READERS' COMMENTS |
Holden’s last hurrah
March 20, 2020
Great article Tim!
Let me know if there's any petition to sign or any other pressure we can get to bear on Government or GM to get this important area saved for conservation. It's an ongoing disgrace that so many multinational corporations are the first to come to government when they're in financial trouble, yet baulk at paying any tax as part of their quid pro quo!
Pete Muskens
Great article and idea Tim.
Peter Dann
Congratulations, Tim! A refreshing look at a possible future for the GMH Proving Ground, an incredibly valuable environmental and economic asset which should be gifted or bought for the good of the community.
Meryl Tobin Brown
That's an excellent article. I do so hope the site is gifted for wildlife conservation or that council and government unite to protect it for that purpose. The income and tax figures you quote are appalling in their cost to Australians. Thank you for presenting this important article.
Susan Linley
Send a message to GM HQ.
Mary Barra - CEO and Chair of GM
linkedin.com/in/mary-barra-29469712
Dhivya Suryadevara GM CFO
linkedin.com/in/dhivya-suryadevara
General Motors Company
P.O. BOX 33170
Detroit, MI 48232-5170
Geoff Ellis
Thanks Tim. It is always good to get the facts - the proving ground has always had a slightly mysterious air about it.
Anyway it can be kept as it is, count me in.
Joan Woods
Good idea for tourism but at this point of time with USA virtually closed down and we not far behind not the time to pursue this.
The governments, companies and people around the world have more important things on their mind than a block of land in Victoria.
Nothing will happen at this time , follow up at the right time and that is certainly not now.
Christopher Day
An excellent article and great idea. Not enough is being done in conservation on this scale. This is such a good opportunity for the Council and Government to move on this together, NOW, before it's too late......what possibilities, they're endless when it comes to the environment and the future. I say, act fast and act now.
Gillian Armstrong
I enjoyed most of Tim's article and agree that the site would be a wonderful area for conservation purposes. However I think it would have been better if Tim had not published such misleading figures. He cites Gross Income for several years and complains that no tax was paid on this income. He conveniently forgets to take into account the operating expenses of those years or to mention that in the years 2013/14 the company made an operating loss of 554 million dollars and in the year 2014/15 made an operating loss of 255 million to mention just two. The subsequent years were not much better. It was these huge losses over several consecutive years that led to GM opting out of Australia. Consequently this shows that there is a very good reason that no tax was paid during the period Tim published. Given Tim's background he must have known how misleading the article is.
Trevor Brown
Trevor Browns information on GMH losses adds a new dimension to the debate. You certainly wouldn't want to approach GMH with incorrect financial information they would dismiss any discussion . I doubt they would only be interested in selling the land for the best deal for them clearly they we're in bad financial situation or they wouldn't be withdrawing from all right hand drive markets around the world not just Australia . The last few months and however long this corona virus lasts will no doubt leave them in far worse financial position .
If the Victorian community it going to obtain this parcel of land for long term benefit of the community it needs to put together a financial offer that they could accept expecting them to donate it is a waste of time . Of course as a housing estate it could provide a developer great parcel of land in an area where future housing is closer to Melbourne than areas like Wonthaggi so to stop that happening any approach to GMH has to be commercially well put together . Another question is does Bass Coast council currently collect rates for this land and if so how much is paid each year.
Chris Day
Ed and the Birds
March 20, 2020
So much food for thought! I thoroughly enjoyed reading this Karen and have to digest the good and bad news to work out if we're coming out on top.
Hilary Stuchbery
loved the story and the complexities in it.
it reminded me there's quite a few guerrilla planters out there .
one of them informed me when i was explaining some of the looks and questioning it best to some how get the word ' beautification ' of the medium strip into conversations. And yes just keep planting
Nerida Melsmith
It was such a pleasure to read this first time around and, on the second reading, it really resonates, especially the last line.
Geoff Ellis
Karen, I loved your inspiring story about Ed and the birds. I had virtually given up planting shrubs at my place on Phillip Island as they need a lifetime of defending from wallabies. Trees get above wallaby height and tussock grasses get too rough for their palate. But your story has made me rethink how I can create little protected shrubby places for the small birds. And all power to Ed’s guerrilla tactics!
Linda Cuttriss
This is a kind and inspiring story. Thanks Karen. You write beautifully.
Carmel Anderson
Karen what a wonderful account of Ed, the birds, the interrelationships and the changing face of our world. Thank goodness for optimists no matter how plodding! Thank you.
Julie Constable
Hello Karen, Wow what a wonderful article, I remember our ramblings around Inverloch 20 years ago, my how it has changed.
Wendy Davies
Thanks everyone for your kind comments, and for taking the time to read it.
Karen Blackman
Immensely proud of my cousin Karen, on her ability to make me think about things in a way I never have before. Writing is a passion, but a cheerleader for change. Well done wild cousin Karen, which has different connotations to me now. Natural, native and not prescribed. So very proud of you x
Sara Fellows
The virus diaries
March 20, 2020
Thank you Catherine! You have made me laugh and cheered my week no end.
Camilla Myers
What a brilliant piece! Your observation is accurate and I love your witty expression scattered through your writing. Your insight and wisdom certainly lifted my heart in these uncertain times. Now our local gym and swimming pool The Y is closed and I'm jobless. Thank goodness I have my writing.
Etsuko Yasunaga
How easily our civilisation can unravel, it seems like only yesterday that our leaders were exhorting us to take an empty esky, go out to the bushfire-ravaged areas and buy from small businesses. It appears that the hordes have taken this too literally, pillaging our country supermarkets - how unseemly. I expect that Post readers will behave in a more civilised manner than most and that you all remain safe from this latest version of armageddon. Perhaps next time the PM is consulting his good book and praising the lord he will look up the chapter titled Wrath of God.......
Mark Robertson
Oh Catherine you do make me laugh
This is a pretty common trauma response as as for being unAustralia, I cringed when I heard the PM say stock up- I though you have no idea what you are unleashing. Turns out he didn’t and is now blaming the people - give me a break please!
As for me I probably fit into some kind of food hoarder category- what has Costcodone to us ! I shop late Oct Nov and buy enough nonperishables and new products I’ve never seen before ( to try! Cos I can) to feed a family and friends of 12 for a month. This January Feb wasn’t that busy, and the two chooks on fire rescue lay an egg every few days. So fresh fruit and veg is all that’s needed.. I don’t feel quite so odd now!
Nerida Melsmith
What a hoot Catherine! As I went into IGA (no toilet rolls, no pasta, no UHT (only 'fake' Milk- made from seeds and nuts -yuk drink water) but plenty of people to have a chat with and shake our heads over people's foolishness. Loved your comment about not being able to get crap from China (in our family we call it Chinese Landfill), but for .
'cheap' we let our manufacturing industries shrivel so lots of 'stuff' comes from OS. I do read labels and usually can find products in the food line Made in Australia (avoid asparagus from Peru and cherries from the US of A). We eat seasonally and grow vegies and fruit. Keep up the good work and full marks to the contributors of articles and cartoons. Some clown said life wasn't meant to be easy. Cheers.
Yvonne McRae
The clown (Malcolm Fraser, former PM) actually said “Life is not meant to be easy, my child; but take courage: it can be delightful.”. Like all good journalists, only part of the quote was reported and continues to be, incorrectly, reported. It was a call for people to have a go and don't be afraid. The results can be delightful. The quote is from a Bernard Shaw play,
Perhaps now with our borders closed, etc. we will remember what it was like to be self-sufficient and start manufacturing again. We just need to keep a rein on the wages so that we don't make our industries unable to compete with the "Chinese Landfill". We do make a bit of a profit out of the imported landfill - it's usually our iron ore!
Pamela Jacka
Bravo Catherine, I hope the hordes read the post. And well done to the commentators 1e Frank, Yvonne,Nerida... You've said it all. except, Australia also had ration books during and after the war. A message for the Polis,: Get them back again quick!
Heather Tobias
I simply love your story. I think all your readers can relate to it. Thank you Catherine
Jellie N. Wyckelsma
It was at Aldi's, not a bottle shop and l wasn't joking.
Hamish Watson
Could this be a return to village life, circa 1820, when people's concerns and information-exchange centred on the neighbours, the inn, the post office, the grocer's and the local dance? Likewise journalism and the bygone 'vox pop', where voices of people on the street appeared on a printed page. Thank you, Catherine! Just what the doctor ordered, apart from the hand wash and face mask.
John Gascoigne
Man of many parts
March 20, 2020
An interesting insight into one of our local hardworking councillors. Well written Liane.
Rob Parsons
As an ex ratepayer in his ward, I'd just like to back up Rob Parsons's praise of Geoff Ellis..
Not only for his interest in conserving as much of Bass Coast as possible, exemplified by his backing of Preserve Western Port in the "2014 "Battle of Hastings", (aka the container port), but also his 100% backing of me in a personal issue in the months before I moved back to Melbourne.
I know he is flat out 100% of the time, but I still wish he'd find time to have that dinner with me up here in Melbourne we discussed before I moved back here!!!!!
Tho that of course may have to wait until after this "Bug" drama plays out.
Good luck to all down there in the current crisis. I know full well what tourism means to Bass Shire...
Sincerely
Kevin Chambers
Great story Liano, we need more people like Geoff. I wish him all the best with the Lang Lang proving grounds. Hardly any bush left in West Gippsland, we need to conserve what remains.
Peter Bogg
Despite my inherent distrust of politicians I enjoyed this biography and the writing moved along smoothly.
Rowland Arno
Very interesting article on a very interesting person, Liane. I've met Geoff on a number of occasions over the last couple of years. A genuine,open minded person of great heart. An absolute asset to our community.
Ellen Hubble
Self portrait of an architect
March 20, 2020
A familiar journey for creatives I suspect- the inner need to puzzle and scrutinise their purpose... Architecture as the portrait of the client makes me smile... studio of delight. Yes. I reflect on my husbands and my own spaces within our home. It explains a lot 🤪 Thank you for the article
Jeannie Haughton
Tim, an informative article thankyou. Here are some random points about creativity in general I'd make. If you're scared to make a mistake creativity will suffer. If you follow the master you will not learn your way. Mistakes are your sub-conscious letting lose. "Considered mistakes" have an unexpected new direction, renewed power and surprising outcomes. My first boss said to me as a passing comment on something I was doing at my art desk... he said "Peter, take the bull by the horns",something I have used my whole career to date. Our pathways have a similar echo Tim.
Peter Walker
How wonderful to read another of your incredibly well-crafted, profoundly thought and beautifully written pieces Tim. I love the way your writing makes me think, question, wonder and then smile. I look forward to the next one!
Linda Cuttriss
The solace of birds
March 20, 2020
What a wonderful and sensitive piece of non-fiction writing about your love of nature, conservation and the environment. Your illustrations were a superb visual way to accompany the article. Every one applauds the many decades of your efforts and voluntary work you have devoted to Phillip Island and surrounding areas.
Phyllis Papps
Your words, with what they describe in the neighbouring 'nest', make for the most beguiling reading experience. Thank you, Patsy.
John Gascoigne
Lovely to read your observations of the birds in your garden Patsy. They are insightful and informative and your illustrations are wonderful. I always refer to your illustrations when I visit the bird hide at Swan Lake. They are excellent representations and it’s great be able to identify all the birds I am observing. I look forward to Solace of Birds Part 2.
Linda Cuttriss
Lovely article Patsy, I can so relate to your garden. My garden is my sanctuary, and is the food bowl for many native birds. I can really relate to your sentiment and your illustrations. My kids remember with warmth the drawings you would do for them as Lollypop Lady!
Gillian Armstrong
Such arrogance!
March 20, 2020
Just get in there and re-vegetate, erect a sign at the property boundary explaining the need for and value of the works. If the sign gets vandalised erect a bigger one!
Neil Rankine
On common ground
March 20, 2020
Thanks Frank, always good to hear from you and your incredible historical knowledge- totally agree
Angela Wishart
Thank you for this Frank. I love it. Beautifully written and absolutely fascinating.
