US who tells us they played it at a 4th of July concert at the White House for former president Bill Clinton. They'd thought it was of NZ, not Australian origin. And driving this international linkup was David Petersen from Arizona via Catherine Watson from the wonderful Bass Coast Post. We thank them both.
The piano roll added a new piece to the puzzle - lyrics that fit (sometimes only-just!) to the score. Now all it needs is a brave person to volunteer to sing it on Gippsland's naming day next March 12. Any takers? Email susanw@ptarmigan.com.au for the lyrics.
Sue Webster, Agribusiness Gippsland
June 11, 2014
Hospital claim misleading and incorrect
The statement in your article Just the facts (June 7 2014) that the Phillip Island Advertiseris running a campaign for a hospital in Cowes is misleading, and incorrect.
So too your assertion that a “very short” letter pointing out some facts, written by Mal McCann, Cowes Ambulance team manager, was “buried” in the Advertiser.
The Advertiser supports the establishment of 24/7 health services in Cowes. That is, the provision of health care after the doctor’s surgery has closed. Not every medical emergency requires an ambulance and the latest proposal, to this end, for employment of an after hours nurse practitioner, appears to have wide support, including from Mr McCann.
The 548 word letter you refer to can hardly be described as “very short” and was published on the letters page (April 24, 2014) precisely as Mr McCann intended it to be.
Had he suggested further editorial, or more focus on his viewpoint, this would have been cheerfully provided.
Your inference that Mr McCann’s letter was deliberately “buried” presumably in order to suppress a view not in accord with that of the Phillip Island Advertiser, is a most unfair one.
Anne Oswin, Phillip Island and San Remo Advertiser
Former mayor to contest Bass
June 9, 2018
Go Clare!!
Heather Gardner
Wonderful news! Thanks for circulating it so promptly. I'm sick of being taken for granted as a safe seat at both state and federal levels.
Anne Heath Mennell
June 8, 2014
Message from Sun City West
Re The Gippsland March (March 8, 2014), if Sue Webster has not found any sheet music for the Gippsland March, I can put her in contact with a marching/concert band, in California, that plays the march to this day.
David Peterson, Sun City West, Arizona
June 8, 2014
Shame on you
Shame on you for republishing the Australian story about Coronet Bay, Family mission a personal journey ... I didn’t read the story (who wants to subscribe to the Australian) but if you had dug a little deeper ... in say Cape Paterson ... you might find a very different story about what David ‘Unwise’ has actually done in previous ‘developments’
Gary Martyn
Fibs, whoppers and beautiful lies
June 8, 2014
Well Bob, If you are told by anyone, especially a Kiwi - "Bob, I tell you for true ..." you know a whopping fib is to follow! Cheers.
Lenice, Papamoa
June 6, 2014
Landcare SOS
With impending budget cuts to the Landcare Program (Rural communities mourn demise of Landcare, May 24, 2014), we need Landcare networks and groups across Australia to be more self-sufficient to be able to continue undertaking Landcare works into the future.
You can support the Bass Coast Landcare Network here. All donations over $2 are tax deductible.
The Bass Coast Landcare Network Public Fund supports the Bass Coast Landcare Network’s core purposes and will focus on supporting essential environmental works that protect and enhance our region’s precious natural asserts.
The Public Fund’s project ‘Bass Coast Arc – community access to public space’ aims to support local community groups to undertake activities such as revegetation work to repair and restore landscapes, develop wildlife corridors linking areas of fragmented bushland and create environmental education opportunities.
You can also make a donation by calling the Bass Coast Landcare Network office on 5678 2335 between 9am and 4pm Monday to Friday.
Sarah Van Stokrom, Bass Coast Landcare Network
June 3, 2014
Reforms put Landcare community back at the helm
Re Rural communities mourn demise of Landcare ( May 24, 2014), in relation to Landcare, this year’s budget delivers more than $2 billion over four years for key Coalition commitments in natural resource management and environmental initiatives across Australia.
The management of our natural resources will be delivered through the National Landcare Program, the Green Army, Reef 2050 Plan, Working on Country, the Land Sector Package and investments in the Great Barrier Reef Foundation.
The National Landcare Program will consist of a national component and a regional component. The national component will deliver on key election commitments including the 20 Million Trees Program, Coastal River Recovery Initiatives, Cumberland Conservation Corridor, Whale and Dolphin Protection Plan, Kimberley Cane Toad Clean Up and Dandenong Ranges Wildlife Recovery.
Reforms to the National Landcare Program will put the Landcare community back at the centre of land management programs that will encourage partnerships with Green Army and Working on Country projects.
This is about merging Caring for Country and Landcare, as was set out prior to the election.
The Green Army represents enormous opportunity for local environment and Landcare groups. Green Army is not a work for the dole program; it is a voluntary program for young people 17-24 to gain training and experience in environmental and heritage conservation fields and explore careers in conservation management.
Greg Hunt, MP for Flinders and Minister for the Environment
June 1, 2014
Port studies just a sham
The Minister for Ports Mr David Hodgett today drove a nail into the coffin of Western Port as we know it. The Minister for Ports has just announced that the project is declared under Major Transport Projects Facilitation Act 2009 that will seek to avoid proper economic, environmental and social scrutiny.
Clearly, assurances from the Port of Hastings Development Authority that the international container project would go ahead “only if the science and economics stacked up”, was just a smoke screen.
The declaration and the Ministers statement confirms the view that the Liberal Government has already made up its mind on this project and that the environmental and economic assessments are just a formality.
It's really disappointing to have lip service paid to Western Port’s beautiful wildlife and Ramsar listed wetlands. He has demonstrated that the Government does not care about the environment and just wants to steam roll this project through”
The Government is spending $110 million of taxpayers’ money on a consultant’s picnic, paying consultants to tell them what the Government what it wants to hear.
The Ports Minister Mr David Hodgett said: “By declaring the Port of Hastings expansion under the Major Transport Projects Facilitation Act, the Coalition Government is sending a clear message that we are committed to developing the project and will get on with seeking the necessary approvals and undertaking critical studies to progress this project through the planning approvals process.”
Jeff Nottle, chairman of Preserve Western Port action group
Them and us
June 3, 2014
Thanks for the good sense and kindness in your story. Outrage has its place but I'm not sure it's always the most useful response. Further to this theme, everyone is welcome to attend a Reconciliation Week lunchtime gathering at the Wonthaggi Community Garden this Wednesday 4/6, from 12.30pm. There will be a chance to meet a diverse group of local people, share some tucker and enjoy the garden. Cheers Bass Coast Post!
Linda, Wonthaggi.
May 31, 2014
I love your article on 'reconciliation day'. Thank you for sharing some of yourself. It's funny how we don't feel so alone when others share stories and we get energy.
Sarah Crinall
Brilliant piece. That is the vital issue. These people are ignorant of the facts, thus easily brainwashed. I am sure that Sam will be a slightly different person after your informative conversation. Keep it up.
Felicia De Stafano
May 29, 2014
Landcare the best model
I would like to applaud Anne Davie's article on the demise of Landcare (Rural community mourns demise of Landcare, May 24, 2014). It would be a great pity to see the end to the community-driven care of the environment.
A bureaucratic-managed model is likely to cost much more with the least desirable results. And it will probably exclude the people who care most.
Heather Murray Tobias, Wonthaggi
Chalk it up to Stand Alone
May 26, 2014
Regrettable statements
It is regrettable that you have made these statements, your assumptions or so called quotes from Don Turner are not all correct and could have been better communicated.
The statement on maintenance is incorrect, if you bothered to read the agenda I am sure you would have seen council said Wonthaggi costs $391,325 per year, and once built Phillip Island could be $968,374 over the first five years, In my mind that would be $193,675 per year so it would be a savings of $197,650 on Wonthaggi regarding running costs.
We have supplied your publication with our official response to last week's council meeting and look forward to you posting it on your website.
You are free to make any assumption of your own, but please don't include our representatives in your article in the future to help make your point of view.
I would say yes this may have been a political statement that Council has made, but don't forget the hard work the Phillip Island community has put into the last 22 years of trying to overcome a very determined Council wish to stop any attempt of success.
Peter McMahon, secretary/public officer, Phillip Island Aquatic Centre Fund
Editor's note: A spokesman for Bass Coast Council confirmed that $968,374 is the annual average cost for operation and maintenance of the existing Bass Coast Aquatic Centre and a new Phillip Island Aquatic Centre.
May 26, 2014
Offensive comment
In your article you write: “If Phillip Island’s ‘stand alone’ movement fizzles out, it can at least claim the credit for one major achievement: persuading local councillors to support an aquatic centre on the island.”
