Oasis on a crowded planet
December 16, 2017
Excellent comments on Phillip Islands future by Phil Wright.To accommodate the inevitable growth in Melbourne's south east corridor which will force increased public pressure on Phillip Island there needs to be a viable vision and strategic plan supported by both state and local governments to establish the Island as a permanent natural retreat for residents and visitors.
The opportunity exists today to create a strategy for an Islands future that recognises, and retains, its natural attractions, open spaces and environmental uniqueness.
Essential to this strategy is the control of vehicle traffic and the associated parking demands by planning for free and frequent shuttle bus services with parking on the mainland. The service to shuttle the day visitors to and from the many tourist destinations that the Island can provide including the towns, beaches, nature reserves and the Penguin parade.
The future of the Island must be decided by forward thinking people not by continuous unfettered growth.
Ian Samuel
Fantastic Phil, let us all contribute to this vision and make it a reality.
Jan Fleming
Couldn't agree more about buses, park and ride, but how about electric, not dirty, noisy, grinding diesels? Now not later.
Bernie
Showing great vision Phil. If London can work towards a National Park., why Not Phillip Island? The statutory purpose of national park status is to "conserve and enhance the natural beauty, wildlife and cultural heritage of the area" and "promote opportunities for the understanding and enjoyment of the special qualities of the park by the public." What if we took these ideas and applied them to Phillip Island? I think this would radically change how we see, think about, design, manage and experience Phillip Island and how we can preserve the island for generations.
Cr Clare Le Serve
Yes I agree Bernie.
Electric shuttle buses with charging points in San Remo and Cowes would promote the vision of a nature park and demonstrate a commitment to the environment.
If the Victorian State Government is prepared, "as it is claimed", to subsidise the operation of a car ferry, then a subsidy for establishing and operating electric shuttle
buses to protect our unique Island environment should be given priority by both local and state authorities.
Ian Samuel
Well written Phil. I could not agree with you more. The seed needs to be planted into the minds of our younger generation to continue the good work of Land Care and all it's
wonderful band of volunteers.
I also agree that the farming community have a clear vision of the potential use their land offers to the tourist industry.
If we had better transport all year round this too would protect our environment.
We can dream.
Pamela J Gill JP
A carrying capacity of 70,000, and they still want a car ferry to bring on MORE???
Gimme a break!
Mike Cleeland
I agree wholeheartedly with Clare Le Serve that we could work towards making the island a National Park for the benefit of future generations. Volunteers working for such bodies as the Barb Martin Bushbank have already contributed significantly to the revegetation of the island.
All of us need to work together towards this vision.
Jan Fleming
Thank you Phil for a very thought provoking article.
As a result of it, I hope we can hear the voices of the kids at school, the young adults who are leaving school, the young families who see this place as their home, as well as the current and past custodians of the land.
I want to know what they believe are the future actions that will ensure outcomes that they believe are "sustainable/desirable" for their future and the future of our place.
It would be very nice if they endorsed and supported the Phil's views.
We could all then move forward with confidence and trust.
Ray McNamara
The art of Robert Smith
December 16, 2017
What a great gift. It’s difficult to fully comprehend the enormity and importance of this collection to the Wonthaggi community. If ever there was an impetus to the development of an “arts precinct “ this surely is it. The proposals to build a regional gallery and the Rotary International Sculpture Park together with the “Wonthaggi Plinth” Sculpture competition for Australian sculptors adds to the growing of Wonthaggi’s identity as mature and sophisticated.
John Mutsaers
Thank you Catherine. I join in welcoming Robert Smith to Wonthaggi and very much look forward to seeing the collection he has given us. In the near future I look forward to seeing the whole of the Bass Coast and surrounds art collection in a Wonthaggi based cultural precinct incorporating a gallery, a library and a theatre. We need to aim high.
Felicia Di Stefano
Such a generous,valuable and timely gift as another focus on Wonthaggi in the arts, helping secure our place on the cultural map.
Ellen Hubble
What a great acquisition for the Wonthaggi community. Lets all do what we can to ensure suitable gallery space is provided for these valuable items.
Beth Spence
To Robert Smith and the wonderful people of Wonthaggi.
I knew Robert when I was an undergraduate at Flinders University. He is a wonderful man, a Renaissance
man, an academic with vibrant, knowledgeable compassionate and dedicated values always. I feel so very proud of his wonderful contribution to your fine place. He is such a genuine soul. I owe any success of my own to his enthusiastic life's work as a meaningful professional.
Thanks Robert. You are one of the most excellent human beings that have ever been.
John Gallagher
Down by the river
December 16, 2017
Thanks Anne the day clashed with a Red Nose grandparents meet.
Love landcare they make horticulture accessible to everyone.
Neri Melsmith
This is brilliant and in such a great spot - almost every visitor to, and most residents of, Bass Coast will witness the development of this garden.
Landcare: Keep at it!
Geoff Ellis
Wonthaggi à la mode
December 16, 2017
Thanks Catherine for acquainting us with this interesting collection and it's imminent exhibition in Wonthaggi! The items you have included for viewing have wet my curiosity and I'll be sure to visit the town hall this January.
Sue Packham
Stunning. I look forward to viewing this great collection. So lucky to live in this part of the world with so many talented people sharing tbeir collections and ideas.
N Smith
Popped into the Civic Centre yesterday- this exhibition is stunning, the passion of the people behind it is inspiring and another reason for a regional gallery/ arts/ exhibition centre in Bass Coast NOW or at least ASAP.
Geoff Ellis
Diamonds are forever
December 16, 2017
Congratulations and all the best to the unforgettable and delightful Jill Muir
Trish Hogan
15 years! - Thanks Jill, your wit and wisdom will be missed.
Geoff Ellis
Blessings
December 16, 2017
Thank you for a sunny story, Miriam. Your self analysis is certainly inspirational. I agree, when we are gentle with ourselves and recognise our potential, we shine. I return your blessing; Shalom.
Felicia Di Stefano
Island at the crossroads
December 1, 2017
I sigh whenever people state on Vicroads forums and the PI Traffic forum that we must "build another bridge" and "widen all the main roads with extra lanes."
Interestingly, I never recognise the writers of these comments as permanent locals.
We must decide what we want our Island to be. The very reason it is so attractive at present is the abundance of natural attractions, including the untouched beaches, green landscapes and rural breaks, rather than just a sea of houses, big chain Melbourne stores, and congested traffic, as the Mornington Peninsula has now become.
Cr Whelan writes: "Greater density of development within the town of Cowes, with no expansion of the town boundaries. Sensitive development must also be demanded in the small coastal towns to preserve their integrity and appeal."
This will require a shift from the “one size fits all” approach of the State Planning Policy framework, which requires councils to ensure 10 years’ land supply for residential development. This dictum is driven by a desire to house an increasing Melbourne population but is blind to the requirements of a tourism destination that relies on its natural environment.
PLEASE, please let's think of this now and plan, rather than look back with a sigh at how it "used to be."
Natasha
It's very heartening to read Cr Whelan's analysis of Phillip Island's strategic planning challenge.
It can't be said too often: "the environment is the economy". If we ignore this obvious fact then our Island is likely to end up just another overdeveloped appendage to Melbourne's urban sprawl.
He's dead right to call for urgent transference of key tourism and environment strategies into the Bass Coast Planning Scheme via amendments, without delay. The one-size-fits-all current Scheme must not be allowed to dictate the development future of such a unique place with such a lot at stake. We hope local councillors and Spring Street politicians are listening to Cr Whelan's timely warning.
Greg Johnson
What Councillor Whelan and, unfortunately, several of his fellow Councillors, have got wrong, is that the current Planning Scheme is what you have to work with.
To be using Strategic Plans or wish lists of the future to guide your planning decisions now is wrong and your planning staff should be telling you so.
To be planning an overlay which will affect privately owned land with out informing or consulting with the owner of the land is extremely arrogant.
To refuse the application for a Rehab Centre in the Warley Hospital because you would like to see it turn into a seven story block of flats even though that is not a permitted use now, is breath taking!
Still believe in Santa?
Ruth Partridge
Thanks Ruth. Yes I do believe in Santa but he didn't come to me - he came to the developers that left the legacy issues of estates on Phillip Island with no made roads or drainage, that have been able to develop small blocks with not trees and even less character. That put an industrial estate surrounded by housing and directs heavy vehicles through settled areas and along roads of wonderful conservation value such as Coghlan Road. Yes well done to the Planning Scheme and those who travel with her. We have commenced the process to change it by the way and include our wish list (I mean strategies) in it. And yes your version of arrogance is actually spelt 'leadership' in my dictionary.
Michael Whelan
Totally agree with Cr. Whelan's sentiments. Phillip Island is unique and equal to many other places of significant natural beauty. A "one size fits all" planning scheme will not work for Phillip Island or Bass Coast.
Carmen Bush
I totally agree you cannot replace what is lost. A prime example of this is the "Gold Coast"
Once a pleasant holiday destination visited for its natural beauty and relaxed atmosphere, over development has turned this area into a mini las Vegas with beautiful beaches and natural attractions being overlooked by high rise development and glitzy night life.
This must not be the destination for Phillip Island where the most significant and unique values of our Island and environs are based on the appreciation of nature, rural scenes and clean beaches.
State Government give lip service to supporting and retaining our unique environment with one size fits all planning schemes overriding the potential advantages that are unique to this area.
Continuous growth of the residential area must be avoided, and I applaud the Councilors who have the conviction to address this problem
Ian Samuel
I am so pleased that Councillor Whelan has it so right about Phillip Island.Our special environment is our future and thankfully he will stand to protect that before all is lost.
Vicki Breen
I’m interested in your point about encouraging medium density housing in Cowes, rather than the grotesque suburban development we’re seeing now, of big houses on small blocks.
In European cities like Copenhagen and Amsterdam, most people live in well-designed four- or five-storey apartment blocks with balconies and common gardens and public spaces. They are close to shops and public transport. Few people have cars. Bikes are the preferred mode of transport.
With higher density, all sorts of things become possible – better public transport, café culture, cinemas, bars, tennis courts, swimming pools, a year-round economy.
For closer inspiration on how Cowes might evolve into a vibrant small town, perhaps we could look to Brunswick where two medium-rise apartment blocks, the Commons and Nightingale, by Breathe Architecture (http://www.breathe.com.au/) are setting a new standard for sustainable, thoughtful, affordable design.
Of course these places are not for everyone; some people want their own house on their own block. But I can see a growing cohort of ageing baby boomers who would be quite happy to swap the quarter acre and house for a smart, sustainable apartment in a vibrant small town on an island of natural wonders.
But how does Bass Coast Council encourage, or perhaps even mandate, better urban development?
Catherine Watson
Thanks Catherine, I agree we can learn a lot from overseas cities that have a history before the motor vehicle. I attended a briefing on the Nightingale project - am excellent project wouldn't it be great to see something like that in Cowes.
Michael Whelan
There is one thing you need and another you have, to achieve these protections. You need a Localised Planning Statement embedded in the planning scheme. These tell the government the characteristics you desire for an area. There are a few in the state planning scheme at present, e.g. Mornington and Ballarine Peninsulas, which are municipality wide. They can be used more specifically to a part of a municipality, like the Island, which then allows stronger controls as we already have the second thing needed - the mainland, and in particular Wonthaggi, which can provide the bulk of the 15 year land supply demanded by government for the greater municipality. This assures Wonthaggi's future as a regional centre, and flowing from that, more jobs for the whole municipality.
Neil Rankine
Bandicoot island
December 1, 2017
Great to read of a successful return of one of natures beautiful creatures and in our district too.
Daryl Hook
I commend the Nature Parks. The success of the release is wonderful, at both Churchill Island and the Summerlands Peninsula.
Jan Fleming
Full and plenty
December 1, 2017
Thank you for a most interesting story, Carolyn. We try to emulate the forebearers you describe. As well as providing fresh and home made produce, subsistence farming lightens the footprint on our earth.
Felicia Di Stefano
I am printing out this story for my 2 Italian friends, I am sure they would be delighted to read it as much as me and my Italian partner. Thank you Carolyn.
Natasha Williams
Wet wonderland
December 1, 2017
Wonthaggi is lucky to have reserves that can be returned to a natural wonderland ,lucky to have people like Terri too.
Daryl Hook
Wonderful Terri.I hope you included some of this in an objection re the proposed 93 lot subdivision adjoining the Rifle Range wetland. The last thing the wetland needs is the storm water from a huge subdivision pouring into the Rifle Range.
Yvonne McRae
Great description Terry, thank goodness we have wonderful people like you, Nola, Lorraine, Dinah and others.
Jan Fleming
Thanks again to Terri Allen for a finely detailed and beautifully succinct picture of the wonder of Wonthaggi's wetlands.And, of course, to the Post for bringing this important story to us.
Linda Gordon
Out of the shadows
November 18, 2017
Wednesday 15th November, 2017
I woke up and my first thought was, today’s the day
I’d run out of grog and had to dash to Foodworks for my spelt bread
I made it back in time and turned on the telly at about a quarter to 10
I inhaled, felt tense, then forced myself to relax
I found the theatre of the announcement amusing
The moment soon arrived
I held my breath
The announcement
I shed a tear
O fabjous day! *
* Thanks to Lewis Carroll’s Jabberwocky
69 year old gay woman, Wonthaggi (I’m withholding my name because the event was not about me, it was about all 69 year old gay women.)
Our own families sometimes provide our worst experiences of homophobia. For those of us unlucky enough to have such families, the hurt can be so deep that it is difficult to articulate it – especially in a way that others can understand. Family bonds, both positive and negative, run so deep.
Given this, and that we live in a heteronormative society, I think marriage equality offers important legal and emotional support for gay people. We will not just be “almost" equal in law but actually equal. (At least we will be equal when it comes to matters of wills, superannuation, not having to “prove” our relationships, and the like, even if our religious MPs insist on inserting certain ridiculous exemptions from anti-discrimination when it comes to gay people.)
Name withheld for family reasons
On Wednesday morning, I was as grumpy as Tony Abbott. Weren’t there more important matters? People kept reminding me it wasn’t about weddings, or even wedding cakes, it was about equality.
Turnbull hailed it as “a vote for fairness” and democracy at its best. I don’t care much for this sort of democracy. Sixty per cent for, 40 against. Therefore same-sex marriage is good. Ten years ago it would have been 40 for and 60 against. Same-sex marriage would have been bad. By definition, the people are always right in a democracy.
I wasn’t even going to vote – I thought a pox on both your houses – but my straight friends were so enthusiastic and idealistic I felt I had to support them by returning my form.
It’s been a long road to equality, much longer than the past three months of political nonsense. It has finally happened because of people like Wayne and Keith and Phyllis and Francesca and all those who were brave enough to be themselves despite society’s disapproval.
Catherine Watson
Fantastic news for everyone.
We certainly voted yes.
Jan Fleming and John Adam.
I woke up on Wednesday morning hoping for the best and ready for the worst. As a gay retired statistician I had been tracking the polls on Excel and was quietly confident and had a big figure "7 million" in mind which when announced I knew we had won. I punched the air and said "YES!!!" and unexpectedly cried. It took a few seconds more I guess for that figure to be put in percentage terms of 61.5% for the rest of the LGBTIQ community to realise we had won.
Sadly a lovely older Christian lady in my small community and I haven't spoken during this divisive debate. I am sure in her own way she is as devastated by the result as I would have been if it had gone the other way.
What to do? Go on being the ordinary and great neighbours we have always been. Not the flashy Mardi Gras crowd or loud activists, who nonetheless all have their place. Prove to them that this is not the Gaypocalypse they feared. Respect the differences and get on with our ordinary (and just a tiny bit fabulous) lives.
James
What I find saddest is that 40% still voted No - and the first two comments have their names withheld.
And for what? A bit of paper. Matt and I married after 15 years together a couple of years ago because we had to have that piece of paper in order to volunteer overseas. So important it was that we forgot to tell people of the news in our New Year's note to family and friends on the preceding year's events.
Having said that it is important to some people and so - why have so many thought (and sought through their vote) to deny this joy to others?
Liane Arno
Hello Liane, I didn't withhold my name for any reason other than I wanted other 69 year old women to feel as though I was speaking on their behalf. They could own my comment as well. It's not the piece of paper that's important, it's the sense of belonging. There are probably many gay people who will choose not to marry but it's nice to know that soon they can make that choice.
Pamela Jacka
Across the country 133 electorates said YES and 17 electorates said NO. Of the 17 electorates that said NO most were in Western Sydney. A lot of the people in Western Sydney are overseas born and very conservative. And there is nothing wrong with this.
Just think about the fact that 89% of the electorates across Australia said YES and be very proud of ourselves for recognising that we are all equal.
F W Schooneveldt
Australia has Voted. So move on.
Get over it.
Remember those special seven letters.
RESPECT
Pamela Gill JP
I, like our editor was not going to vote. Do not know if this makes sense but it is a fantasy of mine that when the powers that be in the AFL put up the Grand Final prices to a high that excludes many I have this dream that not a soul will turn up at the MCG in protest.Just think of that. An empty stadium echoing with protest. That is how I felt about the vote. Why oh why do we have to take a vote on such an injustice?
Why did I change my mind? An old and dear friend visited recently and made it clear he would vote NO. So I had to negate his vote. He claimed homosexuality was due to parental upbringing. So now I am wondering when the rest of my kids will cross over to the rainbow side of the street to join one of my four children. (Laptop hasn't been very straight these past few days hence my late comment. Sorry.)
Bob Middleton
Pun intended, Bob? :o)
Pamela Jacka
Broadbent: it’s still no
November 16, 2017
Russell, Have you not heard that democracy is of the people, for the people, by the people.
Your people have voted.
Your people have said YES.
Your duty as their representative is to vote YES.
If you don't get that message - resign.
Ray McNamara
Russell Broadbent hasn't heard any of the above, especially the YES, and more unfortunately, the RESIGN. He seems to forget that we pay his wages to represent us. Why would he bother responding to Bass Coast Post? He doesn't bother to respond to his constituency about anything. And as for responding to the ABS survey results ... Go on Russell, have a 'conscience vote' based on your own personal opinion and values. That's far more important than betrayal of the electorate's opinion and wishes. A NO vote is a vote for homophobia and divisiveness. And always remember, the heterosexual marriage between a man and a woman is always the marriage that produces the gay, lesbian & transgender offspring.
Julie Tyrrell
Whoa, whoa Julie, you have to understand that, although you think that gay marriage is OK, other people have the right to disagree without being labelled homophobic or divisive.
It is possible to hold a view that accepts homosexual relationships as a loving and joyous part of our society, and also consider marriage to be the union of a man and a woman.
Ruth Partridge
exactly - please leave now and close that door behind you … When the majority of your electorate speaks you should have listened
Rosemary
Russell, I voted yes because I believe in equality.
I understand that you have a conscience vote on the SSM Bill and are not restricted to vote along party lines or how your electorate voted. I note that a number of NSW elected members have said they will support the bill even though the majority of their constituents voted no.
We need to respect a person’s right for a conscience vote because this is democracy.
Frank W Schooneveldt
As a voter in this electorate, I would like my YES preferences to be reflected along with the majority of voters in the region. I would like any member of this community to have equal rights or better to my own as a old and therefore almost invisible member of our community.
Fran Carroll
"Yes" or "No" not "MAYBE, EH? Can't decide?" What message would abstention send in a conscience vote? Wow.
Some party. Two members who represent different chunks of Bass Coast with opposing responses to similar data, cancel each other out.
$120 million for a void. This is a void:( ). This one's free.
Some other party: Next time rainbow revelry reigns in Cape P extend the invitation, please. People in Flinders have more to celebrate, apparently.
Geoff Ellis
Geoff, Your use of the English language is beyond me. Please write in simple ways that we can all understand. You need to respect a conscience vote and what that means in a democratic society.
Frank W Schooneveldt
Frank - Thanks for the instruction but I am used to writing to a word limit - I completely respect a conscience vote - every time I raise my hand at a council meeting it's a conscience vote. I was democratically elected.
Comment decoded - Cape Paterson residents live in McMillan and their representative is going to vote No or abstain which is essentially saying no but not owning it.
By accident I live in Flinders and my federal rep is going to vote YES so I have more to celebrate than if I lived in Cape Paterson as I voted YES.
If the vote was going to be based on the member's conscience why did they spend $120 mill to ask us what we thought only to ignore it? The connotative definition of a conscience vote in this context is equivalent to a 'free' vote ie not guided by party lines, rather than guided by their conscience. It's the collective conscience of the electorate that informs a conscience vote, not the bias of an individual.
The federal government did the same thing with the Uluru statement so at least they are consistently ignoring OUR views.
Geoffrey Ellis
Bye bye Russell
Sandra Guy
Russell, most of the dinosaurs became extinct 120 million years ago........
Mark Robertson
I think the YES is.....Russell... RESIGN if you cannot agree with the people who elected you.
Fran Carroll
Geoff, The Australian electorate voted Yes in 133 electorates and no in 17 electorates. The majority of the No electorates are in NSW.
This is one of the most strongest endorsements of the importance of people’s equality there can be and sends a clear message to politicians in Canberra to pass the SSM Bill and quickly. I have no doubt the the bill will pass regardless of how Russell Broadbent votes.
I think Russell Broadbent as already said he will not be contesting the next election which is a good thing. This is an an opportunity to bring in some young progressive thinkers into the electorate.
Frank W Schooneveldt
Frank, I totally agree with your first points though I haven't heard about Mr Broadbent's plans to contest, or not contest. Who ever stands I hope they check their compliance with our constitution. Hopefully Mr Broadbent will be the last member for McMillan! He was the last member for Corinella but that didn't deter him.........
Geoff Ellis
This is where conscience votes get tricky. Should they represent the MP's own views or the views of the majority of the electorate? The answer probably depends on whether they vote according to our own views.
But we can't have it both ways. After all, in 2006 many of us applauded Russell Broadbent when he crossed the floor to vote against his own party’s immigration policy, which involved mandatory processing of asylum seekers off-shore. Only a minority of voters in his electorate would have supported his action then, but he voted according to his conscience.
So while I don't agree with Mr Broadbent's view on marriage equality, I do agree that he should vote according to his own conscience, not ours.
Catherine Watson
There's been some discussion about this in my little neck of the woods, and I've come the conclusion that the vote in Parliament should be as per the MP's electorate. Conscience votes were for the survey.
An acquaintance of mine said that Mr Broadbent should vote as electorate voted but didn't apply the same "logic" to Mr Jason Clare who has also decided to vote against his electorate. The only difference is that Mr Clare is going to vote Yes whereas his electorate of Blaxland voted No. It's a funny world, isn't it?
Pamela Jacka
The whole saga of EQUALITY has been handled poorly by our Parliament - this is far from over but lets face it they love our taxes at work
Rosemary
Let's not forget that freedoms include freedom of conscience. Russell Broadbent is entitled to his own freedoms. He has served this community well over many years and deserves respect just like every voter who voted No and every voter who voted Yes. The people who cannot understand that are displaying a low level of intelligence.
Mohan de Run
Let's not forget that this was but a survey, not a warrant and sans obligation.
Geoff Ellis
ALP selects ex-mayor
November 17, 2017
Jordan,
Congratulations on your pre- selection. I have always respected your views even when we are poles apart.
Cheers and good luck.
Frank W Schooneveldt
Wonderful news
Neri
Congratulations Jordan. I remember your tireless and important work for the Bass Coast Council. I support you in every way. Best of luck.
Felicia Di Stefano
Wonderful news. May your path lead to success. We need people like you to help light up the way. You have my support. Go for it.
Bob Middleton
As an ALP member for 45 years, I join with so others congratulating Jordan Crugnale on her candidature for the ALP for the seat of Bass. Jordan is the candidate that will inspire people to vote Labor.
I stood for a seat that had been held historically by the liberals and won it for Labor for the first time. Seats change all the time.
Jordan has enormous energy, strength, organising abilities and compassion, and living in the electorate.
Having been a local councillor will have expert and in depth knowledge concerning the local area.
The community will have a quality ALP candidate to fight the State election next year, and hopefully an ALP MP in the Andrews Government to represent the needs of the bass community.
Kay Setches
Good on you Jordan - I will help in anyway I can with your campaign to win Bass for the ALP.
Susan Anderson
Go Jordan.!🐸
Daryl Hook
Warley drug clinic rejected
November 16, 2017
I attended the Council Meeting on Wednesday evening and was disappointed Cr Fullarton did not have the numbers to get approval for this much needed Medical Facility in Cowes. Addiction issues unfortunately exist in most communities and Phillip Island is no exception . I believe the treatment that is to be provided in the Rehab Centre would give support to users and their families and show that we are a caring community.
Anne Davie
Our Council have a "wish" that the old Warley Hospital site will be redeveloped into an high density residential building and are planning an overlay to facilitate this. That will not make it happen how ever hard you wish.
It is privately owned and has been mostly vacant for the past 12 years. At last there is a potential tenant who would refurbish it, put it to good use, provide employment for a range of skills, return on investment for the owners and our Council says "NO".
We will all thank you so very much as our dear old hospital, given to our community by a man with vision, slowly slides into dereliction and becomes an eyesore waiting, maybe for decades, for someone will very deep pockets to fulfill a planning "wish". What hogwash.
Having denied the owners of Warley hospital the chance to get a return on their investment, I suggest that the Council should not be charging rates!!
Ruth Partridge
Can't believe Council has rejected and not welcomed such a vital facility that perfectly fit the abandoned shell. On a locally significant site dedicated to community purpose (c. 1923) this renewal would have inherited the values of a long term vision that provided for community before tourism was a word. And for corrective vision, note the Cowes Activity Centre Plan has been edited already.
Nicola Tragear
This would have been one great step forward for the community, We have a Huge lack of support of rehabilitation programs seems the people on Council out of touch you are supposed to represent the community take your horse blinkers off we are here to help not discriminate
Duke
Why I won’t watch the Oils
November 18, 2017
That heckler was right, when they played at the Island years ago with Painters and Dockers, the Oils were way too serious. The Dockers blew them off the stage!
Jeff Sim
Thanks, John, for such an articulate and moving article. I am filled with rage whenever I see Peter Garrett in the news, particularly in recent times as he has the gall to get back on stage and assume his old persona (it seems to me). Such utter hypocrisy and I'm astounded that, for the most part, it seems no one calls him out on it. It truly is dispiriting.
Sue Saliba
Absolutely so true.
I too was inspired in the late 80s.
I had the oils tattooed on my back and thought Peter stood for so much more.
Only to find the desal plant, the home insulation scheme and even mining up north.
It’s a shame he sold out and wants to go back
Andrew
Well said John - Garrett and Burke, along with the Victorian Labour experts ,denied the existence of our special winter visitors for years, despite the heroic efforts of caring locals - even the stunning photos of Geaff Glare and Lisa Schonberg failed to convince them. The Winter Whale Watch program which was initiated by Watershed eventually spawned the Bass Coast Whale Trail signs along our coast - validating our concerns. I have tried to have the Watershed logo included on the signs, in recognition of the hundreds of people who contributed, but it has been decided that it is not appropriate. Even a direction from council is not enough. Last week, the Sentinel times proclaimed that Harriet Shing is throwing money into the Island Whale Festival -the very state government who dismissed our valid concerns are now promoting the Bass Coast whales.!!! I am both proud and befuddled at the entire process -proud that our efforts are recognised, and befuddled that all the so-called experts got it so wrong. Our question was simple - if the voluminous desal EES could not see something as big as a whale, then what else had been overlooked? That question still stands, given the complete lack of evidence surrounding the long-term environmental impact s during operation of the Great White Elephant. The desal protests displayed the caring nature and incredible expertise of our residents, and I am incredibly proud of all who stood up to the big and nasty bullies.
Mark Robertson . President. Watershed Victoria
Reminds me of when the GFC hit and all the ministers had to come up with plans on what to do to invigorate the economy. Peter Garrett's idea was to insulate every house in Australia. We know how that turned out and Kevin Rudd took the hit for it even though it was his minister Peter Garrett's idea and Peter Garrett had information from New Zealand on what not to do but still did it and people died as a consequence of his inaction
David Norton
Spot on John this is my home this is my sea Don't paint it with the future, of factories Peter Garrett's legacy
Duke
View from the chamber
November 4, 2017
Along with this increase in population goes a responsibility, particularly on the part of our Council, to protect our natural environment.
On Phillip Island, the human population increases and the native birds and animals along with the indigenous vegetation suffers dramatically. A new resident moves in and up go the huge suburban paling fences, out comes the chainsaw and yet another gum tree (or two or three) is coming down. There is less and less habitat every day as a result of the wonderful (to some) local property boom.
Council should hang its head in shame at the state of the island's northern foreshore - what should be indigenous coastal vegetation (and a rich source of habitat) is a mass of weeds and private (illegal) tracks as well as lawns that adjacent land holders have created in their (illegal) appropriation of public land. Before putting out the welcome mat to more people, Bass Coast Shire needs to look after the natural environment it has and put in place proper procedures to make sure that all residents, visitors and potential new home owners understand their responsibilities to the local natural environment.
Sue Saliba
Brett, I fully support your comments and glad to read that the Bass Coast Shire finances are in better shap than once thought.
Frank W Schooneveldt
Great article Brett. But I totally endorse comments made by Sue Saliba regarding residents, potential new owners, visitors etc. understanding their responsibilities related to protecting our wonderful natural environment.
Also, I should add that many areas of Bass Coast Shire are lacking the proper infrastructure and community services to cope with this influx of people coming to our wonderful region. I Do realize some of these are issues related to State Government and Federal Government responsibilities.
Being a tourist or visitor or holiday home owner is totally different to living here permanently where we experience what I call the 'chain saw massacres.' Trees are destroyed and blocks of land are sub-divided. Then more trees are destroyed and this has a major impact on the native birds, animals and indigenous vegetation.
We welcome people to come here and live in this beautiful region and share its delights. BUT there is always a price tag. The word is RESPONSIBILITY and respect for conservation of our environment.
We don't want to become another inner Melbourne Suburban district.
Phyllis Papps
Brett good article, thanks for the acknowledgement, all the best moving forward.
Bradley Drew.
Cr. Brett, whilst you are dealing with the queues of eager developers, could you please let them know of Wonthaggis other secret - that we already have a heritage and culture which runs far deeper than our long-closed coal mines. Wonthaggi is a unique place- the town with a heart, the town which refused to die. Our fantastic (but overstretched) facilities were achieved by generations of community-minded residents, and will need thoughtful expansion plans to cope with the seething masses. The profit-seeking developers need to understand that our community is not some outer-suburban paddock, ripe for exploitation. I would be horrified to see our town sacrificed to the gods of suburban sprawl and big brands - even to "protect" the rest of our shire. The recent development approval for the Miners Rest site provides little comfort to me. A prominent, welcoming site for our many new visitors, and the best that the developers can come up with is the unholy trinity of booze, fuel and junk food.....Wonthaggi should be playing to our strengths - quirky businesses offering our legendary service, and a sense of hidden delights, both natural and anthropomorphic and, dare I say it, a growing sense of sophistication. I fear that our town will, instead evolve into yet another sad suburban wasteland. Is this really what we want to attract? Come on council and business leaders, think big and think different, we only get one shot at this!
Mark Robertson
If we are not careful, and by we I mean all of us and future councils, the answer to Brett's question "will we lose our character"[s a resounding YES. Developers pushing for smaller and smaller allotments and council's planning on building envelopes and building materials show a lack of awareness as to Wonthaggi's character.
A case in point is the recently developed Heartlands estate. Such an opportunity lost on a lovely site. It looks like the cramped outskirts of Cranbourne. Why do we insist on brick as the dominant building material in our town? Go see Heartlands, walk along Poplar and Outlook Drive in North Wonthaggi and then stroll through the old parts of South Wonthaggi and tell me which has the most character. All credit to Brett ,especially for his acknowledgement of the work of the previous council and his obvious love of our town. But I am firmly with Sue and Phyllis and Mark Robertson on this one.
Bob Middleton
Brett, it takes a wise person to be able to stand back and acknowledge the successes and understand the challenges of one's predecessors. The previous council's foresight ensured a plan was put in place for the future success of the entire shire. I am pleased the current council are working to the plan and looking to the future of the shire and our residents. Maintaining balanced, continued growth is the next hurdle for you and your team. Yes, please don't forget our heritage and natural assets, but in parallel please don't let us miss out on opportunities to grow and develop either ... We can have both. And after all, we didn't all buy here to retire ...
Rob Easton
Changing trains
November 4, 2017
Thank you Mark for sharing your beautiful and moving story with us folks in Wonthaggi. Congratulations on finishing your lovely, sustainable house. I'm sure you will prosper in such a kind, tolerant atmosphere as you are experiencing in Japan. Good luck with future train rides in life.
Hilary Stuchbery
Over this past cruel winter, I watched with awe as Mark finished his house. Sakura Studio has been designed with thoughtfulness and built with loving craftsmanship. It is a small space of beautiful proportions that gives a sense of peace to all who enter.
It's also an antidote to the big, dumb, brick veneer barns going up in their hundreds on new estates all around Bass Coast. If only our shire could buck the suburban trend with more unique places like this.
Catherine Watson
What a lovely story about love and kindness and a beautiful house bulit with sensitivity !
Marilyn Shaw
Impossible to pass by this studio house and not have your interest and curiosity aroused, a tribute to it's eye catching design. Thank you for showing us inside Mark and for sharing with us part of your adventurious life. May we read more in the Post as time goes by..
Bob Middleton
What an wonderful inspiring story, by and equally wonderful and inspiring human being.
Sammi Colenso-Wallace
Great read Mark. All the best in Japan. Hope you get a few waves over there
Michelle Fincher
Awesome read Teddy ~ all the best for the next stage of your journey. Kaz x
Karen Morse
Beautiful words Ted :)
Well done mate, I’m massively proud of you. Congratulations for getting off that train to destruction. Please don’t ever step back on it.
Say a big Gday to Toko and Sakura for me.
Paul Mannix
Lovely Story, is this Studio available for rent/short stay and through whom?
Glenda Fraser
Strength does not come from what you can do. It comes when you take challenging moments in your stride & determined not to give up. When you go through hardship & decides not to surrender that is strength.
You my brother have buckets full of strength xxx
Sandy
Mark you are an inspiration. I often think of our adventures at the island and would love to recreate them with my family. You should be so very proud of your achievements. xx
Barb McConnell
Euthanasia a step too far
November 4, 2017
Your arrogance in taking this stance appals me. I ask you to nurse your mother for 6 months while she dies of colon cancer and watch the agony she had to endure, and then tell me, that the Voluntary Assisted Dying Bill isn't a good thing. Voting no to this bill is tantamount to endorsing state approved torture. At the very least, you could abstain from voting. Please show some compassion !!!
Libby Lambert
My cousin in Holland was diagnosed with cancer that had riddled her body and was given two years to live. She was in extreme pain and suffering that can come with an incurable disease so she saw two doctors to obtain permission so that she could die at the time of her choosing. Permission was granted and she had the comfort of knowing when the time the pain become unbearable she was able to end it.
Elizabeth Kluber Ross in her book on death and dying said that it is a privilege to know when you are going to die and so it was for my cousin.
She could say her goodbyes to friends and family on her terms.
One morning she woke up and said to her partner that today was a good day to die. She gathered her family together said her goodbyes and died very peacefully.
Her partner said it was a beautiful death.
A right to die on our own terms with the right safeguards in place like the Dutch the proposed Victorian legislation is timely. Please support the bill.
Frank W Schooneveldt
I understand Mr Mulino is entitled to his view, but also shouldn't he be reprsenting the views of the majority of his voters. I cared for my 90 year old mother so she cou,d stay in her own home. At her insistence I continued working my job as she was a fiercly indpendant woman. I came home from work to find she had unsuccessfully tried to take her own life by taking an overdose ofpills and cutting her wrists. A sight I will never forget. My mother passed away 13 months later and that was no where near as sad as the event 13 months prior and watching her endure the time betwen these events. Where is his compassion for others?
N
I watched my mother in law die. This is what I believe she experienced,
"I just want to die. I don’t say this out of melancholy. I have had a good life. I have travelled the world. Had more wonderful experiences than most and have had not only a caring marriage but many treasured friendships and associations. My life has been rich. But now, I am weary. I have lived many long years and tonight I long for rest.
A short while ago I fell. Neither I, nor my doctor, is sure whether my hip broke and I fell, or I fell and broke my hip. Bones are brittle at my age. I now wonder why I agreed to have a hip replacement but it was always on the stipulation that I would not be resuscitated if I died during surgery. Those wishes were ignored. I wonder whether I should have had the words, “Do not resuscitate”, on my now bony chest to make sure that the well-meaning surgeons understood – but I did not. I died on the operating table and should have stayed that way. We all know I have now only a short time left.
And so tonight I live in pain. I lie in a hospital bed where my family visit to comfort me. A physio therapist comes to try and get me to walk on my new hip but all I feel is pain. I try to speak to my family but my words do not come out as I want them to. I see them trying to understand what I am saying – but I can’t form the words. The nurse grabs what she can of my shrunken belly to drive a needle into the flesh to give me an injection to prevent me from getting deep vein thrombosis. The pain radiates through my body and almost makes me vomit. Why must I endure this?
If I was able I would be able to take my own life. I could haul a rope from the rafters, or stick a hose in the exhaust from my car, or take the shotgun from its rack in the gun safe. But I am too feeble to do this. Too feeble to take the steps that I took in caring for my own pets when they were close to death and in pain.
I read the well-meaning words of politicians who do not wish me to die as their faces shine with health and optimism from the pages of the Bass Coast Post. Tonight I long for rest.
Liane Arno
Very, very sadly this is such a common story. These people deserve better and there is an opportunity to take the first step in this process. Also, sadly, we have to rely on the goodwill of politicians as the initial starter. I feel your pain Liane.
N Smith
MP: 90% against assisted dying
November 4, 2017
Here's number 201 for the 'yes' vote to the Voluntary Assisted Dying Bill. I ask you to nurse your mother until she dies of colon cancer and watch the agony she had to endure, and then you tell me, that the Voluntary Assisted Dying Bill isn't a good thing. Frankly I don't recollect you being voted in so you could play God with other people’s lives ? Voting no to this bill is tantamount to endorsing state approved torture. At the very least, you could abstain from voting. Please show some compassion !!!
Libby Lambert
Thank you for your fair comment on this legislation. Our opinions are always coloured by our own experiences. My own opinion as a retired Palliative Care nurse is that Paliative care should be available to everyone and offered as the first option as fear is one of the biggest obstacles people face when confronted with the fact that death is will be the consequence of their diagnosis. All options regarding treatment and palliation should be expalined at the outset.
One of the biggest areas of concern for me is the Aged Care sector where very vulnerable people are often left with far than adequate care in their final days.
If this legislation is place fron and centre then funding for adequate and increased Palliative care services may not eventuate for the majority that you talk about and that would be a tragedy.
Maggie L
Count me in as #202 for YES to VAD.
I agree - "The autonomy of the individual must be measured against the irretrievable alteration of society." - surely the measuring scales validate YES.
Geoff Ellis
And here is number 203 to YES. Both my parents are still alivee. Father at 93 and mother at 91. Father will never want to die, Mother has benn wanting to go for a number of year. She does not fit the category for assisted dying. She does not have an incurable illness except old age, she is not in pain. But she cannot walk and cannot see any purpose to life. She is simply tired of living. We have told her she has a purpose, it is just different to what it used to be. She is our matriarch. She cannot accept this. Yes her memory is going but she is still has the cognitive ability to make her choice. So much so, she is trying to starve herself to death. What do I do - force feed her? I believe every persons natural inclination is to live. So when a choice like this is made, it is genuine and should be respected.
Sandra M
Sandra, what a dreadful situation for all of you. My mother made me promise to do away with her if she ever had to go into a nursing home. There are worse things than death; there is such a thing as a living death, when there is no hope of improvement, only endurance.
The current legislation isn't going to do much for people in your mother's situation but at least it's a start.
One day I hope we will all have the right to say "It's been lovely but I want to go now."
In the meantime, my thoughts are with you.
Catherine Watson
Coming from a farming background, I was brought up with the ethic of not letting animals suffer. In fact, it is illegal to do so. Mercifully dispatching a suffering animal was part of life. However, by law, we must let our loved ones suffer unnecessarily at life's end as we cannot assist people to ease their passing.
Thankfully, many in the medical profession share the old farmers ethics and help patients end their life with dignity. It is estimated that 30% of deaths in hospitals are facilitated by the medical profession. I hope when my time comes, I will have a compassionate and caring doctor to help me on my way rather than let me suffer.
For those that worry about the implications of VAD, let's make a deal: I won't interfere with the way you depart this world and you leave me alone to make my own decisions about how I shed my mortal coil.
Peter
Melinda, The Netherlands legalised voluntary euthanasia in 2001.
