READERS' COMMENTS |
Minister steps into mining stoush
Nov 27, 2020
A great summary of very challenging times for Bass Coast, Catherine. Does the community want the peace and beauty of our scenic Bass Coast with its ancient Grass Tree forest, arguably the biggest and best in Australia in perpetuity, or does it want sand and sand trucks?
At 12.30 pm today (Friday, Nov 27), Leader of Save Western Port's Coastal Forest was interviewed on Ch9 Gippsland, Tune in to Ch 5 at 5.30 pm to see and hear him.
Meryl Tobin
What's the local state government member, Jordan Crugnale, going to do about the destruction of these precious grass trees?? She seemed to be keen to progress future environmental protection prospects for the Holden Proving Ground which was commendable. The sand mine area is not that far away so hoping she is as interested in this sad issue .
Nola Smith
In response to community concerns and photographic images sent to me, last Friday (being the 27th October) I asked the Minister that DELWP staff with Earth Resources Regulation staff visit the Grantville Quarry as a matter of urgency to assess the translocation of Grasstrees at the site.”
I have contacted the Mr Viglietti and will make arrangements to visit the site in the coming weeks to learn more about their operations and grass tree translocation processes.’
I encourage the new Council to request a briefing and presentation from Sand Supplies Pty Ltd.”
I am available to also meet with representatives of the conservation group to discuss their concerns in more depth.”
The views, comments and interests of everyone in the community are important to me, we work at our best when we have all the information at hand and I look forward to having these conversations – there is a delicateness to this entire area and some work needing to be done to build relations.
Jordan Crugnale, Labor Member for Bass
How sad that these majestic grass trees are being destroyed, just when they were recovering from the bushfires. How little respect given to those who fought so hard to save the conservation area from the ravages of the bushfire.
Joy Herring
If you want to know what a politician or councillor thinks, please ask them. Then they know the concerns of the community and it gives them ammunition to fire when they go in to fight for you. When we wrote to Jordan äbout the situation this morning, she answered, I have asked the Minister that DELWP staff visit the Grantville Quarry Reserve site with Earth Resources Regulation staff as a matter of urgency to assess the translocation of Grasstrees at the site." All, please stand up and be counted on this issue. Write to councillors and politicians so they know what is important to you.
Also, if you or a group you belong to would like to go on the mailing list of Save Western Port's Coastal Forest, please write to Bass Coast Post <editor@basscoastpost.com>.
Meryl Tobin
Most definitely have and will do this. Thank you for being the guardian of the trees and the area
Ant Gent
If sand extraction from our endangered native forest is approved.
Re-forestation with native species must be immediate continuous and enforced by site inspections as part of any Government approval process for the extractive industry.
There is no justification to replace native vegetation at the industries convenience it needs to an integral part of the extraction process
Ian Samuel
A great Summary of a tragic situation for our environment Catherine. We need to fight on to protect this beautiful Bass Coast where we live
Margaret Lee
This landscape cathedral was burnt during the bush fires in Jan 2019, but because of their resilience and adversity to bush fires they were one of the few things that survived and thrived in the Grantville Nature Conservation Reserve and Adams Creek Nature Conservation Reserve. This never would have been allowed to happen if it was in for example in Mornington Shire. When dieback disease was affecting some of the areas in Mornington Nature Reserves, entire areas and road surrounding the one xanthorrhoea tree were closed off to the public to ensure the disease did not affect the tree. In May 2019 Bass Coast locals were invited to participate in Bass Coast as Distinctive Areas and Landscapes Project under the new Part 3AAB of the Planning and Environment Act 1987. This area was highlighted by myself and many other locals of priority significance, and when reviewing Phase 2 of the document this significant area has once again been ignored. Is it because it is surrounded by multiple quarries/sand mines, as well as our councils transfer station? These studies and engagement projects are fluff, and bluff, when in the end those in power and who have the dollars are the ones who are heard. Federal, State and local government as well as these greedy immoral businesses have dead xanthorrhoeas and the destruction of a whole ecosystem to answer for.
Ant Gent
It would have been a reasonable idea (now that they have been pulled out and bagged) if these begged up grass trees were donated to cranbourne botanical gardens. I have contacted them to see if they can step in. Maybe others following this issue could contact them to assist so we can at least salvage the pulled out and bagged trees?
Ant Gent
Have you heard anything back from the Gardens, Ant?
Anne Heath Mennell
No, I have not Anne, I contacted them on Saturday, so I will follow up during the week.. I have also tried contacting the Save Western Port's Coastal Forest FB page with no response, which is disappointing. It would be great if those who are concerned would get behind some sort of real solution.
Ant Gent
I can assure you the SWPCF, of which I am a Committee member, hasn't stopped trying to save the grass trees, Ant. I have already passed your suggestion onto Council who had moved to get Landcare involved. Use your passion to work with us - we're all on the same side.
Please, everyone who care about the Grass Trees, don't leave it to someone else to do something, because we are up against very tough opposition - including the State Govt who has earmarked the sand resource from Nyora-Lang Lang to Grantville for Melbourne's needs for decades.
Please join the SWPCF by writing to Bass Coast Post <editor@basscoastpost.com> asap to swell our numbers past the 100 groups and individuals who are already members.
Then write to the Quarry Manager/Diorector, Robbie Viglietti at Sand Supplies Pty Ltd at
<robbie@sabbiadevelopments.com.au>,
Program Manager, Natural Environment, Gippsland,
Mick D Bramwell (DELWP) <Mick.Bramwell@delwp.vic.gov.au>, Regional Manager, Metropolitan Melbourne | Earth Resources Regulation,
Department of Jobs, Precincts and Regions, Barry R Strong (DJPR) <barry.strong@ecodev.vic.gov.au>,
Premier Daniel Andrews <daniel.andrews@parliament.vic.gov.au>, Minister for Environment, Lily DÁmbrosio <lily.dambrosio@parliament.vic.gov.au>,
Minister for Planning,
Richard Wynne <Richard.Wynne@parliament.vic.gov.au>,
Member for Bass, Jordan Crugnale <jordan.crugnale@parliament.vic.gov.au>
and local councillors and anyone other relevant people who might be able to help that you can think of.
You only need to tell them you are appalled at what is happening to the grass trees and the Grantville Grass Tree Forest and ask them to immediately save the dying trees and stop the taking any more of the trees until after a review of the situation.
SWPCF member, Tim Herring, has checked the trees twice since last Sunday (Nov 22) when I saw them, and reports they have still not been tended to or watered.
Time is running out.
Meryl Tobin
https://sgst.com.au/2020/12/grantville-quarry-operator-rejects-environmental-vandalism-claims/
Robbie Viglietti
Lily d'Ambrosio presented Accelerating the Circular Economy organised by the CEBIC team at Sustainability Victoria #VicGoesCircular
Instead of allowing the expansion of extraction of sand in a conservation reserve, the government should promote more glass recycling for reuse like, for example:
https://www.ammann.com/au-en/news-media/news/waste-glass-becomes-high-quality-sand
I. Higgins
Paper Thin
Nov 27, 2020 -
Thank you for giving us this intimate and very moving experience.
Jeannie Haughton
Absolutely beautiful and moving. I hear your voice like quiet yet profound piece of classical music. I was swept away by your writing's internal rhythm of nature, almost like a tidal wave. When I read the photographer and the picture of the Egret, my heart soared. He is my dear husband and I'm so happy that his picture made such a significant contribution to your introspective process. Your writing certainly made a difference to my understanding of the world. Thank you.
Etsuko Yasunaga
What a beautiful comment, thank you so much Etsuko, and to hear you are Rob's partner - I can't believe it! His photo means a lot to me, please pass on my gratitude! Thank you again, Lucinda Bain
Exquisitely beautiful Lucinda. Your words are so light, delicate, divine yet hold such profound feeling. Sadness, happiness. Birth, death. Sublimely balanced. So personal, yet something we all can share. Thank-you.
Linda Cuttriss
Dear Lucinda, it was a great pleasure to meet you and the other award-winning writers of the Bass Coast Prize for Non-fiction 2020. Sunday was a very, very special occasion.
This is just a brief summation that the judges (Catherine Watson, Geoff Ellis and Anne Heath-Mennell) said about your very moving and thought-provoking article 'Paper Thin':
"From the first line we see a real writer at work: “I thought I knew something of death. Until, on the 20th of May 2016 – my 34th birthday – I found myself breastfeeding my third baby in the same room as my dead grandfather.” A slice of memoir becomes a meditation on the trajectories of births and deaths, from breath to breath. Beautifully written."
Best Wishes with your writing in the future.
Phyllis Papps
Dear Phyllis, it was such a privilege to meet you and such a wonderful group of writers on the weekend. Thank you for facilitating a fabulous opportunity for writers and making it such a wholesome experience. I am very thankful to you! Many thanks, Lucinda
Lucinda Bain
Well done, I haven't yet read it all, but it is beautifully written about the mundane and the terrible trials of life. I'll enjoy reading it all the way through during the next week.
Joan Woods
Life of a freewheeler
Nov 27, 2020
I am saddened to learn of Dave's passing, a bloke with boundless passion for all things mechanical. In earlier years he was also a very talented trumpet player, until he lost some teeth. Getting some new ones was low on the list of priorities , well behind bikes, beer and assorted other substances. Rest in peace Dave, and keep on tinkering.
Mark Robertson
Mark, interesting to read your comment. My original opening to the story was that I had been told Dave played trumpet internationally, but I could find no confirmation of that and decided it was too far fetched, even for Dave. Today at Dave's farewell do, on his front lawn, his sister Jaynie related that Dave was a member of the Victoria Youth Orchestra which toured in Europe in the 1970s. There's a great photo of him at a reception with the Lord Mayor of London. This morning's gathering was the occasion for some wonderful stories about Dave. The legend grows.
Catherine Watson
Beautifully written piece Catherine which gave me a few rueful laughs and lots of insights to Dave's life - thank you!
Hilary Stuchbery
This text I received from Dave not long before he died shows the character of the man:
"Hello mate, just remembered you rang sorry busy afternoon. had 3 Ebikes1 beginner and grandson on 6 sp 20 atx giant I just put together. I took them down the rifle range track butheaps of it was underwater. great stuff lotrs of mud 1 stall in enormous puddle which swallowed the 20 inch, that kid learned fast then followed me on thr rises on the hellish track and we made it back dry waist down. not bad I'll ring on a minute. [bike emoji}
Mark Finsterer
I find myself missing Dave to a degree disproportionate to our involvement and it is not as most who have been to our front door would suggest, have anything to do with the 14 or so bikes in various operational states. I think it was 2016 that my friend Roger had given me Dave’s number as a man of the bikes. I’d been working on the mighty Ayr Ck at the time and was appalled at the lowly value placed on bikes as judged by the seven in three weeks that I found dumped and not reclaimed through the police. Hence regular visits with yet another gem for Dave to pull into shape.
A Giant ‘Rockhopper’ ten years old with a broken gear lever or was that the 29inch Meridian? Doesn’t matter. That is when Dave revealed his online capabilities. His evident satisfaction in finding the product number of the arcane part, chasing it down, bidding at auction, winning it from locations exotic - Bentleigh to Shanghai. And of course, bagging it for the bargain basement price of a mere $12, a part, that if you could get it would retail for more like $40. No matter that he’d spent until three in the morning twice.
I can’t really say I knew Dave, but as my mum would say you treat people as you find them and I found beguiling mischief. Whether it was the range of his ebike or the ride to Kilcunda on the rail trail Dave to me had a twinkle in his eye and a smile on his dial. I have just reviewed my text messages from January till now, much humor, racing mobility scooters to rival ride-on lawn-mower racing mentioned.
We are about the same vintage and compared to Dave and his sharpness as witnessed by his bike and particularly his ebike work I’d led a relatively sheltered existence with my own tortuous take on the hand eye coordination and memory that Dave obviously had in abundance and shared with the others of his blood.
We’d been in contact in the last couple of weeks and, though crook, he insisted I drop off our ebike that needed his magic. Unfortunately, Dave in his sickness had fallen for my not uncommon failing in confusing ambition with ability, although it didn’t dent his optimism as the new tool case, bike work stand, batteries and the magnificent Giant off-road bike (to be electrified) all brought at great prices attest.
I called to see Dave on my way to Melbourne, he was wretched, I just said I wasn’t leaving, perhaps that’s what made the prospect of the ambulance and hospital the least worst option. He was bad, no matter how bad, respect was his due and dignity his right. He dressed, cleaned himself up as best he could, gathered up his belongings, said he wasn’t coming back and walked from his house.
Ed Thexton
What a wonderful article, Catherine, and a bloody brilliant cartoon by Natasha. And the last 10 days has showed me that he *was* already where he belonged; amongst excellent friends busying himself doing what he loved and sharing the results to benefit as many people as he could ... that passed his entrance exam!
Jaynee Russell-Clarke
Catherine Watson
What a wonderful article and honour to Dave.
Julie Vippond
In the flow of love and loss
Nov 27, 2020 -
Absolute tragedy for our Indigenous brethren and all lovers of this magnificent country. Hundreds of years of history wiped out in hours with a bulldozer blade. How dare the sand mining crowd - vandals of the highest order. - think their mining takes precedence over natures beauty. Where was the Minister responsible ? Probably no permission requested by the vandals, just destruction in their quest for the mighty dollar. I grieve with Auntie Fay and the rest of the People. Yvonne McRae
Yvonne McRae
Yvonne It's even worse. The sand miners did nothing wrong/illegal and did not have to seek permission/approval from anyone. They are quite free to expand and continue the destruction with the approval and encouragement of our State government. The community and Council are basically powerless to do anything. It is truly a tragedy.
Anne Heath Mennell
Shame the community were not given the opportunity to remove the grass trees and replant them. Keeping the grass trees in the area.
Debbie Gilbert
Down to business
Nov 27, 2020
How much longer can this ind of sand mining continue, at the rate of 2000 B Doubles per day? Is that correct? For something as heavy as sand, instead of wrecking roads, surely it should only ever have been allowed by rail? Considering Climate Emergency, what can be done to make rail transport mandatory?
Bernie McComb
Off to the Powlett River
Nov 27, 2020
I love this article! Please give us more like it.
Annie Chisholm
Grass tree forest, by Meryl Brown Tobin
Nov 27, 2020
Thank you, Meryl and Hartley
Carolyn Landon
Who speaks for the trees and creeks?
Nov 13, 2020
I would like to quote the Judges' comments: (Catherine Watson, Geoff Ellis and Anne Heath-Mennell): "The author mourns the loss of an avenue of beloved trees and embarks on an investigation in which she discovers the Kafkaesque world of environmental law where native vegetation can be listed on a Register of Protected Trees – and still be chain-sawed by a development company. The story is familiar but she builds a powerful narrative: heartfelt, persuasive, illuminating. This is a polemic but a restrained one, concluding with an urgent call to action."
I have planted a tree here at Rhyll to celebrate your work.
Phyllis Papps
Thank you for your passion, your artistry and your caring, Jeannie. I feel privileged to have read your cry of puzzlement and your commitment to overcoming.
Felicia Di Stefano
Jeannie I love your beautiful descriptions of childhood memories in Nature, the simplicity and wonder of it and am moved and unsettled and saddened by the tragedy of the fallen trees and the lost creek and the sodden areas. I love the way you have balanced your frustration and anger with the list of toothless strategies and plans and all the time people took to develop the Register of Significant Trees and all the other people and organisations that continue to fight and write for the trees and creeks and the climate .... and how heartbreaking it is that since you wrote this piece, one of the magnificent, sacred Djab Wurrung trees has actually been taken down! Congratulations Jeannie on your very moving, powerful call to action.
Linda Cuttriss
Thank you Linda. It was an honour to be with you alongside all the prizewinners. Aren't we fortunate to have an award that recognises non fiction and a the Bass Coast Post publishing our longform writings? I look forward to reading the others!! And yes, heartbreaking to lose the Djab Warrung Directions Tree.
We are all the losers when we destroy these ancient, culturally significant trees. It is especially mortifying that such losses are usually avoidable. (sigh)
Jeannie Haughton
Thank you Jeannie for your thought provoking article. The destruction of your local environment is a consequence of the deliberate ‘Big Australia’ policy which encourages, ‘One for the father, one for the mother and one for the country’ or an expansive migration scheme utilised by people wishing to move to greener pastures and settle here. There seems to be no concern that the environment has limitations and therefore its destruction is acceptable. Humans are like rabbits, goats or deer etc, which build up their numbers, in the absence of predators, to go past totally exploiting the environment on which they depend. The inevitable population collapse is the result. Fortunately, humans don’t need to have predators/disease to manage our numbers as we can manage our fertility to produce the numbers we want. I wondered if those people you mentioned in your article, who are defending the environment, may have also contributed in their own little way to the problems they are working towards fixing. Simply put, have they exceeded the total fertility rate (TFR) of 2.1 children per women? I hope your prize winning article starts people thinking about the connection between the environment, population and family size.
Peter Bogg
Hello Peter, Thank you for reading my article and commenting. Yes I have often thought about over population as the critical issue and key contributor to world woes. But equally so, greed and inequality.
I wonder if Western society can ever appreciate or acknowledge the enormous contribution to population control made by China and its One Child Policy? Yet the Human Rights toll, and misery of parents, especially women who found themselves unexpectedly pregnant, and the subsequent gender imbalance are the results. So nothing is black and white. It is an issue that will continue to take a toll on the world's resources for sure. Cannot answer that one.
However, I think what I have come up against is the sheer greed of some housing development companies, their inability to compromise and change their view of land and trees and animals, their refusal to see trees as an asset rather than an inconvenience, to see that they can make a contribution toward better quality of community living.
It is not hard to make a big difference. I have also discovered how inadequate the Statutory protections for the environment are. It has been an eye-opening journey for me. I agree with you that we must all do what we can, and yes getting people thinking is the aim.
Jeannie Haughton
It was with a heavy heart that I read your impassioned article. To say I felt saddened and uneasy, would be an understatement.
I found a voice in my head screaming out, how can they ignore the promises made in the past about protecting trees and vegetation. How would any of those involved in making those original decisions be feeling now. Where will the birds, animals and insects go?
I don't feel as articulate as you Jeannie, the penalties of those damaging areas, previously promised to be protected should include imprisonment.
These large development companies have clever lawyers that befuddle people easily to get their own way. I am sure they knew about sensitive areas.When they think no-one is looking and if they think they can get away with it the quickly remove plants from areas if they feel they can get away with it. All to produce urban type housing development that is ugly to my eyes, puzzling me that they are bought. Big homes on tiny properties, to bring maximum profit to the developers and the councils.
My heart is still aching as I finish up, currently sitting in remote australian community, in a spectacular area, where i come to work amongst unspoilt country. Whilst at home my council
busily finds ways of how to pack the most homes in the smallest area. Grrrr
Janet Caulfield
Thanks for comments Janet. Like a lot of areas of ethics and Law, the statutory protections for Environment are inadequate; they have fallen behind the practices that strip the land for housing. There are those who work to benefit community, and others who work only to benefit only themselves. Those who sit on a payroll or commission and work to find loopholes in the Law, those who try to find ways to grow a healthier environment and community for everyone to share.
In fact our Council has rejected permits but their decisions have been overturned at a higher level. Having said that many former Councils were decidedly pro-development. I hope the new Council is alert and active in prioritising environment and moving faster and harder to protect it.
Jeannie Haughton
Hi Jeannie, Loved your piece and share your empathy with trees. It seems to be a lack of reverence for anything other than self these days. Where it started and where it will finish is something that will be revealed in the fullness of time: when there are no trees and the ground slides from under our feet and houses.
Keep it up, each tree felled needs to be registered in a book or log.
Joan Woods
Three resolutions to consider for 2021:
Actively respect nature. Binning that errant cigarette packet in the park is a start.
Sit beneath any leafy centenarian giant, feeling its immensity and listening to its conversation with the breeze. Experience your own transience.
If you enjoy reading, act on Jeannie's recommendations. Richard Powers' Overstory resonates with this reader daily.
John Gascoigne
Thank you, Dr Mangrove
Nov 13, 2020
Thank you, Meryl for an informative tribute to a rich, useful life.
Felicia Di Stefano
What a wonderful tribute! I really enjoyed learning about the breadth of Dr Mangrove’s contributions. The two song videos by his daughter which included many photos and stories of his life were also very moving. The chorus of Wendy’s song was particularly poignant: “And he says that the planet will recover one day when we’re all extinct and well out of the way. In the meantime, he does the few things that he can to counteract the ravages and greed of man”.
Thanks Meryl for also reminding us through Tim’s example of the power of simple Sharon Willcox
communication in environmental advocacy.
Kind gentleman who advcocated for our local environment. I learnt about mangroves as a child, but Tim taught us about the true importance of these incredible plants
Michelle Graham
Thank you Meryl. Congratulations on such a well researched, beautifully written and moving tribute to our friend Tim.
Jean Coffey
Thank you Meryl. As with the Trees I have written about, so many people are quietly making A contribution and caring for the natural world around them. Vale Tim Ealey.
Jeannie Haughton
It is hard to believe the world will still keep turning without Tim. But then, there are his hundreds of Enviromental Science mafia, all the children and adults he taught, and his lovely Laura and daughters to keep it spinning.
The years I spent studying for my Master of Environmental Science, then as one of Tim's crew on the staff of the Graduate School of Environmental Science at Monash, have probably been the most influential in my life. And in the life of my family. My children and grandchildren are committed greenies. My mother was too. So the ripples of Tim's grand influence go on spreading and growing.
He was indeed a great man, a wonderful colleague and dear friend. May you find comfort in wonderful memories Laura.
Andrea Lindsay
Thank you, Meryl for this beautiful tribute. I didn't know Tim very well and I had no idea of the extent of his achievements. He will be sorely missed but what an incredible beneficial impact he had on the world - what a legacy he leaves. As Andrea says, the ripples will keep on spreading well into the future. Be assured that those of us who knew him will continue his work, especially in Western Port, as best we can. Condolences to Laura anf Vale Tim the Warrior!
Anne Heath Mennell
Bass Coast puts out the welcome mat
Nov 13, 2020
Yeah, a big warm welcome to our Congo Republic Australians. May your new life in the beautiful Bass Coast be safe, healthy and successful. Xxx
Sharon
Nature’s showtime
Nov 13, 2020
Linda, what a beautifully written and sensitive article about your passion for nature, our environment and our wild life. Your incredible observations have been matched with superb photos.
Phyllis Papps
Fabulous description of nature at your place Linda.
Congratulations on winning the Bass Coast Literary Award.
Janet Fleming
A picture worth a thousand words? You’ve changed the equation, Linda: fifty pictures, five-hundred words.
John Gascoigne
Flying high
Nov 13, 2020
Thank you for this thoughtful piece, Etsuko. You show such empathy for the birds. I especially love your last line, 'Birds, those beautiful winged creatures, ought to fly as they belong to the free sky.'
Birds in cages seems so wrong. This was never brought brought home to me as clearly as it was when I visited the NT and saw a large flock of budgerigars take off. It was a wonderous sight.
Injured birds do sometimes need to be kept in cages by wildlife carers. These carers often feel quite attached to the birds they help to heal, but feel very excited when they are able to release them.
Bron Dahlstrom
A beautiful ‘tale’. Thank you for sharing. I too had two bird stories this week. Our lives continue to be entwined. The Tie that Binds x
Pip
I love your experiences and the outcome of the meeting with the birds.
Like Bron I love them in the sky, not in cages.
Verena
Virus diaries 16
Nov 13, 2020
I always read your Virus diaries first Catherine. So interesting. A couple of weeks in your Wonthaggi gives us everyday and some outstanding characters and events to muse upon. Those last two words you wrote in capitals - maybe we need to share Post Virus impressions when the hordes hit our town?
Sue Packham
Although I have enjoyed every day of your Covid diaries, this one is the best. So many good stories. Thank you for sharing your reactions and interactions with friends and family both local and abroad. As another commented, this has always been the first thing I read. Will miss it.
Janice Orchard
The virus diaries remind me of my early life, growing up in a quieter,more natural Wonthaggi, roaming the backlanes and beaches with my mates. The recent onslaught of urban visitors and big brands makes me realise that I grew up in an absolute paradise. Could the incoming council please recognise this and plan to preserve our local nirvana, and hopefully not allow our home to become yet another " suburban dream". With regard to the pumpkin competition, next year the competitors should be provided with seeds from locally - fecund plants. They will bloom and grow well, and should not cost anything.
Mark Robertson
Catherine, We did first visit Cape Woolamai in late 60's and by early 70's bought a block of land on first stage of Cape Woolamai Estate .
Unmade roads, no drainage but we camped on it and fell in love with the area. Built a small house by early 80's and our 2 sons and now 5 grand children just love the whole area. Roads in/out issue for few weeks each year but rest of the year it's easy to get around, and the new roundabout will make access much easier at peak times. One big advantage is if the winds blowing say on the Backbeach just walk across to
the bay beach in few minutes and your out of it. When the tides out you can walk for klms on the beach have a look at the Colonnades superb.
Chris Day
Thanks very much Catherine, I have enjoyed your diaries over the months. Regards, Jan.
Janet Fleming
Thanks for allowing us to follow your journey during COVID Catherine. I have enjoying following it all and hope to continue to keep contact as we fight for our beautiful backyard especially in the sandmining areas.
Margaret Lee
Green, green hills of home
Nov 13, 2020
So glad that you are enjoying Inverloch, Sharon. Welcome. I've been living in Inverloch for 11 years and love the Bass Coast.
Congratulations on your decision to give up flying. It is great to see that many others are making this same decision. One good thing about the pandemic is that it has put a break on the amount of flying that people do, although it worries me that once things open up, people may go crazy.
I must admit that last year I flew to Japan and had a wonderful holiday. I learnt a great deal and met many wonderful people. I do think that travelling to other countries opens our minds to new worlds, yet if we keep flying the way we have been, the world will change so much that not only will future generations not be able to fly, they will inherit a world that we cannot even imagine. I'm hoping that flight in electric planes that give no emissions will become commonplace in the not too distant future, although I doubt that I will be here for that. Such a plane took flight in May this year. It was able to take 9 passengers and could only fly 100 kms, and only the pilot flew in it for the test run. But big things grow from small beginnings.
Now we need governments all over the world to do the right thing. Our government won't even commit to zero emissions by 2050. That would be a start, but even that is too little too late.
Bron Dahlstrom
Aunty Fay’s mission
Nov 13, 2020
What a wonderful story of the life and times of Aunty Fay. Absolutely time for recognition of this excellent woman's heritage and public service. I agree with the rubbish history as taught at school. As an older person we did BRITISH history at secondary school. I remember asking why we didn't do Australian history but was told British was the curriculum study. As a primary school teacher myself I made sure the students at Wonthaggi North heard the Dream time Stories, watched the films available about the people of the Western Desert, heard about the Boon Wurrung people of our area and the middens etc. still here from thousands of years ago. I still remember a boy in a Grade 4 saying, 'Mrs. McRae you said that in the desert they didn't have hospitals, so where did those children come from'.
Yvonne McRae
Aunty Fay Stewart-Muir is a legend. A wonderful teacher and linguist, always sharing her aboriginal culture with others including so many children (who love her)
Aunty Fay is exactly the woman who the creators of the Victorian Women's Honour Roll knew should be celebrated for their immence contributions to Victorian community.
The Victorian Women's Honour Roll was established by the Bracks Labour Government, following recommendations by former Premier Joan Kirner, that part of the Centenary of Federation 2001,
"Women Shaping the Nation" should be run for 12 months. Hugely successful, The Honour Roll has been extended indefinitly.
Aunty Fay is a national treasure. And the Honour Roll keeps celebrating such women.
Im asking that people now understand that the request for nominations for the Roll are annual. Start thinking about nominating a remarkable woman you know.
Kay Setches
Old hands, fresh faces on new council
Nov 7, 2020
Congratulations to all councillors voted into office and congratulations and thank you to all councillors who have served Bass Coast over the last four years.
Thanks to live-streaming of Council, the public has been able to see and hear what goes on in Council and who says and does what. At the May meeting, we were pleased to hear every councillor speak in favour of Cr Clare Le Serve's motion asking the Council to approach the State Government to buy the GMH Proving Ground at Lang Lang to preserve the site's environmental, cultural and coastal habitat values. All councillor put forward powerful arguments, worked as a team and voting unanimously for the motion.
At the June meeting, it was refreshing to see an almost repeat performance regarding the proposed Maher's Landing marina, with councillors unanimously rejecting the unpopular proposal.
Hearing councillors understand such important issues gives electors heart and energizes them to keep working for common goals. As a conservationist who has worked for decades to preserve out natural environment from unsustainable development, I have been impressed at this development in Council and hope this move to advocate for and to protect our Shire's Distinctive Areas and Landscapes continues.
A special congrats and thank you to former Cr Geoff Ellis for his enormous contribution to protect the Holden Proving Ground site and the Grantville Grass Tree Forest. Not only did he work hard for the community in this area, but he was at the forefront of all movements to improve life for Bass Coast residents and visitors. You will be missed, Geoff. All the best in this new chapter of your life.
Meryl Tobin
Congratulations everyone, welcome back and welcome. I look forward to achieving zero emissions very soon, a solar plant with batteries, enough social housing and care for those in our shire who are unable to cope with our complex society, a recycling plant and higher rates to enable us to afford such progressive, compassionate development. I know that Geoff Ellis was a hard worker towards social housing. We will miss his input.
Felicia Di Stefano
Congratulations to all of the newly elected councillors. Issues to be corrected moving forward are of the utmost importance.
The red landfill garbage bin pick up in peak times and a complete public review of all garbage, recycle and green waste contracts must happen. Revision of the Media Engagement Policy 2020, the Transparency Policy 2020, the Investment Policy 2020, the Procurement Policy 2020, increasing the 50 word limit to 100 or 150 for community question time and reporting full details in the annual report for councils Capital Works Program Status % and full financials and a fully detailed report included as an attachment in the Annual report for all Capital Works Projects not expensed or completed at years end 30 June of a year. Ratepayers who pay rates including our newly elected councillors have a right to be presented with these missing reports and corrections of policy or contact matters. Changes are over due. The Audit and Risk Committee and its Charter must step up and target necessary important changes. I look forward for our councillors, the board of council taking control and lead instead of following.
Graham Jolly
Hopefully this new Council will listen to the Community that elected them to represent them. Geoff Ellis not being returned to Council was as a result of his attitude at public meetings in San Remo and Newhaven to Council concerns. Clare has gone from number 2 on the ticket to No 3 without the Virus impacting on areas around S R /Cape Woolamai/ Newhaven having many ratepayers unable to visit their property's for 7 months there may well have been more candidates standing. The demo graphics in this part of Bass Council area between permanent and non permanent ratepayers is significantly different but it showed in the Public Meetings on Issues like Skate Park and Local internal roads that ratepayers love this area whether there living there full or part time. It's not a cheap area to own a property with Bass Coast rates considerably more expensive than many suburbs of Melbourne with similar property values.Now Melbourne restrictions have been lifted the local businesses will get a significant lift in turn over. Obviously until overseas tourism returns the visitors from rest of Victoria is critical for the Bass economy.
chris day
Chris, that seems a very illogical explanation of Geoff Ellis’s demise since all three Western Port councillors were at the meeting you describe and they were all subjected to extreme rudeness from a largely hostile crowd of some 150 people. One of those councillors topped the poll.
Maybe, now that Trump has met his demise, we can all start treating one another with more courtesy, even people with whom we disagree.
Catherine Watson
Catherine, I am not sure how Chris's post is discourteous. Were you at that meeting in San Remo? I was. It didn't start out hostile and "extreme rudeness' is slightly overstating the situation. Perhaps when people express their disagreement with what council is proposing that constitutes extreme rudeness. Several people advised the councilors of the physical and practical problems to building a skate park on the San Remo foreshore. The councilors dismissed those concerns out of hand. It was the total disregard of the concerns of the community that caused the residents to become irate. Some of the concerns raised at this meeting and lambasted by the councilors were in fact the actual reason why the San Remo foreshore was abandoned as a venue for the skate park. The reason, in a democracy, that we have elections is that we are able to express our dissatisfaction with sitting members by voting them out of office. I agree with Chris and consider if there had been more candidates there may have been more changes. Councilors are voted in to represent the residents and rate payers and be their voice in council. If the voters perceive that they are not taking this responsibility seriously they will vote them out at the next election. Assuming there are enough candidates.
TREVOR BROWN
At Screw Creek
Oct 31, 2020 –
Dear Linda, an absolutely brilliant piece of long-form Non-fiction.
So much research, so many memories, so personal and a wonderful piece of pioneer local history AND the search for truth. A superb merging and combination of so many elements to your story.
Accolades and orchids to you. !!!!
Warm Regards, Phyllis Papps
Great story and thank you for preserving this history. Also thank your brother and community for preserving the area. Without you and your brother, we would lose our sense of place and time which gives us an understanding of how we have come to be where we are now.
Peter Bogg
Thanks Peter for your heart-warming comments. To preserve the history and acknowledge the community's conservation of the precious bushland at Screw Creek was what I was hoping to do.
And a huge thank-you to Phyllis Papps for your generous Bass Coast Prize for Non-fiction and for your time and effort. The competition gave me the impetus to write this story (I had a deadline and knew someone would read it) and it gave me the opportunity to challenge myself. But much more than that, over the past two years 86 pieces of writing have been produced about Bass Coast and Gippsland that might not otherwise have been written. A priceless archive of stories and knowledge.
And many thanks to the Bass Coast Post and Waterline News for auspicing the Prize and to Catherine Watson, Geoff Ellis and Anne Heath Mennell for giving your time as judges.
Linda Cuttriss
Congratulations Linda. I loved reading the intertwining of your family's stories and the history of the area. I wonder if more evidence will surface one day about the fate of Lizzie.
Julie Constable
Lovely story, beautifully written, I'll look at the area through another lens now...thanks.
Brian Carr
A moving story Linda. Growing up with you in Inverloch I had no idea of these stories and the history of the Screw Creek area. I was impressed by the way you wove together: your exploratory return journey with John; your family history and links to the area; the history of the area itself, including its more recent conservation story; and the history of the First People who cared for the country. I have bits and pieces of stories from my great grandparents who were also pioneers in Inverloch. Your story has inspired me to try to learn more about their lives while my mother and her aunt are still alive. Thanks Linda and congratulations on the well deserved first prize award.
Marion Brown
So well crafted, Linda. I love the sense of layering, the peeling back of each story to reveal something deeper; the crisscrossing of paths made over time. There’s such humility and respect in this.
Gill Heal
A reflection on depression (and COVID)
Oct 30, 2020 –
Thanks Tim. It is so ironic that one of the big customers for Tim's book is a company which puts so many chemical.additives in its products. Food additives are so prevalent in our diets for the last 50 years, and burgeoning still. That, I suspect, contributes more to health issues generally than anything! And of course there are lots of them in medications. Tim's main point of community support is spot on though!
Christine Grayden
Thanks Tim for your insightful and timely thoughts. Even an easing of this COVID lockdown presents its challenges: which of the old habits, jettisoned over all these months, do I pick up again. And Bob has a voice in all this. On my daily runs around our parks, the plethora of dogs has shown what mankind can be: innocent and curious, non-judgemental, loyal and loving, and able to appreciate (sniff out?) the wonders of life.
John Gascoigne
Thank you so Tim much for this critical, timely, well reasearched and most of all compassionate piece. Ideally, it will help us all to remember how to genuinely care for each other.
Sharon Hurley
There is room for revision in some of the points made. For instance anger is a great outlet for depression after having tried to help yourself help is not always readily available..
Joan Woods
Please share our journey
Oct 30, 2020
Can't wait until the 8th :)
Stephen Edge
Unfortunately, I’ve needed to postpone the NAIDOC Week online art workshop until further notice. Thank you for all the positive interest in it so far.
Safina Stewart
Safina, such beautiful and evocative words, reflecting the intensity and complexity of your artistic endeavour, and echoing the strength and passion of the Uluru Statement from the Heart. 'This is the magnificence of our people' indeed. Your cultural, spiritual and creative expression through your art, and your family's and community's, is truly magnificent. Art that speaks to the ancientness of your lineage and the sacredness of your land. I hope many, many people will come to the Celebration of Indigenous Artists to meet you where you (and your fellow artists) are at.
Marg Lynn
Sand miner digs in
Oct 30, 2020
To whom it may concern,
Please don’t let the sand mine to be constructed in the vegetated section of this land. There is plenty of open land that could be used instead.
The loss of the vegetated area will take out a significant nature link between The Gurdies Nature Conservation Reserve and Deep Creek down to the Grantville Nature Conservation Reserve and Colbert Creek. Regeneration is a smoke screen, it will take years if ever to come back to the state it’s currently in.
Don’t let these companies who have pillaged from their part of Victoria come and devalue the Bass Coast.
Once it’s gone, it gone forever & then these companies have crept in and changed the very fabric & integrity of pristine land.
I love the Bass Coast, it is good for the soul to come breathe fresh air & enjoy the beautiful areas you have, don’t let your rich, vibrant area become an industrial wasteland.
The result of the community action was the "Regional Sand Strategy - Lang Lang to Grantville" ratified by the then Minister for Planning and incorporated into the relevant Planning Schemes.
Anne M Westwood
Thank you, AGL
Oct 30, 2020 –
Thank you Neil, Excellent article. We must continue the fight and preserve Western Port.
Clare Le Serve
Well written Neil. The remarkable community response highlights the importance of preventing the AGL plan. Following the Ministers decision in early 2021 the ultimate end game rests with the AGL Board who claim they will not proceed without “social licence”. Given the current reactions how can such a licence exist? Yes we do need to see commitments for permanent industrial protections for Western Port.
Jeff Nottle
Shannon Hurley's excellent article in VNPA's Sept Parkwatch p13, provides a sobering visual of what the Crib Point Gas Import facility could look like.
Anne Paul
Music inspired by the places we love
Oct 30, 2020
Congratulations Laura and all composers, what a great line up!
Irene Proebsting
All aboard for Wonthaggi
Oct 16, 2020
Totally agree with Cliff. We need a railway line for many and all the reasons Cliff raised. We also need councillors with a clear vision for the future, that don't just follow what has been set as the norm for this area. Why, in this day and age, haven't we got what should be basic for life anywhere, a railway line?
Monica Smith
They should NOT of taken the train service away ..Lets get it BACK NOW.......Robert Hayward Cape Paterson
Robert Hayward
It would be a world class tourist attraction and provide a much needed transport link. I mostly travelled to Melbourne by train when I lived in Echuca as many others did. However now I live in Inverloch the public transport service from this area is so bad most people don’t use it
Rhonda Sutton
Fully agree
Paul Bickerstaff
To make public transport viable, many, if not all of us, need to abandon our so called love affair with our cars. If it seems unthinkable, some of us remember life before cars, not much more than 50 years ago. Why prolong the agony? If cars bend priorities out of shape, how about charges to hasten their demise?
Bernie Mccomb
I am opposed to the reintroduction of passenger rail from the city to Wonthaggi. Am I alone in coming to this beautiful area because of its rural surrounds? I believe an easy commute to the city will turn Wonthaggi into a "bedroom suburb" for Melbourne workers who will build housing development after housing development on the land around our town and destroy any "country" feel that we still enjoy. Do we really want Wonthaggi to be another Bendigo or Ballarat, both of which have populations over the 100,000 mark - you might as well live in the city. This is a gut response to Peter's article, but if you can assure me that zoning laws etc. would ensure over-development would not follow the reintroduction of passenger rail, I'd be pleased to hear it.
Carol Cox
Life before cars was much more adventurous, imagine not spending so much time in traffic jams and hustling for car park spots?
Bernie McComb
Agree with you Carol. A recent trip to Japan showed me how to make rail viable, just add lots and lots and lots of people.
P.S rail would never be rebuilt on top of the dunes at Kilcunda.
Jeff Sim
I don't think you need to worry carol, passenger railway services are only maintained to big cities and towns like the ones you mentioned. Wonthaggi/Inverloch certainly will not be getting a rail service before the combined population reaches 100,000.
Step O'Rafferty
I have had the pleasure to spend short amounts of time from Melbourne in Wonthaggi late last year whilst my daughter was doing her medical internship at the local hospital. Similarly at Bendigo when she was at the hospital there prior. I fully agree Wonthaggi charm needs to be preserved and not be overrun with population. A nice weekend sea -side resort would do me fine. But a train service could add to the charm and keep the automobiles away especially on the busy Bass Hwy. However, that will require an optimum population density to be viable and that needs very harsh and enforceable zoning rules to avoid becoming Gold Coast overnight.
Some of the old country rail services in Europe and Britain have been revived by community involvement but these are few and far between. Mostly these have shut for good.
https://www.sbs.com.au/ondemand/program/walking-britains-lost-railways
(interesting stories here). Victoria did not fare any better once the mining and timber carriage was over.
Sam
It's a "NO BRAINER"! The recommissioning of the line is essential for the growth and development of the region and to ease pressure on the already congested road system to and from Melbourne.
Lou Pecora
Trains are a wonderful way to travel and allows people who don't have cars to move around without too much cost. A well managed service that allows people to see the beauty of Gippsland from a quiet window seems good for our communities, the environment, businesses and employment. especially if there is a carriage for bike storage.
Tricia O'Brien
To rebuild railway infrastructure to Wonthaggi on which trains could operate as fast as the current buses would cost at least a billion dollars. If it was built the line would be better off branching from the mainline at Lang Lang so it could serve the coastal towns and then after departing Bass, rejoin the old formation on the climb from Woolamai to Anderson. The current bus service takes 53 minutes to run from Lang Lang to Wonthaggi. The train journey was 84 minutes. I don't think any state government would be willing to invest that much in the Bass Coast region for a rail service.
Step O'Rafferty
Bird heaven
Oct 16, 2020
Loved reading about this Liane and seeing all the beautiful birds that are visiting you. Though we haven't got much of a back garden to plant many things, I'm going to do what I can to attract as many of these beautiful creatures as I can. Thanks for such an entertaining read!
Monica Smith
Surely your brilliant waratah bush will bring them in hoards!
Liane Arno
Lovely article Liane. I recall the weeds & blackberries on our side of the fence were just as thick as yours.
Joanne
A great story, thanks for sharing it.
Tricia O'Brien
What a stunning array of visitors you have Liane. What a joy. Beautiful photos. Hope they all turn up next week for the Aussie Bird Count!
Linda Cuttriss
Such beautiful birds and photographs Liane. What a joy after all your hard work
Margaret Lee
History with a twist wins non-fiction prize
Oct 16, 2020
What a fabulous event. congratulations to all winners and participants. looking forward to a few good reads coming up in the future.
Tricia O'Brien
Congratulations Linda and all the winners and highly commended. I'm looking forward to reading them all.
Julie Constable
Eagles Nest, by John Mutsaers
Oct 16, 2020
Special Place and lovely hues and Characters like 'Boober' expressing time enjoyed with those on holiday times. I remember when a one week per year, for a holiday visiting other places, remains memorable. Long walks/hikes in Fern Gullies Otways, time up the Alps late season so deep snow and crispy 6am walk/warm ups for a good day/week and yep, Coastal Burgs now more worried by tides and changes.
Tropical locations/nations share rapid change and may require assistance/s, those living safe places can assist.
Jillian Verhardt.
Harmers, by Catherine Watson
Oct 16, 2020
thank you Catherine, my school Latin has faded, but I know the light, the ripple & crash of the tide, the cacophony of a dawn chorus. I know also the winter by the ocean is perfect.
VC Hamilton
Councillor in corruption probe
Sept 25, 2020
First with the news once again. Thank you Catherine
Felicia Di Stefano
Well researched Catherine as usual. I hope there are more details BEFORE ratepayers are to vote in the upcoming election. Yvonne
Yvonne McRae
Unfortunately for the community a catch 22 situation.
As the accused is not guilty until proven, but if found guilty after the election this will require a by election to replace an elected councilor.
Ian Samuel
Just like to let everybody know it is not me being investigated, that is the only comment I can and will make at this stage. Regards Brett
Brett Tessari
Well done Brett. Now we know one councilor it isn't. Perhaps if the rest of the innocent councilors could advise that it's not them we would have a better idea of who it is. So much for loyalty Brett????? All councilors who have put their hands up as it not being them should hang their collective heads in shame. Rather than this being a reason for returning them i would think it a better reason for not.
Trevor Brown
This is unfortunate and leads inevitably to speculation on the whole group. I can say that I have not seen any instance of corruption in my time and respect all of my colleagues on the Council. I am placed in a position of having to affirm my innocence and can further confirm that I was interstate at an Australian Coastal Council conference at the time the alleged incident occurred.
Michael Whelan
Thanks for bringing light to this important issue, Catherine. I hope we find out more before the election!
Mikhaela Barlow
The timing does make the accusation very suspect, I hope we are not having state style politics intruding into our local government democratic process.
Jeni Jobe
It has come to my attention that the Victorian Local Government Inspectorate is investigating alleged corruption allegations of a Bass Coast Councillor.
I would like to state that I am not under investigation by IBAC. I fully understand the legal rules and responsibilities of being a Councillor and as this is a legal matter and I am unable to make any further comments.
Cr Clare Le Serve
Just confirming that I am not under investigation by IBAC. I fully understand the legal rules that IBAC work under and it would be inappropriate and possibly unlawful for me to make any further comment.
Cr Bruce Kent
I am aware that a media outlet has released comments that a Bass Coast Councillor is under investigation by IBAC.
I can confirm that I am not under investigation by IBAC.
I fully understand the legal structure that IBAC operates under.
It would be inappropriate and possibly unlawful for me to make any further comment.
Cr Geoff Ellis
Wow. Shades of Hillary in 2016. Given the alleged incident was at least a couple of years ago (if under previous CEO) why is it being made public now and by whom? If every Councillor confirms it is not them, the person involved will not remain anonymous for much longer, with all that implies for the election campaign. What a terrible way to end a hardworking Council which has achieved so much.
Anne Heath Mennell
Hmmmm.. As a rate payer, there is a lot to answer, however, this would not be the first in the last 100yrs and won't be the last
Theresa A O'Dea
The timing of this news is very unfortunate.
Especially since according to the Sentinal this complaint was lodged two years ago.
I sincerely hope that the Bass Coast elections doesn’t descend into gutter politics. All candidates should be judged on their promises and/or their track record in office.
Ronnie Bauer
Ronnie, I fully agree with your comment.
Cr Geoff Ellis
I think the leaking of this information is regrettable and that on-sharing of it is irresponsible, given that the person is not able to be named.
This puts other councillors in a position of having to publicly state their non-involvement, as seen in above comments.
By omission, the person under investigation may end up being identified. This is not fair and not helpful to the investigation process.
Julie Thomas
This investigation has now been reported in detail in today's Age newspaper.
In view of upcoming council elections, the legal question is can a serving councilor continue to be on council or be nominated for re-election when subject to an IBAC investigation.
This needs urgent clarification by the bass Coast CEO Ali Wastie prior to election voting
Ian Samuels
Disgraceful action by who ever leaked this information. If it's right that this was in regard to "something that happened 2 years ago" even worse. If that proves to be right even more explanation by Bass Coast CEO is required or as suggested should go to IBAC.
Our Community overall has little trust in Bass Coast Council and the way it operates but for most of us there are more important things happening in our lives than local government issues. Great shame this election is being held at this time when a large number of rate payers can't even visit their property's in Bass Coast Area Yet the Bills keep flowing in!! After the "performance" of our 3 local Councillors in regard to the Public Meeting in San Remo on the Skate Park the 3 existing local councillors re standing for election are very lucky they are not standing against a number of candidates. Any other year they would
be.
Christopher Day
I disagree with you Ian, that’s not a legal question that that needs to be answered because, surely the answer is already obvious.
Firstly, the allegations are unproven, and have not been yet tested by either IBAC or VLGI.
Secondly, the requirements of the Act will already be well known to Councillors, the CEO and council administrators.
Indeed, the Sentinel Times is now reporting that the matter was reported to IBAC back in October 2018, but went uninvestigated at the time. (Perhaps IBAC determined the matter did not merit further investigation?)
I have no doubt that the CEO and/or the Victorian Electoral Commission will have already made Cr. Larke aware as to what the legal requirements are. As Cr. Larke and other Councillors have publicly acknowledged, they are legally bound by confidentiality.
However it remains in the interests of justice that the following public questions to be put to CEO Ali Wastie:
• Will the CEO also refer to IBAC the allegation that a Councillor (or someone at council) leaked this sensitive and confidential information to the media?
• Will the CEO conduct an internal investigation into who at Council may have leaked this sensitive and confidential information to the media?
• Does the CEO have any idea already as to who at Council might have leaked this sensitive and confidential information to the media?
One question I’m certain that the community already knows the answer to is why the sneak(s) released this sensitive and confidential information to the media on the eve of Council elections.
Kevin Griffin
Kevin Yes Firstly I agree that the leak of this confidential and sensitive information must be immediately investigated as it improper and is prejudicial.
Secondly although it is no doubt already known by the CEO if there is a legal restriction on a candidate facing election, the community needs to be advised now that this has been leaked into the public domain so that elections can proceed without further damage being done to public confidence or individual integrity
Ian Samuel
Ian, I have no doubt that if there were any legal restriction that point would have been flagged to the community and BCP from some source by now. Possibly even by the person(s) that leaked the information.
But as you point out, some community members would like to know the answer to your question, and quickly.
Now I’m willing to wager that Catherine has Ali’s number, and that Ali would take her call. On that basis I recommend that Catherine call Ali now.
That way Catherine gets the scoop, and the rest of us get to know the answer to your question as soon as is possible.
What do you think?
Kevin Griffin
Catherine I observe that you have censored out my questions to each of the comments published by the Councillors individually.
Do you wish to offer your readers the courtesy of an explanation of your action?.
Kevin Griffin
Kevin, I haven't censored you. You've made your point. Once is enough.
Catherine Watson, editor
Before some post readers lose track of the issue at stake here I would like to pose several questions. Firstly, was it appropriate for a councillor to allegedly attempt to buy votes from other councillors in order to wear the mayoral robes? Secondly, was it the right thing to do to refer this to the proper authorities? Thirdly, was it sensible to keep this from ratepayers and voters for two years? Finally, I would ask readers to please not "shoot the messenger".
Mark Robertson
Hi Mark, couldn't agree more that it is not appropriate for a councilor to allegedly buy votes from other councilors in order to wear the Mayoral robes. If in fact this happened it is the right thing to do to refer it to the proper authorities. It appears that this was done some two years ago and IBAC has not done anything about it. This would, at face value, suggest that there may not have been any substance to the allegation. Therefore it was probably proper to not have this matter in the public domain. We don't know who the messenger is and his or her motives for taking this action. I think that this should be referred to the proper authorities not because of what the leak was about but, because the leak occurred at all.
Trevor Brown
I have had first-hand dealings with Councillor Les Larke over the past couple of years. I have found him to be a diligent and committed Councillor. In my experience, he has returned phone calls and taken the time to speak to me. He has provided considered responses to requests for information and feedback, where other Councillors have not even responded. In my dealings with him, he has also referred matters I have raised with Council Officers and ensured that matters were addressed.
Sharon Harrison
Sharon, I totally agree with you in relation to councilor Larke. I have also had occasion to ask Councilor Larke for assistance. I found him responsive and informed and prepared to give concise and unbiased responses. It may be a coincidence but, at the time this matter was apparently referred to IBAC, Councilor Larke had been raising questions about the financial operation of the council. I also agree that it would be a crying shame if this councilor was not re-elected.
Trevor Brown
Councillor Larke has been an advocate of greater transparency. I note that at the Council Meeting on 18 September 2019 Councillors Les Larke and Julian Brown were the only Councillors to vote against the Motion by Councillors Pamela Rothfield and Geoff Ellis to block the Bass Coast Shire Council Meeting Livestreaming Policy 2019. Councillors Stephen Fullarton, Clare Le Serve, Brett Tessari, Michael Whelan and Bruce Kent all supported the motion to block the livestreaming of Council meetings.
Sharon Harrison
I totally agree with the questions Mark Robinson has raised.
I note that in the Australian High Court there is mandatory retirement of judges when they reach 70 years of age. In my option this should also apply to all levels of government in order to reduce the likelihood of extraordinary decisions.
Frank W Schooneveldt
I have to disagree with you here. The reason I voted for Councillor Larke at the last election is that he comes to the Council with a great deal of experience in financial management and governance. Councillor Larke is the former general manager at State Trustees and a certified practising accountant of CPA Australia.
Sharon Harrison
Sharon, Irrespective of these new allegations Les Larke has done so much damage to our Council particularly for misleading his follow councillors re the the Shire finances and his judgement that we were living beyond our means. Analysis of the various budgets showed that this was not so.
The overturning of the $17 million Cowes Cultural Centre is a case in point. Here we are four years later and we are only now starting the $19 million Cowes Cultural Centre.
That’s four years of wasted time and I hate waste. It’s time we never get back.
IBAC and the VLGI need to rapidly assess these serious allegations.
Frank W Schooneveldt
I agree with Frank W Schoonveldt regarding the need for an expedited resolution of the IBAC and VLGI investigations. I also concur with Kevin Griffin that, given that the alleged incident was referred to IBAC in 2018, perhaps IBAC determined at the time that action was not warranted?
Turning to the age of Councillors I would like to add the further comment that, given that according to the 2016 Census the median age in Bass Coast is 50 and we have higher number of senior citizens, we need older people's voices on our Council.
My final point is that while some in community may disagree with Councillor Larke's actions as a Councillor, ultimately it is up to the voters in the Bunurong Ward to decide if they will re-elect him, as he is elected to represent this Ward.
Sharon Harrison
I agree the timing of leaking this information is political, and indicative of dirty politics. The Councillors who have let us know it wasn't them, I feel, were forced to declare their innocence. Overall I find the BCC progressive, trying hard to cover issues of human rights, the environment and local infrastructure.
Robyn Smith
Catherine, I see that your censorship of my posts is increasing.
Would you be so kind as to offer your readers and myself the courtesy of an explanation for your censorship actions?
Kevin Griffin
There are many things I have come to like about the Bass Coast Post since its inception eight years ago, but three stand out.
1. The number of people in our community with whom I have become acquainted through reading their articles and comments. Many of these I have not met physically, yet I feel I know them.
2. The standard that requires contributions to be made in a civil, respectful and non-defamatory manner. This is not an impediment to expressing ourselves passionately but it obliges us to express ourselves in a mature and responsible fashion befitting a civil society.
3. Every article is accompanied by the name of the person who wrote it.
Keep up the good work, Catherine, and thank you to all the contributors, including the Councillors, who have used this forum to keep us informed and to share their impressions and experiences of civic service.