Nancy Vaughan
Love your work Frank. What a beautiful piece of writing. Thanks for sharing
Tracie McIntosh
Ditto from me Frank. I love your stories. Please keep them coming. It’s always a good time to be reminded of Wonthaggi’s egalitarian roots. Not just for the sake of nostalgia, but as a legacy for now and the future, a reminder of what’s important about being human.
Linda Cuttriss
Berry delicious
March 20, 2020
Well done Jan. I really enjoy your recipes. Cheers, Yvonne
Yvonne McRae
Not so fast, GM
March 6, 2010
Amazing idea!
Vicki Breen
Good contribution to the wider conversation, Mikhaela. I'm sure there are plenty of ideas out there, which I hope will be heard by decision makers. My personal hope is that this unique place will become a State asset for the people of Victoria and, whatever activities are eventually approved, that the flora and fauna continue to be protected. We need to watch this one carefully.
Anne Heath Mennell
Michaela & BCP - you have well said exactly what has been on my mind since the Holden announcement. Get onto Jordan Crugnale to make representations on behalf of community to State Govt too.
Anne Paul
Hi Mikhaela, I think that GM should by rights gift this land to the people of Australia.
While Holden was riding high on the hog in the Australian market, with as much as 50% market share - and remember too that GM was assisted by the Chifley Government to establish manufacturing here under the General Motors banner - it repatriated handsome profits to GM balance sheets in Detroit for the better part of 60 years. It has also benefited from huge amounts of Government largesse by way of the Green Car Innovation Fund (which began at $500million, and grew to $1billion); then later, the Automotive Transformation Scheme - tipping another $400million into local manufacturing (before the announcements of closure).
In fact, over the 12 years from 2001-2013, Holden's own figures show it received $2.17billion in state and federal government assistance, compared to $1.1 billion for Ford and $1.2 billion for Toyota.
Each of these manufacturers was then assisted with taxpayer money - after the announcement of closures - to shutter the factories and retrain the workforce. This amounted to another $150million (or so).
To load more salt into the wounds, GMH hasn't paid for tax for years: income 2016/17 - $4,601,580,614, tax - $0. (You can thank internal invoicing, fees from the parent company, for that.)
So, should it gift its proving grounds to Lang Lang? I should think so. Australian taxpayers have, after all, already paid handsomely for it.
I reckon we can get a groundswell going here. I'm a former motoring journalist, I think I can swing a lot of them in behind this campaign.
So, who's going to be in from down here? Let's get a group going and see what we can get rolling.
Tim O’Brien
Great idea it's an asset that could add to the tourism in this area. Tourism is vital for the economy of not just Bass area but all of Australia.
Obviously the coronavirus is on everybody's priority at moment but it is showing us how important tourism is. It's also showing us how stupid we are as a country to close down our manufacturing sector which the state of Victoria dominated since WW2 mainly driven by buyers of major retailers going into Asia to get cheaper products and make more money. Now we find ourselves running out of products as we have no back up available .
My suggestion would be to get the federal government involved in this issue as vic govt have no new money to spend in sure the treasurer won't let Premier Dan anywhere near this issue.
Don't waste your energy thinking GMH will assist or donate the land they have shown only interested in their own situation not those who sold , serviced or bought their products .
Chris Day
Alzheimer Sufferer/Carer Suite
March 6, 2010
Malcolm, your tribute to moments - too seldom caught - in two lives eternally tied into one is gripping, devastating, haunting, cleansing. Bravo.
Fiona
Bravo Malcolm.
Jeannie Haughton
Lovely words. Thus we process what must have been hard to live!
Heather Slutzkin
Heather, what a profound way of putting it. The act of writing, though often hard, brings understanding. "Emotion recollected in tranquillity", as Wordsworth described it.
Catherine Watson
What very insightful comments, Heather.
Ann Stocker
Congratulations on the publication of this book of poems. Very insightful on the emotions and moments one goes through.
Lynn Rogers
Malcolm, this wonderful piece of poetry about love, life and loss is a superb piece of writing.
I truly hope that you will be able to have it published in book form.
Warm regards, Phyllis
Phyllis Papps
A special relationship documented, explored and cherished by the poet.
An achievement of note.
Nancy Endersby-Harshman
Damn you, John Mutsaers
March 6, 2010
Sorry Catherine, Messing with dreams mmmmmm?? nice thought.
Here is a little clue which I shared at the opening.
A man goes into a hardware shop and asks for 10 mm drill bit: what is it that he really wants???? He wants a 10mm hole. look beyond, behind and in the nooks and crannies then close your eyes and dream words.
John Mutsaers
Hi Catherine, I did brave the crowd and heard John speak, yes he seeks to tantalise and provoke, just what art should do. My takeaway was that the birds are thoughts and the cage is our captive paradigm; our upbringing; schooling; our fears and a wish to fit in. The great thinkers at least made it to a more expansive birdcage.
Michael Whelan
Catherine, Fantastic article, such an enjoyable read. You think you’ve got problems with John messing with your head, I’ve been married to him for 53 years!!!
Exhibition closes on the 29th March. Writers, come along and experience the exhibition and see if John messes with your head.
Mary Mutsaers
Catherine, You've nailed it. One of John's pieces just makes me laugh every time I think of it. Tried to write down why and failed a dozen times. A thousand emails end to end, endless bitumen stretching to the next event, that stretch of foreshore. I'll keep trying but
Geoff Ellis
Thank you Catherine .... loved this piece and made my grey day. Love your sense of
humour. Thank you.
Joy Button
So wonderful to see the mediums intersect...and go crashing off in different directions!!! Well done Catherine for having a crack, and thank you John for brilliantly making us leave your exhibition with more questions than answers!!!!!!!
Mick Green
Inverloch Primary School were fortunate to have our Year 6 minds discuss their thoughts of freedom while pondering over the fish in the glass art piece. 11 year olds discussed their thoughts in a conversation with the artist. Truly inspiring, thought provoking and challenging, with joy and cheekiness. All that art and education should be.
Amanda McMahon
Hi Catherine. I've worked out what the egg means! Only teasing!
Thanks to John for not only his wonderful works - but to give us such a challenge. I have finally managed to pen a piece - managed somehow to weave yellow, a cage and a mirror into a story - must have been drunk at the time!
Liane Arno
Poles apart
March 6, 2010
I'm a 30+ year firefighter (CFA), I live in the Bass Coast but spent days down in East Gippsland fighting the fires, I spend time on fuel reduction burns and I see the fire season getting longer and more intense. Yes, fuel reduction burns can help, particularly around assets like towns, where it can assist with firefighting. In the bush it's a different situation though, risk of loosing control, replacement growth can be more hazardous, much shorter windows to burn effectively.
I also vote Greens most of the time, as they have the policies most influenced by facts and science, not money and madness.
Some fourty years ago I finished an honours degree studying physics and modeling at Monash University. Back then we were taught the very basic physics, known for at least 50 years, of how greenhouse gases facilitate the warming of the Earth. Since we knew this we have nearly put half as much greenhouse gases again up into the atmosphere than has been there for a hundred thousand years or more.
There is no question any longer that this must and does influence atmospheric physics (the energy in the climate system). There is no question any more that things are still to get significantly worse with lags in the system, unless we act immediately to move to the systems of the future, that even the prime minister's advisers know, and tell him are here now and ready to use.
We have to replace our aging and unreliable coal and gas soon anyway, why is there any question about where we should be going? And why are we waiting, this will stimulate economic activity, create many more jobs than our current systems, open new markets for savy farmers and reduce the price of power. And that's not to mention saving our children from inheriting one hell of a job to cleaning up our mess if we don't act now.
Neil Rankine
I appreciate the effort that you put into your letter and commend you for being prepared to stand up for what you believe. And start a debate in these virtual pages.I believe our friendship can only be strengthened by serious discussion about real issues. Thank you.
I am working on a full and worthy response to the letter and would just like to clarify a couple of things. Hopefully the editor will allow me to have a couple of bites of the cherry!
You say that "A lot of the message that you conveyed was about the fires". My article consisted of 21 paragraphs and ONE was about the fires.
In regards Jam Jerrup, the failing I point out is the planning scheme (OURS) that allows development on an eroding coastline. I recently was informed that the rock revetment has been designed.
Right now I have to get back to my Infinite Birdcage. Cheers Cobber.
Geoff Ellis
John, you state:' I believe that today’s Labour Party and the Greens have much to answer for. They are the "fuckwits that are in power" in this state for not allowing controlled burn offs...'
I have heard this statement repeated often. It is wrong. Both the Labor government and the Greens have policies that encourage fuel reduction burns. Could you provide one example where Labor or the Greens have stopped a fuel reduction burn?
Fuel reduction burns have not been undertaken for various reasons, but basically for safety concerns. This is sensible decision making.
Peter Bogg
John: 'The Aboriginal people who fought in WWI and WWII fought under the Australian flag and provided a great service to this country. Australia does exist, and we are all part of it, fighting for it, and fighting for solutions. We are one country, one flag, one anthem and one people!'
Not true John, Most Australians fought under the Union Jack in WW1. Most Australians fought under either the Australian Red Ensign or the Union Jack in World War II. All Australian Naval personnel fought under the British Naval Ensign in both world wars.
The Australian flag as we know it now, was only legally defined in the flags act 1953.
Peter Bogg
Home is where the art is
March 6, 2010
Thank you Catherine. As part of the small team at ESPI we really need great publIcity as you have provided. Lovely article full of useful history of this energetic group.
Margaret McCubbery
Friends honour the 'two Bills'
March 6, 2010
A fitting memorial to two good men.
Peter Brown
We will miss farmer Bill in Harmers, he was part of the landscape
Trish Hogan
Pittosporum Flowering
February 21, 2010
Julie, thank you for gracing us with a beautiful read. Your writing evoked such a strong and magnificent sense of place and I was happy to have visited awhile in a place that you so dearly loved. It is a well deserved accolade.
Jessica Berry
That was beautiful Julie, thank you for sharing. I confess, I may too be harbouring a few little pittosporums. Thank you for so eloquently sticking up for our oft-persecuted weedy friends and giving us a glimpse into your world. May our gardens and forests be graced by such lovely inhabitants and protectors as yourself!
Dan
Lovely story, Julie. A pleaure to read.
Karen Bateman
Julie, what a beautiful narrative, so informative and skilfully woven personal and political, xx
Karen
Thank you - most enjoyable read.
Led Leunig
I really enjoyed your memoir Julie. Beautifully written, a joy to read, especially the imagery of the plants, forest and landscape. And I loved the way you weaved the personal, political and scientific through the piece.
Linda Cuttriss
Pulling all the threads together so eloquently, makes me intensely happy to have our wonderful subtle landscape so articulately traversed.
Learned a beautiful new word too! Nimbed! Glorious. Thanks Julie, a truly significant contribution toward our understanding of ourselves in this place. Hopefully opening a greater appreciation of and care for this beautiful land.
Susan Purdy
Beautiful
Theresa Cicero
Absolutely beautiful piece of writing I felt totally atuned to. Look forward to sharing with Lisa Kennedy. 😃✨🌸
Peter Corser
So informative Julie, I couldn't agree more with the bad rap those magnificent trees receive. Could it be possible that they are fire retardant, they look it. Regards, Pauline
Pauline Enright Amon
Thank you Julie, I feel as if you have strolled through my out of control oasis.
Twenty years ago I wandered through the Cowes St Philips Market to be overwhelmed by the most exotic fragrance, in a large pot, Mock Orange I was advised, though Pittosporum was not uttered. When it is in flower, & I'm asked, my response is a miracle of nature; as is a hedge of cream bell-shaped wonga flowers draped over the old trellis fence, behind the gas bottles. through the gate into Missy's garden, the Lost Dogs Home creature, to be framed by the white sprays of the clematis drape through the old pagoda to my back door.
I immediately identified with your wonderful narrative.