I know from first hand experience that the legislation works in helping people die with peace, dignity and with a lot less pain and suffering. In a humane society we need to stop pain and suffering and respect the right of people to choose to die at a time of their choice.
I urge you to support the bill.
F W Schooneveldt
The town that vanished
November 4, 2017
A fascinating look at early European history in the Queensferry area, Libby. Thank you.
Meryl Tobin
Great article please have more of them on a regular basis
Warren
Beaches, bays and one fatal shot
November 4, 2017
A lovely story, Linda, of a place of interesting natural and human history. I share your concern about the potential disaster if one of those tankers runs aground. Coincidentally, I was reading the log of the Lady Nelson today,at the Wonthaggi Historical Society. It reminded me of the trip our family made on her replica a few years ago during an anniversary tour. We sailed between Rhyll and Cowes, and my young son was able to take the helm. Quite a contrast to the high-speed craft which terrorise the western entrance today!
m
What a tour de force embracing the history, geography and wildlife of your beloved island.So many things we casual visitors would not know or observe. Thank you Linda for an informative and beautifully written article.
Bob Middleton
November 11, 2017
Following recent article and letters on your website (Island caravan park knocked back, September 22, 2017), great to see the Foreshore Committee have acted and the only Public Toilet Block in San Remo is having a major makeover.
In addition the rock wall path has also had some remedial work to make it easier to walk on.
Thank you to the Foreshore Committee for acting to improve the facilities in San Remo which are important assets for both visitors and locals before the busiest part of the tourist season.
For anybody driving past or into San Remo knows only too well its vital that the infrastructure is maintained by all the responsible authority's year round which clearly hasn't been the situation over the last several years.
It doesn't make any sense that we have at least 4 different areas of government (State & Local) that controls different parts of the town, and not much cooperation seems to take between any of them!
Chris Day, San Remo
New Wonthaggi college by 2019
October 27, 2017
WOW! Congrats to all the people who worked hard to make their voices heard. What a great announcement!
Carmen Bush
Great reporting and great timing. Wonderful news.Thanks BCP and thanks vicgov..
Bob Middleton
Hooray how absolutely wonderful! Great reporting, great news and a great future ahead for Wonthaggi...much deserved.
Ursula Theinert
So happy to hear this news.
Jacqui Paulson
One more step towards a well supplied and rounded community. Well done all concerned. Thanks for the news BCP.
Hilary Stuchbery
Great reporting, Catherine. Thank goodness we have at State level, a Labor Government that listens to its constituents.We are very lucky to have Harriet Shing as our Upper House member.
Ruth and Peter Glare
Fantastic News! there have been many promises over the years with many people working very hard to get to this point. Educating is the backbone to better opportunities. Thank you to the State Government for listening.
Clare Le Serve
Amazing news! Credit to all those involved with the funding bid. Many individuals within the community spent countless unpaid hours lobbying stakeholders and government to support this endeavour. Let's not forget the indoor stadium funding announcement as well. Amazing effort. Well done to all.
James Archibald
The 'countless hours' is what it takes for the MPs to hear the message relating to the needs of a community! Well done to those who did the hard yards so well and for so long. The kids of tomorrow will benefit from what sounds like a facility providing a wide range of learning options for our diverse region.
Sue Packham
Ecstatic news. Will make a great town even better. Looking to the future is what a town needs to flourish. Congrats to Bass Coast Post for giving us this news.
N Smith
What an absolute delight to open the Bass Coast Post and read such very good news! Thank you, Catherine for getting this out so promptly. It’s fantastic - especially the fact that Daniel Andrews came down to Wonthaggi himself - and that everything is actually planned to begin so soon. Excellent!
Jane Westworth
Well done team Bass Coast! Congratulations to a strong, vocal community that passionately showed the State Government what matters.
Well done Daniel Andrews for listening and thank you Harriet Shing - you represent an enormous community and you do it with compassion and dedication.
We should also acknowledge the huge effort of Mayor Rothfield and previous Mayors Le Serve, Rankine and Crugnale who set the stage for this by getting those ministers down here last year.
And the tireless BCSC staff and officers - they deserve a bloody great pat on the back.
Geoff Ellis
Amidst the headlong rush to congratulate all the paid participants from the state government and Bass Coast Shire, I would like to acknowledge the years of effort put in by the unpaid School Council members, particularly its president, Geoff Robertson. Well done my brother for displaying the care and tenacity which has made Wonthaggi a community which has always punched far above its weight.I am exceedingly proud of you.
Mark Robertson
Naming rights
October 20, 2017
I for one believe we should seize this opportunity to rectify the naming of this electorate. Angus McMillan was responsible for the deaths of hundreds of Aboriginal people in the 1840s through a number of mass-scale killings. This is not something we should be proud of. This shameful history of McMillan should not continue to be celebrated nor immortalized. We have the opportunity, in a small way, to right a wrong. Furthermore I believe it is only fair that the Aboriginal Communities of this region are given the opportunity to help rename our electorate.
Rinchen Wilson
I agree with Rinchen. The name needs to be changed and we should ask & be guided by the local Aboriginal community on a suitable name.
Rob Humphrys
Thanks Geoff Ellis for this. I support Rinchen's comments and the name change.
Samiro Douglas
Thank you, Geoff for once more standing up for justice in our community. Murderers must not be honoured. I too support Rinchen's ideas of asking the Aboriginal community of the area to name their land.
Felicia Di Stefano
I agree with Geoff raising this issue and welcome his research and usual balanced discussion; also his wise words that it should not become a debate.
There are many villains in the history of mankind whose misdeeds should be remembered, thus to help avoid future crimes. Let us not forget the crimes of Pol Pot, Mao, Oswald, Amin, Caligula, and even the big bad wolf. The list is very long.
Recent assaults upon the statues of Robert E. Lee and James Cook, destruction of the Bamiyan Buddahs and Palmyra in Syria, renaming Colston Hall in Bristol and Penny Lane in Liverpool all received attention from righteous citizens who did not agree with the actions of others. I both agree and disagree with their 'personal' reasoning, but I find it difficult to sanction the good guys attempts at rewriting history.
In the case of Angus McMillan, would it be better to condemn him for his misdeeds, alongside his achievements? I doubt his name would be chosen for the electorate today and fair enough, but judgement without evidential trial in a time of different morality will not correct the actions of the past either.
Is there a Gunai/Kurnai name available to replace him or is the tribal name a suitable suggestion? I am not so sure.
Peter Brown
Peter, Thanks for the kind words and I applaud your insightful broadening of the discussion. There's so much to consider and I guess every place and country has history, good and bad, to deal with and finding the right balance is the aim. You've given us more to think about, cheers.
Geoff Ellis
Thank you for your article. This morning after reading an add in The AGE I wrote to the Redistribution Committee for Victoria Australian Electorate Commission to suggest that the name of Angus McMillan must be removed from the electorate because it represents so much sadness for our indigenous brothers and sisters who live in the electorate as well as for so many non - indigenous people who also live in the electorate. We offered three suggested name changes for the electorate.viz,
"The Gunai /Kurni Electorate" after the original inhabitants of the area, "The Warrigal Electorate" named after a tribe of Gunai/Kurni people who resided in the electorate or "The West Gippsland Electorate"which covers the area where the electorate sits.
Frank W Schooneveldt
Well written and thank you. I support your suggestions and would be pleased to see the opportunity given to Gunnai/Kurnai elders to choose the new name.
Karen Sandon
Well said, Geoff, as always. I applaud your sentiments and those of Rinchen and others who have commented. The Bass Coast South Gippsland Reconciliation Group has a process in train of working with a fully representative group of Gippsland’s Aboriginal organisations towards their selecting a name. I would ask those of you who plan to make a submission to the AEC to respect the right of an authentic Aboriginal voice to speak on this matter. While it is tempting to offer names, if we want the AEC to hear our recommendation of an Aboriginal choice, it would be great if people would commend that process. It is likely that the Aboriginal choice of name will be submitted at a later stage in the AEC’s commenting process.
Marg Lynn
Marg, I think there is a genuine desire for a change of name of the McMillan electorate and the more submissions to the AEC for a change the better. What name is your group suggesting?
Frank W Schooneveldt
Thanks Frank, our preference is not to provide a name but to provide a rationale for the Aboriginal Community choosing a name. Aboriginal organisations have now settled on a process for getting together and working out a mutually acceptable name. I would hope that this process will be accepted and respected by the AEC and those of like mind who want to see an Aboriginal name chosen, as a small token of recompense for the hurt and pain inflicted by McMillan that has lasted to this day.
Marg Lynn
Let’s rename it Tarra Bulga after the National Park. Also acknowledges the role of Charlie Tarra, who provided invaluable assistance to Strzelecki.
Mike Cleeland
Marg, That’s all good but the AEC have procedures and processes as well and are calling for suggestions of a name change by Friday 17th November2017. It will be interesting to see what Aboriginal and other organisations and individuals recommend as a name change.
What we must ensure that at this redistribution a name change occurs.
Frank W Schooneveldt
Frank, I agree absolutely and I don't think we are contradicting each other. i believe there will be enough community pressure to impress on the AEC that there needs to be a change of name. That's part 1. Part 2 is then the naming and we believe that the AEC (and they have told us so) will accept later comment on the initial report, which is when the Aboriginal naming outcome can be presented.
Marg Lynn
Thank you again Geoff for raising this justice issue . Together we can use our voice through the Electoral Commission to right the terrible wrong, by the re-naming of the electorate of McMillan.
Anne Davie
Folks, As per the AEC indicative timetable, up to November 17 we can make suggestions. There will be later invitations for comments on suggestions, objections to suggestions, comments on objections and one or two public hearings - the final recommendation won't be made until the middle of 2018 at the earliest.
It's a long conversation and it’s great to hear so many voices.
Geoff Ellis
Thanks for the useful elaboration on the AEC process, Geoff.
Marg Lynn
Geoff, We received our acknowledgment of our suggestions for a change of name for the electorate from Ann Dougan Secretariat officer for the VIC Redistribution Secretariat AEC yesterday who outlined the process you mentioned.
We urge you all to write to the AEC requesting a change of name for the electorate. Go to www.aec.gov.au/vic-redistribution to submit your request.
Frank W Schooneveldt
October 26, 2017
Thank you Geoff & Peter Brown for a well delivered explanation of the reasoning & process involved when considering such an important change. Prior to reading both of your inputs to this discussion, all I had heard have been emotive arguments and divisive words which make a bull (Taurean) like me dig my heels in! The emotion has now been removed and I am now able to look at the proposition in a much more rational frame of mind. Discussions are so much easier (and more productive) than debates & arguments, aren't they?
Pamela Jacka
October 28, 2017
Might I suggest that a non-anthropoid name be chosen,. After all , we have treated most of our indigenous species with world-beating contempt. Perhaps Karmai -the traditional name for our spectacular and (literally) downtrodden giant earthworm could be considered. We put our species on a pedestal, but in the grand scheme of things we are but a fleeting and destructive footnote in our planetary history, no matter what our colour or heritage
Mark Robertson
In the lion’s den
October 21, 2017
Congratulations Pam !! What a fantastic year for you. Yes, it must have been a steep learning curve trying to get a diverse group of new Councillors together (and one Councillor who had been re-elected) all working towards the same ultimate goal. This is probably the most difficult challenge you had to face.
At the same time getting to understand the protocols, processes, policies and plans of BCSC meant it was very different for you and the other new Councillors, because you were no longer 'looking in from the outside.'
YET YOU DID IT, with your incredible communication skills, financial skills, leadership skills and an excellent understanding of the key issues related to the Bass Coast region and the community in general.
It is very hard to comprehend how you have managed everything in a 24 hour day - this involves incredible passion, energy, time and commitment. You should feel very proud of your achievements during the past 12 months.
Phyllis Papps
I agree with Phyllis, well done Mayor, Councillor Rothfield. I think you have done a splendid job!
Carmen Bush
Thank you for your willing work to enhance our community, Pamela.
Felicia Di Stefano
Congratulations to you and all your team for your professionalism and community support. A great first year towards a positive creative future.
Ursula Theinert
Phyllis, I agree with you 110%, particularly your last paragraph. FYI the next council meeting is Nov !5th.
Geoff Ellis
Thank you Madam Mayor! I’m so glad you highlighted the professionalism of the council.
Bernadette
October 26, 2017
“We are all travelling down the river, in different canoes – but in the same direction.
“We don’t always agree – but we do have respect for each other’s opinion.”
It can certainly be done, as you have all shown this year.
Natasha Crestani
This one’s for Ray
October 21, 2017
Great to see our representatives, Mr Paynter and Ms Shing (as per last BCP) supporting the views of the community and voting with their conscience - a hard deliberation to part of and thank you for your courage.
Geoff Ellis
A hard issue, well thought out Brian. Commitments are important, Ray was a leader on this issue with insight that it is impossible to fathom.
Michael Whelan
To honour a commitment and follow your conscience in the face of opposition is courageous. Congratulations on your courage.
Felicia Di Stefano
Thanks very much for your vote Brian.
Jan Fleming
Thank you Brian for sharing your views on this heartfelt topic and also to you and the other MP's who voted for this legislation.
N Smith
Thank you Brian. It is difficult to see how anyone could not support this issue having had such a first hand encounter. So sad to think many of us do not come to this conclusion unless confronted with the stark reality. .
Bob Middleton
Thanks Brian for not simply following the party line on this important issue. Ray was an outstanding human being, and his expertise in dealing with end-of-life experience, both from a nursing and patient viewpoint , was unparalleled. I am so pleased that his efforts have borne fruit. All political decisions should be guided by conscience, not by what is deemed to be plotically-expedient.
Mark Robertson
Thank you Brian for your compassion and humanity.
Anne Davie
Thank you Brian for your beautifully written piece. I Have had similar experiences and am impressed by your strong stance on this issue.
Rhonda Sutton
Man about town
October 21, 2017
Delightful Bob! And we, who count you among our 'new best friends', are very pleased you are but a short detour from our Wetlands stroll. Sally is also pleased to see Charlie more often!
Maddy Harford
October 24, 2017
Thanks Bob - it's great to hear how you've handled the change to from 'outback' to 'town centre'.
We'll have to do it one day being on an acre and a half and as you said, it seems to get bigger by the day. Till then if you've got the urge, you're welcome to visit our rural piece of paradise in Woolamai - Charlie too of course.
Sue Packham
October 26, 2017
Welcome to the "big smoke" Bob! I hope you learn to admire the wattlebirds as a very industrious and loving parent. I had always been told they were aggressive, etc. but I hadn't experience that with my mix of reds and little wattlebirds .. until last year! I've lived in my house for seven years but they only built a nest last year! I do admire the way they bully the common (formerly Indian) minah birds though and I'm pleased the magpies just ignore them. I have a couple of young wattlebirds splashing around in the bird bath in my backyard, at the moment, which is delightful. If you haven't already, wait until you see the changing colours of the starlings. The blackbird couple wait until the wattlebirds have gone to bed before coming in for a swim. Every bird has its day, even the dull and boring! Enjoy your new abode and see you around town.
Pamela Jacka
A work in progress
October 21, 2017
Totally support Meryl's view on development in our shire ,Grantville is lucky to have her as a Community leader.
Vicki Breen
Ditto to Millowl ( Phillip Island )
Rob Humphrys
An insightful snapshot. I too, congratulate the members of the new Grantville Business and Community Association. The hard working component groups bought many improvements to the gateway to Bass Coast.
I admire their commitment and would like to acknowledge that the members off all community associations and committees – Resident and Ratepayer, Progress, Foreshore, Section 86….the list is endless – donate so much of their lives to craft the Bass Coast in which everyone wants to live.
Meryl has encapsulated the conundrum of balancing progress, our environment and amenity. Having so many active and passionate groups across the Waterline contributing to, and scrutinizing council strategies makes the deliberations of a councillor much easier.
I look forward to the day when I can admire the bushland and beaches then shop at the Grantville Supermarket on the way home.
Cr Geoff Ellis
Thanks Meryl for such a well written and well balanced summation of our wonderful part of the world. The contribution of yourself and your Husband, Hartley, is greatly appreciated my the community.
Roger Clark
Council backs fracking ban
October 21, 2017
Thank you for letting us know, Catherine. Well done Bass Coast Council for a healthy environment and people's rights. .
Felicia Di Stefano
Until there is concrete proof that fracking wont "frack" the environment, more power to the arm and vote of those Bass Coast Crs who passed this motion.
We've already had a "close environmental shave"with the abandonment of the Hasting Container Port, don't need any more attempts at spoiling our precious Bass Coast.
Kevin Chambers
Out of the chaos
October 21, 2017
Beautiful story about a beautiful woman. I own one of Mary's prints. She befriended my son and he bought the print for me. Mary is so youthful and interesting and of course talented.
Anne Tindall
Sweet as
October 6, 2017
Megan, so nice to welcome you to the land of snakes, redback spiders and kangaroos, dead or alive. Your timing is almost spot on for the footy will give you a rest now but only for a week or two. You served us coffee a few days ago and I can see now why your Silver Ferns are so hard to beat. Hope you stay a while.
Bob Middleton
Thank you, Megan - I loved reading this! We lived in New Zealand for two years before coming to Australia, and I had really hoped that I'd grasped the vocabulary of the southern oceans in Wellington, and wouldn't have to start all over again in Melbourne. No such luck. We had managed to survive across most of Europe with the generic 'flip flop' as summer footwear. In New Zealand, this morphed into 'jandals', and, in Melbourne, to 'thongs'. I felt I had never had such frustrating conversations in shops ever before, and, like you, I had never heard of 'flake'!
I'm very glad your aunt persuaded you to get it all down quickly, and I hate to tell you this, but you write very well - and I hope you'll write more!
Jane Westworth
Thanks for the laughs, Megan.
John Coldebella
October 7, 2017
A very enjoyable read. Thank you Megan.
N Smith
Really enjoyed your article Megan. It reminded me of the years my husband and son and I lived in Bahrain where there was a mostly British expat community and we also were confronted by a whole range of English language confusions on both sides! It caused often odd quizzical looks but mostly many laughs at how there was so much variance within the English language. Hope you enjoy your stay and may it be long and fun.
Ursula Theinert
Hi my beautiful darling wot a crack up love it. You could write a book my darling it was so awesome to read the experiences you have seen. wow please keep posting on your time line.
it is so cool love you so much mwahhhhh <3
Aunty moana Tahau
Here's one who has walked most of the places you have done, except it took me years to do. Never ona bike though, too little balance. Keep looking and enjoying and staying put.
Joan Woods
Chur chur cuz. On yer bike Aunty, your natural successor has arrived. What a westie she is, eh broess?
Jill Nicholas
you've nailed it Bro (Cuz), I was in stiches reading this. it's a perfect description of Wonthaggi, and they all go to Cape Patterson for their holidays
Pauline Wilkinson
October 8, 2017
Bonzer read, cobber. Start a travel blog and crowd fund your trips, eh?
Can't wait to read your impressions of Krowera. :-)
Geoff Ellis
What a funny, lovely breath of fresh air. Great read Megan. Please write more!
Linda Cuttriss
Very glad you've come to visit. And could you please keep contributing because it's lovely and it helps Aunty.
Linda Gordon
October 11, 2017
Forget the "footy" Megan ... go the Tahs! Also, you are in Victoria and it's not Australia as such. Australia is huge and each state has its own personality. Moving from NSW, I was surprised to find that the language down here is quite different, which is fascinating even for old Aussies like me! I've seen quite a few brown faces in Wonthaggi too, some being neighbours for a while. This is certainly an interesting place to live and you're absolutely right that no one is normal but then what is normal, eh? Enjoy the experience.
Pamela Jacka
Fake news!!! I'm not skinny, just beautifully slim. Apart from that it was a great story. I proud of you my girl.
Hamish Watson (Megan's dad)
What an inspiring read!
Catherine was right; things very quickly become “normal”. It’s a good reminder to stop and take it all in.
Amara Miles
Four dead in Ohio
October 6, 2017
Beautifully said Cr Ellis, thank you!
Rinchen Wilson
Couldn't agree more Geoff. Just a shame those higher up the line do not share or act on our views. I don't know what they are so scared of or why compassion is so lacking.
N Smith
N - I wish I could answer that question, I really do.
Geoff Ellis
Geoff, what a brilliant article and so well written. I think your next career or parallel career should be as a writer. Never forget that 'The pen is mightier than the sword.'
I agree with everything you say and have a couple of comments to make. I blame the Internet, the Social media such as Facebook, Twitter etc. and the bias of some of the printed Media. Everything is 'open slather' in terms of venting rage, vitriol, hate etc. AND of course it can be anonymous and very superficial. As a result, thousands of people can read it or in some cases millions and can be influenced by this sort of information which isn't always accurate. AND my theory is, that as a consequence many people have become immune to humanity, compassion and kindness.
Phyllis Papps
Well said Geoff; does any sane person really believe that the loss of one innocent US life is more tragic than the loss of one innocent Rohingyan life?
Walter Broussard
Again well said Geoff. The tragic difference is that they (the Rohingyans) are poor and they are black.
Michael Whelan
Thanks Michael. That's a stone cold fact.
Geoff Ellis
October 13, 2017
Wow Geoff what a great article and so well written It makes my heart sad to see the plight of the Rohingyans. I’m sure they would thrive here and do Australia proud
Levinus Van Der Neut
Life and death
October 6, 2017
Thank you Harriet. Your deliberation is greatly appreciated and your decision is strongly supported by me and many around me. My father had to beg people to act in secret to free him from the unbearable.
Geoff Ellis
Thanks Harriet. We are coming up to a very significant moment l. Thanks for your very considered response. I am glad you have come to this decision to vote Yes to pass the bill.
Samiro Douglas
On the sick list
October 6, 2017
I consider myself something of an expert on hospitals having once spent 8 months in a large public hospital in Sydney. Later as a day patient at Royal Melbourne and ER at the Hepworth with a couple of overnight stays. Lately I have had to use Wonthaggi Hospital about once a year often staying overnight. If it is possible to love a hospital then I love Wonthaggi, or at least their staff. Being small though you are likely to end up in a mixed ward, as I was, next to a woman loudly discussing her vajayjay operation while an elderly gentleman opposite slowly expired. And unlike large Melbourne hospitals you are only a few steps, or a short wheelchair roll, from the car park, for which, bless them, they don't charge.
Jim
Thanks for writing this article. Your experiences largely match my own, although I have also experienced patient centered care cultures at some large hospitals and other country hospitals too. Caring and showing it doesn't compromise professionalism or secularity at all. Let's hope the positive cultures become the norm, sooner rather than later.
Karen Sandon
The Custodian
October 7, 2017
What an honour
Neri Melsmith
A wonderful portrait of a great leader and role model. The embodiment of compassion.
Geoff Ellis
The Hovell Tree
October 7, 2017
Thank you Terri.
Ailsa Drent
October 9, 2017
Sorry I got to your story so late Terri. The wonder for me is that after some 15 years of being a South Gippsland resident I still know so little about the area and it's history. You and people like Linda Cuttris of the island help me to fill in these inexcusable empty spaces.
Bob Middleton
Stop, in the name of love!
September 23, 2017
I have voted yes for equality Mikhaela.
Jan Fleming
YES!
Nola Smith
Definitely YES!
And thank you for such a personal, logical, committed and passionate argument!
Jane Westworth
YES with a tick not a cross.
This needs wider distribution, Mikhaela - hope it is being re-posted widely through many different networks, including at national level.
Anne Heath Mennell
Mikhaela's words have displayed exactly what our politicians should be providing -common sense, decency, insight and honesty. Barlow for PM!
Mark Robertson
Mikhaela this is brilliant and must be get out to other media outlets. I am proud to say I know you and that I admire your courage and strength.
Anne Davie
How many times do we need to keep on ‘Coming Out’ before we are accepted as equals in the society we live in?’
The first time for Francesca and myself was in 1970 in a very public way on Australian Television.
The second time was in 1985. I ‘Came Out’ professionally in front of about 100 Malvern women on International Womens’ Day when I was host of a function held at Malvern Town Hall.
The third time was in 2015 when Francesca and I danced together at a pre-Christmas function organized by Griffith’s Point Lodge in San Remo. This is a Nursing Home with 28 residents, one of whom is my mother who has been there for six years.
The last time was July 2017 in the article I wrote for Bass Coast Post entitled “Somewhere Over the Rainbow.” This was our fourth time of ‘Coming Out’ publicly –this time in the community we have lived in since 2001.
Obviously all our friends, members of the family, neighbours and colleagues know we are gay, but this will be our last time of ‘Coming Out.’
When the plebiscite survey arrives in your mail during the next few weeks, read the questions carefully and think about the implications. Also ask yourself the following: are you prejudiced? biased? discriminatory? sexist? ageist? homophobic? racist? xenophobic? Or are you a bigot? a religious fanatic? someone who hates ?
If so, what are you afraid of?
If not, then vote for Marriage Equality for all, irrespective of gender, sexual orientation and lifestyle choices.
Phyllis Papps
Phyllis, I am proudly voting YES.
I agree with everything you have written about LGBTIQ matters and admire your determined courage.
RE your penultimate paragraph of questions - if only every commentator, broadcaster and politician would ask themselves those questions every morning.
Towards the end of 'Somewhere Over The Rainbow' you wrote that "The only thing we don’t have is a piece of paper that states that we are married, even though we exchanged gold wedding rings back in 1970.'
I pray that all our bits of paper ensure that you can get that piece of paper. It's a matter of equal human rights.
Cr Geoff Ellis
I voted yes. There are no valid arguments to support a no vote. The arguments put up are either irrelevant to the question or based in hate or fear.
Noel
Thank you Mikhaela for such a well-written cry from the heart which has given me insights and expanded my (already open) view. It's a Yes from this household and we wish you happiness.
Hilary Stuchbery
What if you meet both of them later in life and fall madly in love, you'd still be screwed.
The law should just say, consenting adults, not just 2 people.
Mark Ellis
Thank you for sharing your story Mikhaela, you made your points very well.
As someone who didn't have family support I am glad that not only did you have support from your family, but also you reach out to others.
Well done, and keep up the great work!!!!
Steve
Thank you Mikhaela and Phyllis for your courage and for sharing your incredibly valuable insights and heartfelt experiences. You are both so inspiring. I voted as soon as I received the letter in the post - and I voted a very strong YES!
Sue Saliba
Island caravan park knocked back
September 24 2017
If Council and community will not allow any development of this property then it should purchase it at realistic price so that the land. I'm sure council are still sending rates bills to the owners.
One should ask councillors and the community members objection "how would you feel if this was your property?"
Those of us who have been owner here for long while clearly remember the camping area next to this land, what was proposed was a vast improvement on that facility and Yes we are a tourist area. Hard to tell at time with the terrible facilities we provide for visitors and locals. Councillors "have you ever been inside the toilet block at San Remo?" As someone out walking everyday we are asked all the time "where are the public toilets?" It's embarrassing to point out where it is, and yes it is the only one in town centre!! We've just returned from staying at Kings Beach near Coloundra the public facilities are superb and well maintained by the local council and they have nowhere near the number of overseas visitors that we do.
Christopher Day
I agree with Chris Day. Recently I had a friend staying with me from NZ he went to the toilets in San Reno. He came out not happy! Niether was I. What an embarrasment. Bass Coast Shire.
Pamela J Gill JP
Just a note of clarification. The San Remo toilets are owned and managed by the San Remo Foreshore Committee of Management. So, this time the Council can be exonerated for the poor state of the SR toilet block. However, the state of the toilet block does reflect the rest of the SR foreshore. Dangerous paths, weeds everywhere. The "landscaping" along the northern edge of the Phillip Island Tourist Road is another cringe-worthy eyesore.
Is it time for the Council to step in and take control away from the Committee?
Ray McNamara
A great decision by council. The people who bought the land knew what they were buying so why should council buy the property, that is silly. Speculation is not always successful. This is definitely not a position for a caravan park when all shops and facilities require entering a crowded highway. The parks in town are much better located for walking to restaurants etc.
Phil Bagley
Being an Aussie
September 24, 2017
Anne Some of us are getting better at recognising racism but some feel freed to express it. We are not far removed from the White Australia Policy - your experience of immigration would be similar today juxtaposed against a punishing regime for people fleeing oppression. I wonder how many non western people seeking citizenship would seek to accept it on Australia Day if they were aware of the British oppression of the original inhabitants of this Country - the very behaviour many of them are seeking to leave in their own countries.
Michael Whelan
Thanks you for this wonderful piece Anne. This is a shameful time in our history when intolerance and our lack of compassion is compromising us and whatever we believed was about being an Australian.
Anne Davie
Thank you Anne; great article. I came to Australia in 1956 at the age of 14. In those days we had to wait five years to become a citizen. The Dutch were often referred to as the "invisible migrant" because we looked a bit English and soon picked up the language. That made our transition very comfortable. For me it was all a huge adventure but as I get older I often reflect on what it must be like for those who are coming to Australia now expecting refuge in a nation they believe to be mature and understanding. I am ashamed about how we treat these people who are in such dire need. In 1956 we had the White Australia policy but it didn't seem to be so cruel on such a large scale. It is ironic that white Australia stole this land from the indigenous inhabitants and now we think we have the right to stop others from coming here. In this regard the Australian government has a lot in common with the white supremacist movement.
John Mutsaers
Short sentence for Carlowe
September 23, 2017
Great story, beautifully written, sad ending, but that's the way with animals, their only weakness is that they do not live long enough.
Roger Clark
Great story Geoff, it brought a few tears to my eyes.
Jan Fleming
Thank you, Geoff. I'm glad you wrote it in the present tense: it means that we all had the chance to share in Carlowe's life, as well as the memories. There is a kind of unity forged by loss, an empathy, and, if we shed tears, they make it easier to smile. Thank you for sharing Carlowe.
Jane Westworth
Fucking Lymphoma strikes again! My faithful hound, Layla, has been a loyal companion throughout my lymphoma journey. She only understands two human commands - breakfast and tea!, but warms my feet during those cold Bass coast nights. Give Finn a pat for me and find him a new mate, it will be good for all. Hope to see them bounding along the beach at Harmers soon.
Mark Robertson
Thank you Geoff for sharing Carlowes story. Whenever I stroke a new dog on meeting I find myself feeling for those deadly bumps.Our old terrier developed them at a far too early age and I still wake at night sometimes and recall the trusting look he gave me as the needle went in and the light faded from his eyes. But the joy they give outweighs the tears of goodbye.
Bob Middleton
A wild ride
September 23, 2017
What a great description of the Summerland Peninsula Linda, thanks.
Jan Fleming
A great journey in words. I call the south coast road Phillip Islands 'mini great ocean road'.
Anne Paul
Beautiful pics and great writing about a place that we need to treasure. Mini Great Ocean Road for sure!
Geoff Ellis
Up close and natural
September 23, 2017
Thanks for your words and insight! As I work in my studio situated in my garden I share your wonder of nature and observe the going ons in my small garden. Lots of birds, blue tongue lizards, little insects and happily bees buzzzing to blooms and the water in my bird baths!
Heather Fahnle
Thank you, Mark, for reminding us of the wonders of nature and the benefits of taking time to look around, pause and then focus quietly and patiently on what is around us. Thank you also for introducing me to the concept of ethology - how species interact with each other and their surrounds. I hadn't come across the term before but I am aware of the complex ecosystems involved in the various connections between organisms, including within our own human bodies. I'd like to put in a plea for people to learn about and respect the life forms which we can't see because they are too small. They help us to digest our food, ferment and break down organic matter, make soil fertile, allow plants, including trees, to communicate with one another, among many other things. Spare a thought for bacteria, microbes, fungi, mosses, and many other types of microscopic flora and fauna without which there would be no life as we currently know it.
Anne Heath Mennell
Thanks Anne, it is so important for us to realise that all life is important - not only the exotic and endangered, along with the supposedly-superior humans. The world (both organic and inorganic) cooporates and thrives due to incredibly complex, yet simple interactions and natural laws. The sooner man realizes this, and stops the hell-bent craziness to dominate our shared world, the better.I hope that our children realise what a mess that modern society has made in such a short time, and brings the leaders to their senses. Celebrate the mundane and common, before they too are gone, and never be afraid to tell the emperor that he has no clothes on!
Mark Robertson
I could not have put this any better, Mark, thank you. Good to know I'm not alone - hope we might be members of a growing minority which will one day help humans to recognise we are only one part of a miraculous web of life and begin to make amends before it is too late.
Anne Heath Mennell
No joy for tourist operator
September 23, 2017
I am pleased to see that this venture was refused. Projects start small but can become a nightmare like the helicopters operating from the airport site in Newhaven. The noise can be heard from every flight and many are in the evening when quietness is appreciated.
Penny Manning
Cr Kent states" this is just a small person". This couple would be amongst the wealthiest in Inverloch. This venture is just a play thing at the expense of neighbours.
Luke
You are absolutely correct Penny the noisy persistent helicopters at Newhaven flying a loop for long periods with multiple helicopters is destroying the amenity of Newhaven and San Remo and to make matters worse council has no control over or the inclination to rein in the noise. Thank your lucky stars that 5 councillors have the ratepayers interests at heart. Start with one little plane then all of a sudden 3 very noisy helicopters would be permitted to conduct joy flights. The people of Inverloch have avoided a nightmare.
Phil Bagley
Rhyll artist in the frame
Congratulations Jill from Rhyll.
Jan Fleming and John Adam.
Jill, Congratulations, such a tranquil painting.
Melissa Hayes
On the road again
September 2, 2017
Congratulations Cr. Le Serve. After reading your very insightful article I hope that residents of Bass Coast Shire will understand and appreciate all the hard work that BCSC staff and Councillors do on behalf of their community. As you rightly point out - it's NOT just about Roads, Rates and Rubbish. It's also about community involvement and planning for the future needs of the people of the Bass Coast region and beyond.
You have had an excellent track record as a former Mayor/Councillor AND that is the reason why you were re-elected for a second term. Your journey has been a tough one, but your integrity and commitment to the community has paid off.
Phyllis Papps
I agree with Phyllis, particularly the comments about integrity and commitment.
Geoff Ellis
Calling Australia home
Hear Hear! Just over a hundred years ago Australia had a paternally German PM (Chris Watson) who had been born in Chile and came here on a boat. He remains our only PM born in a non-empire/commonwealth country and I wonder if they'd even let him into the country today?
Geoff Ellis
Well if he was also brown, muslim or gay I doubt he'd get a look in! Let's just hope that Nick Xenophon is not also a Cypriot lol.
Eve Hollole
The hills are alive
A beautiful piece Frank
Linda Cuttriss
Terrific story. You have brought this Piano back to life. Will we hear about the trunk? It looks like it's got something to say.
Edward Buckingham
Thanks Frank, Loved your story.
Jan Fleming
Beautifully written, Frank. Loved the story.
Ruth and Peter Glare
Wonderful story.
Alli Coulson
Back to nature
September 2, 2017
Beautiful photos.
Beautiful place.
Thanks John.
Jan Fleming
A lot of credit is due to John for the wonderful work at Scenic Estate marshalling his volunteers on a regular basis - his knowledge is immense and he was a catalyst in the flora survey that was completed recently.
I note the designation 'an aboriginal place of low significance' What could be significant is a name change to reflect the aboriginal history and show acknowledgement and respect for this place.
Michael Whelan
I agree about the name. Beautiful place, dreadful name (although it does reflect its recent history). It would be great to hear what the traditional owners think about a name that reflects their history.
Catherine Watson
Lean times
September 2, 2017
Great advice,
Thanks Miriam.
Jan Fleming
Thanks for your witty words of wisdom Miriam!
Linda Cuttriss
Between a Red Rock and a hard place
August 18, 2017
Michael, Congratulations if councillors don't take up issues on behalf of the community who will?
In San Remo we border "Keams" property. Its within existing town boundary's and we all knew it would be developed. When Keams original sub division lapsed because of their inaction over many years , we we're suddenly hit with a new plan which would have brought "Pakenham to San Remo to a large parcel of land that can be seen to every person crossing the bridge and beyond.
When the San Remo community challenged what was planned we were told it was all a "done deal" Council Officers recommended it to go ahead. Bradley Drew as at the time our new local councillor managed to convince other councillors that Council should challenge. History shows it went to VCAT and the community successfully challenged the application.
The VCAT ruling is worth reading for any of the new councillors if they haven't seen it. It was damning of the whole process. While their are still elements of the revised application now approved by VCAT that could be better in my opinion, it's still a far better outcome for the community that what what we looked like having to live with for ever. Developers walk away once it's sold, even Council officers etc are most likely not themselves affected but we the community are left with the problem for ever.
The response at the time of one new councillor made a big difference to San Remo and the Bass Community for ever.
Chris Day
It is both gratifying and reassuring that our Councillors are so concerned about the ongoing condition of our beautiful Island and its flora and fauna. Well done to all who opposed this proposed over-development.
Doug Elms
August 19, 2017
It is wonderful that our councillors will fight to preserve the nature of Phillip Island and its diminishing open spaces and vote against high density development.It is after all why visitors come to Phillip Island and what the community is increasingingly becoming very concerned with."When it is gone,it is gone for good"
Vicki Breen
I also fully agree and congratulations on the council stand to oppose this type of development.
Garry Busowsky
Well done Michael,this is what we need,
councillors who are prepared to stand up for our environment.
It would also be a step in the right direction if you all got behind the lack of infrastructure re;unmade roads throughout the shire and take the politics out of it.
Pamela J Gill JP
August 20, 2017
The Island councillors should perhaps pause for a moment and reflect what the situation would be if they stood alone . There would need to be a 15 year supply of housing sites available on the precious Phillip Island . Fortunately good old Wonthaggi is available to soak up the demand- we have zero environmental values at risk....... By the way, whatever happened to the Stand Alone proponents? They were most vocal before the last municipal elections, but since then, not a peep. I hope that our shire recognises that the entire Bass Coast deserves proper scrutiny of any and all proposed developments - North Wonthaggi and Mahers Landing , for example.
Mark Robertson
Thank you to Councillor Michael Whelan and to the other eight councillors for standing up for what is important on Phillip Island - our natural environment and our community. Well done, Bass Coast Shire councillors!
Sue Saliba
August 22, 2017
Councilor Whelan, it is gratifying to see that some councilors are prepared to do what is, in actual fact, their duty and do the right thing on behalf of the residents who voted for them, not just accept the dictates of council officers. We all understand that the council has a large area to administer and a relatively low population base to extract funds from. Therefore it needs to continue to create additional ratepayers. However this council's officers seem to regularly overlook its own published strategies and criteria in order to allow for developments that may or may not be in the best interests of the community at large. They seem to leave these issues to residents, waiting for objections instead of applying their own criteria and strategies. Once again it is gratifying to see that some councilors are prepared to recognise that they are in fact, on behalf of the residents, the employers of council officers not the other way round and that councilors are representing their community and not answerable to council officers.
Trevor Brown
August 24, 2017
Well done Sue -it is so important that the local residents stand up to protect the special and irreplacable parts of our Bass Coast home. Hope that the AGL intrusion of Westernport is as easily dispatched. All power to those who care.
Mark Robertson
A brief history of Grantville
August 18, 2017
Well done for your initiative and drive. Grantville certainly has moved forward and it looks more vibrant and welcoming - good work.
Liz Glynn
I remember very well the early changes in Grantville. I always say if you sit back and wait nothing happens but if you put strong people with passion for change things will happen. Well done Helen and the people of Grantville.
Margaret Murray
August 19, 2017
Thanks Margaret, I trust you are having a nice time in your retirement. Best regards. Helen
Helen Zervopoulos
Thank you to Christopher, and yourself Helen, for the commitment and hard work that you contributed to the Waterline townships over the years. I learnt so much about 'community' and always admired the way you achieved so much and had fun.
Joy Button
Like many others we have travelled from Melbourne to our holiday home at Ventnor since 1985 and breezed through Grantville.when the tram stop cafe near Jam Jerrup closed many years ago we made Grantville our coffee break stop. It is now sometimes difficult to get a park,it is a hub for locals to chat and visitors to grab a bite and community news letter.
Heaps of community spirit evident !
Gary Watkins
Hi, interesting article. I arrived in the area in 2010 so clearly a lot was done in a very short space of time! I am interested in the "Waterline Townships" plans. Was Jam Jerrup included? Where can I get a copy please.
James
Hi James, no Jam Jerrup was not included, not sure why. The township plans were written for each individual community it was not a general overall waterline plan.
Helen Zervopoulos
August 27, 2017
A wonderful look back Helen. You and Christopher are to be congratulated for your persistent contributions and never say die attitudes. You will be missed.
Zena Benbow
Memories of Wally
August 18, 2017
Lovely tribute Antoinetta, I will certainly miss him, and his old dog at the markets.
Thank you for thinking enough of him to pen this tribute.
Roger Clark
Some lovely words about Wally and would chat to him over the years we have been here. He told Richard that he had worked on the trains in the UK. My funniest memory is going to his house to buy plants and after knocking on the door went to the back and there was Wally gardening round the back, absolutely starkers. Richard told me when it was okay to come round. He was a lovely gentle man with some stories and very sad to hear of his passing.