John Coldebella
Pamela Rothfield Q&A
Sept 14, 2020 –
What a fantastic article Catherine, Pam is an amazing person and we are so lucky to of had her representing not only Island but the whole shire so energetically and passionately. Well done Pam, time to dust of the clubs.
Brett Tessari
Thankyou Pamela for great service to the Bass Coast community, if only we could retain your services, but it sounds like it's time to reclaim your life as your own.
Neil Rankine
Thanks Pam, for your positive encouragement. I really appreciated your input and good council you gave to the arts community. I wish you well. Kind regards
John Mutsaers
Thank you Pam for the quality of capable and compassionate leadership which you;ve demonstrated throughout your years on Council. The positive contributions you have made will continue to be felt in the years to come.
Laura Brearley
Thank you Pam for your four years of extraordinary commitment. I look forward to your next achievements for PI in your other community roles; but also to your being able to play lots of golf!
Christine Grayden
Pamela - A wonderful contribution as Mayor and Councillor. Besides a true lady in every thought, shape and form. Well done!,
Sincerely, Mohan de Run
Thank you Pamela Rothfield for your great contribution to the beautiful Bass Coast. Your achievements are to be congratulated.
We have five million people on our door step that now due to the pandemic are realising what a wonderful place the Bass Coast is and they will come. We need to be able to cater for growth in our population in a sustainable way. By increasing our population it will create a larger revenue so that we can finally “ fix the pot holes”.
Frank W Schooneveldt
thank you Pamela! I remember telling people back in 2016, "she's committed and very capable." I was thrilled when you were elected so easily - but not surprised. Our community is all the better for your devoted contribution over the years.
Natasha Crestani
Thanks Pam for your dedication and commitment as a Councillor. Your support and advocacy for important infrastructure and services have ensured the community of Bass Coast can face the future with confidence.
Anne Davie
A wonderful inspiring article. Pamela, we haven’t met but your words regarding negativity resonated with me - so well expressed. Let’s embrace the positive dreams and achievements. Thank-you for your service to our community.
Lyn Bennett
May I add my sincere thanks to you as well, Pamela? I thank you for all the reasons written above as well as for your beautiful encouraging smile. Whenever I spoke to the council I was drawn to and encouraged by your smile. The secret of your success and popularity is that you treat each individual with sincere respect. Enjoy your leisure time.
Felicia Di Stefano
Pamela, with the positive vibe you bring to every endeavor it's not surprising that your advocacy leadership enjoyed great success. You and Brett formed a formidable team. Commitment to LG is a thankless and exhausting task. Your contribution has been outstanding. Time to smell a few roses.
Wayne Moloney
Thanks Pam, it was great working with you. You showed great professionalism and leadership with this Council and we achieved a great deal as a team with your guidance. Best Wishes
Clare Le Serve
As an outsider looking in on Council it was very clear that you have both given your all and done an excellent job. Thank you very much. You are a great role model for whoever gets elected.
Michael Nugent
Birdman of Cape Paterson
Sept 14, 2020 –
What a wonderful place to be living at THE CAPE with nature
We have always been supporters of the ( ECO Village ) THE CAPE
Virginia & Robert Hayward
Fabulous photographs and fascinating to read about the bird life in The Cape. Always keen to learn more about the area in which we live and the wildlife and bird life.
Joy Button
A letter to Tim’s iPhone
Sept 14, 2020 –
As Tim has so adroitly put it, the Phone has not only changed but is now the essence of our life. Without it we are marooned in a sea of cyber space.
With it, we are a slave to its demands, apps and all seeing eye and knowledge.
From a handy piece of hardware to a controlling essential part of life
with memories stored beyond recall.
As our independence, privacy and ability for human contact and verbal communication slips away with each new innovation, one wonders where to from now..
Ian Samuel
Thanks Tim. So much of our lives on that tiny device. Imagine coming out of a long coma and seeing everyone staring at this thing in their hand. We used to memorise things but there's no point any more. What would happen if the WWW suddenly disappeared, either hacked or caught the equivalent of COVID. Would everything grind to a halt?
Catherine Watson
A good question Catherine,,,,I have a recollection of when first I heard of a thing called the World Wide Web, and as far as I might rely on my actual rather than my virtual memory, life was running its course happily enough, but perhaps back then time was valued differently.
Tim Shannon
Speak up, Russell and Darren!
Sept 14, 2020 –
Thanks for the work you are doing. I will be registering!
Nicky Miller
Virus diaries 12
Sept 14, 2020 –
Thank you for explaining bubbles, Catherine, now I know. Thanks for the rest as well. You seem to be leading an active C 19 life in your social neighbourhood.
Felicia Di Stefano
Dear Catherine
The way your COVID diaries reveal your beauty and the beauty of our community brings me close to tears every time. It's something about how the everyday details of life touch the transcendent that is so moving. Thank you for your eloquence in recording the ways in which life, death, chooks, dogs, virtual 5th birthday parties, adolescents who listen and asparagus shoots in Spring are all interwoven.
Laura Brearley
I hope the corolla is behaving again, they are legendarily reliable. Rolls Royce used to claim that their cars never broke down, they just "failed to proceed".
Mark Robertson
Happy Birthday Evie-B
Thomas McNish
A spring in her step
Sept 14, 2020 –
Etsuko, another wonderful article and another challenge for you. So much passion and so much enthusiasm. There is only one word to describe you- UNIQUE.
Warm regards,
Phyllis Papps
Dear Phyllis, thank you for your kind words. Passion and enthusiasm are fundamental elements of any of my quests. I can't think of any other way than following only what interests me. I love the word 'unique' very much, and hope this word continue to describe me.
Etsuko Yasunaga
Admiration for you comes easy. I love your determination to complete what you started and to be enthusiastic about it. I know there will be more to read from you and your passion in life. I am looking forward to it. Verena
Verena Hoefler
Weekends at Remo
Sept 14, 2020
4 Comments
Thanks for such an entertaining article. An insight into Remo in the 1950,s. My family spent the 50,s-1990 holiday in’s at Balnarring Beach Fresh fish 3 meals a day, precious memories.
Robyn
Thanks Kev for an insight in Remo from the 50s till yesteryear. Clearly a deep knowledge and history held dear. Western Port and its environs would not be the same today without your dedicated volunteer support to protect and defend what is unique.
Jeff Nottle
Thank you Jeff, But it was you, as the Preserve Western Port, "fearless leader" and the untiring efforts of other "PWP'ers, that won the "Battle of Hastings.
Old management adage, "TEAM" Together Everyone Achieves More" and what we all achieved in stopping that monstrosity was just great.
I just have to live down the day of our celebration. When I got up to sing the song I wrote to celebrate our victory and after handing out lyric sheets to all present, promptly forgot the lyrics as I sang it!!
Ah the memories...!!
Kevin Chambers
End of the line
Sept 14, 2020 –
Thank you Sophie for bringing this important topic into the light and nudging us to think about it personally. I wonder whether you've heard of older people coming together in a house and hiring nursing, cooking and cleaning staff. Would that be an option?
Felicia Di Stefano
While this may be a reality check for some people, it is a subject I have had cause to give a great deal of thought to due to having cared for 4 older and 1 palliative care family member. The elephant in the room is that two of these, and many other people for various reasons do not want to either linger at home or go into care to die but really want a non judgemental service freely available to assist them have a peaceful end at a time and location of their own choosing. Why is this not a basic human right?
Christine Grayden
Great article Sophie!
Peter Ghys
Sophie, as you say, there are worse things than death. Anyone who has worked in a nursing home will be familiar with the rows of drugged up residents propped in front of a TV tuned to a commercial station, volume on full, in an overheated room. (We get a taste of what lies ahead in doctors’ waiting rooms.) Not one of these once vital people would have chosen this sort of living hell and now they are trapped. Will any government ever have the courage to extend assisted dying to those who decide “It’s been lovely but it’s time to go.”
Catherine Watson
Ive been thinking about Felicia's questions regarding the possibility of a group of older people setting up their own aged care facility.
I remember seeing a story years ago, on ABC TV, about a group doing this but do not know if it was successful. It is often a hot topic amongst the LGBTQI community who fear they may experience discrimination and prejudice in traditional aged care.
I have not been able to find any information about projects like this.
Is there someone else out there who can answer this question?
A few things to consider before you set out on that quest:
Aged care is very expensive and unless you have deep pockets, you will need some government funding. Government funding is dependent on eligibility and approval (as outlined in the Aged Care Act 1997) and many requirements must be fulfilled before you can set up a residential aged care facility.
If you have lots of money and don't need government funding, you can afford to build a suitable house and employ a large contingent of wonderful staff. You will also need honest, reliable and skilled advocates to act on your behalf if you are no longer able to make informed decisions.
Aged care requires a large number of staff and many need to be rostered for 24 hours, 7 days a week. This usually involves 3 shifts per day of carers and nurses. Kitchen, laundry, cleaning and maintenance staff are necessary. Doctors and allied health personnel also need to be employed. The list gors on and on.
The group of friends will need to design a house that takes into account the health care needs, mobility and cognitive function of all the residents.The level of their care needs may increase, sometimes quickly, depending on factors such as health conditions and falls.
The qualifications and skills of staff should be appropriate to provide all these levels of care.
A group of friends may have the best intentions when thinking of sharing accommodation, but it may be difficult to design a home that will accommodate everyone's specific care needs. This has been a major reason/rationale for the hospital style design of most aged care homes. The building must be able to suit clients' wheelchairs, walking frames, lifting machines, health care equipment, hospital style beds, access friendly bathrooms, floors that can be easily cleaned-this list also goes on and on.
I regret that I can't be more positive about Felicia's suggestion.
I will keep researching this topic and let you know if I find more information.
Sophie Cuttriss
Having read all the above replies, I will add what I consider is another imperative - that the contributions of each person in a shared older household is managed by a really honest person who can be trusted to have residents hearts in their own.
Joan Woods
Finally, Cowes centre is under way
Sept 4, 2020
HIP HIP HOORAY! A great design. Let's hope it's smooth sailing from here.
Marian Quigley
Hip, hip hooray indeed! This beautiful design is a sensitive and intelligent response to the many, many years of hard work and lobbying by the wider arts community on Phillip Island.
Sandra Peeters
An intriguing design that appears to cater for community needs
Exterior night lighting for community areas must play an integral part of the design concept plus integration of the existing iconic bells and tree bench
Solar panel roofing and consideration of geothermal heating should be an added design feature illustrating the Bass Coasts commitment to an energy neutral community.
External wall colouring and texture should reflect the local coastal environment that we treasure
Wall or glass wall murals by local artists would be an added feature.
The devil is in the detail yet to be developed, but hopefully will include the above suggestions to make this an outstanding Cowes civic centre.
Ian Samuel
Thank you Catherine for reminding us that four years ago the Councillors shelved this facility on the basis that we were broke and could not afford it. It now cost $19 million and not $17 million.
I hate waste and time is waste because you never ever get it back.
Please Councillors lean the word “do” and get rid of people who can’t.
Frank W Schooneveldt
I endorse Mayor Tessari's comments. The exciting building will enable the Island's dynamic, diverse community to be displayed, experienced and enjoyed. The spaces will enable opportunities for small and larger events throughout the year. The design will acknowledge and celebrate aboriginal culture. The new Library has been much needed for many years.
The Centre will be a source of pride for the Island community now and into the future The construction will provide jobs during construction and after completion.
Anne Davie
Back to the quiet life
Sept 4, 2020
A wonderful summary Angela and thank you for all your efforts in support of the 350+ objectors to this inappropriate development.
Janne Morrison
Congrats on a fine article with touches of poetry to describe all that is so lovely about living at Coronet Bay, Angela. Congrats to the Coronet Bay community on a battle well fought and now won.
Meryl Tobin
Lovely post, thankyou Angela. What a horrible, greedy overdevelopment it was. I suppose it means that they’ll be looking to do it elsewhere now. Let’s support the next community that will be in the firing line.
Frank Flynn
I was one of the many who put in an objection, Angela. I too was exultant at the news. Your love for the local area shines through your writing and for once love has triumphed over greed. Well done to you and all the others who fought so hard and for so long.
Anne Heath Mennell
Aged care: a checklist
Sept 4, 2020
Thank you very much, Sofie. Ishall keep all the points you write about but does a facility with the correct answers to your question exist?
Several of us are planning to form our own mini care home. Would that work?
Felicia Di Stefano
That idea sounds interesting Felicia. How many people do you see being part of it?
Sue Packham
Beautifully put Sophie Cuttriss.
Ben
This is such a practical and helpful article Soph. I hope readers who have ageing parent/s still at home take Soph’s advice and quietly have a look around at the options in their area with Soph’s checklist in hand WELL before circumstances are suddenly upon them and they’re stressed, overwhelmed, guilt-ridden and in urgent need of aged care accommodation for their loved-one. Even though I knew I had Soph’s expertise on hand I allowed my denial and guilt to paralyse me (and Soph respectfully didn’t interfere). I don’t think anything would have taken away the grief and stress but it would have really helped to have done some homework in advance. As Soph says, we need to be more honest and courageous sooner.
Linda Cuttriss
Sophie, you have written really well about what good aged care looks like. When I worked in a large aged care home I was trained in the Eden Alternative and then asked to train up all staff from the manager, nursing and care staff, to the kitchen, laundry and maintenance workers. And it did have an impact. Sadly when the home's management changed the top down support so necessary for such a big structural shift was no longer a priority. Aged care, specifically dementia care in my case, was a tough but enlightening gig for me. Tough for the reasons you've pointed out and an education because I was challenged in every possible way, every shift.
Linda Gordon
Thank you Sophie for highlighting what our Aged Care system needs to be like.
I worked in Aged Care in the late 1980s when they took registered Nurses out of the system. As a weekend Supervisor for another 12 months I was horrified at the downturn in care and spent all my weekends trying to get essential medical Care to people who had been neglected during the week. I also had worked in Palliative Care for many years and am pleased to see that you have highlighted the need for specialized end of life care. Our current system is badly broken and needs immediate attention. Thank you
Margaret Lee
What a clear statement you have made Sophie. I would think you (or everyone!) could do worse than put this case before our politicians so that funding is increased to help more education and possible modelling on European models of operation. Brav
Hilary Stuchbery
Our extinction crisis
Sept 4, 2020
The Federal Government just today rammed through a weakened EPBC Act reform. They even cut short debate on the issue, one so important to so many of us. Let's hope the Senate can ensure that doesn't get through.
Neil Rankine
Thank you for such an interesting and positive article, Lauren. I find it unbelievable that the Federal Minister for the Environment can act on an interim report to weaken an already ineffective piece of protective legislation to make it easier for more destruction to occur, supposedly in the interest of The Economy and good old Jobson Growth (remember him?). You described lots of good work being done locally and I think each of us can only do our bit to protect and restore the remnant parts of our locality. Together we really can make a difference.
Anne Heath Mennell
The first encounter
Sept 4, 2020
A fascinating and well-told story of an historic meeting, Pat.
As a long-time supporter of the proposal for a national park along the eastern side of Western Port Bay, I think your suggestion of Bonkoolawal (Bass River) as its name is an excellent one. Should the park become a reality, I hope the Aboriginal Land Council would approve the use of the name.
Meryl Tobin
The Cultural Heritage Management Plan for the (now abandoned) Norsemans Road Hotel lists hundreds of Aboriginal artefacts that have been there for thousands of years. This article breathes life into those artefacts and I would suggest that the State Government should acquire the land and gift it to the Traditional Owners as an act of reconciliation and a portent of Treaty.
Geoff Ellis
Well said Cr Ellis. Great article Pat.
Neil Rankine
6000 years ago, before the 'bay' was a 'bay' (or 'enbayment' if you prefer) there was a river running between French Island and the east coast with the Holden Proving Grounds not far to the east. It would make sense that this would be a likely site of habitation for the 35,000+ years humans have lived need Western Port, should have great stories to reveal.
Pat Macwhirter
I'd never heard of this first hand account before, Pat (perhaps because it was a Frenchman rather than an Englishman?). Historically and culturally priceless. It adds weight to our attempts to protect what is left of the landscape and cultural sites and artifacts we have found.
Anne Heath Mennell
Virus Diaries 11
Sept 4, 2020 –
Nice diary Catherine. Just a comment re Thursday: I hope people realise that the State of Emergency is different from the lockdown. It is needed so the Chief Health Officer can make rules for our safety eg mandatory mask-wearing. It doesn't mean staying in stage 3 or 4. If everyone is careful we can start to open up. Let's hope so!
Jennifer Skewes
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. I have missed your diary and am glad to see it back.
Janice Orchard
Catherine your virus diaries are superb, and a genuinely valuable historical document, not just of the social effects of the restrictions but of life in general. Informative and entertaining both, I laugh out loud at least once with every one.
Thank you so much and please, if you can, keep them going.
Miriam Strickland
Well said, Miriam.
Nicky Miller
Hear hear, Miriam. A bright spot in the darkness which cheers me up no end. Keep 'em coming, Catherine - please.
Anne Heath Mennell
My time has come
Sept 4, 2020
Frank, Thank you for reminding me why I love this part of the world. You've captured some beautiful moments which help me become a bit more mindful too!
Leticia Laing
What a colourful and inspirational picture of life’s possibilities
Deb
Thanks Frank, can’t help but be a little envious of your roving and rambling life but blessed to share your delight of this coast and to see it through your lens. Thank you.
Jennie
Great story of your journey. So glad you're around to share your love of the beautiful Bass Coast and revel in new found freedoms
Rosemary
Great insight Frank - I too went for a walk somewhere I have been saying for years "I must stop and check this conservation reserve out for a walk". I am talking about The Gurdies Conservation Reserve. Went there yesterday and thoroughly enjoyed the walk through the bushland and am very glad I took the time (from Ventnor on Phillip Island) to check it out. We are indeed very fortunate to live in this regional area and the abundance of nature on our doorstep.
Imelda
Frank you have a wonderful eye for detail.
As a 9-5 worker (or whatever extra hours it takes to get the job done!), I’m incredibly jealous of your lifestyle. Enjoy the retirement you’ve earned it.
N Valks
What a terrific solution to what some people dread...retirement....and what a visual feast you've chosen to explore...The Strezleckis, the coast, and the people....you'll need more terabytes to store those images on now.
Brian Carr
I love your view of our wonderful Bass Coast Frank. I have been here for the past 20 years and like you have taken to photography especially the Flora, Fungi,Lichens and mosses in The Gurdies Conservation Reserve. Just through my back gate.........
Margaret Lee
Blow that! Neighbours fuming
Aug 22, 2020
Perhaps the community could get together and build one monster wind turbine for everyone to benefit from. The Daylesford community did this and it must have been successful as last time I was up there, they had built a second one.
Peter Bogg
Unfortunately a Shearwater rookery is situated opposite.
.Birds taking off and returning every morning and evening are likely to be flying into the blades as happens with the power lines.
Jan Fleming
This is absolutely terrible. Thanks for pointing this appalling fact out, Jan.
Sue Saliba
We lived near acres of wind turbines near Texel in Netherlands.Plenty of seabirds about, walked the dogs under the wind turbines and trust me, the place was not littered with dead birds. Birds fly with updraughts and the turbulence from the turning wind vanes would mean birds avoided the wind turbines like the plague.
Elizabeth (Libby) M. Lambert
By painting one blade black, wind farms can reduce bird deaths by 72% a recent Norwegian study has found. Could this be a solution Jan?https://www.evwind.es/2020/08/21/bird-deaths-from-wind-turbines-drop-by-72-per-cent-when-one-blade-is-painted-black/76686
Tess
I wonder if people would prefer a nuclear power station next door instead of a wind turbine ? Would they complain if their neigbour planted a local eucalypt species which would grow to 10 metres plus within a few years, and when the wind whistling through its branches would be at least as noisy as the vanes of the wind turbine turning ?
Elizabeth (Libby) M. Lambert
Noise from wind turbines is mostly a function of tip speed. This one looks no more than 10kW with blades no more than 3m. Standing under the 6 turbines in Wonthaggi, even on windy day, noise is not a big deal at all. In extreme winds, which could be noisy, blades are orientated to not catch wind and are stopped for no noise. There was this kind of wind turbine, owned by Ruth Partridge on the Island, no noise to worry about.
Bernie Mccomb
I am not against wind turbines but not next to a Shearwater rookery.
Shearwaters are also called Moonbirds, The juveniles use the moon as a compass when flying every year to Siberia, leaving at night, A lot are killed on the bridge at San Remo, more recently the lights are turned off for the few weeks it takes for them to leave.
When they are here they leave early morning to feed usually in the dark, they return in the evening at dusk. Outside lights are not encouraged of an evening on the Esplanade at Surf Beach, how will they see a wind turbine? .
Jan Fleming
They will not need to see them, they will feel the air turbulence from the rotating vanes and not go anywhere near them. hey are no more likely to fly into static vanes than crash into a tree.
Elizabeth (Libby) M. Lambert
The use of renewable energy is sound, I think the Daylesford scheme works well, and if it has gotten to the stage where residents are building turbines in their own yards it is time we upped the push for more community wind farms in nice windy places of which Bass Coast abounds. I lived in Surf Beach for many years and agree also the wether you call them Mutton Birds, Moon Birds or Shearwaters rookeries are important also.
Robyn Smith
We are fully supportive of wind energy, but turbines must be installed in appropriate locations. The backyard of a property in a built up, residential area is not an appropriate location.
No permits are currently required and Council must take action to put regulations in place to ensure that turbines are installed safely, and that the amenity of the neighbourhood, the health of residents and the preservation of wildlife are not impacted. Limits should be set on the number of turbines that can be erected on any one site.
K. & M. Nair
Me again, small turbines generally more trouble than they’re worth, can’t get clear air at useful speed anywhere near house or trees in suburban block. Power generated (and noise) is function of cube of size. Twice as big doesn’t mean twice the power but 2*2*2=8 times. In the real world, especially at top of high tower, 10 times bigger means 10*10*10=1000 times more power. Small proposed might be 6m diameter utility size generally 80m or more.
Bernie Mccomb
A vertical wind turbine is a much better proposition.
Brian Carr
Your article is missing a number of facts.
1. Will it be free standing?
2. How tall is the house and/neighbouring houses?
3. What does the model look like?
The picture included is NOT an accurate representation and only insights confusion and unrest amongst your readers. Please consider reporting the benifits of using facts when reporting on polarizing issues.
NB. I don't know this resident
Ben Cavender
Point taken, Ben. The illustration was just a simple graphic image, not a representation of the turbine in question, which hasn't been built yet. No one knows what it will look like because the owner doesn't have to submit plans or apply for a permit. The only thing we know is that the turbine is under 11 metres because taller than that he does have to get a permit. But there will be a huge difference between a turbine with three-metre blades and a turbine with 50cm blades.
Catherine Watson
For all those in support of the wind turbine, would you feel that way if it were a few meters from your house, in your neighbour’s yard? This is a free-standing 3 storey wind turbine (similar to the photo shown). All the houses neighboring it are single storey. This will even be higher than power lines and most trees. Regardless of your views of wind energy, there should be planning and building permits required with the opportunity for neighbours to object and local environment to be considered. You can’t erect a flagpole without permits, yet an enormous industrial-looking electrical device is fine?
Monika
Before retirement I worked at Swinburne university and they installed 2 turbine's one 20 mtrs from a aged care facility and has been turned off for years as noise and electronic interference with medical equipment was impacted . The second was outside the electronics class rooms has to be shut down because in strong winds the brakes automatically apply and vibrate causing a shuddering loud noise and this turbine will be about 7to 8 mtrs from our bedroom. This is totally against our amenity . I am not against wind farms just not on a suburban block of land
Stan
Council climate plan zeroes in on 2030
Aug 22, 2020 –
Noticed that Mornington Shire Council voted unanimously against the Crib Point AGL gas terminal. They said it does not stack up economically or environmentaly Our Shire will be impacted by the massive gas tankers coming into Westernport Bay and dislodging water into that bay. There has been big demos against this proposal on the Peninsula including a flotilla on the bay. Hope Bass Coast Shire supports Mornington on this.
Burt Blackburne
Hi Burt Mornington Peninsula shire vote was welcome but Bass Coast adopted a strong resolution some months ago against the AGL FSRU. It is also putting in a strong submission to the EES process backing up its stance.
Michael Whelan
I was thinking about those emissions as I was working on the story and made two decisions:
I will change from gas heating and gas water heating to all electric
I will change my newspaper subscription to a digital one.
It would be interesting if the council (or someone) set up a site or kept a record of the small decisions Bass Coast people make and the resulting reduction in emissions.
Catherine Watson
Another thing people can do is change electricity supplier and get onto one that contracts just renewable energy and give the polluters like AGL and Energy Australia the flick. I use Powershop.
The plan provides for a community hub that will provide community groups an interface for their projects. The emissions tracking is sophisticated and the reporting in the plan allows for the tracking of the various sectors and will reveal the progress being made.
michael Whelan
Council’s ‘COVID’ budget
Aug 22, 2020
This budget is a bad budget because it does not address the backlog of the $600 million in infrastructure issues in the Bass Coast.
It does not fix the pot holes.
It does not fix the roads, drainage issues and other amenities like swimming pools.
And on another issue to quote the minister for agriculture David Littleproud in The Age of 24th August 2020, “we don’t subsidise our farmers, they’re on their own two feet”
Well I this budget we give our farmers a 20% discount on their rates, which is a subsidy.
It would be far better to pay our farmers some form of fee for looking after the land and environment they maintain.
Frank W Schooneveldt
‘Stand clear – here comes Mrs Gilmour!’
Aug 22, 2020
Does anyone know where Gilmour track is at the Cape?
Frank Flynn
Yes Frank, it's at the first surf beach car park.
Catherine Watson
Great story, what a legend ?
Brian Carr
I loved the story of Annie Gilmour .... what a personality and a fabulous legacy she has also left behind.
Joy Button
Good reporting Catherine I enjoyed this story a lot.
Joan Woods
Forest campaign intensifies
Aug 22, 2020 –
I strongly support all your work to protect not only the Holden Proving Ground but Bass Coast shire in general, keep up the good work.
Rodney Boyle
Good work Tim and Catherine, a good coalition of interests is forming here. But as I emphasised in Council the other day it is important to involve the traditional voice here. They are dispossessed of their land and it is important to keep their interests in this land front of mind.
Michael Whelan
I agree Michael. Our group recognises that this whole corridor sits on the ancestral lands of the Bunurong people, and that their ideas and aspirations and the protection and preservation of their culturally significant places should be front and centre of this discussion.
Tim Obrien
With time becoming in shorter supply, houses are now made of concrete hence the sand need. Personally, I think that concrete houses are not nice - becoming smelly and cold. Perhaps it is time for the Australian 'dream' to be reevaluated.
Joan Woods
‘Get on with it!’
Aug 22, 2020 –
I have known Anwyn for so many decades and it was a privilege to get to know her and work with her.
She will always be remembered for her tireless efforts being involved in so many causes, so many campaigns, so many organizations.
We salute you Anwyn for all the work you have done on behalf of our region.
I am so grateful that I had the opportunity to see you at Banfields in your final year.
May you now rest in peace. Your work is now complete.
Phyllis Papps
I loved Anwyn, I went on a few bird trips interstate with her, we always had fun. Always forthright with her opinions, she had a wicked sense of humour.
Although I felt sad when I saw her a Banfields, she was always happy to see me.
Jan Fleming
We knew Anwyn for only about 15 years and she was a remarkable lady. A great sense of humour ... I have heard the story from Libby Skidmore of Anwyn dressing up as a ghost during Libby's Ghost Walks at Corinella Cemetery. She was a very clever lady and one who managed to get things done for her community with good grace and goodwill. Rest in peace Anwyn as you have left a great legacy for others.
Joy Button
I worked with Anwyn once only and we were delighted to make a much needed $100+ for a fledgling charity. We had two or three hours together and she was a delightful companion
Joan Woods
We miss Anwyn’s call rallying the troops to Bass Valley Landcare meetings. A huge loss and we miss her dry wit. An outstanding contributor to the community in so many ways. She leaves behind a great legacy.
Ian James
The life of a COVID campaigner
Aug 22, 2020
What an excellent article Leticia. The issues you raise are so important for the forthcoming Local Govt. elections AND especially for women.
As you rightly stated, there are only two Councillors out of nine in The Bass Coast Shire who are women. A great imbalance, because there are so many women who have struggled to balance various roles in their lives and battled against so many challenges and odds against them.
Of the two women who are currently in Council: Cr Rothfield (Island Ward) is now retiring after an incredible two very successful terms of office as Councillor and Mayor. The other is Cr. Clare Le Serve (Western Port Ward) who has also been Mayor and plans to stand for a third term.
I salute both of them for their incredible achievements over the decades on behalf of our community.
Let's hope more women will stand for the LG elections this year-despite major obstacles and challenges.
Good luck with your campaign. What Ward are you planning to stand for?
Phyllis Papps
You have my total support and I suspect the support of many, many Cape locals. It’s well overdue, to have a rep from Cape Paterson on council. Best of luck!
Frank Flynn
Leticia you write beautifully, your article struck a chord with me because I'm also standing for council. Best of luck with your campaign, I have no doubt we will get a chance to meet.
Jeni Jobe Candidate for Island Ward
It’s nice to hear you are coming from a care for family... but what do you stand for? There needs to be very aware humans working for the people right now! That you are going through this in a ‘normal family’ way is great but how do you view what’s happening? Do you feel what’s going on right now is...right/lawful/necessary?
Lee-Ann
To be fair, Lee-Ann, the brief to Leticia wasn't to write about her policies but to write about the complications of campaigning during a lockdown. Once nominations close, the Post will be questioning all council candidates about their policies and the issues that are important to them.
Catherine Watson, editor
Hi Lee-Ann
This piece was designed to be thought-provoking rather than pushing an agenda. I'm happy to see how the dialogue has unfolded. I encourage you to check out my Facebook page on where I stand on a number of issues: @leticia4bccouncil
Leticia Laing
The Solace of Birds VI
Aug 13, 2020 –
Patsy, another wonderful and descriptive article about our beautiful bird life. I will always keep on looking at the sky (not for the weather) and the natural world that surrounds us.
Thank you so much for all of your excellent articles with superb images.
I am truly sorry this is the last of the series and hope maybe you can be convinced to write more of your experiences and share this knowledge with others.
Phyllis Papps
Thanks Patsy it was a great series.
What would we do without our fabulous birds?
Jan Fleming
Another beautiful piece, like the others in the series. Thanks, Patsy, for sharing your love of the island's precious birds with us.
Sue Saliba
An artist in lockdown
Aug 22, 2020
A charming and inspiring article Marian. Beautiful artwork. Thank you for cheering me up.
Ursula Theinert
Hi Marian a positive article about your work.
A brilliant portrait of Warren - captures his minimalism as well as his humour.
John Adam
Good to see the island arts community is thriving, and finding ways to stay connected.
Catherine Watson
Marian has indeed captured the highs & lows of a practicing artist during these crazy times. In acknowledging the imposed restrictions I'm reminded of a favourite quote "Art Intensifies the Feeling of Being Alive" (see The Illogic of Kassel by Enrique Vila-Matas).
Paint on, I say!
Warren Nichols
Great work Marion, love it!
Carolyn Goldberg
Great body of work Marian. Strong and vibrant despite everything!
Annie Duncan
There is much to be enjoyed in both your painting and your writing.
Margaret Ainscow
Thanks Marian, great insight into your world of art. I loved your piece on 'Warren' and had a chuckle about the description. When this crisis is over, I believe the connections people make will be life long.
Clare Le Serve
The missing link
Aug 22, 2020
Great memories Terri, and spot on...we need to keep these links open today, more than ever. Sadly the powers that be don’t value the importance of walking track and beach links. This was highlighted over a year ago when Parks Victoria removed the culvert over the main drain between the rail trail / South Dudley and Five Brace. Complaints at the time said it would be replaced, which it hasn’t, ensuring that the drain cannot be forded once the rain comes.
We need to keep these links open at all times for both our physical and mental health.
Jim Barritt
Old Rifle Range Road reserve where the fence blocks it at the moment can still be opened to the public. It's a bit wet down the bottom where the Broom Crescent road reserve cuts through, so some appropriate drainage infrastructure will be needed but if enough people tell the shire that they want this track open there is plenty of justification in the shire's aspirational paths/trails strategy. This is a route identified in that plan.
Neil Rankine
Is it worth canvassing support for this ? I'm sure residents could see the value in what it could add to the area, and there seems to be a bit more money around for just this sort of thing, not that it has to be a fancy road, (a mate with a bobcat and a slab or two might do the trick :) )....soon to be Broome Crs resident.
Brian Carr
Well said Terry! I also grew up in Wonthaggi and our home was in Hunter Street. No TV or 'screens' in those days so kids made their own fun and activities. My siblings, other kids in the street and nearby often used the tracks Terry mentions out to the Back Beach, Lake Lister and the bush all around. I do know that some reps. from several of our environmentally aware groups made an appointment and met with a boffin from the Shire Council to outline their ideas of again opening the track to community. Great idea the chap agreed BUT suggested the way to go was for these people to apply for a grant for a feasibility study, then if successful apply for another grant to actually do the work !!!!! Hello? This is Shire land so it is up to the Council to facilitate the whole procedure NOT fob everything off to 'others'. It is budget time with the Council and there is money allocated for walking tracks etc. so how about it? I will write a letter to the CEO for the Council and encourage like-minded folk to do the same. Come on Council how hard is it to kick start a project for our community, visitors to the area and the myriad Uni. students who study and monitor our magnificent flora and fauna. Yvonne McRae
Yvonne McRae
The burden of care
Aug 13, 2020
Thank you Sophie and the Post for this excellent conversation the community must have about the situation with regards to aged care in this country.
Anne Davie
Sophie,this situation could have been avoided, and your words could not be more true. Have worked in aged care, and although finding it distressing,I was fortunate enough to work with excellent RNs and ENs. I treated the residents like they were my own grand-parents. I am truly disgusted and distressed that the aged care sector is all about the $$$$$, with a few exceptions. I think we are so fortunate on the Bass Coast to have excellent facilities for our aged and disabled. Please continue to teach and advocate for some of our most vulnerable people..
Michelle
Thank you for the work you have done to deliver a comprehensive assessment of the state of aged care in this country.
The whole sector needs a considerable shake up.
Ben Cavender
Proving ground campaign not done yet
August 13, 2020
Reminds me of how the Japanese used to buy WA wood chips made from native karri forests because they valued the natural beauty of their own forests to destroy them just for wood chips.
James Glover
Pfft. It was cleared farmland 50 years ago!
Dave Tgarth
Songs for Western Port
Aug 13, 2020 –
What a lovely and meaningful way to highlight the need to protect "our Bay"..."Circumstances" dictated my 2018 move back to Melbourne from The Gurdies, but Western Port has been and always will be a huge part of my life.
The same "circumstances" prevent me from taking an active part in the current AGL battle, but I continue to support from afar where I can.
I find it ironic that the current Andrews Government shut down the Hastings Container Port proposal on environmental grounds, but these do not seem to apply to the AGL proposal..
Methinks gas powered hot showers get more "city voter" attention than where their next lot of imported flat screen televisions are unloaded. Port Phillip or Hastings.
Good luck to all involved in this vital battle.
Kevin Chambers
I am lodging my EES submission tonight. It’s not onerous and i encouage others to speak up for the Bay too... the more voices the better.
Anne Paul
What brilliant work. It is a great comfort to know that a submission of this quality is being sent to the inquiry. Thank you for sharing
Geoff Heyes
Mum, here’s to you
Aug 13, 2020
Thank you, Miriam, for this heartfelt personal story... These 'covid times' lead to much reflection... Strange times for sure.
Nicky Miller
In search of Truginini
Aug 13, 2020
Thanks for the article about Truganini, Tunnerminnerwait, Maulboyheener and their group.
We will never know what motivated their escape from the early white settlement of "Melbourne". However, their raids and robberies of numerous white settlements in this area are well documented in "Jack of Cape Grim" by Jan Roberts and Tunnerminnerwait and Maulboyheenner: The involvement of Aboriginal people from Tasmania in key events of early Melbourne" by Clare Land.
Jessica Harrison
A watery makeover
Aug 13, 2020
Zostera is the genus name muelleri is
the species name
Hugh Kirkman
How ironic that while Melbourne Water is trying to rehabilitate the Bay environment, Environment Minister Wynne seems hell-bent on fast-tracking AGL’s environment destroying LPG gas terminal at Hastings which reportedly will subject the Bay waters to millions of litres per day of LPG flows at 15 degrees lower than Bay water temperatures.
Obviously the frozen gas needs warming to pump it to Cranbourne but Bay waters will be significantly cooled which will naturally damage and probably destroy parts of the ecosystem; it’s not rocket science.
When Wynne pushes this through will it be goodbye to the fragile colony identified of local seahorses and other vulnerable species? Will it be goodbye to the fish nurseries because of much colder temperatures in the Bay and how will the sea grasses be affected by the new man-made devastation about to be unleashed courtesy of an Environmental Dept approval that will beggar belief if it goes ahead.
Jordan Crugnale’s support for saving Westernport Bay from this madness is needed far more than any futile attempt to buy the Holden Proving Ground. Commonsense says that in this economic environment the Government doesn’t have the money. The future of the Bay is far more important in the big picture. The community needs to get its priorities right.
Trevor Fothergill
Armchair arts tour
Aug 13, 2020 –
Thank you so much Liane for your passion and vigilance regarding promoting arts and culture and being heavily involved in this region for decades- especially more recently during this period.
Phyllis Papps
Virus diaries 10
Aug 13, 2020
Lovely medley, Catherine.
Rob Youl
Thanks Catherine, I enjoy your diaries very much.
Janet Fleming
Catherine, I look forward to reading your diaries, keeping me in touch with life in South Wonthaggi while I am exiled on the south coast of NSW.
Leonie Smith
I've been thoroughly enjoying your diaries too. Post covid, you should put them into a book!
Marian Quigley
Thanks so much Catherine, I also enjoy your insights whilst in exile in Footscray. You continually remind us of our beautiful Bass area.
Sharon
love it..keep up the great work. You express what we all feel, and love your brother in-law’s joke!
Michelle
As always - you do an amazing job pulling all of this together. I absolutely love your virus diaries - I only wish I was interesting enough to appear in every one of them. The scary thing is that you are up to Number 10. Any bets on which number sees the conclusion??
Liane Arno
Wonderful! you just took me thru the areas where I used to walk daily, sadly missed. Thank you so much Cathrine. I am sure Matilda and Nugget would have been friends!
Heather Tobias
Not too coastal, urges alliance
July 31, 2020
The Alliance is spot on. The 'somebodies' sitting in their ivory tower offices, looking at a desk top map, and thinking, 'This would be great. Look at that strip of vegetation along the cliff tops visitors would have great views,' Never considering that people would access the beaches onto the rock platforms and some would be caught out by the tides. Once the tide is rushing in the 'gutters' in the platforms become rushing torrents, and even mountain goats would find scaling the cliffs almost impossible - disaster WILL happen. The Alliance plan also means any walker having a health difficulty could be accessed by emergency services easily on their proposed trail. Hopefully the 'planners' will listen to local 'experts', and not go along with some hare-brained City scheme. The danger to birds, small mammals, reptiles and our precious coastline should be uppermost in the planning. Who remembers when the scheme was mooted (years ago) for the outfall from the Inverloch Sewerage Scheme to be pumped over the cliffs near Flat Rocks? I remember being involved with that fight. I remember my submission renamed the locations - Crap Rocks, Eagles Mess and Point Shite. Roll on Brave New World!
Yvonne McRae
A couple of years back Councillor Brown advocated that the rail trail be extended from Wonthaggi to Inverloch. Very good idea as it will improve safety and access for walkers and cyclists for moderate cost.
A coastal path that hugs the coast will cost a bomb and render a wildness area accessible but offer little in the way of a link between the towns.
Now that the Nyora to Leongatha railway is finally being replaced with a rail trail The council and state government should consider extending the rail trail beyond Anderson and create a link. The beauty is that it’s all crown land and we have some outstanding bike trails in south gippsland already in place.
Edward
Yes, when I was on council some 5 or six years ago we started work on this shared pathway linking Wonthaggi and Inverloch. A lot of work has been done identifying where vegetation is too valuable and needs to be bi-passed, fundamentally it's the sensible and not too difficult option.
Neil Rankine
Thank you Neil. My mistake for not mentioning the longstanding work by council on the Wonthaggi to Inverloch bike/walking trail .
There are so many reasons to extend and link up the rail trails.
It’s also a great way for us to attract people to the area who will swap cars for bikes ... reducing the velocity of visitors, providing an opportunity for them to work up an appetite and spend money locally.
The coastal path sounds like more car /bus traffic to me. Not much in it for the local economy
Edward
Nah, can’t agree. A walk close to the coast (and preferably along the beach at low tide) is what will bring people.
Peter Ghys
I agree with every single recommendation of the Alliance. The Rail Trail through Kilcunda is already being diverted through the Lionel Rose car park as that dune gets washed into the sea and the town is over run with wayward tourists hunting coffee on any sunny day.
Directing the hordes from Melbourne along the delicate foreshore of Harmers is eco-vandalism and expecting travellers to dodge the tides as they walk the beaches is negligence.
Stick to the path that's there, this isn't some eco-Disneyland, and why do we have to make every damn piece of nature accessible to everyone who needs to take a selfie next to some poor creature clinging to it's disappearing habitat.
Cr Geoff Ellis
Well said, Geoff. The very idea of this plan fills me with horror.
Sue Saliba
Hear, hear!!
Liz Glynn
I get the impression that many of those who disagree with a coastal path have never walked on the many popular coastal paths in the UK. These have brought very many tourists to admire the scenery and environment and contribute to the local economy.
Could it be that many of those who object to this coastal path are land owners who object to the general public accessing a narrow strip next to their properties? Horrors! Imagine tourists from Melbourne actually walking by their land!
Please don't be small minded and try to exclude others who want to experience our wonderful coastal scenery.
Hugh Hungerford
Open letter to everyone - I will happily give anyone a guided tour of Harmers Haven and point out why the options of stumbling along fragile sand dunes, trampling plovers nests, disturbing cultural heritage or wandering along a dirt track that passes for a main road are unacceptable options. What was the song "Find paradise, put in a walking track."?
Was it small minded to save the Daintree? Small minded to say "don't climb Uluru?"
wpwbcge@gmail.com
CR Geoff Ellis
Some of the pleasure of a “coastal” walk is experiencing a variety of environments, including coming around a corner to get a different vista of the ocean. Having done the multi day Great Ocean Walk in the west of our state, it is not all on the beach or cliff top, but goes inland, as appropriate. Very sensible recommendations from the group.
Nola Maxfield
I think the coastal alliance has nailed it. The section from San Remo to just past Kilcunda is the best of the clifftop views. Take the track inland after that and walkers are in for a different kind of treat. They’ll walk beneath the windmills, encounter mobs of kangaroos and perhaps even emus, see hundreds of water birds at Baxters wetlands, then wander past the remains of the number 5 mine brace and an introduction to Wonthaggi’s rich mining history.
Catherine Watson
We live in a coastal region and yet so often we try to create less ways for people to access and enjoy it. Around the world communities value ocean vista and access to beaches yet again here we have groups trying to find ways for those who come to the coast not access it. While I fully understand the need for environmental protection there are creative ways of doing this and still accessing the ocean vistas. We are currently in one of the greatest crisis our world has faced, communities are threatened both socially and economically. Yes potentially there could be better realignment along the Kilcunda to Cape Paterson component but imagine a creatively road side but not attached dual walk / bike pathway from Inverloch to the Cape. The economic and social benefits would be amazing. It could be one of the great walk / rides in the country and then creatively attach it to the five beaches amazing. People who come to the Bass Coast largely come for a coastal experience, yet we continually try to create infra structure and barriers to that very experience they come for.
Max Wells
Thank goodness that I’m not the only one who thinks that a coastal walk should be actually on the coast. 😊
Peter Ghys
Council: we’re hiring
July 31, 2020
Thanks for such a good, positive article.
Nicky Miller
Congratulations to the councilors for addressing the problem and providing support to our hard pressed community
Ian Samuel
A great initiative and good on the council. Especially good to see a stimulus package that also caters for women for once. One quibble: confining Working for Victoria to people who have lost their jobs because of COVID perpetuates the idea that they are more worthy than the people who lost their jobs for a multitude of reasons in the years before. I would like to see the scheme opened up to anyone who needs a job. There is no shortage of work that needs to be done!
Catherine Watson
Good news from the Council employment department. What a change of perspective. The hills will in future have the sounds of wind music through the leaves of whatever.
I have a few wattle seedling needing tlc - pick them up if they are useful for the program.
JOan Woods
It's great to read that conservation work has been included in this initiative. I do hope that the re-vegetation team will work to remove the weeds along the northern foreshore of Phillip Island and put in the indigenous coastal vegetation that should be there and, for various reasons, including illegal foreshore encroachment by neighbouring properties, isn't. This is a crucial area needing attention particularly as habitat for our native animals.
Sue Saliba
Places in the heart
July 31, 2020 –
What a beautiful thing to do! Thank you Laura and your team of lovely people. I hope to write a few things for you. Thanks for publishing this Catherine. I have shared this on four FB pages.
Christine Grayden
Thank you Christine for your kind words and for passing on the Coastal Connections invitation. Every bit of love for the Earth and for each other counts more than ever right now. Go gently dear woman.
Laura Brearley
I am very interested in this. What a fabulous idea. I will put pen to paper.
San
Great idea. I will give it a go.
John Adam
Ciconte Close
July 31, 2020 –
Beautiful story to read, teaches me to be resilient . It reminds me of my parent’s struggle as migrants from Holland
Petra Shandley
Great story and so indicative of Italian culture in Australia, managing to keep their families together while working very hard - or perhaps that is the key.
Congratulations to all story tellers and author.
Joan Woods
What a great read. Thankyou!
N Smith
Thank you .... I thoroughly enjoyed the story. Would love to hear more of these stories.
Joy Button
My husband Michael and my two sons holidayed with them at I Paoli in 1985.
My in-laws house was next door to Tomasi Ciconte’s house, who is his brother.
We were there for 3 months.
We had so many laughs and amazing walks, best time ever.
Also we had a fruit shop in Pakenham and Dom would come to our shop once a week to deliver some of his veggies and my husband Michael would pick up some fruit from from the market in Melbourne.
We loved to see him weakly.
He would tell us what was happening in Wonthaggi
I was very interested as l went to school there.
I am one of the Nero girls, Raffaelina.
Raffaelina Nero Scuglia
Whatever it takes
July 31, 2020
Wonderful job Ian! You are doing a great thing restoring those machines. Are they available to view in some way? Do you have them on a website? I'd also like to know if you have photos of the process of restoring them - that would be a great record for other/future restorers. Maybe Catherine can do a few feature articles about each one of your restored machines with some info on each and they can be shared that way. Best wishes for future projects.
Christine Grayden
A little treasure trove of way by gone farming history restored with great detail. Fabulous craftsmanship Ian.
David Taylor
This Coast Post is a great antidote to COVID depression. Creation, restoration and a population pulling together in hard times. Makes you think of Aristotle, who said about 2340 years ago that the Whole (read "Bass Coast community in mid 2020") is Greater than the Sum of its Parts.
John Gascoigne
Great juncture Ian - the modern initiative with past trades craft.
Love the buggy your family arrived in. It must have been a shock for them all.
joan Woods
Virus diaries 9
July 31, 2020 –
We are here at Upper Ferntree Gully just wishing we could go down to our unit at San Remo. We waited for school holidays to finish so we wouldn't get caught up with school holiday visitors but then shut down Metropolitan Melbourne started. So enjoy the extra freedom you have still in Bass. We are social distancing all the time and really not a lot of people walking around here although today for first time in couple of weeks
saw 4 people in few minutes with no masks. They obviously think carrying a drink even though not drinking anything means they don't need one.
Knox is large area and we are literally 800 metres from Yarra Ranges so with 1000 steps closed except for few walkers and bike riders only locals walking around, always dog walkers out there wherever you go!
So enjoy the extra freedom you have at this time, and just to let you know that although many would like to get out of town we are doing the right thing and staying away. Lets hope our State can get on top of this virus and numbers drop we have Family including grand sons living in Northern Suburbs and one doing Year 12 at this stage still going to school using public transport so they are very much our main concern.
Stay Safe. Enjoy the sea fresh air,
Chris Day
Oh. Catherine, it’s so good to read your virus diaries. Having not been down that way for sooo long now. It’s the only connection that reminds us of another world of another life.
Thankyou.
Jill Shannon
Thank you dear Catherine for reaching out to us with your COVID diaries and naming the layers of feeling that come with this experience.
You open your heart to us in your diaries and you write for us all.
Thanks for holding us in this way.
Laura Brearley
Testing times for writers
July 31, 2020 –
Dear readers and writers.
150 words? 250 words? 500 words? Definitely NOT.
The Bass Coast Prize for Non-fiction 2020 aims to encourage writers of long form Non-fiction that is meaningful, thought provoking and in-depth about issues, places, people, local history and related to the Gippsland region.
This is a rare opportunity and challenge for Gippsland Non-fiction writers to 'spread their wings' and write something meaningful that isn't just a quick piece of easy writing (such as Facebook, Twitter and the social media)
Entries need to be between 4000-10,000 words and the closing date is 4th September.
Check the website: https://basscoastprizefornonfiction.weebly.com
Phyllis Papps
A curator's view
July 17, 2020
Love this idea as it would keep the vegetation pristine whilst encouraging visitation.
Susan Acheson
The complex would need, in my opinion, to be preserved because that is as important to members of our past and future communities as is the natural features.
Congratulations of bringing it to our attention.
Joan Woods
It would seem that such an intact resource with the history of Holden in Victoria should be taken up by the State and the community. An aea like that of reasonably preserved coastal bushland is likely not available anywhere else and with the possible removal of some weed species trees would not need rehabilitation, just some gentle maintenance.
I think that purchase is a good idea and should be pursued with the government as only thay can guarantee it's continued preservation. That land, like all around it is subject to sand mining applications and only the State can prevent that happening.
Great idea to include museum in the grounds. I have experienced museums that are really popular with domestic travelers and this concept would enhance the site.
Jeff Cole
Holden purchase on the cards
July 17, 2020
Would be a wonderful asset for the local and wider community. There are few if any such large areas of native vegetation (as well as the rare fauna) in our region.
Neil Stewart
Protective overlays would be a great start but the best protection would be for the government to acquire this unique and precious piece of land and create a nature reserve for the community to enjoy and safeguard its survival in its entirety for future generations. If sold to private interests, backdoor deals can still be made overriding planning controls by applying to planning minister's office directly. Also if sold to private interests despite strict planning controls would mean the site remain inaccessible to the community.
Barbara Moje
The Corinella Residents & Ratepayers Association Inc. (CRRA) also supports this group.
An invaluable asset that needs to be preserved and for the community to have access to enjoy it.
David Laing
The Solace of birds V
July 15, 2020 –
Patsy, what another beautifully written and illustrated 'The solace of birds.'
I truly look forward to reading The Solace of Birds VI.
Phyllis Papps
Black lives matter here too
July 17, 2020 –
Well said, Marg - you sum up the situation succinctly. Regrettably, even 232 years after the invasion of this country by the British Government, indigenous people still suffer from the historical effects of colonialism and there is still no treaty. It doesn't take much imagination or empathy to appreciate where Australians, indigenous and non-indigenous, would be today if we had lost the Second World War. In much the same position as indigenous people find themselves now, I would suggest.
The gut-wrenching CCTV footage of torture, such as the teargassing, manhandling, stripping and pinning down and hooding and restraining of young indigenous boys in Darwin's Don Dale Youth Detention Centre and footage of a young indigenous man murdered in a cell by being pinned down by guards and so unable to breathe is there for anyone to see. How was it allowed to happen and what is being done about such crimes and injustices in Australia, our wonderful country where it's supposedly a fair go for all?
Meryl Tobin
Maybe you could encourage readers to write to their local federal MP to encourage them to support the Uluru Statement and actively lobby Scott Morrison to adopt it? If we all speak out then there may be a chance it could happen.
Sue Acheson
Unfortunately, the winner takes all mentality is rife throughout our communities. How can we swing this bias around.
Joan Woods
Good question, Joan. The short answer is education.
John Coldebella
Thank you Marg, for the truths from the heart. May all the changes you write are needed, come to pass soon. A change of government would help.
Felicia Di Stefano
Thank you for your affirming comments. I think you are right, Sue, that writing to our MPs, if there were enough of us, would indicate the strength of feeling and support for the Uluru Statement, and perhaps put some courage in them to argue for, and vote for constitutional change to embed the Voice. Having said that, Aboriginal leaders have indicated their faith in the Australian people to support such a referendum question, and surveys indicate they are right, but they have no faith in politicians to show the same empathy and understanding. But we need the pollies to promote the referendum! So write those letters.
Marg Lynn
Virus diaries 8
July 17, 2020 –
Keep it coming Catherine. I am loving the stories and you are making a record for the future generations who will study this pandemic and how civilisation coped.
Interesting to read about how your friend I South Africa is doing. Such a contrast between her situation and yours. She seems happy.
By the way, my garden is also experiencing Spring like changes.
Janice Orchard
Love it Catherine; it does me good to smile and have a giggle when I am one of those health care workers that worry constantly about patients, husband, and family in Melbourne..
Michelle Graham
And the band played on
July 16, 2020
To Terry & Laura, Lyndall & Strat. That looked like alot of fun! Thankyou
Mary Whelan
'Streets ahead' with your Fantastic initiative and VERY entertaining!!!! Music filling the gaps!! Just great.
Ellen Hubble
It was great fun to participate in this event
MaggieL
Bass Coast embraces green power
July 17, 2020
Has Council initiated any particular advocacy recently? Particularly, how about advocating that Federal sign off on legals to enable Star of the South offshore wind farm?
Bernie Mccomb
Thank you Michael. The Bass Coast community is fortunate to have a progressive Council that takes Climate Change seriously and is ensuring responsible energy supply now and into the future.
Anne Davie
Well done Bass Coast Shire Council. Congratulations on an important start. Thank you.
Felicia Di Stefano
Gaslighting Gippsland
July 3, 2020
Lauren, your excellent article exposes numerous reasons all of us should share your concern about on-shore gas exploration. I too attended a Gippsland Resource and Land Use Planning online community workshop about on-shore gas. When I asked the proponents if gas exploration in the Lang Lang to Grantville area was being considered, one said it was unlikely because it was on the edge of the study area and there were a lot of constraints. But I still gave feedback indicating all our Distinctive Areas and emphasizing the environmental-sensitivity of this area. However, I’m concerned not just for this area but for anywhere in Gippsland, indeed Victoria. Why prop up a dying and unsustainable energy source when public monies could be better spent on funding renewable energies such as solar?