Virginia Hamilton
Memories of Hiroshi
February 21, 2010
What an incredible article , beautifully written to conjure up a picture of both an energetic and delightful young man and an aunt who holds him so gently in her heart . Etsuko has the ability to share her deepest emotions without overwhelming the reader - instead she draws you in so that you too can share in her pride, her grief ? Her resolution and her happiness . An inspirational article/ thank you Etsuko
Anne McDonald
Thank you Anne sincerely for taking time to read my written piece. I believe that everything (including both happiness and sadness) is better shared. If my writing can bring solace to any grieving heart, then I am content. Your kind words are much appreciated.
Etsuko Yaunaga
Dear friend Etsuko, so much wisdom, so much pain and grief and re-generation.
Your writing is so SPECIAL because you express so much emotion and so many words that most mere mortals are afraid of doing or saying or writing.
We are all enriched by your writing and your philosophy of life and happiness. Regards, Phyllis Papps
Dear Phyllis, your kind words touched my heart and also affirmed my passion for writing. Learning to write in a second language was difficult, but once I cleared the barriers, words flowed naturally. I feel everything deeply, and there is no other way I can see the world. Sometimes it's painful to be this way but when I can share my feeling with others through my writing it brings a whole new meaning to my creative pursuit.
Etsuko Yaunaga
Etsuko, your words have me in tears. Despite your loss and intense grief, you have found a way through this to enrich your life every day. I can only dream of escaping the grief that engulfs me daily, but your words give me some hope that with time I may be able to achieve this. Thank you.
Heather Sullivan
Oh Heather, grief is very personal process and everyone responds differently. I was lucky enough to have writing in my life when this tragedy took place, and found solace in expressing my feeling. Any creative pursuit helps to heal grieving hearts. I trust that you already have special creativity inside you, so explore your talent and share it with others who appreciate its beauty. Thanks for your honesty and taking time to read my writing. Much appreciated.
Etsuko Yaunaga
I have just read this because I didn't want to read it in a rush. This was too important to rush through and not be able to process as it should be. I have just read it.....3 times. And I say this my beautiful friend - I understand it so very much. My entire life's focus changed on January 1st 2019 with the diagnosis that destroyed my family and everything I knew. It is kind of like learning to walk again - except a little bit braver because they have been denied the chance to live the life that they should have had.....so we can't take it for granted. We must do the things that scare us and the things we didn't think we could.....quite simply because they no longer can. We have to find a new way to relate to people that we love so dearly and are a part of our hearts but now feel that little bit further away. We cannot let them know our grief or despair or how lost we feel because what they are going through is so much worse. We understand and we know but we find a way to process our pain so that they don't have to bear ours as well. My friend this writing is extraordinary. I just want you to know that I hear you, I see you and I understand and above all - I am always here xxxx
Mardi Jones
Dear friend Mardi, First of all thank you for having waited till an appropriate time to read my piece. I appreciate your thoughtfulness, care and respect for my writing. I always ask people to find quiet time and space to read my writing so that they can process. You did. Thank you also for using 'extraordinary' to describe my writing. It's one of my favourite words to receive from my readers.
There are two types of people in the world. Those who have experienced an acute, raw pain of grieving (like you and I), and those who haven't (yet). It's almost impossible to understand this kind of intense pain without going through the actual suffering. I always accept people's sympathy graciously regardless of their experience, but words like yours hit my heart deeply. I hear you, I understand you and I'm with you always. We are strong and resilient because of our grieving experience. Hope you find solace in my writing, and on Daniel's 9th anniversary (or sooner) you are happy as I am right now.
Etsuko Yaunaga
Dear Etsuko
Your gift of making me feel the deep love you have of your family and of life itself is beautiful to me.Keep writing, and living in the now is a very special achievement that I feel is very worthwhile to pursue.
Verena Hoefler
Thank you Verena for your kind words. Writing has helped me find solace. Furthermore by sharing my writing with others I receive strong affirmation to keep on writing. It's my pure joy and is the only way I can see and understand the world.
Etsuko Yaunaga
Beautiful words Etsuko, life takes many unplanned turns, some for the better, some in a different direction. Your words touch many hearts deeply. I love your not a secret!! Focus on what you love
Tony O'Connell
Thank you very much for your words of wisdom, Tony. The fact that they come from the man I respect deeply means a lot to me. I learned quite early that where the mind goes energy flows. Yes I will continue to focus on what I love and what brings joy in my life. I'm so grateful that our paths have crossed.
Etsuko Yaunaga
Why I love Cape
February 21, 2010
Thank you Pete for your article which pretty much sums up my love affair with Cape Paterson and my real concerns about the development plans currently under consideration.
Do we have to ruin all the coastline with over development?! Surely the addition of the Eco-Village on the west side of the township should be the end to development at Cape for a very long time!
Barbara Smith
Thanks Barbara
Yes, one would've hoped that the Ecovillage be the end of it but Matthew Guy's arbitrary expansion on the town boundary to suit the developers means we are constantly fighting this battle. Not until the boundaries are put back to Seaward Drive will this business end.
If this application succeeds, we'll see no end of pressure to build over the whole coast from san remo to Inverloch. It's time to draw a line!
Pete Muskens
My sentiments exactly. I often don’t go near the beach at the Cape as I am somewhat disabled. This does not worry me as I live among the trees on my property. I have upward of 20 gums, many of which are flowering gums of all colours. The local koala comes visiting and possums scurry across our roof. I regret not being able to participate in the regeneration projects run by CPRRA as the volunteers have done a magnificent job. It has also helped to invoke a sense of community that I wish I could be part of. Thanks for your articles that captures the essence of Cape Paterson.
Gael McLeod
Not being a resident of Cape Paterson , but a relatively new resident of Wonthaggi, I would respectfully suggest that all residents of the Cape, not to be silent, have your say or your peaceful township will become like so many other towns, villages, and hamlets, Nothing more than part of the suburban sprawl. My town (Drouin) was a beautiful little village, as a child it was a great place to be.Things changed and now it is almost a suburb of Warragul .mainly because of the apathy of the residents and that includes me. Open your eyes and look at Pakenham, Yarragon, Trafalgar,Poowong, Nyora.. Because that may be your future .
John Cobbledick
I love cape been here for a year and wouldn’t change it at all ! Needs to stay how it is ! For sure ! ❤️
Sam Kahu
Hi Pete. I have read through your article and the responses. I very much agree.
I am having a late attempt to draft a letter to BCSC re amendment C136.
I want to do this in a manner that isn’t just a whinging complaint. Do you have any point form information that could help with my draft?
David Hubble
Enough with the climate gloom
February 21, 2010
Congratulations to Cr Whelan for going plastic free which I will try to emulate.
Joan Woods
Congrats Michael and Geoff at NCES. Did anybody from BCSC admin attend?
Bernie McComb
Hi Bernie Yes BCSC Climate Change Adviser attended the Summit and the council workshop, and is doing a fine job
Michael Whelan
What a thoughtful article from Cr Whelan. So pleased he is being proactive not reactive on this most critical issue. Lets hope it is contagious.
Pete Granger
Thanks Michael for opting to steer the discussion in a more positive direction. Agree with Pete here, we all need it to catch on.
Miriam Strickland
It is great to read this article and I try my best to help along with reducing plastic usage. I do not always find it easy. Positive approach of our community leaders is helping to do our best.
Verena Hoefler
Cancer service to ease the pain
February 21, 2010
A great step forward for Bass Coast and regional Victoria. Congratulations to all involved!
Meryl Tobin
Thank you very much Jan Child and Bass Coast Health.
Jan Fleming
Being member of Probus at San Remo for last 12 years i've seen first hand how difficult it is for people to live in Bass Coast Area and the hours involved in travel for treatment. Our club many times had rosters of drivers to help those unable to travel that far on their own.
Any treatment available at Wonthaggi will be a great improvement for residents.
Having being diagnosed with Lymphoma Cancer In August i now see the issues from the patients perspective. Clearly there is a lot more that needs to be available for the regional areas of Victoria to fully assist you through the whole process. Last week alone i had a Pet Scan and MRI Brain Scan both at Knox Private then following Day a Lumber Puncture at Epworth Box Hill. This equipment is very expensive plus you need the staff to go with it. Plus you need the Cancer specialist Doctors to firstly decide on what your illness is, then the process you need to go through to try to provide you with a cure and then the management of this process. This is a long term process the treatment like chemo is important part but it needs to be linked with all of the above, it doesn't sit out on its own.
With the size of the population in Victoria today having most of these services only available in Metropolitan Melbourne is a major concern and one the Federal & State Govts need to be far more pro active in. Its no good saying the City's are getting too large and we need people to move to regional areas but without the medical services being provided this is never going to happen. Few months ago i was in Albury and the Hospital Services provided by NSW government for that population is amazing. That's what needs to occur in Victoria.
My situation is sadly we know longer can live in San Remo even though we wanted to and really have enjoyed being part of the community in our retirement years. I know great number of people in our community over the last 15 years who have had to make the same decision as we have.
Christopher Day
Salutations from the high ground
February 21, 2010
Thanks very much Geoff for all you do. Loved the comment by Julian Burnside.
Jan Fleming
Jobs that no longer exist
February 10, 2020
Christine's extremely well written account of her early life on Phillip Island provides a fantastic record of the rural life that is now only a distant memory to many and a revelation to most. In the current world of instant gratification it is a delight to read about the first hand experience of the early life on Phillip Island.
I hope that Christine can provide us with further recollections of this fascinating period when Phillip Island was a small farming and fishing community.
Ian Samuel
Loved this article. Reminded me of the simpler Philip Island of the late 60's and 70's when, as a young boy, we would visit family friends who also farmed and fished on the island. But nothing like Christine's experience!
Brett Rogers
Christine, I very much enjoyed your memoir. I have seen a the kilns when visiting PI since I was a child and wondered what the process was. I was also impressed what people did to 'earn a crust'. Very hard work too. Thanks for sharing your experiences.
Pee Bee
Christine i really enjoyed your well written essay on days gone by on PI. It reminded me of my youth during the school holidays, going to work with my Dad Eric, who was a self employed iceman whose customers were the big hotels in Melbourne CBD. The Federal Hotel, Australia Hotel, Menzies Hotel are just a few of those long gone impressive posh hotels which needed broken up ice for the
drinks served.
How marvellous for you to remember and describe in so much detail your former jobs.
I always look at the remaining Chichory kilns and wonder what went on inside all those years ago.
Kay Setches
You create lovely word pictures, Christine. I was somewhere else, living a very different kind of life -- yet I feel a poignant nostalgia for the world you've created here. Some envy, too. Congratulations.
John Gascoigne
My memories of other places and different tasks in my young years was brought to life by Christine's stories. Well written, interesting and I think the word evocative fits.
As an apprentice 'cadet' in the British Merchant Navy, our first day at sea after perhaps a week in port, was spent tossing dunnage over the side. Great heaps went overboard.
Dunnage was a cheap grade of wooden plank used to keep cargo ventilated and apart from the steelwork at the bottom of a ship's hold to avoid condensation damaging valuable cargo. Any moisture would collect in the bilges and be pumped overboard.
Any dunnage which was damaged and rendered not reusable by the discharge of cargo was stacked on deck and jettisoned once the ship had cleared harbour. The dunnage on PI beaches was presumably from ships out of Melbourne.
Containerisation presumably saw an end to the practice.
Peter Brown
Thank goodness for Uncle Keith! I found that fascinating. Hard work out in the environment certainly shaped you Christine. Could WPPC please reproduce this?
Karri Giles
Thank you Christine. What a wonderful story about Phillip Island, capturing the vivid personal experience and the historical connections of the work on the island. My Aunty and Uncle lived at Ventnor and I have many holiday memories — of swimming at Red Rocks and cycling over to Summerland on quiet roads in the 1960s, 70s.
Julie Constable
What a beautifully written memoir Christine. Such a joy to read. The rich detail is a precious record of how these 'extinct' jobs were done and those shared moments toasting crumpets and honey while singing songs late into the night at the chicory kiln are marvellous, capturing a way of working from another time.