Joy Button
I missed Wally in my time and your touching story Ant Gent has made me realise what a loss that is for me.So many good qualities that we can admire and hopefully learn from.Thank you for telling his story..
Bob Middleton
Some years ago I bought a lime tree for a wet spot in the garden and he gave me directions on how to plant it: fabulous tree now. I stopped by his stall last year and thanked him for his very sage advice. Sorry to hear of his passing. Not many characters around these days.
Liz Glynn
I'm glad you've introduced me to Wally, Ant. He epitomises qualities i admire and which counteract the negative stories we hear so often. Seems he was a man full of determination, generosity and so knowledgable about those indispensable things - plants.
Sue Packham
Loved reading your tribute to Wally. Sometimes we lose the characters of our life without knowing when or how. Community is a lot of things and Wally excuded the sense of community I love. His passion for plants, making a few bob on the side, his cheeky smirk when pressed for a discount, his vocal outbursts when challenged over the issues of the day. RIP Wally
David Norton
August 24, 2017
Many good memories of you at Grantville market. Choco the dog. RIP Wally.
Dan
When your foot starts tapping …
August 5, 2017
Wonderful story Brian. I agree absolutely with respect to Craig's legacy. He will be sorely missed on the Island.
Pamela Rothfield
August 6, 2017
It is a good thing that a diversity of opinions and beliefs is welcomed and practiced in our community. Because I believe in one truth, it does not mean that your truth is invalid. This needs to apply to all diversity in our community.
Felicia Di Stefano
How refreshing to read something positive. I hope Brian the uplifting feeling stays with you.
Coleen Coleman
Love your description of the service and Craig. I remember my first time in the church and it was very similar. I was one of the four that got baptised that day and gave my testimony (2nd to speak, lady in her 30s). I decided a few years ago to be a Christian and true believer not a denomination, family and friends have other strong opinions. Glad you got to witness and what a farewell for Craig and his family. They have been so involved in the whole community for 17 years. Thank you for your words.
Jess O'Brien
Yes, Craig and family have been an absolute blessing to us during our January holidays every year. Thank you so much Craig - God's blessings for your future
Bob Boucher
Keep talking
August 5, 2017
Geoff, you ARE the voice of reason and sensitivity to all the issues that we face every day living here in the Bass Coast region.
It is such a pity that people who are uninformed, ignorant, angry and unreasonable who vent their rage on the Councillors of BCSC as well as the staff. (via Email, Facebook, Twitter etc.)
In our world today, there are visionaries, pragmatists, philosophers and great activists.
Keep up the good work because you are highly respected in our community.
Phyllis Papps
Geoff I think you would be good at teaching councillors how to do what you are doing. Would love to see people in my council region working as you do. We never get to even see them. My experience has always shown me that the closer you connect with the public good or bad the more you learn where change needs to happen and at the same time you show your community that you care and you want to listen. Well done!
Helen
WE live in complex in San Remo with 24 owners and body corporate. With the new bins starting at a time when many permanent residents away, and holiday home owners staying warm else where we had some concerns on the change. The response from council officers has been very impressive. Prompt response, a site meeting arranged and decision reached and confirmed by Council. Yes it's a big task the Council officers face with this new service. There will be issues but from our experience they can be resolved with common sense discussion.
Chris Day
Chris, Great to read such a positive message. Extending the life of the current landfill cell will be a great outcome and working through issues this way provides a template for other initiatives.
Cr Geoff Ellis
At least the yellers are consistent and yell at every council. That is why some councillors did not re-contest the previous council elections, to the community's loss. Society is like this; most reasonable, some not. Articles like yours are important in education our community but perhaps your article needs to be delivered through other channels as well, to reach those who would not read the BCP. Thank you for kindly for including SGRAR as part of our community.
Felicia Di Stefano
Once again your very thoughtful and informative article make us ever more aware how fortunate we are to have such a vehicle for public discussion as the Bass Coast Post. Thank you councillor,may many of your colleagues take advantage of this forum.
Bob Middleton
Once again Geoff very well written. Your thoughtful and well written words are always enjoyable to read and I always walk away feeling more informed. You are right on the money that most people we meet and chat with are positive and just looking for someone to hear them, unfortunately there will always be the aggressive minority.
Couldn't agree more with your message about the counter staff, the faces at the coal front, we shouldn't shoot the messenger.
Keep up the great work Geoff, the Westernport Ward, the Bass Coast Shire Council are so lucky to have you, the work you do and advocacy you pursue for your ward and our shire is unquestionable.
Cr Brett Tessari
Thanks Brett, Being part of such a supportive team makes it easier for all of us to achieve the outcomes to which our people aspire.
As you say, most people are positive and, when we have to present them with outcomes that might not meet their expectations they take it well. With limited resources it's impossible to realise every great initiative and I admire your ability to negotiate and find a way forward that achieves the greater good.
Cr Geoff Ellis
Paradise lost
August 6, 2017
Preservation of existing pockets of indigenous vegetation in settled areas on Phillip Island is vital. 'Development' of areas like this one at Red Rocks will destroy the very thing that makes living on and visiting Phillip Island so desirable. We need to preserve the beautiful rural and coastal views together with unique flora & fauna. If we don't we will be faced with living in just another poorly planned and ugly suburban wasteland. We'll also face living with the guilt of having allowed the destruction of something which should have been handed on to future generations. It's time to stop putting short term profits for a few before precious environmental & social considerations. The Red Rocks area is particularly lovely. It would be so sensible to protect the area, preserve the vegetation and use part of it for community activity - a small playground and perhaps an appropriate trail which would allow enjoyment of the birds and plants. I hope Council will heed its own documents when it considers this application.
Mary-Lu Burt
This should never be allowed to happen a park would be much better
Philip Kinniff
Home-grown talent
August 5, 2017
What I love about living in Bass Coast is the number of talented people we have here. What an inspiring story - Well done Maureen!!
Susan Anderson
I have admired Maureen's work for many years and have been very moved by the process she has undertaken to fulfill her passion for watercolours. Her eye captures the heart of the chosen place and the outcome is joyous.
Thankyou so much Maureen
Ailsa Drent
I have a few small paintings of Maureen . I used to live quite close to her a long time ago ... Some of my kids were friends with her youngest daughter . I have s very lovely small oil painting of her daughter and my son with horses .., I treasure it as it brings back beautiful memories ... Thanks Maureen , such talent !!!
Henny
A soft target
July 22, 2017
I sincerely apologise, on behalf of white skinned people, for the racism you have suffered in South Gippsland. My experience in the Bass Coast is very different to yours, Rinchen. I took my South Sudanese friends and their children around Wonthaggi; shops, banks, doctors, Centrelink, parks. Nowhere did we experience racism. My husband and I sponsored a Karen family and as we went around Wonthaggi town shopping, people would smile at us, some extend hands to shake. I had tears rolling down my eyes as the checkout lady at big W held out her hand and said "welcome to Australia." I too have suffered extreme racism in the land of my birth. I am a Jew. But never in Australia. Must be because I have a white appearance. It sounds as if some of the population of South Gippsland needs to be educated about diversity and how it has served and still serves Australia.
Felicia Di Stefano
Thank you, Bass Cost Post, and Mikhaela and Rinchen, for two challenging, gutsy and helpful articles on racism, and for the many penetrating responses from the public.
Rob Youl
I am saddened that racism is still prevalent in our country. It shocks me that people can be mistreated just because of the colour of their skin. All I can say is that we are not all like that and I hope and pray that you will have many positive experiences that will show these awful actions to be foolish gestures made by ignorant people who do not understand the wonder and beauty of diversity.
Jacqui Paulson
Thank you for the letters. I too am sorry that people have not embraced difference of colour and culture. Diversity is a great gift for us all. If we can only embrace difference Australia and South Gippsland will be a richer, happier and more secure place for everyone.
Philip Beggs
To be honest I'm a little bothered and feeling defensive of all I've read My town is a welcoming town IMPO - different on many levels than others in both bass coast and south gipps land but thats just my opinion
Rosemary
Thank you Rinchen for your bravery and honesty. It takes courage to speak up out against personal experiences of racism. I feel a sense of shame and dismay that there are people in our community who are prepared to judge others simply on the colour of their skin. They are however a small minority. I want you to know that there are many here in the community who abhor racist attitudes and are prepared to stand with you.
Susan Pryde
Apologies to Rinchen for the sadness to her ( and many others) by pig-ignorant people. I was a young teenager in the 50's and remember the racism by many towards the Italians who moved to Wonthaggi to work in the State Coal Mine. Where would we be now culturally without their input to our town (to say nothing of decent coffee, fabulous food etc.) I remember when olive oil was only sold at chemist's shops! Rinchin when we hear every day of the apathy and mistreatment towards the owners of this land (here for at least 65,000 years), and us invaders for what 200+ years? my heart bleeds for you and yours. Of course racism is encouraged by many of our politicians whose power base are the 'rednecks' both in towns and rural areas. If I am ever fortunate enough to meet you, Rinchin, I would take you in for a good coffee and just let anyone look sideways they would feel the edge of my tongue. Best wishes to you and I do know plenty of people in Bass Coast Shire who would support you.
Yvonne McRae
Rinchen, I am so sorry. I am so sorry that you've had to deal with small-minded, ignorant people. I'm so sorry that you've been treated this way, and I'm so sorry you're thinking of moving from your dream house to get away from this.
If you ever need support, or would like to discuss ways we can both help stop this in our area, I would love to have coffee with you sometime. Catherine has my email.
Thank you for reading my piece last week and sharing your story. That took a lot of courage.
Mikhaela Barlow
How fortunate we have young women like Mikhaela and Rinchen calling it as they see it.
They remind us that we must individually and collectively condemn racism whenever and where ever we are. Thank you both.
Anne Davie
July 23, 2017
I have timidly put out 'hello's and how are you to newer members of our community. Theirr reaction is non commital so now I leave them alone. I'm sorry for this but feel it may be for the best. Thanks for Mikhaela and R for bringing it to my attention.
Joan Woods
Mary and I recently gave Ancestry.com a DNA sample and was somewhat surprised to find that my direct descents went for 116 pages and Mary's for 230 pages which equates to lots and lots of relatives from all over the world with diverse backgrounds and races. Throughout our lives we have observed examples of casual racism and there is nothing casual about it.
It is through education that we can change racial prejudice. Richen, we are glad to read that you have been invited to sit on the Govenor of Victoria's round table of Victoria's leaders to help develop Victoria's Multicultural policy All of us.
At this forum you have the opportunity to voice your concerns and make recommendations to change the culture that you say exits in South Gippsland and elsewhere.
Frank W Schooneveldt
One of the reasons I am so ashamed of living here :( I moved from Melb - being the parents of migrants myself I still see and feel the angst of not being a true Anglo in this community :( I have grown up with many races and religions in Melb - just another part of our beautiful world - mingling with varied people and cultures has been such a gift - these people who discriminate have not had the privileged to mingle and learn and love the variety of cultures inner Melb has - and all i can say - it is their silly idiotic loss - thank you for being to true and honest to some of the ugliness of old school regional Victoria
Ant
I was shocked and saddened to read Mikhaela's earlier article, as My experience has been quite different, as a new arrival in Bass Coast. But then I'm white and also, one tends to make friends with people with similar philosophies. I did have one experience, in a group I joined, some members of which expressed objectionable (to me) attitudes to refugees and asylum seekers (equating them with terrorists). I challenged this at the time but it was clear they weren't listening (they just shouted over the top of me), so I decided not to waste my time with that group.
When I read Mikhaela's article and again this week, reading Rinchin's account of her treatment, I am ashamed and furious. People are of course entitled to their opinions, however cruel and ignorant. So I want to channel my fury into thinking about how we can work to marginalise such attitudes and ultimately see them disappear. We need to focus on educating our young people, providing them with powerful experiences that help them understand we are all human, with loves, hopes and skills that can contribute to enriching our community.
Maddy Harford
Due to the hiring practices of many companies in Australia over the last 15 years, it doesn't surprise me that racism is on the rise. When low, middle and indeed some professional employees find themselves replaced by workers holding temporary work /holiday visas, racism will flourish. It's no excuse, but not surprising.
Jeff Sim
Bravely written Rinchen & Mikhaela. Thanks you for reminding us all that not speaking up when we hear a racist comments can be just as much of a problem and just as hurtful. Unfortunately a much needed reminder that we all have a responsibility to build the welcome and accepting communities we want to live in and should be vigilant to stop the comments and treatment you have received.
Issie
Beautifully written Rinchen. Thank you for being so brave.
Deb
Bilbao, MONA, TarraWarra … Wonthaggi?
July 22, 2017
Council should begin the process? I take a different view; the community should begin the process, if indeed it really supports the initiative being suggested. Councils role is to facilitate and support the community in achieving its goals.
I would support an inclusive community movement to achieve a regional gallery or an even greater initiative once it had demonstrated a willingness to engage extensively within the artistic and broader community and was open in setting its goals.
I note that MONA in Hobart, the Guggenheim Museum in Bilbao, Spain, and Tarrawarra Museum of Art in the Yarra Valley were not Council initiatives but the products of philanthropy.
At the Council meeting in June an Arts and Culture Advisory Committee was formed, expressions of interest will be called shortly – that could be where this starts – get on board.
Michael Whelan
I agree that the Advisory committee is a good starting point. A related point - members if community groups who are passionate about their cause don't necessarily know where to start, who to approach and how. Perhaps a service/strategy that council could implement is an education program/workshop for community groups on when and how to approach council, the role of council officers etc.
Marian Quigley
I fully support the idea, and think it's worth pursuing.
Jill Shannon
We have a dramatic landscape, flourishing creative and artistic base,progressive growers and a steadily growing tourism rate. Bendigo has grown into a regional arts hub on the back of their highly successful gallery. Food and wine contribute, and I see South Gippsland having the potential to become this region's focal point for art, food and travel.
Kathleen O'Neill
Why does everything go to Wonthaggi? Phillip Island, which raises all the revenue is neglected again.
Pauline Enright Amon
As is Almurta, Bass, Corinella, Coronet Bay, Glen Alvie, Glen Forbes, Grantville, The Gurdies, Jam Jerrup, Kernot, Kongwak, Krowera, Pioneer Bay, Pound Creek, San Remo, Tenby Point, Wattle Bank.
Woodleigh, Cape Paterson, Harmers Haven, South Dudley, Anderson, Archies Creek, Hicksborough, Kilcunda, Lance Creek, Powlett River, St Clair, Wattle Bank, Dalyston, Blackwood Forest, Ryanston,
West Creek and Inverloch.
Geoff Ellis
Renovator's delight
July 22, 2017
Geoff beautifully captures how places get under the skin. Lew's place another treasured gem in 'them there hills'.
Jeannie Haughton
Love energy, and determination works wonders. Well done.
Pamela J Gill
I don't know Lew or his farm, but, after reading this, I feel I would like them both. You have evoked person and place in a way which is heart warming and reassuring in these troubled times. Long may Lew and Landcare prosper to safeguard and restore this beautiful area we humans and many other life-forms call home.
Anne Heath Mennell
A well written article about one of the hinterlands most interesting characters as he battles to turn a green desert into a lush and productive oasis. Many have tried to make a living from small farms and Lew describes the hard work and dedication needed to succeed. Did the author get to try Lew's home made ginger beer?
Janice Orchard
No hint of ginger beer so far but I reckon it will be worth the wait.
Geoff Ellis
Forget the ginger beer, You should have asked for his pear cider! Legendary!!!
Judy Potter
What a wonderful story. It reminds me of my parent's struggle 70 years ago when they bought 33 acres in Wonga Park and endeavoured to build a productive orchard. Dedication and hard work were the key then and still are.
Heather Reid
Well done Lew. Great read. Looking forward to our catch up at the reunion. Cheers Joan & Azza
Joan & Paul Azzopardi
My place
July 22, 2017
Welcome to Bass Coast! Another well kept secret - the Kernot Shop and the drive around the historic towns of the hinterland.
Geoff Ellis
Thanks kindly, Geoff, I had heard that rumour and will def check Kernot out!
Jen
July 24
Hi Jen and welcome to Bass Coast.
Now that you are a resident and settled in why not call into the Corinella and District Community Center and say hello. There is a good bunch of happy volunteers there who would be pleased to let you know what is happening in the area. Pick up one of our brochures while you are there and there may be something that interests you. We also have a free book exchange.
I volunteer there every Monday so call in and have a chat as I enjoyed reading your article.
cheers
Janice Orchard
Hi Jen,
I am in the same situation you were in, still looking for something I like in my price range. Moved down here a few months ago and renting. Beautiful place hope you will love it here. If you have pets just watch out as someone deliberately ran down and killed my cat outside my place and that was devastating, considering he had survived 11 years in inner Melbourne.
Good luck and enjoy.
Kath
Hi Jen and Kath,
Another welcome to Bass Coast!
Jen, your story parallels mine, except that I moved from Murrumbeena, the agent who showed me round the area before taking me to see my little bit of paradise was Gordon who still works at Alex Scott in Grantville, and I moved in to Tenby Point, just up the road from Corinella. That was sixteen years ago.
Kath, I was so sorry to hear what happened to your puss. Have you had a look at Tenby Point? It may not suit you (no shop or public transport) but in other ways is delightful. Hope you find 'your' place in the area soon.
Anne Heath Mennell
August 3, 2017
Hi Jen! Thank you for the recommendation! It was a pleasure pointing out all the features of this beautiful coastal area to you, and you're right, it really is a bit of a secret. The word is getting out though hence housing stock being scarce at present. I'm so glad you found the right one for you! Once you introduce yourself to the locals, I'm sure you will find out more about this gem of an area to explore.
Liz Leahy, Stockdale & Leggo Real Estate, Grantville.
Drinking from a firehose in the age of information
July 22, 2017
Well considered reflections on our crowded, overloaded lives and a great critique of what passes for entertainment. I can recall a time when TV actually stopped - every night, around midnight - and I went to the library to borrow books to read in the quiet times.
My 'time out from the endless noise that surrounds us': Cinema.
Geoff Ellis
So much nonsense all over the media, especially too much reporting of politics, government by such frequent diversion of attention, is it any wonder attention span is shorter than a sneeze?
Bernie
Stop reading the Herald Sun - our local papers are fine - especially the letters columns.....plenty of sense there, eh Bernie?
Geoff Ellis
I miss F troop and Green Acres
Frank Coldebella
Oliver Wendell Douglas is my role model.
Geoff Ellis
Little white lies
July 7, 2017
I am so heartened by this article I feel like shouting 'hooray!' - every day, casual racism is so insidious and perhaps more dangerous that the more obvious forms that this abuse appears in. I too have noticed the habitual and disheartening racism of many residents in the Bass Coast, often from the mouths of lovely and dear people. I always speak up about it whether I do so in a light hearted, jokey way or an angry, direct way. To be silent is to be complicit. I am saddened to hear that the small cohort of african refugees have mainly left the shire as my personal opinion is that refugees are desperately needed in this seemingly culturally homogeneous area. Anyhow, good on you Mikhaela, your article has heartened me no end.
Alice Ansara
Brilliant writing Mikhaela. My hope is that it can be published elsewhere to reach a wider audience. I aml sure the readers of the Bass Coast Post are already with you on this issue.In view of your comments I wonder if Barney Noonan and Curl would consider heeding your advice as it seems to have fallen on some council ears not fully tuned in to the problem.
Bob Middleton
Great to see this piece. Subtle racism go unnoticed. You need to watch out for the phase "I'm not racist, but!!!!!"
Samiro Douglas
Well said and courageously spoken. We set our standards by what we are prepared to walk past and I will mention to the Bendigo bank next time I am in there that their mural is in bad taste. It is as you say the loud and ugly abuse that is offensive but the subtle everyday use of language that is insidious.
Michael Whelan
July 8, 2017
Excellent piece of writing. Let's all stop being so complacent and stand up and say something when we see racism. The person getting attacked will then know we all don't agree with the attacker's views and feel grateful for the support.
Linda D
Great article. Congratulations on calling out racism in its many subtle and not so subtle ways. Thanks
Rosemary Paterson
Beautifully written. Maybe someone with any mainstream media contacts could assist to have Mikhaela's article published elsewhere. Travelling on Metro trains a few weeks ago, after leaving the footy at the MCG, I thought I was fortunate to find a seat. It had been a big crowd game and seats on the line I travelled are always rare. It was in a section with 4 seats, 2 facing each other.. A Sikh family from India. Mother and father visiting their adult son who is currently living here. The parents had very minimal English but the son and I engaged in various conversations and I interacted with the parents via the son. I thought, what an enriching opportunity for me, but also could see in my peripheral vision stares and even glares from other passengers. So sad. The family were getting off the train 2 stops prior to me. The son commented that it had been an enjoyable meeting and I had been generous to him and his parents...common courtesy was all it was...and a seat on a train instead of standing for me. After we had shaken hands (I must admit I am ignorant if this was appropriate to their religion, but I felt I wanted to offer my hand, also as a demonstration to the other "observers" on the train), they left. My heart was warm from the meeting, but I also felt so very sad. As an aside, it wasn't just chance that caused the empty seat. Seats are normally rushed at with trains leaving Richmond station after footy matches. There is still such a very long way to travel on the road to equality for all and acceptance of all races and religions, but as individuals we also have to lead lives of inclusion and standing up for other as Mikhaela demonstrated in the shop in Cowes.
Nola Smith
Mikhaela you are a wonderful, insightful and writer of truth. The topics you wrote with such passion, I term as the ISM'S and PHOBIAS of society in general. So here is the list: Racism, Sexism, Misogynism, Ageism, and of course Homophobia and many other phobias and Ism's .. the list is endless.
As one of the WOGS (of Greek origin) who came here to Australia in 1950 I can't see that very much has changed. There will always be fear of the unknown. When we came here, we were called "New Australians" so my parents worked hard, we got a good education and assimilated into society and made a contribution to society. We even changed our surname by Deed Poll because no one could cope with pronouncing our name.
After the 1950s influx of Italians and Greeks came the Asians in the 1970s as a result of getting rid of the White Australia Policy. Australia is not white, it is multicultural and has been greatly enriched and has benefited from all the migrants and refugees who have come here. But we must always remember who the real owners of Australia are.
Whenever we see, hear or feel that one of the Ism's or Phobias is in words, deeds or actions then we should fight it in every way we possibly can. Australia is NOT for the white, middle class, wealthy people BUT for everybody of any race, colour, religion, politics, sex, gender, age etc.
Just remember Mikhaela, the pen is mightier than the sword. So you have a great future ahead of you as a writer, deep thinker and catalyst for change.
Phyllis Papps
Good to see you still standing up for right Mikhaela, although, given the " caring attitude displayed by our political leaders towards those who have risked all to enter our country, the disgraceful behaviour of bigoted and moronic Australians is not surprising. We are supposed to be the land of the fair go- hopefully your powerful writing will wake them up to what being Australian really means.
Mark Robertson
Yes, I agree that Mikhaela's article is timely and 'on the money'. And, of course, racism is common right across the country, and in all sectors and levels, with bad examples given by too many of our leaders.
However I would like to slightly disagree with Mikhaela's comment that 'you can't be a little bit racist.' I think most of us occasionally have some racist thoughts, maybe subconsciously. But it is how we control our thoughts and actions.
Our society needs to confront fear of the other.
Tom Wolkenberg
July 11, 2017
I think you're right, Tom. It's probably human nature to be suspicious and fearful of "the other", and would have been an evolutionary advantage in the past. But we now face a different reality. I'm heartened whenever I go into multicultural city schools to see the easy camaraderie of children of all races and cultures. They probably don't realise it but they're so lucky! It's by getting to know "others" that we lose our fear.
Catherine Watson
July 10, 2017
Today, research undertaken between 2014 - 15 revealed that Muslims had reportedly been subject to 243 cases of abuse including physical, mainly in NSW and Victoria. Of this number, 75% of attacks had been suffered by Muslim women mainly because of their scarves. About half these women had their children with them at the time of the attacks and abuse. The attacks had been overwhelmingly by white males.
Horrifically, while most of these attacks occurred in public places like public transport or shopping malls, people stood by and watched including police officers and did not intervene to stop such abuse. Very few assisted the women.
I have developed a habit of speaking to Muslim women in public places, welcoming them to Phillip Island or wherever I happen to see them. They have been surprised and then grateful for the positive encounter with an older Anglo woman.
These yobbos, do not act or speak in my name, and never will. Good work Michaela for speaking up with the 2 other young people. If we all spoke kindly and and in a welcoming manner to Muslims, we would all feel better and in help counter the hate speech and actions.
I feel that we Australian can be better than those in the research.
Kay Setches
The power behind the mine
July 7, 2017
What a fantastic achievement by all the people and organisations involved! And the revolving funds will see more new energy innovations emerge in our community. The possible wetlands are a bonus!
Sue Packham
July 8, 2017
The way of the future is right here in our back yard.
Daryl Hook
July 10, 2017
Can we assume that the power generated is first used to power the mine pumps and that the excess only is sold to Parks Vic? The article doesn't say so.
Walter Broussard
The pumps are part of the State Coal Mine.
Geoff Ellis
Full and plenty
I've only been a 'local' for 10 years. In that time the Powlett floods have been a joy for a nature lover with the influx of birds to the lake-like area. Landowners surely would have known of the floodplain's annual behaviour before purchase. If inherited then they would have absorbed the families' negative attitudes. Hopefully they're as impressed as I am with the care that's taken before artificially opening the river's mouth to the sea. From my observations the grasses have plenty of time to grow the Spring/Summer pastures - a rich brew for the grazing animals.
Sue Packham
Estuarywatch volunteers tested the river waters on monday arvo and found there to be good levels of dissolved oxygen at both bridges, along with a wide variety of waterbirds.
Mark Robertson
From telegram boy to postmaster
July 8, 2017
What a brilliant article - a post card from a world where customer service was paramount.
Geoff Ellis
Great article - the name was Hugh Buggy.
As ever, brilliant newsletter - many thanks!
Rob Youl
It makes you think
July 8, 2017
The Hypothetical, The Literary Festival, The BCP and these sessions fill me with hope and pride that Bass Coast has the collective emotional maturity to discuss issues and ideas without the need to hurl slogans and abuse from the parapets.
Geoff Ellis
July 10, 2017
When you get to the essence of genetic engineering and other modern ethical challenges, there is no black and white, only shades of grey. Congratulations to Richard for persuading us to think beyond the slogans and easy answers.
Catherine Watson
Value for money
Excellent and informative article Catherine. This local representative falls far short of my expectations, although nothing seems to surprise me with Cr Larke. The only positive thing I can note is that he has resigned from the Access and Inclusion committee.
Nola Smith
Catherine, thank you for your detailed article.
I agree that Cr Les Larke should look at his own position first.
As I have expressed in this forum and elsewhere, I fundamentally disagree with Cr Les Larke's stated position on the state of the Bass Coast Shire's finances.
I note that for the 2015/2016 year the average rates and charges for the Bass Coast Shire Council was $1684 which is low when compared to the Baw Baw Shire Council of $1987 and South Gippsland Shire Council of $1990.
In view of this I am all for increasing council rates and charges to improve services and infrastructure for the people of Bass Coast.
There are numerous examples of austerity measures that poison growth. For example take a look at the UK government actions.
But this does not mean that there should not be good corporate practice by the Shire officers and accountability to the people of Bass Coast.
Frank W Schooneveldt
Dear Frank
I have enjoyed our robust conversations and note you are supportive of Bass Coast Shire Council and the fact that it has 71.4 fulltime equivalent employees (General Managers + Managers + Coordinators + Supervisors + Team Leaders + Others with direct reports) with managerial responsibilities for 244.7 full time equivalent employees - a span of supervision of less than 1:4, which may be of interest given your financial and commercial background.
Cr Les Larke
Les, I enjoy reasoned arguments that are based on facts.
And yes, I am supportive of the Bass Coast and desire to see it grow through population growth and this requires infrastructure and services.
The numbers you quote are meaningless unless you can benchmark your numbers
with similar large Shire councils.
The Bass Coast is unique in that we have a large coastline to look after, a lot of holiday residences and a lot of tourists....which is all good but I am sure creates management and financial issues that need a team approach to resolve.
We all need to work together for the greater good of the Bass Coast.
Frank W Schooneveldt
I have no personal animosity toward Cr Larke but I do object to the grandstanding that he is pursuing.
Councillors expect a reasonable time to consider their position on matters that are important to the Shire, two hours for multiple motions and amendments is not reasonable - hence my rebuke was not in respect to a particular amendment but his overall approach and abuse of Council time. My comment goes to his failure to work as part of a team. A councillor cannot achieve anything on his or her own other than generate publicity for himself.
In respect to the document to which he refers I did sign a document that dealt with the span of control of managers. I had the expectation and had expressed the view at the time it would go to the CEO for his input and advice as to the accuracy of the figures in it and a possible long term strategy consistent with the reviews that are already underway.
The figures it turns out are spurious and self serving.
It was however represented to the CEO as a Councillor decision for implementation. I realised how stupid I had been and withdrew any association with the paper. I now have a better understanding of the procedures for Councillors to raise matters with the CEO and senior staff.
Cr Michael Whelan
An excellent article Catherine and insightful comments.
Thank you all.
Ursula Theinert
Quick decisions create regret.
Cr Larke's non attendance at pre briefings and meetings is showing his disinterest and disrepect to his fellow councillors, council officers, his ward constituents (the ones that voted him in) and the wider Bass Coast community. Rocking up on Council Meeting day with uninformed and wordy alternate recommendations (that you need a PhD to deipher) is wasting everyone's time - work with the team Cr Larke, you'll get much better results for the community. If your heart is not in it, or personal issues are taking a priority (which they should) step aside and let someone else take on the opportunity, and the training and the money.
H Torley
Victorian Ombudsman Statement: "In relation to briefing sessions for councillors, other states have specific legislation and guidance materials aimed at deterring agreement or consensus being reached by councillors in briefing sessions and other fora outside council meetings". I support that ethical approach.
Les Larke
How fortunate we are in Bass Coast, to have journalism of such excellence and rigour. Congratulations Catherine on your thoroughgoing research revealing and analysing Cr Larke's contribution to council's efforts.
For Cr Larke's, (or any other councillor bar Cr Le Serve), to claim credit for any improvement in council finances is spurious and pure hubris on his part, given the hard work invested by the previous council and the CEO, in long term financial planning, which is now, slowly bearing fruit.
Maddy Harford
June 24, 2017
The buggered boat ramp, the Grantville pot hole, line marking across the misty hills of Krowera, the three bin bonanza……the list is endless and clocks are ticking.
As one lone councillor I can shout from the Cape Horn Lookout but I need a mob to get things done…
… The VEC decreed that Bass Coast needed nine councillors and the underlying surplus of three councillors per ward infers a collegiate approach to collective action – or inaction, Hypocrites had the right idea: firstly, do no harm!
One of my electoral commitments was to fix that damn pot hole outside the Pharmacy and I could do it tonight – don my farmer’s hi viz, grab a bucket of gravel and ….fixed.
There are too many metaphorical pot holes and that’s where the mob steps up. I have yet to meet a council employee who wasn’t gainfully occupied with at least one task or question.
Many that I speak to are trying to prioritize several competing demands on council time and limited resources. What ever their title, they are working for the good of the community.
The need for teamwork is self evident – especially in a small shire with a huge coastline and shifting support from other levels of government.
The team needs to be the residents and ratepayers, the council and the councillors. The four year plan, SRP, annual budgets and long term financial and strategic plans are the things that bring us together – you spoke, we listened, this is what we heard, what do you reckon – a six month conversation and now we need to work together.
Council is not a reality TV show. We spend long days together and there are codes of conduct, local laws, state regulations and, what should be the most easily adhered to – the bounds of certain common courtesies and respect for each other.
There is a confidentiality around our deliberations but then there is a readership that wants to know what is going on. That line is as clear as diluted printer’s ink. Hopefully we haven't crossed it - I'm saving all those scribbled notes for my memoirs while watching for the next pot hole.
I agree with the comments about giving credit where it is due - we are building on reviews and strategies that commenced when I was simply a writer of letters to the editor(s). That ink's dried.
Cr Geoff Ellis
June 25, 2017
Les - Be not afraid of the criticism. Continue to have the courage to bring about the changes needed in fiscal and governance fields. The people who voted you in want that outcome. Expect betrayal. That's a part of human history. Chase the dynamics, articulate the case, get the numbers around you and pick the fruit higher up the tree leaving the low hanging stuff to those who do not have the reach. In cricket parlance it is time to take take the bowling apart. The silent majority are behind you. Good Luck!
Mohan de Run
Mohan, I always thought a majority was greater than 50%.
At the last election Cr Les Larke achieved a primary vote of just 16.79% and after distribution of preferences it increased to just 25% which is hardly support of the silent majority.
I note that former Cr Neil Rankine got 16.61% of the primary vote but was not elected.
I also note that after distribution of preferences there was just 14 votes between Mr larke's winning his seat on council and Mr Rankine's failure to retain his seat on council.
It is interesting to see that all the elected Councilors for Bunruong ward received 2.5 times to 3.5 times the preference votes that Mr Rankine received.
Which begs the question what preference deals were done, but that is another story.
Frank W Schooneveldt
Strange fruit ahead? Thanks for agreeing with me Mohan and can commentators please stick to one analogy/metaphor/simile/cliche per comment, please ?
I appreciate the follow on from Ms Harford's comment but cricket parlance tosses up so many words and phrases that I think references to people's stature (physical or moral) in comparison to orchards deplete the image of leather against willow. And better fit Austen-like forebodings of betrayal.
Geoff Ellis
June 26, 2017
Frank, while I agree with most things you have written and I enjoy your side of the story, I just want to be clear that there certainly weren't any deals done for preferences, not by myself anyway. While I did align myself with Max Wells and didn't hide from the fact, we (Max and myself) did not publish preference order and made it quite clear that while we shared similar ideals we were not running together as a 1 vote 2 vote.
In fact from memory Neil did publish preferences as did Jessica, Mohan and Mark. The other 5 Bunurong candidates didn't. Apart from the rate payers association which had me at 5 and Julian at 4 we all had to work hard for our votes.
I might not agree with all Cr Larke’s views on everything and he may have gotten the bonus of being number 1 on the ballot and the BCRRA's number 1 selection no one can deny he walked the miles, met the community and put in a campaign worthy of selection.
Hopefully this current hard working council will start getting results worthy of this robust discussion and I look forward to those moving forward.
Cr Brett Tessari
Brett, Thank you for the explanation. Local Government always creates robust debate. I am alll about results and not excuses.
Frank W Schooneveldt
Glad to hear that Frank; we are too. (all about results and not excuses).
Geoff Ellis
Excellent article Catherine, the analysis is spot on, people in glass houses shouldn't throw stones!
Lorrie Read
It took me a long time to understand my varied responsibilities when I was elected to State Parliament years ago. Government Departmental briefings, state wide organisations, businesses and not for profits, constituents,ALP, unions, local organisations, schools, local hospitals etc. provided me with invaluable correct information to ensure I could carry out my work as effective MP.
On the surface it appears to be so easy to balance a budget by reducing costs by reducing 40+ Shire employees.
The resultant reduction in Shire services would be a severe related cost to ratepayers. Also this huge reduction in wage earners within Bass Coast would be felt in less money spent on goods and services.
Cr. Larke cannot have thought through the outcomes of his draconian measure. It serves the Shire if Councillors are working together to deliver good governance. Cr Larke should review his stance on attending Shire Briefings, where he would have been advised of the folly of his purely financial view.
Kay Setches
Thank you Kay for your wise words. I totally agree.
Frank W Schooneveldt
A dog’s life
A beautiful story and thank you Jenni and a wonderful thing you have done. This quote came to me recently and I pass it on now: “Wherever you turn, you can find someone who needs you. Even if it is a little thing, do something for which there is no pay but the privilege of doing it. Remember, you don’t live in the world all of your own.”
~Albert Schweitzer
Joy Button
A wonderful article on the work DKD does and volunteers like your self Jenni - it is bittersweet but so worth it! I hope Sunday is a success!
Ant
Time and tide
June 26, 2017
Another excellent edition - thanks!
Meryl’s article was great. I was fascinated to learn of the Corinella volcanics - not an area I know well.
Mike: Is this another dot point in your prescription for action on climate change?
What if we re-created as many swamps as we could in the footprint of the ancient Kooweerup Swamp, using the water for local irrigation, recreation and biodiversity, and somehow letting as little as possible flow directly into Westernport Bay?
Rob Youl
The battle for the right to die
June 20, 2017
The irony of this topic is the fact that allowing an animal to suffer pain and distress is punishable by a jail sentence. Humans are required by law to suffer beyond their wishes. Some years ago, a local man with an aggressive cancer was alleged to have said: "If I was a mongrel dog, you'd put a bullet in me." He ended up delivering the bullet himself, as did another local man not long afterwards. I suspect this goes on every day.
I'm not surprised at the small number of comments regarding this article. Death is a topic that people find uncomfortable at the best of times, and so avoid where possible. Many people who have been in the same situation as Catherine and Geoff are unable to discuss it, such was the trauma of the experience, which is why Catherine and Geoff are to be thanked and commended for opening old wounds in order to try and make things easier for human beings who are dying. I am also aware of people who are unable to visit loved ones in certain medical facilities because of the memory of previous devastating experiences.
Thanks for getting this subject out of the too hard basket, and putting it on the table. In the meantime, remember that every time we part company with someone could be the last time we see them, regardless of age and current health status.
John Coldebella
A man of many parts
June 20, 2017
Many thanks Liane for your interesting story on John French. I was at the gallery one day and immediately drawn to the Warrior. The intricate detail of each mosaic depicting indigenous art was captivating. I glanced upwards and noted the tiny mosaics of models, most clad in lingerie, fascinated by the collective size of it all and was then called away. Some time later and from a distance, I was astounded to see these 'cheeky' bottoms lined up for all to admire! What a funfilled discovery that turned out to be and look forward to more of John's creativity on show at the gallery.
Vilya Congreave
The John Sparks mystery
June 19, 2017
The Wonthaggi RSL has been aware of Cpl John Sparks for more than three years and has held a copy of his service record. He was brought to the sub branch attention by a distance relative who presented the Wonthaggi RSL with framed photographs and replica medals at a ceremony attended by some ancestors of Cpl Sparks. More recently the Wonthaggi RSL has been assisting the Wonthaggi CFA with DVA and CWGC protocols to support their planned visit to France, and will continue to do so as requested by them.
The proper name for the "Dead Mans" Penny" is the "Memorial Plaque". its issue was accompanied by a letter from the King. Some 1,355,000 memorial plaques were issued representing some 450 tonnes of bronze. They were issued well into the 1930s to include those service personnel who died of war related injuries and illness. The Wonthaggi RSL does hold a memorial plaque. It was issued to honour the sacrifice of those veterans and their families as result of service in the Great War. To refer to the Memorial Plaque as macabre disrespects those veterans and their families who received the medallion issued by the Commonwealth as the highest recognition of their service. Just like the Returned from Active Service Badge", it is a humble reward for service but of great value to those families and individuals.
The Mapping our ANZACS website has been replaced by "Discovering our ANZACS" at the National Archives of Australia. Another important site is the "AIF Project" This website was developed by the University of New South Wales and the Australian Defence force Academy.
The Wonthaggi RSL has been researching the local veterans of WW1 from the Bass District, and has recently received a State Government Grant to develop a website dedicated to the veterans from this district. The website will include the burial information gathered by the "Friends of The Wonthaggi Cemetery": who have already passed on to the Wonthaggi RSL some 220 records of veterans buried at Wonthaggi, including 9 Prisoners of War from WW1.
The Wonthaggi RSL will later on this year re call the service of a veteran, born in Wonthaggi and Killed in Vietnam by placing a plaque on the wall adjacent to the Wonthaggi Cenotaph.
Rod Gallagher (Veteran), Secretary, Wonthaggi RSL
Wonderful story. Very well told. Beautiful.
Edward Buckingham
Dinosaur hunter
June 20, 2017
A great summing-up of Bass Coast's living treasure, Mike Cleeland, Geoff! Like myself and many others, you have obviously enjoyed listening to someone with a passion and with great knowledge about it and committed to finding out more.
Meryl Tobin
Somewhere over the rainbow
June 2, 2017
Phyllis, what a wonderful article. It is full of courage and you should be so proud of your trailblazing.
You have more than earned a place in society, to which you continue to contribute.
Pamela Rothfield
June 4, 2017
Thank you so much Pam. I truly believe that all Councillors who supported the motion for Marriage Equality at the last Council meeting are the true heroes. My response was due to the negative and highly inflammatory prejudiced comments made by several members of the community in the previous edition of Bass Coast Post.
Phyllis Papps
I agree with Pam a great snapshot of a movement - and you have shown great courage in your life.