Meryl Tobin
I too attended the so called "public consultation workshop". The inverted commas are on purpose as the session was anything but - it was a marketing activity trying to sell us onshore gas exploration despite everything that's wrong with it. Your article explains it so well - there is almost no upside to onshore gas but a lot of downside. We should all reject any proposals from the gas industry.
Annie Rivera
I commend Lauren for reminding us, that our politicians, both Federal and State, are captured by forces that prevent what we all desperately need to avoid a climate change catastrophe, one that will make our present Covid-19 fears and restrictions almost irrelevant.
Unless natural gas leakage (methane) from on-shore gas wells is kept below around 3%, there is no climate advantage changing from coal to gas powered power stations.
The use of natural gas to create, so called, "clean energy hydrogen" being advocated by the same, "powers to be" that provided the lump of coal for Scott Morrison's Federal Parliament theatre is definitely not the answer, far from it.
Australia has an abundance of renewable energy sources (solar PV and solar thermal, wind, tidal and geothermal) which, without present, fossil fuel vested interest political influence, could soon move Australia to a thriving zero emissions economy powering itself and other southern hemisphere countries with clean, lifesaving energy.
Tony Hughes
What a great article Lauren, so full of wise critique about this appalling situation. It should be essential reading for all politicians. Could you submit it to The Age perhaps?
Marg Lynn
Thanks Marg. I just emailed it to the Age to see if they're interested!
Lauren
Does everybody know about story, with strong recommendations to not connect to gas when building new house, in ATA Renew magazine, by no less than AGL? How much more ridiculous can energy politics get?
Bernie Mccomb
Lovely article, Lauren.You demonstrate the casual way important decisions, which are more important than the participants, occur.A mild criticism:- in 2015 when the gas industry got a huge export deal which short changed Australians and tripled domestic gas pricess the companies are not to blame .They were doing their job for profits as expected. The blame is entirely with PM Gillard and her naive ministry.
Benedict Clark
But Benedict, the current LNP government is totally ignoring the issue of over-commitment of resources and LNG trains in Queensland.
They have reneged on a deal with Senator Patrick to bring in gas reservation as used in WA.
Ian Teese
Gillard’s government ended in 2013, I’m afraid this was an Abbott job 😀
Lauren Burns
How can any government support the planned disruption and damage just to get six months supply of gas?
Brian James
The Gippsland Climate Change Network totally opposes the search for on shore gas exploration in Gippsland We have enough renewables that will come on line in Gippsland over the next 10 to 20 years that will more than compensate for such small amount of gas produced on shore in Gippsland and given the modification for water use in the Macalister Irrigation District Plan just announced and what dairying and agriculture means to Gippsland We can not see the VGP getting up or other
Ian Southall
Water and Gas don't mix. In the early 1980 a book was written detailing rings of trees research. It said that briegly = that it was as likely that we would experience an ice age rather than a hot age. Which ever way it goes, climate change is here and we should acknowledge it at every level of government.
Joan Woods
Dream on, PM
July 3, 2020
Really interested in this history. My grandmother's family (not Smiths), also farmed cane at Sarina in the same period. On a bit of history seekingin the past I discovered that during the Spanish flu period some of the Kanak workers became unwell, passed away and were buried in a small cemetery on the property. I also cringe at the use of these workers at that time....as well as some entrenched racist attitudes today
Nola Smith
Thank you for sharing this story. We need to know our history whether it is palatable or not.
Margaret Lee
Yes, we've progressed in different spheres of our society, but there's a cringeworthy element in all four photos. Perhaps if Harry had stood beside his bride gender inequality wouldn't be raising its ugly head.
John Gascoigne
Could it be anything other than slavery when stealing a loaf of bread etc was crime punishable by transportation? And how about all orphan kids exported from UK and stolen generation kids into forced labour slavery? And still happening with “people trafficking”. Advance Australia indeed.
Bernie Mccomb
A little-known part of our history that you have researched well, Robyn. Another thing for our Government to say Sorry for and belatedly do something about.
Meryl Tobin
Thanks Robyn for reminding us of some of our not so well known history.
The good news is that the Seasonal Worker Program and Pacific Labour Facility allows workers from the same areas to work in agriculture and hospitality here.
The twist is that they are rigorously supported to ensure they receive award pay and conditions and have (mostly) good accommodation. Some of these workers are seen from Aug-Jan picking the asparagus on the Kooweerup Swamp and other places. They often return each year.
Ian Teese
Holden bushlands campaign powers up
July 3, 2020
Thank you to everyone involved, so happy to read that council and our Bass MP Jordan Crugnale are trying to make this happen. I wish them good luck and will make sure to spread the message so we can get behind them.
Jeni Jobe
Well done to all involved. Let me know how I can help? I would love a dedicated area for Mountain Biking in Bass Coast as this is something we lack with the nearest areas over 90 mins away. Complimentary to the conservation benefits of this site becoming state own we could see a network of hiking and mountain bike trails to be enjoyed which would be a great asset for local residents and a year round (off peak) attractor to the region. The You Yangs being one of the better examples.
Michael Wright
Absolutely support this, especially in the context of the Healesville to Phillip Island Nature Link of which the Holden Bushlands needs to be a part for conservation, recreational and biodiversity reasons.
Pat Macwhirter
Thank you to everyone for all your efforts so far to ensure that the bushland is retained for community use. There is no doubt that the townships will be supportive and fingers crossed that this precious reserve can be retained for future generations.
Joy Button
thanks to and support for all trying to save this bush
Anthea Spehr
Well done... Certainly hope this site can be preserved for bushland.
Nicky Miller
Well done eveyone for the time you are putting in to try to save this bushland, I hope you are successful, thank you for caring about nature.
Sunny
Best thing I've heard of in years. So important to the future of W.Gippy.
Joan Woods
Virus diaries 7
July 3, 2020
another secret Ray Bradbury fan, welcome Catherine, the Bass coast is full of us (once i was a Martian or perhaps an ancient tree )
i probably have all the Ray Bradbury books except the most popular which are still avaliable, happy to lend, once i find the box they are stored, in due to replaced leaking roof and ceilings.
science fiction as predicted most of the messes we find ourselves in.
on the Feminist side U.L Quin wrote so she could be published the Wizard of Earthsea the most well known.
Love your diary slant on Covid life Nerida
Nerida Melsmith
Thank you, Catherine.
Nicky Miller
Call for action on safe cycling
July 6, 2010 –
We definitely need to extend our bike path network and upgrade and replace sections of the existing network which has failed.
Remember, it’s dream selling season, and without a plan, it’s just a thought bubble. The same bubble I’ve been hearing about my whole life. Where is the plan?
I have one. https://mikhaelabarlow.wixsite.com/mbarlowforbasscoast/arts-and-lifestyle
Just an idea, have thoughtful day everybody.
Mikhaela Barlow
Saving the magic forest
July 3, 2020 –
Thank you Meryl for a most informative story. These grass trees must be protected.
Dan Drummond
Thank you for your research and advocacy for this amazing bit of bush.
Nicky Miller
600 years old! And they want to destroy them, how sad, very sad, money is a temporary gain, but nature is there for all generations to enjoy. Please save the grass tree's>
Sunny
The journey continues
July 3, 2020
Inspirational Stuff!
Rowan
Second time round
July 3, 2020
Beautifully written Etsuko and so informative. Thank you for sharing and especially for sharing those GORGEOUS photos!
Shaz Green
Etsuko, once again a beautifully written and sensitive article by a UNIQUE woman.
We are very privileged to have you in our lives and for you to share your stories.
Phyllis Papps
Dear Etsuko san. My goodness! 60 amazing years clocked up! I imagine this COVID-19 lockdown has made your 60th year specially reflective and nostalgic. I wish you all the very best and a wonderful future. Just like the tombo- keep moving forwards! You are a lovely lady and like a muffled temple bell echoing through the dawn, my memory of you stirs me even after all these years..hugs, kisses and respect from Ian xx
Ian Thomason
‘Absolute disgrace’ in 2020
June 19, 2020
We must, never, ever forget Julia Gillard's brilliant speech regarding misogyny, sexism and how men in 'power' use their privilege to dominate and try to silence women.
Phyllis Papps
Heart warming comments, Brett. That humility should be bottled.
Gill Heal
Thank you Brett. Such important comments from a community Leader. They really matter,
Anne Davie
Big-spending budget to kickstart economy
June 19, 2020
Is Cowes Cultural Centre really going to be a totally rectangular tilt slab box? For $20M?
Bernie Mccomb
Thank you Catherine. OK BUT only $130,000 for Affordable Housing Initiative?? And what can you do with $130,000? Some repairs? We need more affordable housing in our area.
Felicia Di Stefano
On a matter of debt and interest. Is the Shire permitted to issue bonds - at the mortgage rate charged by banks? If so, many older people with savings might like to invest in their Shire. Interest from bank deposits is too low for some oldies - and they live on income from savings - a diminishing return.
Peter Brown
Hi Peter, This sounds like a good idea. The Municipal Association of Victoria does have a funding vehicle... Local Government Funding Vehicle for councils to use to borrow funds at cheaper rates than banks. Your thought should be investigated by our Shire Council.
Frank Schooneveldt
Virus diaries 6
June 19, 2020
Excellent Catherine. Library to open this Monday - Hooray! But a big thank you to the Wishart Street book swap, stopped me going stir-crazy. I love Don Watson's writing. I keep his Dictionary of Weasel Words in my bedside cupboard - open it at random often and SO GOOD. The Mahers Landing nonsense unbelievable - Anderson's Inlet is the delta of the Tarwin River - the channels shift with the tides and amount of water flowing from the river. Silly developers could dredge forever and even sillier 'buyers' would find their jetty with water one day. overnight the water has moved over to Point Smythe! Mother Nature has her own agenda - remember the Morwell River diverted for an open-cut coal mine, then the river decide to go back to its original bed - goodbye coal mine. Crazy. Homo Sapiens think they are clever enough to 'tame' nature. Covid 19 could be another weapon in the Planet's armory, We would do well to remember - there is no Planet B. Yvonne McRae
Yvonne McRae
Another good read and I feel I am immersing myself into the life of a stranger as I follow your daily routine through your diaries. I, too have just visited a dear friend who lives in a care home and was devastated to see the downward spiral of her dementia in just nine weeks. She has lost herself and does not understand. Her mind wanders off and she struggles to find the simplest of words. To me this is the highest price of Covid and I hate it. I want her back, but sadly she can’t come.
Janice Orchard
What a smorgasbord of happenings you've gathered Catherine - thank you! Living 20 minutes out of Wonthaggi has made my trips to 'town' diminished to once per week during the lockdown. Other days are slow and relaxed - a wonderful way to wile away 6 days a week! Not that I'm not busy - transforming garden produce to freezer parcels, or to dried fruit jars, planting brassicas and more lettuces and colourful flower pots, knitting a coffee plunger a 'jacket' ... and if course reading - Watson's 'The Bush' is still waiting, which is just as well as the restrictions are back on from Monday. Not sad.
Sue Packham
Catherine, I have been loving the insights of your virus diaries and was amazed to see the poster of Resurrection: Ertuğrul in number 6. I too have been watching the travails of the Turkish Kayi tribe as they are riven by internal factions as well as having to combat the Templars in season one, battle the Mongol invading force led by the Noyen, an enigmatic character constantly shadowed by his drumming shaman in season two, followed by conflict with a fellow Turkish tribe, the Cavdars and Vasiliyus the unlikeable Christian commander of an outpost fortress in season 3. So many enemies; such a long time. I need a break now before tackling season four. Strangely, I have also been reading the Neapolitan novels.
Julie Constable
Councillors can marina plan
June 19, 2020
Thank you to councillors and officers for consigning this astonishingly insensitive proposal to the bin,where it belongs. The landfill bin- not for recycling in the future.
Mark Robertson
The inside story
June 19, 2020
Well done Jane, Nick and Matt, Now you can write your own headlines!
Readers will always go where the best story tellers have the freedom to inform and inspire. Stay true, stay local and the readership will find you.
Geoff Ellis
Good luck Matt and team with your new venture. Will you be covering Yarram as well?
Julie Constable
Great to see this initiative. Please don't allow it to be a vehicle for anyone's personal agendas. If we know news and stories are accurate and informative we will support you.
Neil Rankine
May you succeed Matt and staff. I look forward to reading 'The Paper'. I well remember you remarkable story about community sponsorship of refugees and the lack of it in Australia.
Felicia Di Stefano
Your eloquent Farewell To Print makes me want to read more of you, Matt. If courage is "grace under pressure" (Hemingway), you're not lacking in that department either. Paper is dead. Long live The Paper!
John M Gascoigne
Money, going cheap
June 19, 2020
Bass Shire is full of dirt road suburbs like Jam Jerrup. We are always 3-4 years away from getting the bitumen, drains and pavements. Meanwhile we put up with dust in summer, mud in winter and people and dogs sharing the roads with cars. In the good old days road building was a useful source of projects to increase employment during a recession. So how about clearing that backlog of dirt road suburbs that never get sealed because there is no new subdivision levy to pay for them.
James Glover
The solace of birds IV
June 19, 2020
Patsy, every time I read, listen to, observe, look at your wonderful paintings and read your wonderful stories- I am in total awe.
Phyllis Papps
Thank you, Patsy. What relief from busy computer research to look at lovely bird paintings and read your descriptions. We have visits from almost all the birds you mention but love to watch the little wrens splash in the bird bath as we eat lunch on our sunny deck.
Felicia Di Stefano
Clock ticking on Holden sale
June 12, 2020
A great article, Catherine! It summarizes how local groups and individuals have been working to save the woodlands of the GMH Proving Ground since first alerted to the probability of the site coming on the market. Hopefully, Bass Coast Shire Council will pass motions concerning the Proving Ground next meeting.
Should the Victorian Government buy the Proving Ground, what a chance to set up an almost instant Western Port National Park (working title only)––one starting less than 100 km from Melbourne and taking in reserves stretching along the Bass Highway from Lang Lang to the Corinella turn-off and then to Bass Landing on the Bass River and back along the coast taking in foreshore land to the Lang Lang River. What a gateway to many of Melbourne’s prime tourism areas!
The purchase of the Proving Ground is the key to the establishment of such a park.
Anyone who agrees with the proposal for the State Government to buy the Proving Ground and the reason why should let our Government representatives know immediately. If not, the land could be sold any time behind closed doors to someone else.
Contact the Member for Bass, Jordan Crugnale: Jordan.Crugnale@parliament.vic.gov.au, 9 McBride Avenue, Wonthaggi, VIC 3995 or ph (03) 5672 4755; the Premier, Daniel Andrews, daniel.andrews@parliament.vic.gov.au, and the Minister for Energy, Environment and Climate Change, Lily DÁmbrosio lily.dambrosio@parliament.vic.gov.au.
Meryl Tobin
One of the last areas of its kind . It must be saved .
Rob Wilson
Thank you Catherine for this succinct summary of the situation. I hope many readers will support this campaign by contacting relevant politicians and spread the word to anyone else who might add to the effort. In other times there would have been public meetings to inform the community and share the reasons why protecting this site is so vital. Make your views known anyway you can!
Anne Heath Mennell
This is an excellent summary of the effort that a large number of people and organisations have put in, in order to save this site and it's unique flora and fauna for future generations. The importance of this site from an environmental and ecological view point cannot be overstated. You would think that Bass Coast Council and Victorian State Government, both very vocal in their green ideologies, would have jumped at the chance to take positive action on this matter. I find it interesting that the Bass Council chose to approach the State Government on the issue rather that applying its own protective overlay on the property. It is a mystery to me why the Bass Coast Council did not decide to do both. This would have given some protection and clearly demonstrated council's intent. I would be interested to know whether the council receives rates for the property and if so how much and whether the council receives a royalty for the removal of sand from the site. Also the value of such royalty. I have been following the discussion on this matter and the one thing that stands out is that whenever council's actions are queried those queries are dismissed as being negative and not to be actually answered. It seems to me that it is possible, council decided to take this matter to the State Government knowing there was no chance they would buy the property. This way Council and councilors will be seen to be trying to do the right thing only to be thwarted by the State Government. This way they will be able to point out that Council raised a motion to approach the State Government to buy the property, This motion was supported by all councilors and passed unanimously. Subsequently Council officers and councilors made repeated approaches to the State government with out success. Once the property has been sold, we need to deal with the new owners and reach agreement on usage and protection measures..
Trevor Brown
A break from poverty
June 12, 2020
Saying that Newstart has risen since petrol was 65 cents a litre is not quiet true. Newstart has increased with inflation over time to cover some of the increase in things like the price of petrol.
Peter Bogg
Has It? I am happy to be corrected.
Geoff Ellis
Something very wrong when unemployed people are forced to live on $40 per day.
Julie Tyrrell
I agree - wrong, inhumane, punitive and undoubtedly unChristian! Are you listening PM?
Anne Heath Mennell
Very interesting however, slightly embellished I think. Having been made redundant before retirement age ten years ago, I had to go on Newstart because I was not old enough to claim the Pension. Newstart is not a lot of money but it's not intended to be a substitute for a wage. I applied for at least a dozen jobs in Wonthaggi but the Centrelink officer who interviewed me, placed me with an Employment Agency that would take into consideration the likelihood that I wouldn't be able to get a job, so didn't enforce the interview criteria etc. Slightly frustrating because I really wanted to get a job but realised early on that was not going to happen in Wonthaggi.
Anyway, after a couple of years I was able to claim the Pension which I thought was hard to live on until a fabulous ANZ bank officer showed me how to budget. I still haven't got a lot of spare cash but I don't panic now when bills come in because the money has already been set aside. I cancelled private health cover a couple of years ago and have now gone totally public. Good enough for Paul Keating, so good enough for me. Sure, you have to wait a bit longer for dental but it's not the end of the world.
There is also superannuation, presumably, if the examples in this article are employed or have been employed until recently. Mine was spent long ago to make my little old house liveable but I'm comfortable and can save up for the rest of the refurbishment. My car was recalled by the manufacturer a couple of months ago for airbag issues but was too old to repair. With the money provided (market value) I was able to buy a tricycle, with some leftover for a bottle or two of red! My range has now shrunk but the freedom of not worrying about running a car is amazing not to mention the financial saving. I could sit hear and whinge but, hey, I'm alive and the sun is shining. There is always a rainbow in every situation ... eventually.
"a victim of a heartless scheme of an evil genius in the government to extract money from the poorest people in our society" is a bit over the top and I guess you'll be pleased to hear that the PM has apologised.
I'm gonna have to buy ear muffs soon though .. the wind whistling passed my ears in the morning is getting a bit chilly!
Pamela Jacka
The positive disrupter
June 12, 2020
It is absolutely impossible to define this wonderful, inspirational woman who 'moved the earth' and motivated so many people and especially women.
Kay was, and still is, an absolutely powerful force in politics as well as a wonderful feminist and community activist.
We all salute you for your incredible achievements. !!!
Phyllis Papps
Brilliant nomination and wonderful nominee! Kay you are wonderful and I celebrate this award with you. Our friend Margaret Ray would be proud!
Ian Turnnidge
A new beard and a smiling mind
June 12, 2020
Hi Miriam, You're lucky only to have two single hairs at the moment. I have dozens and my erstwhile fair facial fuzz is turning black and bristly in places. I don't think a beard would suit me so I still remove the worst. Let us know how you go with yours ...
Anne Heath Mennell
Hi Anne, yes, I may change my attitude if the density increases significantly!
Miriam Strickland
Miriam,
another wonderful, thought-provoking and at times an amusing article.
YES- the aging process is not much fun.
BUT one of the advantages is: we don't have to look stunning all the time, we don't need to do anything unless we feel like it. And yes 'The Black Dog' is there lurking in the background...
As for meditation, gym classes, learning how to use Zoom etc. etc. I just choose what I enjoy the most- my garden, my dog, my friends AND my music (because it soothes my soul.)
As for past failings and future fears- I just write about them exactly the way you did. Somehow by writing, it eases our anxieties and fears.
I look forward to reading another one of your articles.
Phyllis Papps
The armchair arts tour 4
June 12, 2020
What fabulous writers we have here in our region !!!!
Combining the brilliant and intriguing art of John Mutsauers, with words and music was very inspirational.
Congratulations to everyone who entered the competition and especially our highly esteemed editor of Bass Coast Post for winning the first prize, Karen Bateman for receiving second prize and Wendy Saphin for third prize.
All the writers who entered the competition have the opportunity to submit an entry for the Bass Coast Prize for Non-fiction 2020. Closing date 4th September. Check the website: https://basscoastprizefornonfiction.weebly.com
Phyllis Papps
Don't be sad Liane. Freedom is having the thought: 'Damn it! I can win this'!
John Coldebella.
Bravo, Catherine! Wonderful writing: humorous, wise, perceptive, layered, offering such breadth of commentary on the human condition through each one of John's paintings. I loved it! Congratulations too to Karen and Wendy for their beautiful essays.
Marg Lynn
Marina project fails on 17 counts
June 12, 2020
Fingers crossed this will be a rare win for the community and common sense!
Anne Heath Mennell
University hub announced
June 1, 2020
This is superb news. Congratulations to all involved! As a former secondary teacher and as a parent whose children had to live away from home to gain their tertiary qualifications, I am very aware how desirable it is to have tertiary educational centres in regional areas.
Meryl Tobin
Great news for our young folk, who by now have had extra practice with remote/online learning, and maybe for some of us elders as well.
Miriam Strickland
Congratulations to everybody involved in this great initiative. A fantastic opportunity for our youth and for those of us who want to return to further their education.
Great news
Frank W Schooneveldt
This is big news and great for the region.
And yes Miriam, I've also been really impressed with how community members of all ages have embraced Zoom technology during the COVID lockdown.
Rev Ian Turnnidge hosts a Zoom conversation after the livestreaming of the Sunday service from St John's. It's absolutely wonderful to see people, some of whom are in their eighties, happily connecting and conversing in Zoomland.
Laura Brearley
Fantastic news with exciting potential for Bass Coast population.
Sandra Peeters
Exciting news, just fabulous! Congrats. to the BC team working during the past year on this initiative. So good for our young (and older) people to be able to live at home and keep in touch with their local community. Also the money aspect of students having to find suitable accommodation in the City and pay their rent (always high) or even part rent ALL the year even when Universities are closed. So good! What a relief to parents etc. who had to find the cash to 'help' out their precious children. Well done everybody. Yvonne McRae
Yvonne McRae
This is good news, but a University that would attract outside students, and similar rural universities elsewhere may give our students that essential experience of the step into independence and adulthood. In England, tertiary students embrace studying outside their area as part of the tertiary experience, even if they have a local regional university in their nearest city.
It will be interesting to see the level of support offered to hub users. As a postgrad who studied from home, with very few on campus experiences, i know the value of rubbing shoulders with other students; that 'increment of association'.
Jennifer Boer
Very exciting news for this community. Well done to the team that brought this initiative to our community.
Samiro Douglas
Congratulations BCP first with the news again. Will be good for children who cannot afford to go to leave home to study as well as all the other benefits mentioned. I know of such a one. She will be very happy.
Felicia Di Stefano
Fantastic, this will provide so much more access especially for those students who do not have good access to the internet too.
Sunny
Congratulations BCP for this great news. How exciting for Wonthaggi and our region at large
This is going to be a great opportunity for upcoming students in our community wishing to go to university. It will also be great as students will have the opportunity to live at home while doing their university studies.
It is great for our community and for the bass coast region.
Nina Debono Wills
Wonderful news! - really worthy of the 'news flash' thanks Catherine for keeping us up to speed so well.
Lee Tierney
This is tremendous news!
David Manning
Wonderful news. I am so glad that this is happening.
Jacqui Paulson
I was the first in my family to go to university, at a time when girls like me didn't always have the support to undertake tertiary study. It was a wonderful experience and my degree has opened doors I would never have known existed. Whilst I agree with Jennifer about the value of leaving home and value the experience of living and learning on campus with other students, any initiatives which reduce barriers to higher education are very welcome. Everyone deserves the opportunity to continue their education, reach their potential and enter careers their parents only dreamed of. Living in the country should not be a barrier, especially with all the online opportunities now available. The next barrier is money. I was only able to go to uni because I qualified for a grant. Now may not be the time but I would like to see fees reduced, especially for students from regional and remote areas. Surely the costs of providing online learning must be less than lectures/seminars/ and facilities to on-campus students.
Well done everyone at BCSC.
Anne Heath Mennell
Fantastic news......for our community, young and the not so young. To be able to study at a tertiary level locally is going to open doors for a lot of people who might otherwise miss out because of distance, finances and the cost of accommodation in the city. Really good news !
Gillian Armstrong
Fantastic news for the whole area!
Peter Efthymiou
This is very exciting, might even go back to uni myself. Congratulations BCSC.
John Mutsaers
This is such a fantastic outcome for our community. Very proud of our shire for leading this project.
Nina Barry-Macaulay
I can imagine Wonthaggi as a University City. Next it'll have a world famous 'how to chill' festival, and continue to be a cooperative initiative - the soul of Wony.
Julie-Anne Trease
Just wonderful news. Best wishes to all involved.
Natasha Williams
This is such fantastic news! great work BCSC.
Amy Easton, Secretary Wonthaggi Business & Tourism Association
Excellent news and congratulations to BCSC.
Ursula Theinert
This is great news! It will hopefully engage more young people in their education, with the prospect of being able to keep their connections to family and friends and achieve their goals without moving away.
Rhonda De Stefano
A work in progress
May 29, 2020
Thanks for this personal insight Pamela - a piece including much common sense. I too hope: “perhaps we will also gain a greater sense of community and willingness to support those in need without judgement, because who knows what tomorrow brings and when we, ourselves, may be that person in need.”
What a well organised desk you have. It’s got me looking at mine....
Natasha Crestani
Pam, another fantastic article. So meaningful, so enlightening. Because you and Judy are, and have always been such great inspirations.
Love from all of us at Rhyll AND the rest of the community.
Phyllis Papps
Excellent article Pamela, once we all start to realise that goods & services should last, be effective and not harm our environment, and ideally be produced in Australia we will realise we don't need to work five days a week to consume junk, whether consumables, media, services that could be delivered at the local level, etc. We don't need overseas holidays if we take the time to appreciate the environment right here in Bass Coast. Life can be a lot simpler and more enjoyable. I can remember 40 odd years ago a teacher telling us we would soon be working only four days a week, with technology improvements, how did we complicate things so much? Perhaps the time has come though.
Neil Rankine
Congratulations to Pam for questioning old ways of working. The five-day working week is drudgery for most people. When I reduced my working week from five to four and then three days (with a pro rata drop in pay, of course), I started to enjoy work again. I’m sure I was much more productive and much more creative.
The COVID crisis has started the conversation we need to have about work: a four-day working week, staggered working hours, remote working, at least some of the time …
Pam writes of the lockdown: ”New business opportunities opened up as staff developed creative and innovative ways to diminish the possible isolation”.
Good managers foster ideas and creativity in their staff. The happiest and most productive workplaces are those where workers have a high degree of autonomy. They know what they have to do but it’s up to them how they do it, and it can apply to anyone from a truck driver to a solicitor. Autonomy fosters a sense of ownership of the job and pride in the work. It also lifts productivity, which the PM keeps telling us is the necessary precursor for higher wages.
Several friends who’ve been working from home have commented on how much more productive they are at home. One found she could do all her work in the morning. She wonders whether she will return to the distractions and obligations of office life, including those interminable meetings about nothing in particular.
It’s not for everyone, of course. Some people have complicated home lives. Others enjoy the convivial atmosphere of a workplace. And of course we’re really only talking about office workers, not the bulk of Bass Coast workers.
Then there’s the debate about casualisation and job insecurity, but that’s for another time.
Catherine Watson
Get ready for action
May 29, 2020
It is good to see the positive notes from Mayor Tessari and to see that he is embracing remote meetings and conferencing. It is also encouraging that councilors and the council are actively seeking state and federal funding for all sorts of projects designed to stimulate the local Bass Community economy. However it is disappointing that there does not seem to be any attempt to obtain funding to complete the welter of internal roads that have never been sealed. This despite several strategy plans for the San Remo, Newhaven area that, although approved by council many years ago, are still waiting to be actioned. Funding for these types of projects would provide several jobs, which is in line with the general thrust of the article by Mayor Tessari. Comments from the Premier have indicated that this type of infrastructure would be advantageous and greatly assist in the state's recovery. Also in terms of value this would not require tens of millions of dollars, the residents affected would, I am sure, be prepared to contribute and the tourists and locals alike would have the use of safe access into the relative townships. Which, especially in San Remo, is something lacking at the moment. Mayor Tessari rightly points out that tourism is the major driver of our economy and any action that is able to be taken to enrich and enhance everyone's experience would be helpful. So how about spending some funds on the safety of tourists and residents. This may not be as visual, as print worthy and something that you can say look at what we have done as would a new Skate Park, a new Cultural Center or a new Tourist Information Center but, in my opinion much more important.
Trevor Brown
I agree with you Trevor. We have a huge backlog of infrastructure structure works in the Bass Coast that needs to be fixed especially the roads and footpaths. Here in the Bass Coast we have a very strong Balance Sheet that we need to gear to tackle the infrastructure issues.
I am sure that if we were to borrow some money and ask the state and federal government to match our borrowings we could fix the infrastructure issues and create jobs.
Frank W Schooneveldt
COVID-19 has shown up Bass Coast's heavy reliance on the Tourism and Hospitality industry. Too many eggs in one basket! Brett, your comments about new opportunities and working from home should prompt thinking in Council about strategies to encourage new industries to grow in our region.
Wonthaggi is projected to grow strongly over the next decade. What are the jobs being developed? More B&Bs and cafes? More Construction - to build the houses but then what?
'Knowledge industries' include businesses that can take advantage of the NBN and our relative proximity to Melbourne, enabling workers (and their families) to live and work in our beautiful environment (see Pamela Rothfield's article in this editon).
Now is the the time to be building on the capabilities we've developed during the Lockdown, to diversify the Bass Coast economy.
Maddy Harford
Maddy, I agree with you it's the whole country that needs to re think its approach to what businesses we run, Victoria especially was the manufacturing base for Australia with highly skilled work force, the last few months have shown we can't continue as an economy that just buys things from rest of the world, stores and delivers them. In Wonthaggi years ago there was manufacturing all disappeared to be replaced by shops selling mainly imported goods. Now retail shopping is also struggling to survive, in this fast changing world we need to be smarter and no reason while areas like Wonthaggi can't be part of the revival. Tourism is certainly still a very important part of our economy on Bass Coast and hopefully the Council can be part of the solution to get the economy going, as Trevor Brown and Frank Schooneveldt mention in their comments.
Chris Day
Last gasp for Jam Jerrup
May 29, 2020
Congratulations Tony on your success. We were down there last weekend checking the birdlife at Stockyard Point and was surprised at the ongoing destruction of the cliffs/beach. What struck me was the lack of Mangroves. We passed a healthy stand on the walk to Stockyard Point and wondered why they were not growing in front of the houses or cliffs. I would have thought that planting them in front of the houses would be a cheap and effective way of stopping/minimising the erosion.
Peter Bogg
The Cyan Way
May 29, 2020
very interesting and great insight the science is there and evidence
George V
Excellent concept. Its time to rejuvenate and protect what is left of our precious wetland environments. Jump on this opportunity and invest in a new market which has multiple benefits to all stakeholders and our fragile coastal environment.
Muddy Feet
Country comes alive
May 29, 2020
Dr Laurie Brearley and Terry Malvin have created a beautiful film with underlying tones and feelings that expresses and involves the viewer in a small insight into the culture and understanding of the Boon Wurrung
Thank you for the journey
Ian Samuel
Thank you Laura and Terry for this amazing video of Kugerungmome. A special walking place for me as well.
Margaret Lee
Thanks for your comments.
I'm discovering that Kugerungmome (Powlett River) is a special place for quite a few of our community members, including our much loved Bass Coast Post Editor, Catherine Watson.
Laura Brearley
Wonderful !! Thanks
Michael Nugent
thank you - beautiful images, sounds and words!
Ann Taket
Beautiful!
Marian Quigley
One of my favourite places and made more special by Terry's video and Laura's research and beautiful writing. 'm delighted to learn this new Boonwurrung word Kugerungmome. Language is our way into reconciliation. I look forward to the day when we greet our friends with "Womenjika!".
Catherine Watson
Virus Diaries 5
May 29, 2020 –
Another brilliant and insightful article. Lots of hugs (social distancing of course) and hope Matilda can cope with three legs/arms. !!!!!
Phyllis Papps
Loved it, made me smile and of course reflect. Hoping Matilda makes a speedy recovery
Michelle Graham
Thank you so much,Catherine, for your newsy and entertaining pieces. Zoom, Skype and especially the Bass CoastPost have really helped to connect us in isolation... as well as, of course, wonderful friends and neighbours here on Phillip Island and nearby towns. Let's
see what happens now, and Thankyou!
Carolyn Goldberg
Fruit of the gods
May 29, 2020
Thanks for these ideas. I've just dealt with our copious fig crop for this year - eating fresh, fig jams - with apple or ginger, fig paste, and fig spread.
Have printed and will keep these recipes in mind for 2021.
Elizabeth Hickey
Our 100 year old fig is still going strong and I was delighted with the jam we made using cassia bark and stirring in lemon peel. An added bonus - the lemon peel which is removed from the jam before bottling is to die for. Steeped in the fig and cassia bark flavour it is a perfect accompaniment to blue cheese.
Liane Arno
Grebe $m community 0
May 15, 2020
Thank you, Peter, for attending, and for reporting, however depressing.
Nalin
Reading Peter's account of his involvement in the VCAT process certainly struck.a chord with me. I was President of a group called Friends of Skeleton Hill (North East Victoria) some years ago that opposed an application from a mining giant to turn said hill into a quarry. I have to say that from the moment the VCAT hearing began, which ran for something like two weeks, I knew in my heart that ours was a lost cause. The Shire in question had rejected the planning application, but as was apparently the case here, just didn't have the financial resources to match those of the applicant. They were paying a senior counsel $14,000 each day, plus whatever his bevy of underlings and expert witnesses were costing them. It was very obvious that the VCAT panel and the applicants senior counsel were on very good terms with each other, which certainly didn't fill me with any great sense of hope. Needless to say, the developer won the battle, and like Peter, I doubt if I would ever bother to front VCAT again, no matter how passionate I felt about the issue at hand. My estimate is that the quarry company probably spent over $500,000 arguing their case at VCAT, we managed to raise $20,000 from our tiny community to help put our case to VCAT, and that was probably the difference in the end.
Graeme Charles
HUGE thank you to Peter and his stalwart band who attended VCAT. Little people who live next to or near a proposed development and objected (30+) are pushing the proverbial uphill, compared to the $m's available to Planning Mafia, consultants, 'expert' witnesses, blah blah. Council are in a bind also - how much ratepayer monies do they spend on legal eagles and others. It has cost the developer huge money to fight for 4 years. There is still the million for infrastructure before the 83 lots can be paced out. Then will people want to live next to the Transfer Station and Dog Pound, and the cemetery. Over the many years I have lived here I have planted thousands of trees, shrubbery etc. for massive shelter belts and wind breaks. The developers want to make sure they show prospective buyers around on calm, sunny days, otherwise the Southerly blusters will push them over to North Wonthaggi! Cheers, Yvonne
Yvonne McRae
Thank you Peter, and your band of committed community members, who tried to oppose this development. Disappointing result, particularly when we are always told, particularly lately, that we live in a democracy. Sometimes, you cannot help but wonder .....
Joy Button
Thank you Peter and supporters for trying and for telling us about the process. At least you managed to delay the development so that's something. I heard a zoom discussion among several lawyers recently. There was Julian Burnside, Jess Taylor and a couple more. Among other issues, the group decided that the law and justice are not connected.
Felicia Di Stefano
Thanks Peter for the report. There is no justice when a developer can withhold documentation to stop the council from making a decision, thus forcing a hearing at VCAT.
In my experience, VCAT favours development but in the 5 times I have attended hearings, I have been successful if my objections are within the ResCode. Other objections are not considered.
The continual increase in Australia's population means more of the areas you tried to preserve will be sacrificed on the alter of 'Big Australia'.
Peter Bogg
Thank you Peter Mckenzie for writing up the VCAT response. It is
discourging for people who put in hours of volunteer work weekly on the
Rifle Range site.The loop holes developers have in process is disturbing
in our democracy. We were all so tired as three and a half years was a long battle. I want to give up but the new issues as outlined by Peter are important so we go again.
It is important to read the VCAT documents on cases as I have noted in the other press lately their account differs from the fact.
Beth Banks
Thanks Peter for this insightful analysis and also, very useful advice for how the Cape Paterson development proceeds. The lack of detail in developers' plans is something that is clear in the Cape Pat scenario too.
Leticia
i have to agree with Peter - The VCAT process is arduous and defeating. The fight to stop the 250 caravan site behind Forest Caves is entering its 4th year at VCAT.
As a local resident VCAT now asks me to pay to attend and receive information, it starts at $20.00 and I wonder where it will stop.
Building on a swamp, one sandhill from an unpatroled beach, a new entrance onto Phillip Isalnd Road, no amenities at all, scary stuff will it join the airport development at cape woolamai ? That makes makes a bit more sense as it abuts housing development already.
Nerida Melsmith
Thanks Peter for your article, and especially to you, Dave, Beth (and anyone else?) for putting up a good fight in VCAT. We appreciate all the hard work that went into it, and hope the community can be active and vocal about opposing the Maher's Landing development proposal, and saving the GMH Proving Ground as a public reserve.
Alison Brewster
Thanks for the memories
May 15, 2020
Ed, the real estate, restaurant & travel (albeit two double-sided pages only) were in the Weekend Australian.
Listening to all the comments about coping during the pandemic, I wonder if we would be better off if we managed instead? Coping is a negative word, whereas managing has much more of a control sound, don't you think?
Pamela Jacka
Thanks for your thoughtful piece of writing Ed.
Your son is lucky to have such an actively engaged Dad.
Your family is lucky to be eating home-made sourdough bread.
And we are lucky to have you articulate some of the details and richness of your lockdown experience.
It may look like a 'small life' from the outside but your thinking is expansive. I really enjoyed your seamless weaving together of thoughts about cruise ships, empathy for people in the London blitz and the marvels of comparative rainfall analysis.
Keep writing. You have a gift.
Laura Brearley
Great to see how you've settled into life in Inverloch Ed....and now your boy is 12, how quickly time passes.With all good wishes, Bob
Bob Sharples
Simply the best locked-down story I’ve read, Ed — bright and breezy sweeping confinement from its foundations!
John Gascoigne
Great article Ed but what about the environmental gem you care for which fills you with joy and gains so much respect from people like me.
Daryl Hook
When blood turns bad
May 15, 2020
Hopeful in so may ways. Great story, Mark.
Gill Heal
What a great story of courage & tenacity Mark. Congratulations to you & the Wonthaggi medical team.
Marie Broussard
Happy to read that you need not go to Melbourne for "a twenty minute" treatment anymore Mark and thank you for an up to date report on the BCH cancer treatment unit. Good to have so much support from local community at a difficult time in your life.
Felicia Di Stefano
Hi Felecia, the treatments take a bit longer than 20 minutes - 12 hours of infusions spread over 2 days. This meant 2 nights stay in Melbourne. Now I can be back home and resting, so much better for
my soul.
Mark Robertson
Thanks so much for sharing this, Mark.
Nicky Miller
Down to earth
May 15, 2020 –
This is wonderful Liz. I'm intrigued by reclining trees as well, including those that re-sprout, pushing branches vertically once again. And your childhood memoir is enchanting. Thank you!
Miriam Strickland
Liz, you always write with great feeling and sensitivity about nature - trees, birds and your personal experiences connecting with nature. Check out the website for Bass Coast Prize for Non-fiction 2020.
Phyllis Papps
Brave new world
May 15, 2020
Interesting article. Come join our art group. The Isolated Penguins. We have an article in this edition of the Bass Coast Post as well
The-art-of-isolation. We a group of artists making art on these themes. We began at the beginning of this pandemic. In the article is a link to our Facebook page. Or simply search The Isolated Penguins
Baden Johnson
Well said Frank, What better way to spend recovery dollars than deal with climate change, thus; employing people, improving and cleaning what we're doing on/to this planet and respecting others and their positions. Ain't it great when cleaners and nurses are valued. Ain't it great that we're finally listening to scientists again. Should all fall in to place if we just stop and have a think along the way.
Neil Rankine
The solace of birds III
May 15, 2020
A beautiful story but one that is common to many districts - disappearing native species - birds and mammals - forced out by homo sapiens. Patsy I have had Grey Shrike Thrushes at my home on the outskirts of Wonthaggi township for many years. If I sit out on my deck in the sunshine invariably one (or two) come and sit on the railings - they sing to me and I do a fair impression of their song back (even if I do say so myself). I usually give them a tiny bit of cheese and they like this. Keep up your good work. My whole acre of trees, shrubbery and gardens are a haven for birds. I have compiled a list over the years and have identifies hundreds. This is why I regularly set cat traps (and catch them - BC By-laws officers remove same). My place is for BIRDS and Mammals and reptiles - not a smorgasbord for cats. Take care, Yvonne
Yvonne McRae
Good on you Yvonne.
Neil Rankine
Patsy, another beautifully written and illustrated article- so sensitive, so natural. I look forward to reading parts IV, V, VI etc.
As for traps of any kind, I totally object. There must be other ways that selfish cat owners can be educated or penalized regarding the importance of preserving our wildlife and environment. The other alternative is that they go back to suburbia.
Phyllis Papps
Literary flame still burns in Bass Coast
May 1, 2020
Well done Phyllis for encouraging local writers again, and thank you to Catherine and Geoff for generously supporting this initiative.
Lorrie Read
Thank you, Phyllis, for your incredible generosity in every sense. Your contribution to our community is immense. And thank you Catherine and Geoff for all the amazing and hard work you put into this project.
Sue Saliba
Thank you Catherine (Bass Coast Post) and Geoff (Waterline News) and all our wonderful supporters and writers in the Gippsland region.
We hope the Bass Coast Prize for Non-fiction 2020 will attract more entries this year and we definitely want to encourage and support non-fiction writers.
Just check the website: https://basscoastprizefornonfiction.weebly.com.
Phyllis Papps
Gotta run
May 1, 2020
A wonderful read and very timely share Etsuko. Thank you for sharing the joys of life when you slow down and when you run. A dichotomy many of us are facing in our lives either literally or figuratively.
Shaz Green
I love the way you write Etsuko. From the heart, and in this case, about the heart :-)
Tony O'Connell
Etsuko, I am so happy for you, that your health is all good!
I look forward to the day we can all get back in to Park Run and see so many happy faces, enjoying our beautiful region.
Lyn Harris
Etsuko- you are so honest and generous in your writing - that story is all the more powerful because of that - thank-you. This time makes us pause and face our mortality - you've shown a way to make that a good thing.
Kathy Hill
Etsuko, une piece tres incitative; nous rappelant que chaque jour nous devons apprendre de ce que la vie nous donne.
Helen Patterson
Bonsoir Etsuko, Je suis vraiment contente que votre joli coeur soit en parfaite condition!
Et je suis d’accord avec Helen.
C’est dommage que ce soit seulement après avoir surmonté des moments difficiles dans la vie, que la plupart des gens réalisent que les plaisirs de la vie se trouvent dans les choses et les moments les plus simples. Je vous admire!
Bernadette
With a smile I read the end of your story.
I really enjoy your writing and am so pleased that your heart is happy to run.
Enjoy it Etsuko and also life in general
Keep writing, not in stress, in passion.
Verena
Open for business
May 1, 2020
Good for all those businesses. Keep safe. BUT I am bursting for the Library to again be open. I have read all I had, many my daughter brought up from Melbourne, re-read books from years ago, (now on The Transit of Venus), but am really hanging out for an open Library.- go away Covid-19 you have outstayed your welcome. Cheers to all, Yvonne McRae
Yvonne McRae
I agree, Yvonne. Surely if the state govt is thinking of re-opening the Casino and pubs it will allow Libraries to open? They are so much more than just books ...
Anne Heath Mennell
Too close to home
May 1, 2020
Love it, 'Jennifer'. yes, Gratitude, or the need to express it, is a life-saver but we have to get real at the same time. People like you (and my daughters) working and home schooling at the same time, are the heroes who are making the government policies actually work! We won't forget it!
Jillian Durance
Bob Smith and Wonthaggi
May 1, 2020
Thank you Wendy for your commitment in securing this magnificent Collection for Wonthaggi. In the years to come it will be acknowledged as a great gift to the people of the Bass Coast Shire.
Anne Davie
Thanks Catherine for keeping this in our span. Thank you Wendy for bringing Bob Smith and his amazing gift to us. It’s hard to realise the enormity of the Robert Smith collection.
John Mutsaers
What a fantastic legacy Bob leaves - let's hope that the Arts precinct gets off the ground. Bass Coast is so much more than sun and surf!
Pete Muskens
Sorry to hear that Bob has passed on. It’s a tremendous legacy and proof that even in your last years you can really make a difference to the community.
Edward Buckingham
Virus diaries 4
May 1, 2020
You are so funny and clever, Catherine, capturing a little of all our experiences in your gorgeous musings. Thank you.
Margaret
About fab; a really great read, thks Catherine.
Michael Nugent
Catherine many of us can relate to your experiences. The Post has been a welcome 'read' in these lockdown times. Cannot wait to drive through Wishart Street - hope there are couple of books still there. (I have 2 to leave for 'other' people). My daughter escaped to Wonthaggi once Melbourne became unbearable. She has found clearing up around my garden (1 acre) never is finished. All the blown down bark, twigs etc. collected and then along comes the next 'blow'. Keep well everyone and there will be a 'light at the end of the tunnel' just hope it isn't another train coming in ! Roll on Library OPEN please. Cheers, Yvonne
Yvonne Mcrae
Thank you Catherine, I'm really enjoying your Virus Diaries good for a lol and a gratitude check in.
Susan Fowler
Cathrine thank you for an interesting read and insight into different experiences of COVID-19
Robyn Smith
The reading goddesses are smiling on the good people in Wishart Street. Something to READ thank you. Yvonne
Yvonne McRae
Loved your writing. I can hear your voice and its inflections as I read. Very relaxing and sane.
Judy Soerink
Thank you Catherine. I'm loving your diary observations. The daily oddities and normalities. The contrasts with the experiences of friends in other lands. I left a bag of books for a neighbour in the letter box this week. She left me eggs. cheers Julie
Julie Constable
Constant reader
May 3, 2020
Dear Catherine,
I am no longer a resident of the Bass Coast but have many wonderful memories of the people and the landscape. Over the last couple of years i have continued to read the Post and have always found it such an interesting and enjoyable read.
The latest edition has been my favourite, so many wonderful stories written by such talented community members.
Virginia Stelzer, Jan Juc
Fast forward to 2022
April 17, 2020
Mikhaela, what a wonderful vision you have. I applaud your enthusiasm, passion and creative thinking and sincerely hope that we witness your vision coming to fruition in the future.
Pamela Rothfield
Thank you, Mikhaela! Just what we need in these dark times. I don't think it's a pipe-dream at all. Everything you've imagined is feasible and you provide a wonderful vision for us to aim at. Keep spreading the word - we'll need all the support we can muster to make this vision a reality. Onward ...
Anne Heath Mennell
What marvelous imagination and vision you have. It must come to fruition, I and I am sure many others applaud and support you. What can I do to help? Congrats and thank you.
Pauline Taylor
What a beautiful vision! Thank you for the positivity.
Nalin
Thank you Mikhaela. Yes we will dare to dream.
Anne Davie
Brilliant Mikhaela! You’ve mapped out a truly tangible vision.
Linda Cuttriss
Thank you Mikhaela. It really is a beautiful vision - even if half of it comes trues - it will be of enormous benefit.
Joan Woods
Congratulations Mikhaela! a very thoughtful and thought provoking piece. It is a vision that is comprehensive, creative yet doable. It's a wonderful goal for our comunity to work towards.
Maddy Harford
Congratulations for having the tenacity to pursue your vision for the GMH Proving Ground at Lang Lang and present a scenario post the Coronavirus pandemic, Mikhaela.
Though you outline in some detail your vision for the developed section of the site for active community recreation, I'd like to see more detail given concerning the protection of the natural environment. I see this as the major concern - how best to preserve and pass on a priceless heritage to future generations. That's why my vision is for the GMH site to be declared a national park with consideration given to community use for the developed section.
Meryl Tobin
Crises I have known
April 17, 2020
Human beings have an amazing capacity to adapt and work with change. Thank you for sharing these inspiring stories. When we return to work, business, play and life - we will do it in an adapted way, think outside the box, and we will do it together - whether we ever have a vaccination or not.
Natasha
Why do we continue to ignore these forgotten memories from our Grandmothers & Grandfathers? Mostly Grandmothers? 💖
Kim Veness
Hello Kim, by virtue of the fact that this article has been printed, it seems clear to me that we do not ignore these memories. As a member of a district historical group, I can assure you those memories are being recorded and are available for everyone to see. Check out your local historical groups when all this is over and you will be pleasantly surprised.
Pamela
Thanks Eulalie your memories made excellent reading .The bit about Post Office on the front verandah reminded me that Margaret’s grandmother ran the Pound Creek post office from her verandah? We even have a photo to prove it. Cheers Daryl
Daryl Hook
Thanks Eulalie, it is a great reminder to those of thus that until now have led a life free of these types of events. My mother was in London in WWII and tells me about how she was evacuated to the countryside where she enjoyed freedoms that she would not have had in London.
Wendy Davies
When I was 10yo the threat of a 3rd world war was areal fear due to the Cuba crisis . Never forgot those few weeks. So my point is how much it affects the children during all of this.
We have had it easy compared with our parents. I appreciate the article written by Eulie Brewster
Rosemary Loughnan
I so enjoyed reading your article Eualie. Polio still left its mark when I was at school in the 50's.The sister of a friend spent her days on an elevated bed with huge bicycle wheels and others had calipers on their legs. Alan Marshall came to Hampton High school when I was in Year 7 to talk about his childhood after writing " I Can Jump Puddles"
The epidemic I can recall was Scarlet Fever. The hospitals were so overcrowded that because my case was relatively mild I stayed at home in isolation. A barrier across the bedroom door so my younger brother and sister couldn't come in and ihad daily visits from a doctor. He gave me horrible huge injections for the first week then revolting tablets to suck. Imagine mum's horror when she found I was hiding them under the pillow!! I think I was about 8 at the time and books and coloring were about my only entertainment.
Didn't Hampton High School see some changes. We were in church halls and portable classrooms at Hampton State school down the road to start our secondary education. There'd been a fire in the main building. Later that basketball court was again sacrificed for a school Hall and now it's just a housing development.
Now isolation give more time for reflection and enjoying the garden and local environment.
Carole Johnston
Ninety-three years bring a lot of memories. Thank you, Eulalie. The Scouts’ motto “Be prepared” produced an air raid shelter in our backyard during World War 2, but my mum famously filled it in after scooping out one too many drowned hedgehogs. In the 1950s, the motto also had us sent home from primary school after any big earthquake. Then, from our dad’s tool shed roof in the backyard, my brothers and I would peer over our neighbours’ hedge, prepared for the ‘tidal wave’ we’d been warned about. This was, after all, in Blenheim, near Cook Strait in the Shaky Isles. The wave, which, disappointingly to my overactive mind, never arrived, would have been in fact a tsunami, a word that came to (un)popular use decades later.
John Gascoigne
Virus diaries 3
April 17, 2020
The Wonthaggi Food Collective has wholemeal flour in stock.
Jessica Harrison
Thank you for a very funny summary of your week in Wonthaggi .... loved it. With regard to your beer loaf ..... you may have overworked the dough when mixing and perhaps try 'resting' the dough in the tin for five minutes to allow the gluten in the flour to develop. Regarding wholemeal flour .... an alternative could be to put some rolled oats through a food processor for a little bit and add to plain flour? May not be like the real deal but could be a compromise. Happy baking and good luck ..... I literally have banana bread waiting to come out of my oven as I type. Fingers crossed.
Joy Button
Catherine I am in awe of how you have captured life as it is for now and have become aware of the subtle changes in mood as time in isolation leaves it mark.
As someone who was already in retirement before the s#!t hit the proverbial fan, I must confess to not feeling too much of a strain other than the curtailment of my very busy social life. While I have reveled in time painting in my studio, pottering in the veggie patch and cooking endless batches of scones, I have been guilty of saying "this is not too bad".
But now I am aware of the extreme hardships this isolation is causing for others confined with small children, juggling working from home and home schooling. And then there are women stuck in situations of domestic abuse who must feel so very alone. While I have been counting my blessings others have been counting the days until they can escape difficult conditions.
Shame on me for enjoying the comfort of my own bubble.
Janice Orchard
I think the hardest thing for me to come to grips with is the hardship suffered by the homeless. They are moved on relentlessly by the police who monitor the campsites, the beaches and the rivers. They get told to go home. But where is home for them?
Liane Arno
Catherine, you made me laugh out loud and nod in recognition many times. Thank you. Our comic relief has been to begin a small bbq shed project with my husband despairing of a woman who doesn’t want all right angles and regular shapes. Grand Designs has a lot to answer for, he wails!!! Stay well 😊
Jeannie Haughton
I wondered why sewers would be called hearties but then I realised it wasn't the type of sewer that the s**t runs down!
My 22 year old car was recalled about a month ago, perhaps longer, and after waiting a couple of weeks, I became the proud owner of a 7-speed/battery powered (for the hills) tricycle. Therefore, I say, what virus?! I'm too busy ringing the bell and warning people that there's a "learnatic" on the paths! Plus I'm an "essential service" for a local not-for-profit group whose emails I check twice weekly which keeps me relatively sane. I'm looking forward to what Australia is going to be like when it's all over. I'm feeling quite positive.
Pamela Jacka
Such a great piece of writing! Captured this period perfectly. Lovely.
Nalin
I read every day about the words and deeds of Morrison, Trump, Frydenberg and Pence. Then I switch on to Coast Post and learn what Etsuko, Simon, Jill, D, Linda and Cate have been up to. Only one group is vibrant and real to me. It's not the first one.
John Gascoigne
If you can make people laugh out loud at themselves and the situation they're in, you're doing a great job, Catherine. Many thanks to you for your Virus Diaries which I look forward to each issue. Apart from the laughs, they are very informative of what is going on in our society.