I must say I find that statement to be regrettably offensive. Having been a member of the Phillip Island Aquatic Centre Fund committee and participant in the trials and tribulations over many years, you might pay more regard to this group of community volunteers who have persevered with dedicated effort toward this long-challenged goal of establishing an aquatic facility on Phillip Island.
If you could furnish me with the details of similar action taken by Stand-Aloners to get to this point I'd be better informed I guess.
Nicola Tragear
May 15, 2014
The Tragedy of Stolen
Mothers’ hearts wrenched apart.
While fathers in anger scream.
Brothers’ posts on Twitter and Facebook
Circulate across the World
The tragedy of young girls taken.
Chocolate skin and gentle velvet eyes.
Young scholars stolen.
Education broken.
Progress stalled.
Hundreds incarcerated.
They dared to read.
Slavery hangs over young heads,
How can this be
In our world today?
The people weep,
Brown eyes, blue and green
Gather in all countries crying
Bring our beloved girls home.
Where are they now these girls,
Who embraced education?
And because of this were stolen
Across the World
We hope and yet we weep.
Penny Walder
Independence movement gathers force
May 4, 2014
Let's not create a rumour about the environmentalists versus the commercialists, Wonthaggi versus Phillip Island. Let's not create a rumour about which political party is behind the Stand Alone movement.
It is Phillip Islanders standing up for Phillip Islanders. Phillip Islanders have been bullied for many years. As a community, we have regressed and continue to regress. We have been ignored by the governments, our shire and VicRoads for far too long.
Support those who have had the courage and determination to stand up for all of you.
We need to support and protect our senior citizens, with health services and facilities to improve their quality of life, such as an aquatic centre, a cinema, a lovely and clean shopping strip, a hospital and safe streets.
We need to support our young families, we need to instil a sense of community pride and responsibility within our education system, we need to attract more vibrant young families to our island and the way this is done is through providing services for these people: hospitals, aquatic centre, sporting facilities, social connectivity and pride.
Be realistic about development, be realistic about the environment. It all matters and it all has a place on this island and in our hearts.
Let’s not get wound up in the intricacies at this stage, they will be nutted out later by those who are educated to do so. We can ruminate over their findings at a later stage.
Carly van der Zwet, Newhaven
May 3, 2014
I’m thrilled there is so much community interest in the Phillip Island Stand Alone, so many people wanting to get the best for Phillip Island and the community. The question is whatis the best for the Phillip Island community?
I’ve recently been in contact with some of the members of the Stand Alone committee, and am planning to continue to have discussions with them.
Nobody at this stage knows if Phillip Island, or the Bass Coast, would be worse/better off separating. Stand Alone is asking for a municipal review, or feasibility study to look at what a separation would look like. This review will give us the answers, so the only harm that can come out of it is that taxpayers pay a few dollars to find these answers.
What are the financial implications? What are the planning implications? In the short term, will we have administrators? How will we get a work force? Long term, what will the projections be? Will our rates go up on average, or will they go down?
The committee have also been very clear to me that this campaign is not a criticism of the councillors.
Why not do the feasibility study? We will get the answers to make a proper, well-informed decision (even though this probably comes back to a state decision). Hopefully, whatever comes out of this campaign, we get the best outcome for our community.
Cr Andrew Phillips, Thompson Ward
May 2, 2014
The key points raised by the 'Stand Alone' group are dissatisfaction with expenditure, services and infrastructure on the island dating back to amalgamation in 1994.
A significant number of Phillip Island projects have been delivered in the last two terms of Council. These include the Phillip Island Early Learning Centre, Cowes Town Square, local road upgrades, development of the bicycle path across Phillip Island linking Newhaven to Cowes, numerous boat ramp upgrades and the purchase of land in Cowes for future health, recreation and community needs, just to name a few.
The 'Stand Alone' campaign has raised issues including the provision of health services, a public secondary school, and major road upgrades. It is important to understand that all these issues are actually the responsibility of state or federal governments.
The upcoming election creates an opportunity for the entire shire to work together to seek funding support for key initiatives that benefit us all.
The highest priority for the coming election is to upgrade Wonthaggi Hospital to sub-regional level with increased services. This will support the new facility at Cowes and the paramedics will continue to transfer Island residents to the most appropriate level of care required.
By leveraging off each other's strengths we can do this. We invite groups across the shire to engage with the council to develop opportunities and priorities.
Cr Neil Rankine, Bass Coast Mayor
April 28, 2014
As a home owner on Phillip island, I am ambivalent on whether we should or should not go it alone. My only concern is, and I do not want to sound ungenerous, if the local Island Liberal Party is involved in this. We all saw the sort of deals that get done behind closed doors with the Cadogan Farm fiasco in 2011. So my message to people is be very wary of those who tell you what you want to hear and prey on your grievances as they usually have ulterior motives.
Stephen Paul
April 26, 2014
I believe the proponents of the stand alone campaign for Phillip Island have acted irresponsibly in not giving more information to people they are asking to sign the petitions.
I have seen people signing petitions who I know for a fact have no financial experience at all.
How many people who sign the petitions would be in any way competent or have enough knowledge in local government and governance issues to be in a position to put their names to what appears to be such a simple question?
I believe the move is fraught with danger and full of pitfalls which could see the whole shire and its residents all end up suffering for decades to come.
Be careful what you wish for – you just might get it, and regret it!
Roger Clark, Grantville
April 23, 2014
While doing the weekly shopping I came across a person collecting signatures for the petition for Phillip Island to stand alone.
A one-liner saying we want to stand alone is just not enough information. I asked “Can you show me financials, a business case or business plan that backs up your statement so I can make an informed decision?”.
He could not. All he could offer is that we pay the majority of the rates and we are hard done by. Don’t get me wrong. I’m open to change. I just require more information. People have to ask what this will achieve and who will win in the end.
There are two sides, the first being the commercial sector and the other being the environmental group. Which one of these groups has the greater strength or power and what is the outcome that everyone wants?
Do we want more visitors to the island?
Do we want further development?
What is the best way to manage the traffic?
Have we asked why our private hospital closed? Has there been a business case done on whether a new hospital would be viable?
What are the start-up costs to form a new Phillip Island shire?
If we are to stand alone, we should be answering these and other questions first.
My opinion is that those answers will be divided.
Some want to preserve what is here and do not want further development. On the other hand, people with a business interest want commercial gains, so they want to value-add and bring greater tourists to the Island.
Which side are you on?
Braxton Laine, Ventnor
April 20, 2014
I fully support the move by PI residents to break away from the Bass Coat shire. I also urge San Remo residents to join in the movement.
Bass Coast Council has consistently failed to return ratepayers’ funds in new capital works or in enhanced services both on the Island and in San Remo.
Residents here only get council maintenance on assets that were mostly created pre-amalgamation.
Services are still at the same levels that were experienced and expected 20 years ago pre-amalgamation.
Let’s look at the financial numbers associated with secession and find a way to make it work.
I note the comments from Cr Drew, and urge sitting councillors to have an open mind on this important issue and help their ward residents work through the issues.
Ray McNamara, San Remo
Phillip Island wanting to secede from Bass Coast Council (, April 19, 2014) is a good idea as Phillip Island is a unique place and a lot different to the rest of the Shire. In fact I think most of the towns in the Bass Coast Shire would like to secede from the Shire Council as they are not a very well organised bunch of councillors.
Robert Scott, Inverloch
April 20, 2014
House sitter wanted
My husband Harry and I are travelling to the UK and Europe in mid June and plan to be away for seven weeks, returning in the first week of August. We are looking for someone to come in and baby sit our property. "Our property" comprises four acres, with a couple of alpacas, goats a sheep, a few chooks and our beloved dog, Sally (kelpie). Our house is a newly built 'low energy' house, which is very warm and comfortable and close to Wonthaggi (10 mins).
Anyone interested can contact me on maddy.harford@gmail.com.
Maddy Harford
Cape scheme abandoned
April 9, 2014
Great news! Congratulations to all involved: the residents and the council.
Heather Tobias, Wonthaggi
April 8, 2014
Very good news. Democracy prevails.
Tim Wilson
No Inverloch look alike for Cape Pat. Great news.
Karen Ellis, Cape Paterson
The sad part about all this saga is that if the Shire had consulted the property owners of Cape Paterson beforehand, the amount spent on this proposed project could have been spent on improvements here at Cape rather than spend the alleged $260,000 to present this project.
The question to be asked is who drove this project with such lack of community consultation?
Tony Quinlan, Cape Paterson
Great news ... democracy does work!