Linda Cuttriss
A wonderful, well written story Christine. As a latecomer to Phillip Island, I was fascinated by your evocation of a bygone era. Congratulations on winning the award - well deserved!
Marian Quigley
Lovely story, Christine evoking an era and life we can only wonder about. Well done and congratulations on your win.
Sally Bird
Memoir of bygone jobs takes top writing prize
February 10, 2020
Congratulations to you all! An outstanding outcome! Well done Phyllis for your inspiration and encouragement!
Carmen Bush
Congratulations Christine! And to other pirze winners and commendations.
Miriam Strickland
Congratulations to all involved.
Nicky Miller
Well done Christine and others!
I would love to read Jobs that no longer exist and Pittosporum flowering how does one do that please?
Karri Giles
Hi Karri. The prize winning and commended entries will be published in the Post. First up is Christine's work, which has been published, and Pittosporum Flowering will be published in the next issue of the Post.
Catherine Watson
Thank you for hosting such an inspiring event and Congratulations to the Winner - Christine Grayden and all nominees. We are blessed to have so many amazingly talented people in Bass Coast
Clare Le Serve
Congratulations Christine and everyone involved.
Peter Dann
It’s complicated
February 10, 2020
Congratulations to Pauline and Miriam. Thanks for sharing and thanks for your honesty about the ups and down. BCP doesn't allow comment emoticons and I would choose a raised glass of Champagne. Cheers!
Geoff Ellis
10/2/2020 09:46:37 pm
Ditto to Geoff's comments!
Nicky Miller
‘Blue poles’ director hailed from Wonthaggi
February 10, 2020
I caught up with James Mollison few years back (when mayor) to discuss the Robert Smith collection.
He left Wonthaggi when he was five. His uncle was the person who ok’d artist Noel Counihan to go into the mines to draw the series of prints which are now part of the Bass coast shire collection. It was very rare for artists to even go into the mines back in the day - in fact probable it was the first time.
James employed me a lifetime ago at the NGV - would you believe.
Jordan Crugnale, MP for Bass
A force of nature
February 10, 2020
Great to see Eulie's effort recognised and recorded in such an engaging article. Well done Terri.
Geoff Ellis
Keep it #$%@!!*& nice
January 25, 2020
My repertoire of wise old sayings includes “give them an inch and they take a mile”, along with something about people in glass houses, and “if you have nothing nice to say it is best to say nothing”.
It would be appalling if your Post and all the energy that has gone into it was to be corrupted to ruin by a few bad apples.
Dear Catherine, stay the course !
Tim Shannon
Thankyou Catherine for your journalistic experience and I support your decision to erase the personal criticism.
I appreciate the literature and variety of topics you attract to The Post.
Marjorie Scott
Thank you for your perseverance and all the time you put into the Post. We always look forward to reading all the interesting articles and agree with your decision. Happy New Year Catherine.
Alison Ribush
Enjoyed every article as usual. Keep up the great work!
Michelle Graham
Not living "down there:" anymore, but keep up the good work Catherine,Love reading the (constructive) comments on things happening in Bass Coast
Kevin Chambers
Love the Bass Coast Post.
Thank you Catherine.
Jan Fleming
Gorgeous Catherine!
Without you people like me would not have a voice - we would be less informed - we would not be able to share in a safe environment.
Bullies can be awfully devious - and so destructive - so thank you for not allowing them to have a voice.
Liane Arno
Good decision - i fully support you and thanks for doing such a great job on the Post
Lesley Bretherton
Thank you Catherine for gifting us the Bass Coast Post. Respect is vital and support your decision to stop abuse. Just love reading the articles in the Post and whilst you may not always agree with some views, one often gains knowledge of the reasons for differing views in the written article. Thank you for all that you do.
Joy Button
I totally agree with Catherine and thank her for the outstanding development of a Post with principles
It is indeed unfortunate that journalism as an industry has deteriorated to sensationalism and distortion of the truth to the detriment of the profession.
Informed articles are the source of knowledge shared, with the Post leading in the dissemination of views and opinions without acrimony
Keep up the good work
Ian Samuel
I agree, civil discussion is desperately needed at a time when we seem to becoming more polarised. But abusive retorts achieve nothing but further separation. Keep up the good work Catherine, I so enjoy the Post.
Lorrie Read
Catherine, whilst your intentions are admirable, beware! I used to subscribe to a large national newspaper that permitted what I called "vigorous" debate (which were, to be honest, horrific during the SSM debate) then belatedly decided that they needed moderation. I had several comments (favourable mostly) "rejected" and there was to be no discussing the reasons why. Other readers of the newspaper made similar observations. Eventually it appeared that the rejections were more personal than ethical, so I decided to pull the plug. There will be no political correctness in my house! It is yet another form of censorship.
Everyone views a topic differently, so I believe it would be quite difficult to be impartial and eventually what one considers offensive, others would not.
Pamela Jacka
Hi Pamela. I certainly don’t want to censor readers’ views. The more the merrier! However, the Post has picked up a few trolls along the way and I need to deal with them. The personal criticism and abuse are a diversion from genuine debate. They also deter others from entering the discussion. Let’s see how we go!
Catherine Watson, editor
I'm with you on this one Pamela, You cannot write about topics in Bass Coast Post in a joking, entertaining manner at the expense of people who are working so hard to save their own environment and are struggling with potential unbearable loss (Newhaven Skate Park article) and expect people who are so distraught and emotionally devastated about that topic that is being joked about and not expect a reaction that is pure raw emotion and spelling out nothing but raw facts. The truth hurts unfortunately and the truth should not be deleted or edited. If that raw emotion is taken out then its just not genuine or real and the writing lacks soul of the person who is hurting and who put their real feelings into words.
Min Beaumont
I have so enjoyed reading bass coast post articles for many years, I would be disappointed if a few trolls ruined it for all.
Catherine, she's your baby & I fully support your editorial rights 💞
Kim Veness
This kind of has to work both ways and what has happened to freedom of speech as a reaction to a writers actions, that's what you are after isn't it, a reaction?
Min Beaumont
I totally agree with your right to edit the Post Catherine as you see fit.
That’s your job.
I also totally agree in using reasoned arguments which are based on facts.
Emotional language does not fix the issues.
Frank W Schooneveldt
There are comments on this post that certainly break the rules under which I operate several organisations' popular Facebook pages. Our rules are: No personal attacking of others or name calling in the post or in the comments. No comments which do not pertain to the principles of whichever group's FB page it is, as clearly set out on their websites, e.g. constitutions and forward planning documents agreed to by the members. No swearing - even mild swearing - under any circumstances. There is so much vitriol on the internet these days and it is totally unhelpful. All it does is make people angrier, and in fact curtails rational debate. Catherine your readers may have 'ownership' of your wonderful website, but it is actually YOUR website, and you are perfectly entitled to make your rules, especially after several years of operation have taught you the hard way that some people seriously need to be given clear firm rules to abide by. It is a waste of your valuable time having to moderate everything, but stay firm and eventually everyone will get the message and all behave in a civilised manner.
Christine Grayden
Forged by fire
January 25, 2020
Thank you Laura for your personal experience of the recent fires- such tragic and dramatic disasters continue to ripple long beyond the proverbial splash; the upheaval is unimaginable but then it happens. I hope this unparalleled summer of fire shifts the nation's focus and clarifies priorities. So pleased you and yours are safe.
Jeannie Haughton
Thank you Laura for sharing your story. And thank goodness you are all safe.
Your story certainly brings home what is important.
Caring for Country, caring for people, caring for community, caring for one and another and caring about the World we leave to our Grandchildren.
Frank & Mary Schooneveldt
Laura and Terry, we are very glad your family is safe. Best wishes,
Jan Fleming and John Adam
Thanks so much for sharing, Laura. When I saw and heard you at 'Heads in the Sand' I didn't get to talk to you. I had no idea about your family. I had no idea that the climate refugees I saw from Mallacoota were your grandchildren.
I'm glad that the family is safe. They will be scarred by their experience, but on the day I noted that they seemed such brave people, and from what you say, that is true. They may also become stronger people.
Much was learnt during the Black Saturday fires about safe behaviour at times of fires. If only the media and government could learn all the lessons about climate change that the world should have been acting on many years ago. I hope that the majority of people have learnt enough to insist that we change how we act. If not now, when? If not now, who will be left to decide? If not now, will anyone have any choice?
Bron Dahlstrom
Thanks for this piece Laura. So glad your family survived, and also that the house was saved. I believe Bob and I stayed in their airbnb last year, such a nice spot. We had no idea of their connection to you.
Jenny Skewes
Thank you so much for your kind words and for your understanding. They are truly appreciated.
Terry has just finished making a short film about the Climate Action held at Inverloch that I mention in the article.
Here is the link ... https://vimeo.com/387580606
I'm really grateful to be part of a community that is awake to the importance of climate justice and the need for action.
Laura Brearley
So moving to read your personal account especially after your Black Saturday experiences. Thank you. I am so pleased they can return home already even tho it is so shocking and the smoke and ash seems to stay for a long time.
It's a long haul cleaning up and rebuilding and a community that can put forward what it wants from agerncies and govt often fairs better in the long term reconstruction.
You and Terry are truly fantastic and such a wonderful support. These events call on all our resources and more.
I love the grandchildren taking action with their posters, a positive sign amongst the aftermath.
(Re climate refugees - I'm caring for three of the family 's non laying old chooks ! )
Neri Melsmith
Thank you for your story. My Niece's Fiance Nikolai Handsjuk's Mother's house burnt down at Mallacoota and his Grandmother's was about the only one left in the street.
Caroline Giles
Weighty words
January 25, 2020
Thank you all three for your wonderful work. There certainly seems to be much talent in Gippsland. I very much look forward to reading the winning entry.
Felicia Di Stefano
Sounds like there were many fabulous entries and a challenge Catherine just to establish a short list. Looking forward to the announcement on February 9. Will this announcement be open to the public as I cannot see time that it starts.
Joy Button
Fabulous! can't wait to find out who is the winner.
Clare Le Serve
Looks great Catherine; and I wonder, might it be worth publishing the best 10 or 15 as a book?
Max Richter
A blazing star
Jan 25, 2020
Far too young to leave us - I still try not to think about this but it was a life well lived and my friend for so much of his time in the Wonthaggi area. Ricardo entered some photographs in the Show that I help organise just before he passed. Thank you Merle for encouraging him. Well anyway he did very well and was so happy with his prizes That was the last I heard about him when Merle contacted me that fateful night.To me his joy of achieving something that I was part of made me smile as well as make me cry - Loved you Ricardo - A joy to know and call a friend
Rosemary Loughnan
Ricardo, Ricardo, Ricardo !!
My elderly mother used to say when she visited Garnham House in Wonthaggi once a week.
Then some years later, she was stunned when she and a few of the residents of Griffiths Point Lodge (in San Remo) were driven to his exhibition.
What a wonderful artist, photographer, writer and very special person who gave warmth to so many people who had the privilege of meeting you and being with you.
Vale, Ricardo, may you rest in peace
Phyllis Papps
Thrills and spills
Jan 25, 2020 –
This story deserves support and reflection.
Near death experiences - all survived - mostly cherished - by those who were lucky enough to have a childhood before helicopter parenting.
We learned a confidence and love of the wild parts of our world.
Peter Brown
I enjoyed this story and did similar stuff in the 70s and 80s
Caroline Giles
Oh my goodness Liz, what you write about climbing a tree is in exact detail of what the children of Newhaven at Phillip Island did in the Grayden's Memorial Park in the 70's. The cypress trees which still stand there today as part of Newhaven's unique history and green environment and were planted in a similar fashion as the ones down Thompson Avenue in Cowes are still the main characteristics of our much loved park and township. The cypress in the park was a haven for play when children were free to roam. We too could climb up the trunk by firstly pulling ourselves up via forked branches like monkey bars. I look at the tree now and wonder how we managed to pull ourselves up
Min Beaumont
March 20, 2020
Great article Tim!