Meryl Tobin
A time to spend
April 17, 2020
Well said Michael. This crisis sucks but we might as well use it to build a better future.
Lars Olsen
"But the time will come – hopefully soon – when the focus will shift to stimulus and investment in projects that create jobs.."
Yes! Hope and looking for the positive is the way forward.
Natasha
I congratulate the Council on its decision to proceed with the Redevelopment of the Cowes Cultural Centre. In the years to come we will reflect that the Centre was achieved at a challenging time, because the Council of the day believed that community empowerment is an investment in its future.
Anne Davie
Great news! It is also known that the plans put in place by Roosevelt also had loop holes which have led to the present unequal situation the world faces today.
Make it watertight please.
Joan Woods
Hi Joan. In 2017 Yunus stated that eight individuals now own more wealth than 50 per cent of the global population. That continues to concentrate I suspect and wealth has a way of aggregating especially in tough times. He suggests another way in 'A World of Three Zeroes" but I am not optimistic. Trickle down is a cruel joke it is at least a Trickle Up and mostly a flow. A complimentary way is suggested by Rifkin in 'The Third Industrial Revolution." Decentralised production of eg energy and goods similar perhaps to the commons approach.
Michael Whelan
Just dropped in
April 17, 2020
We have mesh wrapped around our metal chimney which touch wood keeps starlings out.Something about the smell tells starlings that a hollow tree is right here.Like you Maddy they already think it's spring and time to look for a nesting site.Why oh why did early settlers bring rats mice and starlings.PS and us.
Daryl Hook
Had the same trouble Maddy, though not with starlings. I tried mesh around the flue, but that sooted up and stopped the fire drawing properly. It was also a bit of a hazard. Finally got a chimney man to replace with a bird-proof cap.
Tony Norquay
Happy to read that you are finding interesting and diverse ways to occupy your down time Maddy, as well as keeping your brain active solving the problem of the best way to evict a starling out of a house. You may acquire new skills and be an expert in a new field. Then you'll be the one thanking the starlings.
Felicia Di Stefano
Maddy, I laughed out loud. The matador image was delightful, is your tea towel red? When I was a child brush tailed possums used to get down the chimney into the wood heater - Mum and Dad would do as you have described to allow the possums their freedom.
Wendy Davies
Solace of birds, II
April 17, 2020
Patsy, another most enjoyable article about the birds in your garden. Your observation and understanding of birds is excellent, as is the wonderful way you describe each bird species and how much they love your very natural garden.
Your paintings add such a beautiful visual element to what you have written.
Also I should add that your passion for bird-life, nature, conservation and the environment is truly appreciated by so many people in the community.
I look forward to 'The solace of birds III' and hopefully one day soon you may decide to publish a book.
Phyllis Papps
Thank you, Patsy. Whenever I see beautiful illustrations like yours I brace myself for the dry-as-birdseed text by the writer’s ornithological collaborator. At the end of my reading just now, I felt as though I'd had the full Leunig experience -- creatures reflecting the best of humanity back at us. Boy, do we need both of you now!
John Gascoigne
Council's $1m support package
It is good to see the Shire looking after its own. Sometimes the future needs to remain in the future while the present is taken care of. It's the old saying - We can make plans but life happens.
Joan Woods
Open all hours
April 19, 2020
Well done Catherine Watson. A wonderful initiative and generous gesture. I hope that you receive lots of responses.
Rob Parsons
Beaches closed for Easter
April 7, 2020
Once again the majority of good abiding citizens are punished with draconian laws for the few that will disregard any restrictions that don't suite their selfish and narcissistic nature.
Why not empower the good people of Bass Coast with the maturity and respect they deserve in confronting and shaming those that may do the wrong thing.
The current system is working well and there is no reason why it can't continue to.
Lou Pecora
Punished or protected? Sadly, the system isn't working and a vigilante confrontational shaming system is doomed to fail. Too many people have been flouting covid19 protocols and they have ruined it for everyone. Our hospital system is not designed to cope with a huge influx so the advice is STAY HOME and stay safe. That's why the beaches are closed.
Geoff Ellis
I think people's health is much more important than a fun gamble on one of our beautiful beaches. That would include everyone's health in our area and beyond. Authorities are doing their best to keep us all as safe as possible. We must acknowledge their efforts - by staying away from beaches and making the most of our own homes and properties.
Sue Packham
I'm disappointed to see that the general public are being encouraged to act as pseudo police. Very dangerous and, dare I say, "unAustralian" (which is not a real word but ...). Think how nice and clean (no foot prints, etc.) the beaches will be after Easter when all the locals can return to their usual pursuits. It's only for a few days, so let's not fret too much. Just don't dob people in. If you're there to see them, perhaps you are also flouting the rules? Let those employed to do the job, do the job.
Pamela Jacka
Thank you and hopefully there will be a large sign put the at entrance to San Remo and at the Bridge between San Remo and Phillip Island
Judy Rogers
Hooray! Well done, let’s hope people abide by the regulations.
Lynda M Hanlon
Meaning? The beaches at Inverloch have had signs up for days saying they are closed, but we have been allowed to swim and walk; just no sitting. Please explain. 😊
Peter Ghys
Peter, I think this is the "Beaches Really Closed" moment. The earlier signs were designed to deter city people but these are the real deal. No one is permitted to go on the beaches. I gather it will be policed.
They are assuring us it is just for Easter so we must be vigilant.
Catherine Watson
Beaches - is this legal? The Victorian government hasn't stipulated this - many other beaches are open. A week ago there were about 6 people on a 2km stretch of beach, with no threat of encroaching on each other as we walked along and tried to clear our minds whilst excising.
I understand that people are worried about Wonthaggi hospital's ability to cope, but it's getting confused with holiday home owners.
If holiday home owners come down (for example to secure their homes, since we may not be able to do this for many months) we are in no way impacting on local hospitals due to COVID-19. As the article itself puts it, Wonthaggi hospital doesn't offer the services. We would rather return to Melbourne for health services. We are not making the situation worse locally.
I don't want to fixate on hospitals, but most local comments seem to be about concern for Wonthaggi to cope. Lets follow this through for a moment - if we aren't welcome at our own local hospitals in Bass Coast, should Melbourne residents welcome permanent Bass Coast residents to Melbourne hospitals? Didn't think you'd like that idea.
We have no intention to interact with the local community under these circumstances (but normally we would love to interact and support!).
So many issues here, just saying that we should be permitted to secure our properties and get out.
Please try to be considered and understanding in your responses. We LOVE Bass Coast and identify with it very strongly. Would love to be retired there already, but need to earn some more money to enable that in the city :-)
Georgina Day
The Chief Health Officer, the Victoria Police Deputy Commissioner and Dan Andrews himself have all said holiday home owners staying in their homes should be manageable, provided they follow the rules whilst there. They have also said that holiday home owners (and long term renters) will not be fined for travelling between their properties.
Georgina Day
I suppose this means we can all spend time mingling in the safety of Bunnings ,et al, Seriously, for someone like me with very low immunity a quiet beach and some fresh air is probably the safest place.
Mark Robertson
Good point Mark. There are many inconsistencies. You can't go for a round of golf (minus the drinks on the 19th hole) or take a tinny out to sea but you can shop at Coles. Oh and you can go out to shoot ducks, thank god.
BTW, it seems that the Bass Coast beaches managed by Parks Victoria are not closed for Easter. That includes Harmers and Williamsons.
Catherine Watson
Looks like you're correct. Lots of reserves still open, including Kilcunda - Harmers Haven coastal reserve https://www.parks.vic.gov.au/get-into-nature/safety-in-nature/covid-19-update
Georgina Day
Beyond the view
April 3, 2020
Thanks, Linda - a superb and fascinating summary.
One comment: I really enjoy the way that traditional chicory kilns have inspired contemporary buildings on Phillip Island.
Rob Youl
Linda, a fine tale of give and take, well told, and now recorded. Thank you.
Tim Shannon
Great work Linda. Your “big picture” account of how the landscape has changed over the past two centuries of European settlement points us to a more considered interaction with our wild and beautiful island.
Peter Dunlop
Sublime.
Geoff Ellis
Congratulations, Linda. What a huge amount of research you must have done to write such a comprehensive feature. Thank you.
Meryl Tobin
An excellent article, well researched, beautifully written and with some very good references. A meticulous history. Well done Linda.
Phyllis Papps
What a comprehensive look at the changing face of the island’s landscapes and the pressures, threats and will to overcome them. Thank you Linda.
Julie Constable
Great work, Linda! A well researched and interesting read.
Karen Bateman
The virus diaries 2
April 3, 2020
Catherine your take on this gives some light relief amongst so much hysteria.
I’m part of ‘essential service ‘ too - acting as supervisor and morning site meeting attender without having to leave my house as a carport gets built and reroofing.
Up to 4 or 5 different Gracie folk a day apologising for disturbing me when I’m isolated due to bronchits ( yep a bit more scary than usual ! )
I whip out my ‘ workie tape’ to the requisite 1.5 mtr and say ‘please you’re living up my day no end! ’ We’ve all managed to turn serious discussions abt lockdown, if the roof‘s half off, into a Monty python type comedy!
How lucky am I - construction is a week ahead of schedule!
I offer free drive by Grand Design tours with tomato foraging on the side.
Pm me for the postcode to avoid uncalled for vigilante island behaviour. The fear is out of control certainly worsened by the media.
Nerida Melsmith
Thank you for making me laugh a lot, Catherine. Best c...... update I have read so far. What a friendly, sharing street you live in. No chance mistrusting neighbours around your area. Stay well and keep laughing. Though I worry about those who cannot pay the rent and refugees squashed in detention centres and hotels, I am enjoying the peace and the vegetables and fruit from our garden.
Felicia Di Stefano
Thank you so much for your Virus Diary Catherine. As we learn to daily deal with the new normal, your take on things makes it more possible to think outside the new square.
I know it is being said all the time but we really are all in this together,
Anne Davie
As usual, Catherine (editor of Bass Coast Post) is wonderful at observing people, their behavior and has an excellent understanding of human nature. She also has a wonderful network of friends, neighbours, colleagues etc. AND of course she is a brilliant and satirical journalist/writer.
Another fantastic summing up of what our life is like now.
Phyllis Papps
Oh you are a gem, and an essential services one at that!!!!
Lynne Steer
Thanks Catherine that was fun. When The Post hits my inbox it brightens the day
Geoff Heyes
Thanks Catherine. Loved your diary comments. It's such a pleasure to smile and your dry
humour helps our poor media soaked brains get back some perspective.
Judy Soerink
Thankyou Catherine, love your delightful observations. We all need to adopt a sense of humour if we are to survive the next ?? months!
Susan Pryde
Have you thought about writing professionally? You're very good! You almost sound like a conser ... no, I can' say it! Slagging the ABC? I have to say I'm surprised. Good on you, it's time we had a laugh about this.
ps. Totally unrelated but the storm on Saturday night was his orchestrated departure and I can't publish in the Sentinel - Felix 02.05.2000 - 04.04.2020
Pamela Jacka
Nineteen years, eleven months and 28 (29?) days is good going. A storm is the perfect soundtrack for Felix's ascent.
Catherine Watson
Anyone who knows Catherine is very well aware of her extensive professional background in terms of writing biographies, journalism, fantastic news stories, profile stories, feature articles etc. The list is endless.
Phyllis Papps
It's time for our own national park
April 3, 2020
Thank you for sharing the historical background, Meryl. We need all the information we can find to make the most of this opportunity, not just for Bass Coast but the whole of Victoria and Australia. Preserved by a fluke for more than sixty years, we cannot allow this treasure to be lost. I just hope we can be heard given the current difficult times.
Anne Heath Mennell
During the Spring of 2018 I visited The Gurdies. I was surprised to see horse riders had access to the park and were trampling the precious orchids.
Colleen FitzGerald
Never mind the Horse Poo in the Gurdies Reserve. We dog owners must take ours home.
Has anyone else noticed the mountain Bike tracks built by enthusiasts despite local restrictions. Parks Victoria assures me it will be put right but nothing has happened since my reporting it last October. Trees chopped and jumps made, precious soil piled against trees to improve the run.
The home of the precious Spurred Helmet orchid vandalised........
Margaret Lee
I do hope that this site can be developed into a national park. I have walked The Gurdies many times over the years and it is a hidden treasure.
Joy Button
What about conserving some of the sacred land that helped “prove” a national emblem, the mighty Holden. Just kidding. A suitably inscribed chassis panel, discreetly hidden, would do the job.
John Gascoigne
A most valuable ecological initiative. So good to hear about the way you are going about this. All the very best for early progress.
Elizabeth Ann Buckingham
Thank you for your comments. It is good to know others care about our natural environment. Anyone who is interested and not already part of the group working to preserve the woodlands of the Holden Proving Ground could email editor@basscoastpost.com to join in the correspondence on this. Those interested in the wider vision outlined above, such as those wanting to ensure the Grantville Grass Tree forest is protected, might also like to be part of it.
Meryl Tobin
Closer to the edge
April 3, 2020
Well said Geoff ... in particular your last paragraph which I urge all Bass Coast Post readers to re-read.
Rob Parsons
Have recently come back from a short holiday to the south west of W.A In Busselton we saw the geotextile sandbags being used on the beach. They were pleasing to the eye, made a great seat and were saving the beach from erosion. The beach was beautiful and I took photos in the hope that I could show this method of erosion control to people who didn't want to see more basalt boulders on the beaches of Bass Coast. They are a no brainer, when it comes to aesthetics and family friendly apart from saving our beautiful foreshores from further erosion. Keep up the good work and make it Bass Coast wide where erosion control is needed . I suggest the Silverleaves beach area, east of Sanders Road be a place of great need, and used by many families with young children every holiday. Hopefully NOT this Easter...
Gillian Armstrong
Thanks Gillian. The bags do make very useful seating. Maybe they will evolve into outdoor forums.
Cr Geoff Ellis
Excellent idea Geoff...... another plus for this 'multi purpose' method of erosion control !
Gillian Armstrong
I support Rob Parson's comments and Geoff Ellis article. I served for a number of years on the Grantville and District Foreshore Committee but resigned in frustration in October 2017. Despite a number of community meetings to discuss the continuing erosion threatening Waterline Communities and suggestions for measures to ameliorate the problem no worthwhile funding was forthcoming. Solutions morphed into talkfests. There have been some valiant efforts by Bass Coast Landcare Network to tackle the problem but funding for more substantial works such as sandbags, rock walls and groynes have not been forthcoming. It seems that residents of the Waterline Communities lack the clout of more affluent areas of Bass Coast such as Inverloch and Silverleaves.
Ian James
Thanks Ian. Agree and thank you for your efforts.
Geoff Ellis
Holden’s last hurrah
March 20, 2020
Great article Tim!
Let me know if there's any petition to sign or any other pressure we can get to bear on Government or GM to get this important area saved for conservation. It's an ongoing disgrace that so many multinational corporations are the first to come to government when they're in financial trouble, yet baulk at paying any tax as part of their quid pro quo!
Pete Muskens
Great article and idea Tim.
Peter Dann
Congratulations, Tim! A refreshing look at a possible future for the GMH Proving Ground, an incredibly valuable environmental and economic asset which should be gifted or bought for the good of the community.
Meryl Tobin Brown
That's an excellent article. I do so hope the site is gifted for wildlife conservation or that council and government unite to protect it for that purpose. The income and tax figures you quote are appalling in their cost to Australians. Thank you for presenting this important article.
Susan Linley
Send a message to GM HQ.
Mary Barra - CEO and Chair of GM
linkedin.com/in/mary-barra-29469712
Dhivya Suryadevara GM CFO
linkedin.com/in/dhivya-suryadevara
General Motors Company
P.O. BOX 33170
Detroit, MI 48232-5170
Geoff Ellis
Thanks Tim. It is always good to get the facts - the proving ground has always had a slightly mysterious air about it. Anyway it can be kept as it is, count me in.
Joan Woods
Good idea for tourism but at this point of time with USA virtually closed down and we not far behind not the time to pursue this.
The governments, companies and people around the world have more important things on their mind than a block of land in Victoria.
Nothing will happen at this time , follow up at the right time and that is certainly not now.
Christopher Day
An excellent article and great idea. Not enough is being done in conservation on this scale. This is such a good opportunity for the Council and Government to move on this together, NOW, before it's too late......what possibilities, they're endless when it comes to the environment and the future. I say, act fast and act now.
Gillian Armstrong
I enjoyed most of Tim's article and agree that the site would be a wonderful area for conservation purposes. However I think it would have been better if Tim had not published such misleading figures. He cites Gross Income for several years and complains that no tax was paid on this income. He conveniently forgets to take into account the operating expenses of those years or to mention that in the years 2013/14 the company made an operating loss of 554 million dollars and in the year 2014/15 made an operating loss of 255 million to mention just two. The subsequent years were not much better. It was these huge losses over several consecutive years that led to GM opting out of Australia. Consequently this shows that there is a very good reason that no tax was paid during the period Tim published. Given Tim's background he must have known how misleading the article is.
Trevor Brown
Trevor Browns information on GMH losses adds a new dimension to the debate. You certainly wouldn't want to approach GMH with incorrect financial information they would dismiss any discussion . I doubt they would only be interested in selling the land for the best deal for them clearly they we're in bad financial situation or they wouldn't be withdrawing from all right hand drive markets around the world not just Australia . The last few months and however long this corona virus lasts will no doubt leave them in far worse financial position .
If the Victorian community it going to obtain this parcel of land for long term benefit of the community it needs to put together a financial offer that they could accept expecting them to donate it is a waste of time . Of course as a housing estate it could provide a developer great parcel of land in an area where future housing is closer to Melbourne than areas like Wonthaggi so to stop that happening any approach to GMH has to be commercially well put together . Another question is does Bass Coast council currently collect rates for this land and if so how much is paid each year.
Chris Day
Ed and the Birds
March 20, 2020
So much food for thought! I thoroughly enjoyed reading this Karen and have to digest the good and bad news to work out if we're coming out on top.
Hilary Stuchbery
loved the story and the complexities in it.
it reminded me there's quite a few guerrilla planters out there .
one of them informed me when i was explaining some of the looks and questioning it best to some how get the word ' beautification ' of the medium strip into conversations. And yes just keep planting
Nerida Melsmith
It was such a pleasure to read this first time around and, on the second reading, it really resonates, especially the last line.
Geoff Ellis
Karen, I loved your inspiring story about Ed and the birds. I had virtually given up planting shrubs at my place on Phillip Island as they need a lifetime of defending from wallabies. Trees get above wallaby height and tussock grasses get too rough for their palate. But your story has made me rethink how I can create little protected shrubby places for the small birds. And all power to Ed’s guerrilla tactics!
Linda Cuttriss
This is a kind and inspiring story. Thanks Karen. You write beautifully.
Carmel Anderson
Karen what a wonderful account of Ed, the birds, the interrelationships and the changing face of our world. Thank goodness for optimists no matter how plodding! Thank you.
Julie Constable
Hello Karen, Wow what a wonderful article, I remember our ramblings around Inverloch 20 years ago, my how it has changed.
Wendy Davies
Thanks everyone for your kind comments, and for taking the time to read it.
Karen Blackman
Immensely proud of my cousin Karen, on her ability to make me think about things in a way I never have before. Writing is a passion, but a cheerleader for change. Well done wild cousin Karen, which has different connotations to me now. Natural, native and not prescribed. So very proud of you x
Sara Fellows
The virus diaries
March 20, 2020
Thank you Catherine! You have made me laugh and cheered my week no end.
Camilla Myers
What a brilliant piece! Your observation is accurate and I love your witty expression scattered through your writing. Your insight and wisdom certainly lifted my heart in these uncertain times. Now our local gym and swimming pool The Y is closed and I'm jobless. Thank goodness I have my writing.
Etsuko Yasunaga
How easily our civilisation can unravel, it seems like only yesterday that our leaders were exhorting us to take an empty esky, go out to the bushfire-ravaged areas and buy from small businesses. It appears that the hordes have taken this too literally, pillaging our country supermarkets - how unseemly. I expect that Post readers will behave in a more civilised manner than most and that you all remain safe from this latest version of armageddon. Perhaps next time the PM is consulting his good book and praising the lord he will look up the chapter titled Wrath of God.......
Mark Robertson
Oh Catherine you do make me laugh
This is a pretty common trauma response as as for being unAustralia, I cringed when I heard the PM say stock up- I though you have no idea what you are unleashing. Turns out he didn’t and is now blaming the people - give me a break please!
As for me I probably fit into some kind of food hoarder category- what has Costcodone to us ! I shop late Oct Nov and buy enough nonperishables and new products I’ve never seen before ( to try! Cos I can) to feed a family and friends of 12 for a month. This January Feb wasn’t that busy, and the two chooks on fire rescue lay an egg every few days. So fresh fruit and veg is all that’s needed.. I don’t feel quite so odd now!
Nerida Melsmith
What a hoot Catherine! As I went into IGA (no toilet rolls, no pasta, no UHT (only 'fake' Milk- made from seeds and nuts -yuk drink water) but plenty of people to have a chat with and shake our heads over people's foolishness. Loved your comment about not being able to get crap from China (in our family we call it Chinese Landfill), but for .
'cheap' we let our manufacturing industries shrivel so lots of 'stuff' comes from OS. I do read labels and usually can find products in the food line Made in Australia (avoid asparagus from Peru and cherries from the US of A). We eat seasonally and grow vegies and fruit. Keep up the good work and full marks to the contributors of articles and cartoons. Some clown said life wasn't meant to be easy. Cheers.
Yvonne McRae
The clown (Malcolm Fraser, former PM) actually said “Life is not meant to be easy, my child; but take courage: it can be delightful.”. Like all good journalists, only part of the quote was reported and continues to be, incorrectly, reported. It was a call for people to have a go and don't be afraid. The results can be delightful. The quote is from a Bernard Shaw play,
Perhaps now with our borders closed, etc. we will remember what it was like to be self-sufficient and start manufacturing again. We just need to keep a rein on the wages so that we don't make our industries unable to compete with the "Chinese Landfill". We do make a bit of a profit out of the imported landfill - it's usually our iron ore!
Pamela Jacka
Bravo Catherine, I hope the hordes read the post. And well done to the commentators 1e Frank, Yvonne,Nerida... You've said it all. except, Australia also had ration books during and after the war. A message for the Polis,: Get them back again quick!
Heather Tobias
I simply love your story. I think all your readers can relate to it. Thank you Catherine
Jellie N. Wyckelsma
It was at Aldi's, not a bottle shop and l wasn't joking.
Hamish Watson
Could this be a return to village life, circa 1820, when people's concerns and information-exchange centred on the neighbours, the inn, the post office, the grocer's and the local dance? Likewise journalism and the bygone 'vox pop', where voices of people on the street appeared on a printed page. Thank you, Catherine! Just what the doctor ordered, apart from the hand wash and face mask.
John Gascoigne
Man of many parts
March 20, 2020
An interesting insight into one of our local hardworking councillors. Well written Liane.
Rob Parsons
As an ex ratepayer in his ward, I'd just like to back up Rob Parsons's praise of Geoff Ellis..
Not only for his interest in conserving as much of Bass Coast as possible, exemplified by his backing of Preserve Western Port in the "2014 "Battle of Hastings", (aka the container port), but also his 100% backing of me in a personal issue in the months before I moved back to Melbourne.
I know he is flat out 100% of the time, but I still wish he'd find time to have that dinner with me up here in Melbourne we discussed before I moved back here!!!!!
Tho that of course may have to wait until after this "Bug" drama plays out.
Good luck to all down there in the current crisis. I know full well what tourism means to Bass Shire...
Sincerely
Kevin Chambers
Great story Liano, we need more people like Geoff. I wish him all the best with the Lang Lang proving grounds. Hardly any bush left in West Gippsland, we need to conserve what remains.
Peter Bogg
Despite my inherent distrust of politicians I enjoyed this biography and the writing moved along smoothly.
Rowland Arno
Very interesting article on a very interesting person, Liane. I've met Geoff on a number of occasions over the last couple of years. A genuine,open minded person of great heart. An absolute asset to our community.
Ellen Hubble
Self portrait of an architect
March 20, 2020
A familiar journey for creatives I suspect- the inner need to puzzle and scrutinise their purpose... Architecture as the portrait of the client makes me smile... studio of delight. Yes. I reflect on my husbands and my own spaces within our home. It explains a lot 🤪 Thank you for the article
Jeannie Haughton
Tim, an informative article thankyou. Here are some random points about creativity in general I'd make. If you're scared to make a mistake creativity will suffer. If you follow the master you will not learn your way. Mistakes are your sub-conscious letting lose. "Considered mistakes" have an unexpected new direction, renewed power and surprising outcomes. My first boss said to me as a passing comment on something I was doing at my art desk... he said "Peter, take the bull by the horns",something I have used my whole career to date. Our pathways have a similar echo Tim.
Peter Walker
How wonderful to read another of your incredibly well-crafted, profoundly thought and beautifully written pieces Tim. I love the way your writing makes me think, question, wonder and then smile. I look forward to the next one!
Linda Cuttriss
The solace of birds
March 20, 2020
What a wonderful and sensitive piece of non-fiction writing about your love of nature, conservation and the environment. Your illustrations were a superb visual way to accompany the article. Every one applauds the many decades of your efforts and voluntary work you have devoted to Phillip Island and surrounding areas.
Phyllis Papps
Your words, with what they describe in the neighbouring 'nest', make for the most beguiling reading experience. Thank you, Patsy.
John Gascoigne
Lovely to read your observations of the birds in your garden Patsy. They are insightful and informative and your illustrations are wonderful. I always refer to your illustrations when I visit the bird hide at Swan Lake. They are excellent representations and it’s great be able to identify all the birds I am observing. I look forward to Solace of Birds Part 2.
Linda Cuttriss
Lovely article Patsy, I can so relate to your garden. My garden is my sanctuary, and is the food bowl for many native birds. I can really relate to your sentiment and your illustrations. My kids remember with warmth the drawings you would do for them as Lollypop Lady!
Gillian Armstrong
Such arrogance!
March 20, 2020
Just get in there and re-vegetate, erect a sign at the property boundary explaining the need for and value of the works. If the sign gets vandalised erect a bigger one!
Neil Rankine
On common ground
March 20, 2020
Thanks Frank, always good to hear from you and your incredible historical knowledge- totally agree
Angela Wishart
Thank you for this Frank. I love it. Beautifully written and absolutely fascinating.
Nancy Vaughan
Love your work Frank. What a beautiful piece of writing. Thanks for sharing
Tracie McIntosh
Ditto from me Frank. I love your stories. Please keep them coming. It’s always a good time to be reminded of Wonthaggi’s egalitarian roots. Not just for the sake of nostalgia, but as a legacy for now and the future, a reminder of what’s important about being human.
Linda Cuttriss
Berry delicious
March 20, 2020
Well done Jan. I really enjoy your recipes. Cheers, Yvonne
Yvonne McRae
Not so fast, GM
March 6, 2010
Amazing idea!
Vicki Breen
Good contribution to the wider conversation, Mikhaela. I'm sure there are plenty of ideas out there, which I hope will be heard by decision makers. My personal hope is that this unique place will become a State asset for the people of Victoria and, whatever activities are eventually approved, that the flora and fauna continue to be protected. We need to watch this one carefully.
Anne Heath Mennell
Michaela & BCP - you have well said exactly what has been on my mind since the Holden announcement. Get onto Jordan Crugnale to make representations on behalf of community to State Govt too.
Anne Paul
Hi Mikhaela, I think that GM should by rights gift this land to the people of Australia.
While Holden was riding high on the hog in the Australian market, with as much as 50% market share - and remember too that GM was assisted by the Chifley Government to establish manufacturing here under the General Motors banner - it repatriated handsome profits to GM balance sheets in Detroit for the better part of 60 years. It has also benefited from huge amounts of Government largesse by way of the Green Car Innovation Fund (which began at $500million, and grew to $1billion); then later, the Automotive Transformation Scheme - tipping another $400million into local manufacturing (before the announcements of closure).
In fact, over the 12 years from 2001-2013, Holden's own figures show it received $2.17billion in state and federal government assistance, compared to $1.1 billion for Ford and $1.2 billion for Toyota.
Each of these manufacturers was then assisted with taxpayer money - after the announcement of closures - to shutter the factories and retrain the workforce. This amounted to another $150million (or so).
To load more salt into the wounds, GMH hasn't paid for tax for years: income 2016/17 - $4,601,580,614, tax - $0. (You can thank internal invoicing, fees from the parent company, for that.)
So, should it gift its proving grounds to Lang Lang? I should think so. Australian taxpayers have, after all, already paid handsomely for it.
I reckon we can get a groundswell going here. I'm a former motoring journalist, I think I can swing a lot of them in behind this campaign.
So, who's going to be in from down here? Let's get a group going and see what we can get rolling.
Tim O’Brien
Great idea it's an asset that could add to the tourism in this area. Tourism is vital for the economy of not just Bass area but all of Australia.
Obviously the coronavirus is on everybody's priority at moment but it is showing us how important tourism is. It's also showing us how stupid we are as a country to close down our manufacturing sector which the state of Victoria dominated since WW2 mainly driven by buyers of major retailers going into Asia to get cheaper products and make more money. Now we find ourselves running out of products as we have no back up available .
My suggestion would be to get the federal government involved in this issue as vic govt have no new money to spend in sure the treasurer won't let Premier Dan anywhere near this issue.
Don't waste your energy thinking GMH will assist or donate the land they have shown only interested in their own situation not those who sold , serviced or bought their products .
Chris Day
Alzheimer Sufferer/Carer Suite
March 6, 2010
Malcolm, your tribute to moments - too seldom caught - in two lives eternally tied into one is gripping, devastating, haunting, cleansing. Bravo.
Fiona
Bravo Malcolm.
Jeannie Haughton
Lovely words. Thus we process what must have been hard to live!
Heather Slutzkin
Heather, what a profound way of putting it. The act of writing, though often hard, brings understanding. "Emotion recollected in tranquillity", as Wordsworth described it.
Catherine Watson
What very insightful comments, Heather.
Ann Stocker
Congratulations on the publication of this book of poems. Very insightful on the emotions and moments one goes through.
Lynn Rogers
Malcolm, this wonderful piece of poetry about love, life and loss is a superb piece of writing.
I truly hope that you will be able to have it published in book form.
Warm regards, Phyllis
Phyllis Papps
A special relationship documented, explored and cherished by the poet.
An achievement of note.
Nancy Endersby-Harshman
Damn you, John Mutsaers
March 6, 2010
Sorry Catherine, Messing with dreams mmmmmm?? nice thought.
Here is a little clue which I shared at the opening.
A man goes into a hardware shop and asks for 10 mm drill bit: what is it that he really wants???? He wants a 10mm hole. look beyond, behind and in the nooks and crannies then close your eyes and dream words.
John Mutsaers
Hi Catherine, I did brave the crowd and heard John speak, yes he seeks to tantalise and provoke, just what art should do. My takeaway was that the birds are thoughts and the cage is our captive paradigm; our upbringing; schooling; our fears and a wish to fit in. The great thinkers at least made it to a more expansive birdcage.
Michael Whelan
Catherine, Fantastic article, such an enjoyable read. You think you’ve got problems with John messing with your head, I’ve been married to him for 53 years!!!
Exhibition closes on the 29th March. Writers, come along and experience the exhibition and see if John messes with your head.
Mary Mutsaers
Catherine, You've nailed it. One of John's pieces just makes me laugh every time I think of it. Tried to write down why and failed a dozen times. A thousand emails end to end, endless bitumen stretching to the next event, that stretch of foreshore. I'll keep trying but
Geoff Ellis
Thank you Catherine .... loved this piece and made my grey day. Love your sense of
humour. Thank you.
Joy Button
So wonderful to see the mediums intersect...and go crashing off in different directions!!! Well done Catherine for having a crack, and thank you John for brilliantly making us leave your exhibition with more questions than answers!!!!!!!
Mick Green
Inverloch Primary School were fortunate to have our Year 6 minds discuss their thoughts of freedom while pondering over the fish in the glass art piece. 11 year olds discussed their thoughts in a conversation with the artist. Truly inspiring, thought provoking and challenging, with joy and cheekiness. All that art and education should be.
Amanda McMahon
Hi Catherine. I've worked out what the egg means! Only teasing!
Thanks to John for not only his wonderful works - but to give us such a challenge. I have finally managed to pen a piece - managed somehow to weave yellow, a cage and a mirror into a story - must have been drunk at the time!
Liane Arno
Poles apart
March 6, 2010
I'm a 30+ year firefighter (CFA), I live in the Bass Coast but spent days down in East Gippsland fighting the fires, I spend time on fuel reduction burns and I see the fire season getting longer and more intense. Yes, fuel reduction burns can help, particularly around assets like towns, where it can assist with firefighting. In the bush it's a different situation though, risk of loosing control, replacement growth can be more hazardous, much shorter windows to burn effectively.
I also vote Greens most of the time, as they have the policies most influenced by facts and science, not money and madness.
Some fourty years ago I finished an honours degree studying physics and modeling at Monash University. Back then we were taught the very basic physics, known for at least 50 years, of how greenhouse gases facilitate the warming of the Earth. Since we knew this we have nearly put half as much greenhouse gases again up into the atmosphere than has been there for a hundred thousand years or more.
There is no question any longer that this must and does influence atmospheric physics (the energy in the climate system). There is no question any more that things are still to get significantly worse with lags in the system, unless we act immediately to move to the systems of the future, that even the prime minister's advisers know, and tell him are here now and ready to use.
We have to replace our aging and unreliable coal and gas soon anyway, why is there any question about where we should be going? And why are we waiting, this will stimulate economic activity, create many more jobs than our current systems, open new markets for savy farmers and reduce the price of power. And that's not to mention saving our children from inheriting one hell of a job to cleaning up our mess if we don't act now.
Neil Rankine
I appreciate the effort that you put into your letter and commend you for being prepared to stand up for what you believe. And start a debate in these virtual pages.I believe our friendship can only be strengthened by serious discussion about real issues. Thank you.
I am working on a full and worthy response to the letter and would just like to clarify a couple of things. Hopefully the editor will allow me to have a couple of bites of the cherry!
You say that "A lot of the message that you conveyed was about the fires". My article consisted of 21 paragraphs and ONE was about the fires.
In regards Jam Jerrup, the failing I point out is the planning scheme (OURS) that allows development on an eroding coastline. I recently was informed that the rock revetment has been designed.
Right now I have to get back to my Infinite Birdcage. Cheers Cobber.
Geoff Ellis
John, you state:' I believe that today’s Labour Party and the Greens have much to answer for. They are the "fuckwits that are in power" in this state for not allowing controlled burn offs...'
I have heard this statement repeated often. It is wrong. Both the Labor government and the Greens have policies that encourage fuel reduction burns. Could you provide one example where Labor or the Greens have stopped a fuel reduction burn?
Fuel reduction burns have not been undertaken for various reasons, but basically for safety concerns. This is sensible decision making.
Peter Bogg
John: 'The Aboriginal people who fought in WWI and WWII fought under the Australian flag and provided a great service to this country. Australia does exist, and we are all part of it, fighting for it, and fighting for solutions. We are one country, one flag, one anthem and one people!'
Not true John, Most Australians fought under the Union Jack in WW1. Most Australians fought under either the Australian Red Ensign or the Union Jack in World War II. All Australian Naval personnel fought under the British Naval Ensign in both world wars.
The Australian flag as we know it now, was only legally defined in the flags act 1953.
Peter Bogg
Home is where the art is
March 6, 2010
Thank you Catherine. As part of the small team at ESPI we really need great publIcity as you have provided. Lovely article full of useful history of this energetic group.
Margaret McCubbery
Friends honour the 'two Bills'
March 6, 2010
A fitting memorial to two good men.
Peter Brown
We will miss farmer Bill in Harmers, he was part of the landscape
Trish Hogan
Pittosporum Flowering
February 21, 2010
Julie, thank you for gracing us with a beautiful read. Your writing evoked such a strong and magnificent sense of place and I was happy to have visited awhile in a place that you so dearly loved. It is a well deserved accolade.
Jessica Berry
That was beautiful Julie, thank you for sharing. I confess, I may too be harbouring a few little pittosporums. Thank you for so eloquently sticking up for our oft-persecuted weedy friends and giving us a glimpse into your world. May our gardens and forests be graced by such lovely inhabitants and protectors as yourself!
Dan
Lovely story, Julie. A pleaure to read.
Karen Bateman
Julie, what a beautiful narrative, so informative and skilfully woven personal and political, xx
Karen
Thank you - most enjoyable read.
Led Leunig
I really enjoyed your memoir Julie. Beautifully written, a joy to read, especially the imagery of the plants, forest and landscape. And I loved the way you weaved the personal, political and scientific through the piece.
Linda Cuttriss
Pulling all the threads together so eloquently, makes me intensely happy to have our wonderful subtle landscape so articulately traversed.
Learned a beautiful new word too! Nimbed! Glorious. Thanks Julie, a truly significant contribution toward our understanding of ourselves in this place. Hopefully opening a greater appreciation of and care for this beautiful land.
Susan Purdy
Beautiful
Theresa Cicero
Absolutely beautiful piece of writing I felt totally atuned to. Look forward to sharing with Lisa Kennedy. 😃✨🌸
Peter Corser
So informative Julie, I couldn't agree more with the bad rap those magnificent trees receive. Could it be possible that they are fire retardant, they look it. Regards, Pauline
Pauline Enright Amon
Thank you Julie, I feel as if you have strolled through my out of control oasis.
Twenty years ago I wandered through the Cowes St Philips Market to be overwhelmed by the most exotic fragrance, in a large pot, Mock Orange I was advised, though Pittosporum was not uttered. When it is in flower, & I'm asked, my response is a miracle of nature; as is a hedge of cream bell-shaped wonga flowers draped over the old trellis fence, behind the gas bottles. through the gate into Missy's garden, the Lost Dogs Home creature, to be framed by the white sprays of the clematis drape through the old pagoda to my back door.
I immediately identified with your wonderful narrative.
Virginia Hamilton
Memories of Hiroshi
February 21, 2010
What an incredible article , beautifully written to conjure up a picture of both an energetic and delightful young man and an aunt who holds him so gently in her heart . Etsuko has the ability to share her deepest emotions without overwhelming the reader - instead she draws you in so that you too can share in her pride, her grief ? Her resolution and her happiness . An inspirational article/ thank you Etsuko
Anne McDonald
Thank you Anne sincerely for taking time to read my written piece. I believe that everything (including both happiness and sadness) is better shared. If my writing can bring solace to any grieving heart, then I am content. Your kind words are much appreciated.
Etsuko Yaunaga
Dear friend Etsuko, so much wisdom, so much pain and grief and re-generation.
Your writing is so SPECIAL because you express so much emotion and so many words that most mere mortals are afraid of doing or saying or writing.
We are all enriched by your writing and your philosophy of life and happiness. Regards, Phyllis Papps
Dear Phyllis, your kind words touched my heart and also affirmed my passion for writing. Learning to write in a second language was difficult, but once I cleared the barriers, words flowed naturally. I feel everything deeply, and there is no other way I can see the world. Sometimes it's painful to be this way but when I can share my feeling with others through my writing it brings a whole new meaning to my creative pursuit.
Etsuko Yaunaga
Etsuko, your words have me in tears. Despite your loss and intense grief, you have found a way through this to enrich your life every day. I can only dream of escaping the grief that engulfs me daily, but your words give me some hope that with time I may be able to achieve this. Thank you.
Heather Sullivan
Oh Heather, grief is very personal process and everyone responds differently. I was lucky enough to have writing in my life when this tragedy took place, and found solace in expressing my feeling. Any creative pursuit helps to heal grieving hearts. I trust that you already have special creativity inside you, so explore your talent and share it with others who appreciate its beauty. Thanks for your honesty and taking time to read my writing. Much appreciated.
Etsuko Yaunaga
I have just read this because I didn't want to read it in a rush. This was too important to rush through and not be able to process as it should be. I have just read it.....3 times. And I say this my beautiful friend - I understand it so very much. My entire life's focus changed on January 1st 2019 with the diagnosis that destroyed my family and everything I knew. It is kind of like learning to walk again - except a little bit braver because they have been denied the chance to live the life that they should have had.....so we can't take it for granted. We must do the things that scare us and the things we didn't think we could.....quite simply because they no longer can. We have to find a new way to relate to people that we love so dearly and are a part of our hearts but now feel that little bit further away. We cannot let them know our grief or despair or how lost we feel because what they are going through is so much worse. We understand and we know but we find a way to process our pain so that they don't have to bear ours as well. My friend this writing is extraordinary. I just want you to know that I hear you, I see you and I understand and above all - I am always here xxxx
Mardi Jones
Dear friend Mardi, First of all thank you for having waited till an appropriate time to read my piece. I appreciate your thoughtfulness, care and respect for my writing. I always ask people to find quiet time and space to read my writing so that they can process. You did. Thank you also for using 'extraordinary' to describe my writing. It's one of my favourite words to receive from my readers.
There are two types of people in the world. Those who have experienced an acute, raw pain of grieving (like you and I), and those who haven't (yet). It's almost impossible to understand this kind of intense pain without going through the actual suffering. I always accept people's sympathy graciously regardless of their experience, but words like yours hit my heart deeply. I hear you, I understand you and I'm with you always. We are strong and resilient because of our grieving experience. Hope you find solace in my writing, and on Daniel's 9th anniversary (or sooner) you are happy as I am right now.
Etsuko Yaunaga
Dear Etsuko
Your gift of making me feel the deep love you have of your family and of life itself is beautiful to me.Keep writing, and living in the now is a very special achievement that I feel is very worthwhile to pursue.
Verena Hoefler
Thank you Verena for your kind words. Writing has helped me find solace. Furthermore by sharing my writing with others I receive strong affirmation to keep on writing. It's my pure joy and is the only way I can see and understand the world.
Etsuko Yaunaga
Beautiful words Etsuko, life takes many unplanned turns, some for the better, some in a different direction. Your words touch many hearts deeply. I love your not a secret!! Focus on what you love
Tony O'Connell
Thank you very much for your words of wisdom, Tony. The fact that they come from the man I respect deeply means a lot to me. I learned quite early that where the mind goes energy flows. Yes I will continue to focus on what I love and what brings joy in my life. I'm so grateful that our paths have crossed.
Etsuko Yaunaga
Why I love Cape
February 21, 2010
Thank you Pete for your article which pretty much sums up my love affair with Cape Paterson and my real concerns about the development plans currently under consideration.
Do we have to ruin all the coastline with over development?! Surely the addition of the Eco-Village on the west side of the township should be the end to development at Cape for a very long time!
Barbara Smith
Thanks Barbara
Yes, one would've hoped that the Ecovillage be the end of it but Matthew Guy's arbitrary expansion on the town boundary to suit the developers means we are constantly fighting this battle. Not until the boundaries are put back to Seaward Drive will this business end.
If this application succeeds, we'll see no end of pressure to build over the whole coast from san remo to Inverloch. It's time to draw a line!
Pete Muskens
My sentiments exactly. I often don’t go near the beach at the Cape as I am somewhat disabled. This does not worry me as I live among the trees on my property. I have upward of 20 gums, many of which are flowering gums of all colours. The local koala comes visiting and possums scurry across our roof. I regret not being able to participate in the regeneration projects run by CPRRA as the volunteers have done a magnificent job. It has also helped to invoke a sense of community that I wish I could be part of. Thanks for your articles that captures the essence of Cape Paterson.
Gael McLeod
Not being a resident of Cape Paterson , but a relatively new resident of Wonthaggi, I would respectfully suggest that all residents of the Cape, not to be silent, have your say or your peaceful township will become like so many other towns, villages, and hamlets, Nothing more than part of the suburban sprawl. My town (Drouin) was a beautiful little village, as a child it was a great place to be.Things changed and now it is almost a suburb of Warragul .mainly because of the apathy of the residents and that includes me. Open your eyes and look at Pakenham, Yarragon, Trafalgar,Poowong, Nyora.. Because that may be your future .
John Cobbledick
I love cape been here for a year and wouldn’t change it at all ! Needs to stay how it is ! For sure ! ❤️
Sam Kahu
Hi Pete. I have read through your article and the responses. I very much agree.
I am having a late attempt to draft a letter to BCSC re amendment C136.
I want to do this in a manner that isn’t just a whinging complaint. Do you have any point form information that could help with my draft?
David Hubble
Enough with the climate gloom
February 21, 2010
Congratulations to Cr Whelan for going plastic free which I will try to emulate.
Joan Woods
Congrats Michael and Geoff at NCES. Did anybody from BCSC admin attend?
Bernie McComb
Hi Bernie Yes BCSC Climate Change Adviser attended the Summit and the council workshop, and is doing a fine job
Michael Whelan
What a thoughtful article from Cr Whelan. So pleased he is being proactive not reactive on this most critical issue. Lets hope it is contagious.
Pete Granger
Thanks Michael for opting to steer the discussion in a more positive direction. Agree with Pete here, we all need it to catch on.
Miriam Strickland
It is great to read this article and I try my best to help along with reducing plastic usage. I do not always find it easy. Positive approach of our community leaders is helping to do our best.
Verena Hoefler
Cancer service to ease the pain
February 21, 2010
A great step forward for Bass Coast and regional Victoria. Congratulations to all involved!
Meryl Tobin
Thank you very much Jan Child and Bass Coast Health.
Jan Fleming
Being member of Probus at San Remo for last 12 years i've seen first hand how difficult it is for people to live in Bass Coast Area and the hours involved in travel for treatment. Our club many times had rosters of drivers to help those unable to travel that far on their own.
Any treatment available at Wonthaggi will be a great improvement for residents.
Having being diagnosed with Lymphoma Cancer In August i now see the issues from the patients perspective. Clearly there is a lot more that needs to be available for the regional areas of Victoria to fully assist you through the whole process. Last week alone i had a Pet Scan and MRI Brain Scan both at Knox Private then following Day a Lumber Puncture at Epworth Box Hill. This equipment is very expensive plus you need the staff to go with it. Plus you need the Cancer specialist Doctors to firstly decide on what your illness is, then the process you need to go through to try to provide you with a cure and then the management of this process. This is a long term process the treatment like chemo is important part but it needs to be linked with all of the above, it doesn't sit out on its own.
With the size of the population in Victoria today having most of these services only available in Metropolitan Melbourne is a major concern and one the Federal & State Govts need to be far more pro active in. Its no good saying the City's are getting too large and we need people to move to regional areas but without the medical services being provided this is never going to happen. Few months ago i was in Albury and the Hospital Services provided by NSW government for that population is amazing. That's what needs to occur in Victoria.
My situation is sadly we know longer can live in San Remo even though we wanted to and really have enjoyed being part of the community in our retirement years. I know great number of people in our community over the last 15 years who have had to make the same decision as we have.
Christopher Day
Salutations from the high ground
February 21, 2010
Thanks very much Geoff for all you do. Loved the comment by Julian Burnside.
Jan Fleming
Jobs that no longer exist
February 10, 2020
Christine's extremely well written account of her early life on Phillip Island provides a fantastic record of the rural life that is now only a distant memory to many and a revelation to most. In the current world of instant gratification it is a delight to read about the first hand experience of the early life on Phillip Island.
I hope that Christine can provide us with further recollections of this fascinating period when Phillip Island was a small farming and fishing community.
Ian Samuel
Loved this article. Reminded me of the simpler Philip Island of the late 60's and 70's when, as a young boy, we would visit family friends who also farmed and fished on the island. But nothing like Christine's experience!
Brett Rogers
Christine, I very much enjoyed your memoir. I have seen a the kilns when visiting PI since I was a child and wondered what the process was. I was also impressed what people did to 'earn a crust'. Very hard work too. Thanks for sharing your experiences.
Pee Bee
Christine i really enjoyed your well written essay on days gone by on PI. It reminded me of my youth during the school holidays, going to work with my Dad Eric, who was a self employed iceman whose customers were the big hotels in Melbourne CBD. The Federal Hotel, Australia Hotel, Menzies Hotel are just a few of those long gone impressive posh hotels which needed broken up ice for the
drinks served.
How marvellous for you to remember and describe in so much detail your former jobs.
I always look at the remaining Chichory kilns and wonder what went on inside all those years ago.
Kay Setches
You create lovely word pictures, Christine. I was somewhere else, living a very different kind of life -- yet I feel a poignant nostalgia for the world you've created here. Some envy, too. Congratulations.
John Gascoigne
My memories of other places and different tasks in my young years was brought to life by Christine's stories. Well written, interesting and I think the word evocative fits.
As an apprentice 'cadet' in the British Merchant Navy, our first day at sea after perhaps a week in port, was spent tossing dunnage over the side. Great heaps went overboard.
Dunnage was a cheap grade of wooden plank used to keep cargo ventilated and apart from the steelwork at the bottom of a ship's hold to avoid condensation damaging valuable cargo. Any moisture would collect in the bilges and be pumped overboard.
Any dunnage which was damaged and rendered not reusable by the discharge of cargo was stacked on deck and jettisoned once the ship had cleared harbour. The dunnage on PI beaches was presumably from ships out of Melbourne.
Containerisation presumably saw an end to the practice.
Peter Brown
Thank goodness for Uncle Keith! I found that fascinating. Hard work out in the environment certainly shaped you Christine. Could WPPC please reproduce this?
Karri Giles
Thank you Christine. What a wonderful story about Phillip Island, capturing the vivid personal experience and the historical connections of the work on the island. My Aunty and Uncle lived at Ventnor and I have many holiday memories — of swimming at Red Rocks and cycling over to Summerland on quiet roads in the 1960s, 70s.
Julie Constable
What a beautifully written memoir Christine. Such a joy to read. The rich detail is a precious record of how these 'extinct' jobs were done and those shared moments toasting crumpets and honey while singing songs late into the night at the chicory kiln are marvellous, capturing a way of working from another time.
Linda Cuttriss
A wonderful, well written story Christine. As a latecomer to Phillip Island, I was fascinated by your evocation of a bygone era. Congratulations on winning the award - well deserved!
Marian Quigley
Lovely story, Christine evoking an era and life we can only wonder about. Well done and congratulations on your win.
Sally Bird
Memoir of bygone jobs takes top writing prize
February 10, 2020
Congratulations to you all! An outstanding outcome! Well done Phyllis for your inspiration and encouragement!
Carmen Bush
Congratulations Christine! And to other pirze winners and commendations.
Miriam Strickland
Congratulations to all involved.
Nicky Miller
Well done Christine and others!
I would love to read Jobs that no longer exist and Pittosporum flowering how does one do that please?
Karri Giles
Hi Karri. The prize winning and commended entries will be published in the Post. First up is Christine's work, which has been published, and Pittosporum Flowering will be published in the next issue of the Post.
Catherine Watson
Thank you for hosting such an inspiring event and Congratulations to the Winner - Christine Grayden and all nominees. We are blessed to have so many amazingly talented people in Bass Coast
Clare Le Serve
Congratulations Christine and everyone involved.
Peter Dann
It’s complicated
February 10, 2020
Congratulations to Pauline and Miriam. Thanks for sharing and thanks for your honesty about the ups and down. BCP doesn't allow comment emoticons and I would choose a raised glass of Champagne. Cheers!
Geoff Ellis
10/2/2020 09:46:37 pm
Ditto to Geoff's comments!
Nicky Miller
‘Blue poles’ director hailed from Wonthaggi
February 10, 2020
I caught up with James Mollison few years back (when mayor) to discuss the Robert Smith collection.
He left Wonthaggi when he was five. His uncle was the person who ok’d artist Noel Counihan to go into the mines to draw the series of prints which are now part of the Bass coast shire collection. It was very rare for artists to even go into the mines back in the day - in fact probable it was the first time.
James employed me a lifetime ago at the NGV - would you believe.
Jordan Crugnale, MP for Bass
A force of nature
February 10, 2020
Great to see Eulie's effort recognised and recorded in such an engaging article. Well done Terri.
Geoff Ellis
Keep it #$%@!!*& nice
January 25, 2020
My repertoire of wise old sayings includes “give them an inch and they take a mile”, along with something about people in glass houses, and “if you have nothing nice to say it is best to say nothing”.
It would be appalling if your Post and all the energy that has gone into it was to be corrupted to ruin by a few bad apples.
Dear Catherine, stay the course !
Tim Shannon
Thankyou Catherine for your journalistic experience and I support your decision to erase the personal criticism.
I appreciate the literature and variety of topics you attract to The Post.
Marjorie Scott
Thank you for your perseverance and all the time you put into the Post. We always look forward to reading all the interesting articles and agree with your decision. Happy New Year Catherine.
Alison Ribush
Enjoyed every article as usual. Keep up the great work!
Michelle Graham
Not living "down there:" anymore, but keep up the good work Catherine,Love reading the (constructive) comments on things happening in Bass Coast
Kevin Chambers
Love the Bass Coast Post.
Thank you Catherine.
Jan Fleming
Gorgeous Catherine!
Without you people like me would not have a voice - we would be less informed - we would not be able to share in a safe environment.
Bullies can be awfully devious - and so destructive - so thank you for not allowing them to have a voice.
Liane Arno
Good decision - i fully support you and thanks for doing such a great job on the Post
Lesley Bretherton
Thank you Catherine for gifting us the Bass Coast Post. Respect is vital and support your decision to stop abuse. Just love reading the articles in the Post and whilst you may not always agree with some views, one often gains knowledge of the reasons for differing views in the written article. Thank you for all that you do.
Joy Button
I totally agree with Catherine and thank her for the outstanding development of a Post with principles
It is indeed unfortunate that journalism as an industry has deteriorated to sensationalism and distortion of the truth to the detriment of the profession.
Informed articles are the source of knowledge shared, with the Post leading in the dissemination of views and opinions without acrimony
Keep up the good work
Ian Samuel
I agree, civil discussion is desperately needed at a time when we seem to becoming more polarised. But abusive retorts achieve nothing but further separation. Keep up the good work Catherine, I so enjoy the Post.
Lorrie Read
Catherine, whilst your intentions are admirable, beware! I used to subscribe to a large national newspaper that permitted what I called "vigorous" debate (which were, to be honest, horrific during the SSM debate) then belatedly decided that they needed moderation. I had several comments (favourable mostly) "rejected" and there was to be no discussing the reasons why. Other readers of the newspaper made similar observations. Eventually it appeared that the rejections were more personal than ethical, so I decided to pull the plug. There will be no political correctness in my house! It is yet another form of censorship.
Everyone views a topic differently, so I believe it would be quite difficult to be impartial and eventually what one considers offensive, others would not.