Pamela Jacka, Wonthaggi
Sign of a good council, listening to majority opinion.
Felicia Di Stefano, Wonthaggi
Hooray!
Tim Shannon
Lucky them. We had to pay big time.
Rosemary Loughnan, Wonthaggi
April 6, 2014
Economic progress at what cost?
I am sure there are two sides to the debate about coal seam gas, Mr Reith, and both could hold merit in their own right (Gippslanders conned on gas, says Reith, March 29, 2014). It may be good for Gippsland's economy and here is the but, at what cost to the Gippsland community in the long term? A good example is asbestos. Government and big business approval for asbestos has cost lives.
Once again, the decision is driven by money and politicians without the knowledge of how it may compromise the beautiful environment of Gippsland, amongst other things. Not even the CSIRO can clearly define the impact of the long-term mining of CSG.
Margaret Murray, Maddingley
April 5, 2014
Remembering Old Jim
Loved the story by Terri Allen (no relation): Old Jim's Hut (March 29, 2014). These guys used to be everywhere and deserve to be remembered. Terri did that terri-bly well indeed ... all the informative tangents, acute observations. Great stuff, thanks!
Martin Allen
March 28, 2014
Art-felt thanks
I just loved the article The Unknown Crocheter (March 22, 2014). What a tale and what a crocheter. How clever of the artist to find such a good place where his/her work of art has to be sought out and to be appreciated. To place the work piece by piece without being seen was a remarkable feat and in a way I do not think that I want to know who the crocheter is. I think I have seen some of his/her work in a shop or two in Wonthaggi and the talent is great. Hopefully we will be blessed with seeing another piece of artwork a little later. Just loved the imagination of it all and loved the story.
Joy Button, Coronet Bay
March 25, 2014
Fiddlesticks to missing it
Many thanks Jacqui for your article on the Yinnar Fiddleback Festival (Strings are snappin', toes are tappin', March 22 2014). What an incredible lineup of talent. Kicking myself that I missed it but will definitely get there next year!
Vilya Congreave, Wonthaggi
I love your article on 'reconciliation day'. Thank you for sharing some of yourself. It's funny how we don't feel so alone when others share stories and we get energy.
Sarah Crinall
Brilliant piece. That is the vital issue. These people are ignorant of the facts, thus easily brainwashed. I am sure that Sam will be a slightly different person after your informative conversation. Keep it up.
Felicia De Stafano
May 29, 2014
Landcare the best model
I would like to applaud Anne Davie's article on the demise of Landcare (Rural community mourns demise of Landcare, May 24, 2014). It would be a great pity to see the end to the community-driven care of the environment.
A bureaucratic-managed model is likely to cost much more with the least desirable results. And it will probably exclude the people who care most.
Heather Murray Tobias, Wonthaggi
Chalk it up to Stand Alone
May 26, 2014
Regrettable statements
It is regrettable that you have made these statements, your assumptions or so called quotes from Don Turner are not all correct and could have been better communicated.
The statement on maintenance is incorrect, if you bothered to read the agenda I am sure you would have seen council said Wonthaggi costs $391,325 per year, and once built Phillip Island could be $968,374 over the first five years, In my mind that would be $193,675 per year so it would be a savings of $197,650 on Wonthaggi regarding running costs.
We have supplied your publication with our official response to last week's council meeting and look forward to you posting it on your website.
You are free to make any assumption of your own, but please don't include our representatives in your article in the future to help make your point of view.
I would say yes this may have been a political statement that Council has made, but don't forget the hard work the Phillip Island community has put into the last 22 years of trying to overcome a very determined Council wish to stop any attempt of success.
Peter McMahon, secretary/public officer, Phillip Island Aquatic Centre Fund
Editor's note: A spokesman for Bass Coast Council confirmed that $968,374 is the annual average cost for operation and maintenance of the existing Bass Coast Aquatic Centre and a new Phillip Island Aquatic Centre.
May 26, 2014
Offensive comment
In your article you write: “If Phillip Island’s ‘stand alone’ movement fizzles out, it can at least claim the credit for one major achievement: persuading local councillors to support an aquatic centre on the island.”
I must say I find that statement to be regrettably offensive. Having been a member of the Phillip Island Aquatic Centre Fund committee and participant in the trials and tribulations over many years, you might pay more regard to this group of community volunteers who have persevered with dedicated effort toward this long-challenged goal of establishing an aquatic facility on Phillip Island.
If you could furnish me with the details of similar action taken by Stand-Aloners to get to this point I'd be better informed I guess.
Nicola Tragear
May 15, 2014
The Tragedy of Stolen
Mothers’ hearts wrenched apart.
While fathers in anger scream.
Brothers’ posts on Twitter and Facebook
Circulate across the World
The tragedy of young girls taken.
Chocolate skin and gentle velvet eyes.
Young scholars stolen.
Education broken.
Progress stalled.
Hundreds incarcerated.
They dared to read.
Slavery hangs over young heads,
How can this be
In our world today?
The people weep,
Brown eyes, blue and green
Gather in all countries crying
Bring our beloved girls home.
Where are they now these girls,
Who embraced education?
And because of this were stolen
Across the World
We hope and yet we weep.
Penny Walder
Independence movement gathers force
May 4, 2014
Let's not create a rumour about the environmentalists versus the commercialists, Wonthaggi versus Phillip Island. Let's not create a rumour about which political party is behind the Stand Alone movement.
It is Phillip Islanders standing up for Phillip Islanders. Phillip Islanders have been bullied for many years. As a community, we have regressed and continue to regress. We have been ignored by the governments, our shire and VicRoads for far too long.
Support those who have had the courage and determination to stand up for all of you.
We need to support and protect our senior citizens, with health services and facilities to improve their quality of life, such as an aquatic centre, a cinema, a lovely and clean shopping strip, a hospital and safe streets.
We need to support our young families, we need to instil a sense of community pride and responsibility within our education system, we need to attract more vibrant young families to our island and the way this is done is through providing services for these people: hospitals, aquatic centre, sporting facilities, social connectivity and pride.
Be realistic about development, be realistic about the environment. It all matters and it all has a place on this island and in our hearts.
Let’s not get wound up in the intricacies at this stage, they will be nutted out later by those who are educated to do so. We can ruminate over their findings at a later stage.
Carly van der Zwet, Newhaven
May 3, 2014
I’m thrilled there is so much community interest in the Phillip Island Stand Alone, so many people wanting to get the best for Phillip Island and the community. The question is whatis the best for the Phillip Island community?
I’ve recently been in contact with some of the members of the Stand Alone committee, and am planning to continue to have discussions with them.
Nobody at this stage knows if Phillip Island, or the Bass Coast, would be worse/better off separating. Stand Alone is asking for a municipal review, or feasibility study to look at what a separation would look like. This review will give us the answers, so the only harm that can come out of it is that taxpayers pay a few dollars to find these answers.
What are the financial implications? What are the planning implications? In the short term, will we have administrators? How will we get a work force? Long term, what will the projections be? Will our rates go up on average, or will they go down?
The committee have also been very clear to me that this campaign is not a criticism of the councillors.
Why not do the feasibility study? We will get the answers to make a proper, well-informed decision (even though this probably comes back to a state decision). Hopefully, whatever comes out of this campaign, we get the best outcome for our community.
Cr Andrew Phillips, Thompson Ward
May 2, 2014
The key points raised by the 'Stand Alone' group are dissatisfaction with expenditure, services and infrastructure on the island dating back to amalgamation in 1994.
A significant number of Phillip Island projects have been delivered in the last two terms of Council. These include the Phillip Island Early Learning Centre, Cowes Town Square, local road upgrades, development of the bicycle path across Phillip Island linking Newhaven to Cowes, numerous boat ramp upgrades and the purchase of land in Cowes for future health, recreation and community needs, just to name a few.
The 'Stand Alone' campaign has raised issues including the provision of health services, a public secondary school, and major road upgrades. It is important to understand that all these issues are actually the responsibility of state or federal governments.
The upcoming election creates an opportunity for the entire shire to work together to seek funding support for key initiatives that benefit us all.
The highest priority for the coming election is to upgrade Wonthaggi Hospital to sub-regional level with increased services. This will support the new facility at Cowes and the paramedics will continue to transfer Island residents to the most appropriate level of care required.
By leveraging off each other's strengths we can do this. We invite groups across the shire to engage with the council to develop opportunities and priorities.