Let me know if there's any petition to sign or any other pressure we can get to bear on Government or GM to get this important area saved for conservation. It's an ongoing disgrace that so many multinational corporations are the first to come to government when they're in financial trouble, yet baulk at paying any tax as part of their quid pro quo!
Pete Muskens
Great article and idea Tim.
Peter Dann
Congratulations, Tim! A refreshing look at a possible future for the GMH Proving Ground, an incredibly valuable environmental and economic asset which should be gifted or bought for the good of the community.
Meryl Tobin Brown
That's an excellent article. I do so hope the site is gifted for wildlife conservation or that council and government unite to protect it for that purpose. The income and tax figures you quote are appalling in their cost to Australians. Thank you for presenting this important article.
Susan Linley
Send a message to GM HQ.
Mary Barra - CEO and Chair of GM
linkedin.com/in/mary-barra-29469712
Dhivya Suryadevara GM CFO
linkedin.com/in/dhivya-suryadevara
General Motors Company
P.O. BOX 33170
Detroit, MI 48232-5170
Geoff Ellis
Thanks Tim. It is always good to get the facts - the proving ground has always had a slightly mysterious air about it.
Anyway it can be kept as it is, count me in.
Joan Woods
Good idea for tourism but at this point of time with USA virtually closed down and we not far behind not the time to pursue this.
The governments, companies and people around the world have more important things on their mind than a block of land in Victoria.
Nothing will happen at this time , follow up at the right time and that is certainly not now.
Christopher Day
An excellent article and great idea. Not enough is being done in conservation on this scale. This is such a good opportunity for the Council and Government to move on this together, NOW, before it's too late......what possibilities, they're endless when it comes to the environment and the future. I say, act fast and act now.
Gillian Armstrong
I enjoyed most of Tim's article and agree that the site would be a wonderful area for conservation purposes. However I think it would have been better if Tim had not published such misleading figures. He cites Gross Income for several years and complains that no tax was paid on this income. He conveniently forgets to take into account the operating expenses of those years or to mention that in the years 2013/14 the company made an operating loss of 554 million dollars and in the year 2014/15 made an operating loss of 255 million to mention just two. The subsequent years were not much better. It was these huge losses over several consecutive years that led to GM opting out of Australia. Consequently this shows that there is a very good reason that no tax was paid during the period Tim published. Given Tim's background he must have known how misleading the article is.
Trevor Brown
Trevor Browns information on GMH losses adds a new dimension to the debate. You certainly wouldn't want to approach GMH with incorrect financial information they would dismiss any discussion . I doubt they would only be interested in selling the land for the best deal for them clearly they we're in bad financial situation or they wouldn't be withdrawing from all right hand drive markets around the world not just Australia . The last few months and however long this corona virus lasts will no doubt leave them in far worse financial position .
If the Victorian community it going to obtain this parcel of land for long term benefit of the community it needs to put together a financial offer that they could accept expecting them to donate it is a waste of time . Of course as a housing estate it could provide a developer great parcel of land in an area where future housing is closer to Melbourne than areas like Wonthaggi so to stop that happening any approach to GMH has to be commercially well put together . Another question is does Bass Coast council currently collect rates for this land and if so how much is paid each year.
Chris Day
Ed and the Birds
March 20, 2020
So much food for thought! I thoroughly enjoyed reading this Karen and have to digest the good and bad news to work out if we're coming out on top.
Hilary Stuchbery
loved the story and the complexities in it.
it reminded me there's quite a few guerrilla planters out there .
one of them informed me when i was explaining some of the looks and questioning it best to some how get the word ' beautification ' of the medium strip into conversations. And yes just keep planting
Nerida Melsmith
It was such a pleasure to read this first time around and, on the second reading, it really resonates, especially the last line.
Geoff Ellis
Karen, I loved your inspiring story about Ed and the birds. I had virtually given up planting shrubs at my place on Phillip Island as they need a lifetime of defending from wallabies. Trees get above wallaby height and tussock grasses get too rough for their palate. But your story has made me rethink how I can create little protected shrubby places for the small birds. And all power to Ed’s guerrilla tactics!
Linda Cuttriss
This is a kind and inspiring story. Thanks Karen. You write beautifully.
Carmel Anderson
Karen what a wonderful account of Ed, the birds, the interrelationships and the changing face of our world. Thank goodness for optimists no matter how plodding! Thank you.
Julie Constable
Hello Karen, Wow what a wonderful article, I remember our ramblings around Inverloch 20 years ago, my how it has changed.
Wendy Davies
Thanks everyone for your kind comments, and for taking the time to read it.
Karen Blackman
Immensely proud of my cousin Karen, on her ability to make me think about things in a way I never have before. Writing is a passion, but a cheerleader for change. Well done wild cousin Karen, which has different connotations to me now. Natural, native and not prescribed. So very proud of you x
Sara Fellows
The virus diaries
March 20, 2020
Thank you Catherine! You have made me laugh and cheered my week no end.
Camilla Myers
What a brilliant piece! Your observation is accurate and I love your witty expression scattered through your writing. Your insight and wisdom certainly lifted my heart in these uncertain times. Now our local gym and swimming pool The Y is closed and I'm jobless. Thank goodness I have my writing.
Etsuko Yasunaga
How easily our civilisation can unravel, it seems like only yesterday that our leaders were exhorting us to take an empty esky, go out to the bushfire-ravaged areas and buy from small businesses. It appears that the hordes have taken this too literally, pillaging our country supermarkets - how unseemly. I expect that Post readers will behave in a more civilised manner than most and that you all remain safe from this latest version of armageddon. Perhaps next time the PM is consulting his good book and praising the lord he will look up the chapter titled Wrath of God.......
Mark Robertson
Oh Catherine you do make me laugh
This is a pretty common trauma response as as for being unAustralia, I cringed when I heard the PM say stock up- I though you have no idea what you are unleashing. Turns out he didn’t and is now blaming the people - give me a break please!
As for me I probably fit into some kind of food hoarder category- what has Costcodone to us ! I shop late Oct Nov and buy enough nonperishables and new products I’ve never seen before ( to try! Cos I can) to feed a family and friends of 12 for a month. This January Feb wasn’t that busy, and the two chooks on fire rescue lay an egg every few days. So fresh fruit and veg is all that’s needed.. I don’t feel quite so odd now!
Nerida Melsmith
What a hoot Catherine! As I went into IGA (no toilet rolls, no pasta, no UHT (only 'fake' Milk- made from seeds and nuts -yuk drink water) but plenty of people to have a chat with and shake our heads over people's foolishness. Loved your comment about not being able to get crap from China (in our family we call it Chinese Landfill), but for .
'cheap' we let our manufacturing industries shrivel so lots of 'stuff' comes from OS. I do read labels and usually can find products in the food line Made in Australia (avoid asparagus from Peru and cherries from the US of A). We eat seasonally and grow vegies and fruit. Keep up the good work and full marks to the contributors of articles and cartoons. Some clown said life wasn't meant to be easy. Cheers.
Yvonne McRae
The clown (Malcolm Fraser, former PM) actually said “Life is not meant to be easy, my child; but take courage: it can be delightful.”. Like all good journalists, only part of the quote was reported and continues to be, incorrectly, reported. It was a call for people to have a go and don't be afraid. The results can be delightful. The quote is from a Bernard Shaw play,
Perhaps now with our borders closed, etc. we will remember what it was like to be self-sufficient and start manufacturing again. We just need to keep a rein on the wages so that we don't make our industries unable to compete with the "Chinese Landfill". We do make a bit of a profit out of the imported landfill - it's usually our iron ore!
Pamela Jacka
Bravo Catherine, I hope the hordes read the post. And well done to the commentators 1e Frank, Yvonne,Nerida... You've said it all. except, Australia also had ration books during and after the war. A message for the Polis,: Get them back again quick!
Heather Tobias
I simply love your story. I think all your readers can relate to it. Thank you Catherine
Jellie N. Wyckelsma
It was at Aldi's, not a bottle shop and l wasn't joking.
Hamish Watson
Could this be a return to village life, circa 1820, when people's concerns and information-exchange centred on the neighbours, the inn, the post office, the grocer's and the local dance? Likewise journalism and the bygone 'vox pop', where voices of people on the street appeared on a printed page. Thank you, Catherine! Just what the doctor ordered, apart from the hand wash and face mask.
John Gascoigne
Man of many parts
March 20, 2020
An interesting insight into one of our local hardworking councillors. Well written Liane.
Rob Parsons
As an ex ratepayer in his ward, I'd just like to back up Rob Parsons's praise of Geoff Ellis..
Not only for his interest in conserving as much of Bass Coast as possible, exemplified by his backing of Preserve Western Port in the "2014 "Battle of Hastings", (aka the container port), but also his 100% backing of me in a personal issue in the months before I moved back to Melbourne.
I know he is flat out 100% of the time, but I still wish he'd find time to have that dinner with me up here in Melbourne we discussed before I moved back here!!!!!
Tho that of course may have to wait until after this "Bug" drama plays out.
Good luck to all down there in the current crisis. I know full well what tourism means to Bass Shire...
Sincerely
Kevin Chambers
Great story Liano, we need more people like Geoff. I wish him all the best with the Lang Lang proving grounds. Hardly any bush left in West Gippsland, we need to conserve what remains.
Peter Bogg
Despite my inherent distrust of politicians I enjoyed this biography and the writing moved along smoothly.
Rowland Arno
Very interesting article on a very interesting person, Liane. I've met Geoff on a number of occasions over the last couple of years. A genuine,open minded person of great heart. An absolute asset to our community.
Ellen Hubble
Self portrait of an architect
March 20, 2020
A familiar journey for creatives I suspect- the inner need to puzzle and scrutinise their purpose... Architecture as the portrait of the client makes me smile... studio of delight. Yes. I reflect on my husbands and my own spaces within our home. It explains a lot 🤪 Thank you for the article
Jeannie Haughton
Tim, an informative article thankyou. Here are some random points about creativity in general I'd make. If you're scared to make a mistake creativity will suffer. If you follow the master you will not learn your way. Mistakes are your sub-conscious letting lose. "Considered mistakes" have an unexpected new direction, renewed power and surprising outcomes. My first boss said to me as a passing comment on something I was doing at my art desk... he said "Peter, take the bull by the horns",something I have used my whole career to date. Our pathways have a similar echo Tim.
Peter Walker
How wonderful to read another of your incredibly well-crafted, profoundly thought and beautifully written pieces Tim. I love the way your writing makes me think, question, wonder and then smile. I look forward to the next one!
Linda Cuttriss
The solace of birds
March 20, 2020
What a wonderful and sensitive piece of non-fiction writing about your love of nature, conservation and the environment. Your illustrations were a superb visual way to accompany the article. Every one applauds the many decades of your efforts and voluntary work you have devoted to Phillip Island and surrounding areas.
Phyllis Papps
Your words, with what they describe in the neighbouring 'nest', make for the most beguiling reading experience. Thank you, Patsy.
John Gascoigne
Lovely to read your observations of the birds in your garden Patsy. They are insightful and informative and your illustrations are wonderful. I always refer to your illustrations when I visit the bird hide at Swan Lake. They are excellent representations and it’s great be able to identify all the birds I am observing. I look forward to Solace of Birds Part 2.
Linda Cuttriss
Lovely article Patsy, I can so relate to your garden. My garden is my sanctuary, and is the food bowl for many native birds. I can really relate to your sentiment and your illustrations. My kids remember with warmth the drawings you would do for them as Lollypop Lady!
Gillian Armstrong
Such arrogance!
March 20, 2020
Just get in there and re-vegetate, erect a sign at the property boundary explaining the need for and value of the works. If the sign gets vandalised erect a bigger one!
Neil Rankine
On common ground
March 20, 2020
Thanks Frank, always good to hear from you and your incredible historical knowledge- totally agree
Angela Wishart
Thank you for this Frank. I love it. Beautifully written and absolutely fascinating.