Michael Whelan
June 5, 2017
Thanks Phyllis and BCP. One of the many great things about the Post is the freedom to express ourselves sans editorial interference.
Geoff Ellis
Thank you for telling us your story Phyllis and thank god we have people as you both that have given life long support and activism to equality for all. Hopefully one day we will get there.
Clare Le Serve
June 3, 2017
Phyllis and Francesca: Thank you for sharing your courage with us and enabling people to emerge from the shadows. One day that bit of paper, that says so much, will be available to all.
Geoff Ellis
Thank you Phyllis for such a beautiful rendition of yours & Francesca's journey. You have both demonstrated great courage & truth.
With all my heart I hope your dream will come true. In the mean time - Thank you.
Marie Broussard
My sincere thanks to everyone for their very positive comments on Bass Coast Post and for the Emails and phone calls we have received. Let's hope true equality is well on the way for everybody - irrespective of race, gender, age, color, education, political beliefs etc. The list is endless.
Phyllis Papps
It is always inspiring to read the story of true trail blazers, thanks for sharing your story Phyllis and Francesca you really are an inspiration to all who seek equality. I wish my lesbian daughter was able to share the rights taken for granted by her heterosexual sisters. Until all members of society are free to express their love for each other in the same way, we are not truly equal. Well done to Bass Coast Shire for their support. Over to you Malcolm!
Lorrie Read
Absolutely agree with you Lorrie up to "are not truly equal". I just do not think that the Bass Coast Shire Council has a role here. Nor do they have a mandate.
Let’s ask the Bass Coast Shire to make a Proclamation that we : Openly and proudly proclaim the fundamental right that within the Shire of Bass Coast all human souls are equal regardless of their race, colour, religion, disability or sexual orientation and will be treated with equal respect, kindness and civility as one would expect for one's self.
Then over to Malcolm and Bill to see what the population of Australia want regarding same sex marriage. This is a democracy! We all get a say in what happens. And that is a wonderful and treasurable thing, the envy of many.
Ruth Partridge
What I’ve learnt
June 2, 2017
Congratulations, Brett, on the ability to take on board truths of which you had been unaware and change your perspective. A rare skill in adults. I wholeheartedly support your acceptance of united humanities' differences. Yes we need to support peoples choice of a partner in life, yes we need to provide our youth every opportunity for growth and security. I am happy that you are on our council.
Felicia Di Stefano
Great issues Brett - yes we have to take them on and ensure we keep them front of mind. We probably cannot achieve solutions but we can achieve progress and hopefully assist people in their journey. Nice article.
Michael Whelan
Good on you Brett for writing such a thoughtful article. At the forum (run by BCS for future planning ) that I attended front and centre was the need for things to happen in our Shire for our youth. And viva la difference as the French say. We are all human beings and the permutations of gender, values, hopes and aspirations especially of young people must always be included in Shire forward planning. Keep up with what is important to young people, They are the future of our world.
Yvonne McRae
June 4, 2017
Brett, well said and well thought out. Being a Councillor certainly raises your awareness and provides an opportunity to change things for the better.
I concur and will do whatever I can to advocate for their safe place.
And any number of people have pointed at that big empty ex-coles building and said what a great place - it could be a home for several community groups.
Geoff Ellis
On board MH128
June 2, 2017
Congratulations on your quick thinking and bravery, Fab and Troy. You helped diffuse a dangerous situation, bomb or no bomb. Thank you for sharing their story, Nina. You and Troy's wife and boys had a lot of pluck to let them continue their journey!
Meryl Tobin
June 3, 2017
OMG. A well told tale of bravery. Have to wonder how bomb-like "black device about 40 centimetres round and 15 centimetres high" passed through security.
Geoff Ellis
June 4, 2017
These two men should be nominated for a bravery award along with that heroic stewardess. What a courageous trio of people.
Lyn Blom
To be or not to be
June 2, 2017
Thank you, Catherine, on enlightening us about the limitations of the current Victorian Government bill on assisted dying. Despite its apparent limitation, the bill, if passed would be a first step in the right direction. As well, the strict parameters of its conditions, should allay the main fears of its detractors.
Felicia Di Stefano
June 4, 2017
There are compelling arguments on both sides of the debate and I'm sitting on the fence, I believe Victoria should not rush into the lead on this issue. Standards,Values and Ethics have dropped alarmingly in the last decade. Deception is rampant in every space of life. Before this is allowed, lets plug all the loopholes, after we see what happens in NSW.
Mohan de Run
June 6, 2017
No need to sit on the fence - start a Rip Van Winkle movement so we never move forward. Ever.
Geoff Ellis
The Battle for Western Port
June 2, 2017
Great effort Jeff and the team - we must stay vigilant in the interests of Westernport,
I look forward to Brian Paynter and the other candidates in the upcoming State Election declaring their support for Preserving Westernport - not just from a Port but from other development also.
Michael Whelan
Brothers and sisters
June 5, 2017
I don’t agree with Rob Easton’s views but like all on his side of the debate, he is entitled to his opinion.
I do not believe the majority of the voting public in this country are ready to accept marriage equality and many like me, share the fear of the unintended consequences, especially for the children of today.
So for the sake of the children, who are the future of every country, I say to both sides, press for the plebiscite.
That will be a fair way of dealing with this proposed piece of social engineering and I for one will respect that outcome.
Should the Marriage equality group believe they have the numbers for a change in the law, there is no reason to fear the plebiscite and they should lobby the crossbench senators to bring in whatever amendments are necessary to the bill before them in the senate to ensure the outcome of the Plebiscite receives full endorsement in both houses of parliament.
Mohan de Run
One of the great things about the Bass Coast Post is the ability for people to exchange views and opinions in a public, un-moderated forum.
I respect your views and as I said in the preamble to item F4 you can not legislate morality and I do not want to challenge people's beliefs.
Our motion has nothing to do with social engineering, we are adding weight to the community push for equality and a change to legislation that should better reflect the social norm. As always the inertia built into our democracy needs to be overcome occasionally.
I am glad that you have declared that Rob and I, "like everyone on" our "side of the debate" are entitled to our opinion, that's a particularly benevolent attitude, thank you.
I do not fear 'the plebiscite' - the proposal was for non-binding one so it was simply pointless, merely another Kanute-like gesture. There are better ways to spend $160 million dollars.
I agree that we need to press for our elected representatives to achieve a result in both houses of parliament but why not just press them to have a conscience vote based on what their electorates tell them - if we need to put this to a plebiscite we also need to run a number of other matters through a similar process. Let’s start with plebiscites about coal mines, climate change, free trade, refugee quotas, coward punch laws, euthanasia, penalty rates, tougher sentencing, the age limit for drinking, which schools should be built, .....mmmmm....maybe it’s easier to get politicians to do what they know is right and fair. It's why we vote for them.
That's just my opinion, of course.
Geoff Ellis
We do: Bass Coast commits
May 20, 2017
There are a great many rate payers of profound faith who will disagree with the Council's public display of political correctness. There are a great many rate payers of no faith at all who will agree with them.
This is not Council business! You do not have a mandate to make such a decision.
Ruth Partridge
Ruth, they have EVERY such mandate. Elected representatives are there for the purpose of ensuring the community (not just white, straight, AngloSaxons) are represented. Ruth, a mandate is not only what legislative capabilities they have as elected representatives, it's a mandate for their MORAL duty and ETHICAL code to ensure the broader Bass Coast Community is represented. And that, they have done! Well done, Bass Coast Councillors. May we continue to be represented in legislation AND ethos/morality for many years to come! You have provided a beacon of guidance to this community, And Councillors, and you should be commended for it!
Rob Easton
Did the council as me for my views..NO So why should we accept their views.....NO.
Does the council get things right NO.....
So ask for the ratepayers opinion before you think you know what we want....Get our views...or is that to hard to do
May Gardner
Not at all hard, May, but MAJORITY of our community, across the nation, support EQUALITY and FAIRNESS before the law; just as majority of our community, across the shire, feel the same. Bigotry and small-mindedness will get you, me, and us absolutely nowhere. Wake up and smell the 2017 Roses. They are full of colour and full of diversity. You might enjoy it!
Rob Easton
The views of the silent majority will always prevail at the right time and place no matter the attempt of the loud few who wish to push for dangerous social engineering for the limp reasons that it is contemporary thinking or unreliable belief that it makes a difference. That vast majority know different and will properly consider the unintended consequences of going against nature.
Mohan de Run
Mohan de Run, going against nature? I have a few studies I can reference that might prove otherwise... Nature, life and biology in general is fluid and ever evolving. As is sexuality. Only the inability to acknowledge it remains a stagnant and flaccid part of our ever-present (and in my opinion) long out-of-date religious heritage that dictates a status-quo no longer relevant or correct. I hate to tell you, but it's now high time and long overdue that we respect, embrace and support each other, rather than discount the rights of your fellow citizens. Perhaps get out more, meet a few of your LGBTIQ friends and neighbours, realise that they are not in fact an abomination, but just that same as you. They pay the same taxes, respect the same laws ... and deserve the same rights before the law that you hold so dear. Let's hope you don't have a child, brother, sister, niece, nephew, friend who happens to 'go against nature' -- I hate to think the reception you'll provide them when they need someone to explain why their community thinks them only an 'unreliable belief' !! Our councillors have acknowledged that their community is just as broad as the rest of our great Nation and have shown just how committed they are to ensuring cohesion and acceptance. Feel free to join the cause.
Rob Easton
A Gay and Happy Future
In love, the two plan
a long life together
But marriage plans rest
with a prime minister, his
party and maybe a plebiscite
the result of which colleagues
might or might not
respect.
Meryl Brown Tobin
All the more reason to put some weight behind the argument Meryl. Hopefully The Prime Minister and his party, and all those cross-benchers and opposition members may just listen and think with their hearts... for once! Well done to our local Council for thinking outside of party politics and agendas, and supporting our community (no matter their sexual preferences, religion or backgrounds) !
Rob Easton
Back in October 2014, Bass Coast Shire Council proclaimed its support for marriage equality by agreeing with the request from Byron Shire Council to develop, adopt and endorse a proclamation which was then compiled and presented to the Prime Minister by the aforementioned Council.
As formally outlined in a dot point proclamation and agglutinated here – “we believe our elected leaders have a responsibility to protect the rights of all citizens, the current law needs to change and that is it about human rights and respect, celebrating diversity and inclusion”.
Strategic justification was easy – as part of the healthy communities objective, the aim was to foster wellness in a supportive, inclusive, healthy and active community. The debate was insightful, personal, respectful and the motion was carried six to one, translating to 85 per cent.
The current council’s vote of seven for, one absent and one abstaining, the percentage three years on, is open to interpretation. With the plethora of national polls in the public realm ranging from 64-70 per cent support for marriage equality, with the standout being our inclusively minded and socially responsible young people (18-24) at 81%, it seems support is increasing with time, as you would expect, our elected representatives are quite representative of the community they serve and a change to the Act is hopefully imminent.
Jordan Crugnale, Bass Coast Shire councillor 2012-16
Kick start for Cowes
May 20, 2017
Michael. Well said.
John Wright
I totally agree
Marilyn Shaw
Ditto
Peter Brown
It's all good and it's a start but for the life of me I cannot understand why we are not building the Philip Island Aquatic Centre and renovating the Wonthaggi Aquatic Centre now.
We have the financial capacity to do so.
We live in times of historic low interest rates so it's a good time to borrow money now and to lock in interest rates for the longer term.
The Council should ask questions; like where are we now, where do we want to be and how are we going to get there.
The population of Bass Coast will grow and we need to build infrastructure to catchup with current needs and underpin future ones.
Think the City of Bass Coast, what it will look like and how we are going to meet that challenge.
Frank W Schooneveldt
The progress being made by Council to invest and re-invigorate Phillip Island is to be commended.
As a healthy democracy supports the majority, it must be appreciated that there will always be public debate and dissent on issues of priority.
As the community have endlessly demonstrated significant support for a Phillip Island Aquatic center this deserves to receive immediate council support in both word and funding.
Ian Samuel
Well stated Michael ... press ahead !
Garry Busowsky
I couldn't agree more, Cowes needs new investment and revitalising, let's work together to smarten it up for the celebrations next year.
Lorrie Read
Dear Mr Andrews
May 5, 2017
If the mayor manages a meeting with the premier, could he please be thanked for the $30 million of desal water - it will be useful for damping down the asbestos fibres swirling around the ancient corridors of Wonthaggi Secondary college - in an alternative universe it would have made more sense to spend those millions on a new school.........
Mark Robertson
Hear hear to the Mayor's message. Well said and I hope that we can extract a solid commitment - maybe next (election) year.
Geoff Ellis
The Age last Wednesday reported that the budget would fund nine new schools (only one in the east at Pakenham) and 108 schools would be upgraded. I can't imagine that there are 108 schools in Victoria in a worse condition than Wonthaggi. I look forward to hearing the Premier's response to this issue.
Anne Heath Mennell
Good point, Anne, but it's possibly a hopeful sign. The government wouldn't want to spent money on upgrading the current school if they are planning to replace it. I think next year (before the election) will be our year but in the meantime we must become noisy and annoying.
Catherine Watson
I hope that they listen to you this time, they haven't before, but keep pushing Pam. Have you noticed that other than some expenditure on the rail system to the valley, NOTHING has been allocated anywhere South East of Melbourne with the exception of the Pakenham area. It's as if we don't exist or would it be that the Premier and his cohorts are all geographically challenged or were the relevant pages of their Melways been removed. I know one party I won't support come election time. Just a clue Premier, it's just a very short drive from your white elephant (the desal plant) to the town centre.
Barrie Stewart
I agree with Mayor Rothfield's comments, however l remind the people of Bass Coast that this is not an election year.
I have been looking at the State of Victoria's balance sheet that reveals cash and cash equivalents balance forecast for the 30th June 2017 of $7.2 billion and that is forecast to grow to $9.5 billion by 30th June 2021. Obviously the Victorian government does not have any money issues and could easily fund the Wonthaggi high school and other infrastructure projects if it wanted to.
This is a huge war chest that will be spent at the Government's choosing. We, the people of Bass Coast need to shout a lot louder.
Frank W Schooneveldt
All aboard for Port Albert
What a wonderful way of taking us back in time through this narrative. Reading about history in this manner is not an exercise of dates and places (which I can never remember!), but a marvellous journey.
Liane Arno
Clear as mud
May 4, 2017
Cr. Les Larke's spiel re the budget would lose most people the will to live. A 'transformational approach'? Perhaps with Cr. Larke interested in the Wonthaggi Cemetery ratepayers bored to death by his ramblings and goobledegook could get a 'cut-price' plot?
Yvonne McRae
April 23, 2017
I believe it's about time that Cr Larke ought understand his role as a Councillor. He is elected to represent his constituents and not unlike any member of a board is there on Council, in conjunction with his elected colleagues, to set and monitor strategic direction.
It certainly is not his role to "harass financial staff", as reported, and be involved in financial detail.
In fact he ought not approach Council staff other than those whom the CEO permits.
Warren Nichols
April 23, 2017
If Cr Larke is so concerned (obsessed) about financial transparency, maybe he should consider resigning from his current role as Councillor. Sooner rather than later. Much time and money would be saved. Or, he might like to consider that he's not really value for money, at all. His role is as a municipal Councillor and his duties are to represent the residents and ratepayers of Bunurong ward. It seems Cr Larke prefers to be an unofficial representative of the CPA and loves to grandstand his knowledge of financial matters. I note that Cr Larke signs letters with his CPA credentials, followed by his Cr title. No man can serve two masters, and I'm sick of my rates funding a pedantic and myopic councillor.
Julie Tyrrell
April 22, 2017
Thank you Catherine. This made excellent reading!
I had a conversation with Cr Larke during the campaign and, like Nola, I was disappointed to see that my fears about his approach to the role of councillor were realised from the 'get go'.
Maddy Harford
Thank you Catherine for this enlightened report.
I have read the Councils Strategic Resource Plan (SRP) and next years Budget that was released on Friday afternoon.
These are impressive documents and I offer my congratulations to all involved.
The Budget appears to be framed on a conservative basis and we appear to have scope to build more infrastructure like cultural centers and swimming pools.
The Council's finances are in good shape.
We all need to work together for the greater good of the Bass Coast.
Cheers
Frank Schooneveldt
April 22, 2017
I am glad to read Mr Schooneveldt's positive feedback.
I value the results of informed scrutiny and I encourage all members of the community to offer feedback on matters that they feel might be of importance.
I totally agree that "We all need to work together for the greater good of the Bass Coast".
Cr Geoff Ellis
Thankyou Catherine for the information re Councillors. As a resident of Bunurong, I was disappointed with the last council election result. My fears are being realised. We could have ben represented by many more enlightened people rather than a time waster. Cr Larke might be a man of many words but didn't even bother to auto acknowledge an email I sent him, let alone make a reply. We need positive people who want to make a genuine contribution to the shire.
Nola Smith
Nola, I understand that every email and every issue is important and I can personally vouch for the tireless effort that Cr Larke has put into following up people's concerns and ideas. He has been a role model in this area.
I can also personally attest to the high volume of emails that are received by your representatives.
I know I haven't replied to all the emails sent to me, for various reasons, one of which is the time required for a worthy reply. I do read them all and trust that the senders know that I treat them on their merits and action them accordingly.
I also would like to point out that general enquiries can be made to basscoast@basscoast.vic.gov.au and these will be passed on to Councillors when appropriate.
Cr Geoff Ellis (Western Port Ward)
Geoff. I think what Nola has suggested is that, if the volume of e-correspondence is high, then a polite way to deal with this is in the first instance, to set up an 'auto response' that, at the very least, acknowledges receipt.
I certainly don't see Cr Larke as a positive model of any aspects of the role of councillor. He has been unremittingly negative about community development and seemingly obsessed with the minutiae of numbers, persisting even in the face of acknowledged authority on the subject.
Maddy Harford
Light at the end of the tunnel
April 23, 2017
Hello. Thanks for another great entertaining and informative article. Have seen this type of burrow a number of times in the district and wondered if they were worms. Never heard of these critters- I'd thought they might have been to do with the local scorpion varieties.. great. Thanks again!
Karen Sandon
Thanks Geoff, I enjoy your stories.
Jan Fleming
May 1, 2017
Quick Update - there are now over a dozen of these chimneys on the lawn between the side fence and the house - the very similar land on the other side of the fence has NONE but that is where the cows graze.
Geoff Ellis
Our John Clarke
April 18, 2017
I immediately grabbed my phone and called many friends. "John Clarke Has died!" were the first words I spoke. Most of the calls I received that day, those were the first words spoken to me. Incredulity, shock followed by despair and desolation for this irreplaceable loss.
That day I attended a fundraising lunch for Emilys List, the financial and mentoring network that works to increase the number of ALP women MPs in Australian Parliaments,where Julia Gillard, the first Woman Prime Minister of Australia, was the guest speaker.
Almost the first words spoken to me from Julia were "John Clarke has died" followed by the most sincere comments on how much she enjoyed the Clarke/Dawe interviews, they were an absolute must to see on TV.
Julia said that no matter who is in Government, political satire as John wrote and performed year after year, is the cornerstone of a true democracy. We have to be prepared for such close uncomfortable scrutiny and the resultant comedy.
I have been an MP and Minister in former state Governments, and have a particular insight into the effectiveness and discomfort of such incisive, surgical and topical hilarious comedy. I hope we can learn from John's played back observations.
Like all good and valued people, we can't imagine a world without them until the calamity of their loss.
His marvellous mischievous, highly intelligent observations turned into so many types of visual and written comedy has been a great gift from John to all of us.
What will I do now on Wednesday evenings prior to the ABC TV news?
Kay Setches, Surf Beach
April 16, 2015
Thank you Liz and Anne and Kellie for sharing your memories and comments about John Clarke. While his mother country was New Zealand we have every right to embrace him as a Bass Coaster. Both he and his long time friend and brother in arms Brian Dawes had strong Island connections.
Bob Middleton, Wonthaggi
April 15, 2017
John Clarke, along with Dr Tim Ealey, John Barnard, QC, and the late Professor John
Swan, started the Western Port Seagrass Partnership in 2001 at a time when seagrass loss in Western Port was dire. Clarke conceived of and hosted a beautiful and hard-hitting DVD on Western Port's environment, including footage from the research program of the 1970s. The DVD has been widely distributed for free by the WPSP and is still available from their website.
Last October Clarke was the guest speaker for the dinner of the Museums Australia Victoria conference on Churchill Island. Rather than crack jokes, he took advantage of being in the company of many of Australia's brightest museum and gallery people to tell them about the battles to save the Western Port environment, and urge them to take action to save their local environments. Clarke also practised what he preached, planting seagrass and revegetating the land he had at Rhyll. Western Port will greatly miss such a champion.
Christine Grayden, Cowes
It was lovely to read tributes to John Clarke by Anne Davie, Liz McDonald and Kellie Nichols in Bass Coast Post. As they showed, he was a very special person. Like many thousands of others, we greatly enjoyed the five minute program Clarke and Dawe on Channel 2 each Thursday at 6.55 pm. His death is a great loss not only to his family and friends but also to the wider community, including the millions of people whose lives he enhanced with his comic genius and his love and protection of the environment which enriched past, present and future generations.
Deepest sympathy to his family.
Meryl and Hartley Tobin, The Gurdies
Thank you, Dr Brooks
Outstanding tribute to a great man, who will be sadly missed by our entire community.
Roger Clark, Grantville
Let’s just do it
April 14, 2017
I totally agree.
Frank Schooneveldt
I totally agree as well. Build it and they will come is an old saying that springs to mind.
Steven Haby
April 21, 2017
Yes. Yes. Let's just do it, and the sooner the better as our need for such a centre is really urgent. To keep Phillip Island up to a standard, and with facilities to be proud of; which fills such a long-felt want for so many people - residents, business-people, visitors, tourists - a top class centre is essential. Barbara Brierley
Natasha's take
April 12, 2017
Roaming through past articles some weeks ago it suddenly hit me what a great body of work (30 plus) cartoonist Natasha has contributed to the Bass Coast Post. Each cartoon has been created with skill and insight and unerringly hits the mark. Of course I have my favourite but since it enhances an article I submitted I am reluctant to disclose which one.
Bob Middleton, Wonthaggi
December 16, 2017
Excellent comments on Phillip Islands future by Phil Wright.To accommodate the inevitable growth in Melbourne's south east corridor which will force increased public pressure on Phillip Island there needs to be a viable vision and strategic plan supported by both state and local governments to establish the Island as a permanent natural retreat for residents and visitors.
The opportunity exists today to create a strategy for an Islands future that recognises, and retains, its natural attractions, open spaces and environmental uniqueness.
Essential to this strategy is the control of vehicle traffic and the associated parking demands by planning for free and frequent shuttle bus services with parking on the mainland. The service to shuttle the day visitors to and from the many tourist destinations that the Island can provide including the towns, beaches, nature reserves and the Penguin parade.
The future of the Island must be decided by forward thinking people not by continuous unfettered growth.
Ian Samuel
Fantastic Phil, let us all contribute to this vision and make it a reality.
Jan Fleming
Couldn't agree more about buses, park and ride, but how about electric, not dirty, noisy, grinding diesels? Now not later.
Bernie
Showing great vision Phil. If London can work towards a National Park., why Not Phillip Island? The statutory purpose of national park status is to "conserve and enhance the natural beauty, wildlife and cultural heritage of the area" and "promote opportunities for the understanding and enjoyment of the special qualities of the park by the public." What if we took these ideas and applied them to Phillip Island? I think this would radically change how we see, think about, design, manage and experience Phillip Island and how we can preserve the island for generations.
Cr Clare Le Serve
Yes I agree Bernie.
Electric shuttle buses with charging points in San Remo and Cowes would promote the vision of a nature park and demonstrate a commitment to the environment.
If the Victorian State Government is prepared, "as it is claimed", to subsidise the operation of a car ferry, then a subsidy for establishing and operating electric shuttle
buses to protect our unique Island environment should be given priority by both local and state authorities.
Ian Samuel
Well written Phil. I could not agree with you more. The seed needs to be planted into the minds of our younger generation to continue the good work of Land Care and all it's
wonderful band of volunteers.
I also agree that the farming community have a clear vision of the potential use their land offers to the tourist industry.
If we had better transport all year round this too would protect our environment.
We can dream.
Pamela J Gill JP
A carrying capacity of 70,000, and they still want a car ferry to bring on MORE???
Gimme a break!
Mike Cleeland
I agree wholeheartedly with Clare Le Serve that we could work towards making the island a National Park for the benefit of future generations. Volunteers working for such bodies as the Barb Martin Bushbank have already contributed significantly to the revegetation of the island.
All of us need to work together towards this vision.
Jan Fleming
Thank you Phil for a very thought provoking article.
As a result of it, I hope we can hear the voices of the kids at school, the young adults who are leaving school, the young families who see this place as their home, as well as the current and past custodians of the land.
I want to know what they believe are the future actions that will ensure outcomes that they believe are "sustainable/desirable" for their future and the future of our place.
It would be very nice if they endorsed and supported the Phil's views.
We could all then move forward with confidence and trust.
Ray McNamara
The art of Robert Smith
December 16, 2017
What a great gift. It’s difficult to fully comprehend the enormity and importance of this collection to the Wonthaggi community. If ever there was an impetus to the development of an “arts precinct “ this surely is it. The proposals to build a regional gallery and the Rotary International Sculpture Park together with the “Wonthaggi Plinth” Sculpture competition for Australian sculptors adds to the growing of Wonthaggi’s identity as mature and sophisticated.
John Mutsaers
Thank you Catherine. I join in welcoming Robert Smith to Wonthaggi and very much look forward to seeing the collection he has given us. In the near future I look forward to seeing the whole of the Bass Coast and surrounds art collection in a Wonthaggi based cultural precinct incorporating a gallery, a library and a theatre. We need to aim high.
Felicia Di Stefano
Such a generous,valuable and timely gift as another focus on Wonthaggi in the arts, helping secure our place on the cultural map.
Ellen Hubble
What a great acquisition for the Wonthaggi community. Lets all do what we can to ensure suitable gallery space is provided for these valuable items.
Beth Spence
To Robert Smith and the wonderful people of Wonthaggi.
I knew Robert when I was an undergraduate at Flinders University. He is a wonderful man, a Renaissance
man, an academic with vibrant, knowledgeable compassionate and dedicated values always. I feel so very proud of his wonderful contribution to your fine place. He is such a genuine soul. I owe any success of my own to his enthusiastic life's work as a meaningful professional.
Thanks Robert. You are one of the most excellent human beings that have ever been.
John Gallagher
Down by the river
December 16, 2017
Thanks Anne the day clashed with a Red Nose grandparents meet.
Love landcare they make horticulture accessible to everyone.
Neri Melsmith
This is brilliant and in such a great spot - almost every visitor to, and most residents of, Bass Coast will witness the development of this garden.
Landcare: Keep at it!
Geoff Ellis
Wonthaggi à la mode
December 16, 2017
Thanks Catherine for acquainting us with this interesting collection and it's imminent exhibition in Wonthaggi! The items you have included for viewing have wet my curiosity and I'll be sure to visit the town hall this January.
Sue Packham
Stunning. I look forward to viewing this great collection. So lucky to live in this part of the world with so many talented people sharing tbeir collections and ideas.
N Smith
Popped into the Civic Centre yesterday- this exhibition is stunning, the passion of the people behind it is inspiring and another reason for a regional gallery/ arts/ exhibition centre in Bass Coast NOW or at least ASAP.
Geoff Ellis
Diamonds are forever
December 16, 2017
Congratulations and all the best to the unforgettable and delightful Jill Muir
Trish Hogan
15 years! - Thanks Jill, your wit and wisdom will be missed.
Geoff Ellis
Blessings
December 16, 2017
Thank you for a sunny story, Miriam. Your self analysis is certainly inspirational. I agree, when we are gentle with ourselves and recognise our potential, we shine. I return your blessing; Shalom.
Felicia Di Stefano
Island at the crossroads
December 1, 2017
I sigh whenever people state on Vicroads forums and the PI Traffic forum that we must "build another bridge" and "widen all the main roads with extra lanes."
Interestingly, I never recognise the writers of these comments as permanent locals.
We must decide what we want our Island to be. The very reason it is so attractive at present is the abundance of natural attractions, including the untouched beaches, green landscapes and rural breaks, rather than just a sea of houses, big chain Melbourne stores, and congested traffic, as the Mornington Peninsula has now become.
Cr Whelan writes: "Greater density of development within the town of Cowes, with no expansion of the town boundaries. Sensitive development must also be demanded in the small coastal towns to preserve their integrity and appeal."
This will require a shift from the “one size fits all” approach of the State Planning Policy framework, which requires councils to ensure 10 years’ land supply for residential development. This dictum is driven by a desire to house an increasing Melbourne population but is blind to the requirements of a tourism destination that relies on its natural environment.
PLEASE, please let's think of this now and plan, rather than look back with a sigh at how it "used to be."
Natasha
It's very heartening to read Cr Whelan's analysis of Phillip Island's strategic planning challenge.
It can't be said too often: "the environment is the economy". If we ignore this obvious fact then our Island is likely to end up just another overdeveloped appendage to Melbourne's urban sprawl.
He's dead right to call for urgent transference of key tourism and environment strategies into the Bass Coast Planning Scheme via amendments, without delay. The one-size-fits-all current Scheme must not be allowed to dictate the development future of such a unique place with such a lot at stake. We hope local councillors and Spring Street politicians are listening to Cr Whelan's timely warning.
Greg Johnson
What Councillor Whelan and, unfortunately, several of his fellow Councillors, have got wrong, is that the current Planning Scheme is what you have to work with.
To be using Strategic Plans or wish lists of the future to guide your planning decisions now is wrong and your planning staff should be telling you so.
To be planning an overlay which will affect privately owned land with out informing or consulting with the owner of the land is extremely arrogant.
To refuse the application for a Rehab Centre in the Warley Hospital because you would like to see it turn into a seven story block of flats even though that is not a permitted use now, is breath taking!
Still believe in Santa?
Ruth Partridge
Thanks Ruth. Yes I do believe in Santa but he didn't come to me - he came to the developers that left the legacy issues of estates on Phillip Island with no made roads or drainage, that have been able to develop small blocks with not trees and even less character. That put an industrial estate surrounded by housing and directs heavy vehicles through settled areas and along roads of wonderful conservation value such as Coghlan Road. Yes well done to the Planning Scheme and those who travel with her. We have commenced the process to change it by the way and include our wish list (I mean strategies) in it. And yes your version of arrogance is actually spelt 'leadership' in my dictionary.
Michael Whelan
Totally agree with Cr. Whelan's sentiments. Phillip Island is unique and equal to many other places of significant natural beauty. A "one size fits all" planning scheme will not work for Phillip Island or Bass Coast.
Carmen Bush
I totally agree you cannot replace what is lost. A prime example of this is the "Gold Coast"
Once a pleasant holiday destination visited for its natural beauty and relaxed atmosphere, over development has turned this area into a mini las Vegas with beautiful beaches and natural attractions being overlooked by high rise development and glitzy night life.
This must not be the destination for Phillip Island where the most significant and unique values of our Island and environs are based on the appreciation of nature, rural scenes and clean beaches.
State Government give lip service to supporting and retaining our unique environment with one size fits all planning schemes overriding the potential advantages that are unique to this area.
Continuous growth of the residential area must be avoided, and I applaud the Councilors who have the conviction to address this problem
Ian Samuel
I am so pleased that Councillor Whelan has it so right about Phillip Island.Our special environment is our future and thankfully he will stand to protect that before all is lost.
Vicki Breen
I’m interested in your point about encouraging medium density housing in Cowes, rather than the grotesque suburban development we’re seeing now, of big houses on small blocks.
In European cities like Copenhagen and Amsterdam, most people live in well-designed four- or five-storey apartment blocks with balconies and common gardens and public spaces. They are close to shops and public transport. Few people have cars. Bikes are the preferred mode of transport.
With higher density, all sorts of things become possible – better public transport, café culture, cinemas, bars, tennis courts, swimming pools, a year-round economy.
For closer inspiration on how Cowes might evolve into a vibrant small town, perhaps we could look to Brunswick where two medium-rise apartment blocks, the Commons and Nightingale, by Breathe Architecture (http://www.breathe.com.au/) are setting a new standard for sustainable, thoughtful, affordable design.
Of course these places are not for everyone; some people want their own house on their own block. But I can see a growing cohort of ageing baby boomers who would be quite happy to swap the quarter acre and house for a smart, sustainable apartment in a vibrant small town on an island of natural wonders.
But how does Bass Coast Council encourage, or perhaps even mandate, better urban development?
Catherine Watson
Thanks Catherine, I agree we can learn a lot from overseas cities that have a history before the motor vehicle. I attended a briefing on the Nightingale project - am excellent project wouldn't it be great to see something like that in Cowes.
Michael Whelan
There is one thing you need and another you have, to achieve these protections. You need a Localised Planning Statement embedded in the planning scheme. These tell the government the characteristics you desire for an area. There are a few in the state planning scheme at present, e.g. Mornington and Ballarine Peninsulas, which are municipality wide. They can be used more specifically to a part of a municipality, like the Island, which then allows stronger controls as we already have the second thing needed - the mainland, and in particular Wonthaggi, which can provide the bulk of the 15 year land supply demanded by government for the greater municipality. This assures Wonthaggi's future as a regional centre, and flowing from that, more jobs for the whole municipality.
Neil Rankine
Bandicoot island
December 1, 2017
Great to read of a successful return of one of natures beautiful creatures and in our district too.
Daryl Hook
I commend the Nature Parks. The success of the release is wonderful, at both Churchill Island and the Summerlands Peninsula.
Jan Fleming
Full and plenty
December 1, 2017
Thank you for a most interesting story, Carolyn. We try to emulate the forebearers you describe. As well as providing fresh and home made produce, subsistence farming lightens the footprint on our earth.
Felicia Di Stefano
I am printing out this story for my 2 Italian friends, I am sure they would be delighted to read it as much as me and my Italian partner. Thank you Carolyn.
Natasha Williams
Wet wonderland
December 1, 2017
Wonthaggi is lucky to have reserves that can be returned to a natural wonderland ,lucky to have people like Terri too.
Daryl Hook
Wonderful Terri.I hope you included some of this in an objection re the proposed 93 lot subdivision adjoining the Rifle Range wetland. The last thing the wetland needs is the storm water from a huge subdivision pouring into the Rifle Range.
Yvonne McRae
Great description Terry, thank goodness we have wonderful people like you, Nola, Lorraine, Dinah and others.
Jan Fleming
Thanks again to Terri Allen for a finely detailed and beautifully succinct picture of the wonder of Wonthaggi's wetlands.And, of course, to the Post for bringing this important story to us.
Linda Gordon
Out of the shadows
November 18, 2017
Wednesday 15th November, 2017
I woke up and my first thought was, today’s the day
I’d run out of grog and had to dash to Foodworks for my spelt bread
I made it back in time and turned on the telly at about a quarter to 10
I inhaled, felt tense, then forced myself to relax
I found the theatre of the announcement amusing
The moment soon arrived
I held my breath
The announcement
I shed a tear
O fabjous day! *
* Thanks to Lewis Carroll’s Jabberwocky
69 year old gay woman, Wonthaggi (I’m withholding my name because the event was not about me, it was about all 69 year old gay women.)
Our own families sometimes provide our worst experiences of homophobia. For those of us unlucky enough to have such families, the hurt can be so deep that it is difficult to articulate it – especially in a way that others can understand. Family bonds, both positive and negative, run so deep.
Given this, and that we live in a heteronormative society, I think marriage equality offers important legal and emotional support for gay people. We will not just be “almost" equal in law but actually equal. (At least we will be equal when it comes to matters of wills, superannuation, not having to “prove” our relationships, and the like, even if our religious MPs insist on inserting certain ridiculous exemptions from anti-discrimination when it comes to gay people.)
Name withheld for family reasons
On Wednesday morning, I was as grumpy as Tony Abbott. Weren’t there more important matters? People kept reminding me it wasn’t about weddings, or even wedding cakes, it was about equality.
Turnbull hailed it as “a vote for fairness” and democracy at its best. I don’t care much for this sort of democracy. Sixty per cent for, 40 against. Therefore same-sex marriage is good. Ten years ago it would have been 40 for and 60 against. Same-sex marriage would have been bad. By definition, the people are always right in a democracy.
I wasn’t even going to vote – I thought a pox on both your houses – but my straight friends were so enthusiastic and idealistic I felt I had to support them by returning my form.
It’s been a long road to equality, much longer than the past three months of political nonsense. It has finally happened because of people like Wayne and Keith and Phyllis and Francesca and all those who were brave enough to be themselves despite society’s disapproval.
Catherine Watson
Fantastic news for everyone.
We certainly voted yes.
Jan Fleming and John Adam.
I woke up on Wednesday morning hoping for the best and ready for the worst. As a gay retired statistician I had been tracking the polls on Excel and was quietly confident and had a big figure "7 million" in mind which when announced I knew we had won. I punched the air and said "YES!!!" and unexpectedly cried. It took a few seconds more I guess for that figure to be put in percentage terms of 61.5% for the rest of the LGBTIQ community to realise we had won.
Sadly a lovely older Christian lady in my small community and I haven't spoken during this divisive debate. I am sure in her own way she is as devastated by the result as I would have been if it had gone the other way.
What to do? Go on being the ordinary and great neighbours we have always been. Not the flashy Mardi Gras crowd or loud activists, who nonetheless all have their place. Prove to them that this is not the Gaypocalypse they feared. Respect the differences and get on with our ordinary (and just a tiny bit fabulous) lives.
James
What I find saddest is that 40% still voted No - and the first two comments have their names withheld.
And for what? A bit of paper. Matt and I married after 15 years together a couple of years ago because we had to have that piece of paper in order to volunteer overseas. So important it was that we forgot to tell people of the news in our New Year's note to family and friends on the preceding year's events.
Having said that it is important to some people and so - why have so many thought (and sought through their vote) to deny this joy to others?
Liane Arno
Hello Liane, I didn't withhold my name for any reason other than I wanted other 69 year old women to feel as though I was speaking on their behalf. They could own my comment as well. It's not the piece of paper that's important, it's the sense of belonging. There are probably many gay people who will choose not to marry but it's nice to know that soon they can make that choice.
Pamela Jacka
Across the country 133 electorates said YES and 17 electorates said NO. Of the 17 electorates that said NO most were in Western Sydney. A lot of the people in Western Sydney are overseas born and very conservative. And there is nothing wrong with this.
Just think about the fact that 89% of the electorates across Australia said YES and be very proud of ourselves for recognising that we are all equal.
F W Schooneveldt
Australia has Voted. So move on.
Get over it.
Remember those special seven letters.
RESPECT
Pamela Gill JP
I, like our editor was not going to vote. Do not know if this makes sense but it is a fantasy of mine that when the powers that be in the AFL put up the Grand Final prices to a high that excludes many I have this dream that not a soul will turn up at the MCG in protest.Just think of that. An empty stadium echoing with protest. That is how I felt about the vote. Why oh why do we have to take a vote on such an injustice?
Why did I change my mind? An old and dear friend visited recently and made it clear he would vote NO. So I had to negate his vote. He claimed homosexuality was due to parental upbringing. So now I am wondering when the rest of my kids will cross over to the rainbow side of the street to join one of my four children. (Laptop hasn't been very straight these past few days hence my late comment. Sorry.)
Bob Middleton
Pun intended, Bob? :o)
Pamela Jacka
Broadbent: it’s still no
November 16, 2017
Russell, Have you not heard that democracy is of the people, for the people, by the people.
Your people have voted.
Your people have said YES.
Your duty as their representative is to vote YES.
If you don't get that message - resign.
Ray McNamara
Russell Broadbent hasn't heard any of the above, especially the YES, and more unfortunately, the RESIGN. He seems to forget that we pay his wages to represent us. Why would he bother responding to Bass Coast Post? He doesn't bother to respond to his constituency about anything. And as for responding to the ABS survey results ... Go on Russell, have a 'conscience vote' based on your own personal opinion and values. That's far more important than betrayal of the electorate's opinion and wishes. A NO vote is a vote for homophobia and divisiveness. And always remember, the heterosexual marriage between a man and a woman is always the marriage that produces the gay, lesbian & transgender offspring.
Julie Tyrrell
Whoa, whoa Julie, you have to understand that, although you think that gay marriage is OK, other people have the right to disagree without being labelled homophobic or divisive.
It is possible to hold a view that accepts homosexual relationships as a loving and joyous part of our society, and also consider marriage to be the union of a man and a woman.
Ruth Partridge
exactly - please leave now and close that door behind you … When the majority of your electorate speaks you should have listened
Rosemary
Russell, I voted yes because I believe in equality.