Cr Neil Rankine, Bass Coast Mayor
April 28, 2014
As a home owner on Phillip island, I am ambivalent on whether we should or should not go it alone. My only concern is, and I do not want to sound ungenerous, if the local Island Liberal Party is involved in this. We all saw the sort of deals that get done behind closed doors with the Cadogan Farm fiasco in 2011. So my message to people is be very wary of those who tell you what you want to hear and prey on your grievances as they usually have ulterior motives.
Stephen Paul
April 26, 2014
I believe the proponents of the stand alone campaign for Phillip Island have acted irresponsibly in not giving more information to people they are asking to sign the petitions.
I have seen people signing petitions who I know for a fact have no financial experience at all.
How many people who sign the petitions would be in any way competent or have enough knowledge in local government and governance issues to be in a position to put their names to what appears to be such a simple question?
I believe the move is fraught with danger and full of pitfalls which could see the whole shire and its residents all end up suffering for decades to come.
Be careful what you wish for – you just might get it, and regret it!
Roger Clark, Grantville
April 23, 2014
While doing the weekly shopping I came across a person collecting signatures for the petition for Phillip Island to stand alone.
A one-liner saying we want to stand alone is just not enough information. I asked “Can you show me financials, a business case or business plan that backs up your statement so I can make an informed decision?”.
He could not. All he could offer is that we pay the majority of the rates and we are hard done by. Don’t get me wrong. I’m open to change. I just require more information. People have to ask what this will achieve and who will win in the end.
There are two sides, the first being the commercial sector and the other being the environmental group. Which one of these groups has the greater strength or power and what is the outcome that everyone wants?
Do we want more visitors to the island?
Do we want further development?
What is the best way to manage the traffic?
Have we asked why our private hospital closed? Has there been a business case done on whether a new hospital would be viable?
What are the start-up costs to form a new Phillip Island shire?
If we are to stand alone, we should be answering these and other questions first.
My opinion is that those answers will be divided.
Some want to preserve what is here and do not want further development. On the other hand, people with a business interest want commercial gains, so they want to value-add and bring greater tourists to the Island.
Which side are you on?
Braxton Laine, Ventnor
April 20, 2014
I fully support the move by PI residents to break away from the Bass Coat shire. I also urge San Remo residents to join in the movement.
Bass Coast Council has consistently failed to return ratepayers’ funds in new capital works or in enhanced services both on the Island and in San Remo.
Residents here only get council maintenance on assets that were mostly created pre-amalgamation.
Services are still at the same levels that were experienced and expected 20 years ago pre-amalgamation.
Let’s look at the financial numbers associated with secession and find a way to make it work.
I note the comments from Cr Drew, and urge sitting councillors to have an open mind on this important issue and help their ward residents work through the issues.
Ray McNamara, San Remo
Phillip Island wanting to secede from Bass Coast Council (, April 19, 2014) is a good idea as Phillip Island is a unique place and a lot different to the rest of the Shire. In fact I think most of the towns in the Bass Coast Shire would like to secede from the Shire Council as they are not a very well organised bunch of councillors.
Robert Scott, Inverloch
April 20, 2014
House sitter wanted
My husband Harry and I are travelling to the UK and Europe in mid June and plan to be away for seven weeks, returning in the first week of August. We are looking for someone to come in and baby sit our property. "Our property" comprises four acres, with a couple of alpacas, goats a sheep, a few chooks and our beloved dog, Sally (kelpie). Our house is a newly built 'low energy' house, which is very warm and comfortable and close to Wonthaggi (10 mins).
Anyone interested can contact me on maddy.harford@gmail.com.
Maddy Harford
Cape scheme abandoned
April 9, 2014
Great news! Congratulations to all involved: the residents and the council.
Heather Tobias, Wonthaggi
April 8, 2014
Very good news. Democracy prevails.
Tim Wilson
No Inverloch look alike for Cape Pat. Great news.
Karen Ellis, Cape Paterson
The sad part about all this saga is that if the Shire had consulted the property owners of Cape Paterson beforehand, the amount spent on this proposed project could have been spent on improvements here at Cape rather than spend the alleged $260,000 to present this project.
The question to be asked is who drove this project with such lack of community consultation?
Tony Quinlan, Cape Paterson
Great news ... democracy does work!
Pamela Jacka, Wonthaggi
Sign of a good council, listening to majority opinion.
Felicia Di Stefano, Wonthaggi
Hooray!
Tim Shannon
Lucky them. We had to pay big time.
Rosemary Loughnan, Wonthaggi
April 6, 2014
Economic progress at what cost?
I am sure there are two sides to the debate about coal seam gas, Mr Reith, and both could hold merit in their own right (Gippslanders conned on gas, says Reith, March 29, 2014). It may be good for Gippsland's economy and here is the but, at what cost to the Gippsland community in the long term? A good example is asbestos. Government and big business approval for asbestos has cost lives.
Once again, the decision is driven by money and politicians without the knowledge of how it may compromise the beautiful environment of Gippsland, amongst other things. Not even the CSIRO can clearly define the impact of the long-term mining of CSG.
Margaret Murray, Maddingley
April 5, 2014
Remembering Old Jim
Loved the story by Terri Allen (no relation): Old Jim's Hut (March 29, 2014). These guys used to be everywhere and deserve to be remembered. Terri did that terri-bly well indeed ... all the informative tangents, acute observations. Great stuff, thanks!
Martin Allen
March 28, 2014
Art-felt thanks
I just loved the article The Unknown Crocheter (March 22, 2014). What a tale and what a crocheter. How clever of the artist to find such a good place where his/her work of art has to be sought out and to be appreciated. To place the work piece by piece without being seen was a remarkable feat and in a way I do not think that I want to know who the crocheter is. I think I have seen some of his/her work in a shop or two in Wonthaggi and the talent is great. Hopefully we will be blessed with seeing another piece of artwork a little later. Just loved the imagination of it all and loved the story.
Joy Button, Coronet Bay
March 25, 2014
Fiddlesticks to missing it
Many thanks Jacqui for your article on the Yinnar Fiddleback Festival (Strings are snappin', toes are tappin', March 22 2014). What an incredible lineup of talent. Kicking myself that I missed it but will definitely get there next year!
Vilya Congreave, Wonthaggi
Media spinning in its own news cycle
March 14, 2014
It's very depressing/annoying to watch/hear coverage of the Malaysian Airways MH 370 tragedy. There is one fact: that at 1.22 am radar and radio contact ceased.
MH 370 seems to be caught in a 24-hour news cycle that operates thus:
Today, a (once well respected) Melbourne morning paper even cited that MH370 could have reached the Pakistan border. This was based on information in an American article that the journalist had just refuted.
It really makes me worry about the future of "news" reporting.
Geoff Ellis, Wattle Bank
March 13, 2014
Message from Zimbabwe
Your work is good. I enjoy poetry most and short stories. All the way from Zimbabwe, keep up the good work.
Cain Chikwava, Bulawayo
A crime against nature
March 4, 2014
Engineer-driven plans never take into account common sense. (There’s an old adage: “The sad thing about common sense is that it is NOT common”.)
Natural surfaces in a village like the Cape are much more sensible. But councils and engineers LOVE kerb and channel, drains to make water disappear as soon as possible (into the sea or sewerage storm water). Where are the plans for recycling storm water? Where is the developers' contribution to all this scheming?
For some reason known only to themselves our Bass Coast Council, planners, engineers et al will not be happy until our coastal villages resemble mini Cold Coast horrors. Roll on, Brave New World!
Yvonne McRae, Wonthaggi
March 4, 2014
Very good article, Liz. I can’t see many benefits, if any, from this sealed road/drainage project. I wonder if the council engineers have ever considered a retention system that collects rubbish and pollutants such as oil runoff before the “additional” stormwater enters and pollutes our local beaches? Such retention systems have been introduced in some parts of the world but would only add further costs to an already flawed scheme.
Tim Wilson, Wonthaggi
The blackberry wars
March 4, 2014
Loved the blackberry stories. When we were kids, Dad took us blackberrying (and fishing and shooting rabbits). How otherwise did parents feed six growing kids? My friend, Chris, brought me about 4 pounds a couple of weeks ago. He had collected on his property - on one side of the patches as an emu ate berries on the other side. I made jam and shared around - old Wonthaggi mining days never die.
Yvonne McRae, Wonthaggi
March 4, 2014
It's not just Catherine and her crew who enjoy the benefits of the nearby blackberry harvest. We were lucky enough to score a jar of Catherine's blackberry jam this summer and breakfast has just shifted to the next level at our place. Heavenly. Long may you forage.