Nancy Vaughan
Love your work Frank. What a beautiful piece of writing. Thanks for sharing
Tracie McIntosh
Ditto from me Frank. I love your stories. Please keep them coming. It’s always a good time to be reminded of Wonthaggi’s egalitarian roots. Not just for the sake of nostalgia, but as a legacy for now and the future, a reminder of what’s important about being human.
Linda Cuttriss
Berry delicious
March 20, 2020
Well done Jan. I really enjoy your recipes. Cheers, Yvonne
Yvonne McRae
Not so fast, GM
March 6, 2010
Amazing idea!
Vicki Breen
Good contribution to the wider conversation, Mikhaela. I'm sure there are plenty of ideas out there, which I hope will be heard by decision makers. My personal hope is that this unique place will become a State asset for the people of Victoria and, whatever activities are eventually approved, that the flora and fauna continue to be protected. We need to watch this one carefully.
Anne Heath Mennell
Michaela & BCP - you have well said exactly what has been on my mind since the Holden announcement. Get onto Jordan Crugnale to make representations on behalf of community to State Govt too.
Anne Paul
Hi Mikhaela, I think that GM should by rights gift this land to the people of Australia.
While Holden was riding high on the hog in the Australian market, with as much as 50% market share - and remember too that GM was assisted by the Chifley Government to establish manufacturing here under the General Motors banner - it repatriated handsome profits to GM balance sheets in Detroit for the better part of 60 years. It has also benefited from huge amounts of Government largesse by way of the Green Car Innovation Fund (which began at $500million, and grew to $1billion); then later, the Automotive Transformation Scheme - tipping another $400million into local manufacturing (before the announcements of closure).
In fact, over the 12 years from 2001-2013, Holden's own figures show it received $2.17billion in state and federal government assistance, compared to $1.1 billion for Ford and $1.2 billion for Toyota.
Each of these manufacturers was then assisted with taxpayer money - after the announcement of closures - to shutter the factories and retrain the workforce. This amounted to another $150million (or so).
To load more salt into the wounds, GMH hasn't paid for tax for years: income 2016/17 - $4,601,580,614, tax - $0. (You can thank internal invoicing, fees from the parent company, for that.)
So, should it gift its proving grounds to Lang Lang? I should think so. Australian taxpayers have, after all, already paid handsomely for it.
I reckon we can get a groundswell going here. I'm a former motoring journalist, I think I can swing a lot of them in behind this campaign.
So, who's going to be in from down here? Let's get a group going and see what we can get rolling.
Tim O’Brien
Great idea it's an asset that could add to the tourism in this area. Tourism is vital for the economy of not just Bass area but all of Australia.
Obviously the coronavirus is on everybody's priority at moment but it is showing us how important tourism is. It's also showing us how stupid we are as a country to close down our manufacturing sector which the state of Victoria dominated since WW2 mainly driven by buyers of major retailers going into Asia to get cheaper products and make more money. Now we find ourselves running out of products as we have no back up available .
My suggestion would be to get the federal government involved in this issue as vic govt have no new money to spend in sure the treasurer won't let Premier Dan anywhere near this issue.
Don't waste your energy thinking GMH will assist or donate the land they have shown only interested in their own situation not those who sold , serviced or bought their products .
Chris Day
Alzheimer Sufferer/Carer Suite
March 6, 2010
Malcolm, your tribute to moments - too seldom caught - in two lives eternally tied into one is gripping, devastating, haunting, cleansing. Bravo.
Fiona
Bravo Malcolm.
Jeannie Haughton
Lovely words. Thus we process what must have been hard to live!
Heather Slutzkin
Heather, what a profound way of putting it. The act of writing, though often hard, brings understanding. "Emotion recollected in tranquillity", as Wordsworth described it.
Catherine Watson
What very insightful comments, Heather.
Ann Stocker
Congratulations on the publication of this book of poems. Very insightful on the emotions and moments one goes through.
Lynn Rogers
Malcolm, this wonderful piece of poetry about love, life and loss is a superb piece of writing.
I truly hope that you will be able to have it published in book form.
Warm regards, Phyllis
Phyllis Papps
A special relationship documented, explored and cherished by the poet.
An achievement of note.
Nancy Endersby-Harshman
Damn you, John Mutsaers
March 6, 2010
Sorry Catherine, Messing with dreams mmmmmm?? nice thought.
Here is a little clue which I shared at the opening.
A man goes into a hardware shop and asks for 10 mm drill bit: what is it that he really wants???? He wants a 10mm hole. look beyond, behind and in the nooks and crannies then close your eyes and dream words.
John Mutsaers
Hi Catherine, I did brave the crowd and heard John speak, yes he seeks to tantalise and provoke, just what art should do. My takeaway was that the birds are thoughts and the cage is our captive paradigm; our upbringing; schooling; our fears and a wish to fit in. The great thinkers at least made it to a more expansive birdcage.
Michael Whelan
Catherine, Fantastic article, such an enjoyable read. You think you’ve got problems with John messing with your head, I’ve been married to him for 53 years!!!
Exhibition closes on the 29th March. Writers, come along and experience the exhibition and see if John messes with your head.
Mary Mutsaers
Catherine, You've nailed it. One of John's pieces just makes me laugh every time I think of it. Tried to write down why and failed a dozen times. A thousand emails end to end, endless bitumen stretching to the next event, that stretch of foreshore. I'll keep trying but
Geoff Ellis
Thank you Catherine .... loved this piece and made my grey day. Love your sense of
humour. Thank you.
Joy Button
So wonderful to see the mediums intersect...and go crashing off in different directions!!! Well done Catherine for having a crack, and thank you John for brilliantly making us leave your exhibition with more questions than answers!!!!!!!
Mick Green
Inverloch Primary School were fortunate to have our Year 6 minds discuss their thoughts of freedom while pondering over the fish in the glass art piece. 11 year olds discussed their thoughts in a conversation with the artist. Truly inspiring, thought provoking and challenging, with joy and cheekiness. All that art and education should be.
Amanda McMahon
Hi Catherine. I've worked out what the egg means! Only teasing!
Thanks to John for not only his wonderful works - but to give us such a challenge. I have finally managed to pen a piece - managed somehow to weave yellow, a cage and a mirror into a story - must have been drunk at the time!
Liane Arno
Poles apart
March 6, 2010
I'm a 30+ year firefighter (CFA), I live in the Bass Coast but spent days down in East Gippsland fighting the fires, I spend time on fuel reduction burns and I see the fire season getting longer and more intense. Yes, fuel reduction burns can help, particularly around assets like towns, where it can assist with firefighting. In the bush it's a different situation though, risk of loosing control, replacement growth can be more hazardous, much shorter windows to burn effectively.
I also vote Greens most of the time, as they have the policies most influenced by facts and science, not money and madness.
Some fourty years ago I finished an honours degree studying physics and modeling at Monash University. Back then we were taught the very basic physics, known for at least 50 years, of how greenhouse gases facilitate the warming of the Earth. Since we knew this we have nearly put half as much greenhouse gases again up into the atmosphere than has been there for a hundred thousand years or more.
There is no question any longer that this must and does influence atmospheric physics (the energy in the climate system). There is no question any more that things are still to get significantly worse with lags in the system, unless we act immediately to move to the systems of the future, that even the prime minister's advisers know, and tell him are here now and ready to use.
We have to replace our aging and unreliable coal and gas soon anyway, why is there any question about where we should be going? And why are we waiting, this will stimulate economic activity, create many more jobs than our current systems, open new markets for savy farmers and reduce the price of power. And that's not to mention saving our children from inheriting one hell of a job to cleaning up our mess if we don't act now.
Neil Rankine
I appreciate the effort that you put into your letter and commend you for being prepared to stand up for what you believe. And start a debate in these virtual pages.I believe our friendship can only be strengthened by serious discussion about real issues. Thank you.
I am working on a full and worthy response to the letter and would just like to clarify a couple of things. Hopefully the editor will allow me to have a couple of bites of the cherry!
You say that "A lot of the message that you conveyed was about the fires". My article consisted of 21 paragraphs and ONE was about the fires.
In regards Jam Jerrup, the failing I point out is the planning scheme (OURS) that allows development on an eroding coastline. I recently was informed that the rock revetment has been designed.
Right now I have to get back to my Infinite Birdcage. Cheers Cobber.
Geoff Ellis
John, you state:' I believe that today’s Labour Party and the Greens have much to answer for. They are the "fuckwits that are in power" in this state for not allowing controlled burn offs...'
I have heard this statement repeated often. It is wrong. Both the Labor government and the Greens have policies that encourage fuel reduction burns. Could you provide one example where Labor or the Greens have stopped a fuel reduction burn?
Fuel reduction burns have not been undertaken for various reasons, but basically for safety concerns. This is sensible decision making.
Peter Bogg
John: 'The Aboriginal people who fought in WWI and WWII fought under the Australian flag and provided a great service to this country. Australia does exist, and we are all part of it, fighting for it, and fighting for solutions. We are one country, one flag, one anthem and one people!'
Not true John, Most Australians fought under the Union Jack in WW1. Most Australians fought under either the Australian Red Ensign or the Union Jack in World War II. All Australian Naval personnel fought under the British Naval Ensign in both world wars.
The Australian flag as we know it now, was only legally defined in the flags act 1953.
Peter Bogg
Home is where the art is
March 6, 2010
Thank you Catherine. As part of the small team at ESPI we really need great publIcity as you have provided. Lovely article full of useful history of this energetic group.
Margaret McCubbery
Friends honour the 'two Bills'
March 6, 2010
A fitting memorial to two good men.
Peter Brown
We will miss farmer Bill in Harmers, he was part of the landscape
Trish Hogan
Pittosporum Flowering
February 21, 2010
Julie, thank you for gracing us with a beautiful read. Your writing evoked such a strong and magnificent sense of place and I was happy to have visited awhile in a place that you so dearly loved. It is a well deserved accolade.
Jessica Berry
That was beautiful Julie, thank you for sharing. I confess, I may too be harbouring a few little pittosporums. Thank you for so eloquently sticking up for our oft-persecuted weedy friends and giving us a glimpse into your world. May our gardens and forests be graced by such lovely inhabitants and protectors as yourself!
Dan
Lovely story, Julie. A pleaure to read.
Karen Bateman
Julie, what a beautiful narrative, so informative and skilfully woven personal and political, xx
Karen
Thank you - most enjoyable read.
Led Leunig
I really enjoyed your memoir Julie. Beautifully written, a joy to read, especially the imagery of the plants, forest and landscape. And I loved the way you weaved the personal, political and scientific through the piece.
Linda Cuttriss
Pulling all the threads together so eloquently, makes me intensely happy to have our wonderful subtle landscape so articulately traversed.
Learned a beautiful new word too! Nimbed! Glorious. Thanks Julie, a truly significant contribution toward our understanding of ourselves in this place. Hopefully opening a greater appreciation of and care for this beautiful land.
Susan Purdy
Beautiful
Theresa Cicero
Absolutely beautiful piece of writing I felt totally atuned to. Look forward to sharing with Lisa Kennedy. 😃✨🌸
Peter Corser
So informative Julie, I couldn't agree more with the bad rap those magnificent trees receive. Could it be possible that they are fire retardant, they look it. Regards, Pauline
Pauline Enright Amon
Thank you Julie, I feel as if you have strolled through my out of control oasis.
Twenty years ago I wandered through the Cowes St Philips Market to be overwhelmed by the most exotic fragrance, in a large pot, Mock Orange I was advised, though Pittosporum was not uttered. When it is in flower, & I'm asked, my response is a miracle of nature; as is a hedge of cream bell-shaped wonga flowers draped over the old trellis fence, behind the gas bottles. through the gate into Missy's garden, the Lost Dogs Home creature, to be framed by the white sprays of the clematis drape through the old pagoda to my back door.
I immediately identified with your wonderful narrative.