I understand that you have a conscience vote on the SSM Bill and are not restricted to vote along party lines or how your electorate voted. I note that a number of NSW elected members have said they will support the bill even though the majority of their constituents voted no.
We need to respect a person’s right for a conscience vote because this is democracy.
Frank W Schooneveldt
As a voter in this electorate, I would like my YES preferences to be reflected along with the majority of voters in the region. I would like any member of this community to have equal rights or better to my own as a old and therefore almost invisible member of our community.
Fran Carroll
"Yes" or "No" not "MAYBE, EH? Can't decide?" What message would abstention send in a conscience vote? Wow.
Some party. Two members who represent different chunks of Bass Coast with opposing responses to similar data, cancel each other out.
$120 million for a void. This is a void:( ). This one's free.
Some other party: Next time rainbow revelry reigns in Cape P extend the invitation, please. People in Flinders have more to celebrate, apparently.
Geoff Ellis
Geoff, Your use of the English language is beyond me. Please write in simple ways that we can all understand. You need to respect a conscience vote and what that means in a democratic society.
Frank W Schooneveldt
Frank - Thanks for the instruction but I am used to writing to a word limit - I completely respect a conscience vote - every time I raise my hand at a council meeting it's a conscience vote. I was democratically elected.
Comment decoded - Cape Paterson residents live in McMillan and their representative is going to vote No or abstain which is essentially saying no but not owning it.
By accident I live in Flinders and my federal rep is going to vote YES so I have more to celebrate than if I lived in Cape Paterson as I voted YES.
If the vote was going to be based on the member's conscience why did they spend $120 mill to ask us what we thought only to ignore it? The connotative definition of a conscience vote in this context is equivalent to a 'free' vote ie not guided by party lines, rather than guided by their conscience. It's the collective conscience of the electorate that informs a conscience vote, not the bias of an individual.
The federal government did the same thing with the Uluru statement so at least they are consistently ignoring OUR views.
Geoffrey Ellis
Bye bye Russell
Sandra Guy
Russell, most of the dinosaurs became extinct 120 million years ago........
Mark Robertson
I think the YES is.....Russell... RESIGN if you cannot agree with the people who elected you.
Fran Carroll
Geoff, The Australian electorate voted Yes in 133 electorates and no in 17 electorates. The majority of the No electorates are in NSW.
This is one of the most strongest endorsements of the importance of people’s equality there can be and sends a clear message to politicians in Canberra to pass the SSM Bill and quickly. I have no doubt the the bill will pass regardless of how Russell Broadbent votes.
I think Russell Broadbent as already said he will not be contesting the next election which is a good thing. This is an an opportunity to bring in some young progressive thinkers into the electorate.
Frank W Schooneveldt
Frank, I totally agree with your first points though I haven't heard about Mr Broadbent's plans to contest, or not contest. Who ever stands I hope they check their compliance with our constitution. Hopefully Mr Broadbent will be the last member for McMillan! He was the last member for Corinella but that didn't deter him.........
Geoff Ellis
This is where conscience votes get tricky. Should they represent the MP's own views or the views of the majority of the electorate? The answer probably depends on whether they vote according to our own views.
But we can't have it both ways. After all, in 2006 many of us applauded Russell Broadbent when he crossed the floor to vote against his own party’s immigration policy, which involved mandatory processing of asylum seekers off-shore. Only a minority of voters in his electorate would have supported his action then, but he voted according to his conscience.
So while I don't agree with Mr Broadbent's view on marriage equality, I do agree that he should vote according to his own conscience, not ours.
Catherine Watson
There's been some discussion about this in my little neck of the woods, and I've come the conclusion that the vote in Parliament should be as per the MP's electorate. Conscience votes were for the survey.
An acquaintance of mine said that Mr Broadbent should vote as electorate voted but didn't apply the same "logic" to Mr Jason Clare who has also decided to vote against his electorate. The only difference is that Mr Clare is going to vote Yes whereas his electorate of Blaxland voted No. It's a funny world, isn't it?
Pamela Jacka
The whole saga of EQUALITY has been handled poorly by our Parliament - this is far from over but lets face it they love our taxes at work
Rosemary
Let's not forget that freedoms include freedom of conscience. Russell Broadbent is entitled to his own freedoms. He has served this community well over many years and deserves respect just like every voter who voted No and every voter who voted Yes. The people who cannot understand that are displaying a low level of intelligence.
Mohan de Run
Let's not forget that this was but a survey, not a warrant and sans obligation.
Geoff Ellis
ALP selects ex-mayor
November 17, 2017
Jordan,
Congratulations on your pre- selection. I have always respected your views even when we are poles apart.
Cheers and good luck.
Frank W Schooneveldt
Wonderful news
Neri
Congratulations Jordan. I remember your tireless and important work for the Bass Coast Council. I support you in every way. Best of luck.
Felicia Di Stefano
Wonderful news. May your path lead to success. We need people like you to help light up the way. You have my support. Go for it.
Bob Middleton
As an ALP member for 45 years, I join with so others congratulating Jordan Crugnale on her candidature for the ALP for the seat of Bass. Jordan is the candidate that will inspire people to vote Labor.
I stood for a seat that had been held historically by the liberals and won it for Labor for the first time. Seats change all the time.
Jordan has enormous energy, strength, organising abilities and compassion, and living in the electorate.
Having been a local councillor will have expert and in depth knowledge concerning the local area.
The community will have a quality ALP candidate to fight the State election next year, and hopefully an ALP MP in the Andrews Government to represent the needs of the bass community.
Kay Setches
Good on you Jordan - I will help in anyway I can with your campaign to win Bass for the ALP.
Susan Anderson
Go Jordan.!🐸
Daryl Hook
Warley drug clinic rejected
November 16, 2017
I attended the Council Meeting on Wednesday evening and was disappointed Cr Fullarton did not have the numbers to get approval for this much needed Medical Facility in Cowes. Addiction issues unfortunately exist in most communities and Phillip Island is no exception . I believe the treatment that is to be provided in the Rehab Centre would give support to users and their families and show that we are a caring community.
Anne Davie
Our Council have a "wish" that the old Warley Hospital site will be redeveloped into an high density residential building and are planning an overlay to facilitate this. That will not make it happen how ever hard you wish.
It is privately owned and has been mostly vacant for the past 12 years. At last there is a potential tenant who would refurbish it, put it to good use, provide employment for a range of skills, return on investment for the owners and our Council says "NO".
We will all thank you so very much as our dear old hospital, given to our community by a man with vision, slowly slides into dereliction and becomes an eyesore waiting, maybe for decades, for someone will very deep pockets to fulfill a planning "wish". What hogwash.
Having denied the owners of Warley hospital the chance to get a return on their investment, I suggest that the Council should not be charging rates!!
Ruth Partridge
Can't believe Council has rejected and not welcomed such a vital facility that perfectly fit the abandoned shell. On a locally significant site dedicated to community purpose (c. 1923) this renewal would have inherited the values of a long term vision that provided for community before tourism was a word. And for corrective vision, note the Cowes Activity Centre Plan has been edited already.
Nicola Tragear
This would have been one great step forward for the community, We have a Huge lack of support of rehabilitation programs seems the people on Council out of touch you are supposed to represent the community take your horse blinkers off we are here to help not discriminate
Duke
Why I won’t watch the Oils
November 18, 2017
That heckler was right, when they played at the Island years ago with Painters and Dockers, the Oils were way too serious. The Dockers blew them off the stage!
Jeff Sim
Thanks, John, for such an articulate and moving article. I am filled with rage whenever I see Peter Garrett in the news, particularly in recent times as he has the gall to get back on stage and assume his old persona (it seems to me). Such utter hypocrisy and I'm astounded that, for the most part, it seems no one calls him out on it. It truly is dispiriting.
Sue Saliba
Absolutely so true.
I too was inspired in the late 80s.
I had the oils tattooed on my back and thought Peter stood for so much more.
Only to find the desal plant, the home insulation scheme and even mining up north.
It’s a shame he sold out and wants to go back
Andrew
Well said John - Garrett and Burke, along with the Victorian Labour experts ,denied the existence of our special winter visitors for years, despite the heroic efforts of caring locals - even the stunning photos of Geaff Glare and Lisa Schonberg failed to convince them. The Winter Whale Watch program which was initiated by Watershed eventually spawned the Bass Coast Whale Trail signs along our coast - validating our concerns. I have tried to have the Watershed logo included on the signs, in recognition of the hundreds of people who contributed, but it has been decided that it is not appropriate. Even a direction from council is not enough. Last week, the Sentinel times proclaimed that Harriet Shing is throwing money into the Island Whale Festival -the very state government who dismissed our valid concerns are now promoting the Bass Coast whales.!!! I am both proud and befuddled at the entire process -proud that our efforts are recognised, and befuddled that all the so-called experts got it so wrong. Our question was simple - if the voluminous desal EES could not see something as big as a whale, then what else had been overlooked? That question still stands, given the complete lack of evidence surrounding the long-term environmental impact s during operation of the Great White Elephant. The desal protests displayed the caring nature and incredible expertise of our residents, and I am incredibly proud of all who stood up to the big and nasty bullies.
Mark Robertson . President. Watershed Victoria
Reminds me of when the GFC hit and all the ministers had to come up with plans on what to do to invigorate the economy. Peter Garrett's idea was to insulate every house in Australia. We know how that turned out and Kevin Rudd took the hit for it even though it was his minister Peter Garrett's idea and Peter Garrett had information from New Zealand on what not to do but still did it and people died as a consequence of his inaction
David Norton
Spot on John this is my home this is my sea Don't paint it with the future, of factories Peter Garrett's legacy
Duke
View from the chamber
November 4, 2017
Along with this increase in population goes a responsibility, particularly on the part of our Council, to protect our natural environment.
On Phillip Island, the human population increases and the native birds and animals along with the indigenous vegetation suffers dramatically. A new resident moves in and up go the huge suburban paling fences, out comes the chainsaw and yet another gum tree (or two or three) is coming down. There is less and less habitat every day as a result of the wonderful (to some) local property boom.
Council should hang its head in shame at the state of the island's northern foreshore - what should be indigenous coastal vegetation (and a rich source of habitat) is a mass of weeds and private (illegal) tracks as well as lawns that adjacent land holders have created in their (illegal) appropriation of public land. Before putting out the welcome mat to more people, Bass Coast Shire needs to look after the natural environment it has and put in place proper procedures to make sure that all residents, visitors and potential new home owners understand their responsibilities to the local natural environment.
Sue Saliba
Brett, I fully support your comments and glad to read that the Bass Coast Shire finances are in better shap than once thought.
Frank W Schooneveldt
Great article Brett. But I totally endorse comments made by Sue Saliba regarding residents, potential new owners, visitors etc. understanding their responsibilities related to protecting our wonderful natural environment.
Also, I should add that many areas of Bass Coast Shire are lacking the proper infrastructure and community services to cope with this influx of people coming to our wonderful region. I Do realize some of these are issues related to State Government and Federal Government responsibilities.
Being a tourist or visitor or holiday home owner is totally different to living here permanently where we experience what I call the 'chain saw massacres.' Trees are destroyed and blocks of land are sub-divided. Then more trees are destroyed and this has a major impact on the native birds, animals and indigenous vegetation.
We welcome people to come here and live in this beautiful region and share its delights. BUT there is always a price tag. The word is RESPONSIBILITY and respect for conservation of our environment.
We don't want to become another inner Melbourne Suburban district.
Phyllis Papps
Brett good article, thanks for the acknowledgement, all the best moving forward.
Bradley Drew.
Cr. Brett, whilst you are dealing with the queues of eager developers, could you please let them know of Wonthaggis other secret - that we already have a heritage and culture which runs far deeper than our long-closed coal mines. Wonthaggi is a unique place- the town with a heart, the town which refused to die. Our fantastic (but overstretched) facilities were achieved by generations of community-minded residents, and will need thoughtful expansion plans to cope with the seething masses. The profit-seeking developers need to understand that our community is not some outer-suburban paddock, ripe for exploitation. I would be horrified to see our town sacrificed to the gods of suburban sprawl and big brands - even to "protect" the rest of our shire. The recent development approval for the Miners Rest site provides little comfort to me. A prominent, welcoming site for our many new visitors, and the best that the developers can come up with is the unholy trinity of booze, fuel and junk food.....Wonthaggi should be playing to our strengths - quirky businesses offering our legendary service, and a sense of hidden delights, both natural and anthropomorphic and, dare I say it, a growing sense of sophistication. I fear that our town will, instead evolve into yet another sad suburban wasteland. Is this really what we want to attract? Come on council and business leaders, think big and think different, we only get one shot at this!
Mark Robertson
If we are not careful, and by we I mean all of us and future councils, the answer to Brett's question "will we lose our character"[s a resounding YES. Developers pushing for smaller and smaller allotments and council's planning on building envelopes and building materials show a lack of awareness as to Wonthaggi's character.
A case in point is the recently developed Heartlands estate. Such an opportunity lost on a lovely site. It looks like the cramped outskirts of Cranbourne. Why do we insist on brick as the dominant building material in our town? Go see Heartlands, walk along Poplar and Outlook Drive in North Wonthaggi and then stroll through the old parts of South Wonthaggi and tell me which has the most character. All credit to Brett ,especially for his acknowledgement of the work of the previous council and his obvious love of our town. But I am firmly with Sue and Phyllis and Mark Robertson on this one.
Bob Middleton
Brett, it takes a wise person to be able to stand back and acknowledge the successes and understand the challenges of one's predecessors. The previous council's foresight ensured a plan was put in place for the future success of the entire shire. I am pleased the current council are working to the plan and looking to the future of the shire and our residents. Maintaining balanced, continued growth is the next hurdle for you and your team. Yes, please don't forget our heritage and natural assets, but in parallel please don't let us miss out on opportunities to grow and develop either ... We can have both. And after all, we didn't all buy here to retire ...
Rob Easton
Changing trains
November 4, 2017
Thank you Mark for sharing your beautiful and moving story with us folks in Wonthaggi. Congratulations on finishing your lovely, sustainable house. I'm sure you will prosper in such a kind, tolerant atmosphere as you are experiencing in Japan. Good luck with future train rides in life.
Hilary Stuchbery
Over this past cruel winter, I watched with awe as Mark finished his house. Sakura Studio has been designed with thoughtfulness and built with loving craftsmanship. It is a small space of beautiful proportions that gives a sense of peace to all who enter.
It's also an antidote to the big, dumb, brick veneer barns going up in their hundreds on new estates all around Bass Coast. If only our shire could buck the suburban trend with more unique places like this.
Catherine Watson
What a lovely story about love and kindness and a beautiful house bulit with sensitivity !
Marilyn Shaw
Impossible to pass by this studio house and not have your interest and curiosity aroused, a tribute to it's eye catching design. Thank you for showing us inside Mark and for sharing with us part of your adventurious life. May we read more in the Post as time goes by..
Bob Middleton
What an wonderful inspiring story, by and equally wonderful and inspiring human being.
Sammi Colenso-Wallace
Great read Mark. All the best in Japan. Hope you get a few waves over there
Michelle Fincher
Awesome read Teddy ~ all the best for the next stage of your journey. Kaz x
Karen Morse
Beautiful words Ted :)
Well done mate, I’m massively proud of you. Congratulations for getting off that train to destruction. Please don’t ever step back on it.
Say a big Gday to Toko and Sakura for me.
Paul Mannix
Lovely Story, is this Studio available for rent/short stay and through whom?
Glenda Fraser
Strength does not come from what you can do. It comes when you take challenging moments in your stride & determined not to give up. When you go through hardship & decides not to surrender that is strength.
You my brother have buckets full of strength xxx
Sandy
Mark you are an inspiration. I often think of our adventures at the island and would love to recreate them with my family. You should be so very proud of your achievements. xx
Barb McConnell
Euthanasia a step too far
November 4, 2017
Your arrogance in taking this stance appals me. I ask you to nurse your mother for 6 months while she dies of colon cancer and watch the agony she had to endure, and then tell me, that the Voluntary Assisted Dying Bill isn't a good thing. Voting no to this bill is tantamount to endorsing state approved torture. At the very least, you could abstain from voting. Please show some compassion !!!
Libby Lambert
My cousin in Holland was diagnosed with cancer that had riddled her body and was given two years to live. She was in extreme pain and suffering that can come with an incurable disease so she saw two doctors to obtain permission so that she could die at the time of her choosing. Permission was granted and she had the comfort of knowing when the time the pain become unbearable she was able to end it.
Elizabeth Kluber Ross in her book on death and dying said that it is a privilege to know when you are going to die and so it was for my cousin.
She could say her goodbyes to friends and family on her terms.
One morning she woke up and said to her partner that today was a good day to die. She gathered her family together said her goodbyes and died very peacefully.
Her partner said it was a beautiful death.
A right to die on our own terms with the right safeguards in place like the Dutch the proposed Victorian legislation is timely. Please support the bill.
Frank W Schooneveldt
I understand Mr Mulino is entitled to his view, but also shouldn't he be reprsenting the views of the majority of his voters. I cared for my 90 year old mother so she cou,d stay in her own home. At her insistence I continued working my job as she was a fiercly indpendant woman. I came home from work to find she had unsuccessfully tried to take her own life by taking an overdose ofpills and cutting her wrists. A sight I will never forget. My mother passed away 13 months later and that was no where near as sad as the event 13 months prior and watching her endure the time betwen these events. Where is his compassion for others?
N
I watched my mother in law die. This is what I believe she experienced,
"I just want to die. I don’t say this out of melancholy. I have had a good life. I have travelled the world. Had more wonderful experiences than most and have had not only a caring marriage but many treasured friendships and associations. My life has been rich. But now, I am weary. I have lived many long years and tonight I long for rest.
A short while ago I fell. Neither I, nor my doctor, is sure whether my hip broke and I fell, or I fell and broke my hip. Bones are brittle at my age. I now wonder why I agreed to have a hip replacement but it was always on the stipulation that I would not be resuscitated if I died during surgery. Those wishes were ignored. I wonder whether I should have had the words, “Do not resuscitate”, on my now bony chest to make sure that the well-meaning surgeons understood – but I did not. I died on the operating table and should have stayed that way. We all know I have now only a short time left.
And so tonight I live in pain. I lie in a hospital bed where my family visit to comfort me. A physio therapist comes to try and get me to walk on my new hip but all I feel is pain. I try to speak to my family but my words do not come out as I want them to. I see them trying to understand what I am saying – but I can’t form the words. The nurse grabs what she can of my shrunken belly to drive a needle into the flesh to give me an injection to prevent me from getting deep vein thrombosis. The pain radiates through my body and almost makes me vomit. Why must I endure this?
If I was able I would be able to take my own life. I could haul a rope from the rafters, or stick a hose in the exhaust from my car, or take the shotgun from its rack in the gun safe. But I am too feeble to do this. Too feeble to take the steps that I took in caring for my own pets when they were close to death and in pain.
I read the well-meaning words of politicians who do not wish me to die as their faces shine with health and optimism from the pages of the Bass Coast Post. Tonight I long for rest.
Liane Arno
Very, very sadly this is such a common story. These people deserve better and there is an opportunity to take the first step in this process. Also, sadly, we have to rely on the goodwill of politicians as the initial starter. I feel your pain Liane.
N Smith
MP: 90% against assisted dying
November 4, 2017
Here's number 201 for the 'yes' vote to the Voluntary Assisted Dying Bill. I ask you to nurse your mother until she dies of colon cancer and watch the agony she had to endure, and then you tell me, that the Voluntary Assisted Dying Bill isn't a good thing. Frankly I don't recollect you being voted in so you could play God with other people’s lives ? Voting no to this bill is tantamount to endorsing state approved torture. At the very least, you could abstain from voting. Please show some compassion !!!
Libby Lambert
Thank you for your fair comment on this legislation. Our opinions are always coloured by our own experiences. My own opinion as a retired Palliative Care nurse is that Paliative care should be available to everyone and offered as the first option as fear is one of the biggest obstacles people face when confronted with the fact that death is will be the consequence of their diagnosis. All options regarding treatment and palliation should be expalined at the outset.
One of the biggest areas of concern for me is the Aged Care sector where very vulnerable people are often left with far than adequate care in their final days.
If this legislation is place fron and centre then funding for adequate and increased Palliative care services may not eventuate for the majority that you talk about and that would be a tragedy.
Maggie L
Count me in as #202 for YES to VAD.
I agree - "The autonomy of the individual must be measured against the irretrievable alteration of society." - surely the measuring scales validate YES.
Geoff Ellis
And here is number 203 to YES. Both my parents are still alivee. Father at 93 and mother at 91. Father will never want to die, Mother has benn wanting to go for a number of year. She does not fit the category for assisted dying. She does not have an incurable illness except old age, she is not in pain. But she cannot walk and cannot see any purpose to life. She is simply tired of living. We have told her she has a purpose, it is just different to what it used to be. She is our matriarch. She cannot accept this. Yes her memory is going but she is still has the cognitive ability to make her choice. So much so, she is trying to starve herself to death. What do I do - force feed her? I believe every persons natural inclination is to live. So when a choice like this is made, it is genuine and should be respected.
Sandra M
Sandra, what a dreadful situation for all of you. My mother made me promise to do away with her if she ever had to go into a nursing home. There are worse things than death; there is such a thing as a living death, when there is no hope of improvement, only endurance.
The current legislation isn't going to do much for people in your mother's situation but at least it's a start.
One day I hope we will all have the right to say "It's been lovely but I want to go now."
In the meantime, my thoughts are with you.
Catherine Watson
Coming from a farming background, I was brought up with the ethic of not letting animals suffer. In fact, it is illegal to do so. Mercifully dispatching a suffering animal was part of life. However, by law, we must let our loved ones suffer unnecessarily at life's end as we cannot assist people to ease their passing.
Thankfully, many in the medical profession share the old farmers ethics and help patients end their life with dignity. It is estimated that 30% of deaths in hospitals are facilitated by the medical profession. I hope when my time comes, I will have a compassionate and caring doctor to help me on my way rather than let me suffer.
For those that worry about the implications of VAD, let's make a deal: I won't interfere with the way you depart this world and you leave me alone to make my own decisions about how I shed my mortal coil.
Peter
Melinda, The Netherlands legalised voluntary euthanasia in 2001.
I know from first hand experience that the legislation works in helping people die with peace, dignity and with a lot less pain and suffering. In a humane society we need to stop pain and suffering and respect the right of people to choose to die at a time of their choice.
I urge you to support the bill.
F W Schooneveldt
The town that vanished
November 4, 2017
A fascinating look at early European history in the Queensferry area, Libby. Thank you.
Meryl Tobin
Great article please have more of them on a regular basis
Warren
Beaches, bays and one fatal shot
November 4, 2017
A lovely story, Linda, of a place of interesting natural and human history. I share your concern about the potential disaster if one of those tankers runs aground. Coincidentally, I was reading the log of the Lady Nelson today,at the Wonthaggi Historical Society. It reminded me of the trip our family made on her replica a few years ago during an anniversary tour. We sailed between Rhyll and Cowes, and my young son was able to take the helm. Quite a contrast to the high-speed craft which terrorise the western entrance today!
m
What a tour de force embracing the history, geography and wildlife of your beloved island.So many things we casual visitors would not know or observe. Thank you Linda for an informative and beautifully written article.
Bob Middleton
November 11, 2017
Following recent article and letters on your website (Island caravan park knocked back, September 22, 2017), great to see the Foreshore Committee have acted and the only Public Toilet Block in San Remo is having a major makeover.
In addition the rock wall path has also had some remedial work to make it easier to walk on.
Thank you to the Foreshore Committee for acting to improve the facilities in San Remo which are important assets for both visitors and locals before the busiest part of the tourist season.
For anybody driving past or into San Remo knows only too well its vital that the infrastructure is maintained by all the responsible authority's year round which clearly hasn't been the situation over the last several years.
It doesn't make any sense that we have at least 4 different areas of government (State & Local) that controls different parts of the town, and not much cooperation seems to take between any of them!
Chris Day, San Remo
New Wonthaggi college by 2019
October 27, 2017
WOW! Congrats to all the people who worked hard to make their voices heard. What a great announcement!
Carmen Bush
Great reporting and great timing. Wonderful news.Thanks BCP and thanks vicgov..
Bob Middleton
Hooray how absolutely wonderful! Great reporting, great news and a great future ahead for Wonthaggi...much deserved.
Ursula Theinert
So happy to hear this news.
Jacqui Paulson
One more step towards a well supplied and rounded community. Well done all concerned. Thanks for the news BCP.
Hilary Stuchbery
Great reporting, Catherine. Thank goodness we have at State level, a Labor Government that listens to its constituents.We are very lucky to have Harriet Shing as our Upper House member.
Ruth and Peter Glare
Fantastic News! there have been many promises over the years with many people working very hard to get to this point. Educating is the backbone to better opportunities. Thank you to the State Government for listening.
Clare Le Serve
Amazing news! Credit to all those involved with the funding bid. Many individuals within the community spent countless unpaid hours lobbying stakeholders and government to support this endeavour. Let's not forget the indoor stadium funding announcement as well. Amazing effort. Well done to all.
James Archibald
The 'countless hours' is what it takes for the MPs to hear the message relating to the needs of a community! Well done to those who did the hard yards so well and for so long. The kids of tomorrow will benefit from what sounds like a facility providing a wide range of learning options for our diverse region.
Sue Packham
Ecstatic news. Will make a great town even better. Looking to the future is what a town needs to flourish. Congrats to Bass Coast Post for giving us this news.
N Smith
What an absolute delight to open the Bass Coast Post and read such very good news! Thank you, Catherine for getting this out so promptly. It’s fantastic - especially the fact that Daniel Andrews came down to Wonthaggi himself - and that everything is actually planned to begin so soon. Excellent!
Jane Westworth
Well done team Bass Coast! Congratulations to a strong, vocal community that passionately showed the State Government what matters.
Well done Daniel Andrews for listening and thank you Harriet Shing - you represent an enormous community and you do it with compassion and dedication.
We should also acknowledge the huge effort of Mayor Rothfield and previous Mayors Le Serve, Rankine and Crugnale who set the stage for this by getting those ministers down here last year.
And the tireless BCSC staff and officers - they deserve a bloody great pat on the back.
Geoff Ellis
Amidst the headlong rush to congratulate all the paid participants from the state government and Bass Coast Shire, I would like to acknowledge the years of effort put in by the unpaid School Council members, particularly its president, Geoff Robertson. Well done my brother for displaying the care and tenacity which has made Wonthaggi a community which has always punched far above its weight.I am exceedingly proud of you.
Mark Robertson
Naming rights
October 20, 2017
I for one believe we should seize this opportunity to rectify the naming of this electorate. Angus McMillan was responsible for the deaths of hundreds of Aboriginal people in the 1840s through a number of mass-scale killings. This is not something we should be proud of. This shameful history of McMillan should not continue to be celebrated nor immortalized. We have the opportunity, in a small way, to right a wrong. Furthermore I believe it is only fair that the Aboriginal Communities of this region are given the opportunity to help rename our electorate.
Rinchen Wilson
I agree with Rinchen. The name needs to be changed and we should ask & be guided by the local Aboriginal community on a suitable name.
Rob Humphrys
Thanks Geoff Ellis for this. I support Rinchen's comments and the name change.
Samiro Douglas
Thank you, Geoff for once more standing up for justice in our community. Murderers must not be honoured. I too support Rinchen's ideas of asking the Aboriginal community of the area to name their land.
Felicia Di Stefano
I agree with Geoff raising this issue and welcome his research and usual balanced discussion; also his wise words that it should not become a debate.
There are many villains in the history of mankind whose misdeeds should be remembered, thus to help avoid future crimes. Let us not forget the crimes of Pol Pot, Mao, Oswald, Amin, Caligula, and even the big bad wolf. The list is very long.
Recent assaults upon the statues of Robert E. Lee and James Cook, destruction of the Bamiyan Buddahs and Palmyra in Syria, renaming Colston Hall in Bristol and Penny Lane in Liverpool all received attention from righteous citizens who did not agree with the actions of others. I both agree and disagree with their 'personal' reasoning, but I find it difficult to sanction the good guys attempts at rewriting history.
In the case of Angus McMillan, would it be better to condemn him for his misdeeds, alongside his achievements? I doubt his name would be chosen for the electorate today and fair enough, but judgement without evidential trial in a time of different morality will not correct the actions of the past either.
Is there a Gunai/Kurnai name available to replace him or is the tribal name a suitable suggestion? I am not so sure.
Peter Brown
Peter, Thanks for the kind words and I applaud your insightful broadening of the discussion. There's so much to consider and I guess every place and country has history, good and bad, to deal with and finding the right balance is the aim. You've given us more to think about, cheers.
Geoff Ellis
Thank you for your article. This morning after reading an add in The AGE I wrote to the Redistribution Committee for Victoria Australian Electorate Commission to suggest that the name of Angus McMillan must be removed from the electorate because it represents so much sadness for our indigenous brothers and sisters who live in the electorate as well as for so many non - indigenous people who also live in the electorate. We offered three suggested name changes for the electorate.viz,
"The Gunai /Kurni Electorate" after the original inhabitants of the area, "The Warrigal Electorate" named after a tribe of Gunai/Kurni people who resided in the electorate or "The West Gippsland Electorate"which covers the area where the electorate sits.
Frank W Schooneveldt
Well written and thank you. I support your suggestions and would be pleased to see the opportunity given to Gunnai/Kurnai elders to choose the new name.
Karen Sandon
Well said, Geoff, as always. I applaud your sentiments and those of Rinchen and others who have commented. The Bass Coast South Gippsland Reconciliation Group has a process in train of working with a fully representative group of Gippsland’s Aboriginal organisations towards their selecting a name. I would ask those of you who plan to make a submission to the AEC to respect the right of an authentic Aboriginal voice to speak on this matter. While it is tempting to offer names, if we want the AEC to hear our recommendation of an Aboriginal choice, it would be great if people would commend that process. It is likely that the Aboriginal choice of name will be submitted at a later stage in the AEC’s commenting process.
Marg Lynn
Marg, I think there is a genuine desire for a change of name of the McMillan electorate and the more submissions to the AEC for a change the better. What name is your group suggesting?
Frank W Schooneveldt
Thanks Frank, our preference is not to provide a name but to provide a rationale for the Aboriginal Community choosing a name. Aboriginal organisations have now settled on a process for getting together and working out a mutually acceptable name. I would hope that this process will be accepted and respected by the AEC and those of like mind who want to see an Aboriginal name chosen, as a small token of recompense for the hurt and pain inflicted by McMillan that has lasted to this day.
Marg Lynn
Let’s rename it Tarra Bulga after the National Park. Also acknowledges the role of Charlie Tarra, who provided invaluable assistance to Strzelecki.
Mike Cleeland
Marg, That’s all good but the AEC have procedures and processes as well and are calling for suggestions of a name change by Friday 17th November2017. It will be interesting to see what Aboriginal and other organisations and individuals recommend as a name change.
What we must ensure that at this redistribution a name change occurs.
Frank W Schooneveldt
Frank, I agree absolutely and I don't think we are contradicting each other. i believe there will be enough community pressure to impress on the AEC that there needs to be a change of name. That's part 1. Part 2 is then the naming and we believe that the AEC (and they have told us so) will accept later comment on the initial report, which is when the Aboriginal naming outcome can be presented.
Marg Lynn
Thank you again Geoff for raising this justice issue . Together we can use our voice through the Electoral Commission to right the terrible wrong, by the re-naming of the electorate of McMillan.
Anne Davie
Folks, As per the AEC indicative timetable, up to November 17 we can make suggestions. There will be later invitations for comments on suggestions, objections to suggestions, comments on objections and one or two public hearings - the final recommendation won't be made until the middle of 2018 at the earliest.
It's a long conversation and it’s great to hear so many voices.
Geoff Ellis
Thanks for the useful elaboration on the AEC process, Geoff.
Marg Lynn
Geoff, We received our acknowledgment of our suggestions for a change of name for the electorate from Ann Dougan Secretariat officer for the VIC Redistribution Secretariat AEC yesterday who outlined the process you mentioned.
We urge you all to write to the AEC requesting a change of name for the electorate. Go to www.aec.gov.au/vic-redistribution to submit your request.
Frank W Schooneveldt
October 26, 2017
Thank you Geoff & Peter Brown for a well delivered explanation of the reasoning & process involved when considering such an important change. Prior to reading both of your inputs to this discussion, all I had heard have been emotive arguments and divisive words which make a bull (Taurean) like me dig my heels in! The emotion has now been removed and I am now able to look at the proposition in a much more rational frame of mind. Discussions are so much easier (and more productive) than debates & arguments, aren't they?
Pamela Jacka
October 28, 2017
Might I suggest that a non-anthropoid name be chosen,. After all , we have treated most of our indigenous species with world-beating contempt. Perhaps Karmai -the traditional name for our spectacular and (literally) downtrodden giant earthworm could be considered. We put our species on a pedestal, but in the grand scheme of things we are but a fleeting and destructive footnote in our planetary history, no matter what our colour or heritage
Mark Robertson
In the lion’s den
October 21, 2017
Congratulations Pam !! What a fantastic year for you. Yes, it must have been a steep learning curve trying to get a diverse group of new Councillors together (and one Councillor who had been re-elected) all working towards the same ultimate goal. This is probably the most difficult challenge you had to face.
At the same time getting to understand the protocols, processes, policies and plans of BCSC meant it was very different for you and the other new Councillors, because you were no longer 'looking in from the outside.'
YET YOU DID IT, with your incredible communication skills, financial skills, leadership skills and an excellent understanding of the key issues related to the Bass Coast region and the community in general.
It is very hard to comprehend how you have managed everything in a 24 hour day - this involves incredible passion, energy, time and commitment. You should feel very proud of your achievements during the past 12 months.
Phyllis Papps
I agree with Phyllis, well done Mayor, Councillor Rothfield. I think you have done a splendid job!
Carmen Bush
Thank you for your willing work to enhance our community, Pamela.
Felicia Di Stefano
Congratulations to you and all your team for your professionalism and community support. A great first year towards a positive creative future.
Ursula Theinert
Phyllis, I agree with you 110%, particularly your last paragraph. FYI the next council meeting is Nov !5th.
Geoff Ellis
Thank you Madam Mayor! I’m so glad you highlighted the professionalism of the council.
Bernadette
October 26, 2017
“We are all travelling down the river, in different canoes – but in the same direction.
“We don’t always agree – but we do have respect for each other’s opinion.”
It can certainly be done, as you have all shown this year.
Natasha Crestani
This one’s for Ray
October 21, 2017
Great to see our representatives, Mr Paynter and Ms Shing (as per last BCP) supporting the views of the community and voting with their conscience - a hard deliberation to part of and thank you for your courage.
Geoff Ellis
A hard issue, well thought out Brian. Commitments are important, Ray was a leader on this issue with insight that it is impossible to fathom.
Michael Whelan
To honour a commitment and follow your conscience in the face of opposition is courageous. Congratulations on your courage.
Felicia Di Stefano
Thanks very much for your vote Brian.
Jan Fleming
Thank you Brian for sharing your views on this heartfelt topic and also to you and the other MP's who voted for this legislation.
N Smith
Thank you Brian. It is difficult to see how anyone could not support this issue having had such a first hand encounter. So sad to think many of us do not come to this conclusion unless confronted with the stark reality. .
Bob Middleton
Thanks Brian for not simply following the party line on this important issue. Ray was an outstanding human being, and his expertise in dealing with end-of-life experience, both from a nursing and patient viewpoint , was unparalleled. I am so pleased that his efforts have borne fruit. All political decisions should be guided by conscience, not by what is deemed to be plotically-expedient.
Mark Robertson
Thank you Brian for your compassion and humanity.
Anne Davie
Thank you Brian for your beautifully written piece. I Have had similar experiences and am impressed by your strong stance on this issue.
Rhonda Sutton
Man about town
October 21, 2017
Delightful Bob! And we, who count you among our 'new best friends', are very pleased you are but a short detour from our Wetlands stroll. Sally is also pleased to see Charlie more often!
Maddy Harford
October 24, 2017
Thanks Bob - it's great to hear how you've handled the change to from 'outback' to 'town centre'.
We'll have to do it one day being on an acre and a half and as you said, it seems to get bigger by the day. Till then if you've got the urge, you're welcome to visit our rural piece of paradise in Woolamai - Charlie too of course.
Sue Packham
October 26, 2017
Welcome to the "big smoke" Bob! I hope you learn to admire the wattlebirds as a very industrious and loving parent. I had always been told they were aggressive, etc. but I hadn't experience that with my mix of reds and little wattlebirds .. until last year! I've lived in my house for seven years but they only built a nest last year! I do admire the way they bully the common (formerly Indian) minah birds though and I'm pleased the magpies just ignore them. I have a couple of young wattlebirds splashing around in the bird bath in my backyard, at the moment, which is delightful. If you haven't already, wait until you see the changing colours of the starlings. The blackbird couple wait until the wattlebirds have gone to bed before coming in for a swim. Every bird has its day, even the dull and boring! Enjoy your new abode and see you around town.
Pamela Jacka
A work in progress
October 21, 2017
Totally support Meryl's view on development in our shire ,Grantville is lucky to have her as a Community leader.
Vicki Breen
Ditto to Millowl ( Phillip Island )
Rob Humphrys
An insightful snapshot. I too, congratulate the members of the new Grantville Business and Community Association. The hard working component groups bought many improvements to the gateway to Bass Coast.
I admire their commitment and would like to acknowledge that the members off all community associations and committees – Resident and Ratepayer, Progress, Foreshore, Section 86….the list is endless – donate so much of their lives to craft the Bass Coast in which everyone wants to live.
Meryl has encapsulated the conundrum of balancing progress, our environment and amenity. Having so many active and passionate groups across the Waterline contributing to, and scrutinizing council strategies makes the deliberations of a councillor much easier.
I look forward to the day when I can admire the bushland and beaches then shop at the Grantville Supermarket on the way home.
Cr Geoff Ellis
Thanks Meryl for such a well written and well balanced summation of our wonderful part of the world. The contribution of yourself and your Husband, Hartley, is greatly appreciated my the community.
Roger Clark
Council backs fracking ban
October 21, 2017
Thank you for letting us know, Catherine. Well done Bass Coast Council for a healthy environment and people's rights. .
Felicia Di Stefano
Until there is concrete proof that fracking wont "frack" the environment, more power to the arm and vote of those Bass Coast Crs who passed this motion.
We've already had a "close environmental shave"with the abandonment of the Hasting Container Port, don't need any more attempts at spoiling our precious Bass Coast.
Kevin Chambers
Out of the chaos
October 21, 2017
Beautiful story about a beautiful woman. I own one of Mary's prints. She befriended my son and he bought the print for me. Mary is so youthful and interesting and of course talented.
Anne Tindall
Sweet as
October 6, 2017
Megan, so nice to welcome you to the land of snakes, redback spiders and kangaroos, dead or alive. Your timing is almost spot on for the footy will give you a rest now but only for a week or two. You served us coffee a few days ago and I can see now why your Silver Ferns are so hard to beat. Hope you stay a while.
Bob Middleton
Thank you, Megan - I loved reading this! We lived in New Zealand for two years before coming to Australia, and I had really hoped that I'd grasped the vocabulary of the southern oceans in Wellington, and wouldn't have to start all over again in Melbourne. No such luck. We had managed to survive across most of Europe with the generic 'flip flop' as summer footwear. In New Zealand, this morphed into 'jandals', and, in Melbourne, to 'thongs'. I felt I had never had such frustrating conversations in shops ever before, and, like you, I had never heard of 'flake'!
I'm very glad your aunt persuaded you to get it all down quickly, and I hate to tell you this, but you write very well - and I hope you'll write more!
Jane Westworth
Thanks for the laughs, Megan.
John Coldebella
October 7, 2017
A very enjoyable read. Thank you Megan.
N Smith
Really enjoyed your article Megan. It reminded me of the years my husband and son and I lived in Bahrain where there was a mostly British expat community and we also were confronted by a whole range of English language confusions on both sides! It caused often odd quizzical looks but mostly many laughs at how there was so much variance within the English language. Hope you enjoy your stay and may it be long and fun.
Ursula Theinert
Hi my beautiful darling wot a crack up love it. You could write a book my darling it was so awesome to read the experiences you have seen. wow please keep posting on your time line.
it is so cool love you so much mwahhhhh <3
Aunty moana Tahau
Here's one who has walked most of the places you have done, except it took me years to do. Never ona bike though, too little balance. Keep looking and enjoying and staying put.
Joan Woods
Chur chur cuz. On yer bike Aunty, your natural successor has arrived. What a westie she is, eh broess?
Jill Nicholas
you've nailed it Bro (Cuz), I was in stiches reading this. it's a perfect description of Wonthaggi, and they all go to Cape Patterson for their holidays
Pauline Wilkinson
October 8, 2017
Bonzer read, cobber. Start a travel blog and crowd fund your trips, eh?