Terry, Wonthaggi
March 2, 2014
Your blackberry article brought back a memory of a holiday when I was five. We had come down from Eaglehawk, near Bendigo, for two weeks at Dromana. Our rented house was a glorified fibro shack with a wood fired stove and outside dunny. My most vivid memory is of us picking blackberries from beside the the road and then mum and dad making jam. We must have scavenged enough jars to make it possible. The kitchen was full of heat from the wood stove, there was bubbling and sweet smells and a sense of excitement and making do. I knew at the time that making jam on your beach holiday wasn't quite the usual thing to do but the results were wonderful.
Forty years later, camping with our children at Mallacouta, we had a memorable meal of prawns netted the night before from the estuary in front of us, and for dessert, blackberries picked that morning, with cream. Aah!
Liz Low, Cape Paterson
March 2, 2014
I was appalled at your article about blackberries. They are a noxious weed and wreaked havoc on this wretched country for too long. It is bleeding heart liberals like you who are ruining this fair land! You should be knocked on the head and biffed in the creek, as we used to say in the old country.
Hamish Watson
March 2, 2014
Another good implement to take with you when you go black berrying is a long piece of strong fencing wire with one end bent as a hook. You can use this to bring the long canes heavy with berries out of the middle of the patch to you rather than reaching too far and a) entangling yourself in the prickles or b) blindly grabbing a snake or c) falling down the embankment.
Carolyn Landon, Wonthaggi
March 2, 2014
I love the blackberry story. It always amazes me how many of the things that are natural pleasures are taken away by red tape and the thought that we can still find them if we search is encouraging.
Jacqui Paulson
March 2, 2014
What a delightful piece on blackberry gathering. It took me back to my summer childhood holidays at our Bach at Lake Rotoma, so long ago, when we would walk for miles gathering blackberries. My mum made jam with them and it was always a favourite.
Lenice, Papamoa Beach
March 2, 2014
Catherine I loved this story thank you! and enjoy your blackberries!
Pam Spencer
February 24, 2014
Front row seat
Linda Cuttris's article (Just add water, February 22, 2014) puts into words my delight in watching birds going through their morning and evening bathing rituals. I insist on doing morning dishes as I get the front row seat from our kitchen window to watch these aquatic displays.
At first I thought the order of arrival of the different species was haphazard but now I am not so sure. Black birds are up earlier than most and take first dip, often requiring a refill of the bath water as they joyfully splash their way into the start of their day.
As Linda observes you get notification of the change in the seasons with the regular annual visits of the breeds that drop by, stay awhile and then move on.
They confirm what the the changing colours of the country side are telling us but in a more subtle way.
Bob Middleton, Jeetho West
February 23, 2014
Why should Cape residents pay?
Why are the residents of Cape Patterson subject to this “special charge scheme” (Clock ticks for Cape plan, February 22, 2014)? It seems extremely unfair that residents have to foot the bill for public works outside their properties, and a sum of $12,000 to $14,000 would be equivalent to many people’s yearly mortgage payments. Such a project should be funded by the relevant government authorities, as this is a public land project venture. This is why we pay taxes and rates, to pay for public projects. Possibly a small increase in local rates would be fairer.
Leave the gravel roads alone. Proper stormwater drainage makes sense, but covering natural permeable surfaces with non-permeable surfaces such as bitumen and concrete only adds to the stormwater problems when there are large downpours. Many councils in Melbourne are trying to lessen impervious surfaces by initiating rain gardens in nature strips and planting more nature-strip trees, ie. reverse the process of further adding stormwater run-off, not adding to it.
If this project does go ahead, there will be a large increase in stormwater run-off into the beaches, including pollution. Has this been properly considered by council?
Or is this proposal driven by property development and supposed improvements to real estate with no real consideration given to other important issues such as the overall township rural environment and character?
Tim Wilson, Wonthaggi
February 23, 2014
No more consultation needed
In the Mayor’s statement he said: "It is clear to us now, that our community consultation and engagement during the development of the time restrictions has not been as inclusive as it could have been".
This is a bit of an understatement as there was no community consultation on the banning of dogs on leash from 9am to 6pm.
The Mayor then went on to say: "Councillors are committed to improving the consultation and engagement process during the remainder of the trial and beyond. Individuals and groups are welcome to submit their thoughts to council now and as the review progresses, as many have already done".
Now the council want more consultation for the rest of the “trial”. You would think they could work out what the Inverloch people want by the number of letters in the press and the hundreds of letters the councillors and the council have received plus the 3000 signatures on petitions.
Robert Scott, InverlochFebruary 23, 2014
Most dog owners responsible
Loved the positive story about the hoodies (The hoodies of Red Rocks, February 15, 2014) and how dog owners (like me) are helping out by keeping their dogs away and on leashes. The huge majority of people are responsible pet owners who want to do the right thing and respect other people and wildlife, while enjoying the health and social benefits of walking the dog.
Wendy Davies
February 22, 2014
Seeking Loraine Smith
The Bass Coast Post has been contacted by someone in England seeking a relative called Loraine Smith, who in 1989 lived in Baker Road, Krowera. Ms Smith, aged 68, no longer lives at that address and efforts to track her down have been unsuccessful. If anyone knows her, please pass on this message to her and ask her to contact the Post so we can pass on the message from England.
Catherine Watson, editor
February 22, 2014
Ventnor chicks made it too
Great story on the cutest of little birds (The hoodies of Red Rocks, February 15, 2014). I love watching our little family of 2 chicks on Ventnor Beach. Like Red Rocks, they seem to have made it - and fingers crossed people seem to be respecting the protection barriers and signage and keeping their dogs away.
Anne Paul, Ventnor
February 21, 2014
Memories of St Joseph's
Thanks Frank, just read your experiences as a student at St Joe's Wonthaggi (Suffer the little children, November 24, 2012). It brought so many memories back to me as I spent the same years at St. Joseph's at Kooweerup. Its building, behaviour of the teachers, the education, the physical abuse of minors, the sparse play ground were all the same. It was horrible and it has taken a lifetime to get over it.
It is no wonder that something like 97 per cent of students who went through a Catholic education gave the religion away. It was a terrible system.
Pee Bee
February 20, 2014
Running for Kongor School
I’m preparing to run in the Keeping Kids On Track fun run at Kilcunda on 15 March, an event organised by the Bass Coast Triathlon club . A portion of the entry fees paid by participants is donated to the Kongor Primary School support group led by Felicia Di Stefano. This is a group raising money to purchase building equipment and supervision to build a school building in the town of Kongor, South Sudan, the home town of Jacob and Aluel who now live, with their children, in Wonthaggi. Recent events in South Sudan have made supporters of this project even more determined to keep fundraising. I have gained permission from Felicia and from the organisers of the fun run to seek sponsors for my run, to see if I can help make a further contribution to this project. I plan to do the 10km run, which will be a first for me. If Bass Coast Post readers would like to find out how they can sponsor me, or would like more information, they can contact me at mimsy@y7mail.com.
Miriam Strickland, Wonthaggi
February 20, 2014
Fruit-thieving rotters
In the scheme of things I know this isn't a big deal but we've just returned home to Wonthaggi after four weeks away and were dumbfounded to see someone has entered our property and our hidden-from-view small orchard and completely stripped our fruit trees. Not one stone fruit, not one lemon left, not even on the ground! It would have taken many hours and they would have needed a ladder. So disrespectful. Maybe with lemons at $1.70 each, someone saw a chance to make a buck.
Jen, Wonthaggi
Power to the hoodie brigade
February 16, 2014
Loved the hoodie story (The hoodies of Red Rocks, February 15, 2014). The hoodie brigade are really making a difference. And so good to see the dog people and non-dog people have come together over this sweet vulnerable little bird.
Linda Cuttriss, Phillip Island
Lack of certainty
February 16, 2014
There is confusion in the Cape Paterson community about what will happen if property owners cannot pay for the Special Charge up-front (Crunch point for Cape, February 16, 2014). The council has presented an apparently reassuring explanation but the facts are otherwise.
The council’s debt management policy, stated in a document on the council website dated December 13, 2006, gives almost total discretion to decide whether a property owner affected by the Special Charge Scheme can avoid up-front payment of the charge, to a Financial Hardship Panel. There is a right of appeal against decisions to an appeal committee consisting of the mayor, the CEO and the corporate services director.
My understanding of criteria for eligibility for Council assistance for ‘hardship’ is that:
Under the Policy, a home owner who qualifies for the Hardship Scheme "may" be eligible for one of six types of assistance:
Nicholas Low, Cape Paterson
March 14, 2014
It's very depressing/annoying to watch/hear coverage of the Malaysian Airways MH 370 tragedy. There is one fact: that at 1.22 am radar and radio contact ceased.