Pamela Jacka
Hi Pamela. I certainly don’t want to censor readers’ views. The more the merrier! However, the Post has picked up a few trolls along the way and I need to deal with them. The personal criticism and abuse are a diversion from genuine debate. They also deter others from entering the discussion. Let’s see how we go!
Catherine Watson, editor
I'm with you on this one Pamela, You cannot write about topics in Bass Coast Post in a joking, entertaining manner at the expense of people who are working so hard to save their own environment and are struggling with potential unbearable loss (Newhaven Skate Park article) and expect people who are so distraught and emotionally devastated about that topic that is being joked about and not expect a reaction that is pure raw emotion and spelling out nothing but raw facts. The truth hurts unfortunately and the truth should not be deleted or edited. If that raw emotion is taken out then its just not genuine or real and the writing lacks soul of the person who is hurting and who put their real feelings into words.
Min Beaumont
I have so enjoyed reading bass coast post articles for many years, I would be disappointed if a few trolls ruined it for all.
Catherine, she's your baby & I fully support your editorial rights 💞
Kim Veness
This kind of has to work both ways and what has happened to freedom of speech as a reaction to a writers actions, that's what you are after isn't it, a reaction?
Min Beaumont
I totally agree with your right to edit the Post Catherine as you see fit.
That’s your job.
I also totally agree in using reasoned arguments which are based on facts.
Emotional language does not fix the issues.
Frank W Schooneveldt
There are comments on this post that certainly break the rules under which I operate several organisations' popular Facebook pages. Our rules are: No personal attacking of others or name calling in the post or in the comments. No comments which do not pertain to the principles of whichever group's FB page it is, as clearly set out on their websites, e.g. constitutions and forward planning documents agreed to by the members. No swearing - even mild swearing - under any circumstances. There is so much vitriol on the internet these days and it is totally unhelpful. All it does is make people angrier, and in fact curtails rational debate. Catherine your readers may have 'ownership' of your wonderful website, but it is actually YOUR website, and you are perfectly entitled to make your rules, especially after several years of operation have taught you the hard way that some people seriously need to be given clear firm rules to abide by. It is a waste of your valuable time having to moderate everything, but stay firm and eventually everyone will get the message and all behave in a civilised manner.
Christine Grayden
Forged by fire
January 25, 2020
Thank you Laura for your personal experience of the recent fires- such tragic and dramatic disasters continue to ripple long beyond the proverbial splash; the upheaval is unimaginable but then it happens. I hope this unparalleled summer of fire shifts the nation's focus and clarifies priorities. So pleased you and yours are safe.
Jeannie Haughton
Thank you Laura for sharing your story. And thank goodness you are all safe.
Your story certainly brings home what is important.
Caring for Country, caring for people, caring for community, caring for one and another and caring about the World we leave to our Grandchildren.
Frank & Mary Schooneveldt
Laura and Terry, we are very glad your family is safe. Best wishes,
Jan Fleming and John Adam
Thanks so much for sharing, Laura. When I saw and heard you at 'Heads in the Sand' I didn't get to talk to you. I had no idea about your family. I had no idea that the climate refugees I saw from Mallacoota were your grandchildren.
I'm glad that the family is safe. They will be scarred by their experience, but on the day I noted that they seemed such brave people, and from what you say, that is true. They may also become stronger people.
Much was learnt during the Black Saturday fires about safe behaviour at times of fires. If only the media and government could learn all the lessons about climate change that the world should have been acting on many years ago. I hope that the majority of people have learnt enough to insist that we change how we act. If not now, when? If not now, who will be left to decide? If not now, will anyone have any choice?
Bron Dahlstrom
Thanks for this piece Laura. So glad your family survived, and also that the house was saved. I believe Bob and I stayed in their airbnb last year, such a nice spot. We had no idea of their connection to you.
Jenny Skewes
Thank you so much for your kind words and for your understanding. They are truly appreciated.
Terry has just finished making a short film about the Climate Action held at Inverloch that I mention in the article.
Here is the link ... https://vimeo.com/387580606
I'm really grateful to be part of a community that is awake to the importance of climate justice and the need for action.
Laura Brearley
So moving to read your personal account especially after your Black Saturday experiences. Thank you. I am so pleased they can return home already even tho it is so shocking and the smoke and ash seems to stay for a long time.
It's a long haul cleaning up and rebuilding and a community that can put forward what it wants from agerncies and govt often fairs better in the long term reconstruction.
You and Terry are truly fantastic and such a wonderful support. These events call on all our resources and more.
I love the grandchildren taking action with their posters, a positive sign amongst the aftermath.
(Re climate refugees - I'm caring for three of the family 's non laying old chooks ! )
Neri Melsmith
Thank you for your story. My Niece's Fiance Nikolai Handsjuk's Mother's house burnt down at Mallacoota and his Grandmother's was about the only one left in the street.
Caroline Giles
Weighty words
January 25, 2020
Thank you all three for your wonderful work. There certainly seems to be much talent in Gippsland. I very much look forward to reading the winning entry.
Felicia Di Stefano
Sounds like there were many fabulous entries and a challenge Catherine just to establish a short list. Looking forward to the announcement on February 9. Will this announcement be open to the public as I cannot see time that it starts.
Joy Button
Fabulous! can't wait to find out who is the winner.
Clare Le Serve
Looks great Catherine; and I wonder, might it be worth publishing the best 10 or 15 as a book?
Max Richter
A blazing star
Jan 25, 2020
Far too young to leave us - I still try not to think about this but it was a life well lived and my friend for so much of his time in the Wonthaggi area. Ricardo entered some photographs in the Show that I help organise just before he passed. Thank you Merle for encouraging him. Well anyway he did very well and was so happy with his prizes That was the last I heard about him when Merle contacted me that fateful night.To me his joy of achieving something that I was part of made me smile as well as make me cry - Loved you Ricardo - A joy to know and call a friend
Rosemary Loughnan
Ricardo, Ricardo, Ricardo !!
My elderly mother used to say when she visited Garnham House in Wonthaggi once a week.
Then some years later, she was stunned when she and a few of the residents of Griffiths Point Lodge (in San Remo) were driven to his exhibition.
What a wonderful artist, photographer, writer and very special person who gave warmth to so many people who had the privilege of meeting you and being with you.
Vale, Ricardo, may you rest in peace
Phyllis Papps
Thrills and spills
Jan 25, 2020 –
This story deserves support and reflection.
Near death experiences - all survived - mostly cherished - by those who were lucky enough to have a childhood before helicopter parenting.
We learned a confidence and love of the wild parts of our world.
Peter Brown
I enjoyed this story and did similar stuff in the 70s and 80s
Caroline Giles
Oh my goodness Liz, what you write about climbing a tree is in exact detail of what the children of Newhaven at Phillip Island did in the Grayden's Memorial Park in the 70's. The cypress trees which still stand there today as part of Newhaven's unique history and green environment and were planted in a similar fashion as the ones down Thompson Avenue in Cowes are still the main characteristics of our much loved park and township. The cypress in the park was a haven for play when children were free to roam. We too could climb up the trunk by firstly pulling ourselves up via forked branches like monkey bars. I look at the tree now and wonder how we managed to pull ourselves up
Min BeaumontBeaches closed for EasterFast forward to 2022Councillors can marina plan
Nov 27, 2020
A great summary of very challenging times for Bass Coast, Catherine. Does the community want the peace and beauty of our scenic Bass Coast with its ancient Grass Tree forest, arguably the biggest and best in Australia in perpetuity, or does it want sand and sand trucks?
At 12.30 pm today (Friday, Nov 27), Leader of Save Western Port's Coastal Forest was interviewed on Ch9 Gippsland, Tune in to Ch 5 at 5.30 pm to see and hear him.
Meryl Tobin
What's the local state government member, Jordan Crugnale, going to do about the destruction of these precious grass trees?? She seemed to be keen to progress future environmental protection prospects for the Holden Proving Ground which was commendable. The sand mine area is not that far away so hoping she is as interested in this sad issue .
Nola Smith
In response to community concerns and photographic images sent to me, last Friday (being the 27th October) I asked the Minister that DELWP staff with Earth Resources Regulation staff visit the Grantville Quarry as a matter of urgency to assess the translocation of Grasstrees at the site.”
I have contacted the Mr Viglietti and will make arrangements to visit the site in the coming weeks to learn more about their operations and grass tree translocation processes.’
I encourage the new Council to request a briefing and presentation from Sand Supplies Pty Ltd.”
I am available to also meet with representatives of the conservation group to discuss their concerns in more depth.”
The views, comments and interests of everyone in the community are important to me, we work at our best when we have all the information at hand and I look forward to having these conversations – there is a delicateness to this entire area and some work needing to be done to build relations.
Jordan Crugnale, Labor Member for Bass
How sad that these majestic grass trees are being destroyed, just when they were recovering from the bushfires. How little respect given to those who fought so hard to save the conservation area from the ravages of the bushfire.
Joy Herring
If you want to know what a politician or councillor thinks, please ask them. Then they know the concerns of the community and it gives them ammunition to fire when they go in to fight for you. When we wrote to Jordan äbout the situation this morning, she answered, I have asked the Minister that DELWP staff visit the Grantville Quarry Reserve site with Earth Resources Regulation staff as a matter of urgency to assess the translocation of Grasstrees at the site." All, please stand up and be counted on this issue. Write to councillors and politicians so they know what is important to you.
Also, if you or a group you belong to would like to go on the mailing list of Save Western Port's Coastal Forest, please write to Bass Coast Post <editor@basscoastpost.com>.
Meryl Tobin
Most definitely have and will do this. Thank you for being the guardian of the trees and the area
Ant Gent
If sand extraction from our endangered native forest is approved.
Re-forestation with native species must be immediate continuous and enforced by site inspections as part of any Government approval process for the extractive industry.
There is no justification to replace native vegetation at the industries convenience it needs to an integral part of the extraction process
Ian Samuel
A great Summary of a tragic situation for our environment Catherine. We need to fight on to protect this beautiful Bass Coast where we live
Margaret Lee
This landscape cathedral was burnt during the bush fires in Jan 2019, but because of their resilience and adversity to bush fires they were one of the few things that survived and thrived in the Grantville Nature Conservation Reserve and Adams Creek Nature Conservation Reserve. This never would have been allowed to happen if it was in for example in Mornington Shire. When dieback disease was affecting some of the areas in Mornington Nature Reserves, entire areas and road surrounding the one xanthorrhoea tree were closed off to the public to ensure the disease did not affect the tree. In May 2019 Bass Coast locals were invited to participate in Bass Coast as Distinctive Areas and Landscapes Project under the new Part 3AAB of the Planning and Environment Act 1987. This area was highlighted by myself and many other locals of priority significance, and when reviewing Phase 2 of the document this significant area has once again been ignored. Is it because it is surrounded by multiple quarries/sand mines, as well as our councils transfer station? These studies and engagement projects are fluff, and bluff, when in the end those in power and who have the dollars are the ones who are heard. Federal, State and local government as well as these greedy immoral businesses have dead xanthorrhoeas and the destruction of a whole ecosystem to answer for.
Ant Gent
It would have been a reasonable idea (now that they have been pulled out and bagged) if these begged up grass trees were donated to cranbourne botanical gardens. I have contacted them to see if they can step in. Maybe others following this issue could contact them to assist so we can at least salvage the pulled out and bagged trees?
Ant Gent
Have you heard anything back from the Gardens, Ant?
Anne Heath Mennell
No, I have not Anne, I contacted them on Saturday, so I will follow up during the week.. I have also tried contacting the Save Western Port's Coastal Forest FB page with no response, which is disappointing. It would be great if those who are concerned would get behind some sort of real solution.
Ant Gent
I can assure you the SWPCF, of which I am a Committee member, hasn't stopped trying to save the grass trees, Ant. I have already passed your suggestion onto Council who had moved to get Landcare involved. Use your passion to work with us - we're all on the same side.
Please, everyone who care about the Grass Trees, don't leave it to someone else to do something, because we are up against very tough opposition - including the State Govt who has earmarked the sand resource from Nyora-Lang Lang to Grantville for Melbourne's needs for decades.
Please join the SWPCF by writing to Bass Coast Post <editor@basscoastpost.com> asap to swell our numbers past the 100 groups and individuals who are already members.
Then write to the Quarry Manager/Diorector, Robbie Viglietti at Sand Supplies Pty Ltd at
<robbie@sabbiadevelopments.com.au>,
Program Manager, Natural Environment, Gippsland,
Mick D Bramwell (DELWP) <Mick.Bramwell@delwp.vic.gov.au>, Regional Manager, Metropolitan Melbourne | Earth Resources Regulation,
Department of Jobs, Precincts and Regions, Barry R Strong (DJPR) <barry.strong@ecodev.vic.gov.au>,
Premier Daniel Andrews <daniel.andrews@parliament.vic.gov.au>, Minister for Environment, Lily DÁmbrosio <lily.dambrosio@parliament.vic.gov.au>,
Minister for Planning,
Richard Wynne <Richard.Wynne@parliament.vic.gov.au>,
Member for Bass, Jordan Crugnale <jordan.crugnale@parliament.vic.gov.au>
and local councillors and anyone other relevant people who might be able to help that you can think of.
You only need to tell them you are appalled at what is happening to the grass trees and the Grantville Grass Tree Forest and ask them to immediately save the dying trees and stop the taking any more of the trees until after a review of the situation.
SWPCF member, Tim Herring, has checked the trees twice since last Sunday (Nov 22) when I saw them, and reports they have still not been tended to or watered.
Time is running out.
Meryl Tobin
https://sgst.com.au/2020/12/grantville-quarry-operator-rejects-environmental-vandalism-claims/
Robbie Viglietti
Lily d'Ambrosio presented Accelerating the Circular Economy organised by the CEBIC team at Sustainability Victoria #VicGoesCircular
Instead of allowing the expansion of extraction of sand in a conservation reserve, the government should promote more glass recycling for reuse like, for example:
https://www.ammann.com/au-en/news-media/news/waste-glass-becomes-high-quality-sand
I. Higgins
Paper Thin
Nov 27, 2020 -
Thank you for giving us this intimate and very moving experience.
Jeannie Haughton
Absolutely beautiful and moving. I hear your voice like quiet yet profound piece of classical music. I was swept away by your writing's internal rhythm of nature, almost like a tidal wave. When I read the photographer and the picture of the Egret, my heart soared. He is my dear husband and I'm so happy that his picture made such a significant contribution to your introspective process. Your writing certainly made a difference to my understanding of the world. Thank you.
Etsuko Yasunaga
What a beautiful comment, thank you so much Etsuko, and to hear you are Rob's partner - I can't believe it! His photo means a lot to me, please pass on my gratitude! Thank you again, Lucinda Bain
Exquisitely beautiful Lucinda. Your words are so light, delicate, divine yet hold such profound feeling. Sadness, happiness. Birth, death. Sublimely balanced. So personal, yet something we all can share. Thank-you.
Linda Cuttriss
Dear Lucinda, it was a great pleasure to meet you and the other award-winning writers of the Bass Coast Prize for Non-fiction 2020. Sunday was a very, very special occasion.
This is just a brief summation that the judges (Catherine Watson, Geoff Ellis and Anne Heath-Mennell) said about your very moving and thought-provoking article 'Paper Thin':
"From the first line we see a real writer at work: “I thought I knew something of death. Until, on the 20th of May 2016 – my 34th birthday – I found myself breastfeeding my third baby in the same room as my dead grandfather.” A slice of memoir becomes a meditation on the trajectories of births and deaths, from breath to breath. Beautifully written."
Best Wishes with your writing in the future.
Phyllis Papps
Dear Phyllis, it was such a privilege to meet you and such a wonderful group of writers on the weekend. Thank you for facilitating a fabulous opportunity for writers and making it such a wholesome experience. I am very thankful to you! Many thanks, Lucinda
Lucinda Bain
Well done, I haven't yet read it all, but it is beautifully written about the mundane and the terrible trials of life. I'll enjoy reading it all the way through during the next week.
Joan Woods
Life of a freewheeler
Nov 27, 2020
I am saddened to learn of Dave's passing, a bloke with boundless passion for all things mechanical. In earlier years he was also a very talented trumpet player, until he lost some teeth. Getting some new ones was low on the list of priorities , well behind bikes, beer and assorted other substances. Rest in peace Dave, and keep on tinkering.
Mark Robertson
Mark, interesting to read your comment. My original opening to the story was that I had been told Dave played trumpet internationally, but I could find no confirmation of that and decided it was too far fetched, even for Dave. Today at Dave's farewell do, on his front lawn, his sister Jaynie related that Dave was a member of the Victoria Youth Orchestra which toured in Europe in the 1970s. There's a great photo of him at a reception with the Lord Mayor of London. This morning's gathering was the occasion for some wonderful stories about Dave. The legend grows.
Catherine Watson
Beautifully written piece Catherine which gave me a few rueful laughs and lots of insights to Dave's life - thank you!
Hilary Stuchbery
This text I received from Dave not long before he died shows the character of the man:
"Hello mate, just remembered you rang sorry busy afternoon. had 3 Ebikes1 beginner and grandson on 6 sp 20 atx giant I just put together. I took them down the rifle range track butheaps of it was underwater. great stuff lotrs of mud 1 stall in enormous puddle which swallowed the 20 inch, that kid learned fast then followed me on thr rises on the hellish track and we made it back dry waist down. not bad I'll ring on a minute. [bike emoji}
Mark Finsterer
I find myself missing Dave to a degree disproportionate to our involvement and it is not as most who have been to our front door would suggest, have anything to do with the 14 or so bikes in various operational states. I think it was 2016 that my friend Roger had given me Dave’s number as a man of the bikes. I’d been working on the mighty Ayr Ck at the time and was appalled at the lowly value placed on bikes as judged by the seven in three weeks that I found dumped and not reclaimed through the police. Hence regular visits with yet another gem for Dave to pull into shape.
A Giant ‘Rockhopper’ ten years old with a broken gear lever or was that the 29inch Meridian? Doesn’t matter. That is when Dave revealed his online capabilities. His evident satisfaction in finding the product number of the arcane part, chasing it down, bidding at auction, winning it from locations exotic - Bentleigh to Shanghai. And of course, bagging it for the bargain basement price of a mere $12, a part, that if you could get it would retail for more like $40. No matter that he’d spent until three in the morning twice.
I can’t really say I knew Dave, but as my mum would say you treat people as you find them and I found beguiling mischief. Whether it was the range of his ebike or the ride to Kilcunda on the rail trail Dave to me had a twinkle in his eye and a smile on his dial. I have just reviewed my text messages from January till now, much humor, racing mobility scooters to rival ride-on lawn-mower racing mentioned.
We are about the same vintage and compared to Dave and his sharpness as witnessed by his bike and particularly his ebike work I’d led a relatively sheltered existence with my own tortuous take on the hand eye coordination and memory that Dave obviously had in abundance and shared with the others of his blood.
We’d been in contact in the last couple of weeks and, though crook, he insisted I drop off our ebike that needed his magic. Unfortunately, Dave in his sickness had fallen for my not uncommon failing in confusing ambition with ability, although it didn’t dent his optimism as the new tool case, bike work stand, batteries and the magnificent Giant off-road bike (to be electrified) all brought at great prices attest.
I called to see Dave on my way to Melbourne, he was wretched, I just said I wasn’t leaving, perhaps that’s what made the prospect of the ambulance and hospital the least worst option. He was bad, no matter how bad, respect was his due and dignity his right. He dressed, cleaned himself up as best he could, gathered up his belongings, said he wasn’t coming back and walked from his house.
Ed Thexton
What a wonderful article, Catherine, and a bloody brilliant cartoon by Natasha. And the last 10 days has showed me that he *was* already where he belonged; amongst excellent friends busying himself doing what he loved and sharing the results to benefit as many people as he could ... that passed his entrance exam!
Jaynee Russell-Clarke
Catherine Watson
What a wonderful article and honour to Dave.
Julie Vippond
In the flow of love and loss
Nov 27, 2020 -
Absolute tragedy for our Indigenous brethren and all lovers of this magnificent country. Hundreds of years of history wiped out in hours with a bulldozer blade. How dare the sand mining crowd - vandals of the highest order. - think their mining takes precedence over natures beauty. Where was the Minister responsible ? Probably no permission requested by the vandals, just destruction in their quest for the mighty dollar. I grieve with Auntie Fay and the rest of the People. Yvonne McRae
Yvonne McRae
Yvonne It's even worse. The sand miners did nothing wrong/illegal and did not have to seek permission/approval from anyone. They are quite free to expand and continue the destruction with the approval and encouragement of our State government. The community and Council are basically powerless to do anything. It is truly a tragedy.
Anne Heath Mennell
Shame the community were not given the opportunity to remove the grass trees and replant them. Keeping the grass trees in the area.
Debbie Gilbert
Down to business
Nov 27, 2020
How much longer can this ind of sand mining continue, at the rate of 2000 B Doubles per day? Is that correct? For something as heavy as sand, instead of wrecking roads, surely it should only ever have been allowed by rail? Considering Climate Emergency, what can be done to make rail transport mandatory?
Bernie McComb
Off to the Powlett River
Nov 27, 2020
I love this article! Please give us more like it.
Annie Chisholm
Grass tree forest, by Meryl Brown Tobin
Nov 27, 2020
Thank you, Meryl and Hartley
Carolyn Landon
Who speaks for the trees and creeks?
Nov 13, 2020
I would like to quote the Judges' comments: (Catherine Watson, Geoff Ellis and Anne Heath-Mennell): "The author mourns the loss of an avenue of beloved trees and embarks on an investigation in which she discovers the Kafkaesque world of environmental law where native vegetation can be listed on a Register of Protected Trees – and still be chain-sawed by a development company. The story is familiar but she builds a powerful narrative: heartfelt, persuasive, illuminating. This is a polemic but a restrained one, concluding with an urgent call to action."
I have planted a tree here at Rhyll to celebrate your work.
Phyllis Papps
Thank you for your passion, your artistry and your caring, Jeannie. I feel privileged to have read your cry of puzzlement and your commitment to overcoming.
Felicia Di Stefano
Jeannie I love your beautiful descriptions of childhood memories in Nature, the simplicity and wonder of it and am moved and unsettled and saddened by the tragedy of the fallen trees and the lost creek and the sodden areas. I love the way you have balanced your frustration and anger with the list of toothless strategies and plans and all the time people took to develop the Register of Significant Trees and all the other people and organisations that continue to fight and write for the trees and creeks and the climate .... and how heartbreaking it is that since you wrote this piece, one of the magnificent, sacred Djab Wurrung trees has actually been taken down! Congratulations Jeannie on your very moving, powerful call to action.
Linda Cuttriss
Thank you Linda. It was an honour to be with you alongside all the prizewinners. Aren't we fortunate to have an award that recognises non fiction and a the Bass Coast Post publishing our longform writings? I look forward to reading the others!! And yes, heartbreaking to lose the Djab Warrung Directions Tree.
We are all the losers when we destroy these ancient, culturally significant trees. It is especially mortifying that such losses are usually avoidable. (sigh)
Jeannie Haughton
Thank you Jeannie for your thought provoking article. The destruction of your local environment is a consequence of the deliberate ‘Big Australia’ policy which encourages, ‘One for the father, one for the mother and one for the country’ or an expansive migration scheme utilised by people wishing to move to greener pastures and settle here. There seems to be no concern that the environment has limitations and therefore its destruction is acceptable. Humans are like rabbits, goats or deer etc, which build up their numbers, in the absence of predators, to go past totally exploiting the environment on which they depend. The inevitable population collapse is the result. Fortunately, humans don’t need to have predators/disease to manage our numbers as we can manage our fertility to produce the numbers we want. I wondered if those people you mentioned in your article, who are defending the environment, may have also contributed in their own little way to the problems they are working towards fixing. Simply put, have they exceeded the total fertility rate (TFR) of 2.1 children per women? I hope your prize winning article starts people thinking about the connection between the environment, population and family size.
Peter Bogg
Hello Peter, Thank you for reading my article and commenting. Yes I have often thought about over population as the critical issue and key contributor to world woes. But equally so, greed and inequality.
I wonder if Western society can ever appreciate or acknowledge the enormous contribution to population control made by China and its One Child Policy? Yet the Human Rights toll, and misery of parents, especially women who found themselves unexpectedly pregnant, and the subsequent gender imbalance are the results. So nothing is black and white. It is an issue that will continue to take a toll on the world's resources for sure. Cannot answer that one.
However, I think what I have come up against is the sheer greed of some housing development companies, their inability to compromise and change their view of land and trees and animals, their refusal to see trees as an asset rather than an inconvenience, to see that they can make a contribution toward better quality of community living.
It is not hard to make a big difference. I have also discovered how inadequate the Statutory protections for the environment are. It has been an eye-opening journey for me. I agree with you that we must all do what we can, and yes getting people thinking is the aim.
Jeannie Haughton
It was with a heavy heart that I read your impassioned article. To say I felt saddened and uneasy, would be an understatement.
I found a voice in my head screaming out, how can they ignore the promises made in the past about protecting trees and vegetation. How would any of those involved in making those original decisions be feeling now. Where will the birds, animals and insects go?
I don't feel as articulate as you Jeannie, the penalties of those damaging areas, previously promised to be protected should include imprisonment.
These large development companies have clever lawyers that befuddle people easily to get their own way. I am sure they knew about sensitive areas.When they think no-one is looking and if they think they can get away with it the quickly remove plants from areas if they feel they can get away with it. All to produce urban type housing development that is ugly to my eyes, puzzling me that they are bought. Big homes on tiny properties, to bring maximum profit to the developers and the councils.
My heart is still aching as I finish up, currently sitting in remote australian community, in a spectacular area, where i come to work amongst unspoilt country. Whilst at home my council
busily finds ways of how to pack the most homes in the smallest area. Grrrr
Janet Caulfield
Thanks for comments Janet. Like a lot of areas of ethics and Law, the statutory protections for Environment are inadequate; they have fallen behind the practices that strip the land for housing. There are those who work to benefit community, and others who work only to benefit only themselves. Those who sit on a payroll or commission and work to find loopholes in the Law, those who try to find ways to grow a healthier environment and community for everyone to share.
In fact our Council has rejected permits but their decisions have been overturned at a higher level. Having said that many former Councils were decidedly pro-development. I hope the new Council is alert and active in prioritising environment and moving faster and harder to protect it.
Jeannie Haughton
Hi Jeannie, Loved your piece and share your empathy with trees. It seems to be a lack of reverence for anything other than self these days. Where it started and where it will finish is something that will be revealed in the fullness of time: when there are no trees and the ground slides from under our feet and houses.
Keep it up, each tree felled needs to be registered in a book or log.
Joan Woods
Three resolutions to consider for 2021:
Actively respect nature. Binning that errant cigarette packet in the park is a start.
Sit beneath any leafy centenarian giant, feeling its immensity and listening to its conversation with the breeze. Experience your own transience.
If you enjoy reading, act on Jeannie's recommendations. Richard Powers' Overstory resonates with this reader daily.
John Gascoigne
Thank you, Dr Mangrove
Nov 13, 2020
Thank you, Meryl for an informative tribute to a rich, useful life.
Felicia Di Stefano
What a wonderful tribute! I really enjoyed learning about the breadth of Dr Mangrove’s contributions. The two song videos by his daughter which included many photos and stories of his life were also very moving. The chorus of Wendy’s song was particularly poignant: “And he says that the planet will recover one day when we’re all extinct and well out of the way. In the meantime, he does the few things that he can to counteract the ravages and greed of man”.
Thanks Meryl for also reminding us through Tim’s example of the power of simple Sharon Willcox
communication in environmental advocacy.
Kind gentleman who advcocated for our local environment. I learnt about mangroves as a child, but Tim taught us about the true importance of these incredible plants
Michelle Graham
Thank you Meryl. Congratulations on such a well researched, beautifully written and moving tribute to our friend Tim.
Jean Coffey
Thank you Meryl. As with the Trees I have written about, so many people are quietly making A contribution and caring for the natural world around them. Vale Tim Ealey.
Jeannie Haughton
It is hard to believe the world will still keep turning without Tim. But then, there are his hundreds of Enviromental Science mafia, all the children and adults he taught, and his lovely Laura and daughters to keep it spinning.
The years I spent studying for my Master of Environmental Science, then as one of Tim's crew on the staff of the Graduate School of Environmental Science at Monash, have probably been the most influential in my life. And in the life of my family. My children and grandchildren are committed greenies. My mother was too. So the ripples of Tim's grand influence go on spreading and growing.
He was indeed a great man, a wonderful colleague and dear friend. May you find comfort in wonderful memories Laura.
Andrea Lindsay
Thank you, Meryl for this beautiful tribute. I didn't know Tim very well and I had no idea of the extent of his achievements. He will be sorely missed but what an incredible beneficial impact he had on the world - what a legacy he leaves. As Andrea says, the ripples will keep on spreading well into the future. Be assured that those of us who knew him will continue his work, especially in Western Port, as best we can. Condolences to Laura anf Vale Tim the Warrior!
Anne Heath Mennell
Bass Coast puts out the welcome mat
Nov 13, 2020
Yeah, a big warm welcome to our Congo Republic Australians. May your new life in the beautiful Bass Coast be safe, healthy and successful. Xxx
Sharon
Nature’s showtime
Nov 13, 2020
Linda, what a beautifully written and sensitive article about your passion for nature, our environment and our wild life. Your incredible observations have been matched with superb photos.
Phyllis Papps
Fabulous description of nature at your place Linda.
Congratulations on winning the Bass Coast Literary Award.
Janet Fleming
A picture worth a thousand words? You’ve changed the equation, Linda: fifty pictures, five-hundred words.
John Gascoigne
Flying high
Nov 13, 2020
Thank you for this thoughtful piece, Etsuko. You show such empathy for the birds. I especially love your last line, 'Birds, those beautiful winged creatures, ought to fly as they belong to the free sky.'
Birds in cages seems so wrong. This was never brought brought home to me as clearly as it was when I visited the NT and saw a large flock of budgerigars take off. It was a wonderous sight.
Injured birds do sometimes need to be kept in cages by wildlife carers. These carers often feel quite attached to the birds they help to heal, but feel very excited when they are able to release them.
Bron Dahlstrom
A beautiful ‘tale’. Thank you for sharing. I too had two bird stories this week. Our lives continue to be entwined. The Tie that Binds x
Pip
I love your experiences and the outcome of the meeting with the birds.
Like Bron I love them in the sky, not in cages.
Verena
Virus diaries 16
Nov 13, 2020
I always read your Virus diaries first Catherine. So interesting. A couple of weeks in your Wonthaggi gives us everyday and some outstanding characters and events to muse upon. Those last two words you wrote in capitals - maybe we need to share Post Virus impressions when the hordes hit our town?
Sue Packham
Although I have enjoyed every day of your Covid diaries, this one is the best. So many good stories. Thank you for sharing your reactions and interactions with friends and family both local and abroad. As another commented, this has always been the first thing I read. Will miss it.
Janice Orchard
The virus diaries remind me of my early life, growing up in a quieter,more natural Wonthaggi, roaming the backlanes and beaches with my mates. The recent onslaught of urban visitors and big brands makes me realise that I grew up in an absolute paradise. Could the incoming council please recognise this and plan to preserve our local nirvana, and hopefully not allow our home to become yet another " suburban dream". With regard to the pumpkin competition, next year the competitors should be provided with seeds from locally - fecund plants. They will bloom and grow well, and should not cost anything.
Mark Robertson
Catherine, We did first visit Cape Woolamai in late 60's and by early 70's bought a block of land on first stage of Cape Woolamai Estate .
Unmade roads, no drainage but we camped on it and fell in love with the area. Built a small house by early 80's and our 2 sons and now 5 grand children just love the whole area. Roads in/out issue for few weeks each year but rest of the year it's easy to get around, and the new roundabout will make access much easier at peak times. One big advantage is if the winds blowing say on the Backbeach just walk across to
the bay beach in few minutes and your out of it. When the tides out you can walk for klms on the beach have a look at the Colonnades superb.
Chris Day
Thanks very much Catherine, I have enjoyed your diaries over the months. Regards, Jan.
Janet Fleming
Thanks for allowing us to follow your journey during COVID Catherine. I have enjoying following it all and hope to continue to keep contact as we fight for our beautiful backyard especially in the sandmining areas.
Margaret Lee
Green, green hills of home
Nov 13, 2020
So glad that you are enjoying Inverloch, Sharon. Welcome. I've been living in Inverloch for 11 years and love the Bass Coast.
Congratulations on your decision to give up flying. It is great to see that many others are making this same decision. One good thing about the pandemic is that it has put a break on the amount of flying that people do, although it worries me that once things open up, people may go crazy.
I must admit that last year I flew to Japan and had a wonderful holiday. I learnt a great deal and met many wonderful people. I do think that travelling to other countries opens our minds to new worlds, yet if we keep flying the way we have been, the world will change so much that not only will future generations not be able to fly, they will inherit a world that we cannot even imagine. I'm hoping that flight in electric planes that give no emissions will become commonplace in the not too distant future, although I doubt that I will be here for that. Such a plane took flight in May this year. It was able to take 9 passengers and could only fly 100 kms, and only the pilot flew in it for the test run. But big things grow from small beginnings.
Now we need governments all over the world to do the right thing. Our government won't even commit to zero emissions by 2050. That would be a start, but even that is too little too late.
Bron Dahlstrom
Aunty Fay’s mission
Nov 13, 2020
What a wonderful story of the life and times of Aunty Fay. Absolutely time for recognition of this excellent woman's heritage and public service. I agree with the rubbish history as taught at school. As an older person we did BRITISH history at secondary school. I remember asking why we didn't do Australian history but was told British was the curriculum study. As a primary school teacher myself I made sure the students at Wonthaggi North heard the Dream time Stories, watched the films available about the people of the Western Desert, heard about the Boon Wurrung people of our area and the middens etc. still here from thousands of years ago. I still remember a boy in a Grade 4 saying, 'Mrs. McRae you said that in the desert they didn't have hospitals, so where did those children come from'.
Yvonne McRae
Aunty Fay Stewart-Muir is a legend. A wonderful teacher and linguist, always sharing her aboriginal culture with others including so many children (who love her)
Aunty Fay is exactly the woman who the creators of the Victorian Women's Honour Roll knew should be celebrated for their immence contributions to Victorian community.
The Victorian Women's Honour Roll was established by the Bracks Labour Government, following recommendations by former Premier Joan Kirner, that part of the Centenary of Federation 2001,
"Women Shaping the Nation" should be run for 12 months. Hugely successful, The Honour Roll has been extended indefinitly.
Aunty Fay is a national treasure. And the Honour Roll keeps celebrating such women.
Im asking that people now understand that the request for nominations for the Roll are annual. Start thinking about nominating a remarkable woman you know.
Kay Setches
Old hands, fresh faces on new council
Nov 7, 2020
Congratulations to all councillors voted into office and congratulations and thank you to all councillors who have served Bass Coast over the last four years.
Thanks to live-streaming of Council, the public has been able to see and hear what goes on in Council and who says and does what. At the May meeting, we were pleased to hear every councillor speak in favour of Cr Clare Le Serve's motion asking the Council to approach the State Government to buy the GMH Proving Ground at Lang Lang to preserve the site's environmental, cultural and coastal habitat values. All councillor put forward powerful arguments, worked as a team and voting unanimously for the motion.
At the June meeting, it was refreshing to see an almost repeat performance regarding the proposed Maher's Landing marina, with councillors unanimously rejecting the unpopular proposal.
Hearing councillors understand such important issues gives electors heart and energizes them to keep working for common goals. As a conservationist who has worked for decades to preserve out natural environment from unsustainable development, I have been impressed at this development in Council and hope this move to advocate for and to protect our Shire's Distinctive Areas and Landscapes continues.
A special congrats and thank you to former Cr Geoff Ellis for his enormous contribution to protect the Holden Proving Ground site and the Grantville Grass Tree Forest. Not only did he work hard for the community in this area, but he was at the forefront of all movements to improve life for Bass Coast residents and visitors. You will be missed, Geoff. All the best in this new chapter of your life.
Meryl Tobin
Congratulations everyone, welcome back and welcome. I look forward to achieving zero emissions very soon, a solar plant with batteries, enough social housing and care for those in our shire who are unable to cope with our complex society, a recycling plant and higher rates to enable us to afford such progressive, compassionate development. I know that Geoff Ellis was a hard worker towards social housing. We will miss his input.
Felicia Di Stefano
Congratulations to all of the newly elected councillors. Issues to be corrected moving forward are of the utmost importance.
The red landfill garbage bin pick up in peak times and a complete public review of all garbage, recycle and green waste contracts must happen. Revision of the Media Engagement Policy 2020, the Transparency Policy 2020, the Investment Policy 2020, the Procurement Policy 2020, increasing the 50 word limit to 100 or 150 for community question time and reporting full details in the annual report for councils Capital Works Program Status % and full financials and a fully detailed report included as an attachment in the Annual report for all Capital Works Projects not expensed or completed at years end 30 June of a year. Ratepayers who pay rates including our newly elected councillors have a right to be presented with these missing reports and corrections of policy or contact matters. Changes are over due. The Audit and Risk Committee and its Charter must step up and target necessary important changes. I look forward for our councillors, the board of council taking control and lead instead of following.
Graham Jolly
Hopefully this new Council will listen to the Community that elected them to represent them. Geoff Ellis not being returned to Council was as a result of his attitude at public meetings in San Remo and Newhaven to Council concerns. Clare has gone from number 2 on the ticket to No 3 without the Virus impacting on areas around S R /Cape Woolamai/ Newhaven having many ratepayers unable to visit their property's for 7 months there may well have been more candidates standing. The demo graphics in this part of Bass Council area between permanent and non permanent ratepayers is significantly different but it showed in the Public Meetings on Issues like Skate Park and Local internal roads that ratepayers love this area whether there living there full or part time. It's not a cheap area to own a property with Bass Coast rates considerably more expensive than many suburbs of Melbourne with similar property values.Now Melbourne restrictions have been lifted the local businesses will get a significant lift in turn over. Obviously until overseas tourism returns the visitors from rest of Victoria is critical for the Bass economy.
chris day
Chris, that seems a very illogical explanation of Geoff Ellis’s demise since all three Western Port councillors were at the meeting you describe and they were all subjected to extreme rudeness from a largely hostile crowd of some 150 people. One of those councillors topped the poll.
Maybe, now that Trump has met his demise, we can all start treating one another with more courtesy, even people with whom we disagree.
Catherine Watson
Catherine, I am not sure how Chris's post is discourteous. Were you at that meeting in San Remo? I was. It didn't start out hostile and "extreme rudeness' is slightly overstating the situation. Perhaps when people express their disagreement with what council is proposing that constitutes extreme rudeness. Several people advised the councilors of the physical and practical problems to building a skate park on the San Remo foreshore. The councilors dismissed those concerns out of hand. It was the total disregard of the concerns of the community that caused the residents to become irate. Some of the concerns raised at this meeting and lambasted by the councilors were in fact the actual reason why the San Remo foreshore was abandoned as a venue for the skate park. The reason, in a democracy, that we have elections is that we are able to express our dissatisfaction with sitting members by voting them out of office. I agree with Chris and consider if there had been more candidates there may have been more changes. Councilors are voted in to represent the residents and rate payers and be their voice in council. If the voters perceive that they are not taking this responsibility seriously they will vote them out at the next election. Assuming there are enough candidates.
TREVOR BROWN
At Screw Creek
Oct 31, 2020 –
Dear Linda, an absolutely brilliant piece of long-form Non-fiction.
So much research, so many memories, so personal and a wonderful piece of pioneer local history AND the search for truth. A superb merging and combination of so many elements to your story.
Accolades and orchids to you. !!!!
Warm Regards, Phyllis Papps
Great story and thank you for preserving this history. Also thank your brother and community for preserving the area. Without you and your brother, we would lose our sense of place and time which gives us an understanding of how we have come to be where we are now.
Peter Bogg
Thanks Peter for your heart-warming comments. To preserve the history and acknowledge the community's conservation of the precious bushland at Screw Creek was what I was hoping to do.
And a huge thank-you to Phyllis Papps for your generous Bass Coast Prize for Non-fiction and for your time and effort. The competition gave me the impetus to write this story (I had a deadline and knew someone would read it) and it gave me the opportunity to challenge myself. But much more than that, over the past two years 86 pieces of writing have been produced about Bass Coast and Gippsland that might not otherwise have been written. A priceless archive of stories and knowledge.
And many thanks to the Bass Coast Post and Waterline News for auspicing the Prize and to Catherine Watson, Geoff Ellis and Anne Heath Mennell for giving your time as judges.
Linda Cuttriss
Congratulations Linda. I loved reading the intertwining of your family's stories and the history of the area. I wonder if more evidence will surface one day about the fate of Lizzie.
Julie Constable
Lovely story, beautifully written, I'll look at the area through another lens now...thanks.
Brian Carr
A moving story Linda. Growing up with you in Inverloch I had no idea of these stories and the history of the Screw Creek area. I was impressed by the way you wove together: your exploratory return journey with John; your family history and links to the area; the history of the area itself, including its more recent conservation story; and the history of the First People who cared for the country. I have bits and pieces of stories from my great grandparents who were also pioneers in Inverloch. Your story has inspired me to try to learn more about their lives while my mother and her aunt are still alive. Thanks Linda and congratulations on the well deserved first prize award.
Marion Brown
So well crafted, Linda. I love the sense of layering, the peeling back of each story to reveal something deeper; the crisscrossing of paths made over time. There’s such humility and respect in this.
Gill Heal
A reflection on depression (and COVID)
Oct 30, 2020 –
Thanks Tim. It is so ironic that one of the big customers for Tim's book is a company which puts so many chemical.additives in its products. Food additives are so prevalent in our diets for the last 50 years, and burgeoning still. That, I suspect, contributes more to health issues generally than anything! And of course there are lots of them in medications. Tim's main point of community support is spot on though!
Christine Grayden
Thanks Tim for your insightful and timely thoughts. Even an easing of this COVID lockdown presents its challenges: which of the old habits, jettisoned over all these months, do I pick up again. And Bob has a voice in all this. On my daily runs around our parks, the plethora of dogs has shown what mankind can be: innocent and curious, non-judgemental, loyal and loving, and able to appreciate (sniff out?) the wonders of life.
John Gascoigne
Thank you so Tim much for this critical, timely, well reasearched and most of all compassionate piece. Ideally, it will help us all to remember how to genuinely care for each other.
Sharon Hurley
There is room for revision in some of the points made. For instance anger is a great outlet for depression after having tried to help yourself help is not always readily available..
Joan Woods
Please share our journey
Oct 30, 2020
Can't wait until the 8th :)
Stephen Edge
Unfortunately, I’ve needed to postpone the NAIDOC Week online art workshop until further notice. Thank you for all the positive interest in it so far.
Safina Stewart
Safina, such beautiful and evocative words, reflecting the intensity and complexity of your artistic endeavour, and echoing the strength and passion of the Uluru Statement from the Heart. 'This is the magnificence of our people' indeed. Your cultural, spiritual and creative expression through your art, and your family's and community's, is truly magnificent. Art that speaks to the ancientness of your lineage and the sacredness of your land. I hope many, many people will come to the Celebration of Indigenous Artists to meet you where you (and your fellow artists) are at.
Marg Lynn
Sand miner digs in
Oct 30, 2020
To whom it may concern,
Please don’t let the sand mine to be constructed in the vegetated section of this land. There is plenty of open land that could be used instead.
The loss of the vegetated area will take out a significant nature link between The Gurdies Nature Conservation Reserve and Deep Creek down to the Grantville Nature Conservation Reserve and Colbert Creek. Regeneration is a smoke screen, it will take years if ever to come back to the state it’s currently in.
Don’t let these companies who have pillaged from their part of Victoria come and devalue the Bass Coast.
Once it’s gone, it gone forever & then these companies have crept in and changed the very fabric & integrity of pristine land.
I love the Bass Coast, it is good for the soul to come breathe fresh air & enjoy the beautiful areas you have, don’t let your rich, vibrant area become an industrial wasteland.
The result of the community action was the "Regional Sand Strategy - Lang Lang to Grantville" ratified by the then Minister for Planning and incorporated into the relevant Planning Schemes.
Anne M Westwood
Thank you, AGL
Oct 30, 2020 –
Thank you Neil, Excellent article. We must continue the fight and preserve Western Port.
Clare Le Serve
Well written Neil. The remarkable community response highlights the importance of preventing the AGL plan. Following the Ministers decision in early 2021 the ultimate end game rests with the AGL Board who claim they will not proceed without “social licence”. Given the current reactions how can such a licence exist? Yes we do need to see commitments for permanent industrial protections for Western Port.
Jeff Nottle
Shannon Hurley's excellent article in VNPA's Sept Parkwatch p13, provides a sobering visual of what the Crib Point Gas Import facility could look like.
Anne Paul
Music inspired by the places we love
Oct 30, 2020
Congratulations Laura and all composers, what a great line up!
Irene Proebsting
All aboard for Wonthaggi
Oct 16, 2020
Totally agree with Cliff. We need a railway line for many and all the reasons Cliff raised. We also need councillors with a clear vision for the future, that don't just follow what has been set as the norm for this area. Why, in this day and age, haven't we got what should be basic for life anywhere, a railway line?
Monica Smith
They should NOT of taken the train service away ..Lets get it BACK NOW.......Robert Hayward Cape Paterson
Robert Hayward
It would be a world class tourist attraction and provide a much needed transport link. I mostly travelled to Melbourne by train when I lived in Echuca as many others did. However now I live in Inverloch the public transport service from this area is so bad most people don’t use it
Rhonda Sutton
Fully agree
Paul Bickerstaff
To make public transport viable, many, if not all of us, need to abandon our so called love affair with our cars. If it seems unthinkable, some of us remember life before cars, not much more than 50 years ago. Why prolong the agony? If cars bend priorities out of shape, how about charges to hasten their demise?
Bernie Mccomb
I am opposed to the reintroduction of passenger rail from the city to Wonthaggi. Am I alone in coming to this beautiful area because of its rural surrounds? I believe an easy commute to the city will turn Wonthaggi into a "bedroom suburb" for Melbourne workers who will build housing development after housing development on the land around our town and destroy any "country" feel that we still enjoy. Do we really want Wonthaggi to be another Bendigo or Ballarat, both of which have populations over the 100,000 mark - you might as well live in the city. This is a gut response to Peter's article, but if you can assure me that zoning laws etc. would ensure over-development would not follow the reintroduction of passenger rail, I'd be pleased to hear it.
Carol Cox
Life before cars was much more adventurous, imagine not spending so much time in traffic jams and hustling for car park spots?
Bernie McComb
Agree with you Carol. A recent trip to Japan showed me how to make rail viable, just add lots and lots and lots of people.
P.S rail would never be rebuilt on top of the dunes at Kilcunda.
Jeff Sim
I don't think you need to worry carol, passenger railway services are only maintained to big cities and towns like the ones you mentioned. Wonthaggi/Inverloch certainly will not be getting a rail service before the combined population reaches 100,000.
Step O'Rafferty
I have had the pleasure to spend short amounts of time from Melbourne in Wonthaggi late last year whilst my daughter was doing her medical internship at the local hospital. Similarly at Bendigo when she was at the hospital there prior. I fully agree Wonthaggi charm needs to be preserved and not be overrun with population. A nice weekend sea -side resort would do me fine. But a train service could add to the charm and keep the automobiles away especially on the busy Bass Hwy. However, that will require an optimum population density to be viable and that needs very harsh and enforceable zoning rules to avoid becoming Gold Coast overnight.
Some of the old country rail services in Europe and Britain have been revived by community involvement but these are few and far between. Mostly these have shut for good.
https://www.sbs.com.au/ondemand/program/walking-britains-lost-railways
(interesting stories here). Victoria did not fare any better once the mining and timber carriage was over.
Sam
It's a "NO BRAINER"! The recommissioning of the line is essential for the growth and development of the region and to ease pressure on the already congested road system to and from Melbourne.
Lou Pecora
Trains are a wonderful way to travel and allows people who don't have cars to move around without too much cost. A well managed service that allows people to see the beauty of Gippsland from a quiet window seems good for our communities, the environment, businesses and employment. especially if there is a carriage for bike storage.
Tricia O'Brien
To rebuild railway infrastructure to Wonthaggi on which trains could operate as fast as the current buses would cost at least a billion dollars. If it was built the line would be better off branching from the mainline at Lang Lang so it could serve the coastal towns and then after departing Bass, rejoin the old formation on the climb from Woolamai to Anderson. The current bus service takes 53 minutes to run from Lang Lang to Wonthaggi. The train journey was 84 minutes. I don't think any state government would be willing to invest that much in the Bass Coast region for a rail service.
Step O'Rafferty
Bird heaven
Oct 16, 2020
Loved reading about this Liane and seeing all the beautiful birds that are visiting you. Though we haven't got much of a back garden to plant many things, I'm going to do what I can to attract as many of these beautiful creatures as I can. Thanks for such an entertaining read!
Monica Smith
Surely your brilliant waratah bush will bring them in hoards!
Liane Arno
Lovely article Liane. I recall the weeds & blackberries on our side of the fence were just as thick as yours.
Joanne
A great story, thanks for sharing it.
Tricia O'Brien
What a stunning array of visitors you have Liane. What a joy. Beautiful photos. Hope they all turn up next week for the Aussie Bird Count!
Linda Cuttriss
Such beautiful birds and photographs Liane. What a joy after all your hard work
Margaret Lee
History with a twist wins non-fiction prize
Oct 16, 2020
What a fabulous event. congratulations to all winners and participants. looking forward to a few good reads coming up in the future.
Tricia O'Brien
Congratulations Linda and all the winners and highly commended. I'm looking forward to reading them all.
Julie Constable
Eagles Nest, by John Mutsaers
Oct 16, 2020
Special Place and lovely hues and Characters like 'Boober' expressing time enjoyed with those on holiday times. I remember when a one week per year, for a holiday visiting other places, remains memorable. Long walks/hikes in Fern Gullies Otways, time up the Alps late season so deep snow and crispy 6am walk/warm ups for a good day/week and yep, Coastal Burgs now more worried by tides and changes.
Tropical locations/nations share rapid change and may require assistance/s, those living safe places can assist.
Jillian Verhardt.
Harmers, by Catherine Watson
Oct 16, 2020
thank you Catherine, my school Latin has faded, but I know the light, the ripple & crash of the tide, the cacophony of a dawn chorus. I know also the winter by the ocean is perfect.
VC Hamilton
Councillor in corruption probe
Sept 25, 2020
First with the news once again. Thank you Catherine
Felicia Di Stefano
Well researched Catherine as usual. I hope there are more details BEFORE ratepayers are to vote in the upcoming election. Yvonne
Yvonne McRae
Unfortunately for the community a catch 22 situation.
As the accused is not guilty until proven, but if found guilty after the election this will require a by election to replace an elected councilor.
Ian Samuel
Just like to let everybody know it is not me being investigated, that is the only comment I can and will make at this stage. Regards Brett
Brett Tessari
Well done Brett. Now we know one councilor it isn't. Perhaps if the rest of the innocent councilors could advise that it's not them we would have a better idea of who it is. So much for loyalty Brett????? All councilors who have put their hands up as it not being them should hang their collective heads in shame. Rather than this being a reason for returning them i would think it a better reason for not.
Trevor Brown
This is unfortunate and leads inevitably to speculation on the whole group. I can say that I have not seen any instance of corruption in my time and respect all of my colleagues on the Council. I am placed in a position of having to affirm my innocence and can further confirm that I was interstate at an Australian Coastal Council conference at the time the alleged incident occurred.
Michael Whelan
Thanks for bringing light to this important issue, Catherine. I hope we find out more before the election!
Mikhaela Barlow
The timing does make the accusation very suspect, I hope we are not having state style politics intruding into our local government democratic process.
Jeni Jobe
It has come to my attention that the Victorian Local Government Inspectorate is investigating alleged corruption allegations of a Bass Coast Councillor.
I would like to state that I am not under investigation by IBAC. I fully understand the legal rules and responsibilities of being a Councillor and as this is a legal matter and I am unable to make any further comments.
Cr Clare Le Serve
Just confirming that I am not under investigation by IBAC. I fully understand the legal rules that IBAC work under and it would be inappropriate and possibly unlawful for me to make any further comment.
Cr Bruce Kent
I am aware that a media outlet has released comments that a Bass Coast Councillor is under investigation by IBAC.
I can confirm that I am not under investigation by IBAC.
I fully understand the legal structure that IBAC operates under.
It would be inappropriate and possibly unlawful for me to make any further comment.
Cr Geoff Ellis
Wow. Shades of Hillary in 2016. Given the alleged incident was at least a couple of years ago (if under previous CEO) why is it being made public now and by whom? If every Councillor confirms it is not them, the person involved will not remain anonymous for much longer, with all that implies for the election campaign. What a terrible way to end a hardworking Council which has achieved so much.
Anne Heath Mennell
Hmmmm.. As a rate payer, there is a lot to answer, however, this would not be the first in the last 100yrs and won't be the last
Theresa A O'Dea
The timing of this news is very unfortunate.
Especially since according to the Sentinal this complaint was lodged two years ago.
I sincerely hope that the Bass Coast elections doesn’t descend into gutter politics. All candidates should be judged on their promises and/or their track record in office.
Ronnie Bauer
Ronnie, I fully agree with your comment.
Cr Geoff Ellis
I think the leaking of this information is regrettable and that on-sharing of it is irresponsible, given that the person is not able to be named.
This puts other councillors in a position of having to publicly state their non-involvement, as seen in above comments.
By omission, the person under investigation may end up being identified. This is not fair and not helpful to the investigation process.
Julie Thomas
This investigation has now been reported in detail in today's Age newspaper.
In view of upcoming council elections, the legal question is can a serving councilor continue to be on council or be nominated for re-election when subject to an IBAC investigation.
This needs urgent clarification by the bass Coast CEO Ali Wastie prior to election voting
Ian Samuels
Disgraceful action by who ever leaked this information. If it's right that this was in regard to "something that happened 2 years ago" even worse. If that proves to be right even more explanation by Bass Coast CEO is required or as suggested should go to IBAC.
Our Community overall has little trust in Bass Coast Council and the way it operates but for most of us there are more important things happening in our lives than local government issues. Great shame this election is being held at this time when a large number of rate payers can't even visit their property's in Bass Coast Area Yet the Bills keep flowing in!! After the "performance" of our 3 local Councillors in regard to the Public Meeting in San Remo on the Skate Park the 3 existing local councillors re standing for election are very lucky they are not standing against a number of candidates. Any other year they would
be.
Christopher Day
I disagree with you Ian, that’s not a legal question that that needs to be answered because, surely the answer is already obvious.