Can't wait to read your impressions of Krowera. :-)
Geoff Ellis
What a funny, lovely breath of fresh air. Great read Megan. Please write more!
Linda Cuttriss
Very glad you've come to visit. And could you please keep contributing because it's lovely and it helps Aunty.
Linda Gordon
October 11, 2017
Forget the "footy" Megan ... go the Tahs! Also, you are in Victoria and it's not Australia as such. Australia is huge and each state has its own personality. Moving from NSW, I was surprised to find that the language down here is quite different, which is fascinating even for old Aussies like me! I've seen quite a few brown faces in Wonthaggi too, some being neighbours for a while. This is certainly an interesting place to live and you're absolutely right that no one is normal but then what is normal, eh? Enjoy the experience.
Pamela Jacka
Fake news!!! I'm not skinny, just beautifully slim. Apart from that it was a great story. I proud of you my girl.
Hamish Watson (Megan's dad)
What an inspiring read!
Catherine was right; things very quickly become “normal”. It’s a good reminder to stop and take it all in.
Amara Miles
Four dead in Ohio
October 6, 2017
Beautifully said Cr Ellis, thank you!
Rinchen Wilson
Couldn't agree more Geoff. Just a shame those higher up the line do not share or act on our views. I don't know what they are so scared of or why compassion is so lacking.
N Smith
N - I wish I could answer that question, I really do.
Geoff Ellis
Geoff, what a brilliant article and so well written. I think your next career or parallel career should be as a writer. Never forget that 'The pen is mightier than the sword.'
I agree with everything you say and have a couple of comments to make. I blame the Internet, the Social media such as Facebook, Twitter etc. and the bias of some of the printed Media. Everything is 'open slather' in terms of venting rage, vitriol, hate etc. AND of course it can be anonymous and very superficial. As a result, thousands of people can read it or in some cases millions and can be influenced by this sort of information which isn't always accurate. AND my theory is, that as a consequence many people have become immune to humanity, compassion and kindness.
Phyllis Papps
Well said Geoff; does any sane person really believe that the loss of one innocent US life is more tragic than the loss of one innocent Rohingyan life?
Walter Broussard
Again well said Geoff. The tragic difference is that they (the Rohingyans) are poor and they are black.
Michael Whelan
Thanks Michael. That's a stone cold fact.
Geoff Ellis
October 13, 2017
Wow Geoff what a great article and so well written It makes my heart sad to see the plight of the Rohingyans. I’m sure they would thrive here and do Australia proud
Levinus Van Der Neut
Life and death
October 6, 2017
Thank you Harriet. Your deliberation is greatly appreciated and your decision is strongly supported by me and many around me. My father had to beg people to act in secret to free him from the unbearable.
Geoff Ellis
Thanks Harriet. We are coming up to a very significant moment l. Thanks for your very considered response. I am glad you have come to this decision to vote Yes to pass the bill.
Samiro Douglas
On the sick list
October 6, 2017
I consider myself something of an expert on hospitals having once spent 8 months in a large public hospital in Sydney. Later as a day patient at Royal Melbourne and ER at the Hepworth with a couple of overnight stays. Lately I have had to use Wonthaggi Hospital about once a year often staying overnight. If it is possible to love a hospital then I love Wonthaggi, or at least their staff. Being small though you are likely to end up in a mixed ward, as I was, next to a woman loudly discussing her vajayjay operation while an elderly gentleman opposite slowly expired. And unlike large Melbourne hospitals you are only a few steps, or a short wheelchair roll, from the car park, for which, bless them, they don't charge.
Jim
Thanks for writing this article. Your experiences largely match my own, although I have also experienced patient centered care cultures at some large hospitals and other country hospitals too. Caring and showing it doesn't compromise professionalism or secularity at all. Let's hope the positive cultures become the norm, sooner rather than later.
Karen Sandon
The Custodian
October 7, 2017
What an honour
Neri Melsmith
A wonderful portrait of a great leader and role model. The embodiment of compassion.
Geoff Ellis
The Hovell Tree
October 7, 2017
Thank you Terri.
Ailsa Drent
October 9, 2017
Sorry I got to your story so late Terri. The wonder for me is that after some 15 years of being a South Gippsland resident I still know so little about the area and it's history. You and people like Linda Cuttris of the island help me to fill in these inexcusable empty spaces.
Bob Middleton
Stop, in the name of love!
September 23, 2017
I have voted yes for equality Mikhaela.
Jan Fleming
YES!
Nola Smith
Definitely YES!
And thank you for such a personal, logical, committed and passionate argument!
Jane Westworth
YES with a tick not a cross.
This needs wider distribution, Mikhaela - hope it is being re-posted widely through many different networks, including at national level.
Anne Heath Mennell
Mikhaela's words have displayed exactly what our politicians should be providing -common sense, decency, insight and honesty. Barlow for PM!
Mark Robertson
Mikhaela this is brilliant and must be get out to other media outlets. I am proud to say I know you and that I admire your courage and strength.
Anne Davie
How many times do we need to keep on ‘Coming Out’ before we are accepted as equals in the society we live in?’
The first time for Francesca and myself was in 1970 in a very public way on Australian Television.
The second time was in 1985. I ‘Came Out’ professionally in front of about 100 Malvern women on International Womens’ Day when I was host of a function held at Malvern Town Hall.
The third time was in 2015 when Francesca and I danced together at a pre-Christmas function organized by Griffith’s Point Lodge in San Remo. This is a Nursing Home with 28 residents, one of whom is my mother who has been there for six years.
The last time was July 2017 in the article I wrote for Bass Coast Post entitled “Somewhere Over the Rainbow.” This was our fourth time of ‘Coming Out’ publicly –this time in the community we have lived in since 2001.
Obviously all our friends, members of the family, neighbours and colleagues know we are gay, but this will be our last time of ‘Coming Out.’
When the plebiscite survey arrives in your mail during the next few weeks, read the questions carefully and think about the implications. Also ask yourself the following: are you prejudiced? biased? discriminatory? sexist? ageist? homophobic? racist? xenophobic? Or are you a bigot? a religious fanatic? someone who hates ?
If so, what are you afraid of?
If not, then vote for Marriage Equality for all, irrespective of gender, sexual orientation and lifestyle choices.
Phyllis Papps
Phyllis, I am proudly voting YES.
I agree with everything you have written about LGBTIQ matters and admire your determined courage.
RE your penultimate paragraph of questions - if only every commentator, broadcaster and politician would ask themselves those questions every morning.
Towards the end of 'Somewhere Over The Rainbow' you wrote that "The only thing we don’t have is a piece of paper that states that we are married, even though we exchanged gold wedding rings back in 1970.'
I pray that all our bits of paper ensure that you can get that piece of paper. It's a matter of equal human rights.
Cr Geoff Ellis
I voted yes. There are no valid arguments to support a no vote. The arguments put up are either irrelevant to the question or based in hate or fear.
Noel
Thank you Mikhaela for such a well-written cry from the heart which has given me insights and expanded my (already open) view. It's a Yes from this household and we wish you happiness.
Hilary Stuchbery
What if you meet both of them later in life and fall madly in love, you'd still be screwed.
The law should just say, consenting adults, not just 2 people.
Mark Ellis
Thank you for sharing your story Mikhaela, you made your points very well.
As someone who didn't have family support I am glad that not only did you have support from your family, but also you reach out to others.
Well done, and keep up the great work!!!!
Steve
Thank you Mikhaela and Phyllis for your courage and for sharing your incredibly valuable insights and heartfelt experiences. You are both so inspiring. I voted as soon as I received the letter in the post - and I voted a very strong YES!
Sue Saliba
Island caravan park knocked back
September 24 2017
If Council and community will not allow any development of this property then it should purchase it at realistic price so that the land. I'm sure council are still sending rates bills to the owners.
One should ask councillors and the community members objection "how would you feel if this was your property?"
Those of us who have been owner here for long while clearly remember the camping area next to this land, what was proposed was a vast improvement on that facility and Yes we are a tourist area. Hard to tell at time with the terrible facilities we provide for visitors and locals. Councillors "have you ever been inside the toilet block at San Remo?" As someone out walking everyday we are asked all the time "where are the public toilets?" It's embarrassing to point out where it is, and yes it is the only one in town centre!! We've just returned from staying at Kings Beach near Coloundra the public facilities are superb and well maintained by the local council and they have nowhere near the number of overseas visitors that we do.
Christopher Day
I agree with Chris Day. Recently I had a friend staying with me from NZ he went to the toilets in San Reno. He came out not happy! Niether was I. What an embarrasment. Bass Coast Shire.
Pamela J Gill JP
Just a note of clarification. The San Remo toilets are owned and managed by the San Remo Foreshore Committee of Management. So, this time the Council can be exonerated for the poor state of the SR toilet block. However, the state of the toilet block does reflect the rest of the SR foreshore. Dangerous paths, weeds everywhere. The "landscaping" along the northern edge of the Phillip Island Tourist Road is another cringe-worthy eyesore.
Is it time for the Council to step in and take control away from the Committee?
Ray McNamara
A great decision by council. The people who bought the land knew what they were buying so why should council buy the property, that is silly. Speculation is not always successful. This is definitely not a position for a caravan park when all shops and facilities require entering a crowded highway. The parks in town are much better located for walking to restaurants etc.
Phil Bagley
Being an Aussie
September 24, 2017
Anne Some of us are getting better at recognising racism but some feel freed to express it. We are not far removed from the White Australia Policy - your experience of immigration would be similar today juxtaposed against a punishing regime for people fleeing oppression. I wonder how many non western people seeking citizenship would seek to accept it on Australia Day if they were aware of the British oppression of the original inhabitants of this Country - the very behaviour many of them are seeking to leave in their own countries.
Michael Whelan
Thanks you for this wonderful piece Anne. This is a shameful time in our history when intolerance and our lack of compassion is compromising us and whatever we believed was about being an Australian.
Anne Davie
Thank you Anne; great article. I came to Australia in 1956 at the age of 14. In those days we had to wait five years to become a citizen. The Dutch were often referred to as the "invisible migrant" because we looked a bit English and soon picked up the language. That made our transition very comfortable. For me it was all a huge adventure but as I get older I often reflect on what it must be like for those who are coming to Australia now expecting refuge in a nation they believe to be mature and understanding. I am ashamed about how we treat these people who are in such dire need. In 1956 we had the White Australia policy but it didn't seem to be so cruel on such a large scale. It is ironic that white Australia stole this land from the indigenous inhabitants and now we think we have the right to stop others from coming here. In this regard the Australian government has a lot in common with the white supremacist movement.
John Mutsaers
Short sentence for Carlowe
September 23, 2017
Great story, beautifully written, sad ending, but that's the way with animals, their only weakness is that they do not live long enough.
Roger Clark
Great story Geoff, it brought a few tears to my eyes.
Jan Fleming
Thank you, Geoff. I'm glad you wrote it in the present tense: it means that we all had the chance to share in Carlowe's life, as well as the memories. There is a kind of unity forged by loss, an empathy, and, if we shed tears, they make it easier to smile. Thank you for sharing Carlowe.
Jane Westworth
Fucking Lymphoma strikes again! My faithful hound, Layla, has been a loyal companion throughout my lymphoma journey. She only understands two human commands - breakfast and tea!, but warms my feet during those cold Bass coast nights. Give Finn a pat for me and find him a new mate, it will be good for all. Hope to see them bounding along the beach at Harmers soon.
Mark Robertson
Thank you Geoff for sharing Carlowes story. Whenever I stroke a new dog on meeting I find myself feeling for those deadly bumps.Our old terrier developed them at a far too early age and I still wake at night sometimes and recall the trusting look he gave me as the needle went in and the light faded from his eyes. But the joy they give outweighs the tears of goodbye.
Bob Middleton
A wild ride
September 23, 2017
What a great description of the Summerland Peninsula Linda, thanks.
Jan Fleming
A great journey in words. I call the south coast road Phillip Islands 'mini great ocean road'.
Anne Paul
Beautiful pics and great writing about a place that we need to treasure. Mini Great Ocean Road for sure!
Geoff Ellis
Up close and natural
September 23, 2017
Thanks for your words and insight! As I work in my studio situated in my garden I share your wonder of nature and observe the going ons in my small garden. Lots of birds, blue tongue lizards, little insects and happily bees buzzzing to blooms and the water in my bird baths!
Heather Fahnle
Thank you, Mark, for reminding us of the wonders of nature and the benefits of taking time to look around, pause and then focus quietly and patiently on what is around us. Thank you also for introducing me to the concept of ethology - how species interact with each other and their surrounds. I hadn't come across the term before but I am aware of the complex ecosystems involved in the various connections between organisms, including within our own human bodies. I'd like to put in a plea for people to learn about and respect the life forms which we can't see because they are too small. They help us to digest our food, ferment and break down organic matter, make soil fertile, allow plants, including trees, to communicate with one another, among many other things. Spare a thought for bacteria, microbes, fungi, mosses, and many other types of microscopic flora and fauna without which there would be no life as we currently know it.
Anne Heath Mennell
Thanks Anne, it is so important for us to realise that all life is important - not only the exotic and endangered, along with the supposedly-superior humans. The world (both organic and inorganic) cooporates and thrives due to incredibly complex, yet simple interactions and natural laws. The sooner man realizes this, and stops the hell-bent craziness to dominate our shared world, the better.I hope that our children realise what a mess that modern society has made in such a short time, and brings the leaders to their senses. Celebrate the mundane and common, before they too are gone, and never be afraid to tell the emperor that he has no clothes on!
Mark Robertson
I could not have put this any better, Mark, thank you. Good to know I'm not alone - hope we might be members of a growing minority which will one day help humans to recognise we are only one part of a miraculous web of life and begin to make amends before it is too late.
Anne Heath Mennell
No joy for tourist operator
September 23, 2017
I am pleased to see that this venture was refused. Projects start small but can become a nightmare like the helicopters operating from the airport site in Newhaven. The noise can be heard from every flight and many are in the evening when quietness is appreciated.
Penny Manning
Cr Kent states" this is just a small person". This couple would be amongst the wealthiest in Inverloch. This venture is just a play thing at the expense of neighbours.
Luke
You are absolutely correct Penny the noisy persistent helicopters at Newhaven flying a loop for long periods with multiple helicopters is destroying the amenity of Newhaven and San Remo and to make matters worse council has no control over or the inclination to rein in the noise. Thank your lucky stars that 5 councillors have the ratepayers interests at heart. Start with one little plane then all of a sudden 3 very noisy helicopters would be permitted to conduct joy flights. The people of Inverloch have avoided a nightmare.
Phil Bagley
Rhyll artist in the frame
Congratulations Jill from Rhyll.
Jan Fleming and John Adam.
Jill, Congratulations, such a tranquil painting.
Melissa Hayes
On the road again
September 2, 2017
Congratulations Cr. Le Serve. After reading your very insightful article I hope that residents of Bass Coast Shire will understand and appreciate all the hard work that BCSC staff and Councillors do on behalf of their community. As you rightly point out - it's NOT just about Roads, Rates and Rubbish. It's also about community involvement and planning for the future needs of the people of the Bass Coast region and beyond.
You have had an excellent track record as a former Mayor/Councillor AND that is the reason why you were re-elected for a second term. Your journey has been a tough one, but your integrity and commitment to the community has paid off.
Phyllis Papps
I agree with Phyllis, particularly the comments about integrity and commitment.
Geoff Ellis
Calling Australia home
Hear Hear! Just over a hundred years ago Australia had a paternally German PM (Chris Watson) who had been born in Chile and came here on a boat. He remains our only PM born in a non-empire/commonwealth country and I wonder if they'd even let him into the country today?
Geoff Ellis
Well if he was also brown, muslim or gay I doubt he'd get a look in! Let's just hope that Nick Xenophon is not also a Cypriot lol.
Eve Hollole
The hills are alive
A beautiful piece Frank
Linda Cuttriss
Terrific story. You have brought this Piano back to life. Will we hear about the trunk? It looks like it's got something to say.
Edward Buckingham
Thanks Frank, Loved your story.
Jan Fleming
Beautifully written, Frank. Loved the story.
Ruth and Peter Glare
Wonderful story.
Alli Coulson
Back to nature
September 2, 2017
Beautiful photos.
Beautiful place.
Thanks John.
Jan Fleming
A lot of credit is due to John for the wonderful work at Scenic Estate marshalling his volunteers on a regular basis - his knowledge is immense and he was a catalyst in the flora survey that was completed recently.
I note the designation 'an aboriginal place of low significance' What could be significant is a name change to reflect the aboriginal history and show acknowledgement and respect for this place.
Michael Whelan
I agree about the name. Beautiful place, dreadful name (although it does reflect its recent history). It would be great to hear what the traditional owners think about a name that reflects their history.
Catherine Watson
Lean times
September 2, 2017
Great advice,
Thanks Miriam.
Jan Fleming
Thanks for your witty words of wisdom Miriam!
Linda Cuttriss
Between a Red Rock and a hard place
August 18, 2017
Michael, Congratulations if councillors don't take up issues on behalf of the community who will?
In San Remo we border "Keams" property. Its within existing town boundary's and we all knew it would be developed. When Keams original sub division lapsed because of their inaction over many years , we we're suddenly hit with a new plan which would have brought "Pakenham to San Remo to a large parcel of land that can be seen to every person crossing the bridge and beyond.
When the San Remo community challenged what was planned we were told it was all a "done deal" Council Officers recommended it to go ahead. Bradley Drew as at the time our new local councillor managed to convince other councillors that Council should challenge. History shows it went to VCAT and the community successfully challenged the application.
The VCAT ruling is worth reading for any of the new councillors if they haven't seen it. It was damning of the whole process. While their are still elements of the revised application now approved by VCAT that could be better in my opinion, it's still a far better outcome for the community that what what we looked like having to live with for ever. Developers walk away once it's sold, even Council officers etc are most likely not themselves affected but we the community are left with the problem for ever.
The response at the time of one new councillor made a big difference to San Remo and the Bass Community for ever.
Chris Day
It is both gratifying and reassuring that our Councillors are so concerned about the ongoing condition of our beautiful Island and its flora and fauna. Well done to all who opposed this proposed over-development.
Doug Elms
August 19, 2017
It is wonderful that our councillors will fight to preserve the nature of Phillip Island and its diminishing open spaces and vote against high density development.It is after all why visitors come to Phillip Island and what the community is increasingingly becoming very concerned with."When it is gone,it is gone for good"
Vicki Breen
I also fully agree and congratulations on the council stand to oppose this type of development.
Garry Busowsky
Well done Michael,this is what we need,
councillors who are prepared to stand up for our environment.
It would also be a step in the right direction if you all got behind the lack of infrastructure re;unmade roads throughout the shire and take the politics out of it.
Pamela J Gill JP
August 20, 2017
The Island councillors should perhaps pause for a moment and reflect what the situation would be if they stood alone . There would need to be a 15 year supply of housing sites available on the precious Phillip Island . Fortunately good old Wonthaggi is available to soak up the demand- we have zero environmental values at risk....... By the way, whatever happened to the Stand Alone proponents? They were most vocal before the last municipal elections, but since then, not a peep. I hope that our shire recognises that the entire Bass Coast deserves proper scrutiny of any and all proposed developments - North Wonthaggi and Mahers Landing , for example.
Mark Robertson
Thank you to Councillor Michael Whelan and to the other eight councillors for standing up for what is important on Phillip Island - our natural environment and our community. Well done, Bass Coast Shire councillors!
Sue Saliba
August 22, 2017
Councilor Whelan, it is gratifying to see that some councilors are prepared to do what is, in actual fact, their duty and do the right thing on behalf of the residents who voted for them, not just accept the dictates of council officers. We all understand that the council has a large area to administer and a relatively low population base to extract funds from. Therefore it needs to continue to create additional ratepayers. However this council's officers seem to regularly overlook its own published strategies and criteria in order to allow for developments that may or may not be in the best interests of the community at large. They seem to leave these issues to residents, waiting for objections instead of applying their own criteria and strategies. Once again it is gratifying to see that some councilors are prepared to recognise that they are in fact, on behalf of the residents, the employers of council officers not the other way round and that councilors are representing their community and not answerable to council officers.
Trevor Brown
August 24, 2017
Well done Sue -it is so important that the local residents stand up to protect the special and irreplacable parts of our Bass Coast home. Hope that the AGL intrusion of Westernport is as easily dispatched. All power to those who care.
Mark Robertson
A brief history of Grantville
August 18, 2017
Well done for your initiative and drive. Grantville certainly has moved forward and it looks more vibrant and welcoming - good work.
Liz Glynn
I remember very well the early changes in Grantville. I always say if you sit back and wait nothing happens but if you put strong people with passion for change things will happen. Well done Helen and the people of Grantville.
Margaret Murray
August 19, 2017
Thanks Margaret, I trust you are having a nice time in your retirement. Best regards. Helen
Helen Zervopoulos
Thank you to Christopher, and yourself Helen, for the commitment and hard work that you contributed to the Waterline townships over the years. I learnt so much about 'community' and always admired the way you achieved so much and had fun.
Joy Button
Like many others we have travelled from Melbourne to our holiday home at Ventnor since 1985 and breezed through Grantville.when the tram stop cafe near Jam Jerrup closed many years ago we made Grantville our coffee break stop. It is now sometimes difficult to get a park,it is a hub for locals to chat and visitors to grab a bite and community news letter.
Heaps of community spirit evident !
Gary Watkins
Hi, interesting article. I arrived in the area in 2010 so clearly a lot was done in a very short space of time! I am interested in the "Waterline Townships" plans. Was Jam Jerrup included? Where can I get a copy please.
James
Hi James, no Jam Jerrup was not included, not sure why. The township plans were written for each individual community it was not a general overall waterline plan.
Helen Zervopoulos
August 27, 2017
A wonderful look back Helen. You and Christopher are to be congratulated for your persistent contributions and never say die attitudes. You will be missed.
Zena Benbow
Memories of Wally
August 18, 2017
Lovely tribute Antoinetta, I will certainly miss him, and his old dog at the markets.
Thank you for thinking enough of him to pen this tribute.
Roger Clark
Some lovely words about Wally and would chat to him over the years we have been here. He told Richard that he had worked on the trains in the UK. My funniest memory is going to his house to buy plants and after knocking on the door went to the back and there was Wally gardening round the back, absolutely starkers. Richard told me when it was okay to come round. He was a lovely gentle man with some stories and very sad to hear of his passing.
Joy Button
I missed Wally in my time and your touching story Ant Gent has made me realise what a loss that is for me.So many good qualities that we can admire and hopefully learn from.Thank you for telling his story..
Bob Middleton
Some years ago I bought a lime tree for a wet spot in the garden and he gave me directions on how to plant it: fabulous tree now. I stopped by his stall last year and thanked him for his very sage advice. Sorry to hear of his passing. Not many characters around these days.
Liz Glynn
I'm glad you've introduced me to Wally, Ant. He epitomises qualities i admire and which counteract the negative stories we hear so often. Seems he was a man full of determination, generosity and so knowledgable about those indispensable things - plants.
Sue Packham
Loved reading your tribute to Wally. Sometimes we lose the characters of our life without knowing when or how. Community is a lot of things and Wally excuded the sense of community I love. His passion for plants, making a few bob on the side, his cheeky smirk when pressed for a discount, his vocal outbursts when challenged over the issues of the day. RIP Wally
David Norton
August 24, 2017
Many good memories of you at Grantville market. Choco the dog. RIP Wally.
Dan
When your foot starts tapping …
August 5, 2017
Wonderful story Brian. I agree absolutely with respect to Craig's legacy. He will be sorely missed on the Island.
Pamela Rothfield
August 6, 2017
It is a good thing that a diversity of opinions and beliefs is welcomed and practiced in our community. Because I believe in one truth, it does not mean that your truth is invalid. This needs to apply to all diversity in our community.
Felicia Di Stefano
How refreshing to read something positive. I hope Brian the uplifting feeling stays with you.
Coleen Coleman
Love your description of the service and Craig. I remember my first time in the church and it was very similar. I was one of the four that got baptised that day and gave my testimony (2nd to speak, lady in her 30s). I decided a few years ago to be a Christian and true believer not a denomination, family and friends have other strong opinions. Glad you got to witness and what a farewell for Craig and his family. They have been so involved in the whole community for 17 years. Thank you for your words.
Jess O'Brien
Yes, Craig and family have been an absolute blessing to us during our January holidays every year. Thank you so much Craig - God's blessings for your future
Bob Boucher
Keep talking
August 5, 2017
Geoff, you ARE the voice of reason and sensitivity to all the issues that we face every day living here in the Bass Coast region.
It is such a pity that people who are uninformed, ignorant, angry and unreasonable who vent their rage on the Councillors of BCSC as well as the staff. (via Email, Facebook, Twitter etc.)
In our world today, there are visionaries, pragmatists, philosophers and great activists.
Keep up the good work because you are highly respected in our community.
Phyllis Papps
Geoff I think you would be good at teaching councillors how to do what you are doing. Would love to see people in my council region working as you do. We never get to even see them. My experience has always shown me that the closer you connect with the public good or bad the more you learn where change needs to happen and at the same time you show your community that you care and you want to listen. Well done!
Helen
WE live in complex in San Remo with 24 owners and body corporate. With the new bins starting at a time when many permanent residents away, and holiday home owners staying warm else where we had some concerns on the change. The response from council officers has been very impressive. Prompt response, a site meeting arranged and decision reached and confirmed by Council. Yes it's a big task the Council officers face with this new service. There will be issues but from our experience they can be resolved with common sense discussion.
Chris Day
Chris, Great to read such a positive message. Extending the life of the current landfill cell will be a great outcome and working through issues this way provides a template for other initiatives.
Cr Geoff Ellis
At least the yellers are consistent and yell at every council. That is why some councillors did not re-contest the previous council elections, to the community's loss. Society is like this; most reasonable, some not. Articles like yours are important in education our community but perhaps your article needs to be delivered through other channels as well, to reach those who would not read the BCP. Thank you for kindly for including SGRAR as part of our community.
Felicia Di Stefano
Once again your very thoughtful and informative article make us ever more aware how fortunate we are to have such a vehicle for public discussion as the Bass Coast Post. Thank you councillor,may many of your colleagues take advantage of this forum.
Bob Middleton
Once again Geoff very well written. Your thoughtful and well written words are always enjoyable to read and I always walk away feeling more informed. You are right on the money that most people we meet and chat with are positive and just looking for someone to hear them, unfortunately there will always be the aggressive minority.
Couldn't agree more with your message about the counter staff, the faces at the coal front, we shouldn't shoot the messenger.
Keep up the great work Geoff, the Westernport Ward, the Bass Coast Shire Council are so lucky to have you, the work you do and advocacy you pursue for your ward and our shire is unquestionable.
Cr Brett Tessari
Thanks Brett, Being part of such a supportive team makes it easier for all of us to achieve the outcomes to which our people aspire.
As you say, most people are positive and, when we have to present them with outcomes that might not meet their expectations they take it well. With limited resources it's impossible to realise every great initiative and I admire your ability to negotiate and find a way forward that achieves the greater good.
Cr Geoff Ellis
Paradise lost
August 6, 2017
Preservation of existing pockets of indigenous vegetation in settled areas on Phillip Island is vital. 'Development' of areas like this one at Red Rocks will destroy the very thing that makes living on and visiting Phillip Island so desirable. We need to preserve the beautiful rural and coastal views together with unique flora & fauna. If we don't we will be faced with living in just another poorly planned and ugly suburban wasteland. We'll also face living with the guilt of having allowed the destruction of something which should have been handed on to future generations. It's time to stop putting short term profits for a few before precious environmental & social considerations. The Red Rocks area is particularly lovely. It would be so sensible to protect the area, preserve the vegetation and use part of it for community activity - a small playground and perhaps an appropriate trail which would allow enjoyment of the birds and plants. I hope Council will heed its own documents when it considers this application.
Mary-Lu Burt
This should never be allowed to happen a park would be much better
Philip Kinniff
Home-grown talent
August 5, 2017
What I love about living in Bass Coast is the number of talented people we have here. What an inspiring story - Well done Maureen!!
Susan Anderson
I have admired Maureen's work for many years and have been very moved by the process she has undertaken to fulfill her passion for watercolours. Her eye captures the heart of the chosen place and the outcome is joyous.
Thankyou so much Maureen
Ailsa Drent
I have a few small paintings of Maureen . I used to live quite close to her a long time ago ... Some of my kids were friends with her youngest daughter . I have s very lovely small oil painting of her daughter and my son with horses .., I treasure it as it brings back beautiful memories ... Thanks Maureen , such talent !!!
Henny
A soft target
July 22, 2017
I sincerely apologise, on behalf of white skinned people, for the racism you have suffered in South Gippsland. My experience in the Bass Coast is very different to yours, Rinchen. I took my South Sudanese friends and their children around Wonthaggi; shops, banks, doctors, Centrelink, parks. Nowhere did we experience racism. My husband and I sponsored a Karen family and as we went around Wonthaggi town shopping, people would smile at us, some extend hands to shake. I had tears rolling down my eyes as the checkout lady at big W held out her hand and said "welcome to Australia." I too have suffered extreme racism in the land of my birth. I am a Jew. But never in Australia. Must be because I have a white appearance. It sounds as if some of the population of South Gippsland needs to be educated about diversity and how it has served and still serves Australia.
Felicia Di Stefano
Thank you, Bass Cost Post, and Mikhaela and Rinchen, for two challenging, gutsy and helpful articles on racism, and for the many penetrating responses from the public.
Rob Youl
I am saddened that racism is still prevalent in our country. It shocks me that people can be mistreated just because of the colour of their skin. All I can say is that we are not all like that and I hope and pray that you will have many positive experiences that will show these awful actions to be foolish gestures made by ignorant people who do not understand the wonder and beauty of diversity.
Jacqui Paulson
Thank you for the letters. I too am sorry that people have not embraced difference of colour and culture. Diversity is a great gift for us all. If we can only embrace difference Australia and South Gippsland will be a richer, happier and more secure place for everyone.
Philip Beggs
To be honest I'm a little bothered and feeling defensive of all I've read My town is a welcoming town IMPO - different on many levels than others in both bass coast and south gipps land but thats just my opinion
Rosemary
Thank you Rinchen for your bravery and honesty. It takes courage to speak up out against personal experiences of racism. I feel a sense of shame and dismay that there are people in our community who are prepared to judge others simply on the colour of their skin. They are however a small minority. I want you to know that there are many here in the community who abhor racist attitudes and are prepared to stand with you.
Susan Pryde
Apologies to Rinchen for the sadness to her ( and many others) by pig-ignorant people. I was a young teenager in the 50's and remember the racism by many towards the Italians who moved to Wonthaggi to work in the State Coal Mine. Where would we be now culturally without their input to our town (to say nothing of decent coffee, fabulous food etc.) I remember when olive oil was only sold at chemist's shops! Rinchin when we hear every day of the apathy and mistreatment towards the owners of this land (here for at least 65,000 years), and us invaders for what 200+ years? my heart bleeds for you and yours. Of course racism is encouraged by many of our politicians whose power base are the 'rednecks' both in towns and rural areas. If I am ever fortunate enough to meet you, Rinchin, I would take you in for a good coffee and just let anyone look sideways they would feel the edge of my tongue. Best wishes to you and I do know plenty of people in Bass Coast Shire who would support you.
Yvonne McRae
Rinchen, I am so sorry. I am so sorry that you've had to deal with small-minded, ignorant people. I'm so sorry that you've been treated this way, and I'm so sorry you're thinking of moving from your dream house to get away from this.
If you ever need support, or would like to discuss ways we can both help stop this in our area, I would love to have coffee with you sometime. Catherine has my email.
Thank you for reading my piece last week and sharing your story. That took a lot of courage.
Mikhaela Barlow
How fortunate we have young women like Mikhaela and Rinchen calling it as they see it.
They remind us that we must individually and collectively condemn racism whenever and where ever we are. Thank you both.
Anne Davie
July 23, 2017
I have timidly put out 'hello's and how are you to newer members of our community. Theirr reaction is non commital so now I leave them alone. I'm sorry for this but feel it may be for the best. Thanks for Mikhaela and R for bringing it to my attention.
Joan Woods
Mary and I recently gave Ancestry.com a DNA sample and was somewhat surprised to find that my direct descents went for 116 pages and Mary's for 230 pages which equates to lots and lots of relatives from all over the world with diverse backgrounds and races. Throughout our lives we have observed examples of casual racism and there is nothing casual about it.
It is through education that we can change racial prejudice. Richen, we are glad to read that you have been invited to sit on the Govenor of Victoria's round table of Victoria's leaders to help develop Victoria's Multicultural policy All of us.
At this forum you have the opportunity to voice your concerns and make recommendations to change the culture that you say exits in South Gippsland and elsewhere.
Frank W Schooneveldt
One of the reasons I am so ashamed of living here :( I moved from Melb - being the parents of migrants myself I still see and feel the angst of not being a true Anglo in this community :( I have grown up with many races and religions in Melb - just another part of our beautiful world - mingling with varied people and cultures has been such a gift - these people who discriminate have not had the privileged to mingle and learn and love the variety of cultures inner Melb has - and all i can say - it is their silly idiotic loss - thank you for being to true and honest to some of the ugliness of old school regional Victoria
Ant
I was shocked and saddened to read Mikhaela's earlier article, as My experience has been quite different, as a new arrival in Bass Coast. But then I'm white and also, one tends to make friends with people with similar philosophies. I did have one experience, in a group I joined, some members of which expressed objectionable (to me) attitudes to refugees and asylum seekers (equating them with terrorists). I challenged this at the time but it was clear they weren't listening (they just shouted over the top of me), so I decided not to waste my time with that group.
When I read Mikhaela's article and again this week, reading Rinchin's account of her treatment, I am ashamed and furious. People are of course entitled to their opinions, however cruel and ignorant. So I want to channel my fury into thinking about how we can work to marginalise such attitudes and ultimately see them disappear. We need to focus on educating our young people, providing them with powerful experiences that help them understand we are all human, with loves, hopes and skills that can contribute to enriching our community.
Maddy Harford
Due to the hiring practices of many companies in Australia over the last 15 years, it doesn't surprise me that racism is on the rise. When low, middle and indeed some professional employees find themselves replaced by workers holding temporary work /holiday visas, racism will flourish. It's no excuse, but not surprising.
Jeff Sim
Bravely written Rinchen & Mikhaela. Thanks you for reminding us all that not speaking up when we hear a racist comments can be just as much of a problem and just as hurtful. Unfortunately a much needed reminder that we all have a responsibility to build the welcome and accepting communities we want to live in and should be vigilant to stop the comments and treatment you have received.
Issie
Beautifully written Rinchen. Thank you for being so brave.
Deb
Bilbao, MONA, TarraWarra … Wonthaggi?
July 22, 2017
Council should begin the process? I take a different view; the community should begin the process, if indeed it really supports the initiative being suggested. Councils role is to facilitate and support the community in achieving its goals.
I would support an inclusive community movement to achieve a regional gallery or an even greater initiative once it had demonstrated a willingness to engage extensively within the artistic and broader community and was open in setting its goals.
I note that MONA in Hobart, the Guggenheim Museum in Bilbao, Spain, and Tarrawarra Museum of Art in the Yarra Valley were not Council initiatives but the products of philanthropy.
At the Council meeting in June an Arts and Culture Advisory Committee was formed, expressions of interest will be called shortly – that could be where this starts – get on board.
Michael Whelan
I agree that the Advisory committee is a good starting point. A related point - members if community groups who are passionate about their cause don't necessarily know where to start, who to approach and how. Perhaps a service/strategy that council could implement is an education program/workshop for community groups on when and how to approach council, the role of council officers etc.
Marian Quigley
I fully support the idea, and think it's worth pursuing.
Jill Shannon
We have a dramatic landscape, flourishing creative and artistic base,progressive growers and a steadily growing tourism rate. Bendigo has grown into a regional arts hub on the back of their highly successful gallery. Food and wine contribute, and I see South Gippsland having the potential to become this region's focal point for art, food and travel.
Kathleen O'Neill
Why does everything go to Wonthaggi? Phillip Island, which raises all the revenue is neglected again.
Pauline Enright Amon
As is Almurta, Bass, Corinella, Coronet Bay, Glen Alvie, Glen Forbes, Grantville, The Gurdies, Jam Jerrup, Kernot, Kongwak, Krowera, Pioneer Bay, Pound Creek, San Remo, Tenby Point, Wattle Bank.
Woodleigh, Cape Paterson, Harmers Haven, South Dudley, Anderson, Archies Creek, Hicksborough, Kilcunda, Lance Creek, Powlett River, St Clair, Wattle Bank, Dalyston, Blackwood Forest, Ryanston,
West Creek and Inverloch.
Geoff Ellis
Renovator's delight
July 22, 2017
Geoff beautifully captures how places get under the skin. Lew's place another treasured gem in 'them there hills'.
Jeannie Haughton
Love energy, and determination works wonders. Well done.
Pamela J Gill
I don't know Lew or his farm, but, after reading this, I feel I would like them both. You have evoked person and place in a way which is heart warming and reassuring in these troubled times. Long may Lew and Landcare prosper to safeguard and restore this beautiful area we humans and many other life-forms call home.
Anne Heath Mennell
A well written article about one of the hinterlands most interesting characters as he battles to turn a green desert into a lush and productive oasis. Many have tried to make a living from small farms and Lew describes the hard work and dedication needed to succeed. Did the author get to try Lew's home made ginger beer?
Janice Orchard
No hint of ginger beer so far but I reckon it will be worth the wait.
Geoff Ellis
Forget the ginger beer, You should have asked for his pear cider! Legendary!!!
Judy Potter
What a wonderful story. It reminds me of my parent's struggle 70 years ago when they bought 33 acres in Wonga Park and endeavoured to build a productive orchard. Dedication and hard work were the key then and still are.
Heather Reid
Well done Lew. Great read. Looking forward to our catch up at the reunion. Cheers Joan & Azza
Joan & Paul Azzopardi
My place
July 22, 2017
Welcome to Bass Coast! Another well kept secret - the Kernot Shop and the drive around the historic towns of the hinterland.
Geoff Ellis
Thanks kindly, Geoff, I had heard that rumour and will def check Kernot out!
Jen
July 24
Hi Jen and welcome to Bass Coast.
Now that you are a resident and settled in why not call into the Corinella and District Community Center and say hello. There is a good bunch of happy volunteers there who would be pleased to let you know what is happening in the area. Pick up one of our brochures while you are there and there may be something that interests you. We also have a free book exchange.
I volunteer there every Monday so call in and have a chat as I enjoyed reading your article.
cheers
Janice Orchard
Hi Jen,
I am in the same situation you were in, still looking for something I like in my price range. Moved down here a few months ago and renting. Beautiful place hope you will love it here. If you have pets just watch out as someone deliberately ran down and killed my cat outside my place and that was devastating, considering he had survived 11 years in inner Melbourne.
Good luck and enjoy.
Kath
Hi Jen and Kath,
Another welcome to Bass Coast!
Jen, your story parallels mine, except that I moved from Murrumbeena, the agent who showed me round the area before taking me to see my little bit of paradise was Gordon who still works at Alex Scott in Grantville, and I moved in to Tenby Point, just up the road from Corinella. That was sixteen years ago.
Kath, I was so sorry to hear what happened to your puss. Have you had a look at Tenby Point? It may not suit you (no shop or public transport) but in other ways is delightful. Hope you find 'your' place in the area soon.
Anne Heath Mennell
August 3, 2017
Hi Jen! Thank you for the recommendation! It was a pleasure pointing out all the features of this beautiful coastal area to you, and you're right, it really is a bit of a secret. The word is getting out though hence housing stock being scarce at present. I'm so glad you found the right one for you! Once you introduce yourself to the locals, I'm sure you will find out more about this gem of an area to explore.
Liz Leahy, Stockdale & Leggo Real Estate, Grantville.
Drinking from a firehose in the age of information
July 22, 2017
Well considered reflections on our crowded, overloaded lives and a great critique of what passes for entertainment. I can recall a time when TV actually stopped - every night, around midnight - and I went to the library to borrow books to read in the quiet times.
My 'time out from the endless noise that surrounds us': Cinema.
Geoff Ellis
So much nonsense all over the media, especially too much reporting of politics, government by such frequent diversion of attention, is it any wonder attention span is shorter than a sneeze?
Bernie
Stop reading the Herald Sun - our local papers are fine - especially the letters columns.....plenty of sense there, eh Bernie?
Geoff Ellis
I miss F troop and Green Acres
Frank Coldebella
Oliver Wendell Douglas is my role model.