MH 370 seems to be caught in a 24-hour news cycle that operates thus:
- Evening news in USA/Europe relates latest speculation based on unsourced "information”. Experts theorise and extrapolate.
- Newspapers around the word quote and add further speculation without fact checking. (For example, a quick search of the Rolls Royce website negates the premise that lack of engine data transmission after any particular time is sinister.) The underlying theme is lack of respect for Malaysian authority/expertise.
- The latest "information" is refuted at the KL afternoon press conference. The media then start reporting the "confusion", blaming the Malaysians for the spread of misinformation. In actual fact they are doing everything properly; any leads are being investigated and discounted. The only confusion arises from imprecise reporting of what has been said.
- Repeat. Everyone wants to know what happened but there is nothing new to report. "The search goes on ..." doesn't fill the void.
Today, a (once well respected) Melbourne morning paper even cited that MH370 could have reached the Pakistan border. This was based on information in an American article that the journalist had just refuted.
It really makes me worry about the future of "news" reporting.
Geoff Ellis, Wattle Bank
March 13, 2014
Message from Zimbabwe
Your work is good. I enjoy poetry most and short stories. All the way from Zimbabwe, keep up the good work.
Cain Chikwava, Bulawayo
A crime against nature
March 4, 2014
Engineer-driven plans never take into account common sense. (There’s an old adage: “The sad thing about common sense is that it is NOT common”.)
Natural surfaces in a village like the Cape are much more sensible. But councils and engineers LOVE kerb and channel, drains to make water disappear as soon as possible (into the sea or sewerage storm water). Where are the plans for recycling storm water? Where is the developers' contribution to all this scheming?
For some reason known only to themselves our Bass Coast Council, planners, engineers et al will not be happy until our coastal villages resemble mini Cold Coast horrors. Roll on, Brave New World!
Yvonne McRae, Wonthaggi
March 4, 2014
Very good article, Liz. I can’t see many benefits, if any, from this sealed road/drainage project. I wonder if the council engineers have ever considered a retention system that collects rubbish and pollutants such as oil runoff before the “additional” stormwater enters and pollutes our local beaches? Such retention systems have been introduced in some parts of the world but would only add further costs to an already flawed scheme.
Tim Wilson, Wonthaggi
The blackberry wars
March 4, 2014
Loved the blackberry stories. When we were kids, Dad took us blackberrying (and fishing and shooting rabbits). How otherwise did parents feed six growing kids? My friend, Chris, brought me about 4 pounds a couple of weeks ago. He had collected on his property - on one side of the patches as an emu ate berries on the other side. I made jam and shared around - old Wonthaggi mining days never die.
Yvonne McRae, Wonthaggi
March 4, 2014
It's not just Catherine and her crew who enjoy the benefits of the nearby blackberry harvest. We were lucky enough to score a jar of Catherine's blackberry jam this summer and breakfast has just shifted to the next level at our place. Heavenly. Long may you forage.
Terry, Wonthaggi
March 2, 2014
Your blackberry article brought back a memory of a holiday when I was five. We had come down from Eaglehawk, near Bendigo, for two weeks at Dromana. Our rented house was a glorified fibro shack with a wood fired stove and outside dunny. My most vivid memory is of us picking blackberries from beside the the road and then mum and dad making jam. We must have scavenged enough jars to make it possible. The kitchen was full of heat from the wood stove, there was bubbling and sweet smells and a sense of excitement and making do. I knew at the time that making jam on your beach holiday wasn't quite the usual thing to do but the results were wonderful.
Forty years later, camping with our children at Mallacouta, we had a memorable meal of prawns netted the night before from the estuary in front of us, and for dessert, blackberries picked that morning, with cream. Aah!
Liz Low, Cape Paterson
March 2, 2014
I was appalled at your article about blackberries. They are a noxious weed and wreaked havoc on this wretched country for too long. It is bleeding heart liberals like you who are ruining this fair land! You should be knocked on the head and biffed in the creek, as we used to say in the old country.
Hamish Watson
March 2, 2014
Another good implement to take with you when you go black berrying is a long piece of strong fencing wire with one end bent as a hook. You can use this to bring the long canes heavy with berries out of the middle of the patch to you rather than reaching too far and a) entangling yourself in the prickles or b) blindly grabbing a snake or c) falling down the embankment.
Carolyn Landon, Wonthaggi
March 2, 2014
I love the blackberry story. It always amazes me how many of the things that are natural pleasures are taken away by red tape and the thought that we can still find them if we search is encouraging.
Jacqui Paulson
March 2, 2014
What a delightful piece on blackberry gathering. It took me back to my summer childhood holidays at our Bach at Lake Rotoma, so long ago, when we would walk for miles gathering blackberries. My mum made jam with them and it was always a favourite.
Lenice, Papamoa Beach
March 2, 2014
Catherine I loved this story thank you! and enjoy your blackberries!
Pam Spencer
February 24, 2014
Front row seat
Linda Cuttris's article (Just add water, February 22, 2014) puts into words my delight in watching birds going through their morning and evening bathing rituals. I insist on doing morning dishes as I get the front row seat from our kitchen window to watch these aquatic displays.
At first I thought the order of arrival of the different species was haphazard but now I am not so sure. Black birds are up earlier than most and take first dip, often requiring a refill of the bath water as they joyfully splash their way into the start of their day.
As Linda observes you get notification of the change in the seasons with the regular annual visits of the breeds that drop by, stay awhile and then move on.
They confirm what the the changing colours of the country side are telling us but in a more subtle way.
Bob Middleton, Jeetho West
February 23, 2014
Why should Cape residents pay?
Why are the residents of Cape Patterson subject to this “special charge scheme” (Clock ticks for Cape plan, February 22, 2014)? It seems extremely unfair that residents have to foot the bill for public works outside their properties, and a sum of $12,000 to $14,000 would be equivalent to many people’s yearly mortgage payments. Such a project should be funded by the relevant government authorities, as this is a public land project venture. This is why we pay taxes and rates, to pay for public projects. Possibly a small increase in local rates would be fairer.
Leave the gravel roads alone. Proper stormwater drainage makes sense, but covering natural permeable surfaces with non-permeable surfaces such as bitumen and concrete only adds to the stormwater problems when there are large downpours. Many councils in Melbourne are trying to lessen impervious surfaces by initiating rain gardens in nature strips and planting more nature-strip trees, ie. reverse the process of further adding stormwater run-off, not adding to it.
If this project does go ahead, there will be a large increase in stormwater run-off into the beaches, including pollution. Has this been properly considered by council?
Or is this proposal driven by property development and supposed improvements to real estate with no real consideration given to other important issues such as the overall township rural environment and character?
Tim Wilson, Wonthaggi
February 23, 2014
No more consultation needed
In the Mayor’s statement he said: "It is clear to us now, that our community consultation and engagement during the development of the time restrictions has not been as inclusive as it could have been".
This is a bit of an understatement as there was no community consultation on the banning of dogs on leash from 9am to 6pm.
The Mayor then went on to say: "Councillors are committed to improving the consultation and engagement process during the remainder of the trial and beyond. Individuals and groups are welcome to submit their thoughts to council now and as the review progresses, as many have already done".
Now the council want more consultation for the rest of the “trial”. You would think they could work out what the Inverloch people want by the number of letters in the press and the hundreds of letters the councillors and the council have received plus the 3000 signatures on petitions.
Robert Scott, InverlochFebruary 23, 2014
Most dog owners responsible
Loved the positive story about the hoodies (The hoodies of Red Rocks, February 15, 2014) and how dog owners (like me) are helping out by keeping their dogs away and on leashes. The huge majority of people are responsible pet owners who want to do the right thing and respect other people and wildlife, while enjoying the health and social benefits of walking the dog.
Wendy Davies
February 22, 2014
Seeking Loraine Smith
The Bass Coast Post has been contacted by someone in England seeking a relative called Loraine Smith, who in 1989 lived in Baker Road, Krowera. Ms Smith, aged 68, no longer lives at that address and efforts to track her down have been unsuccessful. If anyone knows her, please pass on this message to her and ask her to contact the Post so we can pass on the message from England.
Catherine Watson, editor
February 22, 2014
Ventnor chicks made it too
Great story on the cutest of little birds (The hoodies of Red Rocks, February 15, 2014). I love watching our little family of 2 chicks on Ventnor Beach. Like Red Rocks, they seem to have made it - and fingers crossed people seem to be respecting the protection barriers and signage and keeping their dogs away.