Virginia Hamilton
Memories of Hiroshi
February 21, 2010
What an incredible article , beautifully written to conjure up a picture of both an energetic and delightful young man and an aunt who holds him so gently in her heart . Etsuko has the ability to share her deepest emotions without overwhelming the reader - instead she draws you in so that you too can share in her pride, her grief ? Her resolution and her happiness . An inspirational article/ thank you Etsuko
Anne McDonald
Thank you Anne sincerely for taking time to read my written piece. I believe that everything (including both happiness and sadness) is better shared. If my writing can bring solace to any grieving heart, then I am content. Your kind words are much appreciated.
Etsuko Yaunaga
Dear friend Etsuko, so much wisdom, so much pain and grief and re-generation.
Your writing is so SPECIAL because you express so much emotion and so many words that most mere mortals are afraid of doing or saying or writing.
We are all enriched by your writing and your philosophy of life and happiness. Regards, Phyllis Papps
Dear Phyllis, your kind words touched my heart and also affirmed my passion for writing. Learning to write in a second language was difficult, but once I cleared the barriers, words flowed naturally. I feel everything deeply, and there is no other way I can see the world. Sometimes it's painful to be this way but when I can share my feeling with others through my writing it brings a whole new meaning to my creative pursuit.
Etsuko Yaunaga
Etsuko, your words have me in tears. Despite your loss and intense grief, you have found a way through this to enrich your life every day. I can only dream of escaping the grief that engulfs me daily, but your words give me some hope that with time I may be able to achieve this. Thank you.
Heather Sullivan
Oh Heather, grief is very personal process and everyone responds differently. I was lucky enough to have writing in my life when this tragedy took place, and found solace in expressing my feeling. Any creative pursuit helps to heal grieving hearts. I trust that you already have special creativity inside you, so explore your talent and share it with others who appreciate its beauty. Thanks for your honesty and taking time to read my writing. Much appreciated.
Etsuko Yaunaga
I have just read this because I didn't want to read it in a rush. This was too important to rush through and not be able to process as it should be. I have just read it.....3 times. And I say this my beautiful friend - I understand it so very much. My entire life's focus changed on January 1st 2019 with the diagnosis that destroyed my family and everything I knew. It is kind of like learning to walk again - except a little bit braver because they have been denied the chance to live the life that they should have had.....so we can't take it for granted. We must do the things that scare us and the things we didn't think we could.....quite simply because they no longer can. We have to find a new way to relate to people that we love so dearly and are a part of our hearts but now feel that little bit further away. We cannot let them know our grief or despair or how lost we feel because what they are going through is so much worse. We understand and we know but we find a way to process our pain so that they don't have to bear ours as well. My friend this writing is extraordinary. I just want you to know that I hear you, I see you and I understand and above all - I am always here xxxx
Mardi Jones
Dear friend Mardi, First of all thank you for having waited till an appropriate time to read my piece. I appreciate your thoughtfulness, care and respect for my writing. I always ask people to find quiet time and space to read my writing so that they can process. You did. Thank you also for using 'extraordinary' to describe my writing. It's one of my favourite words to receive from my readers.
There are two types of people in the world. Those who have experienced an acute, raw pain of grieving (like you and I), and those who haven't (yet). It's almost impossible to understand this kind of intense pain without going through the actual suffering. I always accept people's sympathy graciously regardless of their experience, but words like yours hit my heart deeply. I hear you, I understand you and I'm with you always. We are strong and resilient because of our grieving experience. Hope you find solace in my writing, and on Daniel's 9th anniversary (or sooner) you are happy as I am right now.
Etsuko Yaunaga
Dear Etsuko
Your gift of making me feel the deep love you have of your family and of life itself is beautiful to me.Keep writing, and living in the now is a very special achievement that I feel is very worthwhile to pursue.
Verena Hoefler
Thank you Verena for your kind words. Writing has helped me find solace. Furthermore by sharing my writing with others I receive strong affirmation to keep on writing. It's my pure joy and is the only way I can see and understand the world.
Etsuko Yaunaga
Beautiful words Etsuko, life takes many unplanned turns, some for the better, some in a different direction. Your words touch many hearts deeply. I love your not a secret!! Focus on what you love
Tony O'Connell
Thank you very much for your words of wisdom, Tony. The fact that they come from the man I respect deeply means a lot to me. I learned quite early that where the mind goes energy flows. Yes I will continue to focus on what I love and what brings joy in my life. I'm so grateful that our paths have crossed.
Etsuko Yaunaga
Why I love Cape
February 21, 2010
Thank you Pete for your article which pretty much sums up my love affair with Cape Paterson and my real concerns about the development plans currently under consideration.
Do we have to ruin all the coastline with over development?! Surely the addition of the Eco-Village on the west side of the township should be the end to development at Cape for a very long time!
Barbara Smith
Thanks Barbara
Yes, one would've hoped that the Ecovillage be the end of it but Matthew Guy's arbitrary expansion on the town boundary to suit the developers means we are constantly fighting this battle. Not until the boundaries are put back to Seaward Drive will this business end.
If this application succeeds, we'll see no end of pressure to build over the whole coast from san remo to Inverloch. It's time to draw a line!
Pete Muskens
My sentiments exactly. I often don’t go near the beach at the Cape as I am somewhat disabled. This does not worry me as I live among the trees on my property. I have upward of 20 gums, many of which are flowering gums of all colours. The local koala comes visiting and possums scurry across our roof. I regret not being able to participate in the regeneration projects run by CPRRA as the volunteers have done a magnificent job. It has also helped to invoke a sense of community that I wish I could be part of. Thanks for your articles that captures the essence of Cape Paterson.
Gael McLeod
Not being a resident of Cape Paterson , but a relatively new resident of Wonthaggi, I would respectfully suggest that all residents of the Cape, not to be silent, have your say or your peaceful township will become like so many other towns, villages, and hamlets, Nothing more than part of the suburban sprawl. My town (Drouin) was a beautiful little village, as a child it was a great place to be.Things changed and now it is almost a suburb of Warragul .mainly because of the apathy of the residents and that includes me. Open your eyes and look at Pakenham, Yarragon, Trafalgar,Poowong, Nyora.. Because that may be your future .
John Cobbledick
I love cape been here for a year and wouldn’t change it at all ! Needs to stay how it is ! For sure ! ❤️
Sam Kahu
Hi Pete. I have read through your article and the responses. I very much agree.
I am having a late attempt to draft a letter to BCSC re amendment C136.
I want to do this in a manner that isn’t just a whinging complaint. Do you have any point form information that could help with my draft?
David Hubble
Enough with the climate gloom
February 21, 2010
Congratulations to Cr Whelan for going plastic free which I will try to emulate.
Joan Woods
Congrats Michael and Geoff at NCES. Did anybody from BCSC admin attend?
Bernie McComb
Hi Bernie Yes BCSC Climate Change Adviser attended the Summit and the council workshop, and is doing a fine job
Michael Whelan
What a thoughtful article from Cr Whelan. So pleased he is being proactive not reactive on this most critical issue. Lets hope it is contagious.
Pete Granger
Thanks Michael for opting to steer the discussion in a more positive direction. Agree with Pete here, we all need it to catch on.
Miriam Strickland
It is great to read this article and I try my best to help along with reducing plastic usage. I do not always find it easy. Positive approach of our community leaders is helping to do our best.
Verena Hoefler
Cancer service to ease the pain
February 21, 2010
A great step forward for Bass Coast and regional Victoria. Congratulations to all involved!
Meryl Tobin
Thank you very much Jan Child and Bass Coast Health.
Jan Fleming
Being member of Probus at San Remo for last 12 years i've seen first hand how difficult it is for people to live in Bass Coast Area and the hours involved in travel for treatment. Our club many times had rosters of drivers to help those unable to travel that far on their own.
Any treatment available at Wonthaggi will be a great improvement for residents.
Having being diagnosed with Lymphoma Cancer In August i now see the issues from the patients perspective. Clearly there is a lot more that needs to be available for the regional areas of Victoria to fully assist you through the whole process. Last week alone i had a Pet Scan and MRI Brain Scan both at Knox Private then following Day a Lumber Puncture at Epworth Box Hill. This equipment is very expensive plus you need the staff to go with it. Plus you need the Cancer specialist Doctors to firstly decide on what your illness is, then the process you need to go through to try to provide you with a cure and then the management of this process. This is a long term process the treatment like chemo is important part but it needs to be linked with all of the above, it doesn't sit out on its own.
With the size of the population in Victoria today having most of these services only available in Metropolitan Melbourne is a major concern and one the Federal & State Govts need to be far more pro active in. Its no good saying the City's are getting too large and we need people to move to regional areas but without the medical services being provided this is never going to happen. Few months ago i was in Albury and the Hospital Services provided by NSW government for that population is amazing. That's what needs to occur in Victoria.
My situation is sadly we know longer can live in San Remo even though we wanted to and really have enjoyed being part of the community in our retirement years. I know great number of people in our community over the last 15 years who have had to make the same decision as we have.
Christopher Day
Salutations from the high ground
February 21, 2010
Thanks very much Geoff for all you do. Loved the comment by Julian Burnside.
Jan Fleming
Jobs that no longer exist
February 10, 2020
Christine's extremely well written account of her early life on Phillip Island provides a fantastic record of the rural life that is now only a distant memory to many and a revelation to most. In the current world of instant gratification it is a delight to read about the first hand experience of the early life on Phillip Island.
I hope that Christine can provide us with further recollections of this fascinating period when Phillip Island was a small farming and fishing community.
Ian Samuel
Loved this article. Reminded me of the simpler Philip Island of the late 60's and 70's when, as a young boy, we would visit family friends who also farmed and fished on the island. But nothing like Christine's experience!
Brett Rogers
Christine, I very much enjoyed your memoir. I have seen a the kilns when visiting PI since I was a child and wondered what the process was. I was also impressed what people did to 'earn a crust'. Very hard work too. Thanks for sharing your experiences.
Pee Bee
Christine i really enjoyed your well written essay on days gone by on PI. It reminded me of my youth during the school holidays, going to work with my Dad Eric, who was a self employed iceman whose customers were the big hotels in Melbourne CBD. The Federal Hotel, Australia Hotel, Menzies Hotel are just a few of those long gone impressive posh hotels which needed broken up ice for the
drinks served.
How marvellous for you to remember and describe in so much detail your former jobs.
I always look at the remaining Chichory kilns and wonder what went on inside all those years ago.
Kay Setches
You create lovely word pictures, Christine. I was somewhere else, living a very different kind of life -- yet I feel a poignant nostalgia for the world you've created here. Some envy, too. Congratulations.
John Gascoigne
My memories of other places and different tasks in my young years was brought to life by Christine's stories. Well written, interesting and I think the word evocative fits.
As an apprentice 'cadet' in the British Merchant Navy, our first day at sea after perhaps a week in port, was spent tossing dunnage over the side. Great heaps went overboard.
Dunnage was a cheap grade of wooden plank used to keep cargo ventilated and apart from the steelwork at the bottom of a ship's hold to avoid condensation damaging valuable cargo. Any moisture would collect in the bilges and be pumped overboard.
Any dunnage which was damaged and rendered not reusable by the discharge of cargo was stacked on deck and jettisoned once the ship had cleared harbour. The dunnage on PI beaches was presumably from ships out of Melbourne.
Containerisation presumably saw an end to the practice.
Peter Brown
Thank goodness for Uncle Keith! I found that fascinating. Hard work out in the environment certainly shaped you Christine. Could WPPC please reproduce this?
Karri Giles
Thank you Christine. What a wonderful story about Phillip Island, capturing the vivid personal experience and the historical connections of the work on the island. My Aunty and Uncle lived at Ventnor and I have many holiday memories — of swimming at Red Rocks and cycling over to Summerland on quiet roads in the 1960s, 70s.
Julie Constable
What a beautifully written memoir Christine. Such a joy to read. The rich detail is a precious record of how these 'extinct' jobs were done and those shared moments toasting crumpets and honey while singing songs late into the night at the chicory kiln are marvellous, capturing a way of working from another time.