Geoff Ellis
Little white lies
July 7, 2017
I am so heartened by this article I feel like shouting 'hooray!' - every day, casual racism is so insidious and perhaps more dangerous that the more obvious forms that this abuse appears in. I too have noticed the habitual and disheartening racism of many residents in the Bass Coast, often from the mouths of lovely and dear people. I always speak up about it whether I do so in a light hearted, jokey way or an angry, direct way. To be silent is to be complicit. I am saddened to hear that the small cohort of african refugees have mainly left the shire as my personal opinion is that refugees are desperately needed in this seemingly culturally homogeneous area. Anyhow, good on you Mikhaela, your article has heartened me no end.
Alice Ansara
Brilliant writing Mikhaela. My hope is that it can be published elsewhere to reach a wider audience. I aml sure the readers of the Bass Coast Post are already with you on this issue.In view of your comments I wonder if Barney Noonan and Curl would consider heeding your advice as it seems to have fallen on some council ears not fully tuned in to the problem.
Bob Middleton
Great to see this piece. Subtle racism go unnoticed. You need to watch out for the phase "I'm not racist, but!!!!!"
Samiro Douglas
Well said and courageously spoken. We set our standards by what we are prepared to walk past and I will mention to the Bendigo bank next time I am in there that their mural is in bad taste. It is as you say the loud and ugly abuse that is offensive but the subtle everyday use of language that is insidious.
Michael Whelan
July 8, 2017
Excellent piece of writing. Let's all stop being so complacent and stand up and say something when we see racism. The person getting attacked will then know we all don't agree with the attacker's views and feel grateful for the support.
Linda D
Great article. Congratulations on calling out racism in its many subtle and not so subtle ways. Thanks
Rosemary Paterson
Beautifully written. Maybe someone with any mainstream media contacts could assist to have Mikhaela's article published elsewhere. Travelling on Metro trains a few weeks ago, after leaving the footy at the MCG, I thought I was fortunate to find a seat. It had been a big crowd game and seats on the line I travelled are always rare. It was in a section with 4 seats, 2 facing each other.. A Sikh family from India. Mother and father visiting their adult son who is currently living here. The parents had very minimal English but the son and I engaged in various conversations and I interacted with the parents via the son. I thought, what an enriching opportunity for me, but also could see in my peripheral vision stares and even glares from other passengers. So sad. The family were getting off the train 2 stops prior to me. The son commented that it had been an enjoyable meeting and I had been generous to him and his parents...common courtesy was all it was...and a seat on a train instead of standing for me. After we had shaken hands (I must admit I am ignorant if this was appropriate to their religion, but I felt I wanted to offer my hand, also as a demonstration to the other "observers" on the train), they left. My heart was warm from the meeting, but I also felt so very sad. As an aside, it wasn't just chance that caused the empty seat. Seats are normally rushed at with trains leaving Richmond station after footy matches. There is still such a very long way to travel on the road to equality for all and acceptance of all races and religions, but as individuals we also have to lead lives of inclusion and standing up for other as Mikhaela demonstrated in the shop in Cowes.
Nola Smith
Mikhaela you are a wonderful, insightful and writer of truth. The topics you wrote with such passion, I term as the ISM'S and PHOBIAS of society in general. So here is the list: Racism, Sexism, Misogynism, Ageism, and of course Homophobia and many other phobias and Ism's .. the list is endless.
As one of the WOGS (of Greek origin) who came here to Australia in 1950 I can't see that very much has changed. There will always be fear of the unknown. When we came here, we were called "New Australians" so my parents worked hard, we got a good education and assimilated into society and made a contribution to society. We even changed our surname by Deed Poll because no one could cope with pronouncing our name.
After the 1950s influx of Italians and Greeks came the Asians in the 1970s as a result of getting rid of the White Australia Policy. Australia is not white, it is multicultural and has been greatly enriched and has benefited from all the migrants and refugees who have come here. But we must always remember who the real owners of Australia are.
Whenever we see, hear or feel that one of the Ism's or Phobias is in words, deeds or actions then we should fight it in every way we possibly can. Australia is NOT for the white, middle class, wealthy people BUT for everybody of any race, colour, religion, politics, sex, gender, age etc.
Just remember Mikhaela, the pen is mightier than the sword. So you have a great future ahead of you as a writer, deep thinker and catalyst for change.
Phyllis Papps
Good to see you still standing up for right Mikhaela, although, given the " caring attitude displayed by our political leaders towards those who have risked all to enter our country, the disgraceful behaviour of bigoted and moronic Australians is not surprising. We are supposed to be the land of the fair go- hopefully your powerful writing will wake them up to what being Australian really means.
Mark Robertson
Yes, I agree that Mikhaela's article is timely and 'on the money'. And, of course, racism is common right across the country, and in all sectors and levels, with bad examples given by too many of our leaders.
However I would like to slightly disagree with Mikhaela's comment that 'you can't be a little bit racist.' I think most of us occasionally have some racist thoughts, maybe subconsciously. But it is how we control our thoughts and actions.
Our society needs to confront fear of the other.
Tom Wolkenberg
July 11, 2017
I think you're right, Tom. It's probably human nature to be suspicious and fearful of "the other", and would have been an evolutionary advantage in the past. But we now face a different reality. I'm heartened whenever I go into multicultural city schools to see the easy camaraderie of children of all races and cultures. They probably don't realise it but they're so lucky! It's by getting to know "others" that we lose our fear.
Catherine Watson
July 10, 2017
Today, research undertaken between 2014 - 15 revealed that Muslims had reportedly been subject to 243 cases of abuse including physical, mainly in NSW and Victoria. Of this number, 75% of attacks had been suffered by Muslim women mainly because of their scarves. About half these women had their children with them at the time of the attacks and abuse. The attacks had been overwhelmingly by white males.
Horrifically, while most of these attacks occurred in public places like public transport or shopping malls, people stood by and watched including police officers and did not intervene to stop such abuse. Very few assisted the women.
I have developed a habit of speaking to Muslim women in public places, welcoming them to Phillip Island or wherever I happen to see them. They have been surprised and then grateful for the positive encounter with an older Anglo woman.
These yobbos, do not act or speak in my name, and never will. Good work Michaela for speaking up with the 2 other young people. If we all spoke kindly and and in a welcoming manner to Muslims, we would all feel better and in help counter the hate speech and actions.
I feel that we Australian can be better than those in the research.
Kay Setches
The power behind the mine
July 7, 2017
What a fantastic achievement by all the people and organisations involved! And the revolving funds will see more new energy innovations emerge in our community. The possible wetlands are a bonus!
Sue Packham
July 8, 2017
The way of the future is right here in our back yard.
Daryl Hook
July 10, 2017
Can we assume that the power generated is first used to power the mine pumps and that the excess only is sold to Parks Vic? The article doesn't say so.
Walter Broussard
The pumps are part of the State Coal Mine.
Geoff Ellis
Full and plenty
I've only been a 'local' for 10 years. In that time the Powlett floods have been a joy for a nature lover with the influx of birds to the lake-like area. Landowners surely would have known of the floodplain's annual behaviour before purchase. If inherited then they would have absorbed the families' negative attitudes. Hopefully they're as impressed as I am with the care that's taken before artificially opening the river's mouth to the sea. From my observations the grasses have plenty of time to grow the Spring/Summer pastures - a rich brew for the grazing animals.
Sue Packham
Estuarywatch volunteers tested the river waters on monday arvo and found there to be good levels of dissolved oxygen at both bridges, along with a wide variety of waterbirds.
Mark Robertson
From telegram boy to postmaster
July 8, 2017
What a brilliant article - a post card from a world where customer service was paramount.
Geoff Ellis
Great article - the name was Hugh Buggy.
As ever, brilliant newsletter - many thanks!
Rob Youl
It makes you think
July 8, 2017
The Hypothetical, The Literary Festival, The BCP and these sessions fill me with hope and pride that Bass Coast has the collective emotional maturity to discuss issues and ideas without the need to hurl slogans and abuse from the parapets.
Geoff Ellis
July 10, 2017
When you get to the essence of genetic engineering and other modern ethical challenges, there is no black and white, only shades of grey. Congratulations to Richard for persuading us to think beyond the slogans and easy answers.
Catherine Watson
Value for money
Excellent and informative article Catherine. This local representative falls far short of my expectations, although nothing seems to surprise me with Cr Larke. The only positive thing I can note is that he has resigned from the Access and Inclusion committee.
Nola Smith
Catherine, thank you for your detailed article.
I agree that Cr Les Larke should look at his own position first.
As I have expressed in this forum and elsewhere, I fundamentally disagree with Cr Les Larke's stated position on the state of the Bass Coast Shire's finances.
I note that for the 2015/2016 year the average rates and charges for the Bass Coast Shire Council was $1684 which is low when compared to the Baw Baw Shire Council of $1987 and South Gippsland Shire Council of $1990.
In view of this I am all for increasing council rates and charges to improve services and infrastructure for the people of Bass Coast.
There are numerous examples of austerity measures that poison growth. For example take a look at the UK government actions.
But this does not mean that there should not be good corporate practice by the Shire officers and accountability to the people of Bass Coast.
Frank W Schooneveldt
Dear Frank
I have enjoyed our robust conversations and note you are supportive of Bass Coast Shire Council and the fact that it has 71.4 fulltime equivalent employees (General Managers + Managers + Coordinators + Supervisors + Team Leaders + Others with direct reports) with managerial responsibilities for 244.7 full time equivalent employees - a span of supervision of less than 1:4, which may be of interest given your financial and commercial background.
Cr Les Larke
Les, I enjoy reasoned arguments that are based on facts.
And yes, I am supportive of the Bass Coast and desire to see it grow through population growth and this requires infrastructure and services.
The numbers you quote are meaningless unless you can benchmark your numbers
with similar large Shire councils.
The Bass Coast is unique in that we have a large coastline to look after, a lot of holiday residences and a lot of tourists....which is all good but I am sure creates management and financial issues that need a team approach to resolve.
We all need to work together for the greater good of the Bass Coast.
Frank W Schooneveldt
I have no personal animosity toward Cr Larke but I do object to the grandstanding that he is pursuing.
Councillors expect a reasonable time to consider their position on matters that are important to the Shire, two hours for multiple motions and amendments is not reasonable - hence my rebuke was not in respect to a particular amendment but his overall approach and abuse of Council time. My comment goes to his failure to work as part of a team. A councillor cannot achieve anything on his or her own other than generate publicity for himself.
In respect to the document to which he refers I did sign a document that dealt with the span of control of managers. I had the expectation and had expressed the view at the time it would go to the CEO for his input and advice as to the accuracy of the figures in it and a possible long term strategy consistent with the reviews that are already underway.
The figures it turns out are spurious and self serving.
It was however represented to the CEO as a Councillor decision for implementation. I realised how stupid I had been and withdrew any association with the paper. I now have a better understanding of the procedures for Councillors to raise matters with the CEO and senior staff.
Cr Michael Whelan
An excellent article Catherine and insightful comments.
Thank you all.
Ursula Theinert
Quick decisions create regret.
Cr Larke's non attendance at pre briefings and meetings is showing his disinterest and disrepect to his fellow councillors, council officers, his ward constituents (the ones that voted him in) and the wider Bass Coast community. Rocking up on Council Meeting day with uninformed and wordy alternate recommendations (that you need a PhD to deipher) is wasting everyone's time - work with the team Cr Larke, you'll get much better results for the community. If your heart is not in it, or personal issues are taking a priority (which they should) step aside and let someone else take on the opportunity, and the training and the money.
H Torley
Victorian Ombudsman Statement: "In relation to briefing sessions for councillors, other states have specific legislation and guidance materials aimed at deterring agreement or consensus being reached by councillors in briefing sessions and other fora outside council meetings". I support that ethical approach.
Les Larke
How fortunate we are in Bass Coast, to have journalism of such excellence and rigour. Congratulations Catherine on your thoroughgoing research revealing and analysing Cr Larke's contribution to council's efforts.
For Cr Larke's, (or any other councillor bar Cr Le Serve), to claim credit for any improvement in council finances is spurious and pure hubris on his part, given the hard work invested by the previous council and the CEO, in long term financial planning, which is now, slowly bearing fruit.
Maddy Harford
June 24, 2017
The buggered boat ramp, the Grantville pot hole, line marking across the misty hills of Krowera, the three bin bonanza……the list is endless and clocks are ticking.
As one lone councillor I can shout from the Cape Horn Lookout but I need a mob to get things done…
… The VEC decreed that Bass Coast needed nine councillors and the underlying surplus of three councillors per ward infers a collegiate approach to collective action – or inaction, Hypocrites had the right idea: firstly, do no harm!
One of my electoral commitments was to fix that damn pot hole outside the Pharmacy and I could do it tonight – don my farmer’s hi viz, grab a bucket of gravel and ….fixed.
There are too many metaphorical pot holes and that’s where the mob steps up. I have yet to meet a council employee who wasn’t gainfully occupied with at least one task or question.
Many that I speak to are trying to prioritize several competing demands on council time and limited resources. What ever their title, they are working for the good of the community.
The need for teamwork is self evident – especially in a small shire with a huge coastline and shifting support from other levels of government.
The team needs to be the residents and ratepayers, the council and the councillors. The four year plan, SRP, annual budgets and long term financial and strategic plans are the things that bring us together – you spoke, we listened, this is what we heard, what do you reckon – a six month conversation and now we need to work together.
Council is not a reality TV show. We spend long days together and there are codes of conduct, local laws, state regulations and, what should be the most easily adhered to – the bounds of certain common courtesies and respect for each other.
There is a confidentiality around our deliberations but then there is a readership that wants to know what is going on. That line is as clear as diluted printer’s ink. Hopefully we haven't crossed it - I'm saving all those scribbled notes for my memoirs while watching for the next pot hole.
I agree with the comments about giving credit where it is due - we are building on reviews and strategies that commenced when I was simply a writer of letters to the editor(s). That ink's dried.
Cr Geoff Ellis
June 25, 2017
Les - Be not afraid of the criticism. Continue to have the courage to bring about the changes needed in fiscal and governance fields. The people who voted you in want that outcome. Expect betrayal. That's a part of human history. Chase the dynamics, articulate the case, get the numbers around you and pick the fruit higher up the tree leaving the low hanging stuff to those who do not have the reach. In cricket parlance it is time to take take the bowling apart. The silent majority are behind you. Good Luck!
Mohan de Run
Mohan, I always thought a majority was greater than 50%.
At the last election Cr Les Larke achieved a primary vote of just 16.79% and after distribution of preferences it increased to just 25% which is hardly support of the silent majority.
I note that former Cr Neil Rankine got 16.61% of the primary vote but was not elected.
I also note that after distribution of preferences there was just 14 votes between Mr larke's winning his seat on council and Mr Rankine's failure to retain his seat on council.
It is interesting to see that all the elected Councilors for Bunruong ward received 2.5 times to 3.5 times the preference votes that Mr Rankine received.
Which begs the question what preference deals were done, but that is another story.
Frank W Schooneveldt
Strange fruit ahead? Thanks for agreeing with me Mohan and can commentators please stick to one analogy/metaphor/simile/cliche per comment, please ?
I appreciate the follow on from Ms Harford's comment but cricket parlance tosses up so many words and phrases that I think references to people's stature (physical or moral) in comparison to orchards deplete the image of leather against willow. And better fit Austen-like forebodings of betrayal.
Geoff Ellis
June 26, 2017
Frank, while I agree with most things you have written and I enjoy your side of the story, I just want to be clear that there certainly weren't any deals done for preferences, not by myself anyway. While I did align myself with Max Wells and didn't hide from the fact, we (Max and myself) did not publish preference order and made it quite clear that while we shared similar ideals we were not running together as a 1 vote 2 vote.
In fact from memory Neil did publish preferences as did Jessica, Mohan and Mark. The other 5 Bunurong candidates didn't. Apart from the rate payers association which had me at 5 and Julian at 4 we all had to work hard for our votes.
I might not agree with all Cr Larke’s views on everything and he may have gotten the bonus of being number 1 on the ballot and the BCRRA's number 1 selection no one can deny he walked the miles, met the community and put in a campaign worthy of selection.
Hopefully this current hard working council will start getting results worthy of this robust discussion and I look forward to those moving forward.
Cr Brett Tessari
Brett, Thank you for the explanation. Local Government always creates robust debate. I am alll about results and not excuses.
Frank W Schooneveldt
Glad to hear that Frank; we are too. (all about results and not excuses).
Geoff Ellis
Excellent article Catherine, the analysis is spot on, people in glass houses shouldn't throw stones!
Lorrie Read
It took me a long time to understand my varied responsibilities when I was elected to State Parliament years ago. Government Departmental briefings, state wide organisations, businesses and not for profits, constituents,ALP, unions, local organisations, schools, local hospitals etc. provided me with invaluable correct information to ensure I could carry out my work as effective MP.
On the surface it appears to be so easy to balance a budget by reducing costs by reducing 40+ Shire employees.
The resultant reduction in Shire services would be a severe related cost to ratepayers. Also this huge reduction in wage earners within Bass Coast would be felt in less money spent on goods and services.
Cr. Larke cannot have thought through the outcomes of his draconian measure. It serves the Shire if Councillors are working together to deliver good governance. Cr Larke should review his stance on attending Shire Briefings, where he would have been advised of the folly of his purely financial view.
Kay Setches
Thank you Kay for your wise words. I totally agree.
Frank W Schooneveldt
A dog’s life
A beautiful story and thank you Jenni and a wonderful thing you have done. This quote came to me recently and I pass it on now: “Wherever you turn, you can find someone who needs you. Even if it is a little thing, do something for which there is no pay but the privilege of doing it. Remember, you don’t live in the world all of your own.”
~Albert Schweitzer
Joy Button
A wonderful article on the work DKD does and volunteers like your self Jenni - it is bittersweet but so worth it! I hope Sunday is a success!
Ant
Time and tide
June 26, 2017
Another excellent edition - thanks!
Meryl’s article was great. I was fascinated to learn of the Corinella volcanics - not an area I know well.
Mike: Is this another dot point in your prescription for action on climate change?
What if we re-created as many swamps as we could in the footprint of the ancient Kooweerup Swamp, using the water for local irrigation, recreation and biodiversity, and somehow letting as little as possible flow directly into Westernport Bay?
Rob Youl
The battle for the right to die
June 20, 2017
The irony of this topic is the fact that allowing an animal to suffer pain and distress is punishable by a jail sentence. Humans are required by law to suffer beyond their wishes. Some years ago, a local man with an aggressive cancer was alleged to have said: "If I was a mongrel dog, you'd put a bullet in me." He ended up delivering the bullet himself, as did another local man not long afterwards. I suspect this goes on every day.
I'm not surprised at the small number of comments regarding this article. Death is a topic that people find uncomfortable at the best of times, and so avoid where possible. Many people who have been in the same situation as Catherine and Geoff are unable to discuss it, such was the trauma of the experience, which is why Catherine and Geoff are to be thanked and commended for opening old wounds in order to try and make things easier for human beings who are dying. I am also aware of people who are unable to visit loved ones in certain medical facilities because of the memory of previous devastating experiences.
Thanks for getting this subject out of the too hard basket, and putting it on the table. In the meantime, remember that every time we part company with someone could be the last time we see them, regardless of age and current health status.
John Coldebella
A man of many parts
June 20, 2017
Many thanks Liane for your interesting story on John French. I was at the gallery one day and immediately drawn to the Warrior. The intricate detail of each mosaic depicting indigenous art was captivating. I glanced upwards and noted the tiny mosaics of models, most clad in lingerie, fascinated by the collective size of it all and was then called away. Some time later and from a distance, I was astounded to see these 'cheeky' bottoms lined up for all to admire! What a funfilled discovery that turned out to be and look forward to more of John's creativity on show at the gallery.
Vilya Congreave
The John Sparks mystery
June 19, 2017
The Wonthaggi RSL has been aware of Cpl John Sparks for more than three years and has held a copy of his service record. He was brought to the sub branch attention by a distance relative who presented the Wonthaggi RSL with framed photographs and replica medals at a ceremony attended by some ancestors of Cpl Sparks. More recently the Wonthaggi RSL has been assisting the Wonthaggi CFA with DVA and CWGC protocols to support their planned visit to France, and will continue to do so as requested by them.
The proper name for the "Dead Mans" Penny" is the "Memorial Plaque". its issue was accompanied by a letter from the King. Some 1,355,000 memorial plaques were issued representing some 450 tonnes of bronze. They were issued well into the 1930s to include those service personnel who died of war related injuries and illness. The Wonthaggi RSL does hold a memorial plaque. It was issued to honour the sacrifice of those veterans and their families as result of service in the Great War. To refer to the Memorial Plaque as macabre disrespects those veterans and their families who received the medallion issued by the Commonwealth as the highest recognition of their service. Just like the Returned from Active Service Badge", it is a humble reward for service but of great value to those families and individuals.
The Mapping our ANZACS website has been replaced by "Discovering our ANZACS" at the National Archives of Australia. Another important site is the "AIF Project" This website was developed by the University of New South Wales and the Australian Defence force Academy.
The Wonthaggi RSL has been researching the local veterans of WW1 from the Bass District, and has recently received a State Government Grant to develop a website dedicated to the veterans from this district. The website will include the burial information gathered by the "Friends of The Wonthaggi Cemetery": who have already passed on to the Wonthaggi RSL some 220 records of veterans buried at Wonthaggi, including 9 Prisoners of War from WW1.
The Wonthaggi RSL will later on this year re call the service of a veteran, born in Wonthaggi and Killed in Vietnam by placing a plaque on the wall adjacent to the Wonthaggi Cenotaph.
Rod Gallagher (Veteran), Secretary, Wonthaggi RSL
Wonderful story. Very well told. Beautiful.
Edward Buckingham
Dinosaur hunter
June 20, 2017
A great summing-up of Bass Coast's living treasure, Mike Cleeland, Geoff! Like myself and many others, you have obviously enjoyed listening to someone with a passion and with great knowledge about it and committed to finding out more.
Meryl Tobin
Somewhere over the rainbow
June 2, 2017
Phyllis, what a wonderful article. It is full of courage and you should be so proud of your trailblazing.
You have more than earned a place in society, to which you continue to contribute.
Pamela Rothfield
June 4, 2017
Thank you so much Pam. I truly believe that all Councillors who supported the motion for Marriage Equality at the last Council meeting are the true heroes. My response was due to the negative and highly inflammatory prejudiced comments made by several members of the community in the previous edition of Bass Coast Post.
Phyllis Papps
I agree with Pam a great snapshot of a movement - and you have shown great courage in your life.
Michael Whelan
June 5, 2017
Thanks Phyllis and BCP. One of the many great things about the Post is the freedom to express ourselves sans editorial interference.
Geoff Ellis
Thank you for telling us your story Phyllis and thank god we have people as you both that have given life long support and activism to equality for all. Hopefully one day we will get there.
Clare Le Serve
June 3, 2017
Phyllis and Francesca: Thank you for sharing your courage with us and enabling people to emerge from the shadows. One day that bit of paper, that says so much, will be available to all.
Geoff Ellis
Thank you Phyllis for such a beautiful rendition of yours & Francesca's journey. You have both demonstrated great courage & truth.
With all my heart I hope your dream will come true. In the mean time - Thank you.
Marie Broussard
My sincere thanks to everyone for their very positive comments on Bass Coast Post and for the Emails and phone calls we have received. Let's hope true equality is well on the way for everybody - irrespective of race, gender, age, color, education, political beliefs etc. The list is endless.
Phyllis Papps
It is always inspiring to read the story of true trail blazers, thanks for sharing your story Phyllis and Francesca you really are an inspiration to all who seek equality. I wish my lesbian daughter was able to share the rights taken for granted by her heterosexual sisters. Until all members of society are free to express their love for each other in the same way, we are not truly equal. Well done to Bass Coast Shire for their support. Over to you Malcolm!
Lorrie Read
Absolutely agree with you Lorrie up to "are not truly equal". I just do not think that the Bass Coast Shire Council has a role here. Nor do they have a mandate.
Let’s ask the Bass Coast Shire to make a Proclamation that we : Openly and proudly proclaim the fundamental right that within the Shire of Bass Coast all human souls are equal regardless of their race, colour, religion, disability or sexual orientation and will be treated with equal respect, kindness and civility as one would expect for one's self.
Then over to Malcolm and Bill to see what the population of Australia want regarding same sex marriage. This is a democracy! We all get a say in what happens. And that is a wonderful and treasurable thing, the envy of many.
Ruth Partridge
What I’ve learnt
June 2, 2017
Congratulations, Brett, on the ability to take on board truths of which you had been unaware and change your perspective. A rare skill in adults. I wholeheartedly support your acceptance of united humanities' differences. Yes we need to support peoples choice of a partner in life, yes we need to provide our youth every opportunity for growth and security. I am happy that you are on our council.
Felicia Di Stefano
Great issues Brett - yes we have to take them on and ensure we keep them front of mind. We probably cannot achieve solutions but we can achieve progress and hopefully assist people in their journey. Nice article.
Michael Whelan
Good on you Brett for writing such a thoughtful article. At the forum (run by BCS for future planning ) that I attended front and centre was the need for things to happen in our Shire for our youth. And viva la difference as the French say. We are all human beings and the permutations of gender, values, hopes and aspirations especially of young people must always be included in Shire forward planning. Keep up with what is important to young people, They are the future of our world.
Yvonne McRae
June 4, 2017
Brett, well said and well thought out. Being a Councillor certainly raises your awareness and provides an opportunity to change things for the better.
I concur and will do whatever I can to advocate for their safe place.
And any number of people have pointed at that big empty ex-coles building and said what a great place - it could be a home for several community groups.
Geoff Ellis
On board MH128
June 2, 2017
Congratulations on your quick thinking and bravery, Fab and Troy. You helped diffuse a dangerous situation, bomb or no bomb. Thank you for sharing their story, Nina. You and Troy's wife and boys had a lot of pluck to let them continue their journey!
Meryl Tobin
June 3, 2017
OMG. A well told tale of bravery. Have to wonder how bomb-like "black device about 40 centimetres round and 15 centimetres high" passed through security.
Geoff Ellis
June 4, 2017
These two men should be nominated for a bravery award along with that heroic stewardess. What a courageous trio of people.
Lyn Blom
To be or not to be
June 2, 2017
Thank you, Catherine, on enlightening us about the limitations of the current Victorian Government bill on assisted dying. Despite its apparent limitation, the bill, if passed would be a first step in the right direction. As well, the strict parameters of its conditions, should allay the main fears of its detractors.
Felicia Di Stefano
June 4, 2017
There are compelling arguments on both sides of the debate and I'm sitting on the fence, I believe Victoria should not rush into the lead on this issue. Standards,Values and Ethics have dropped alarmingly in the last decade. Deception is rampant in every space of life. Before this is allowed, lets plug all the loopholes, after we see what happens in NSW.
Mohan de Run
June 6, 2017
No need to sit on the fence - start a Rip Van Winkle movement so we never move forward. Ever.
Geoff Ellis
The Battle for Western Port
June 2, 2017
Great effort Jeff and the team - we must stay vigilant in the interests of Westernport,
I look forward to Brian Paynter and the other candidates in the upcoming State Election declaring their support for Preserving Westernport - not just from a Port but from other development also.
Michael Whelan
Brothers and sisters
June 5, 2017
I don’t agree with Rob Easton’s views but like all on his side of the debate, he is entitled to his opinion.
I do not believe the majority of the voting public in this country are ready to accept marriage equality and many like me, share the fear of the unintended consequences, especially for the children of today.
So for the sake of the children, who are the future of every country, I say to both sides, press for the plebiscite.
That will be a fair way of dealing with this proposed piece of social engineering and I for one will respect that outcome.
Should the Marriage equality group believe they have the numbers for a change in the law, there is no reason to fear the plebiscite and they should lobby the crossbench senators to bring in whatever amendments are necessary to the bill before them in the senate to ensure the outcome of the Plebiscite receives full endorsement in both houses of parliament.
Mohan de Run
One of the great things about the Bass Coast Post is the ability for people to exchange views and opinions in a public, un-moderated forum.
I respect your views and as I said in the preamble to item F4 you can not legislate morality and I do not want to challenge people's beliefs.
Our motion has nothing to do with social engineering, we are adding weight to the community push for equality and a change to legislation that should better reflect the social norm. As always the inertia built into our democracy needs to be overcome occasionally.
I am glad that you have declared that Rob and I, "like everyone on" our "side of the debate" are entitled to our opinion, that's a particularly benevolent attitude, thank you.
I do not fear 'the plebiscite' - the proposal was for non-binding one so it was simply pointless, merely another Kanute-like gesture. There are better ways to spend $160 million dollars.
I agree that we need to press for our elected representatives to achieve a result in both houses of parliament but why not just press them to have a conscience vote based on what their electorates tell them - if we need to put this to a plebiscite we also need to run a number of other matters through a similar process. Let’s start with plebiscites about coal mines, climate change, free trade, refugee quotas, coward punch laws, euthanasia, penalty rates, tougher sentencing, the age limit for drinking, which schools should be built, .....mmmmm....maybe it’s easier to get politicians to do what they know is right and fair. It's why we vote for them.
That's just my opinion, of course.
Geoff Ellis
We do: Bass Coast commits
May 20, 2017
There are a great many rate payers of profound faith who will disagree with the Council's public display of political correctness. There are a great many rate payers of no faith at all who will agree with them.
This is not Council business! You do not have a mandate to make such a decision.
Ruth Partridge
Ruth, they have EVERY such mandate. Elected representatives are there for the purpose of ensuring the community (not just white, straight, AngloSaxons) are represented. Ruth, a mandate is not only what legislative capabilities they have as elected representatives, it's a mandate for their MORAL duty and ETHICAL code to ensure the broader Bass Coast Community is represented. And that, they have done! Well done, Bass Coast Councillors. May we continue to be represented in legislation AND ethos/morality for many years to come! You have provided a beacon of guidance to this community, And Councillors, and you should be commended for it!
Rob Easton
Did the council as me for my views..NO So why should we accept their views.....NO.
Does the council get things right NO.....
So ask for the ratepayers opinion before you think you know what we want....Get our views...or is that to hard to do
May Gardner
Not at all hard, May, but MAJORITY of our community, across the nation, support EQUALITY and FAIRNESS before the law; just as majority of our community, across the shire, feel the same. Bigotry and small-mindedness will get you, me, and us absolutely nowhere. Wake up and smell the 2017 Roses. They are full of colour and full of diversity. You might enjoy it!
Rob Easton
The views of the silent majority will always prevail at the right time and place no matter the attempt of the loud few who wish to push for dangerous social engineering for the limp reasons that it is contemporary thinking or unreliable belief that it makes a difference. That vast majority know different and will properly consider the unintended consequences of going against nature.
Mohan de Run
Mohan de Run, going against nature? I have a few studies I can reference that might prove otherwise... Nature, life and biology in general is fluid and ever evolving. As is sexuality. Only the inability to acknowledge it remains a stagnant and flaccid part of our ever-present (and in my opinion) long out-of-date religious heritage that dictates a status-quo no longer relevant or correct. I hate to tell you, but it's now high time and long overdue that we respect, embrace and support each other, rather than discount the rights of your fellow citizens. Perhaps get out more, meet a few of your LGBTIQ friends and neighbours, realise that they are not in fact an abomination, but just that same as you. They pay the same taxes, respect the same laws ... and deserve the same rights before the law that you hold so dear. Let's hope you don't have a child, brother, sister, niece, nephew, friend who happens to 'go against nature' -- I hate to think the reception you'll provide them when they need someone to explain why their community thinks them only an 'unreliable belief' !! Our councillors have acknowledged that their community is just as broad as the rest of our great Nation and have shown just how committed they are to ensuring cohesion and acceptance. Feel free to join the cause.
Rob Easton
A Gay and Happy Future
In love, the two plan
a long life together
But marriage plans rest
with a prime minister, his
party and maybe a plebiscite
the result of which colleagues
might or might not
respect.
Meryl Brown Tobin
All the more reason to put some weight behind the argument Meryl. Hopefully The Prime Minister and his party, and all those cross-benchers and opposition members may just listen and think with their hearts... for once! Well done to our local Council for thinking outside of party politics and agendas, and supporting our community (no matter their sexual preferences, religion or backgrounds) !
Rob Easton
Back in October 2014, Bass Coast Shire Council proclaimed its support for marriage equality by agreeing with the request from Byron Shire Council to develop, adopt and endorse a proclamation which was then compiled and presented to the Prime Minister by the aforementioned Council.
As formally outlined in a dot point proclamation and agglutinated here – “we believe our elected leaders have a responsibility to protect the rights of all citizens, the current law needs to change and that is it about human rights and respect, celebrating diversity and inclusion”.
Strategic justification was easy – as part of the healthy communities objective, the aim was to foster wellness in a supportive, inclusive, healthy and active community. The debate was insightful, personal, respectful and the motion was carried six to one, translating to 85 per cent.
The current council’s vote of seven for, one absent and one abstaining, the percentage three years on, is open to interpretation. With the plethora of national polls in the public realm ranging from 64-70 per cent support for marriage equality, with the standout being our inclusively minded and socially responsible young people (18-24) at 81%, it seems support is increasing with time, as you would expect, our elected representatives are quite representative of the community they serve and a change to the Act is hopefully imminent.
Jordan Crugnale, Bass Coast Shire councillor 2012-16
Kick start for Cowes
May 20, 2017
Michael. Well said.
John Wright
I totally agree
Marilyn Shaw
Ditto
Peter Brown
It's all good and it's a start but for the life of me I cannot understand why we are not building the Philip Island Aquatic Centre and renovating the Wonthaggi Aquatic Centre now.
We have the financial capacity to do so.
We live in times of historic low interest rates so it's a good time to borrow money now and to lock in interest rates for the longer term.
The Council should ask questions; like where are we now, where do we want to be and how are we going to get there.
The population of Bass Coast will grow and we need to build infrastructure to catchup with current needs and underpin future ones.
Think the City of Bass Coast, what it will look like and how we are going to meet that challenge.
Frank W Schooneveldt
The progress being made by Council to invest and re-invigorate Phillip Island is to be commended.
As a healthy democracy supports the majority, it must be appreciated that there will always be public debate and dissent on issues of priority.
As the community have endlessly demonstrated significant support for a Phillip Island Aquatic center this deserves to receive immediate council support in both word and funding.
Ian Samuel
Well stated Michael ... press ahead !
Garry Busowsky
I couldn't agree more, Cowes needs new investment and revitalising, let's work together to smarten it up for the celebrations next year.
Lorrie Read
Dear Mr Andrews
May 5, 2017
If the mayor manages a meeting with the premier, could he please be thanked for the $30 million of desal water - it will be useful for damping down the asbestos fibres swirling around the ancient corridors of Wonthaggi Secondary college - in an alternative universe it would have made more sense to spend those millions on a new school.........
Mark Robertson
Hear hear to the Mayor's message. Well said and I hope that we can extract a solid commitment - maybe next (election) year.
Geoff Ellis
The Age last Wednesday reported that the budget would fund nine new schools (only one in the east at Pakenham) and 108 schools would be upgraded. I can't imagine that there are 108 schools in Victoria in a worse condition than Wonthaggi. I look forward to hearing the Premier's response to this issue.
Anne Heath Mennell
Good point, Anne, but it's possibly a hopeful sign. The government wouldn't want to spent money on upgrading the current school if they are planning to replace it. I think next year (before the election) will be our year but in the meantime we must become noisy and annoying.
Catherine Watson
I hope that they listen to you this time, they haven't before, but keep pushing Pam. Have you noticed that other than some expenditure on the rail system to the valley, NOTHING has been allocated anywhere South East of Melbourne with the exception of the Pakenham area. It's as if we don't exist or would it be that the Premier and his cohorts are all geographically challenged or were the relevant pages of their Melways been removed. I know one party I won't support come election time. Just a clue Premier, it's just a very short drive from your white elephant (the desal plant) to the town centre.
Barrie Stewart
I agree with Mayor Rothfield's comments, however l remind the people of Bass Coast that this is not an election year.
I have been looking at the State of Victoria's balance sheet that reveals cash and cash equivalents balance forecast for the 30th June 2017 of $7.2 billion and that is forecast to grow to $9.5 billion by 30th June 2021. Obviously the Victorian government does not have any money issues and could easily fund the Wonthaggi high school and other infrastructure projects if it wanted to.
This is a huge war chest that will be spent at the Government's choosing. We, the people of Bass Coast need to shout a lot louder.
Frank W Schooneveldt
All aboard for Port Albert
What a wonderful way of taking us back in time through this narrative. Reading about history in this manner is not an exercise of dates and places (which I can never remember!), but a marvellous journey.
Liane Arno
Clear as mud
May 4, 2017
Cr. Les Larke's spiel re the budget would lose most people the will to live. A 'transformational approach'? Perhaps with Cr. Larke interested in the Wonthaggi Cemetery ratepayers bored to death by his ramblings and goobledegook could get a 'cut-price' plot?
Yvonne McRae
April 23, 2017
I believe it's about time that Cr Larke ought understand his role as a Councillor. He is elected to represent his constituents and not unlike any member of a board is there on Council, in conjunction with his elected colleagues, to set and monitor strategic direction.
It certainly is not his role to "harass financial staff", as reported, and be involved in financial detail.
In fact he ought not approach Council staff other than those whom the CEO permits.
Warren Nichols
April 23, 2017
If Cr Larke is so concerned (obsessed) about financial transparency, maybe he should consider resigning from his current role as Councillor. Sooner rather than later. Much time and money would be saved. Or, he might like to consider that he's not really value for money, at all. His role is as a municipal Councillor and his duties are to represent the residents and ratepayers of Bunurong ward. It seems Cr Larke prefers to be an unofficial representative of the CPA and loves to grandstand his knowledge of financial matters. I note that Cr Larke signs letters with his CPA credentials, followed by his Cr title. No man can serve two masters, and I'm sick of my rates funding a pedantic and myopic councillor.
Julie Tyrrell
April 22, 2017
Thank you Catherine. This made excellent reading!
I had a conversation with Cr Larke during the campaign and, like Nola, I was disappointed to see that my fears about his approach to the role of councillor were realised from the 'get go'.
Maddy Harford
Thank you Catherine for this enlightened report.
I have read the Councils Strategic Resource Plan (SRP) and next years Budget that was released on Friday afternoon.
These are impressive documents and I offer my congratulations to all involved.
The Budget appears to be framed on a conservative basis and we appear to have scope to build more infrastructure like cultural centers and swimming pools.
The Council's finances are in good shape.
We all need to work together for the greater good of the Bass Coast.
Cheers
Frank Schooneveldt
April 22, 2017
I am glad to read Mr Schooneveldt's positive feedback.
I value the results of informed scrutiny and I encourage all members of the community to offer feedback on matters that they feel might be of importance.
I totally agree that "We all need to work together for the greater good of the Bass Coast".
Cr Geoff Ellis
Thankyou Catherine for the information re Councillors. As a resident of Bunurong, I was disappointed with the last council election result. My fears are being realised. We could have ben represented by many more enlightened people rather than a time waster. Cr Larke might be a man of many words but didn't even bother to auto acknowledge an email I sent him, let alone make a reply. We need positive people who want to make a genuine contribution to the shire.
Nola Smith
Nola, I understand that every email and every issue is important and I can personally vouch for the tireless effort that Cr Larke has put into following up people's concerns and ideas. He has been a role model in this area.
I can also personally attest to the high volume of emails that are received by your representatives.
I know I haven't replied to all the emails sent to me, for various reasons, one of which is the time required for a worthy reply. I do read them all and trust that the senders know that I treat them on their merits and action them accordingly.
I also would like to point out that general enquiries can be made to basscoast@basscoast.vic.gov.au and these will be passed on to Councillors when appropriate.
Cr Geoff Ellis (Western Port Ward)
Geoff. I think what Nola has suggested is that, if the volume of e-correspondence is high, then a polite way to deal with this is in the first instance, to set up an 'auto response' that, at the very least, acknowledges receipt.
I certainly don't see Cr Larke as a positive model of any aspects of the role of councillor. He has been unremittingly negative about community development and seemingly obsessed with the minutiae of numbers, persisting even in the face of acknowledged authority on the subject.
Maddy Harford
Light at the end of the tunnel
April 23, 2017
Hello. Thanks for another great entertaining and informative article. Have seen this type of burrow a number of times in the district and wondered if they were worms. Never heard of these critters- I'd thought they might have been to do with the local scorpion varieties.. great. Thanks again!
Karen Sandon
Thanks Geoff, I enjoy your stories.
Jan Fleming
May 1, 2017
Quick Update - there are now over a dozen of these chimneys on the lawn between the side fence and the house - the very similar land on the other side of the fence has NONE but that is where the cows graze.
Geoff Ellis
Our John Clarke
April 18, 2017
I immediately grabbed my phone and called many friends. "John Clarke Has died!" were the first words I spoke. Most of the calls I received that day, those were the first words spoken to me. Incredulity, shock followed by despair and desolation for this irreplaceable loss.
That day I attended a fundraising lunch for Emilys List, the financial and mentoring network that works to increase the number of ALP women MPs in Australian Parliaments,where Julia Gillard, the first Woman Prime Minister of Australia, was the guest speaker.