Anne Paul, Ventnor
February 21, 2014
Memories of St Joseph's
Thanks Frank, just read your experiences as a student at St Joe's Wonthaggi (Suffer the little children, November 24, 2012). It brought so many memories back to me as I spent the same years at St. Joseph's at Kooweerup. Its building, behaviour of the teachers, the education, the physical abuse of minors, the sparse play ground were all the same. It was horrible and it has taken a lifetime to get over it.
It is no wonder that something like 97 per cent of students who went through a Catholic education gave the religion away. It was a terrible system.
Pee Bee
February 20, 2014
Running for Kongor School
I’m preparing to run in the Keeping Kids On Track fun run at Kilcunda on 15 March, an event organised by the Bass Coast Triathlon club . A portion of the entry fees paid by participants is donated to the Kongor Primary School support group led by Felicia Di Stefano. This is a group raising money to purchase building equipment and supervision to build a school building in the town of Kongor, South Sudan, the home town of Jacob and Aluel who now live, with their children, in Wonthaggi. Recent events in South Sudan have made supporters of this project even more determined to keep fundraising. I have gained permission from Felicia and from the organisers of the fun run to seek sponsors for my run, to see if I can help make a further contribution to this project. I plan to do the 10km run, which will be a first for me. If Bass Coast Post readers would like to find out how they can sponsor me, or would like more information, they can contact me at mimsy@y7mail.com.
Miriam Strickland, Wonthaggi
February 20, 2014
Fruit-thieving rotters
In the scheme of things I know this isn't a big deal but we've just returned home to Wonthaggi after four weeks away and were dumbfounded to see someone has entered our property and our hidden-from-view small orchard and completely stripped our fruit trees. Not one stone fruit, not one lemon left, not even on the ground! It would have taken many hours and they would have needed a ladder. So disrespectful. Maybe with lemons at $1.70 each, someone saw a chance to make a buck.
Jen, Wonthaggi
Power to the hoodie brigade
February 16, 2014
Loved the hoodie story (The hoodies of Red Rocks, February 15, 2014). The hoodie brigade are really making a difference. And so good to see the dog people and non-dog people have come together over this sweet vulnerable little bird.
Linda Cuttriss, Phillip Island
Lack of certainty
February 16, 2014
There is confusion in the Cape Paterson community about what will happen if property owners cannot pay for the Special Charge up-front (Crunch point for Cape, February 16, 2014). The council has presented an apparently reassuring explanation but the facts are otherwise.
The council’s debt management policy, stated in a document on the council website dated December 13, 2006, gives almost total discretion to decide whether a property owner affected by the Special Charge Scheme can avoid up-front payment of the charge, to a Financial Hardship Panel. There is a right of appeal against decisions to an appeal committee consisting of the mayor, the CEO and the corporate services director.
My understanding of criteria for eligibility for Council assistance for ‘hardship’ is that:
- The property must be the principal place of residence, and the owner must own no other property, land or savings valued at more than $15,000.
- The owner must have an income under $34,000 per year.
Under the Policy, a home owner who qualifies for the Hardship Scheme "may" be eligible for one of six types of assistance:
- No payment for a short period (normally maximum four months). In this case you would pay ‘penalty’ interest on the outstanding debt for the period of non-payment. I understand that the penalty rate is currently 10.5% and likely to be raised to 11.5% per year.
- A partial lump sum payment up-front, with the remainder remaining as a charge on the property ‘at a reduced interest cost’.
- Regular payments (weekly, fortnightly, or monthly). Council allows the balance of the debt to remain a charge on the property. The penalty rate of interest applies.
- Regular payment arrangement for the total debt with periods of non-payment.
- Regular payment arrangement but with zero interest. Council allows the balance of the debt to remain as a charge on the property. We do not know if this includes capitalization of the interest accruing at a penalty rate of 11.5% compound or if no interest is charged at all.
- Deferred payment with zero interest. Again the debt would remain as a charge on the property.
Nicholas Low, Cape Paterson
February 9, 2014
Kerbs and verges
Why is this scheme is being pushed by the council (Revised Cape Scheme still flawed: residents group, February 8, 2014)? A question needs to be asked about the consequences of these hardship loans: their debt and interest can reach an unmanageable level.
I would like to hear from a modern urban planner about the heat sinks created by excessive and unnecessary use of tarmac. At the moment, wandering gravel and grass among trees provides a pleasant environment for human and wildlife at Cape. As stated in Nicholas Low's article, roads that have been made, kerbed and channelled encourage cars to speed and are very unpleasant to walk on or near because of surface heat.
The result of trees becoming starved of water, as the channels carry the water away from their roots can be seen in any sub/urbanised area. A dramatic example was the large-scale destruction of mature trees along the Bass Highway at Lang Lang when the highway was duplicated.
One has to wonder who benefits from this obsession with concrete, seen at its most ludicrous in the concreted paths in Guide Park. Concrete is much more damaging in a fall than gravel and grass.
Surely we can leave some places in a more natural state, as well as taking a more realistic view of residents’ capacity to pay such high costs for unnecessary infrastructure.
Heather Murray Tobias, Wonthaggi
February 9, 2013
Clarifications
The Preserve the Cape Group’s survey most likely applies to the originally proposed scheme, not what we will debate next week (Revised Cape Scheme still flawed: residents group, February 8, 2014). Of the $1.5 million council contribution, about $900,000 is added benefits for Cape Paterson.
The photo shows Park Parade Road reserve. It will not have standard kerbing, rather water gardens allowing water to seep into the environment. Similarly at the Cassia Street lower reserve.
Council will avoid vegetation loss with a passion. Most footpaths have been removed from the revised scheme and drainage will largely be directed around existing trees.
Cr Neil Rankine, Bass Coast Mayor
February 9, 2014
Look to other councils
Both sides of the debate about dogs on beach would gain a wealth of information from a study called Living Well Together (Coronet Bay dog owners join beach fray, February 8, 2014).
Auspiced by the WA government, Dr Woods demonstrates how councils can effectively meet the needs of dog owners and those who want to enjoy beach life without dogs. One of the most telling themes is "a top-down approach of imposing bans is divisive and serves to alienate and divide communities. Plans that meet the needs of both parties assist in building community cohesion, pride and social capital.”
Woods reviews the work of councils from all over Australia in implementing combinations of dog-friendly and no-dog zones in their neighbourhoods. Our council falls a long way behind in the planning and implementation of their "no-dog policies".
Mornington Peninsula, Frankston, Bayside, Hobson Bay and Coffs Harbour all have a good mix of no-dog, restricted times/dates, on-lead and all year "free to roam" public spaces and beaches. These councils have embraced providing safe leash-free park areas and dog-friendly beaches scattered throughout the shire. I have been to many of these and there is good signage, the websites have great information/maps and the councils provide bags and bins for waste disposal.
This so-called trial is a failure. The council shows a lack of foresight and planning, was remiss in communication of its "trial", has conflicting advice on its signage and web page. The trial has only served to cause community unrest and distress. Councillors, read Dr Woods to see how it could be done more effectively.
A process of real community consultation and provision of safe, fenced "free to roam" parks and multi-use beaches, as well as "no dogs allowed areas", is essential to meet the varying needs of ratepayers and visitors to the Bass Coast. When the "trial" has finished, let’s hope the council will engage in some focused planning so we can "Live Well Together".
Maria Nethercott, Kilcunda
February 9, 2014
A little consideration, please
I am a little shocked and surprised to find so many dog owners/lovers are against these laws (Coronet Bay dog owners join beach fray, February 8, 2014). I am a dog lover/owner/never-could-be-without-my-dog type of person. Yet I understand that many dog owners do not properly train or restrain their dogs. This poses many problems to people attempting to enjoy our beaches. Children and adults can be, and are, at risk from dogs with owners that believe the beach belong to them.
Coroners Courts are full of such cases. Sadly others even lose their loved ones from "much loved/adored hunters/carnivores" with owners who need reinforcement of their power and control issues.
Let's be considerate and humane, please.
Kay Pam
February 8, 2013
That’s some dredge!
About dredging Western Port for the Port of Hastings (Barge arrival signals start of port works, February 1, 2014) in comparison with the need for 3 million cubic metres to be dredged in each of Queensland or Bay West in Port Phillip Bay, the account for Hastings is 460 million cubic metres. Western Port is shallow, about eight metres on average. The new big container ships need a minimum clearance of 18 metres of water depth, which means 10 metres needs to be dredged. This is from anchorage for no more than six ships, at 6000 metres x 1000 metres x 10m3, then widening the current narrow channel to at least 500 metres wide x 30,000 metres long x 10m3, and now more anchorage north of Hastings – about 5000 metres x 5000 metres x 10m3. Total 460 million cubic metres. They allocate an onshore area for dredge dumping: no more than 1000 metres x 1000 metres. The pile would have to be 460 metres high if it had vertical sides. The alternative is to shift it through the port by container – it would take nearly 12 million of them.