Linda Cuttriss
A wonderful, well written story Christine. As a latecomer to Phillip Island, I was fascinated by your evocation of a bygone era. Congratulations on winning the award - well deserved!
Marian Quigley
Lovely story, Christine evoking an era and life we can only wonder about. Well done and congratulations on your win.
Sally Bird
Memoir of bygone jobs takes top writing prize
February 10, 2020
Congratulations to you all! An outstanding outcome! Well done Phyllis for your inspiration and encouragement!
Carmen Bush
Congratulations Christine! And to other pirze winners and commendations.
Miriam Strickland
Congratulations to all involved.
Nicky Miller
Well done Christine and others!
I would love to read Jobs that no longer exist and Pittosporum flowering how does one do that please?
Karri Giles
Hi Karri. The prize winning and commended entries will be published in the Post. First up is Christine's work, which has been published, and Pittosporum Flowering will be published in the next issue of the Post.
Catherine Watson
Thank you for hosting such an inspiring event and Congratulations to the Winner - Christine Grayden and all nominees. We are blessed to have so many amazingly talented people in Bass Coast
Clare Le Serve
Congratulations Christine and everyone involved.
Peter Dann
It’s complicated
February 10, 2020
Congratulations to Pauline and Miriam. Thanks for sharing and thanks for your honesty about the ups and down. BCP doesn't allow comment emoticons and I would choose a raised glass of Champagne. Cheers!
Geoff Ellis
10/2/2020 09:46:37 pm
Ditto to Geoff's comments!
Nicky Miller
‘Blue poles’ director hailed from Wonthaggi
February 10, 2020
I caught up with James Mollison few years back (when mayor) to discuss the Robert Smith collection.
He left Wonthaggi when he was five. His uncle was the person who ok’d artist Noel Counihan to go into the mines to draw the series of prints which are now part of the Bass coast shire collection. It was very rare for artists to even go into the mines back in the day - in fact probable it was the first time.
James employed me a lifetime ago at the NGV - would you believe.
Jordan Crugnale, MP for Bass
A force of nature
February 10, 2020
Great to see Eulie's effort recognised and recorded in such an engaging article. Well done Terri.
Geoff Ellis
Keep it #$%@!!*& nice
January 25, 2020
My repertoire of wise old sayings includes “give them an inch and they take a mile”, along with something about people in glass houses, and “if you have nothing nice to say it is best to say nothing”.
It would be appalling if your Post and all the energy that has gone into it was to be corrupted to ruin by a few bad apples.
Dear Catherine, stay the course !
Tim Shannon
Thankyou Catherine for your journalistic experience and I support your decision to erase the personal criticism.
I appreciate the literature and variety of topics you attract to The Post.
Marjorie Scott
Thank you for your perseverance and all the time you put into the Post. We always look forward to reading all the interesting articles and agree with your decision. Happy New Year Catherine.
Alison Ribush
Enjoyed every article as usual. Keep up the great work!
Michelle Graham
Not living "down there:" anymore, but keep up the good work Catherine,Love reading the (constructive) comments on things happening in Bass Coast
Kevin Chambers
Love the Bass Coast Post.
Thank you Catherine.
Jan Fleming
Gorgeous Catherine!
Without you people like me would not have a voice - we would be less informed - we would not be able to share in a safe environment.
Bullies can be awfully devious - and so destructive - so thank you for not allowing them to have a voice.
Liane Arno
Good decision - i fully support you and thanks for doing such a great job on the Post
Lesley Bretherton
Thank you Catherine for gifting us the Bass Coast Post. Respect is vital and support your decision to stop abuse. Just love reading the articles in the Post and whilst you may not always agree with some views, one often gains knowledge of the reasons for differing views in the written article. Thank you for all that you do.
Joy Button
I totally agree with Catherine and thank her for the outstanding development of a Post with principles
It is indeed unfortunate that journalism as an industry has deteriorated to sensationalism and distortion of the truth to the detriment of the profession.
Informed articles are the source of knowledge shared, with the Post leading in the dissemination of views and opinions without acrimony
Keep up the good work
Ian Samuel
I agree, civil discussion is desperately needed at a time when we seem to becoming more polarised. But abusive retorts achieve nothing but further separation. Keep up the good work Catherine, I so enjoy the Post.
Lorrie Read
Catherine, whilst your intentions are admirable, beware! I used to subscribe to a large national newspaper that permitted what I called "vigorous" debate (which were, to be honest, horrific during the SSM debate) then belatedly decided that they needed moderation. I had several comments (favourable mostly) "rejected" and there was to be no discussing the reasons why. Other readers of the newspaper made similar observations. Eventually it appeared that the rejections were more personal than ethical, so I decided to pull the plug. There will be no political correctness in my house! It is yet another form of censorship.
Everyone views a topic differently, so I believe it would be quite difficult to be impartial and eventually what one considers offensive, others would not.
Pamela Jacka
Hi Pamela. I certainly don’t want to censor readers’ views. The more the merrier! However, the Post has picked up a few trolls along the way and I need to deal with them. The personal criticism and abuse are a diversion from genuine debate. They also deter others from entering the discussion. Let’s see how we go!
Catherine Watson, editor
I'm with you on this one Pamela, You cannot write about topics in Bass Coast Post in a joking, entertaining manner at the expense of people who are working so hard to save their own environment and are struggling with potential unbearable loss (Newhaven Skate Park article) and expect people who are so distraught and emotionally devastated about that topic that is being joked about and not expect a reaction that is pure raw emotion and spelling out nothing but raw facts. The truth hurts unfortunately and the truth should not be deleted or edited. If that raw emotion is taken out then its just not genuine or real and the writing lacks soul of the person who is hurting and who put their real feelings into words.
Min Beaumont
I have so enjoyed reading bass coast post articles for many years, I would be disappointed if a few trolls ruined it for all.
Catherine, she's your baby & I fully support your editorial rights 💞
Kim Veness
This kind of has to work both ways and what has happened to freedom of speech as a reaction to a writers actions, that's what you are after isn't it, a reaction?
Min Beaumont
I totally agree with your right to edit the Post Catherine as you see fit.
That’s your job.
I also totally agree in using reasoned arguments which are based on facts.
Emotional language does not fix the issues.
Frank W Schooneveldt
There are comments on this post that certainly break the rules under which I operate several organisations' popular Facebook pages. Our rules are: No personal attacking of others or name calling in the post or in the comments. No comments which do not pertain to the principles of whichever group's FB page it is, as clearly set out on their websites, e.g. constitutions and forward planning documents agreed to by the members. No swearing - even mild swearing - under any circumstances. There is so much vitriol on the internet these days and it is totally unhelpful. All it does is make people angrier, and in fact curtails rational debate. Catherine your readers may have 'ownership' of your wonderful website, but it is actually YOUR website, and you are perfectly entitled to make your rules, especially after several years of operation have taught you the hard way that some people seriously need to be given clear firm rules to abide by. It is a waste of your valuable time having to moderate everything, but stay firm and eventually everyone will get the message and all behave in a civilised manner.
Christine Grayden
Forged by fire
January 25, 2020
Thank you Laura for your personal experience of the recent fires- such tragic and dramatic disasters continue to ripple long beyond the proverbial splash; the upheaval is unimaginable but then it happens. I hope this unparalleled summer of fire shifts the nation's focus and clarifies priorities. So pleased you and yours are safe.
Jeannie Haughton
Thank you Laura for sharing your story. And thank goodness you are all safe.
Your story certainly brings home what is important.
Caring for Country, caring for people, caring for community, caring for one and another and caring about the World we leave to our Grandchildren.
Frank & Mary Schooneveldt
Laura and Terry, we are very glad your family is safe. Best wishes,
Jan Fleming and John Adam
Thanks so much for sharing, Laura. When I saw and heard you at 'Heads in the Sand' I didn't get to talk to you. I had no idea about your family. I had no idea that the climate refugees I saw from Mallacoota were your grandchildren.
I'm glad that the family is safe. They will be scarred by their experience, but on the day I noted that they seemed such brave people, and from what you say, that is true. They may also become stronger people.
Much was learnt during the Black Saturday fires about safe behaviour at times of fires. If only the media and government could learn all the lessons about climate change that the world should have been acting on many years ago. I hope that the majority of people have learnt enough to insist that we change how we act. If not now, when? If not now, who will be left to decide? If not now, will anyone have any choice?
Bron Dahlstrom
Thanks for this piece Laura. So glad your family survived, and also that the house was saved. I believe Bob and I stayed in their airbnb last year, such a nice spot. We had no idea of their connection to you.
Jenny Skewes
Thank you so much for your kind words and for your understanding. They are truly appreciated.
Terry has just finished making a short film about the Climate Action held at Inverloch that I mention in the article.
Here is the link ... https://vimeo.com/387580606
I'm really grateful to be part of a community that is awake to the importance of climate justice and the need for action.
Laura Brearley
So moving to read your personal account especially after your Black Saturday experiences. Thank you. I am so pleased they can return home already even tho it is so shocking and the smoke and ash seems to stay for a long time.
It's a long haul cleaning up and rebuilding and a community that can put forward what it wants from agerncies and govt often fairs better in the long term reconstruction.
You and Terry are truly fantastic and such a wonderful support. These events call on all our resources and more.
I love the grandchildren taking action with their posters, a positive sign amongst the aftermath.
(Re climate refugees - I'm caring for three of the family 's non laying old chooks ! )
Neri Melsmith
Thank you for your story. My Niece's Fiance Nikolai Handsjuk's Mother's house burnt down at Mallacoota and his Grandmother's was about the only one left in the street.
Caroline Giles
Weighty words
January 25, 2020
Thank you all three for your wonderful work. There certainly seems to be much talent in Gippsland. I very much look forward to reading the winning entry.
Felicia Di Stefano
Sounds like there were many fabulous entries and a challenge Catherine just to establish a short list. Looking forward to the announcement on February 9. Will this announcement be open to the public as I cannot see time that it starts.
Joy Button
Fabulous! can't wait to find out who is the winner.
Clare Le Serve
Looks great Catherine; and I wonder, might it be worth publishing the best 10 or 15 as a book?
Max Richter
A blazing star
Jan 25, 2020
Far too young to leave us - I still try not to think about this but it was a life well lived and my friend for so much of his time in the Wonthaggi area. Ricardo entered some photographs in the Show that I help organise just before he passed. Thank you Merle for encouraging him. Well anyway he did very well and was so happy with his prizes That was the last I heard about him when Merle contacted me that fateful night.To me his joy of achieving something that I was part of made me smile as well as make me cry - Loved you Ricardo - A joy to know and call a friend
Rosemary Loughnan
Ricardo, Ricardo, Ricardo !!
My elderly mother used to say when she visited Garnham House in Wonthaggi once a week.
Then some years later, she was stunned when she and a few of the residents of Griffiths Point Lodge (in San Remo) were driven to his exhibition.
What a wonderful artist, photographer, writer and very special person who gave warmth to so many people who had the privilege of meeting you and being with you.
Vale, Ricardo, may you rest in peace
Phyllis Papps
Thrills and spills
Jan 25, 2020 –
This story deserves support and reflection.
Near death experiences - all survived - mostly cherished - by those who were lucky enough to have a childhood before helicopter parenting.
We learned a confidence and love of the wild parts of our world.
Peter Brown
I enjoyed this story and did similar stuff in the 70s and 80s
Caroline Giles
Oh my goodness Liz, what you write about climbing a tree is in exact detail of what the children of Newhaven at Phillip Island did in the Grayden's Memorial Park in the 70's. The cypress trees which still stand there today as part of Newhaven's unique history and green environment and were planted in a similar fashion as the ones down Thompson Avenue in Cowes are still the main characteristics of our much loved park and township. The cypress in the park was a haven for play when children were free to roam. We too could climb up the trunk by firstly pulling ourselves up via forked branches like monkey bars. I look at the tree now and wonder how we managed to pull ourselves up
Min Beaumont