Firstly, the allegations are unproven, and have not been yet tested by either IBAC or VLGI.
Secondly, the requirements of the Act will already be well known to Councillors, the CEO and council administrators.
Indeed, the Sentinel Times is now reporting that the matter was reported to IBAC back in October 2018, but went uninvestigated at the time. (Perhaps IBAC determined the matter did not merit further investigation?)
I have no doubt that the CEO and/or the Victorian Electoral Commission will have already made Cr. Larke aware as to what the legal requirements are. As Cr. Larke and other Councillors have publicly acknowledged, they are legally bound by confidentiality.
However it remains in the interests of justice that the following public questions to be put to CEO Ali Wastie:
• Will the CEO also refer to IBAC the allegation that a Councillor (or someone at council) leaked this sensitive and confidential information to the media?
• Will the CEO conduct an internal investigation into who at Council may have leaked this sensitive and confidential information to the media?
• Does the CEO have any idea already as to who at Council might have leaked this sensitive and confidential information to the media?
One question I’m certain that the community already knows the answer to is why the sneak(s) released this sensitive and confidential information to the media on the eve of Council elections.
Kevin Griffin
Kevin Yes Firstly I agree that the leak of this confidential and sensitive information must be immediately investigated as it improper and is prejudicial.
Secondly although it is no doubt already known by the CEO if there is a legal restriction on a candidate facing election, the community needs to be advised now that this has been leaked into the public domain so that elections can proceed without further damage being done to public confidence or individual integrity
Ian Samuel
Ian, I have no doubt that if there were any legal restriction that point would have been flagged to the community and BCP from some source by now. Possibly even by the person(s) that leaked the information.
But as you point out, some community members would like to know the answer to your question, and quickly.
Now I’m willing to wager that Catherine has Ali’s number, and that Ali would take her call. On that basis I recommend that Catherine call Ali now.
That way Catherine gets the scoop, and the rest of us get to know the answer to your question as soon as is possible.
What do you think?
Kevin Griffin
Catherine I observe that you have censored out my questions to each of the comments published by the Councillors individually.
Do you wish to offer your readers the courtesy of an explanation of your action?.
Kevin Griffin
Kevin, I haven't censored you. You've made your point. Once is enough.
Catherine Watson, editor
Before some post readers lose track of the issue at stake here I would like to pose several questions. Firstly, was it appropriate for a councillor to allegedly attempt to buy votes from other councillors in order to wear the mayoral robes? Secondly, was it the right thing to do to refer this to the proper authorities? Thirdly, was it sensible to keep this from ratepayers and voters for two years? Finally, I would ask readers to please not "shoot the messenger".
Mark Robertson
Hi Mark, couldn't agree more that it is not appropriate for a councilor to allegedly buy votes from other councilors in order to wear the Mayoral robes. If in fact this happened it is the right thing to do to refer it to the proper authorities. It appears that this was done some two years ago and IBAC has not done anything about it. This would, at face value, suggest that there may not have been any substance to the allegation. Therefore it was probably proper to not have this matter in the public domain. We don't know who the messenger is and his or her motives for taking this action. I think that this should be referred to the proper authorities not because of what the leak was about but, because the leak occurred at all.
Trevor Brown
I have had first-hand dealings with Councillor Les Larke over the past couple of years. I have found him to be a diligent and committed Councillor. In my experience, he has returned phone calls and taken the time to speak to me. He has provided considered responses to requests for information and feedback, where other Councillors have not even responded. In my dealings with him, he has also referred matters I have raised with Council Officers and ensured that matters were addressed.
Sharon Harrison
Sharon, I totally agree with you in relation to councilor Larke. I have also had occasion to ask Councilor Larke for assistance. I found him responsive and informed and prepared to give concise and unbiased responses. It may be a coincidence but, at the time this matter was apparently referred to IBAC, Councilor Larke had been raising questions about the financial operation of the council. I also agree that it would be a crying shame if this councilor was not re-elected.
Trevor Brown
Councillor Larke has been an advocate of greater transparency. I note that at the Council Meeting on 18 September 2019 Councillors Les Larke and Julian Brown were the only Councillors to vote against the Motion by Councillors Pamela Rothfield and Geoff Ellis to block the Bass Coast Shire Council Meeting Livestreaming Policy 2019. Councillors Stephen Fullarton, Clare Le Serve, Brett Tessari, Michael Whelan and Bruce Kent all supported the motion to block the livestreaming of Council meetings.
Sharon Harrison
I totally agree with the questions Mark Robinson has raised.
I note that in the Australian High Court there is mandatory retirement of judges when they reach 70 years of age. In my option this should also apply to all levels of government in order to reduce the likelihood of extraordinary decisions.
Frank W Schooneveldt
I have to disagree with you here. The reason I voted for Councillor Larke at the last election is that he comes to the Council with a great deal of experience in financial management and governance. Councillor Larke is the former general manager at State Trustees and a certified practising accountant of CPA Australia.
Sharon Harrison
Sharon, Irrespective of these new allegations Les Larke has done so much damage to our Council particularly for misleading his follow councillors re the the Shire finances and his judgement that we were living beyond our means. Analysis of the various budgets showed that this was not so.
The overturning of the $17 million Cowes Cultural Centre is a case in point. Here we are four years later and we are only now starting the $19 million Cowes Cultural Centre.
That’s four years of wasted time and I hate waste. It’s time we never get back.
IBAC and the VLGI need to rapidly assess these serious allegations.
Frank W Schooneveldt
I agree with Frank W Schoonveldt regarding the need for an expedited resolution of the IBAC and VLGI investigations. I also concur with Kevin Griffin that, given that the alleged incident was referred to IBAC in 2018, perhaps IBAC determined at the time that action was not warranted?
Turning to the age of Councillors I would like to add the further comment that, given that according to the 2016 Census the median age in Bass Coast is 50 and we have higher number of senior citizens, we need older people's voices on our Council.
My final point is that while some in community may disagree with Councillor Larke's actions as a Councillor, ultimately it is up to the voters in the Bunurong Ward to decide if they will re-elect him, as he is elected to represent this Ward.
Sharon Harrison
I agree the timing of leaking this information is political, and indicative of dirty politics. The Councillors who have let us know it wasn't them, I feel, were forced to declare their innocence. Overall I find the BCC progressive, trying hard to cover issues of human rights, the environment and local infrastructure.
Robyn Smith
Catherine, I see that your censorship of my posts is increasing.
Would you be so kind as to offer your readers and myself the courtesy of an explanation for your censorship actions?
Kevin Griffin
There are many things I have come to like about the Bass Coast Post since its inception eight years ago, but three stand out.
1. The number of people in our community with whom I have become acquainted through reading their articles and comments. Many of these I have not met physically, yet I feel I know them.
2. The standard that requires contributions to be made in a civil, respectful and non-defamatory manner. This is not an impediment to expressing ourselves passionately but it obliges us to express ourselves in a mature and responsible fashion befitting a civil society.
3. Every article is accompanied by the name of the person who wrote it.
Keep up the good work, Catherine, and thank you to all the contributors, including the Councillors, who have used this forum to keep us informed and to share their impressions and experiences of civic service.
John Coldebella
Pamela Rothfield Q&A
Sept 14, 2020 –
What a fantastic article Catherine, Pam is an amazing person and we are so lucky to of had her representing not only Island but the whole shire so energetically and passionately. Well done Pam, time to dust of the clubs.
Brett Tessari
Thankyou Pamela for great service to the Bass Coast community, if only we could retain your services, but it sounds like it's time to reclaim your life as your own.
Neil Rankine
Thanks Pam, for your positive encouragement. I really appreciated your input and good council you gave to the arts community. I wish you well. Kind regards
John Mutsaers
Thank you Pam for the quality of capable and compassionate leadership which you;ve demonstrated throughout your years on Council. The positive contributions you have made will continue to be felt in the years to come.
Laura Brearley
Thank you Pam for your four years of extraordinary commitment. I look forward to your next achievements for PI in your other community roles; but also to your being able to play lots of golf!
Christine Grayden
Pamela - A wonderful contribution as Mayor and Councillor. Besides a true lady in every thought, shape and form. Well done!,
Sincerely, Mohan de Run
Thank you Pamela Rothfield for your great contribution to the beautiful Bass Coast. Your achievements are to be congratulated.
We have five million people on our door step that now due to the pandemic are realising what a wonderful place the Bass Coast is and they will come. We need to be able to cater for growth in our population in a sustainable way. By increasing our population it will create a larger revenue so that we can finally “ fix the pot holes”.
Frank W Schooneveldt
thank you Pamela! I remember telling people back in 2016, "she's committed and very capable." I was thrilled when you were elected so easily - but not surprised. Our community is all the better for your devoted contribution over the years.
Natasha Crestani
Thanks Pam for your dedication and commitment as a Councillor. Your support and advocacy for important infrastructure and services have ensured the community of Bass Coast can face the future with confidence.
Anne Davie
A wonderful inspiring article. Pamela, we haven’t met but your words regarding negativity resonated with me - so well expressed. Let’s embrace the positive dreams and achievements. Thank-you for your service to our community.
Lyn Bennett
May I add my sincere thanks to you as well, Pamela? I thank you for all the reasons written above as well as for your beautiful encouraging smile. Whenever I spoke to the council I was drawn to and encouraged by your smile. The secret of your success and popularity is that you treat each individual with sincere respect. Enjoy your leisure time.
Felicia Di Stefano
Pamela, with the positive vibe you bring to every endeavor it's not surprising that your advocacy leadership enjoyed great success. You and Brett formed a formidable team. Commitment to LG is a thankless and exhausting task. Your contribution has been outstanding. Time to smell a few roses.
Wayne Moloney
Thanks Pam, it was great working with you. You showed great professionalism and leadership with this Council and we achieved a great deal as a team with your guidance. Best Wishes
Clare Le Serve
As an outsider looking in on Council it was very clear that you have both given your all and done an excellent job. Thank you very much. You are a great role model for whoever gets elected.
Michael Nugent
Birdman of Cape Paterson
Sept 14, 2020 –
What a wonderful place to be living at THE CAPE with nature
We have always been supporters of the ( ECO Village ) THE CAPE
Virginia & Robert Hayward
Fabulous photographs and fascinating to read about the bird life in The Cape. Always keen to learn more about the area in which we live and the wildlife and bird life.
Joy Button
A letter to Tim’s iPhone
Sept 14, 2020 –
As Tim has so adroitly put it, the Phone has not only changed but is now the essence of our life. Without it we are marooned in a sea of cyber space.
With it, we are a slave to its demands, apps and all seeing eye and knowledge.
From a handy piece of hardware to a controlling essential part of life
with memories stored beyond recall.
As our independence, privacy and ability for human contact and verbal communication slips away with each new innovation, one wonders where to from now..
Ian Samuel
Thanks Tim. So much of our lives on that tiny device. Imagine coming out of a long coma and seeing everyone staring at this thing in their hand. We used to memorise things but there's no point any more. What would happen if the WWW suddenly disappeared, either hacked or caught the equivalent of COVID. Would everything grind to a halt?
Catherine Watson
A good question Catherine,,,,I have a recollection of when first I heard of a thing called the World Wide Web, and as far as I might rely on my actual rather than my virtual memory, life was running its course happily enough, but perhaps back then time was valued differently.
Tim Shannon
Speak up, Russell and Darren!
Sept 14, 2020 –
Thanks for the work you are doing. I will be registering!
Nicky Miller
Virus diaries 12
Sept 14, 2020 –
Thank you for explaining bubbles, Catherine, now I know. Thanks for the rest as well. You seem to be leading an active C 19 life in your social neighbourhood.
Felicia Di Stefano
Dear Catherine
The way your COVID diaries reveal your beauty and the beauty of our community brings me close to tears every time. It's something about how the everyday details of life touch the transcendent that is so moving. Thank you for your eloquence in recording the ways in which life, death, chooks, dogs, virtual 5th birthday parties, adolescents who listen and asparagus shoots in Spring are all interwoven.
Laura Brearley
I hope the corolla is behaving again, they are legendarily reliable. Rolls Royce used to claim that their cars never broke down, they just "failed to proceed".
Mark Robertson
Happy Birthday Evie-B
Thomas McNish
A spring in her step
Sept 14, 2020 –
Etsuko, another wonderful article and another challenge for you. So much passion and so much enthusiasm. There is only one word to describe you- UNIQUE.
Warm regards,
Phyllis Papps
Dear Phyllis, thank you for your kind words. Passion and enthusiasm are fundamental elements of any of my quests. I can't think of any other way than following only what interests me. I love the word 'unique' very much, and hope this word continue to describe me.
Etsuko Yasunaga
Admiration for you comes easy. I love your determination to complete what you started and to be enthusiastic about it. I know there will be more to read from you and your passion in life. I am looking forward to it. Verena
Verena Hoefler
Weekends at Remo
Sept 14, 2020
4 Comments
Thanks for such an entertaining article. An insight into Remo in the 1950,s. My family spent the 50,s-1990 holiday in’s at Balnarring Beach Fresh fish 3 meals a day, precious memories.
Robyn
Thanks Kev for an insight in Remo from the 50s till yesteryear. Clearly a deep knowledge and history held dear. Western Port and its environs would not be the same today without your dedicated volunteer support to protect and defend what is unique.
Jeff Nottle
Thank you Jeff, But it was you, as the Preserve Western Port, "fearless leader" and the untiring efforts of other "PWP'ers, that won the "Battle of Hastings.
Old management adage, "TEAM" Together Everyone Achieves More" and what we all achieved in stopping that monstrosity was just great.
I just have to live down the day of our celebration. When I got up to sing the song I wrote to celebrate our victory and after handing out lyric sheets to all present, promptly forgot the lyrics as I sang it!!
Ah the memories...!!
Kevin Chambers
End of the line
Sept 14, 2020 –
Thank you Sophie for bringing this important topic into the light and nudging us to think about it personally. I wonder whether you've heard of older people coming together in a house and hiring nursing, cooking and cleaning staff. Would that be an option?
Felicia Di Stefano
While this may be a reality check for some people, it is a subject I have had cause to give a great deal of thought to due to having cared for 4 older and 1 palliative care family member. The elephant in the room is that two of these, and many other people for various reasons do not want to either linger at home or go into care to die but really want a non judgemental service freely available to assist them have a peaceful end at a time and location of their own choosing. Why is this not a basic human right?
Christine Grayden
Great article Sophie!
Peter Ghys
Sophie, as you say, there are worse things than death. Anyone who has worked in a nursing home will be familiar with the rows of drugged up residents propped in front of a TV tuned to a commercial station, volume on full, in an overheated room. (We get a taste of what lies ahead in doctors’ waiting rooms.) Not one of these once vital people would have chosen this sort of living hell and now they are trapped. Will any government ever have the courage to extend assisted dying to those who decide “It’s been lovely but it’s time to go.”
Catherine Watson
Ive been thinking about Felicia's questions regarding the possibility of a group of older people setting up their own aged care facility.
I remember seeing a story years ago, on ABC TV, about a group doing this but do not know if it was successful. It is often a hot topic amongst the LGBTQI community who fear they may experience discrimination and prejudice in traditional aged care.
I have not been able to find any information about projects like this.
Is there someone else out there who can answer this question?
A few things to consider before you set out on that quest:
Aged care is very expensive and unless you have deep pockets, you will need some government funding. Government funding is dependent on eligibility and approval (as outlined in the Aged Care Act 1997) and many requirements must be fulfilled before you can set up a residential aged care facility.
If you have lots of money and don't need government funding, you can afford to build a suitable house and employ a large contingent of wonderful staff. You will also need honest, reliable and skilled advocates to act on your behalf if you are no longer able to make informed decisions.
Aged care requires a large number of staff and many need to be rostered for 24 hours, 7 days a week. This usually involves 3 shifts per day of carers and nurses. Kitchen, laundry, cleaning and maintenance staff are necessary. Doctors and allied health personnel also need to be employed. The list gors on and on.
The group of friends will need to design a house that takes into account the health care needs, mobility and cognitive function of all the residents.The level of their care needs may increase, sometimes quickly, depending on factors such as health conditions and falls.
The qualifications and skills of staff should be appropriate to provide all these levels of care.
A group of friends may have the best intentions when thinking of sharing accommodation, but it may be difficult to design a home that will accommodate everyone's specific care needs. This has been a major reason/rationale for the hospital style design of most aged care homes. The building must be able to suit clients' wheelchairs, walking frames, lifting machines, health care equipment, hospital style beds, access friendly bathrooms, floors that can be easily cleaned-this list also goes on and on.
I regret that I can't be more positive about Felicia's suggestion.
I will keep researching this topic and let you know if I find more information.
Sophie Cuttriss
Having read all the above replies, I will add what I consider is another imperative - that the contributions of each person in a shared older household is managed by a really honest person who can be trusted to have residents hearts in their own.
Joan Woods
Finally, Cowes centre is under way
Sept 4, 2020
HIP HIP HOORAY! A great design. Let's hope it's smooth sailing from here.
Marian Quigley
Hip, hip hooray indeed! This beautiful design is a sensitive and intelligent response to the many, many years of hard work and lobbying by the wider arts community on Phillip Island.
Sandra Peeters
An intriguing design that appears to cater for community needs
Exterior night lighting for community areas must play an integral part of the design concept plus integration of the existing iconic bells and tree bench
Solar panel roofing and consideration of geothermal heating should be an added design feature illustrating the Bass Coasts commitment to an energy neutral community.
External wall colouring and texture should reflect the local coastal environment that we treasure
Wall or glass wall murals by local artists would be an added feature.
The devil is in the detail yet to be developed, but hopefully will include the above suggestions to make this an outstanding Cowes civic centre.
Ian Samuel
Thank you Catherine for reminding us that four years ago the Councillors shelved this facility on the basis that we were broke and could not afford it. It now cost $19 million and not $17 million.
I hate waste and time is waste because you never ever get it back.
Please Councillors lean the word “do” and get rid of people who can’t.
Frank W Schooneveldt
I endorse Mayor Tessari's comments. The exciting building will enable the Island's dynamic, diverse community to be displayed, experienced and enjoyed. The spaces will enable opportunities for small and larger events throughout the year. The design will acknowledge and celebrate aboriginal culture. The new Library has been much needed for many years.
The Centre will be a source of pride for the Island community now and into the future The construction will provide jobs during construction and after completion.
Anne Davie
Back to the quiet life
Sept 4, 2020
A wonderful summary Angela and thank you for all your efforts in support of the 350+ objectors to this inappropriate development.
Janne Morrison
Congrats on a fine article with touches of poetry to describe all that is so lovely about living at Coronet Bay, Angela. Congrats to the Coronet Bay community on a battle well fought and now won.
Meryl Tobin
Lovely post, thankyou Angela. What a horrible, greedy overdevelopment it was. I suppose it means that they’ll be looking to do it elsewhere now. Let’s support the next community that will be in the firing line.
Frank Flynn
I was one of the many who put in an objection, Angela. I too was exultant at the news. Your love for the local area shines through your writing and for once love has triumphed over greed. Well done to you and all the others who fought so hard and for so long.
Anne Heath Mennell
Aged care: a checklist
Sept 4, 2020
Thank you very much, Sofie. Ishall keep all the points you write about but does a facility with the correct answers to your question exist?
Several of us are planning to form our own mini care home. Would that work?
Felicia Di Stefano
That idea sounds interesting Felicia. How many people do you see being part of it?
Sue Packham
Beautifully put Sophie Cuttriss.
Ben
This is such a practical and helpful article Soph. I hope readers who have ageing parent/s still at home take Soph’s advice and quietly have a look around at the options in their area with Soph’s checklist in hand WELL before circumstances are suddenly upon them and they’re stressed, overwhelmed, guilt-ridden and in urgent need of aged care accommodation for their loved-one. Even though I knew I had Soph’s expertise on hand I allowed my denial and guilt to paralyse me (and Soph respectfully didn’t interfere). I don’t think anything would have taken away the grief and stress but it would have really helped to have done some homework in advance. As Soph says, we need to be more honest and courageous sooner.
Linda Cuttriss
Sophie, you have written really well about what good aged care looks like. When I worked in a large aged care home I was trained in the Eden Alternative and then asked to train up all staff from the manager, nursing and care staff, to the kitchen, laundry and maintenance workers. And it did have an impact. Sadly when the home's management changed the top down support so necessary for such a big structural shift was no longer a priority. Aged care, specifically dementia care in my case, was a tough but enlightening gig for me. Tough for the reasons you've pointed out and an education because I was challenged in every possible way, every shift.
Linda Gordon
Thank you Sophie for highlighting what our Aged Care system needs to be like.
I worked in Aged Care in the late 1980s when they took registered Nurses out of the system. As a weekend Supervisor for another 12 months I was horrified at the downturn in care and spent all my weekends trying to get essential medical Care to people who had been neglected during the week. I also had worked in Palliative Care for many years and am pleased to see that you have highlighted the need for specialized end of life care. Our current system is badly broken and needs immediate attention. Thank you
Margaret Lee
What a clear statement you have made Sophie. I would think you (or everyone!) could do worse than put this case before our politicians so that funding is increased to help more education and possible modelling on European models of operation. Brav
Hilary Stuchbery
Our extinction crisis
Sept 4, 2020
The Federal Government just today rammed through a weakened EPBC Act reform. They even cut short debate on the issue, one so important to so many of us. Let's hope the Senate can ensure that doesn't get through.
Neil Rankine
Thank you for such an interesting and positive article, Lauren. I find it unbelievable that the Federal Minister for the Environment can act on an interim report to weaken an already ineffective piece of protective legislation to make it easier for more destruction to occur, supposedly in the interest of The Economy and good old Jobson Growth (remember him?). You described lots of good work being done locally and I think each of us can only do our bit to protect and restore the remnant parts of our locality. Together we really can make a difference.
Anne Heath Mennell
The first encounter
Sept 4, 2020
A fascinating and well-told story of an historic meeting, Pat.
As a long-time supporter of the proposal for a national park along the eastern side of Western Port Bay, I think your suggestion of Bonkoolawal (Bass River) as its name is an excellent one. Should the park become a reality, I hope the Aboriginal Land Council would approve the use of the name.
Meryl Tobin
The Cultural Heritage Management Plan for the (now abandoned) Norsemans Road Hotel lists hundreds of Aboriginal artefacts that have been there for thousands of years. This article breathes life into those artefacts and I would suggest that the State Government should acquire the land and gift it to the Traditional Owners as an act of reconciliation and a portent of Treaty.
Geoff Ellis
Well said Cr Ellis. Great article Pat.
Neil Rankine
6000 years ago, before the 'bay' was a 'bay' (or 'enbayment' if you prefer) there was a river running between French Island and the east coast with the Holden Proving Grounds not far to the east. It would make sense that this would be a likely site of habitation for the 35,000+ years humans have lived need Western Port, should have great stories to reveal.
Pat Macwhirter
I'd never heard of this first hand account before, Pat (perhaps because it was a Frenchman rather than an Englishman?). Historically and culturally priceless. It adds weight to our attempts to protect what is left of the landscape and cultural sites and artifacts we have found.
Anne Heath Mennell
Virus Diaries 11
Sept 4, 2020 –
Nice diary Catherine. Just a comment re Thursday: I hope people realise that the State of Emergency is different from the lockdown. It is needed so the Chief Health Officer can make rules for our safety eg mandatory mask-wearing. It doesn't mean staying in stage 3 or 4. If everyone is careful we can start to open up. Let's hope so!
Jennifer Skewes
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. I have missed your diary and am glad to see it back.
Janice Orchard
Catherine your virus diaries are superb, and a genuinely valuable historical document, not just of the social effects of the restrictions but of life in general. Informative and entertaining both, I laugh out loud at least once with every one.
Thank you so much and please, if you can, keep them going.
Miriam Strickland
Well said, Miriam.
Nicky Miller
Hear hear, Miriam. A bright spot in the darkness which cheers me up no end. Keep 'em coming, Catherine - please.
Anne Heath Mennell
My time has come
Sept 4, 2020
Frank, Thank you for reminding me why I love this part of the world. You've captured some beautiful moments which help me become a bit more mindful too!
Leticia Laing
What a colourful and inspirational picture of life’s possibilities
Deb
Thanks Frank, can’t help but be a little envious of your roving and rambling life but blessed to share your delight of this coast and to see it through your lens. Thank you.
Jennie
Great story of your journey. So glad you're around to share your love of the beautiful Bass Coast and revel in new found freedoms
Rosemary
Great insight Frank - I too went for a walk somewhere I have been saying for years "I must stop and check this conservation reserve out for a walk". I am talking about The Gurdies Conservation Reserve. Went there yesterday and thoroughly enjoyed the walk through the bushland and am very glad I took the time (from Ventnor on Phillip Island) to check it out. We are indeed very fortunate to live in this regional area and the abundance of nature on our doorstep.
Imelda
Frank you have a wonderful eye for detail.
As a 9-5 worker (or whatever extra hours it takes to get the job done!), I’m incredibly jealous of your lifestyle. Enjoy the retirement you’ve earned it.
N Valks
What a terrific solution to what some people dread...retirement....and what a visual feast you've chosen to explore...The Strezleckis, the coast, and the people....you'll need more terabytes to store those images on now.
Brian Carr
I love your view of our wonderful Bass Coast Frank. I have been here for the past 20 years and like you have taken to photography especially the Flora, Fungi,Lichens and mosses in The Gurdies Conservation Reserve. Just through my back gate.........
Margaret Lee
Blow that! Neighbours fuming
Aug 22, 2020
Perhaps the community could get together and build one monster wind turbine for everyone to benefit from. The Daylesford community did this and it must have been successful as last time I was up there, they had built a second one.
Peter Bogg
Unfortunately a Shearwater rookery is situated opposite.
.Birds taking off and returning every morning and evening are likely to be flying into the blades as happens with the power lines.
Jan Fleming
This is absolutely terrible. Thanks for pointing this appalling fact out, Jan.
Sue Saliba
We lived near acres of wind turbines near Texel in Netherlands.Plenty of seabirds about, walked the dogs under the wind turbines and trust me, the place was not littered with dead birds. Birds fly with updraughts and the turbulence from the turning wind vanes would mean birds avoided the wind turbines like the plague.
Elizabeth (Libby) M. Lambert
By painting one blade black, wind farms can reduce bird deaths by 72% a recent Norwegian study has found. Could this be a solution Jan?https://www.evwind.es/2020/08/21/bird-deaths-from-wind-turbines-drop-by-72-per-cent-when-one-blade-is-painted-black/76686
Tess
I wonder if people would prefer a nuclear power station next door instead of a wind turbine ? Would they complain if their neigbour planted a local eucalypt species which would grow to 10 metres plus within a few years, and when the wind whistling through its branches would be at least as noisy as the vanes of the wind turbine turning ?
Elizabeth (Libby) M. Lambert
Noise from wind turbines is mostly a function of tip speed. This one looks no more than 10kW with blades no more than 3m. Standing under the 6 turbines in Wonthaggi, even on windy day, noise is not a big deal at all. In extreme winds, which could be noisy, blades are orientated to not catch wind and are stopped for no noise. There was this kind of wind turbine, owned by Ruth Partridge on the Island, no noise to worry about.
Bernie Mccomb
I am not against wind turbines but not next to a Shearwater rookery.
Shearwaters are also called Moonbirds, The juveniles use the moon as a compass when flying every year to Siberia, leaving at night, A lot are killed on the bridge at San Remo, more recently the lights are turned off for the few weeks it takes for them to leave.
When they are here they leave early morning to feed usually in the dark, they return in the evening at dusk. Outside lights are not encouraged of an evening on the Esplanade at Surf Beach, how will they see a wind turbine? .
Jan Fleming
They will not need to see them, they will feel the air turbulence from the rotating vanes and not go anywhere near them. hey are no more likely to fly into static vanes than crash into a tree.
Elizabeth (Libby) M. Lambert
The use of renewable energy is sound, I think the Daylesford scheme works well, and if it has gotten to the stage where residents are building turbines in their own yards it is time we upped the push for more community wind farms in nice windy places of which Bass Coast abounds. I lived in Surf Beach for many years and agree also the wether you call them Mutton Birds, Moon Birds or Shearwaters rookeries are important also.
Robyn Smith
We are fully supportive of wind energy, but turbines must be installed in appropriate locations. The backyard of a property in a built up, residential area is not an appropriate location.
No permits are currently required and Council must take action to put regulations in place to ensure that turbines are installed safely, and that the amenity of the neighbourhood, the health of residents and the preservation of wildlife are not impacted. Limits should be set on the number of turbines that can be erected on any one site.
K. & M. Nair
Me again, small turbines generally more trouble than they’re worth, can’t get clear air at useful speed anywhere near house or trees in suburban block. Power generated (and noise) is function of cube of size. Twice as big doesn’t mean twice the power but 2*2*2=8 times. In the real world, especially at top of high tower, 10 times bigger means 10*10*10=1000 times more power. Small proposed might be 6m diameter utility size generally 80m or more.
Bernie Mccomb
A vertical wind turbine is a much better proposition.
Brian Carr
Your article is missing a number of facts.
1. Will it be free standing?
2. How tall is the house and/neighbouring houses?
3. What does the model look like?
The picture included is NOT an accurate representation and only insights confusion and unrest amongst your readers. Please consider reporting the benifits of using facts when reporting on polarizing issues.
NB. I don't know this resident
Ben Cavender
Point taken, Ben. The illustration was just a simple graphic image, not a representation of the turbine in question, which hasn't been built yet. No one knows what it will look like because the owner doesn't have to submit plans or apply for a permit. The only thing we know is that the turbine is under 11 metres because taller than that he does have to get a permit. But there will be a huge difference between a turbine with three-metre blades and a turbine with 50cm blades.
Catherine Watson
For all those in support of the wind turbine, would you feel that way if it were a few meters from your house, in your neighbour’s yard? This is a free-standing 3 storey wind turbine (similar to the photo shown). All the houses neighboring it are single storey. This will even be higher than power lines and most trees. Regardless of your views of wind energy, there should be planning and building permits required with the opportunity for neighbours to object and local environment to be considered. You can’t erect a flagpole without permits, yet an enormous industrial-looking electrical device is fine?
Monika
Before retirement I worked at Swinburne university and they installed 2 turbine's one 20 mtrs from a aged care facility and has been turned off for years as noise and electronic interference with medical equipment was impacted . The second was outside the electronics class rooms has to be shut down because in strong winds the brakes automatically apply and vibrate causing a shuddering loud noise and this turbine will be about 7to 8 mtrs from our bedroom. This is totally against our amenity . I am not against wind farms just not on a suburban block of land
Stan
Council climate plan zeroes in on 2030
Aug 22, 2020 –
Noticed that Mornington Shire Council voted unanimously against the Crib Point AGL gas terminal. They said it does not stack up economically or environmentaly Our Shire will be impacted by the massive gas tankers coming into Westernport Bay and dislodging water into that bay. There has been big demos against this proposal on the Peninsula including a flotilla on the bay. Hope Bass Coast Shire supports Mornington on this.
Burt Blackburne
Hi Burt Mornington Peninsula shire vote was welcome but Bass Coast adopted a strong resolution some months ago against the AGL FSRU. It is also putting in a strong submission to the EES process backing up its stance.
Michael Whelan
I was thinking about those emissions as I was working on the story and made two decisions:
I will change from gas heating and gas water heating to all electric
I will change my newspaper subscription to a digital one.
It would be interesting if the council (or someone) set up a site or kept a record of the small decisions Bass Coast people make and the resulting reduction in emissions.
Catherine Watson
Another thing people can do is change electricity supplier and get onto one that contracts just renewable energy and give the polluters like AGL and Energy Australia the flick. I use Powershop.
The plan provides for a community hub that will provide community groups an interface for their projects. The emissions tracking is sophisticated and the reporting in the plan allows for the tracking of the various sectors and will reveal the progress being made.
michael Whelan
Council’s ‘COVID’ budget
Aug 22, 2020
This budget is a bad budget because it does not address the backlog of the $600 million in infrastructure issues in the Bass Coast.
It does not fix the pot holes.
It does not fix the roads, drainage issues and other amenities like swimming pools.
And on another issue to quote the minister for agriculture David Littleproud in The Age of 24th August 2020, “we don’t subsidise our farmers, they’re on their own two feet”
Well I this budget we give our farmers a 20% discount on their rates, which is a subsidy.
It would be far better to pay our farmers some form of fee for looking after the land and environment they maintain.
Frank W Schooneveldt
‘Stand clear – here comes Mrs Gilmour!’
Aug 22, 2020
Does anyone know where Gilmour track is at the Cape?
Frank Flynn
Yes Frank, it's at the first surf beach car park.
Catherine Watson
Great story, what a legend ?
Brian Carr
I loved the story of Annie Gilmour .... what a personality and a fabulous legacy she has also left behind.
Joy Button
Good reporting Catherine I enjoyed this story a lot.
Joan Woods
Forest campaign intensifies
Aug 22, 2020 –
I strongly support all your work to protect not only the Holden Proving Ground but Bass Coast shire in general, keep up the good work.
Rodney Boyle
Good work Tim and Catherine, a good coalition of interests is forming here. But as I emphasised in Council the other day it is important to involve the traditional voice here. They are dispossessed of their land and it is important to keep their interests in this land front of mind.
Michael Whelan
I agree Michael. Our group recognises that this whole corridor sits on the ancestral lands of the Bunurong people, and that their ideas and aspirations and the protection and preservation of their culturally significant places should be front and centre of this discussion.
Tim Obrien
With time becoming in shorter supply, houses are now made of concrete hence the sand need. Personally, I think that concrete houses are not nice - becoming smelly and cold. Perhaps it is time for the Australian 'dream' to be reevaluated.
Joan Woods
‘Get on with it!’
Aug 22, 2020 –
I have known Anwyn for so many decades and it was a privilege to get to know her and work with her.
She will always be remembered for her tireless efforts being involved in so many causes, so many campaigns, so many organizations.
We salute you Anwyn for all the work you have done on behalf of our region.
I am so grateful that I had the opportunity to see you at Banfields in your final year.
May you now rest in peace. Your work is now complete.
Phyllis Papps
I loved Anwyn, I went on a few bird trips interstate with her, we always had fun. Always forthright with her opinions, she had a wicked sense of humour.
Although I felt sad when I saw her a Banfields, she was always happy to see me.
Jan Fleming
We knew Anwyn for only about 15 years and she was a remarkable lady. A great sense of humour ... I have heard the story from Libby Skidmore of Anwyn dressing up as a ghost during Libby's Ghost Walks at Corinella Cemetery. She was a very clever lady and one who managed to get things done for her community with good grace and goodwill. Rest in peace Anwyn as you have left a great legacy for others.
Joy Button
I worked with Anwyn once only and we were delighted to make a much needed $100+ for a fledgling charity. We had two or three hours together and she was a delightful companion
Joan Woods
We miss Anwyn’s call rallying the troops to Bass Valley Landcare meetings. A huge loss and we miss her dry wit. An outstanding contributor to the community in so many ways. She leaves behind a great legacy.
Ian James
The life of a COVID campaigner
Aug 22, 2020
What an excellent article Leticia. The issues you raise are so important for the forthcoming Local Govt. elections AND especially for women.
As you rightly stated, there are only two Councillors out of nine in The Bass Coast Shire who are women. A great imbalance, because there are so many women who have struggled to balance various roles in their lives and battled against so many challenges and odds against them.
Of the two women who are currently in Council: Cr Rothfield (Island Ward) is now retiring after an incredible two very successful terms of office as Councillor and Mayor. The other is Cr. Clare Le Serve (Western Port Ward) who has also been Mayor and plans to stand for a third term.
I salute both of them for their incredible achievements over the decades on behalf of our community.
Let's hope more women will stand for the LG elections this year-despite major obstacles and challenges.
Good luck with your campaign. What Ward are you planning to stand for?
Phyllis Papps
You have my total support and I suspect the support of many, many Cape locals. It’s well overdue, to have a rep from Cape Paterson on council. Best of luck!
Frank Flynn
Leticia you write beautifully, your article struck a chord with me because I'm also standing for council. Best of luck with your campaign, I have no doubt we will get a chance to meet.
Jeni Jobe Candidate for Island Ward
It’s nice to hear you are coming from a care for family... but what do you stand for? There needs to be very aware humans working for the people right now! That you are going through this in a ‘normal family’ way is great but how do you view what’s happening? Do you feel what’s going on right now is...right/lawful/necessary?
Lee-Ann
To be fair, Lee-Ann, the brief to Leticia wasn't to write about her policies but to write about the complications of campaigning during a lockdown. Once nominations close, the Post will be questioning all council candidates about their policies and the issues that are important to them.
Catherine Watson, editor
Hi Lee-Ann
This piece was designed to be thought-provoking rather than pushing an agenda. I'm happy to see how the dialogue has unfolded. I encourage you to check out my Facebook page on where I stand on a number of issues: @leticia4bccouncil
Leticia Laing
The Solace of Birds VI
Aug 13, 2020 –
Patsy, another wonderful and descriptive article about our beautiful bird life. I will always keep on looking at the sky (not for the weather) and the natural world that surrounds us.
Thank you so much for all of your excellent articles with superb images.
I am truly sorry this is the last of the series and hope maybe you can be convinced to write more of your experiences and share this knowledge with others.
Phyllis Papps
Thanks Patsy it was a great series.
What would we do without our fabulous birds?
Jan Fleming
Another beautiful piece, like the others in the series. Thanks, Patsy, for sharing your love of the island's precious birds with us.
Sue Saliba
An artist in lockdown
Aug 22, 2020
A charming and inspiring article Marian. Beautiful artwork. Thank you for cheering me up.
Ursula Theinert
Hi Marian a positive article about your work.
A brilliant portrait of Warren - captures his minimalism as well as his humour.
John Adam
Good to see the island arts community is thriving, and finding ways to stay connected.
Catherine Watson
Marian has indeed captured the highs & lows of a practicing artist during these crazy times. In acknowledging the imposed restrictions I'm reminded of a favourite quote "Art Intensifies the Feeling of Being Alive" (see The Illogic of Kassel by Enrique Vila-Matas).
Paint on, I say!
Warren Nichols
Great work Marion, love it!
Carolyn Goldberg
Great body of work Marian. Strong and vibrant despite everything!
Annie Duncan
There is much to be enjoyed in both your painting and your writing.
Margaret Ainscow
Thanks Marian, great insight into your world of art. I loved your piece on 'Warren' and had a chuckle about the description. When this crisis is over, I believe the connections people make will be life long.
Clare Le Serve
The missing link
Aug 22, 2020
Great memories Terri, and spot on...we need to keep these links open today, more than ever. Sadly the powers that be don’t value the importance of walking track and beach links. This was highlighted over a year ago when Parks Victoria removed the culvert over the main drain between the rail trail / South Dudley and Five Brace. Complaints at the time said it would be replaced, which it hasn’t, ensuring that the drain cannot be forded once the rain comes.
We need to keep these links open at all times for both our physical and mental health.
Jim Barritt
Old Rifle Range Road reserve where the fence blocks it at the moment can still be opened to the public. It's a bit wet down the bottom where the Broom Crescent road reserve cuts through, so some appropriate drainage infrastructure will be needed but if enough people tell the shire that they want this track open there is plenty of justification in the shire's aspirational paths/trails strategy. This is a route identified in that plan.
Neil Rankine
Is it worth canvassing support for this ? I'm sure residents could see the value in what it could add to the area, and there seems to be a bit more money around for just this sort of thing, not that it has to be a fancy road, (a mate with a bobcat and a slab or two might do the trick :) )....soon to be Broome Crs resident.
Brian Carr
Well said Terry! I also grew up in Wonthaggi and our home was in Hunter Street. No TV or 'screens' in those days so kids made their own fun and activities. My siblings, other kids in the street and nearby often used the tracks Terry mentions out to the Back Beach, Lake Lister and the bush all around. I do know that some reps. from several of our environmentally aware groups made an appointment and met with a boffin from the Shire Council to outline their ideas of again opening the track to community. Great idea the chap agreed BUT suggested the way to go was for these people to apply for a grant for a feasibility study, then if successful apply for another grant to actually do the work !!!!! Hello? This is Shire land so it is up to the Council to facilitate the whole procedure NOT fob everything off to 'others'. It is budget time with the Council and there is money allocated for walking tracks etc. so how about it? I will write a letter to the CEO for the Council and encourage like-minded folk to do the same. Come on Council how hard is it to kick start a project for our community, visitors to the area and the myriad Uni. students who study and monitor our magnificent flora and fauna. Yvonne McRae
Yvonne McRae
The burden of care
Aug 13, 2020
Thank you Sophie and the Post for this excellent conversation the community must have about the situation with regards to aged care in this country.
Anne Davie
Sophie,this situation could have been avoided, and your words could not be more true. Have worked in aged care, and although finding it distressing,I was fortunate enough to work with excellent RNs and ENs. I treated the residents like they were my own grand-parents. I am truly disgusted and distressed that the aged care sector is all about the $$$$$, with a few exceptions. I think we are so fortunate on the Bass Coast to have excellent facilities for our aged and disabled. Please continue to teach and advocate for some of our most vulnerable people..
Michelle
Thank you for the work you have done to deliver a comprehensive assessment of the state of aged care in this country.
The whole sector needs a considerable shake up.
Ben Cavender
Proving ground campaign not done yet
August 13, 2020
Reminds me of how the Japanese used to buy WA wood chips made from native karri forests because they valued the natural beauty of their own forests to destroy them just for wood chips.
James Glover
Pfft. It was cleared farmland 50 years ago!
Dave Tgarth
Songs for Western Port
Aug 13, 2020 –
What a lovely and meaningful way to highlight the need to protect "our Bay"..."Circumstances" dictated my 2018 move back to Melbourne from The Gurdies, but Western Port has been and always will be a huge part of my life.
The same "circumstances" prevent me from taking an active part in the current AGL battle, but I continue to support from afar where I can.
I find it ironic that the current Andrews Government shut down the Hastings Container Port proposal on environmental grounds, but these do not seem to apply to the AGL proposal..
Methinks gas powered hot showers get more "city voter" attention than where their next lot of imported flat screen televisions are unloaded. Port Phillip or Hastings.
Good luck to all involved in this vital battle.
Kevin Chambers
I am lodging my EES submission tonight. It’s not onerous and i encouage others to speak up for the Bay too... the more voices the better.
Anne Paul
What brilliant work. It is a great comfort to know that a submission of this quality is being sent to the inquiry. Thank you for sharing
Geoff Heyes
Mum, here’s to you
Aug 13, 2020
Thank you, Miriam, for this heartfelt personal story... These 'covid times' lead to much reflection... Strange times for sure.
Nicky Miller
In search of Truginini
Aug 13, 2020
Thanks for the article about Truganini, Tunnerminnerwait, Maulboyheener and their group.
We will never know what motivated their escape from the early white settlement of "Melbourne". However, their raids and robberies of numerous white settlements in this area are well documented in "Jack of Cape Grim" by Jan Roberts and Tunnerminnerwait and Maulboyheenner: The involvement of Aboriginal people from Tasmania in key events of early Melbourne" by Clare Land.
Jessica Harrison
A watery makeover
Aug 13, 2020
Zostera is the genus name muelleri is
the species name
Hugh Kirkman
How ironic that while Melbourne Water is trying to rehabilitate the Bay environment, Environment Minister Wynne seems hell-bent on fast-tracking AGL’s environment destroying LPG gas terminal at Hastings which reportedly will subject the Bay waters to millions of litres per day of LPG flows at 15 degrees lower than Bay water temperatures.
Obviously the frozen gas needs warming to pump it to Cranbourne but Bay waters will be significantly cooled which will naturally damage and probably destroy parts of the ecosystem; it’s not rocket science.
When Wynne pushes this through will it be goodbye to the fragile colony identified of local seahorses and other vulnerable species? Will it be goodbye to the fish nurseries because of much colder temperatures in the Bay and how will the sea grasses be affected by the new man-made devastation about to be unleashed courtesy of an Environmental Dept approval that will beggar belief if it goes ahead.
Jordan Crugnale’s support for saving Westernport Bay from this madness is needed far more than any futile attempt to buy the Holden Proving Ground. Commonsense says that in this economic environment the Government doesn’t have the money. The future of the Bay is far more important in the big picture. The community needs to get its priorities right.
Trevor Fothergill
Armchair arts tour
Aug 13, 2020 –
Thank you so much Liane for your passion and vigilance regarding promoting arts and culture and being heavily involved in this region for decades- especially more recently during this period.
Phyllis Papps
Virus diaries 10
Aug 13, 2020
Lovely medley, Catherine.
Rob Youl
Thanks Catherine, I enjoy your diaries very much.
Janet Fleming
Catherine, I look forward to reading your diaries, keeping me in touch with life in South Wonthaggi while I am exiled on the south coast of NSW.
Leonie Smith
I've been thoroughly enjoying your diaries too. Post covid, you should put them into a book!
Marian Quigley
Thanks so much Catherine, I also enjoy your insights whilst in exile in Footscray. You continually remind us of our beautiful Bass area.
Sharon
love it..keep up the great work. You express what we all feel, and love your brother in-law’s joke!
Michelle
As always - you do an amazing job pulling all of this together. I absolutely love your virus diaries - I only wish I was interesting enough to appear in every one of them. The scary thing is that you are up to Number 10. Any bets on which number sees the conclusion??
Liane Arno
Wonderful! you just took me thru the areas where I used to walk daily, sadly missed. Thank you so much Cathrine. I am sure Matilda and Nugget would have been friends!
Heather Tobias
Not too coastal, urges alliance
July 31, 2020
The Alliance is spot on. The 'somebodies' sitting in their ivory tower offices, looking at a desk top map, and thinking, 'This would be great. Look at that strip of vegetation along the cliff tops visitors would have great views,' Never considering that people would access the beaches onto the rock platforms and some would be caught out by the tides. Once the tide is rushing in the 'gutters' in the platforms become rushing torrents, and even mountain goats would find scaling the cliffs almost impossible - disaster WILL happen. The Alliance plan also means any walker having a health difficulty could be accessed by emergency services easily on their proposed trail. Hopefully the 'planners' will listen to local 'experts', and not go along with some hare-brained City scheme. The danger to birds, small mammals, reptiles and our precious coastline should be uppermost in the planning. Who remembers when the scheme was mooted (years ago) for the outfall from the Inverloch Sewerage Scheme to be pumped over the cliffs near Flat Rocks? I remember being involved with that fight. I remember my submission renamed the locations - Crap Rocks, Eagles Mess and Point Shite. Roll on Brave New World!
Yvonne McRae
A couple of years back Councillor Brown advocated that the rail trail be extended from Wonthaggi to Inverloch. Very good idea as it will improve safety and access for walkers and cyclists for moderate cost.
A coastal path that hugs the coast will cost a bomb and render a wildness area accessible but offer little in the way of a link between the towns.
Now that the Nyora to Leongatha railway is finally being replaced with a rail trail The council and state government should consider extending the rail trail beyond Anderson and create a link. The beauty is that it’s all crown land and we have some outstanding bike trails in south gippsland already in place.
Edward
Yes, when I was on council some 5 or six years ago we started work on this shared pathway linking Wonthaggi and Inverloch. A lot of work has been done identifying where vegetation is too valuable and needs to be bi-passed, fundamentally it's the sensible and not too difficult option.
Neil Rankine
Thank you Neil. My mistake for not mentioning the longstanding work by council on the Wonthaggi to Inverloch bike/walking trail .
There are so many reasons to extend and link up the rail trails.
It’s also a great way for us to attract people to the area who will swap cars for bikes ... reducing the velocity of visitors, providing an opportunity for them to work up an appetite and spend money locally.
The coastal path sounds like more car /bus traffic to me. Not much in it for the local economy
Edward
Nah, can’t agree. A walk close to the coast (and preferably along the beach at low tide) is what will bring people.
Peter Ghys
I agree with every single recommendation of the Alliance. The Rail Trail through Kilcunda is already being diverted through the Lionel Rose car park as that dune gets washed into the sea and the town is over run with wayward tourists hunting coffee on any sunny day.
Directing the hordes from Melbourne along the delicate foreshore of Harmers is eco-vandalism and expecting travellers to dodge the tides as they walk the beaches is negligence.
Stick to the path that's there, this isn't some eco-Disneyland, and why do we have to make every damn piece of nature accessible to everyone who needs to take a selfie next to some poor creature clinging to it's disappearing habitat.
Cr Geoff Ellis
Well said, Geoff. The very idea of this plan fills me with horror.
Sue Saliba
Hear, hear!!
Liz Glynn
I get the impression that many of those who disagree with a coastal path have never walked on the many popular coastal paths in the UK. These have brought very many tourists to admire the scenery and environment and contribute to the local economy.
Could it be that many of those who object to this coastal path are land owners who object to the general public accessing a narrow strip next to their properties? Horrors! Imagine tourists from Melbourne actually walking by their land!
Please don't be small minded and try to exclude others who want to experience our wonderful coastal scenery.
Hugh Hungerford
Open letter to everyone - I will happily give anyone a guided tour of Harmers Haven and point out why the options of stumbling along fragile sand dunes, trampling plovers nests, disturbing cultural heritage or wandering along a dirt track that passes for a main road are unacceptable options. What was the song "Find paradise, put in a walking track."?
Was it small minded to save the Daintree? Small minded to say "don't climb Uluru?"
wpwbcge@gmail.com
CR Geoff Ellis
Some of the pleasure of a “coastal” walk is experiencing a variety of environments, including coming around a corner to get a different vista of the ocean. Having done the multi day Great Ocean Walk in the west of our state, it is not all on the beach or cliff top, but goes inland, as appropriate. Very sensible recommendations from the group.
Nola Maxfield
I think the coastal alliance has nailed it. The section from San Remo to just past Kilcunda is the best of the clifftop views. Take the track inland after that and walkers are in for a different kind of treat. They’ll walk beneath the windmills, encounter mobs of kangaroos and perhaps even emus, see hundreds of water birds at Baxters wetlands, then wander past the remains of the number 5 mine brace and an introduction to Wonthaggi’s rich mining history.
Catherine Watson
We live in a coastal region and yet so often we try to create less ways for people to access and enjoy it. Around the world communities value ocean vista and access to beaches yet again here we have groups trying to find ways for those who come to the coast not access it. While I fully understand the need for environmental protection there are creative ways of doing this and still accessing the ocean vistas. We are currently in one of the greatest crisis our world has faced, communities are threatened both socially and economically. Yes potentially there could be better realignment along the Kilcunda to Cape Paterson component but imagine a creatively road side but not attached dual walk / bike pathway from Inverloch to the Cape. The economic and social benefits would be amazing. It could be one of the great walk / rides in the country and then creatively attach it to the five beaches amazing. People who come to the Bass Coast largely come for a coastal experience, yet we continually try to create infra structure and barriers to that very experience they come for.
Max Wells
Thank goodness that I’m not the only one who thinks that a coastal walk should be actually on the coast. 😊
Peter Ghys
Council: we’re hiring
July 31, 2020
Thanks for such a good, positive article.
Nicky Miller
Congratulations to the councilors for addressing the problem and providing support to our hard pressed community
Ian Samuel
A great initiative and good on the council. Especially good to see a stimulus package that also caters for women for once. One quibble: confining Working for Victoria to people who have lost their jobs because of COVID perpetuates the idea that they are more worthy than the people who lost their jobs for a multitude of reasons in the years before. I would like to see the scheme opened up to anyone who needs a job. There is no shortage of work that needs to be done!
Catherine Watson
Good news from the Council employment department. What a change of perspective. The hills will in future have the sounds of wind music through the leaves of whatever.
I have a few wattle seedling needing tlc - pick them up if they are useful for the program.
JOan Woods
It's great to read that conservation work has been included in this initiative. I do hope that the re-vegetation team will work to remove the weeds along the northern foreshore of Phillip Island and put in the indigenous coastal vegetation that should be there and, for various reasons, including illegal foreshore encroachment by neighbouring properties, isn't. This is a crucial area needing attention particularly as habitat for our native animals.
Sue Saliba
Places in the heart
July 31, 2020 –
What a beautiful thing to do! Thank you Laura and your team of lovely people. I hope to write a few things for you. Thanks for publishing this Catherine. I have shared this on four FB pages.
Christine Grayden
Thank you Christine for your kind words and for passing on the Coastal Connections invitation. Every bit of love for the Earth and for each other counts more than ever right now. Go gently dear woman.
Laura Brearley
I am very interested in this. What a fabulous idea. I will put pen to paper.
San
Great idea. I will give it a go.
John Adam
Ciconte Close
July 31, 2020 –
Beautiful story to read, teaches me to be resilient . It reminds me of my parent’s struggle as migrants from Holland
Petra Shandley
Great story and so indicative of Italian culture in Australia, managing to keep their families together while working very hard - or perhaps that is the key.
Congratulations to all story tellers and author.
Joan Woods
What a great read. Thankyou!
N Smith
Thank you .... I thoroughly enjoyed the story. Would love to hear more of these stories.
Joy Button
My husband Michael and my two sons holidayed with them at I Paoli in 1985.
My in-laws house was next door to Tomasi Ciconte’s house, who is his brother.
We were there for 3 months.
We had so many laughs and amazing walks, best time ever.
Also we had a fruit shop in Pakenham and Dom would come to our shop once a week to deliver some of his veggies and my husband Michael would pick up some fruit from from the market in Melbourne.
We loved to see him weakly.
He would tell us what was happening in Wonthaggi
I was very interested as l went to school there.
I am one of the Nero girls, Raffaelina.
Raffaelina Nero Scuglia
Whatever it takes
July 31, 2020
Wonderful job Ian! You are doing a great thing restoring those machines. Are they available to view in some way? Do you have them on a website? I'd also like to know if you have photos of the process of restoring them - that would be a great record for other/future restorers. Maybe Catherine can do a few feature articles about each one of your restored machines with some info on each and they can be shared that way. Best wishes for future projects.
Christine Grayden
A little treasure trove of way by gone farming history restored with great detail. Fabulous craftsmanship Ian.
David Taylor
This Coast Post is a great antidote to COVID depression. Creation, restoration and a population pulling together in hard times. Makes you think of Aristotle, who said about 2340 years ago that the Whole (read "Bass Coast community in mid 2020") is Greater than the Sum of its Parts.
John Gascoigne
Great juncture Ian - the modern initiative with past trades craft.
Love the buggy your family arrived in. It must have been a shock for them all.
joan Woods
Virus diaries 9
July 31, 2020 –
We are here at Upper Ferntree Gully just wishing we could go down to our unit at San Remo. We waited for school holidays to finish so we wouldn't get caught up with school holiday visitors but then shut down Metropolitan Melbourne started. So enjoy the extra freedom you have still in Bass. We are social distancing all the time and really not a lot of people walking around here although today for first time in couple of weeks
saw 4 people in few minutes with no masks. They obviously think carrying a drink even though not drinking anything means they don't need one.