Almost the first words spoken to me from Julia were "John Clarke has died" followed by the most sincere comments on how much she enjoyed the Clarke/Dawe interviews, they were an absolute must to see on TV.
Julia said that no matter who is in Government, political satire as John wrote and performed year after year, is the cornerstone of a true democracy. We have to be prepared for such close uncomfortable scrutiny and the resultant comedy.
I have been an MP and Minister in former state Governments, and have a particular insight into the effectiveness and discomfort of such incisive, surgical and topical hilarious comedy. I hope we can learn from John's played back observations.
Like all good and valued people, we can't imagine a world without them until the calamity of their loss.
His marvellous mischievous, highly intelligent observations turned into so many types of visual and written comedy has been a great gift from John to all of us.
What will I do now on Wednesday evenings prior to the ABC TV news?
Kay Setches, Surf Beach
April 16, 2015
Thank you Liz and Anne and Kellie for sharing your memories and comments about John Clarke. While his mother country was New Zealand we have every right to embrace him as a Bass Coaster. Both he and his long time friend and brother in arms Brian Dawes had strong Island connections.
Bob Middleton, Wonthaggi
April 15, 2017
John Clarke, along with Dr Tim Ealey, John Barnard, QC, and the late Professor John
Swan, started the Western Port Seagrass Partnership in 2001 at a time when seagrass loss in Western Port was dire. Clarke conceived of and hosted a beautiful and hard-hitting DVD on Western Port's environment, including footage from the research program of the 1970s. The DVD has been widely distributed for free by the WPSP and is still available from their website.
Last October Clarke was the guest speaker for the dinner of the Museums Australia Victoria conference on Churchill Island. Rather than crack jokes, he took advantage of being in the company of many of Australia's brightest museum and gallery people to tell them about the battles to save the Western Port environment, and urge them to take action to save their local environments. Clarke also practised what he preached, planting seagrass and revegetating the land he had at Rhyll. Western Port will greatly miss such a champion.
Christine Grayden, Cowes
It was lovely to read tributes to John Clarke by Anne Davie, Liz McDonald and Kellie Nichols in Bass Coast Post. As they showed, he was a very special person. Like many thousands of others, we greatly enjoyed the five minute program Clarke and Dawe on Channel 2 each Thursday at 6.55 pm. His death is a great loss not only to his family and friends but also to the wider community, including the millions of people whose lives he enhanced with his comic genius and his love and protection of the environment which enriched past, present and future generations.
Deepest sympathy to his family.
Meryl and Hartley Tobin, The Gurdies
Thank you, Dr Brooks
Outstanding tribute to a great man, who will be sadly missed by our entire community.
Roger Clark, Grantville
Let’s just do it
April 14, 2017
I totally agree.
Frank Schooneveldt
I totally agree as well. Build it and they will come is an old saying that springs to mind.
Steven Haby
April 21, 2017
Yes. Yes. Let's just do it, and the sooner the better as our need for such a centre is really urgent. To keep Phillip Island up to a standard, and with facilities to be proud of; which fills such a long-felt want for so many people - residents, business-people, visitors, tourists - a top class centre is essential. Barbara Brierley
Natasha's take
April 12, 2017
Roaming through past articles some weeks ago it suddenly hit me what a great body of work (30 plus) cartoonist Natasha has contributed to the Bass Coast Post. Each cartoon has been created with skill and insight and unerringly hits the mark. Of course I have my favourite but since it enhances an article I submitted I am reluctant to disclose which one.
Bob Middleton, Wonthaggi
Remembering Kit Sleeman
April 1, 2017
You have done well with this story ........................thank you
Rosemary Loughnan, Wonthaggi
Kit's achievements continue to amaze me.
Sue
Kit was a man of many talents. Love reading his essays.
Meryl Collis
Kit was a very talented and interesting person Along with his parents and brother they all had a wealth of knowledge on Wonthaggi and its history..
"Part of my Heart in Wonthaggi"
Terri
Crossing the border
April 4, 2017
Loved reading about your jaunt to Buronga and your adventures but my favourite tale of yours is still your trip to the chook show. Just enjoy your stories ... thank you.
Joy Button
Thanks for sharing your delightful story with us Bob. So good to enjoy another of your gems in The Post again!
Linda Cuttriss
Bob, I too was confronted with the Castlemaine Rail Steps. My companion took both cases and was at the bottom while I was only three steps down. Thank heavens for good friends and partners.
Joan Woods, Wonthaggi
View from the chamber
April 1, 2017
Hear Hear! I commend your diligence and fully endorse another example of strong leadership.
I totally agree that, although the deliberations around Phillip Island Aquatics have been long running, to say the least, we will achieve an outcome that provides good amenity and great facilities that encourage people to visit the Island as well as meeting the needs of the community.
I would also like to note my admiration for the decades long effort that the Phillip Island Aquatic Centre working group.
Well done Pam - a great explanation of the decision making process, well reasoned and well written.
And thanks to the BCP for providing a forum for free and open discussion of Council matters.
Geoff Ellis, Krowera
I wholeheartedly agree with comments made. I would strongly suggest that a far better, fairer and more easily accessible location (particularly at major event times) would be Anderson Roundabout. This location would provide access to thousands more folk in the hinterland and an associated cafe would become a regular meeting place to thousands of visitors too.
Karen Sandon
Thank you Pam, for your common sence. Traffic on Phillip Island is an ongoing problem we do not want to make it even worse.
Ventnor Road, ajoining the Circus land, I understand the shire bought back from them! would be ideal for this venture.
We must think ahead, Phillip Island is not the quiet little hamlet it used to be. We all need to realize that, and look to the future.
Well done and keep up the good work.
Pamela J Gill JP
Pam needs to be congratulated on her rational analysis and support for a Cowes based Aquatic Centre
There is only one chance to build this important community facility in a location which provides for potential expansion and access to vehicle traffic.
I concur with Pamela Gill that location of the facility at the Ventnor road property acquired by the Bass Coast Council for this purpose is the appropriate site.
Ian Samuel
A weight on your mind
April 1, 2017
An amazing,insightful,and sensible article about the relationship between stress and the way,and what we eat. Has given me plenty of food for thought,pardon the pun. Thank you!
Michelle Graham, Pioneer Bay
Think the City of Bass Coast
March 12, 2017
I was most intrigued to read in the Sentinel-Times of the 7th March 2017 that said “In lieu of the upcoming 2017/18 budget Bass Coast Shire Councillors have requested that a report of the shire’s current financial state be released for April 2017. Councillors are leaning heavily on their commitment to financial conservatism”.
Does this imply the Council’s distrust in the monthly financial reporting package that the Council currently receives prepared by Council Staff?
Does this tell us that the Council can’t determine the financial position of the Shire from the monthly financial reports?
I would suggest that the Councillors calls for a twelve month rolling cash flow forecast that reveals monthly income and expenses with forecast monthly closing cash and cash equivalent balance.
I would suggest Councillors calls for the Shires borrowing capacity on a monthly basis.
I suggest that the Bass Coast needs to grow and to grow you need to build infrastructure. If you don’t grow you wither and die.
I suggest that the Councillors need to learn words like ‘do’, ‘can’, ‘how’ because it is actions that speak greater than words.
I suggest that the way to grow is through population growth.
Think the City of Bass Coast and how are we going to get there.
Frank W Schooneveldt
Crunch time
March 4, 2017
Geoff so very well written, much easier looking from the outside in … but hey, we are privileged to be representing the community to the best of our abilities. We have got a few things right.
Brett Tessari
Well done councillor. So good to get a first-hand account from an insider. Do hope there will be progressive reports during your term and that we also hear from your fellow councillors as to their thoughts and aspirations.
Bob Middleton
Congratulations Geoff . . . an excellent insight into the present Council. It is so refreshing to read and hear your thoughts regarding some very controversial decisions that have been taken in recent times. I stand and applaud the Council's consultative approach and the boldness in making decisions that are unpopular for some but as has been demonstrated recently, supported by a large number in the community.
Joy Button
I reckon you're a brave person Geoff - both for taking on the responsibilities that come with being a councilllor as well as writing your impressions for us all to see. Both will get you brick bats no doubt, but hey not from me! I hear your empathy and heart ache about those broken hearts in which some of your votes resulted. And we all know that's inevitable when there's a limited amount of money to share out - just like most of our households really.
Then there are those poorest of the poor people who live in poverty on less than A$2 a day with no Centrelink support. These are the just under a billion people on our planet who have no access to basic services like education, fresh water, health care and sanitation. They are the ones that break my heart - it's just luck that I'm not one of them.
So thank you Geoff and all the other councillors for doing their difficult work keeping our 'basic services' running - and then providing extras to make us even happier!
Sue Packham
March 5, 2017
Geoff, It's all about running a business, that's the role you have taken on and worked hard to win.
When you run a business you are more than aware your decisions affect everybody you employ, often their extended family and you can also impact the lives of both your customers and suppliers but the task is to do the job to the best of your ability, if you’re looking over your shoulder or trying to please all the people all the time you are not the person to be doing the job and will fail.
In the end in any job you’re not the person who decides if you’re the best person for the job, it’s somebody else. Be true to yourself and be well prepared and present your views and beliefs. Unless your name’s Rupert Murdoch you have to accept that if the management group decide something you don't agree with the whole group is locked into supporting that decision and get on with implementation of that decision. Next time your idea might be supported by majority then you would expect support from the rest of the group. That applies in business and Council is a business.
Christopher Day
Geoff, I love your writing, your honesty and your ethics - I love working with you. You have so much to contribute.
Pamela Rothfield
March 8, 2017
Thank you Geoff for sharing your story. Now you have an idea what the previous councillors were subjected to under difficult circumstances, trying to please everyone. It is also warming to see councillors supporting one another, a crucial requirement of any smooth running team. Having said that, could we have a little less self-congratulation. Evaluation of performance is perhaps best left to non-elected ratepayers, and as you pointed out, your term in office is still in its very early days. The kind of transparency ratepayers require is to keep being informed of council decisions and the relevant details associated with any moves the council makes. Eg. When it is announced that a report is being prepared for council, we need to know who is preparing it, and at what cost. Consultancy was a major criticism of the last council.
To all the new councillors, keep up the cohesion in the midst of vigorous debate. Good luck, and may your term continue to expand you.
PS. If you can get hold of a copy of the grade three reader from the 1960's entitled "among friends", there's a story called "trying to please everyone". It's such a good yarn, they used to tell it to 8 year old children. Keep up the good work. While you process the hate, remember those who admire you for all the right reasons.
John Coldebella
D-day for Aquasure
March 3, 2017
I am interested in knowing more about the details of the contractual agreement entered into by AquaSure and the people of Victoria in relation to the supply of water. Is it the case that AquaSure is obliged to produce water regardless of existing supply, or is Victoria obliged to buy water, regardless of existing supply. There is a difference. Or is it as Forest Gump would say, "maybe it's a little bit of both. . . . . . at the same time.
Is there anybody out there who can tell us exactly what we have signed up to? It does seem odd to produce water, given the current storage levels.
John Coldebella
You can compare owning a boat and having a desal plant, They are both usually expensive to obtain and even more to maintain over time, We think of how much we might do with our boat, but we end up throwing a lot more money into it and get very little pleasure from it. Desal is the "States" boat, what a price, and we are still throwing money at it, how much more must we cough up. Water Minister Neville says that the extra costs will be borne by AquaSure and Ausnet, I can't wait to see how quickly they pass the costs on to consumers. Roll on State Elections.
Barrie Stewart
In light of the recent desal/diesel furore several things have become apparent. Firstly, the willingness of AquaSure to risk the health and amenity of residents (and ratepayers) in their desperate attempt to protect profit margins and deliver a pointless water order is simply astonishing. As such, any future statements regarding their care for our community and environment should be taken with a very large pinch of salt (pun intended).
On the other hand, the determination of locals to grasp the rampaging white elephant by the tusks has been magnificent. Concerned community members, Bass Coast shire councillors and the environmental defenders all stood up to the corporate bully in a display of the true meaning of community spirit -the protection of our special coastal home.
Even the EPA had serious concerns about the impacts of the hastily-assembled, filth-spewing generators. It appears that we have, for now, been spared the choking fumes and noise of AquaSure’s Plan b, but we must still endure the many truckloads of chemicals and barrowloads of cash flowing to the plant, along with the 40 tonnes per day of dead marine life leaving. And we are paying handsomely for this - more than $600 million this year.
It will soon be time for our state government to consider next year’s order of water- with an election on the horizon will they prop up the corporate cowboys or spend our money on schools and hospitals? We were promised worlds-best-practice - really?
Mark Robertson. President, Watershed Victoria
Nothing wasted
March 6, 2017
Very interesting Jordan, it is certainly an eye opener compared to how we manage waste here.
I had the opportunity of visiting my sister, who lives in Spain. They have the same system, and everyone is used to this way, of protecting the environment.
What a wonderful thing it would be if we also could go with our jug or glass bottle and collect fresh milk daily and cream on top. This is how I remember my childhood years, growing up in England.
Thank you for sharing your recent experiences
Pamela J Gill
March 9, 2017
How I enjoyed the Foreign Correspondent in the last edition of the Post. It is wonderful that people who live in our community can share their very special and informative experiences, when they return from overseas.
The small community of Alfedeno is truly inspirational with its commitment to recycling and waste management. We all need to take individually and collectively care of the environment in our Shire and thereby contribute to a healthy planet.
Anne Davie
Heslop’s Wonthaggi
February 25, 2017
John, Thank you for this. Robert Heslop subdivided the land on which our property in Boundary Road sits. Original title makes for Interesting reading. It's exciting to read who he was.
Frank Schooneveldt
John, thanks for publishing this, fascinating! I am interested in the mention that there was a ruined house of wattle and daub at 'The Wattles' when Heslop snr bought it. Do you have any idea who would have built this original cottage? Thanks
Chris
Wonthaggi’s blackest day
". . . . deep silence. . . . . many were moved to tears.” How comforting to know there are sentient beings in our midst. People with empathy for strangers. There is hope.
John Coldebella
Wonthaggi highball stadium
February 17, 2017
Finally we have some councillors showing some common sense. Council is a business it needs to get back to the basics of providing services it's responsible for not going off into dreamland spending millions of reports that then never happen because surprise there is no funding. Yes there are many needs for our communities but normally they have to be funded whether by federal or state governments or mix of all three levels of government.
In San Remo area the council was looking to extend the town boundary and add 700 new blocks of land in addition to developments like Keam’s land already within existing boundary. The issue was and still is how would the infrastructure cope with this expansion when it was coping with current size of town, especially in the tourism season.
After numerous meetings with community, hours of work 2 independent reports which council and state government approved and signed off what's happened over 5 years? Well the developments are happening land is being sold, great more rates for council. What's happened to all the recommendations for council and state government to implement, basically nothing!
When recent meeting with councillors held same issues came up only now getting worse, lot of head nodding but when is anybody going to do something about the issues affecting every resident and visitor highlighted in the report? The solutions are there but if nobody starts doing something about it, it's just going to get worse and worse as the population and visitor numbers increase. Doing nothing doesn't solve the problem.
Chris Day
February 17, 2017
My concern over this sorry decision is the lack of vision, the incompetence of all involved and the fear of what is the future ? It just seems so amateurish that councillors have to vote on a proposal presented to them with no price tag until the last moment. In saying that this project has been on the radar for that many years it's not funny. Countless numbers of people have looked at the project for over 20 years yet not one group of councillors have had the intestinal fortitude to look beyond the price tag. Not one has looked at how other councils not only build these facilities but use them. We have councils in bush fire areas and flood areas using stadiums as emergency shelters, we have councils using them for flower shows, wedding expos, tournaments for all ranges of sports. Our neighbours in the South Gippsland shire at Korumburra regularly use theirs for big cabarets, music shows, big football functions etc. This is without the basketball, volleyball, every kind of ball you could imagine being bounced, hit thrown and the use by football clubs in the middle of winter. I accept that previous administrations have let down the people of bass coast by not building the infrastructure that is desperately needed throughout the shire. Someone has to have the guts to start building some of these projects or there are generations of people that will miss out on so much that other shires take for granted.
Andy Thomas
February 19, 2017
All councillors were briefed on Nov. 23rd. If Crs Brown and Larke were so concerned why didn't they asked for a costing back then? Where is the mention of anything to do with people or community in Browns excuses?
Cr. Larke for all of his fiscal excuses and his pursuit of financial responsibility from Council Officers, could have asked way back about costs to ratepayers. The figure that council could have gone ahead with was up to $2 million. Until the submission was funded the local sporting bodies could have pursued other funding thus reducing councils cost. The facility would have been profitable and thus provided a return to council. Unfortunately we will never know as the blind five had no idea what was possible and a very narrow view of excuses around money instead of deferring a decision and doing some investigating. The five showed their unsuitability for a Council in need of providing for all its community.
Lou Godfrey
February 19, 2017
The CEO presented this funding opportunity to council on 23 November 2016.
Mandy Lean
February 19, 2017
Yes we were briefed last November. We were also briefed again by the CEO the week before the Council meeting - we knew the order of magnitude but not the specific amount.
A key consideration in this, as Cr Tessari points out, is that unlike many grant rounds, we were to be given the opportunity to pursue other grants money and had the prospect of substantially reducing our contribution. $2 million was the outside provision we had to make and we could have withdrawn at any time.
Stage 2 of the Swimming Pool development includes a high ball stadium we will still have to find that money at that time.
Cr Michael Whelan
Going, going saved
February 17, 2017
Wow. So basically we have a new Council as bad as the old one- focused only on money except when some loud-mouths make a hoohah in which case they will bow to the whims of the mob. And I had so much hope. Disappointed with the new Council.
Mikhaela Barlow
March 4, 2017
The Messiah has a new name; it is not Brian. It is Kevin. Kevin Griffin.
Kevin is worshipped by the Bass Coast Cult of Fiscal Conservatism. He has been preaching the mantra of rate capping and cost cutting since before he stacked the ballot papers with the names of his followers.
Just like the Monty Python political religious satire “Life of Brian”, Kevin’s worshippers follow him without question because they want to believe that someone will save them, even if they don’t actually need salvation.
In a bizarre contradiction to the Council Plan Principle and his own cost cutting gospel, Kevin has theologised that the need to dump hundreds of thousands of dollars/annum in operating costs and millions of dollars in up-grade and clean-up costs into the Inverloch tip is more important than saving money.
Using political manoeuvring that would make Machiavelli proud, Messiah Kevin has managed to convince the new Council to reverse the decision to shut down the toxic time-bomb that is the Inverloch tip.
Even Monty Python could not come up with a plot twist this absurd.
Justification for keeping the site open is based around “community need”; yet a perfectly good transfer station is located only minutes away in Wonthaggi.
A petition of over 600 people is cited. Interesting that over 32% of the petitioners were from Phillip Island. I wonder how many Islanders use the Inverloch transfer station; how many are members of Stand Alone, the co-worshippers of Kevin Griffin…
Every aspect of the decision to keep the transfer station open and delaying the rehabilitation of the site is wrong.
Economically the site is unsustainable. The community deserves to see a cost benefit analysis of keeping the site open. Stand Alone Councillors dumped an investment in the future in the shape of the Cowes Cultural Centre re-development which had a cost benefit ratio of 12.7:1. Is the cost benefit of keeping the Inverloch tip site open better than 12.7:1? Our Councillors must inform our community of the real cost/tonne of keeping the site open.
Environmentally, the site is bounded by the Screw Creek Conservation and Reserve Zone and is within a wildfire overlay area. For these reasons alone the site must be closed down. No one can say what the cost of the clean-up will finally be. Every day the clean-up is delayed, the costs will increase. This is in direct contradiction to the cost cutting scripture of Kevin Griffin.
Societally, in addition to being bounded by a Conservation and Reserve Zone, the site also borders residential property. Residential land use is completely incompatible with the former tip. Have we forgotten the toxic gas fiasco of the Cranbourne landfill site only a few years ago? Residents were forced to flee their homes when methane gas was discovered in houses allowed to be built next to a former landfill. Who will foot the bill should a similar disaster occur here; will it be Kevin Griffin?
The only justification for keeping the site open is political. Keeping the Inverloch tip open is nothing more than a demonstration that the Messiah can deliver can deliver on his promises.
You are correct Kevin; the new crop of Councillors you helped install are not dancing to the tune of the CEO; they are worshipping before you.
I commend Cr Michael Whelan for opposing this ludicrous economically, environmentally and societally unsustainable proposal.
I suppose I will draw solace from the words of words of Monty Python: Always look on the bright side of life…
P.S. I have over 30 years’ experience in the operation of landfill sites, recycling facilities and quarries.
Robbie J Viglietti
What makes us tick
February 4, 2017
Nice piece on Australia with sprinklings of history and comparisons with other countries. What stood out as missing for me was no reference to Australian blackfellas, the first people of Australia - rather strange within the historic context chosen. Julian feels that Australians are tolerant, supportive people who believe in equality, with a bit of superiority thrown in. Apart from the latter, I lament that these qualities are not evident in our attitudes towards the indigenous people. It doesn't help that all the nations mentioned also denigrate the people who came before the current mob in power. It's time the people of the world face history's bad outcomes and work hard to change attitudes that are detrimental to harmony and peace.
Sue Packham
February 11, 2017
I wholeheartedly support Sue's comments - Julian your article is out of balance without a genuine commitment to acknowledging both the extraordinary history of Aboriginal civilisation way way way earlier than most of the rest of the world, and the depth of knowledge and wisdom we whitefellas have to learn from those folks who have lived here way before us.
I'm also a little saddened that perhaps the cause of your omissions is that schools weren't able to educate you in these issues... at 54 I accept that my education was completely inadequate about colonial policies and treatments of our first nations peoples I feel very sad if yours was too at 35. I had hoped this had improved.
Karen Sandon
Heslop's Wonthaggi
February 4, 2017
John, Thank you for this. Robert Heslop subdivided the land on which our property in Boundary Road sits. Original title makes for interesting reading. It's exciting to read who he was.
Frank Schooneveldt
John, thanks for publishing this, fascinating! I am interested in the mention that there was a ruined house of wattle and daub at 'The Wattles' when Heslop snr bought it. Do you have any idea who would have built this original cottage?
Chris
April 1, 2017
You have done well with this story ........................thank you
Rosemary Loughnan, Wonthaggi
Kit's achievements continue to amaze me.
Sue
Kit was a man of many talents. Love reading his essays.
Meryl Collis
Kit was a very talented and interesting person Along with his parents and brother they all had a wealth of knowledge on Wonthaggi and its history..
"Part of my Heart in Wonthaggi"
Terri
Crossing the border
April 4, 2017
Loved reading about your jaunt to Buronga and your adventures but my favourite tale of yours is still your trip to the chook show. Just enjoy your stories ... thank you.
Joy Button
Thanks for sharing your delightful story with us Bob. So good to enjoy another of your gems in The Post again!
Linda Cuttriss
Bob, I too was confronted with the Castlemaine Rail Steps. My companion took both cases and was at the bottom while I was only three steps down. Thank heavens for good friends and partners.
Joan Woods, Wonthaggi
View from the chamber
April 1, 2017
Hear Hear! I commend your diligence and fully endorse another example of strong leadership.
I totally agree that, although the deliberations around Phillip Island Aquatics have been long running, to say the least, we will achieve an outcome that provides good amenity and great facilities that encourage people to visit the Island as well as meeting the needs of the community.
I would also like to note my admiration for the decades long effort that the Phillip Island Aquatic Centre working group.
Well done Pam - a great explanation of the decision making process, well reasoned and well written.
And thanks to the BCP for providing a forum for free and open discussion of Council matters.
Geoff Ellis, Krowera
I wholeheartedly agree with comments made. I would strongly suggest that a far better, fairer and more easily accessible location (particularly at major event times) would be Anderson Roundabout. This location would provide access to thousands more folk in the hinterland and an associated cafe would become a regular meeting place to thousands of visitors too.
Karen Sandon
Thank you Pam, for your common sence. Traffic on Phillip Island is an ongoing problem we do not want to make it even worse.
Ventnor Road, ajoining the Circus land, I understand the shire bought back from them! would be ideal for this venture.
We must think ahead, Phillip Island is not the quiet little hamlet it used to be. We all need to realize that, and look to the future.
Well done and keep up the good work.
Pamela J Gill JP
Pam needs to be congratulated on her rational analysis and support for a Cowes based Aquatic Centre
There is only one chance to build this important community facility in a location which provides for potential expansion and access to vehicle traffic.
I concur with Pamela Gill that location of the facility at the Ventnor road property acquired by the Bass Coast Council for this purpose is the appropriate site.
Ian Samuel
A weight on your mind
April 1, 2017
An amazing,insightful,and sensible article about the relationship between stress and the way,and what we eat. Has given me plenty of food for thought,pardon the pun. Thank you!
Michelle Graham, Pioneer Bay
Think the City of Bass Coast
March 12, 2017
I was most intrigued to read in the Sentinel-Times of the 7th March 2017 that said “In lieu of the upcoming 2017/18 budget Bass Coast Shire Councillors have requested that a report of the shire’s current financial state be released for April 2017. Councillors are leaning heavily on their commitment to financial conservatism”.
Does this imply the Council’s distrust in the monthly financial reporting package that the Council currently receives prepared by Council Staff?
Does this tell us that the Council can’t determine the financial position of the Shire from the monthly financial reports?
I would suggest that the Councillors calls for a twelve month rolling cash flow forecast that reveals monthly income and expenses with forecast monthly closing cash and cash equivalent balance.
I would suggest Councillors calls for the Shires borrowing capacity on a monthly basis.
I suggest that the Bass Coast needs to grow and to grow you need to build infrastructure. If you don’t grow you wither and die.
I suggest that the Councillors need to learn words like ‘do’, ‘can’, ‘how’ because it is actions that speak greater than words.
I suggest that the way to grow is through population growth.
Think the City of Bass Coast and how are we going to get there.
Frank W Schooneveldt
Crunch time
March 4, 2017
Geoff so very well written, much easier looking from the outside in … but hey, we are privileged to be representing the community to the best of our abilities. We have got a few things right.
Brett Tessari
Well done councillor. So good to get a first-hand account from an insider. Do hope there will be progressive reports during your term and that we also hear from your fellow councillors as to their thoughts and aspirations.
Bob Middleton
Congratulations Geoff . . . an excellent insight into the present Council. It is so refreshing to read and hear your thoughts regarding some very controversial decisions that have been taken in recent times. I stand and applaud the Council's consultative approach and the boldness in making decisions that are unpopular for some but as has been demonstrated recently, supported by a large number in the community.
Joy Button
I reckon you're a brave person Geoff - both for taking on the responsibilities that come with being a councilllor as well as writing your impressions for us all to see. Both will get you brick bats no doubt, but hey not from me! I hear your empathy and heart ache about those broken hearts in which some of your votes resulted. And we all know that's inevitable when there's a limited amount of money to share out - just like most of our households really.
Then there are those poorest of the poor people who live in poverty on less than A$2 a day with no Centrelink support. These are the just under a billion people on our planet who have no access to basic services like education, fresh water, health care and sanitation. They are the ones that break my heart - it's just luck that I'm not one of them.
So thank you Geoff and all the other councillors for doing their difficult work keeping our 'basic services' running - and then providing extras to make us even happier!
Sue Packham
March 5, 2017
Geoff, It's all about running a business, that's the role you have taken on and worked hard to win.
When you run a business you are more than aware your decisions affect everybody you employ, often their extended family and you can also impact the lives of both your customers and suppliers but the task is to do the job to the best of your ability, if you’re looking over your shoulder or trying to please all the people all the time you are not the person to be doing the job and will fail.
In the end in any job you’re not the person who decides if you’re the best person for the job, it’s somebody else. Be true to yourself and be well prepared and present your views and beliefs. Unless your name’s Rupert Murdoch you have to accept that if the management group decide something you don't agree with the whole group is locked into supporting that decision and get on with implementation of that decision. Next time your idea might be supported by majority then you would expect support from the rest of the group. That applies in business and Council is a business.
Christopher Day
Geoff, I love your writing, your honesty and your ethics - I love working with you. You have so much to contribute.
Pamela Rothfield
March 8, 2017
Thank you Geoff for sharing your story. Now you have an idea what the previous councillors were subjected to under difficult circumstances, trying to please everyone. It is also warming to see councillors supporting one another, a crucial requirement of any smooth running team. Having said that, could we have a little less self-congratulation. Evaluation of performance is perhaps best left to non-elected ratepayers, and as you pointed out, your term in office is still in its very early days. The kind of transparency ratepayers require is to keep being informed of council decisions and the relevant details associated with any moves the council makes. Eg. When it is announced that a report is being prepared for council, we need to know who is preparing it, and at what cost. Consultancy was a major criticism of the last council.
To all the new councillors, keep up the cohesion in the midst of vigorous debate. Good luck, and may your term continue to expand you.
PS. If you can get hold of a copy of the grade three reader from the 1960's entitled "among friends", there's a story called "trying to please everyone". It's such a good yarn, they used to tell it to 8 year old children. Keep up the good work. While you process the hate, remember those who admire you for all the right reasons.
John Coldebella
D-day for Aquasure
March 3, 2017
I am interested in knowing more about the details of the contractual agreement entered into by AquaSure and the people of Victoria in relation to the supply of water. Is it the case that AquaSure is obliged to produce water regardless of existing supply, or is Victoria obliged to buy water, regardless of existing supply. There is a difference. Or is it as Forest Gump would say, "maybe it's a little bit of both. . . . . . at the same time.
Is there anybody out there who can tell us exactly what we have signed up to? It does seem odd to produce water, given the current storage levels.
John Coldebella
You can compare owning a boat and having a desal plant, They are both usually expensive to obtain and even more to maintain over time, We think of how much we might do with our boat, but we end up throwing a lot more money into it and get very little pleasure from it. Desal is the "States" boat, what a price, and we are still throwing money at it, how much more must we cough up. Water Minister Neville says that the extra costs will be borne by AquaSure and Ausnet, I can't wait to see how quickly they pass the costs on to consumers. Roll on State Elections.
Barrie Stewart
In light of the recent desal/diesel furore several things have become apparent. Firstly, the willingness of AquaSure to risk the health and amenity of residents (and ratepayers) in their desperate attempt to protect profit margins and deliver a pointless water order is simply astonishing. As such, any future statements regarding their care for our community and environment should be taken with a very large pinch of salt (pun intended).
On the other hand, the determination of locals to grasp the rampaging white elephant by the tusks has been magnificent. Concerned community members, Bass Coast shire councillors and the environmental defenders all stood up to the corporate bully in a display of the true meaning of community spirit -the protection of our special coastal home.
Even the EPA had serious concerns about the impacts of the hastily-assembled, filth-spewing generators. It appears that we have, for now, been spared the choking fumes and noise of AquaSure’s Plan b, but we must still endure the many truckloads of chemicals and barrowloads of cash flowing to the plant, along with the 40 tonnes per day of dead marine life leaving. And we are paying handsomely for this - more than $600 million this year.
It will soon be time for our state government to consider next year’s order of water- with an election on the horizon will they prop up the corporate cowboys or spend our money on schools and hospitals? We were promised worlds-best-practice - really?
Mark Robertson. President, Watershed Victoria
Nothing wasted
March 6, 2017
Very interesting Jordan, it is certainly an eye opener compared to how we manage waste here.
I had the opportunity of visiting my sister, who lives in Spain. They have the same system, and everyone is used to this way, of protecting the environment.
What a wonderful thing it would be if we also could go with our jug or glass bottle and collect fresh milk daily and cream on top. This is how I remember my childhood years, growing up in England.
Thank you for sharing your recent experiences
Pamela J Gill
March 9, 2017
How I enjoyed the Foreign Correspondent in the last edition of the Post. It is wonderful that people who live in our community can share their very special and informative experiences, when they return from overseas.
The small community of Alfedeno is truly inspirational with its commitment to recycling and waste management. We all need to take individually and collectively care of the environment in our Shire and thereby contribute to a healthy planet.
Anne Davie
Heslop’s Wonthaggi
February 25, 2017
John, Thank you for this. Robert Heslop subdivided the land on which our property in Boundary Road sits. Original title makes for Interesting reading. It's exciting to read who he was.
Frank Schooneveldt
John, thanks for publishing this, fascinating! I am interested in the mention that there was a ruined house of wattle and daub at 'The Wattles' when Heslop snr bought it. Do you have any idea who would have built this original cottage? Thanks
Chris
Wonthaggi’s blackest day
". . . . deep silence. . . . . many were moved to tears.” How comforting to know there are sentient beings in our midst. People with empathy for strangers. There is hope.
John Coldebella
Wonthaggi highball stadium
February 17, 2017
Finally we have some councillors showing some common sense. Council is a business it needs to get back to the basics of providing services it's responsible for not going off into dreamland spending millions of reports that then never happen because surprise there is no funding. Yes there are many needs for our communities but normally they have to be funded whether by federal or state governments or mix of all three levels of government.
In San Remo area the council was looking to extend the town boundary and add 700 new blocks of land in addition to developments like Keam’s land already within existing boundary. The issue was and still is how would the infrastructure cope with this expansion when it was coping with current size of town, especially in the tourism season.
After numerous meetings with community, hours of work 2 independent reports which council and state government approved and signed off what's happened over 5 years? Well the developments are happening land is being sold, great more rates for council. What's happened to all the recommendations for council and state government to implement, basically nothing!
When recent meeting with councillors held same issues came up only now getting worse, lot of head nodding but when is anybody going to do something about the issues affecting every resident and visitor highlighted in the report? The solutions are there but if nobody starts doing something about it, it's just going to get worse and worse as the population and visitor numbers increase. Doing nothing doesn't solve the problem.
Chris Day
February 17, 2017
My concern over this sorry decision is the lack of vision, the incompetence of all involved and the fear of what is the future ? It just seems so amateurish that councillors have to vote on a proposal presented to them with no price tag until the last moment. In saying that this project has been on the radar for that many years it's not funny. Countless numbers of people have looked at the project for over 20 years yet not one group of councillors have had the intestinal fortitude to look beyond the price tag. Not one has looked at how other councils not only build these facilities but use them. We have councils in bush fire areas and flood areas using stadiums as emergency shelters, we have councils using them for flower shows, wedding expos, tournaments for all ranges of sports. Our neighbours in the South Gippsland shire at Korumburra regularly use theirs for big cabarets, music shows, big football functions etc. This is without the basketball, volleyball, every kind of ball you could imagine being bounced, hit thrown and the use by football clubs in the middle of winter. I accept that previous administrations have let down the people of bass coast by not building the infrastructure that is desperately needed throughout the shire. Someone has to have the guts to start building some of these projects or there are generations of people that will miss out on so much that other shires take for granted.
Andy Thomas
February 19, 2017
All councillors were briefed on Nov. 23rd. If Crs Brown and Larke were so concerned why didn't they asked for a costing back then? Where is the mention of anything to do with people or community in Browns excuses?
Cr. Larke for all of his fiscal excuses and his pursuit of financial responsibility from Council Officers, could have asked way back about costs to ratepayers. The figure that council could have gone ahead with was up to $2 million. Until the submission was funded the local sporting bodies could have pursued other funding thus reducing councils cost. The facility would have been profitable and thus provided a return to council. Unfortunately we will never know as the blind five had no idea what was possible and a very narrow view of excuses around money instead of deferring a decision and doing some investigating. The five showed their unsuitability for a Council in need of providing for all its community.
Lou Godfrey
February 19, 2017
The CEO presented this funding opportunity to council on 23 November 2016.
Mandy Lean
February 19, 2017
Yes we were briefed last November. We were also briefed again by the CEO the week before the Council meeting - we knew the order of magnitude but not the specific amount.
A key consideration in this, as Cr Tessari points out, is that unlike many grant rounds, we were to be given the opportunity to pursue other grants money and had the prospect of substantially reducing our contribution. $2 million was the outside provision we had to make and we could have withdrawn at any time.
Stage 2 of the Swimming Pool development includes a high ball stadium we will still have to find that money at that time.
Cr Michael Whelan
Going, going saved
February 17, 2017
Wow. So basically we have a new Council as bad as the old one- focused only on money except when some loud-mouths make a hoohah in which case they will bow to the whims of the mob. And I had so much hope. Disappointed with the new Council.
Mikhaela Barlow
March 4, 2017
The Messiah has a new name; it is not Brian. It is Kevin. Kevin Griffin.
Kevin is worshipped by the Bass Coast Cult of Fiscal Conservatism. He has been preaching the mantra of rate capping and cost cutting since before he stacked the ballot papers with the names of his followers.
Just like the Monty Python political religious satire “Life of Brian”, Kevin’s worshippers follow him without question because they want to believe that someone will save them, even if they don’t actually need salvation.
In a bizarre contradiction to the Council Plan Principle and his own cost cutting gospel, Kevin has theologised that the need to dump hundreds of thousands of dollars/annum in operating costs and millions of dollars in up-grade and clean-up costs into the Inverloch tip is more important than saving money.
Using political manoeuvring that would make Machiavelli proud, Messiah Kevin has managed to convince the new Council to reverse the decision to shut down the toxic time-bomb that is the Inverloch tip.
Even Monty Python could not come up with a plot twist this absurd.
Justification for keeping the site open is based around “community need”; yet a perfectly good transfer station is located only minutes away in Wonthaggi.
A petition of over 600 people is cited. Interesting that over 32% of the petitioners were from Phillip Island. I wonder how many Islanders use the Inverloch transfer station; how many are members of Stand Alone, the co-worshippers of Kevin Griffin…
Every aspect of the decision to keep the transfer station open and delaying the rehabilitation of the site is wrong.
Economically the site is unsustainable. The community deserves to see a cost benefit analysis of keeping the site open. Stand Alone Councillors dumped an investment in the future in the shape of the Cowes Cultural Centre re-development which had a cost benefit ratio of 12.7:1. Is the cost benefit of keeping the Inverloch tip site open better than 12.7:1? Our Councillors must inform our community of the real cost/tonne of keeping the site open.
Environmentally, the site is bounded by the Screw Creek Conservation and Reserve Zone and is within a wildfire overlay area. For these reasons alone the site must be closed down. No one can say what the cost of the clean-up will finally be. Every day the clean-up is delayed, the costs will increase. This is in direct contradiction to the cost cutting scripture of Kevin Griffin.
Societally, in addition to being bounded by a Conservation and Reserve Zone, the site also borders residential property. Residential land use is completely incompatible with the former tip. Have we forgotten the toxic gas fiasco of the Cranbourne landfill site only a few years ago? Residents were forced to flee their homes when methane gas was discovered in houses allowed to be built next to a former landfill. Who will foot the bill should a similar disaster occur here; will it be Kevin Griffin?
The only justification for keeping the site open is political. Keeping the Inverloch tip open is nothing more than a demonstration that the Messiah can deliver can deliver on his promises.
You are correct Kevin; the new crop of Councillors you helped install are not dancing to the tune of the CEO; they are worshipping before you.
I commend Cr Michael Whelan for opposing this ludicrous economically, environmentally and societally unsustainable proposal.
I suppose I will draw solace from the words of words of Monty Python: Always look on the bright side of life…
P.S. I have over 30 years’ experience in the operation of landfill sites, recycling facilities and quarries.
Robbie J Viglietti
What makes us tick
February 4, 2017
Nice piece on Australia with sprinklings of history and comparisons with other countries. What stood out as missing for me was no reference to Australian blackfellas, the first people of Australia - rather strange within the historic context chosen. Julian feels that Australians are tolerant, supportive people who believe in equality, with a bit of superiority thrown in. Apart from the latter, I lament that these qualities are not evident in our attitudes towards the indigenous people. It doesn't help that all the nations mentioned also denigrate the people who came before the current mob in power. It's time the people of the world face history's bad outcomes and work hard to change attitudes that are detrimental to harmony and peace.
Sue Packham
February 11, 2017
I wholeheartedly support Sue's comments - Julian your article is out of balance without a genuine commitment to acknowledging both the extraordinary history of Aboriginal civilisation way way way earlier than most of the rest of the world, and the depth of knowledge and wisdom we whitefellas have to learn from those folks who have lived here way before us.
I'm also a little saddened that perhaps the cause of your omissions is that schools weren't able to educate you in these issues... at 54 I accept that my education was completely inadequate about colonial policies and treatments of our first nations peoples I feel very sad if yours was too at 35. I had hoped this had improved.
Karen Sandon
Heslop's Wonthaggi
February 4, 2017
John, Thank you for this. Robert Heslop subdivided the land on which our property in Boundary Road sits. Original title makes for interesting reading. It's exciting to read who he was.
Frank Schooneveldt
John, thanks for publishing this, fascinating! I am interested in the mention that there was a ruined house of wattle and daub at 'The Wattles' when Heslop snr bought it. Do you have any idea who would have built this original cottage?
Chris