They can say the figures above are pessimistic but by how much? Reduce it by 10, 20 or even 50 per cent and it’s still a huge dredge. How can Premier Napthine promote so much waste of money on misguided, enormous, delusional, environmental vandalism.
Bernie McComb, Cowes
February 2, 2014
Wetland wonders
Thank you for your very informative news - I particularly loved the article by Terri Allan (The joy of wetlands, February 1, 2014). "Joy" is the word I also use to describe this beautiful and unique place - pure joy! I walk there regularly in the cooler months taking photos of everything that comes my way - particularly fungi and I have thousands of photos which I am then able to take to community groups to talk about this amazing bush area - thanks Terri. I also loathe the Pittosporum and try my best to pull them out too. I also stomp on the thistles and other wind blown seeding plants before they have flowered. Aren't we blessed with our bush areas surrounding Wonthaggi - thanks again Terri.
Heather Gardner, Wonthaggi
February 2, 2014
New fire levy red hot
Who do I write/email re the fire levy that is now attached to my rates and how very disappointed I am with the government?
This levy was I thought going to be approximately $200 but it is in fact $500-plus. Business is bad enough these days without an extra bill to pay.
Will I get a refund from my insurance company for the fire levy I have already paid?
I am also being slugged a commercial rate on my house in San Remo as I have recently built another house on the same block of land and have my family staying in the front smaller house for holidays.
I only pay one lot of rates previously. Now I have to pay two lots for rates plus the commerical fire levy on both even though I have not subdivided the block of land.
Very, very disappointed in the state government and the stupid, stupid decisions they make without thinking through the effect it will have on an already hurting economy.
Bronwyn Pratt, San Remo
Kerbs and verges
Why is this scheme is being pushed by the council (Revised Cape Scheme still flawed: residents group, February 8, 2014)? A question needs to be asked about the consequences of these hardship loans: their debt and interest can reach an unmanageable level.
I would like to hear from a modern urban planner about the heat sinks created by excessive and unnecessary use of tarmac. At the moment, wandering gravel and grass among trees provides a pleasant environment for human and wildlife at Cape. As stated in Nicholas Low's article, roads that have been made, kerbed and channelled encourage cars to speed and are very unpleasant to walk on or near because of surface heat.
The result of trees becoming starved of water, as the channels carry the water away from their roots can be seen in any sub/urbanised area. A dramatic example was the large-scale destruction of mature trees along the Bass Highway at Lang Lang when the highway was duplicated.
One has to wonder who benefits from this obsession with concrete, seen at its most ludicrous in the concreted paths in Guide Park. Concrete is much more damaging in a fall than gravel and grass.
Surely we can leave some places in a more natural state, as well as taking a more realistic view of residents’ capacity to pay such high costs for unnecessary infrastructure.
Heather Murray Tobias, Wonthaggi
February 9, 2013
Clarifications
The Preserve the Cape Group’s survey most likely applies to the originally proposed scheme, not what we will debate next week (Revised Cape Scheme still flawed: residents group, February 8, 2014). Of the $1.5 million council contribution, about $900,000 is added benefits for Cape Paterson.
The photo shows Park Parade Road reserve. It will not have standard kerbing, rather water gardens allowing water to seep into the environment. Similarly at the Cassia Street lower reserve.
Council will avoid vegetation loss with a passion. Most footpaths have been removed from the revised scheme and drainage will largely be directed around existing trees.
Cr Neil Rankine, Bass Coast Mayor
February 9, 2014
Look to other councils
Both sides of the debate about dogs on beach would gain a wealth of information from a study called Living Well Together (Coronet Bay dog owners join beach fray, February 8, 2014).
Auspiced by the WA government, Dr Woods demonstrates how councils can effectively meet the needs of dog owners and those who want to enjoy beach life without dogs. One of the most telling themes is "a top-down approach of imposing bans is divisive and serves to alienate and divide communities. Plans that meet the needs of both parties assist in building community cohesion, pride and social capital.”
Woods reviews the work of councils from all over Australia in implementing combinations of dog-friendly and no-dog zones in their neighbourhoods. Our council falls a long way behind in the planning and implementation of their "no-dog policies".
Mornington Peninsula, Frankston, Bayside, Hobson Bay and Coffs Harbour all have a good mix of no-dog, restricted times/dates, on-lead and all year "free to roam" public spaces and beaches. These councils have embraced providing safe leash-free park areas and dog-friendly beaches scattered throughout the shire. I have been to many of these and there is good signage, the websites have great information/maps and the councils provide bags and bins for waste disposal.
This so-called trial is a failure. The council shows a lack of foresight and planning, was remiss in communication of its "trial", has conflicting advice on its signage and web page. The trial has only served to cause community unrest and distress. Councillors, read Dr Woods to see how it could be done more effectively.
A process of real community consultation and provision of safe, fenced "free to roam" parks and multi-use beaches, as well as "no dogs allowed areas", is essential to meet the varying needs of ratepayers and visitors to the Bass Coast. When the "trial" has finished, let’s hope the council will engage in some focused planning so we can "Live Well Together".
Maria Nethercott, Kilcunda
February 9, 2014
A little consideration, please
I am a little shocked and surprised to find so many dog owners/lovers are against these laws (Coronet Bay dog owners join beach fray, February 8, 2014). I am a dog lover/owner/never-could-be-without-my-dog type of person. Yet I understand that many dog owners do not properly train or restrain their dogs. This poses many problems to people attempting to enjoy our beaches. Children and adults can be, and are, at risk from dogs with owners that believe the beach belong to them.
Coroners Courts are full of such cases. Sadly others even lose their loved ones from "much loved/adored hunters/carnivores" with owners who need reinforcement of their power and control issues.
Let's be considerate and humane, please.
Kay Pam
February 8, 2013
That’s some dredge!
About dredging Western Port for the Port of Hastings (Barge arrival signals start of port works, February 1, 2014) in comparison with the need for 3 million cubic metres to be dredged in each of Queensland or Bay West in Port Phillip Bay, the account for Hastings is 460 million cubic metres. Western Port is shallow, about eight metres on average. The new big container ships need a minimum clearance of 18 metres of water depth, which means 10 metres needs to be dredged. This is from anchorage for no more than six ships, at 6000 metres x 1000 metres x 10m3, then widening the current narrow channel to at least 500 metres wide x 30,000 metres long x 10m3, and now more anchorage north of Hastings – about 5000 metres x 5000 metres x 10m3. Total 460 million cubic metres. They allocate an onshore area for dredge dumping: no more than 1000 metres x 1000 metres. The pile would have to be 460 metres high if it had vertical sides. The alternative is to shift it through the port by container – it would take nearly 12 million of them.
They can say the figures above are pessimistic but by how much? Reduce it by 10, 20 or even 50 per cent and it’s still a huge dredge. How can Premier Napthine promote so much waste of money on misguided, enormous, delusional, environmental vandalism.
Bernie McComb, Cowes
February 2, 2014
Wetland wonders
Thank you for your very informative news - I particularly loved the article by Terri Allan (The joy of wetlands, February 1, 2014). "Joy" is the word I also use to describe this beautiful and unique place - pure joy! I walk there regularly in the cooler months taking photos of everything that comes my way - particularly fungi and I have thousands of photos which I am then able to take to community groups to talk about this amazing bush area - thanks Terri. I also loathe the Pittosporum and try my best to pull them out too. I also stomp on the thistles and other wind blown seeding plants before they have flowered. Aren't we blessed with our bush areas surrounding Wonthaggi - thanks again Terri.
Heather Gardner, Wonthaggi
February 2, 2014
New fire levy red hot
Who do I write/email re the fire levy that is now attached to my rates and how very disappointed I am with the government?
This levy was I thought going to be approximately $200 but it is in fact $500-plus. Business is bad enough these days without an extra bill to pay.
Will I get a refund from my insurance company for the fire levy I have already paid?
I am also being slugged a commercial rate on my house in San Remo as I have recently built another house on the same block of land and have my family staying in the front smaller house for holidays.
I only pay one lot of rates previously. Now I have to pay two lots for rates plus the commerical fire levy on both even though I have not subdivided the block of land.
Very, very disappointed in the state government and the stupid, stupid decisions they make without thinking through the effect it will have on an already hurting economy.
Bronwyn Pratt, San Remo