Knox is large area and we are literally 800 metres from Yarra Ranges so with 1000 steps closed except for few walkers and bike riders only locals walking around, always dog walkers out there wherever you go!
So enjoy the extra freedom you have at this time, and just to let you know that although many would like to get out of town we are doing the right thing and staying away. Lets hope our State can get on top of this virus and numbers drop we have Family including grand sons living in Northern Suburbs and one doing Year 12 at this stage still going to school using public transport so they are very much our main concern.
Stay Safe. Enjoy the sea fresh air,
Chris Day
Oh. Catherine, it’s so good to read your virus diaries. Having not been down that way for sooo long now. It’s the only connection that reminds us of another world of another life.
Thankyou.
Jill Shannon
Thank you dear Catherine for reaching out to us with your COVID diaries and naming the layers of feeling that come with this experience.
You open your heart to us in your diaries and you write for us all.
Thanks for holding us in this way.
Laura Brearley
Testing times for writers
July 31, 2020 –
Dear readers and writers.
150 words? 250 words? 500 words? Definitely NOT.
The Bass Coast Prize for Non-fiction 2020 aims to encourage writers of long form Non-fiction that is meaningful, thought provoking and in-depth about issues, places, people, local history and related to the Gippsland region.
This is a rare opportunity and challenge for Gippsland Non-fiction writers to 'spread their wings' and write something meaningful that isn't just a quick piece of easy writing (such as Facebook, Twitter and the social media)
Entries need to be between 4000-10,000 words and the closing date is 4th September.
Check the website: https://basscoastprizefornonfiction.weebly.com
Phyllis Papps
A curator's view
July 17, 2020
Love this idea as it would keep the vegetation pristine whilst encouraging visitation.
Susan Acheson
The complex would need, in my opinion, to be preserved because that is as important to members of our past and future communities as is the natural features.
Congratulations of bringing it to our attention.
Joan Woods
It would seem that such an intact resource with the history of Holden in Victoria should be taken up by the State and the community. An aea like that of reasonably preserved coastal bushland is likely not available anywhere else and with the possible removal of some weed species trees would not need rehabilitation, just some gentle maintenance.
I think that purchase is a good idea and should be pursued with the government as only thay can guarantee it's continued preservation. That land, like all around it is subject to sand mining applications and only the State can prevent that happening.
Great idea to include museum in the grounds. I have experienced museums that are really popular with domestic travelers and this concept would enhance the site.
Jeff Cole
Holden purchase on the cards
July 17, 2020
Would be a wonderful asset for the local and wider community. There are few if any such large areas of native vegetation (as well as the rare fauna) in our region.
Neil Stewart
Protective overlays would be a great start but the best protection would be for the government to acquire this unique and precious piece of land and create a nature reserve for the community to enjoy and safeguard its survival in its entirety for future generations. If sold to private interests, backdoor deals can still be made overriding planning controls by applying to planning minister's office directly. Also if sold to private interests despite strict planning controls would mean the site remain inaccessible to the community.
Barbara Moje
The Corinella Residents & Ratepayers Association Inc. (CRRA) also supports this group.
An invaluable asset that needs to be preserved and for the community to have access to enjoy it.
David Laing
The Solace of birds V
July 15, 2020 –
Patsy, what another beautifully written and illustrated 'The solace of birds.'
I truly look forward to reading The Solace of Birds VI.
Phyllis Papps
Black lives matter here too
July 17, 2020 –
Well said, Marg - you sum up the situation succinctly. Regrettably, even 232 years after the invasion of this country by the British Government, indigenous people still suffer from the historical effects of colonialism and there is still no treaty. It doesn't take much imagination or empathy to appreciate where Australians, indigenous and non-indigenous, would be today if we had lost the Second World War. In much the same position as indigenous people find themselves now, I would suggest.
The gut-wrenching CCTV footage of torture, such as the teargassing, manhandling, stripping and pinning down and hooding and restraining of young indigenous boys in Darwin's Don Dale Youth Detention Centre and footage of a young indigenous man murdered in a cell by being pinned down by guards and so unable to breathe is there for anyone to see. How was it allowed to happen and what is being done about such crimes and injustices in Australia, our wonderful country where it's supposedly a fair go for all?
Meryl Tobin
Maybe you could encourage readers to write to their local federal MP to encourage them to support the Uluru Statement and actively lobby Scott Morrison to adopt it? If we all speak out then there may be a chance it could happen.
Sue Acheson
Unfortunately, the winner takes all mentality is rife throughout our communities. How can we swing this bias around.
Joan Woods
Good question, Joan. The short answer is education.
John Coldebella
Thank you Marg, for the truths from the heart. May all the changes you write are needed, come to pass soon. A change of government would help.
Felicia Di Stefano
Thank you for your affirming comments. I think you are right, Sue, that writing to our MPs, if there were enough of us, would indicate the strength of feeling and support for the Uluru Statement, and perhaps put some courage in them to argue for, and vote for constitutional change to embed the Voice. Having said that, Aboriginal leaders have indicated their faith in the Australian people to support such a referendum question, and surveys indicate they are right, but they have no faith in politicians to show the same empathy and understanding. But we need the pollies to promote the referendum! So write those letters.
Marg Lynn
Virus diaries 8
July 17, 2020 –
Keep it coming Catherine. I am loving the stories and you are making a record for the future generations who will study this pandemic and how civilisation coped.
Interesting to read about how your friend I South Africa is doing. Such a contrast between her situation and yours. She seems happy.
By the way, my garden is also experiencing Spring like changes.
Janice Orchard
Love it Catherine; it does me good to smile and have a giggle when I am one of those health care workers that worry constantly about patients, husband, and family in Melbourne..
Michelle Graham
And the band played on
July 16, 2020
To Terry & Laura, Lyndall & Strat. That looked like alot of fun! Thankyou
Mary Whelan
'Streets ahead' with your Fantastic initiative and VERY entertaining!!!! Music filling the gaps!! Just great.
Ellen Hubble
It was great fun to participate in this event
MaggieL
Bass Coast embraces green power
July 17, 2020
Has Council initiated any particular advocacy recently? Particularly, how about advocating that Federal sign off on legals to enable Star of the South offshore wind farm?
Bernie Mccomb
Thank you Michael. The Bass Coast community is fortunate to have a progressive Council that takes Climate Change seriously and is ensuring responsible energy supply now and into the future.
Anne Davie
Well done Bass Coast Shire Council. Congratulations on an important start. Thank you.
Felicia Di Stefano
Gaslighting Gippsland
July 3, 2020
Lauren, your excellent article exposes numerous reasons all of us should share your concern about on-shore gas exploration. I too attended a Gippsland Resource and Land Use Planning online community workshop about on-shore gas. When I asked the proponents if gas exploration in the Lang Lang to Grantville area was being considered, one said it was unlikely because it was on the edge of the study area and there were a lot of constraints. But I still gave feedback indicating all our Distinctive Areas and emphasizing the environmental-sensitivity of this area. However, I’m concerned not just for this area but for anywhere in Gippsland, indeed Victoria. Why prop up a dying and unsustainable energy source when public monies could be better spent on funding renewable energies such as solar?
Meryl Tobin
I too attended the so called "public consultation workshop". The inverted commas are on purpose as the session was anything but - it was a marketing activity trying to sell us onshore gas exploration despite everything that's wrong with it. Your article explains it so well - there is almost no upside to onshore gas but a lot of downside. We should all reject any proposals from the gas industry.
Annie Rivera
I commend Lauren for reminding us, that our politicians, both Federal and State, are captured by forces that prevent what we all desperately need to avoid a climate change catastrophe, one that will make our present Covid-19 fears and restrictions almost irrelevant.
Unless natural gas leakage (methane) from on-shore gas wells is kept below around 3%, there is no climate advantage changing from coal to gas powered power stations.
The use of natural gas to create, so called, "clean energy hydrogen" being advocated by the same, "powers to be" that provided the lump of coal for Scott Morrison's Federal Parliament theatre is definitely not the answer, far from it.
Australia has an abundance of renewable energy sources (solar PV and solar thermal, wind, tidal and geothermal) which, without present, fossil fuel vested interest political influence, could soon move Australia to a thriving zero emissions economy powering itself and other southern hemisphere countries with clean, lifesaving energy.
Tony Hughes
What a great article Lauren, so full of wise critique about this appalling situation. It should be essential reading for all politicians. Could you submit it to The Age perhaps?
Marg Lynn
Thanks Marg. I just emailed it to the Age to see if they're interested!
Lauren
Does everybody know about story, with strong recommendations to not connect to gas when building new house, in ATA Renew magazine, by no less than AGL? How much more ridiculous can energy politics get?
Bernie Mccomb
Lovely article, Lauren.You demonstrate the casual way important decisions, which are more important than the participants, occur.A mild criticism:- in 2015 when the gas industry got a huge export deal which short changed Australians and tripled domestic gas pricess the companies are not to blame .They were doing their job for profits as expected. The blame is entirely with PM Gillard and her naive ministry.
Benedict Clark
But Benedict, the current LNP government is totally ignoring the issue of over-commitment of resources and LNG trains in Queensland.
They have reneged on a deal with Senator Patrick to bring in gas reservation as used in WA.
Ian Teese
Gillard’s government ended in 2013, I’m afraid this was an Abbott job 😀
Lauren Burns
How can any government support the planned disruption and damage just to get six months supply of gas?
Brian James
The Gippsland Climate Change Network totally opposes the search for on shore gas exploration in Gippsland We have enough renewables that will come on line in Gippsland over the next 10 to 20 years that will more than compensate for such small amount of gas produced on shore in Gippsland and given the modification for water use in the Macalister Irrigation District Plan just announced and what dairying and agriculture means to Gippsland We can not see the VGP getting up or other
Ian Southall
Water and Gas don't mix. In the early 1980 a book was written detailing rings of trees research. It said that briegly = that it was as likely that we would experience an ice age rather than a hot age. Which ever way it goes, climate change is here and we should acknowledge it at every level of government.
Joan Woods
Dream on, PM
July 3, 2020
Really interested in this history. My grandmother's family (not Smiths), also farmed cane at Sarina in the same period. On a bit of history seekingin the past I discovered that during the Spanish flu period some of the Kanak workers became unwell, passed away and were buried in a small cemetery on the property. I also cringe at the use of these workers at that time....as well as some entrenched racist attitudes today
Nola Smith
Thank you for sharing this story. We need to know our history whether it is palatable or not.
Margaret Lee
Yes, we've progressed in different spheres of our society, but there's a cringeworthy element in all four photos. Perhaps if Harry had stood beside his bride gender inequality wouldn't be raising its ugly head.
John Gascoigne
Could it be anything other than slavery when stealing a loaf of bread etc was crime punishable by transportation? And how about all orphan kids exported from UK and stolen generation kids into forced labour slavery? And still happening with “people trafficking”. Advance Australia indeed.
Bernie Mccomb
A little-known part of our history that you have researched well, Robyn. Another thing for our Government to say Sorry for and belatedly do something about.
Meryl Tobin
Thanks Robyn for reminding us of some of our not so well known history.
The good news is that the Seasonal Worker Program and Pacific Labour Facility allows workers from the same areas to work in agriculture and hospitality here.
The twist is that they are rigorously supported to ensure they receive award pay and conditions and have (mostly) good accommodation. Some of these workers are seen from Aug-Jan picking the asparagus on the Kooweerup Swamp and other places. They often return each year.
Ian Teese
Holden bushlands campaign powers up
July 3, 2020
Thank you to everyone involved, so happy to read that council and our Bass MP Jordan Crugnale are trying to make this happen. I wish them good luck and will make sure to spread the message so we can get behind them.
Jeni Jobe
Well done to all involved. Let me know how I can help? I would love a dedicated area for Mountain Biking in Bass Coast as this is something we lack with the nearest areas over 90 mins away. Complimentary to the conservation benefits of this site becoming state own we could see a network of hiking and mountain bike trails to be enjoyed which would be a great asset for local residents and a year round (off peak) attractor to the region. The You Yangs being one of the better examples.
Michael Wright
Absolutely support this, especially in the context of the Healesville to Phillip Island Nature Link of which the Holden Bushlands needs to be a part for conservation, recreational and biodiversity reasons.
Pat Macwhirter
Thank you to everyone for all your efforts so far to ensure that the bushland is retained for community use. There is no doubt that the townships will be supportive and fingers crossed that this precious reserve can be retained for future generations.
Joy Button
thanks to and support for all trying to save this bush
Anthea Spehr
Well done... Certainly hope this site can be preserved for bushland.
Nicky Miller
Well done eveyone for the time you are putting in to try to save this bushland, I hope you are successful, thank you for caring about nature.
Sunny
Best thing I've heard of in years. So important to the future of W.Gippy.
Joan Woods
Virus diaries 7
July 3, 2020
another secret Ray Bradbury fan, welcome Catherine, the Bass coast is full of us (once i was a Martian or perhaps an ancient tree )
i probably have all the Ray Bradbury books except the most popular which are still avaliable, happy to lend, once i find the box they are stored, in due to replaced leaking roof and ceilings.
science fiction as predicted most of the messes we find ourselves in.
on the Feminist side U.L Quin wrote so she could be published the Wizard of Earthsea the most well known.
Love your diary slant on Covid life Nerida
Nerida Melsmith
Thank you, Catherine.
Nicky Miller
Call for action on safe cycling
July 6, 2010 –
We definitely need to extend our bike path network and upgrade and replace sections of the existing network which has failed.
Remember, it’s dream selling season, and without a plan, it’s just a thought bubble. The same bubble I’ve been hearing about my whole life. Where is the plan?
I have one. https://mikhaelabarlow.wixsite.com/mbarlowforbasscoast/arts-and-lifestyle
Just an idea, have thoughtful day everybody.
Mikhaela Barlow
Saving the magic forest
July 3, 2020 –
Thank you Meryl for a most informative story. These grass trees must be protected.
Dan Drummond
Thank you for your research and advocacy for this amazing bit of bush.
Nicky Miller
600 years old! And they want to destroy them, how sad, very sad, money is a temporary gain, but nature is there for all generations to enjoy. Please save the grass tree's>
Sunny
The journey continues
July 3, 2020
Inspirational Stuff!
Rowan
Second time round
July 3, 2020
Beautifully written Etsuko and so informative. Thank you for sharing and especially for sharing those GORGEOUS photos!
Shaz Green
Etsuko, once again a beautifully written and sensitive article by a UNIQUE woman.
We are very privileged to have you in our lives and for you to share your stories.
Phyllis Papps
Dear Etsuko san. My goodness! 60 amazing years clocked up! I imagine this COVID-19 lockdown has made your 60th year specially reflective and nostalgic. I wish you all the very best and a wonderful future. Just like the tombo- keep moving forwards! You are a lovely lady and like a muffled temple bell echoing through the dawn, my memory of you stirs me even after all these years..hugs, kisses and respect from Ian xx
Ian Thomason
‘Absolute disgrace’ in 2020
June 19, 2020
We must, never, ever forget Julia Gillard's brilliant speech regarding misogyny, sexism and how men in 'power' use their privilege to dominate and try to silence women.
Phyllis Papps
Heart warming comments, Brett. That humility should be bottled.
Gill Heal
Thank you Brett. Such important comments from a community Leader. They really matter,
Anne Davie
Big-spending budget to kickstart economy
June 19, 2020
Is Cowes Cultural Centre really going to be a totally rectangular tilt slab box? For $20M?
Bernie Mccomb
Thank you Catherine. OK BUT only $130,000 for Affordable Housing Initiative?? And what can you do with $130,000? Some repairs? We need more affordable housing in our area.
Felicia Di Stefano
On a matter of debt and interest. Is the Shire permitted to issue bonds - at the mortgage rate charged by banks? If so, many older people with savings might like to invest in their Shire. Interest from bank deposits is too low for some oldies - and they live on income from savings - a diminishing return.
Peter Brown
Hi Peter, This sounds like a good idea. The Municipal Association of Victoria does have a funding vehicle... Local Government Funding Vehicle for councils to use to borrow funds at cheaper rates than banks. Your thought should be investigated by our Shire Council.
Frank Schooneveldt
Virus diaries 6
June 19, 2020
Excellent Catherine. Library to open this Monday - Hooray! But a big thank you to the Wishart Street book swap, stopped me going stir-crazy. I love Don Watson's writing. I keep his Dictionary of Weasel Words in my bedside cupboard - open it at random often and SO GOOD. The Mahers Landing nonsense unbelievable - Anderson's Inlet is the delta of the Tarwin River - the channels shift with the tides and amount of water flowing from the river. Silly developers could dredge forever and even sillier 'buyers' would find their jetty with water one day. overnight the water has moved over to Point Smythe! Mother Nature has her own agenda - remember the Morwell River diverted for an open-cut coal mine, then the river decide to go back to its original bed - goodbye coal mine. Crazy. Homo Sapiens think they are clever enough to 'tame' nature. Covid 19 could be another weapon in the Planet's armory, We would do well to remember - there is no Planet B. Yvonne McRae
Yvonne McRae
Another good read and I feel I am immersing myself into the life of a stranger as I follow your daily routine through your diaries. I, too have just visited a dear friend who lives in a care home and was devastated to see the downward spiral of her dementia in just nine weeks. She has lost herself and does not understand. Her mind wanders off and she struggles to find the simplest of words. To me this is the highest price of Covid and I hate it. I want her back, but sadly she can’t come.
Janice Orchard
What a smorgasbord of happenings you've gathered Catherine - thank you! Living 20 minutes out of Wonthaggi has made my trips to 'town' diminished to once per week during the lockdown. Other days are slow and relaxed - a wonderful way to wile away 6 days a week! Not that I'm not busy - transforming garden produce to freezer parcels, or to dried fruit jars, planting brassicas and more lettuces and colourful flower pots, knitting a coffee plunger a 'jacket' ... and if course reading - Watson's 'The Bush' is still waiting, which is just as well as the restrictions are back on from Monday. Not sad.
Sue Packham
Catherine, I have been loving the insights of your virus diaries and was amazed to see the poster of Resurrection: Ertuğrul in number 6. I too have been watching the travails of the Turkish Kayi tribe as they are riven by internal factions as well as having to combat the Templars in season one, battle the Mongol invading force led by the Noyen, an enigmatic character constantly shadowed by his drumming shaman in season two, followed by conflict with a fellow Turkish tribe, the Cavdars and Vasiliyus the unlikeable Christian commander of an outpost fortress in season 3. So many enemies; such a long time. I need a break now before tackling season four. Strangely, I have also been reading the Neapolitan novels.
Julie Constable
Councillors can marina plan
June 19, 2020
Thank you to councillors and officers for consigning this astonishingly insensitive proposal to the bin,where it belongs. The landfill bin- not for recycling in the future.
Mark Robertson
The inside story
June 19, 2020
Well done Jane, Nick and Matt, Now you can write your own headlines!
Readers will always go where the best story tellers have the freedom to inform and inspire. Stay true, stay local and the readership will find you.
Geoff Ellis
Good luck Matt and team with your new venture. Will you be covering Yarram as well?
Julie Constable
Great to see this initiative. Please don't allow it to be a vehicle for anyone's personal agendas. If we know news and stories are accurate and informative we will support you.
Neil Rankine
May you succeed Matt and staff. I look forward to reading 'The Paper'. I well remember you remarkable story about community sponsorship of refugees and the lack of it in Australia.
Felicia Di Stefano
Your eloquent Farewell To Print makes me want to read more of you, Matt. If courage is "grace under pressure" (Hemingway), you're not lacking in that department either. Paper is dead. Long live The Paper!
John M Gascoigne
Money, going cheap
June 19, 2020
Bass Shire is full of dirt road suburbs like Jam Jerrup. We are always 3-4 years away from getting the bitumen, drains and pavements. Meanwhile we put up with dust in summer, mud in winter and people and dogs sharing the roads with cars. In the good old days road building was a useful source of projects to increase employment during a recession. So how about clearing that backlog of dirt road suburbs that never get sealed because there is no new subdivision levy to pay for them.
James Glover
The solace of birds IV
June 19, 2020
Patsy, every time I read, listen to, observe, look at your wonderful paintings and read your wonderful stories- I am in total awe.
Phyllis Papps
Thank you, Patsy. What relief from busy computer research to look at lovely bird paintings and read your descriptions. We have visits from almost all the birds you mention but love to watch the little wrens splash in the bird bath as we eat lunch on our sunny deck.
Felicia Di Stefano
Clock ticking on Holden sale
June 12, 2020
A great article, Catherine! It summarizes how local groups and individuals have been working to save the woodlands of the GMH Proving Ground since first alerted to the probability of the site coming on the market. Hopefully, Bass Coast Shire Council will pass motions concerning the Proving Ground next meeting.
Should the Victorian Government buy the Proving Ground, what a chance to set up an almost instant Western Port National Park (working title only)––one starting less than 100 km from Melbourne and taking in reserves stretching along the Bass Highway from Lang Lang to the Corinella turn-off and then to Bass Landing on the Bass River and back along the coast taking in foreshore land to the Lang Lang River. What a gateway to many of Melbourne’s prime tourism areas!
The purchase of the Proving Ground is the key to the establishment of such a park.
Anyone who agrees with the proposal for the State Government to buy the Proving Ground and the reason why should let our Government representatives know immediately. If not, the land could be sold any time behind closed doors to someone else.
Contact the Member for Bass, Jordan Crugnale: Jordan.Crugnale@parliament.vic.gov.au, 9 McBride Avenue, Wonthaggi, VIC 3995 or ph (03) 5672 4755; the Premier, Daniel Andrews, daniel.andrews@parliament.vic.gov.au, and the Minister for Energy, Environment and Climate Change, Lily DÁmbrosio lily.dambrosio@parliament.vic.gov.au.
Meryl Tobin
One of the last areas of its kind . It must be saved .
Rob Wilson
Thank you Catherine for this succinct summary of the situation. I hope many readers will support this campaign by contacting relevant politicians and spread the word to anyone else who might add to the effort. In other times there would have been public meetings to inform the community and share the reasons why protecting this site is so vital. Make your views known anyway you can!
Anne Heath Mennell
This is an excellent summary of the effort that a large number of people and organisations have put in, in order to save this site and it's unique flora and fauna for future generations. The importance of this site from an environmental and ecological view point cannot be overstated. You would think that Bass Coast Council and Victorian State Government, both very vocal in their green ideologies, would have jumped at the chance to take positive action on this matter. I find it interesting that the Bass Council chose to approach the State Government on the issue rather that applying its own protective overlay on the property. It is a mystery to me why the Bass Coast Council did not decide to do both. This would have given some protection and clearly demonstrated council's intent. I would be interested to know whether the council receives rates for the property and if so how much and whether the council receives a royalty for the removal of sand from the site. Also the value of such royalty. I have been following the discussion on this matter and the one thing that stands out is that whenever council's actions are queried those queries are dismissed as being negative and not to be actually answered. It seems to me that it is possible, council decided to take this matter to the State Government knowing there was no chance they would buy the property. This way Council and councilors will be seen to be trying to do the right thing only to be thwarted by the State Government. This way they will be able to point out that Council raised a motion to approach the State Government to buy the property, This motion was supported by all councilors and passed unanimously. Subsequently Council officers and councilors made repeated approaches to the State government with out success. Once the property has been sold, we need to deal with the new owners and reach agreement on usage and protection measures..
Trevor Brown
A break from poverty
June 12, 2020
Saying that Newstart has risen since petrol was 65 cents a litre is not quiet true. Newstart has increased with inflation over time to cover some of the increase in things like the price of petrol.
Peter Bogg
Has It? I am happy to be corrected.
Geoff Ellis
Something very wrong when unemployed people are forced to live on $40 per day.
Julie Tyrrell
I agree - wrong, inhumane, punitive and undoubtedly unChristian! Are you listening PM?
Anne Heath Mennell
Very interesting however, slightly embellished I think. Having been made redundant before retirement age ten years ago, I had to go on Newstart because I was not old enough to claim the Pension. Newstart is not a lot of money but it's not intended to be a substitute for a wage. I applied for at least a dozen jobs in Wonthaggi but the Centrelink officer who interviewed me, placed me with an Employment Agency that would take into consideration the likelihood that I wouldn't be able to get a job, so didn't enforce the interview criteria etc. Slightly frustrating because I really wanted to get a job but realised early on that was not going to happen in Wonthaggi.
Anyway, after a couple of years I was able to claim the Pension which I thought was hard to live on until a fabulous ANZ bank officer showed me how to budget. I still haven't got a lot of spare cash but I don't panic now when bills come in because the money has already been set aside. I cancelled private health cover a couple of years ago and have now gone totally public. Good enough for Paul Keating, so good enough for me. Sure, you have to wait a bit longer for dental but it's not the end of the world.
There is also superannuation, presumably, if the examples in this article are employed or have been employed until recently. Mine was spent long ago to make my little old house liveable but I'm comfortable and can save up for the rest of the refurbishment. My car was recalled by the manufacturer a couple of months ago for airbag issues but was too old to repair. With the money provided (market value) I was able to buy a tricycle, with some leftover for a bottle or two of red! My range has now shrunk but the freedom of not worrying about running a car is amazing not to mention the financial saving. I could sit hear and whinge but, hey, I'm alive and the sun is shining. There is always a rainbow in every situation ... eventually.
"a victim of a heartless scheme of an evil genius in the government to extract money from the poorest people in our society" is a bit over the top and I guess you'll be pleased to hear that the PM has apologised.
I'm gonna have to buy ear muffs soon though .. the wind whistling passed my ears in the morning is getting a bit chilly!
Pamela Jacka
The positive disrupter
June 12, 2020
It is absolutely impossible to define this wonderful, inspirational woman who 'moved the earth' and motivated so many people and especially women.
Kay was, and still is, an absolutely powerful force in politics as well as a wonderful feminist and community activist.
We all salute you for your incredible achievements. !!!
Phyllis Papps
Brilliant nomination and wonderful nominee! Kay you are wonderful and I celebrate this award with you. Our friend Margaret Ray would be proud!
Ian Turnnidge
A new beard and a smiling mind
June 12, 2020
Hi Miriam, You're lucky only to have two single hairs at the moment. I have dozens and my erstwhile fair facial fuzz is turning black and bristly in places. I don't think a beard would suit me so I still remove the worst. Let us know how you go with yours ...
Anne Heath Mennell
Hi Anne, yes, I may change my attitude if the density increases significantly!
Miriam Strickland
Miriam,
another wonderful, thought-provoking and at times an amusing article.
YES- the aging process is not much fun.
BUT one of the advantages is: we don't have to look stunning all the time, we don't need to do anything unless we feel like it. And yes 'The Black Dog' is there lurking in the background...
As for meditation, gym classes, learning how to use Zoom etc. etc. I just choose what I enjoy the most- my garden, my dog, my friends AND my music (because it soothes my soul.)
As for past failings and future fears- I just write about them exactly the way you did. Somehow by writing, it eases our anxieties and fears.
I look forward to reading another one of your articles.
Phyllis Papps
The armchair arts tour 4
June 12, 2020
What fabulous writers we have here in our region !!!!
Combining the brilliant and intriguing art of John Mutsauers, with words and music was very inspirational.
Congratulations to everyone who entered the competition and especially our highly esteemed editor of Bass Coast Post for winning the first prize, Karen Bateman for receiving second prize and Wendy Saphin for third prize.
All the writers who entered the competition have the opportunity to submit an entry for the Bass Coast Prize for Non-fiction 2020. Closing date 4th September. Check the website: https://basscoastprizefornonfiction.weebly.com
Phyllis Papps
Don't be sad Liane. Freedom is having the thought: 'Damn it! I can win this'!
John Coldebella.
Bravo, Catherine! Wonderful writing: humorous, wise, perceptive, layered, offering such breadth of commentary on the human condition through each one of John's paintings. I loved it! Congratulations too to Karen and Wendy for their beautiful essays.
Marg Lynn
Marina project fails on 17 counts
June 12, 2020
Fingers crossed this will be a rare win for the community and common sense!
Anne Heath Mennell
University hub announced
June 1, 2020
This is superb news. Congratulations to all involved! As a former secondary teacher and as a parent whose children had to live away from home to gain their tertiary qualifications, I am very aware how desirable it is to have tertiary educational centres in regional areas.
Meryl Tobin
Great news for our young folk, who by now have had extra practice with remote/online learning, and maybe for some of us elders as well.
Miriam Strickland
Congratulations to everybody involved in this great initiative. A fantastic opportunity for our youth and for those of us who want to return to further their education.
Great news
Frank W Schooneveldt
This is big news and great for the region.
And yes Miriam, I've also been really impressed with how community members of all ages have embraced Zoom technology during the COVID lockdown.
Rev Ian Turnnidge hosts a Zoom conversation after the livestreaming of the Sunday service from St John's. It's absolutely wonderful to see people, some of whom are in their eighties, happily connecting and conversing in Zoomland.
Laura Brearley
Fantastic news with exciting potential for Bass Coast population.
Sandra Peeters
Exciting news, just fabulous! Congrats. to the BC team working during the past year on this initiative. So good for our young (and older) people to be able to live at home and keep in touch with their local community. Also the money aspect of students having to find suitable accommodation in the City and pay their rent (always high) or even part rent ALL the year even when Universities are closed. So good! What a relief to parents etc. who had to find the cash to 'help' out their precious children. Well done everybody. Yvonne McRae
Yvonne McRae
This is good news, but a University that would attract outside students, and similar rural universities elsewhere may give our students that essential experience of the step into independence and adulthood. In England, tertiary students embrace studying outside their area as part of the tertiary experience, even if they have a local regional university in their nearest city.
It will be interesting to see the level of support offered to hub users. As a postgrad who studied from home, with very few on campus experiences, i know the value of rubbing shoulders with other students; that 'increment of association'.
Jennifer Boer
Very exciting news for this community. Well done to the team that brought this initiative to our community.
Samiro Douglas
Congratulations BCP first with the news again. Will be good for children who cannot afford to go to leave home to study as well as all the other benefits mentioned. I know of such a one. She will be very happy.
Felicia Di Stefano
Fantastic, this will provide so much more access especially for those students who do not have good access to the internet too.
Sunny
Congratulations BCP for this great news. How exciting for Wonthaggi and our region at large
This is going to be a great opportunity for upcoming students in our community wishing to go to university. It will also be great as students will have the opportunity to live at home while doing their university studies.
It is great for our community and for the bass coast region.
Nina Debono Wills
Wonderful news! - really worthy of the 'news flash' thanks Catherine for keeping us up to speed so well.
Lee Tierney
This is tremendous news!
David Manning
Wonderful news. I am so glad that this is happening.
Jacqui Paulson
I was the first in my family to go to university, at a time when girls like me didn't always have the support to undertake tertiary study. It was a wonderful experience and my degree has opened doors I would never have known existed. Whilst I agree with Jennifer about the value of leaving home and value the experience of living and learning on campus with other students, any initiatives which reduce barriers to higher education are very welcome. Everyone deserves the opportunity to continue their education, reach their potential and enter careers their parents only dreamed of. Living in the country should not be a barrier, especially with all the online opportunities now available. The next barrier is money. I was only able to go to uni because I qualified for a grant. Now may not be the time but I would like to see fees reduced, especially for students from regional and remote areas. Surely the costs of providing online learning must be less than lectures/seminars/ and facilities to on-campus students.
Well done everyone at BCSC.
Anne Heath Mennell
Fantastic news......for our community, young and the not so young. To be able to study at a tertiary level locally is going to open doors for a lot of people who might otherwise miss out because of distance, finances and the cost of accommodation in the city. Really good news !
Gillian Armstrong
Fantastic news for the whole area!
Peter Efthymiou
This is very exciting, might even go back to uni myself. Congratulations BCSC.
John Mutsaers
This is such a fantastic outcome for our community. Very proud of our shire for leading this project.
Nina Barry-Macaulay
I can imagine Wonthaggi as a University City. Next it'll have a world famous 'how to chill' festival, and continue to be a cooperative initiative - the soul of Wony.
Julie-Anne Trease
Just wonderful news. Best wishes to all involved.
Natasha Williams
This is such fantastic news! great work BCSC.
Amy Easton, Secretary Wonthaggi Business & Tourism Association
Excellent news and congratulations to BCSC.
Ursula Theinert
This is great news! It will hopefully engage more young people in their education, with the prospect of being able to keep their connections to family and friends and achieve their goals without moving away.
Rhonda De Stefano
A work in progress
May 29, 2020
Thanks for this personal insight Pamela - a piece including much common sense. I too hope: “perhaps we will also gain a greater sense of community and willingness to support those in need without judgement, because who knows what tomorrow brings and when we, ourselves, may be that person in need.”
What a well organised desk you have. It’s got me looking at mine....
Natasha Crestani
Pam, another fantastic article. So meaningful, so enlightening. Because you and Judy are, and have always been such great inspirations.
Love from all of us at Rhyll AND the rest of the community.
Phyllis Papps
Excellent article Pamela, once we all start to realise that goods & services should last, be effective and not harm our environment, and ideally be produced in Australia we will realise we don't need to work five days a week to consume junk, whether consumables, media, services that could be delivered at the local level, etc. We don't need overseas holidays if we take the time to appreciate the environment right here in Bass Coast. Life can be a lot simpler and more enjoyable. I can remember 40 odd years ago a teacher telling us we would soon be working only four days a week, with technology improvements, how did we complicate things so much? Perhaps the time has come though.
Neil Rankine
Congratulations to Pam for questioning old ways of working. The five-day working week is drudgery for most people. When I reduced my working week from five to four and then three days (with a pro rata drop in pay, of course), I started to enjoy work again. I’m sure I was much more productive and much more creative.
The COVID crisis has started the conversation we need to have about work: a four-day working week, staggered working hours, remote working, at least some of the time …
Pam writes of the lockdown: ”New business opportunities opened up as staff developed creative and innovative ways to diminish the possible isolation”.
Good managers foster ideas and creativity in their staff. The happiest and most productive workplaces are those where workers have a high degree of autonomy. They know what they have to do but it’s up to them how they do it, and it can apply to anyone from a truck driver to a solicitor. Autonomy fosters a sense of ownership of the job and pride in the work. It also lifts productivity, which the PM keeps telling us is the necessary precursor for higher wages.
Several friends who’ve been working from home have commented on how much more productive they are at home. One found she could do all her work in the morning. She wonders whether she will return to the distractions and obligations of office life, including those interminable meetings about nothing in particular.
It’s not for everyone, of course. Some people have complicated home lives. Others enjoy the convivial atmosphere of a workplace. And of course we’re really only talking about office workers, not the bulk of Bass Coast workers.
Then there’s the debate about casualisation and job insecurity, but that’s for another time.
Catherine Watson
Get ready for action
May 29, 2020
It is good to see the positive notes from Mayor Tessari and to see that he is embracing remote meetings and conferencing. It is also encouraging that councilors and the council are actively seeking state and federal funding for all sorts of projects designed to stimulate the local Bass Community economy. However it is disappointing that there does not seem to be any attempt to obtain funding to complete the welter of internal roads that have never been sealed. This despite several strategy plans for the San Remo, Newhaven area that, although approved by council many years ago, are still waiting to be actioned. Funding for these types of projects would provide several jobs, which is in line with the general thrust of the article by Mayor Tessari. Comments from the Premier have indicated that this type of infrastructure would be advantageous and greatly assist in the state's recovery. Also in terms of value this would not require tens of millions of dollars, the residents affected would, I am sure, be prepared to contribute and the tourists and locals alike would have the use of safe access into the relative townships. Which, especially in San Remo, is something lacking at the moment. Mayor Tessari rightly points out that tourism is the major driver of our economy and any action that is able to be taken to enrich and enhance everyone's experience would be helpful. So how about spending some funds on the safety of tourists and residents. This may not be as visual, as print worthy and something that you can say look at what we have done as would a new Skate Park, a new Cultural Center or a new Tourist Information Center but, in my opinion much more important.
Trevor Brown
I agree with you Trevor. We have a huge backlog of infrastructure structure works in the Bass Coast that needs to be fixed especially the roads and footpaths. Here in the Bass Coast we have a very strong Balance Sheet that we need to gear to tackle the infrastructure issues.
I am sure that if we were to borrow some money and ask the state and federal government to match our borrowings we could fix the infrastructure issues and create jobs.
Frank W Schooneveldt
COVID-19 has shown up Bass Coast's heavy reliance on the Tourism and Hospitality industry. Too many eggs in one basket! Brett, your comments about new opportunities and working from home should prompt thinking in Council about strategies to encourage new industries to grow in our region.
Wonthaggi is projected to grow strongly over the next decade. What are the jobs being developed? More B&Bs and cafes? More Construction - to build the houses but then what?
'Knowledge industries' include businesses that can take advantage of the NBN and our relative proximity to Melbourne, enabling workers (and their families) to live and work in our beautiful environment (see Pamela Rothfield's article in this editon).
Now is the the time to be building on the capabilities we've developed during the Lockdown, to diversify the Bass Coast economy.
Maddy Harford
Maddy, I agree with you it's the whole country that needs to re think its approach to what businesses we run, Victoria especially was the manufacturing base for Australia with highly skilled work force, the last few months have shown we can't continue as an economy that just buys things from rest of the world, stores and delivers them. In Wonthaggi years ago there was manufacturing all disappeared to be replaced by shops selling mainly imported goods. Now retail shopping is also struggling to survive, in this fast changing world we need to be smarter and no reason while areas like Wonthaggi can't be part of the revival. Tourism is certainly still a very important part of our economy on Bass Coast and hopefully the Council can be part of the solution to get the economy going, as Trevor Brown and Frank Schooneveldt mention in their comments.
Chris Day
Last gasp for Jam Jerrup
May 29, 2020
Congratulations Tony on your success. We were down there last weekend checking the birdlife at Stockyard Point and was surprised at the ongoing destruction of the cliffs/beach. What struck me was the lack of Mangroves. We passed a healthy stand on the walk to Stockyard Point and wondered why they were not growing in front of the houses or cliffs. I would have thought that planting them in front of the houses would be a cheap and effective way of stopping/minimising the erosion.
Peter Bogg
The Cyan Way
May 29, 2020
very interesting and great insight the science is there and evidence
George V
Excellent concept. Its time to rejuvenate and protect what is left of our precious wetland environments. Jump on this opportunity and invest in a new market which has multiple benefits to all stakeholders and our fragile coastal environment.
Muddy Feet
Country comes alive
May 29, 2020
Dr Laurie Brearley and Terry Malvin have created a beautiful film with underlying tones and feelings that expresses and involves the viewer in a small insight into the culture and understanding of the Boon Wurrung
Thank you for the journey
Ian Samuel
Thank you Laura and Terry for this amazing video of Kugerungmome. A special walking place for me as well.
Margaret Lee
Thanks for your comments.
I'm discovering that Kugerungmome (Powlett River) is a special place for quite a few of our community members, including our much loved Bass Coast Post Editor, Catherine Watson.
Laura Brearley
Wonderful !! Thanks
Michael Nugent
thank you - beautiful images, sounds and words!
Ann Taket
Beautiful!
Marian Quigley
One of my favourite places and made more special by Terry's video and Laura's research and beautiful writing. 'm delighted to learn this new Boonwurrung word Kugerungmome. Language is our way into reconciliation. I look forward to the day when we greet our friends with "Womenjika!".
Catherine Watson
Virus Diaries 5
May 29, 2020 –
Another brilliant and insightful article. Lots of hugs (social distancing of course) and hope Matilda can cope with three legs/arms. !!!!!
Phyllis Papps
Loved it, made me smile and of course reflect. Hoping Matilda makes a speedy recovery
Michelle Graham
Thank you so much,Catherine, for your newsy and entertaining pieces. Zoom, Skype and especially the Bass CoastPost have really helped to connect us in isolation... as well as, of course, wonderful friends and neighbours here on Phillip Island and nearby towns. Let's
see what happens now, and Thankyou!
Carolyn Goldberg
Fruit of the gods
May 29, 2020
Thanks for these ideas. I've just dealt with our copious fig crop for this year - eating fresh, fig jams - with apple or ginger, fig paste, and fig spread.
Have printed and will keep these recipes in mind for 2021.
Elizabeth Hickey
Our 100 year old fig is still going strong and I was delighted with the jam we made using cassia bark and stirring in lemon peel. An added bonus - the lemon peel which is removed from the jam before bottling is to die for. Steeped in the fig and cassia bark flavour it is a perfect accompaniment to blue cheese.
Liane Arno
Grebe $m community 0
May 15, 2020
Thank you, Peter, for attending, and for reporting, however depressing.
Nalin
Reading Peter's account of his involvement in the VCAT process certainly struck.a chord with me. I was President of a group called Friends of Skeleton Hill (North East Victoria) some years ago that opposed an application from a mining giant to turn said hill into a quarry. I have to say that from the moment the VCAT hearing began, which ran for something like two weeks, I knew in my heart that ours was a lost cause. The Shire in question had rejected the planning application, but as was apparently the case here, just didn't have the financial resources to match those of the applicant. They were paying a senior counsel $14,000 each day, plus whatever his bevy of underlings and expert witnesses were costing them. It was very obvious that the VCAT panel and the applicants senior counsel were on very good terms with each other, which certainly didn't fill me with any great sense of hope. Needless to say, the developer won the battle, and like Peter, I doubt if I would ever bother to front VCAT again, no matter how passionate I felt about the issue at hand. My estimate is that the quarry company probably spent over $500,000 arguing their case at VCAT, we managed to raise $20,000 from our tiny community to help put our case to VCAT, and that was probably the difference in the end.
Graeme Charles
HUGE thank you to Peter and his stalwart band who attended VCAT. Little people who live next to or near a proposed development and objected (30+) are pushing the proverbial uphill, compared to the $m's available to Planning Mafia, consultants, 'expert' witnesses, blah blah. Council are in a bind also - how much ratepayer monies do they spend on legal eagles and others. It has cost the developer huge money to fight for 4 years. There is still the million for infrastructure before the 83 lots can be paced out. Then will people want to live next to the Transfer Station and Dog Pound, and the cemetery. Over the many years I have lived here I have planted thousands of trees, shrubbery etc. for massive shelter belts and wind breaks. The developers want to make sure they show prospective buyers around on calm, sunny days, otherwise the Southerly blusters will push them over to North Wonthaggi! Cheers, Yvonne
Yvonne McRae
Thank you Peter, and your band of committed community members, who tried to oppose this development. Disappointing result, particularly when we are always told, particularly lately, that we live in a democracy. Sometimes, you cannot help but wonder .....
Joy Button
Thank you Peter and supporters for trying and for telling us about the process. At least you managed to delay the development so that's something. I heard a zoom discussion among several lawyers recently. There was Julian Burnside, Jess Taylor and a couple more. Among other issues, the group decided that the law and justice are not connected.
Felicia Di Stefano
Thanks Peter for the report. There is no justice when a developer can withhold documentation to stop the council from making a decision, thus forcing a hearing at VCAT.
In my experience, VCAT favours development but in the 5 times I have attended hearings, I have been successful if my objections are within the ResCode. Other objections are not considered.
The continual increase in Australia's population means more of the areas you tried to preserve will be sacrificed on the alter of 'Big Australia'.
Peter Bogg
Thank you Peter Mckenzie for writing up the VCAT response. It is
discourging for people who put in hours of volunteer work weekly on the
Rifle Range site.The loop holes developers have in process is disturbing
in our democracy. We were all so tired as three and a half years was a long battle. I want to give up but the new issues as outlined by Peter are important so we go again.
It is important to read the VCAT documents on cases as I have noted in the other press lately their account differs from the fact.
Beth Banks
Thanks Peter for this insightful analysis and also, very useful advice for how the Cape Paterson development proceeds. The lack of detail in developers' plans is something that is clear in the Cape Pat scenario too.
Leticia
i have to agree with Peter - The VCAT process is arduous and defeating. The fight to stop the 250 caravan site behind Forest Caves is entering its 4th year at VCAT.
As a local resident VCAT now asks me to pay to attend and receive information, it starts at $20.00 and I wonder where it will stop.
Building on a swamp, one sandhill from an unpatroled beach, a new entrance onto Phillip Isalnd Road, no amenities at all, scary stuff will it join the airport development at cape woolamai ? That makes makes a bit more sense as it abuts housing development already.
Nerida Melsmith
Thanks Peter for your article, and especially to you, Dave, Beth (and anyone else?) for putting up a good fight in VCAT. We appreciate all the hard work that went into it, and hope the community can be active and vocal about opposing the Maher's Landing development proposal, and saving the GMH Proving Ground as a public reserve.
Alison Brewster
Thanks for the memories
May 15, 2020
Ed, the real estate, restaurant & travel (albeit two double-sided pages only) were in the Weekend Australian.
Listening to all the comments about coping during the pandemic, I wonder if we would be better off if we managed instead? Coping is a negative word, whereas managing has much more of a control sound, don't you think?
Pamela Jacka
Thanks for your thoughtful piece of writing Ed.
Your son is lucky to have such an actively engaged Dad.
Your family is lucky to be eating home-made sourdough bread.
And we are lucky to have you articulate some of the details and richness of your lockdown experience.
It may look like a 'small life' from the outside but your thinking is expansive. I really enjoyed your seamless weaving together of thoughts about cruise ships, empathy for people in the London blitz and the marvels of comparative rainfall analysis.
Keep writing. You have a gift.
Laura Brearley
Great to see how you've settled into life in Inverloch Ed....and now your boy is 12, how quickly time passes.With all good wishes, Bob
Bob Sharples
Simply the best locked-down story I’ve read, Ed — bright and breezy sweeping confinement from its foundations!
John Gascoigne
Great article Ed but what about the environmental gem you care for which fills you with joy and gains so much respect from people like me.
Daryl Hook
When blood turns bad
May 15, 2020
Hopeful in so may ways. Great story, Mark.
Gill Heal
What a great story of courage & tenacity Mark. Congratulations to you & the Wonthaggi medical team.
Marie Broussard
Happy to read that you need not go to Melbourne for "a twenty minute" treatment anymore Mark and thank you for an up to date report on the BCH cancer treatment unit. Good to have so much support from local community at a difficult time in your life.
Felicia Di Stefano
Hi Felecia, the treatments take a bit longer than 20 minutes - 12 hours of infusions spread over 2 days. This meant 2 nights stay in Melbourne. Now I can be back home and resting, so much better for
my soul.
Mark Robertson
Thanks so much for sharing this, Mark.
Nicky Miller
Down to earth
May 15, 2020 –
This is wonderful Liz. I'm intrigued by reclining trees as well, including those that re-sprout, pushing branches vertically once again. And your childhood memoir is enchanting. Thank you!
Miriam Strickland
Liz, you always write with great feeling and sensitivity about nature - trees, birds and your personal experiences connecting with nature. Check out the website for Bass Coast Prize for Non-fiction 2020.
Phyllis Papps
Brave new world
May 15, 2020
Interesting article. Come join our art group. The Isolated Penguins. We have an article in this edition of the Bass Coast Post as well
The-art-of-isolation. We a group of artists making art on these themes. We began at the beginning of this pandemic. In the article is a link to our Facebook page. Or simply search The Isolated Penguins
Baden Johnson
Well said Frank, What better way to spend recovery dollars than deal with climate change, thus; employing people, improving and cleaning what we're doing on/to this planet and respecting others and their positions. Ain't it great when cleaners and nurses are valued. Ain't it great that we're finally listening to scientists again. Should all fall in to place if we just stop and have a think along the way.
Neil Rankine
The solace of birds III
May 15, 2020
A beautiful story but one that is common to many districts - disappearing native species - birds and mammals - forced out by homo sapiens. Patsy I have had Grey Shrike Thrushes at my home on the outskirts of Wonthaggi township for many years. If I sit out on my deck in the sunshine invariably one (or two) come and sit on the railings - they sing to me and I do a fair impression of their song back (even if I do say so myself). I usually give them a tiny bit of cheese and they like this. Keep up your good work. My whole acre of trees, shrubbery and gardens are a haven for birds. I have compiled a list over the years and have identifies hundreds. This is why I regularly set cat traps (and catch them - BC By-laws officers remove same). My place is for BIRDS and Mammals and reptiles - not a smorgasbord for cats. Take care, Yvonne
Yvonne McRae
Good on you Yvonne.
Neil Rankine
Patsy, another beautifully written and illustrated article- so sensitive, so natural. I look forward to reading parts IV, V, VI etc.
As for traps of any kind, I totally object. There must be other ways that selfish cat owners can be educated or penalized regarding the importance of preserving our wildlife and environment. The other alternative is that they go back to suburbia.
Phyllis Papps
Literary flame still burns in Bass Coast
May 1, 2020
Well done Phyllis for encouraging local writers again, and thank you to Catherine and Geoff for generously supporting this initiative.
Lorrie Read
Thank you, Phyllis, for your incredible generosity in every sense. Your contribution to our community is immense. And thank you Catherine and Geoff for all the amazing and hard work you put into this project.
Sue Saliba
Thank you Catherine (Bass Coast Post) and Geoff (Waterline News) and all our wonderful supporters and writers in the Gippsland region.
We hope the Bass Coast Prize for Non-fiction 2020 will attract more entries this year and we definitely want to encourage and support non-fiction writers.
Just check the website: https://basscoastprizefornonfiction.weebly.com.
Phyllis Papps
Gotta run
May 1, 2020
A wonderful read and very timely share Etsuko. Thank you for sharing the joys of life when you slow down and when you run. A dichotomy many of us are facing in our lives either literally or figuratively.
Shaz Green
I love the way you write Etsuko. From the heart, and in this case, about the heart :-)
Tony O'Connell
Etsuko, I am so happy for you, that your health is all good!
I look forward to the day we can all get back in to Park Run and see so many happy faces, enjoying our beautiful region.
Lyn Harris
Etsuko- you are so honest and generous in your writing - that story is all the more powerful because of that - thank-you. This time makes us pause and face our mortality - you've shown a way to make that a good thing.
Kathy Hill
Etsuko, une piece tres incitative; nous rappelant que chaque jour nous devons apprendre de ce que la vie nous donne.
Helen Patterson
Bonsoir Etsuko, Je suis vraiment contente que votre joli coeur soit en parfaite condition!
Et je suis d’accord avec Helen.
C’est dommage que ce soit seulement après avoir surmonté des moments difficiles dans la vie, que la plupart des gens réalisent que les plaisirs de la vie se trouvent dans les choses et les moments les plus simples. Je vous admire!
Bernadette
With a smile I read the end of your story.
I really enjoy your writing and am so pleased that your heart is happy to run.
Enjoy it Etsuko and also life in general
Keep writing, not in stress, in passion.
Verena
Open for business
May 1, 2020
Good for all those businesses. Keep safe. BUT I am bursting for the Library to again be open. I have read all I had, many my daughter brought up from Melbourne, re-read books from years ago, (now on The Transit of Venus), but am really hanging out for an open Library.- go away Covid-19 you have outstayed your welcome. Cheers to all, Yvonne McRae
Yvonne McRae
I agree, Yvonne. Surely if the state govt is thinking of re-opening the Casino and pubs it will allow Libraries to open? They are so much more than just books ...
Anne Heath Mennell
Too close to home
May 1, 2020
Love it, 'Jennifer'. yes, Gratitude, or the need to express it, is a life-saver but we have to get real at the same time. People like you (and my daughters) working and home schooling at the same time, are the heroes who are making the government policies actually work! We won't forget it!
Jillian Durance
Bob Smith and Wonthaggi
May 1, 2020
Thank you Wendy for your commitment in securing this magnificent Collection for Wonthaggi. In the years to come it will be acknowledged as a great gift to the people of the Bass Coast Shire.
Anne Davie
Thanks Catherine for keeping this in our span. Thank you Wendy for bringing Bob Smith and his amazing gift to us. It’s hard to realise the enormity of the Robert Smith collection.
John Mutsaers
What a fantastic legacy Bob leaves - let's hope that the Arts precinct gets off the ground. Bass Coast is so much more than sun and surf!
Pete Muskens
Sorry to hear that Bob has passed on. It’s a tremendous legacy and proof that even in your last years you can really make a difference to the community.
Edward Buckingham
Virus diaries 4
May 1, 2020
You are so funny and clever, Catherine, capturing a little of all our experiences in your gorgeous musings. Thank you.
Margaret
About fab; a really great read, thks Catherine.
Michael Nugent
Catherine many of us can relate to your experiences. The Post has been a welcome 'read' in these lockdown times. Cannot wait to drive through Wishart Street - hope there are couple of books still there. (I have 2 to leave for 'other' people). My daughter escaped to Wonthaggi once Melbourne became unbearable. She has found clearing up around my garden (1 acre) never is finished. All the blown down bark, twigs etc. collected and then along comes the next 'blow'. Keep well everyone and there will be a 'light at the end of the tunnel' just hope it isn't another train coming in ! Roll on Library OPEN please. Cheers, Yvonne
Yvonne Mcrae
Thank you Catherine, I'm really enjoying your Virus Diaries good for a lol and a gratitude check in.
Susan Fowler
Cathrine thank you for an interesting read and insight into different experiences of COVID-19
Robyn Smith
The reading goddesses are smiling on the good people in Wishart Street. Something to READ thank you. Yvonne
Yvonne McRae
Loved your writing. I can hear your voice and its inflections as I read. Very relaxing and sane.
Judy Soerink
Thank you Catherine. I'm loving your diary observations. The daily oddities and normalities. The contrasts with the experiences of friends in other lands. I left a bag of books for a neighbour in the letter box this week. She left me eggs. cheers Julie
Julie Constable
Constant reader
May 3, 2020
Dear Catherine,
I am no longer a resident of the Bass Coast but have many wonderful memories of the people and the landscape. Over the last couple of years i have continued to read the Post and have always found it such an interesting and enjoyable read.
The latest edition has been my favourite, so many wonderful stories written by such talented community members.
Virginia Stelzer, Jan Juc
Fast forward to 2022
April 17, 2020
Mikhaela, what a wonderful vision you have. I applaud your enthusiasm, passion and creative thinking and sincerely hope that we witness your vision coming to fruition in the future.
Pamela Rothfield
Thank you, Mikhaela! Just what we need in these dark times. I don't think it's a pipe-dream at all. Everything you've imagined is feasible and you provide a wonderful vision for us to aim at. Keep spreading the word - we'll need all the support we can muster to make this vision a reality. Onward ...
Anne Heath Mennell
What marvelous imagination and vision you have. It must come to fruition, I and I am sure many others applaud and support you. What can I do to help? Congrats and thank you.
Pauline Taylor
What a beautiful vision! Thank you for the positivity.
Nalin
Thank you Mikhaela. Yes we will dare to dream.
Anne Davie
Brilliant Mikhaela! You’ve mapped out a truly tangible vision.
Linda Cuttriss
Thank you Mikhaela. It really is a beautiful vision - even if half of it comes trues - it will be of enormous benefit.
Joan Woods
Congratulations Mikhaela! a very thoughtful and thought provoking piece. It is a vision that is comprehensive, creative yet doable. It's a wonderful goal for our comunity to work towards.
Maddy Harford
Congratulations for having the tenacity to pursue your vision for the GMH Proving Ground at Lang Lang and present a scenario post the Coronavirus pandemic, Mikhaela.
Though you outline in some detail your vision for the developed section of the site for active community recreation, I'd like to see more detail given concerning the protection of the natural environment. I see this as the major concern - how best to preserve and pass on a priceless heritage to future generations. That's why my vision is for the GMH site to be declared a national park with consideration given to community use for the developed section.
Meryl Tobin
Crises I have known
April 17, 2020
Human beings have an amazing capacity to adapt and work with change. Thank you for sharing these inspiring stories. When we return to work, business, play and life - we will do it in an adapted way, think outside the box, and we will do it together - whether we ever have a vaccination or not.
Natasha
Why do we continue to ignore these forgotten memories from our Grandmothers & Grandfathers? Mostly Grandmothers? 💖
Kim Veness
Hello Kim, by virtue of the fact that this article has been printed, it seems clear to me that we do not ignore these memories. As a member of a district historical group, I can assure you those memories are being recorded and are available for everyone to see. Check out your local historical groups when all this is over and you will be pleasantly surprised.
Pamela
Thanks Eulalie your memories made excellent reading .The bit about Post Office on the front verandah reminded me that Margaret’s grandmother ran the Pound Creek post office from her verandah? We even have a photo to prove it. Cheers Daryl
Daryl Hook
Thanks Eulalie, it is a great reminder to those of thus that until now have led a life free of these types of events. My mother was in London in WWII and tells me about how she was evacuated to the countryside where she enjoyed freedoms that she would not have had in London.
Wendy Davies
When I was 10yo the threat of a 3rd world war was areal fear due to the Cuba crisis . Never forgot those few weeks. So my point is how much it affects the children during all of this.
We have had it easy compared with our parents. I appreciate the article written by Eulie Brewster
Rosemary Loughnan
I so enjoyed reading your article Eualie. Polio still left its mark when I was at school in the 50's.The sister of a friend spent her days on an elevated bed with huge bicycle wheels and others had calipers on their legs. Alan Marshall came to Hampton High school when I was in Year 7 to talk about his childhood after writing " I Can Jump Puddles"
The epidemic I can recall was Scarlet Fever. The hospitals were so overcrowded that because my case was relatively mild I stayed at home in isolation. A barrier across the bedroom door so my younger brother and sister couldn't come in and ihad daily visits from a doctor. He gave me horrible huge injections for the first week then revolting tablets to suck. Imagine mum's horror when she found I was hiding them under the pillow!! I think I was about 8 at the time and books and coloring were about my only entertainment.
Didn't Hampton High School see some changes. We were in church halls and portable classrooms at Hampton State school down the road to start our secondary education. There'd been a fire in the main building. Later that basketball court was again sacrificed for a school Hall and now it's just a housing development.
Now isolation give more time for reflection and enjoying the garden and local environment.
Carole Johnston
Ninety-three years bring a lot of memories. Thank you, Eulalie. The Scouts’ motto “Be prepared” produced an air raid shelter in our backyard during World War 2, but my mum famously filled it in after scooping out one too many drowned hedgehogs. In the 1950s, the motto also had us sent home from primary school after any big earthquake. Then, from our dad’s tool shed roof in the backyard, my brothers and I would peer over our neighbours’ hedge, prepared for the ‘tidal wave’ we’d been warned about. This was, after all, in Blenheim, near Cook Strait in the Shaky Isles. The wave, which, disappointingly to my overactive mind, never arrived, would have been in fact a tsunami, a word that came to (un)popular use decades later.
John Gascoigne
Virus diaries 3
April 17, 2020
The Wonthaggi Food Collective has wholemeal flour in stock.
Jessica Harrison
Thank you for a very funny summary of your week in Wonthaggi .... loved it. With regard to your beer loaf ..... you may have overworked the dough when mixing and perhaps try 'resting' the dough in the tin for five minutes to allow the gluten in the flour to develop. Regarding wholemeal flour .... an alternative could be to put some rolled oats through a food processor for a little bit and add to plain flour? May not be like the real deal but could be a compromise. Happy baking and good luck ..... I literally have banana bread waiting to come out of my oven as I type. Fingers crossed.
Joy Button
Catherine I am in awe of how you have captured life as it is for now and have become aware of the subtle changes in mood as time in isolation leaves it mark.
As someone who was already in retirement before the s#!t hit the proverbial fan, I must confess to not feeling too much of a strain other than the curtailment of my very busy social life. While I have reveled in time painting in my studio, pottering in the veggie patch and cooking endless batches of scones, I have been guilty of saying "this is not too bad".
But now I am aware of the extreme hardships this isolation is causing for others confined with small children, juggling working from home and home schooling. And then there are women stuck in situations of domestic abuse who must feel so very alone. While I have been counting my blessings others have been counting the days until they can escape difficult conditions.
Shame on me for enjoying the comfort of my own bubble.
Janice Orchard
I think the hardest thing for me to come to grips with is the hardship suffered by the homeless. They are moved on relentlessly by the police who monitor the campsites, the beaches and the rivers. They get told to go home. But where is home for them?
Liane Arno
Catherine, you made me laugh out loud and nod in recognition many times. Thank you. Our comic relief has been to begin a small bbq shed project with my husband despairing of a woman who doesn’t want all right angles and regular shapes. Grand Designs has a lot to answer for, he wails!!! Stay well 😊
Jeannie Haughton
I wondered why sewers would be called hearties but then I realised it wasn't the type of sewer that the s**t runs down!
My 22 year old car was recalled about a month ago, perhaps longer, and after waiting a couple of weeks, I became the proud owner of a 7-speed/battery powered (for the hills) tricycle. Therefore, I say, what virus?! I'm too busy ringing the bell and warning people that there's a "learnatic" on the paths! Plus I'm an "essential service" for a local not-for-profit group whose emails I check twice weekly which keeps me relatively sane. I'm looking forward to what Australia is going to be like when it's all over. I'm feeling quite positive.
Pamela Jacka
Such a great piece of writing! Captured this period perfectly. Lovely.
Nalin
I read every day about the words and deeds of Morrison, Trump, Frydenberg and Pence. Then I switch on to Coast Post and learn what Etsuko, Simon, Jill, D, Linda and Cate have been up to. Only one group is vibrant and real to me. It's not the first one.
John Gascoigne
If you can make people laugh out loud at themselves and the situation they're in, you're doing a great job, Catherine. Many thanks to you for your Virus Diaries which I look forward to each issue. Apart from the laughs, they are very informative of what is going on in our society.
Meryl Tobin
A time to spend
April 17, 2020
Well said Michael. This crisis sucks but we might as well use it to build a better future.
Lars Olsen
"But the time will come – hopefully soon – when the focus will shift to stimulus and investment in projects that create jobs.."
Yes! Hope and looking for the positive is the way forward.
Natasha
I congratulate the Council on its decision to proceed with the Redevelopment of the Cowes Cultural Centre. In the years to come we will reflect that the Centre was achieved at a challenging time, because the Council of the day believed that community empowerment is an investment in its future.
Anne Davie
Great news! It is also known that the plans put in place by Roosevelt also had loop holes which have led to the present unequal situation the world faces today.
Make it watertight please.
Joan Woods
Hi Joan. In 2017 Yunus stated that eight individuals now own more wealth than 50 per cent of the global population. That continues to concentrate I suspect and wealth has a way of aggregating especially in tough times. He suggests another way in 'A World of Three Zeroes" but I am not optimistic. Trickle down is a cruel joke it is at least a Trickle Up and mostly a flow. A complimentary way is suggested by Rifkin in 'The Third Industrial Revolution." Decentralised production of eg energy and goods similar perhaps to the commons approach.
Michael Whelan
Just dropped in
April 17, 2020
We have mesh wrapped around our metal chimney which touch wood keeps starlings out.Something about the smell tells starlings that a hollow tree is right here.Like you Maddy they already think it's spring and time to look for a nesting site.Why oh why did early settlers bring rats mice and starlings.PS and us.
Daryl Hook
Had the same trouble Maddy, though not with starlings. I tried mesh around the flue, but that sooted up and stopped the fire drawing properly. It was also a bit of a hazard. Finally got a chimney man to replace with a bird-proof cap.
Tony Norquay
Happy to read that you are finding interesting and diverse ways to occupy your down time Maddy, as well as keeping your brain active solving the problem of the best way to evict a starling out of a house. You may acquire new skills and be an expert in a new field. Then you'll be the one thanking the starlings.
Felicia Di Stefano
Maddy, I laughed out loud. The matador image was delightful, is your tea towel red? When I was a child brush tailed possums used to get down the chimney into the wood heater - Mum and Dad would do as you have described to allow the possums their freedom.
Wendy Davies
Solace of birds, II
April 17, 2020
Patsy, another most enjoyable article about the birds in your garden. Your observation and understanding of birds is excellent, as is the wonderful way you describe each bird species and how much they love your very natural garden.
Your paintings add such a beautiful visual element to what you have written.
Also I should add that your passion for bird-life, nature, conservation and the environment is truly appreciated by so many people in the community.
I look forward to 'The solace of birds III' and hopefully one day soon you may decide to publish a book.
Phyllis Papps
Thank you, Patsy. Whenever I see beautiful illustrations like yours I brace myself for the dry-as-birdseed text by the writer’s ornithological collaborator. At the end of my reading just now, I felt as though I'd had the full Leunig experience -- creatures reflecting the best of humanity back at us. Boy, do we need both of you now!
John Gascoigne
Council's $1m support package
It is good to see the Shire looking after its own. Sometimes the future needs to remain in the future while the present is taken care of. It's the old saying - We can make plans but life happens.
Joan Woods
Open all hours
April 19, 2020
Well done Catherine Watson. A wonderful initiative and generous gesture. I hope that you receive lots of responses.
Rob Parsons
Beaches closed for Easter
April 7, 2020
Once again the majority of good abiding citizens are punished with draconian laws for the few that will disregard any restrictions that don't suite their selfish and narcissistic nature.
Why not empower the good people of Bass Coast with the maturity and respect they deserve in confronting and shaming those that may do the wrong thing.
The current system is working well and there is no reason why it can't continue to.
Lou Pecora
Punished or protected? Sadly, the system isn't working and a vigilante confrontational shaming system is doomed to fail. Too many people have been flouting covid19 protocols and they have ruined it for everyone. Our hospital system is not designed to cope with a huge influx so the advice is STAY HOME and stay safe. That's why the beaches are closed.
Geoff Ellis
I think people's health is much more important than a fun gamble on one of our beautiful beaches. That would include everyone's health in our area and beyond. Authorities are doing their best to keep us all as safe as possible. We must acknowledge their efforts - by staying away from beaches and making the most of our own homes and properties.
Sue Packham
I'm disappointed to see that the general public are being encouraged to act as pseudo police. Very dangerous and, dare I say, "unAustralian" (which is not a real word but ...). Think how nice and clean (no foot prints, etc.) the beaches will be after Easter when all the locals can return to their usual pursuits. It's only for a few days, so let's not fret too much. Just don't dob people in. If you're there to see them, perhaps you are also flouting the rules? Let those employed to do the job, do the job.
Pamela Jacka
Thank you and hopefully there will be a large sign put the at entrance to San Remo and at the Bridge between San Remo and Phillip Island
Judy Rogers
Hooray! Well done, let’s hope people abide by the regulations.
Lynda M Hanlon
Meaning? The beaches at Inverloch have had signs up for days saying they are closed, but we have been allowed to swim and walk; just no sitting. Please explain. 😊
Peter Ghys
Peter, I think this is the "Beaches Really Closed" moment. The earlier signs were designed to deter city people but these are the real deal. No one is permitted to go on the beaches. I gather it will be policed.
They are assuring us it is just for Easter so we must be vigilant.
Catherine Watson
Beaches - is this legal? The Victorian government hasn't stipulated this - many other beaches are open. A week ago there were about 6 people on a 2km stretch of beach, with no threat of encroaching on each other as we walked along and tried to clear our minds whilst excising.
I understand that people are worried about Wonthaggi hospital's ability to cope, but it's getting confused with holiday home owners.
If holiday home owners come down (for example to secure their homes, since we may not be able to do this for many months) we are in no way impacting on local hospitals due to COVID-19. As the article itself puts it, Wonthaggi hospital doesn't offer the services. We would rather return to Melbourne for health services. We are not making the situation worse locally.
I don't want to fixate on hospitals, but most local comments seem to be about concern for Wonthaggi to cope. Lets follow this through for a moment - if we aren't welcome at our own local hospitals in Bass Coast, should Melbourne residents welcome permanent Bass Coast residents to Melbourne hospitals? Didn't think you'd like that idea.
We have no intention to interact with the local community under these circumstances (but normally we would love to interact and support!).
So many issues here, just saying that we should be permitted to secure our properties and get out.
Please try to be considered and understanding in your responses. We LOVE Bass Coast and identify with it very strongly. Would love to be retired there already, but need to earn some more money to enable that in the city :-)
Georgina Day
The Chief Health Officer, the Victoria Police Deputy Commissioner and Dan Andrews himself have all said holiday home owners staying in their homes should be manageable, provided they follow the rules whilst there. They have also said that holiday home owners (and long term renters) will not be fined for travelling between their properties.
Georgina Day
I suppose this means we can all spend time mingling in the safety of Bunnings ,et al, Seriously, for someone like me with very low immunity a quiet beach and some fresh air is probably the safest place.
Mark Robertson
Good point Mark. There are many inconsistencies. You can't go for a round of golf (minus the drinks on the 19th hole) or take a tinny out to sea but you can shop at Coles. Oh and you can go out to shoot ducks, thank god.
BTW, it seems that the Bass Coast beaches managed by Parks Victoria are not closed for Easter. That includes Harmers and Williamsons.
Catherine Watson
Looks like you're correct. Lots of reserves still open, including Kilcunda - Harmers Haven coastal reserve https://www.parks.vic.gov.au/get-into-nature/safety-in-nature/covid-19-update
Georgina Day
Beyond the view
April 3, 2020
Thanks, Linda - a superb and fascinating summary.
One comment: I really enjoy the way that traditional chicory kilns have inspired contemporary buildings on Phillip Island.
Rob Youl
Linda, a fine tale of give and take, well told, and now recorded. Thank you.
Tim Shannon
Great work Linda. Your “big picture” account of how the landscape has changed over the past two centuries of European settlement points us to a more considered interaction with our wild and beautiful island.
Peter Dunlop
Sublime.
Geoff Ellis
Congratulations, Linda. What a huge amount of research you must have done to write such a comprehensive feature. Thank you.
Meryl Tobin
An excellent article, well researched, beautifully written and with some very good references. A meticulous history. Well done Linda.
Phyllis Papps
What a comprehensive look at the changing face of the island’s landscapes and the pressures, threats and will to overcome them. Thank you Linda.
Julie Constable
Great work, Linda! A well researched and interesting read.
Karen Bateman
The virus diaries 2
April 3, 2020
Catherine your take on this gives some light relief amongst so much hysteria.
I’m part of ‘essential service ‘ too - acting as supervisor and morning site meeting attender without having to leave my house as a carport gets built and reroofing.
Up to 4 or 5 different Gracie folk a day apologising for disturbing me when I’m isolated due to bronchits ( yep a bit more scary than usual ! )
I whip out my ‘ workie tape’ to the requisite 1.5 mtr and say ‘please you’re living up my day no end! ’ We’ve all managed to turn serious discussions abt lockdown, if the roof‘s half off, into a Monty python type comedy!
How lucky am I - construction is a week ahead of schedule!
I offer free drive by Grand Design tours with tomato foraging on the side.
Pm me for the postcode to avoid uncalled for vigilante island behaviour. The fear is out of control certainly worsened by the media.
Nerida Melsmith
Thank you for making me laugh a lot, Catherine. Best c...... update I have read so far. What a friendly, sharing street you live in. No chance mistrusting neighbours around your area. Stay well and keep laughing. Though I worry about those who cannot pay the rent and refugees squashed in detention centres and hotels, I am enjoying the peace and the vegetables and fruit from our garden.
Felicia Di Stefano
Thank you so much for your Virus Diary Catherine. As we learn to daily deal with the new normal, your take on things makes it more possible to think outside the new square.
I know it is being said all the time but we really are all in this together,
Anne Davie
As usual, Catherine (editor of Bass Coast Post) is wonderful at observing people, their behavior and has an excellent understanding of human nature. She also has a wonderful network of friends, neighbours, colleagues etc. AND of course she is a brilliant and satirical journalist/writer.
Another fantastic summing up of what our life is like now.
Phyllis Papps
Oh you are a gem, and an essential services one at that!!!!
Lynne Steer
Thanks Catherine that was fun. When The Post hits my inbox it brightens the day
Geoff Heyes
Thanks Catherine. Loved your diary comments. It's such a pleasure to smile and your dry
humour helps our poor media soaked brains get back some perspective.
Judy Soerink
Thankyou Catherine, love your delightful observations. We all need to adopt a sense of humour if we are to survive the next ?? months!
Susan Pryde
Have you thought about writing professionally? You're very good! You almost sound like a conser ... no, I can' say it! Slagging the ABC? I have to say I'm surprised. Good on you, it's time we had a laugh about this.
ps. Totally unrelated but the storm on Saturday night was his orchestrated departure and I can't publish in the Sentinel - Felix 02.05.2000 - 04.04.2020
Pamela Jacka
Nineteen years, eleven months and 28 (29?) days is good going. A storm is the perfect soundtrack for Felix's ascent.
Catherine Watson
Anyone who knows Catherine is very well aware of her extensive professional background in terms of writing biographies, journalism, fantastic news stories, profile stories, feature articles etc. The list is endless.
Phyllis Papps
It's time for our own national park
April 3, 2020
Thank you for sharing the historical background, Meryl. We need all the information we can find to make the most of this opportunity, not just for Bass Coast but the whole of Victoria and Australia. Preserved by a fluke for more than sixty years, we cannot allow this treasure to be lost. I just hope we can be heard given the current difficult times.
Anne Heath Mennell
During the Spring of 2018 I visited The Gurdies. I was surprised to see horse riders had access to the park and were trampling the precious orchids.
Colleen FitzGerald
Never mind the Horse Poo in the Gurdies Reserve. We dog owners must take ours home.
Has anyone else noticed the mountain Bike tracks built by enthusiasts despite local restrictions. Parks Victoria assures me it will be put right but nothing has happened since my reporting it last October. Trees chopped and jumps made, precious soil piled against trees to improve the run.
The home of the precious Spurred Helmet orchid vandalised........
Margaret Lee
I do hope that this site can be developed into a national park. I have walked The Gurdies many times over the years and it is a hidden treasure.
Joy Button
What about conserving some of the sacred land that helped “prove” a national emblem, the mighty Holden. Just kidding. A suitably inscribed chassis panel, discreetly hidden, would do the job.
John Gascoigne
A most valuable ecological initiative. So good to hear about the way you are going about this. All the very best for early progress.
Elizabeth Ann Buckingham
Thank you for your comments. It is good to know others care about our natural environment. Anyone who is interested and not already part of the group working to preserve the woodlands of the Holden Proving Ground could email editor@basscoastpost.com to join in the correspondence on this. Those interested in the wider vision outlined above, such as those wanting to ensure the Grantville Grass Tree forest is protected, might also like to be part of it.
Meryl Tobin
Closer to the edge
April 3, 2020
Well said Geoff ... in particular your last paragraph which I urge all Bass Coast Post readers to re-read.
Rob Parsons
Have recently come back from a short holiday to the south west of W.A In Busselton we saw the geotextile sandbags being used on the beach. They were pleasing to the eye, made a great seat and were saving the beach from erosion. The beach was beautiful and I took photos in the hope that I could show this method of erosion control to people who didn't want to see more basalt boulders on the beaches of Bass Coast. They are a no brainer, when it comes to aesthetics and family friendly apart from saving our beautiful foreshores from further erosion. Keep up the good work and make it Bass Coast wide where erosion control is needed . I suggest the Silverleaves beach area, east of Sanders Road be a place of great need, and used by many families with young children every holiday. Hopefully NOT this Easter...
Gillian Armstrong
Thanks Gillian. The bags do make very useful seating. Maybe they will evolve into outdoor forums.
Cr Geoff Ellis
Excellent idea Geoff...... another plus for this 'multi purpose' method of erosion control !
Gillian Armstrong
I support Rob Parson's comments and Geoff Ellis article. I served for a number of years on the Grantville and District Foreshore Committee but resigned in frustration in October 2017. Despite a number of community meetings to discuss the continuing erosion threatening Waterline Communities and suggestions for measures to ameliorate the problem no worthwhile funding was forthcoming. Solutions morphed into talkfests. There have been some valiant efforts by Bass Coast Landcare Network to tackle the problem but funding for more substantial works such as sandbags, rock walls and groynes have not been forthcoming. It seems that residents of the Waterline Communities lack the clout of more affluent areas of Bass Coast such as Inverloch and Silverleaves.
Ian James
Thanks Ian. Agree and thank you for your efforts.
Geoff Ellis
Holden’s last hurrah
March 20, 2020
Great article Tim!
Let me know if there's any petition to sign or any other pressure we can get to bear on Government or GM to get this important area saved for conservation. It's an ongoing disgrace that so many multinational corporations are the first to come to government when they're in financial trouble, yet baulk at paying any tax as part of their quid pro quo!
Pete Muskens
Great article and idea Tim.
Peter Dann
Congratulations, Tim! A refreshing look at a possible future for the GMH Proving Ground, an incredibly valuable environmental and economic asset which should be gifted or bought for the good of the community.
Meryl Tobin Brown
That's an excellent article. I do so hope the site is gifted for wildlife conservation or that council and government unite to protect it for that purpose. The income and tax figures you quote are appalling in their cost to Australians. Thank you for presenting this important article.
Susan Linley
Send a message to GM HQ.
Mary Barra - CEO and Chair of GM
linkedin.com/in/mary-barra-29469712
Dhivya Suryadevara GM CFO
linkedin.com/in/dhivya-suryadevara
General Motors Company
P.O. BOX 33170
Detroit, MI 48232-5170
Geoff Ellis
Thanks Tim. It is always good to get the facts - the proving ground has always had a slightly mysterious air about it. Anyway it can be kept as it is, count me in.
Joan Woods
Good idea for tourism but at this point of time with USA virtually closed down and we not far behind not the time to pursue this.
The governments, companies and people around the world have more important things on their mind than a block of land in Victoria.
Nothing will happen at this time , follow up at the right time and that is certainly not now.
Christopher Day
An excellent article and great idea. Not enough is being done in conservation on this scale. This is such a good opportunity for the Council and Government to move on this together, NOW, before it's too late......what possibilities, they're endless when it comes to the environment and the future. I say, act fast and act now.
Gillian Armstrong
I enjoyed most of Tim's article and agree that the site would be a wonderful area for conservation purposes. However I think it would have been better if Tim had not published such misleading figures. He cites Gross Income for several years and complains that no tax was paid on this income. He conveniently forgets to take into account the operating expenses of those years or to mention that in the years 2013/14 the company made an operating loss of 554 million dollars and in the year 2014/15 made an operating loss of 255 million to mention just two. The subsequent years were not much better. It was these huge losses over several consecutive years that led to GM opting out of Australia. Consequently this shows that there is a very good reason that no tax was paid during the period Tim published. Given Tim's background he must have known how misleading the article is.
Trevor Brown
Trevor Browns information on GMH losses adds a new dimension to the debate. You certainly wouldn't want to approach GMH with incorrect financial information they would dismiss any discussion . I doubt they would only be interested in selling the land for the best deal for them clearly they we're in bad financial situation or they wouldn't be withdrawing from all right hand drive markets around the world not just Australia . The last few months and however long this corona virus lasts will no doubt leave them in far worse financial position .
If the Victorian community it going to obtain this parcel of land for long term benefit of the community it needs to put together a financial offer that they could accept expecting them to donate it is a waste of time . Of course as a housing estate it could provide a developer great parcel of land in an area where future housing is closer to Melbourne than areas like Wonthaggi so to stop that happening any approach to GMH has to be commercially well put together . Another question is does Bass Coast council currently collect rates for this land and if so how much is paid each year.
Chris Day
Ed and the Birds
March 20, 2020
So much food for thought! I thoroughly enjoyed reading this Karen and have to digest the good and bad news to work out if we're coming out on top.
Hilary Stuchbery
loved the story and the complexities in it.
it reminded me there's quite a few guerrilla planters out there .
one of them informed me when i was explaining some of the looks and questioning it best to some how get the word ' beautification ' of the medium strip into conversations. And yes just keep planting
Nerida Melsmith
It was such a pleasure to read this first time around and, on the second reading, it really resonates, especially the last line.
Geoff Ellis
Karen, I loved your inspiring story about Ed and the birds. I had virtually given up planting shrubs at my place on Phillip Island as they need a lifetime of defending from wallabies. Trees get above wallaby height and tussock grasses get too rough for their palate. But your story has made me rethink how I can create little protected shrubby places for the small birds. And all power to Ed’s guerrilla tactics!
Linda Cuttriss
This is a kind and inspiring story. Thanks Karen. You write beautifully.
Carmel Anderson
Karen what a wonderful account of Ed, the birds, the interrelationships and the changing face of our world. Thank goodness for optimists no matter how plodding! Thank you.
Julie Constable
Hello Karen, Wow what a wonderful article, I remember our ramblings around Inverloch 20 years ago, my how it has changed.
Wendy Davies
Thanks everyone for your kind comments, and for taking the time to read it.
Karen Blackman
Immensely proud of my cousin Karen, on her ability to make me think about things in a way I never have before. Writing is a passion, but a cheerleader for change. Well done wild cousin Karen, which has different connotations to me now. Natural, native and not prescribed. So very proud of you x
Sara Fellows
The virus diaries
March 20, 2020
Thank you Catherine! You have made me laugh and cheered my week no end.
Camilla Myers
What a brilliant piece! Your observation is accurate and I love your witty expression scattered through your writing. Your insight and wisdom certainly lifted my heart in these uncertain times. Now our local gym and swimming pool The Y is closed and I'm jobless. Thank goodness I have my writing.
Etsuko Yasunaga
How easily our civilisation can unravel, it seems like only yesterday that our leaders were exhorting us to take an empty esky, go out to the bushfire-ravaged areas and buy from small businesses. It appears that the hordes have taken this too literally, pillaging our country supermarkets - how unseemly. I expect that Post readers will behave in a more civilised manner than most and that you all remain safe from this latest version of armageddon. Perhaps next time the PM is consulting his good book and praising the lord he will look up the chapter titled Wrath of God.......
Mark Robertson
Oh Catherine you do make me laugh
This is a pretty common trauma response as as for being unAustralia, I cringed when I heard the PM say stock up- I though you have no idea what you are unleashing. Turns out he didn’t and is now blaming the people - give me a break please!
As for me I probably fit into some kind of food hoarder category- what has Costcodone to us ! I shop late Oct Nov and buy enough nonperishables and new products I’ve never seen before ( to try! Cos I can) to feed a family and friends of 12 for a month. This January Feb wasn’t that busy, and the two chooks on fire rescue lay an egg every few days. So fresh fruit and veg is all that’s needed.. I don’t feel quite so odd now!
Nerida Melsmith
What a hoot Catherine! As I went into IGA (no toilet rolls, no pasta, no UHT (only 'fake' Milk- made from seeds and nuts -yuk drink water) but plenty of people to have a chat with and shake our heads over people's foolishness. Loved your comment about not being able to get crap from China (in our family we call it Chinese Landfill), but for .
'cheap' we let our manufacturing industries shrivel so lots of 'stuff' comes from OS. I do read labels and usually can find products in the food line Made in Australia (avoid asparagus from Peru and cherries from the US of A). We eat seasonally and grow vegies and fruit. Keep up the good work and full marks to the contributors of articles and cartoons. Some clown said life wasn't meant to be easy. Cheers.
Yvonne McRae
The clown (Malcolm Fraser, former PM) actually said “Life is not meant to be easy, my child; but take courage: it can be delightful.”. Like all good journalists, only part of the quote was reported and continues to be, incorrectly, reported. It was a call for people to have a go and don't be afraid. The results can be delightful. The quote is from a Bernard Shaw play,
Perhaps now with our borders closed, etc. we will remember what it was like to be self-sufficient and start manufacturing again. We just need to keep a rein on the wages so that we don't make our industries unable to compete with the "Chinese Landfill". We do make a bit of a profit out of the imported landfill - it's usually our iron ore!
Pamela Jacka
Bravo Catherine, I hope the hordes read the post. And well done to the commentators 1e Frank, Yvonne,Nerida... You've said it all. except, Australia also had ration books during and after the war. A message for the Polis,: Get them back again quick!
Heather Tobias
I simply love your story. I think all your readers can relate to it. Thank you Catherine
Jellie N. Wyckelsma
It was at Aldi's, not a bottle shop and l wasn't joking.
Hamish Watson
Could this be a return to village life, circa 1820, when people's concerns and information-exchange centred on the neighbours, the inn, the post office, the grocer's and the local dance? Likewise journalism and the bygone 'vox pop', where voices of people on the street appeared on a printed page. Thank you, Catherine! Just what the doctor ordered, apart from the hand wash and face mask.
John Gascoigne
Man of many parts
March 20, 2020
An interesting insight into one of our local hardworking councillors. Well written Liane.
Rob Parsons
As an ex ratepayer in his ward, I'd just like to back up Rob Parsons's praise of Geoff Ellis..
Not only for his interest in conserving as much of Bass Coast as possible, exemplified by his backing of Preserve Western Port in the "2014 "Battle of Hastings", (aka the container port), but also his 100% backing of me in a personal issue in the months before I moved back to Melbourne.
I know he is flat out 100% of the time, but I still wish he'd find time to have that dinner with me up here in Melbourne we discussed before I moved back here!!!!!
Tho that of course may have to wait until after this "Bug" drama plays out.
Good luck to all down there in the current crisis. I know full well what tourism means to Bass Shire...
Sincerely
Kevin Chambers
Great story Liano, we need more people like Geoff. I wish him all the best with the Lang Lang proving grounds. Hardly any bush left in West Gippsland, we need to conserve what remains.
Peter Bogg
Despite my inherent distrust of politicians I enjoyed this biography and the writing moved along smoothly.
Rowland Arno
Very interesting article on a very interesting person, Liane. I've met Geoff on a number of occasions over the last couple of years. A genuine,open minded person of great heart. An absolute asset to our community.
Ellen Hubble
Self portrait of an architect
March 20, 2020
A familiar journey for creatives I suspect- the inner need to puzzle and scrutinise their purpose... Architecture as the portrait of the client makes me smile... studio of delight. Yes. I reflect on my husbands and my own spaces within our home. It explains a lot 🤪 Thank you for the article
Jeannie Haughton
Tim, an informative article thankyou. Here are some random points about creativity in general I'd make. If you're scared to make a mistake creativity will suffer. If you follow the master you will not learn your way. Mistakes are your sub-conscious letting lose. "Considered mistakes" have an unexpected new direction, renewed power and surprising outcomes. My first boss said to me as a passing comment on something I was doing at my art desk... he said "Peter, take the bull by the horns",something I have used my whole career to date. Our pathways have a similar echo Tim.
Peter Walker
How wonderful to read another of your incredibly well-crafted, profoundly thought and beautifully written pieces Tim. I love the way your writing makes me think, question, wonder and then smile. I look forward to the next one!
Linda Cuttriss
The solace of birds
March 20, 2020
What a wonderful and sensitive piece of non-fiction writing about your love of nature, conservation and the environment. Your illustrations were a superb visual way to accompany the article. Every one applauds the many decades of your efforts and voluntary work you have devoted to Phillip Island and surrounding areas.
Phyllis Papps
Your words, with what they describe in the neighbouring 'nest', make for the most beguiling reading experience. Thank you, Patsy.
John Gascoigne
Lovely to read your observations of the birds in your garden Patsy. They are insightful and informative and your illustrations are wonderful. I always refer to your illustrations when I visit the bird hide at Swan Lake. They are excellent representations and it’s great be able to identify all the birds I am observing. I look forward to Solace of Birds Part 2.
Linda Cuttriss
Lovely article Patsy, I can so relate to your garden. My garden is my sanctuary, and is the food bowl for many native birds. I can really relate to your sentiment and your illustrations. My kids remember with warmth the drawings you would do for them as Lollypop Lady!
Gillian Armstrong
Such arrogance!
March 20, 2020
Just get in there and re-vegetate, erect a sign at the property boundary explaining the need for and value of the works. If the sign gets vandalised erect a bigger one!
Neil Rankine
On common ground
March 20, 2020
Thanks Frank, always good to hear from you and your incredible historical knowledge- totally agree
Angela Wishart
Thank you for this Frank. I love it. Beautifully written and absolutely fascinating.
Nancy Vaughan
Love your work Frank. What a beautiful piece of writing. Thanks for sharing
Tracie McIntosh
Ditto from me Frank. I love your stories. Please keep them coming. It’s always a good time to be reminded of Wonthaggi’s egalitarian roots. Not just for the sake of nostalgia, but as a legacy for now and the future, a reminder of what’s important about being human.
Linda Cuttriss
Berry delicious
March 20, 2020
Well done Jan. I really enjoy your recipes. Cheers, Yvonne
Yvonne McRae
Not so fast, GM
March 6, 2010
Amazing idea!
Vicki Breen
Good contribution to the wider conversation, Mikhaela. I'm sure there are plenty of ideas out there, which I hope will be heard by decision makers. My personal hope is that this unique place will become a State asset for the people of Victoria and, whatever activities are eventually approved, that the flora and fauna continue to be protected. We need to watch this one carefully.
Anne Heath Mennell
Michaela & BCP - you have well said exactly what has been on my mind since the Holden announcement. Get onto Jordan Crugnale to make representations on behalf of community to State Govt too.
Anne Paul
Hi Mikhaela, I think that GM should by rights gift this land to the people of Australia.
While Holden was riding high on the hog in the Australian market, with as much as 50% market share - and remember too that GM was assisted by the Chifley Government to establish manufacturing here under the General Motors banner - it repatriated handsome profits to GM balance sheets in Detroit for the better part of 60 years. It has also benefited from huge amounts of Government largesse by way of the Green Car Innovation Fund (which began at $500million, and grew to $1billion); then later, the Automotive Transformation Scheme - tipping another $400million into local manufacturing (before the announcements of closure).
In fact, over the 12 years from 2001-2013, Holden's own figures show it received $2.17billion in state and federal government assistance, compared to $1.1 billion for Ford and $1.2 billion for Toyota.
Each of these manufacturers was then assisted with taxpayer money - after the announcement of closures - to shutter the factories and retrain the workforce. This amounted to another $150million (or so).
To load more salt into the wounds, GMH hasn't paid for tax for years: income 2016/17 - $4,601,580,614, tax - $0. (You can thank internal invoicing, fees from the parent company, for that.)
So, should it gift its proving grounds to Lang Lang? I should think so. Australian taxpayers have, after all, already paid handsomely for it.
I reckon we can get a groundswell going here. I'm a former motoring journalist, I think I can swing a lot of them in behind this campaign.
So, who's going to be in from down here? Let's get a group going and see what we can get rolling.
Tim O’Brien
Great idea it's an asset that could add to the tourism in this area. Tourism is vital for the economy of not just Bass area but all of Australia.
Obviously the coronavirus is on everybody's priority at moment but it is showing us how important tourism is. It's also showing us how stupid we are as a country to close down our manufacturing sector which the state of Victoria dominated since WW2 mainly driven by buyers of major retailers going into Asia to get cheaper products and make more money. Now we find ourselves running out of products as we have no back up available .
My suggestion would be to get the federal government involved in this issue as vic govt have no new money to spend in sure the treasurer won't let Premier Dan anywhere near this issue.
Don't waste your energy thinking GMH will assist or donate the land they have shown only interested in their own situation not those who sold , serviced or bought their products .
Chris Day
Alzheimer Sufferer/Carer Suite
March 6, 2010
Malcolm, your tribute to moments - too seldom caught - in two lives eternally tied into one is gripping, devastating, haunting, cleansing. Bravo.
Fiona
Bravo Malcolm.
Jeannie Haughton
Lovely words. Thus we process what must have been hard to live!
Heather Slutzkin
Heather, what a profound way of putting it. The act of writing, though often hard, brings understanding. "Emotion recollected in tranquillity", as Wordsworth described it.
Catherine Watson
What very insightful comments, Heather.
Ann Stocker
Congratulations on the publication of this book of poems. Very insightful on the emotions and moments one goes through.
Lynn Rogers
Malcolm, this wonderful piece of poetry about love, life and loss is a superb piece of writing.
I truly hope that you will be able to have it published in book form.
Warm regards, Phyllis
Phyllis Papps
A special relationship documented, explored and cherished by the poet.
An achievement of note.
Nancy Endersby-Harshman
Damn you, John Mutsaers
March 6, 2010
Sorry Catherine, Messing with dreams mmmmmm?? nice thought.
Here is a little clue which I shared at the opening.
A man goes into a hardware shop and asks for 10 mm drill bit: what is it that he really wants???? He wants a 10mm hole. look beyond, behind and in the nooks and crannies then close your eyes and dream words.
John Mutsaers
Hi Catherine, I did brave the crowd and heard John speak, yes he seeks to tantalise and provoke, just what art should do. My takeaway was that the birds are thoughts and the cage is our captive paradigm; our upbringing; schooling; our fears and a wish to fit in. The great thinkers at least made it to a more expansive birdcage.
Michael Whelan
Catherine, Fantastic article, such an enjoyable read. You think you’ve got problems with John messing with your head, I’ve been married to him for 53 years!!!
Exhibition closes on the 29th March. Writers, come along and experience the exhibition and see if John messes with your head.
Mary Mutsaers
Catherine, You've nailed it. One of John's pieces just makes me laugh every time I think of it. Tried to write down why and failed a dozen times. A thousand emails end to end, endless bitumen stretching to the next event, that stretch of foreshore. I'll keep trying but
Geoff Ellis
Thank you Catherine .... loved this piece and made my grey day. Love your sense of
humour. Thank you.
Joy Button
So wonderful to see the mediums intersect...and go crashing off in different directions!!! Well done Catherine for having a crack, and thank you John for brilliantly making us leave your exhibition with more questions than answers!!!!!!!
Mick Green
Inverloch Primary School were fortunate to have our Year 6 minds discuss their thoughts of freedom while pondering over the fish in the glass art piece. 11 year olds discussed their thoughts in a conversation with the artist. Truly inspiring, thought provoking and challenging, with joy and cheekiness. All that art and education should be.
Amanda McMahon
Hi Catherine. I've worked out what the egg means! Only teasing!
Thanks to John for not only his wonderful works - but to give us such a challenge. I have finally managed to pen a piece - managed somehow to weave yellow, a cage and a mirror into a story - must have been drunk at the time!
Liane Arno
Poles apart
March 6, 2010
I'm a 30+ year firefighter (CFA), I live in the Bass Coast but spent days down in East Gippsland fighting the fires, I spend time on fuel reduction burns and I see the fire season getting longer and more intense. Yes, fuel reduction burns can help, particularly around assets like towns, where it can assist with firefighting. In the bush it's a different situation though, risk of loosing control, replacement growth can be more hazardous, much shorter windows to burn effectively.
I also vote Greens most of the time, as they have the policies most influenced by facts and science, not money and madness.
Some fourty years ago I finished an honours degree studying physics and modeling at Monash University. Back then we were taught the very basic physics, known for at least 50 years, of how greenhouse gases facilitate the warming of the Earth. Since we knew this we have nearly put half as much greenhouse gases again up into the atmosphere than has been there for a hundred thousand years or more.
There is no question any longer that this must and does influence atmospheric physics (the energy in the climate system). There is no question any more that things are still to get significantly worse with lags in the system, unless we act immediately to move to the systems of the future, that even the prime minister's advisers know, and tell him are here now and ready to use.
We have to replace our aging and unreliable coal and gas soon anyway, why is there any question about where we should be going? And why are we waiting, this will stimulate economic activity, create many more jobs than our current systems, open new markets for savy farmers and reduce the price of power. And that's not to mention saving our children from inheriting one hell of a job to cleaning up our mess if we don't act now.
Neil Rankine
I appreciate the effort that you put into your letter and commend you for being prepared to stand up for what you believe. And start a debate in these virtual pages.I believe our friendship can only be strengthened by serious discussion about real issues. Thank you.
I am working on a full and worthy response to the letter and would just like to clarify a couple of things. Hopefully the editor will allow me to have a couple of bites of the cherry!
You say that "A lot of the message that you conveyed was about the fires". My article consisted of 21 paragraphs and ONE was about the fires.
In regards Jam Jerrup, the failing I point out is the planning scheme (OURS) that allows development on an eroding coastline. I recently was informed that the rock revetment has been designed.
Right now I have to get back to my Infinite Birdcage. Cheers Cobber.
Geoff Ellis
John, you state:' I believe that today’s Labour Party and the Greens have much to answer for. They are the "fuckwits that are in power" in this state for not allowing controlled burn offs...'
I have heard this statement repeated often. It is wrong. Both the Labor government and the Greens have policies that encourage fuel reduction burns. Could you provide one example where Labor or the Greens have stopped a fuel reduction burn?
Fuel reduction burns have not been undertaken for various reasons, but basically for safety concerns. This is sensible decision making.
Peter Bogg
John: 'The Aboriginal people who fought in WWI and WWII fought under the Australian flag and provided a great service to this country. Australia does exist, and we are all part of it, fighting for it, and fighting for solutions. We are one country, one flag, one anthem and one people!'
Not true John, Most Australians fought under the Union Jack in WW1. Most Australians fought under either the Australian Red Ensign or the Union Jack in World War II. All Australian Naval personnel fought under the British Naval Ensign in both world wars.
The Australian flag as we know it now, was only legally defined in the flags act 1953.
Peter Bogg
Home is where the art is
March 6, 2010
Thank you Catherine. As part of the small team at ESPI we really need great publIcity as you have provided. Lovely article full of useful history of this energetic group.
Margaret McCubbery
Friends honour the 'two Bills'
March 6, 2010
A fitting memorial to two good men.
Peter Brown
We will miss farmer Bill in Harmers, he was part of the landscape
Trish Hogan
Pittosporum Flowering
February 21, 2010
Julie, thank you for gracing us with a beautiful read. Your writing evoked such a strong and magnificent sense of place and I was happy to have visited awhile in a place that you so dearly loved. It is a well deserved accolade.
Jessica Berry
That was beautiful Julie, thank you for sharing. I confess, I may too be harbouring a few little pittosporums. Thank you for so eloquently sticking up for our oft-persecuted weedy friends and giving us a glimpse into your world. May our gardens and forests be graced by such lovely inhabitants and protectors as yourself!
Dan
Lovely story, Julie. A pleaure to read.
Karen Bateman
Julie, what a beautiful narrative, so informative and skilfully woven personal and political, xx
Karen
Thank you - most enjoyable read.
Led Leunig
I really enjoyed your memoir Julie. Beautifully written, a joy to read, especially the imagery of the plants, forest and landscape. And I loved the way you weaved the personal, political and scientific through the piece.
Linda Cuttriss
Pulling all the threads together so eloquently, makes me intensely happy to have our wonderful subtle landscape so articulately traversed.
Learned a beautiful new word too! Nimbed! Glorious. Thanks Julie, a truly significant contribution toward our understanding of ourselves in this place. Hopefully opening a greater appreciation of and care for this beautiful land.
Susan Purdy
Beautiful
Theresa Cicero
Absolutely beautiful piece of writing I felt totally atuned to. Look forward to sharing with Lisa Kennedy. 😃✨🌸
Peter Corser
So informative Julie, I couldn't agree more with the bad rap those magnificent trees receive. Could it be possible that they are fire retardant, they look it. Regards, Pauline
Pauline Enright Amon
Thank you Julie, I feel as if you have strolled through my out of control oasis.
Twenty years ago I wandered through the Cowes St Philips Market to be overwhelmed by the most exotic fragrance, in a large pot, Mock Orange I was advised, though Pittosporum was not uttered. When it is in flower, & I'm asked, my response is a miracle of nature; as is a hedge of cream bell-shaped wonga flowers draped over the old trellis fence, behind the gas bottles. through the gate into Missy's garden, the Lost Dogs Home creature, to be framed by the white sprays of the clematis drape through the old pagoda to my back door.
I immediately identified with your wonderful narrative.
Virginia Hamilton
Memories of Hiroshi
February 21, 2010
What an incredible article , beautifully written to conjure up a picture of both an energetic and delightful young man and an aunt who holds him so gently in her heart . Etsuko has the ability to share her deepest emotions without overwhelming the reader - instead she draws you in so that you too can share in her pride, her grief ? Her resolution and her happiness . An inspirational article/ thank you Etsuko
Anne McDonald
Thank you Anne sincerely for taking time to read my written piece. I believe that everything (including both happiness and sadness) is better shared. If my writing can bring solace to any grieving heart, then I am content. Your kind words are much appreciated.
Etsuko Yaunaga
Dear friend Etsuko, so much wisdom, so much pain and grief and re-generation.
Your writing is so SPECIAL because you express so much emotion and so many words that most mere mortals are afraid of doing or saying or writing.
We are all enriched by your writing and your philosophy of life and happiness. Regards, Phyllis Papps
Dear Phyllis, your kind words touched my heart and also affirmed my passion for writing. Learning to write in a second language was difficult, but once I cleared the barriers, words flowed naturally. I feel everything deeply, and there is no other way I can see the world. Sometimes it's painful to be this way but when I can share my feeling with others through my writing it brings a whole new meaning to my creative pursuit.
Etsuko Yaunaga
Etsuko, your words have me in tears. Despite your loss and intense grief, you have found a way through this to enrich your life every day. I can only dream of escaping the grief that engulfs me daily, but your words give me some hope that with time I may be able to achieve this. Thank you.
Heather Sullivan
Oh Heather, grief is very personal process and everyone responds differently. I was lucky enough to have writing in my life when this tragedy took place, and found solace in expressing my feeling. Any creative pursuit helps to heal grieving hearts. I trust that you already have special creativity inside you, so explore your talent and share it with others who appreciate its beauty. Thanks for your honesty and taking time to read my writing. Much appreciated.
Etsuko Yaunaga
I have just read this because I didn't want to read it in a rush. This was too important to rush through and not be able to process as it should be. I have just read it.....3 times. And I say this my beautiful friend - I understand it so very much. My entire life's focus changed on January 1st 2019 with the diagnosis that destroyed my family and everything I knew. It is kind of like learning to walk again - except a little bit braver because they have been denied the chance to live the life that they should have had.....so we can't take it for granted. We must do the things that scare us and the things we didn't think we could.....quite simply because they no longer can. We have to find a new way to relate to people that we love so dearly and are a part of our hearts but now feel that little bit further away. We cannot let them know our grief or despair or how lost we feel because what they are going through is so much worse. We understand and we know but we find a way to process our pain so that they don't have to bear ours as well. My friend this writing is extraordinary. I just want you to know that I hear you, I see you and I understand and above all - I am always here xxxx
Mardi Jones
Dear friend Mardi, First of all thank you for having waited till an appropriate time to read my piece. I appreciate your thoughtfulness, care and respect for my writing. I always ask people to find quiet time and space to read my writing so that they can process. You did. Thank you also for using 'extraordinary' to describe my writing. It's one of my favourite words to receive from my readers.
There are two types of people in the world. Those who have experienced an acute, raw pain of grieving (like you and I), and those who haven't (yet). It's almost impossible to understand this kind of intense pain without going through the actual suffering. I always accept people's sympathy graciously regardless of their experience, but words like yours hit my heart deeply. I hear you, I understand you and I'm with you always. We are strong and resilient because of our grieving experience. Hope you find solace in my writing, and on Daniel's 9th anniversary (or sooner) you are happy as I am right now.
Etsuko Yaunaga
Dear Etsuko
Your gift of making me feel the deep love you have of your family and of life itself is beautiful to me.Keep writing, and living in the now is a very special achievement that I feel is very worthwhile to pursue.
Verena Hoefler
Thank you Verena for your kind words. Writing has helped me find solace. Furthermore by sharing my writing with others I receive strong affirmation to keep on writing. It's my pure joy and is the only way I can see and understand the world.
Etsuko Yaunaga
Beautiful words Etsuko, life takes many unplanned turns, some for the better, some in a different direction. Your words touch many hearts deeply. I love your not a secret!! Focus on what you love
Tony O'Connell
Thank you very much for your words of wisdom, Tony. The fact that they come from the man I respect deeply means a lot to me. I learned quite early that where the mind goes energy flows. Yes I will continue to focus on what I love and what brings joy in my life. I'm so grateful that our paths have crossed.
Etsuko Yaunaga
Why I love Cape
February 21, 2010
Thank you Pete for your article which pretty much sums up my love affair with Cape Paterson and my real concerns about the development plans currently under consideration.
Do we have to ruin all the coastline with over development?! Surely the addition of the Eco-Village on the west side of the township should be the end to development at Cape for a very long time!
Barbara Smith
Thanks Barbara
Yes, one would've hoped that the Ecovillage be the end of it but Matthew Guy's arbitrary expansion on the town boundary to suit the developers means we are constantly fighting this battle. Not until the boundaries are put back to Seaward Drive will this business end.
If this application succeeds, we'll see no end of pressure to build over the whole coast from san remo to Inverloch. It's time to draw a line!
Pete Muskens
My sentiments exactly. I often don’t go near the beach at the Cape as I am somewhat disabled. This does not worry me as I live among the trees on my property. I have upward of 20 gums, many of which are flowering gums of all colours. The local koala comes visiting and possums scurry across our roof. I regret not being able to participate in the regeneration projects run by CPRRA as the volunteers have done a magnificent job. It has also helped to invoke a sense of community that I wish I could be part of. Thanks for your articles that captures the essence of Cape Paterson.
Gael McLeod
Not being a resident of Cape Paterson , but a relatively new resident of Wonthaggi, I would respectfully suggest that all residents of the Cape, not to be silent, have your say or your peaceful township will become like so many other towns, villages, and hamlets, Nothing more than part of the suburban sprawl. My town (Drouin) was a beautiful little village, as a child it was a great place to be.Things changed and now it is almost a suburb of Warragul .mainly because of the apathy of the residents and that includes me. Open your eyes and look at Pakenham, Yarragon, Trafalgar,Poowong, Nyora.. Because that may be your future .
John Cobbledick
I love cape been here for a year and wouldn’t change it at all ! Needs to stay how it is ! For sure ! ❤️
Sam Kahu
Hi Pete. I have read through your article and the responses. I very much agree.
I am having a late attempt to draft a letter to BCSC re amendment C136.
I want to do this in a manner that isn’t just a whinging complaint. Do you have any point form information that could help with my draft?
David Hubble
Enough with the climate gloom
February 21, 2010
Congratulations to Cr Whelan for going plastic free which I will try to emulate.
Joan Woods
Congrats Michael and Geoff at NCES. Did anybody from BCSC admin attend?
Bernie McComb
Hi Bernie Yes BCSC Climate Change Adviser attended the Summit and the council workshop, and is doing a fine job
Michael Whelan
What a thoughtful article from Cr Whelan. So pleased he is being proactive not reactive on this most critical issue. Lets hope it is contagious.
Pete Granger
Thanks Michael for opting to steer the discussion in a more positive direction. Agree with Pete here, we all need it to catch on.
Miriam Strickland
It is great to read this article and I try my best to help along with reducing plastic usage. I do not always find it easy. Positive approach of our community leaders is helping to do our best.
Verena Hoefler
Cancer service to ease the pain
February 21, 2010
A great step forward for Bass Coast and regional Victoria. Congratulations to all involved!
Meryl Tobin
Thank you very much Jan Child and Bass Coast Health.
Jan Fleming
Being member of Probus at San Remo for last 12 years i've seen first hand how difficult it is for people to live in Bass Coast Area and the hours involved in travel for treatment. Our club many times had rosters of drivers to help those unable to travel that far on their own.
Any treatment available at Wonthaggi will be a great improvement for residents.
Having being diagnosed with Lymphoma Cancer In August i now see the issues from the patients perspective. Clearly there is a lot more that needs to be available for the regional areas of Victoria to fully assist you through the whole process. Last week alone i had a Pet Scan and MRI Brain Scan both at Knox Private then following Day a Lumber Puncture at Epworth Box Hill. This equipment is very expensive plus you need the staff to go with it. Plus you need the Cancer specialist Doctors to firstly decide on what your illness is, then the process you need to go through to try to provide you with a cure and then the management of this process. This is a long term process the treatment like chemo is important part but it needs to be linked with all of the above, it doesn't sit out on its own.
With the size of the population in Victoria today having most of these services only available in Metropolitan Melbourne is a major concern and one the Federal & State Govts need to be far more pro active in. Its no good saying the City's are getting too large and we need people to move to regional areas but without the medical services being provided this is never going to happen. Few months ago i was in Albury and the Hospital Services provided by NSW government for that population is amazing. That's what needs to occur in Victoria.
My situation is sadly we know longer can live in San Remo even though we wanted to and really have enjoyed being part of the community in our retirement years. I know great number of people in our community over the last 15 years who have had to make the same decision as we have.
Christopher Day
Salutations from the high ground
February 21, 2010
Thanks very much Geoff for all you do. Loved the comment by Julian Burnside.
Jan Fleming
Jobs that no longer exist
February 10, 2020
Christine's extremely well written account of her early life on Phillip Island provides a fantastic record of the rural life that is now only a distant memory to many and a revelation to most. In the current world of instant gratification it is a delight to read about the first hand experience of the early life on Phillip Island.
I hope that Christine can provide us with further recollections of this fascinating period when Phillip Island was a small farming and fishing community.
Ian Samuel
Loved this article. Reminded me of the simpler Philip Island of the late 60's and 70's when, as a young boy, we would visit family friends who also farmed and fished on the island. But nothing like Christine's experience!
Brett Rogers
Christine, I very much enjoyed your memoir. I have seen a the kilns when visiting PI since I was a child and wondered what the process was. I was also impressed what people did to 'earn a crust'. Very hard work too. Thanks for sharing your experiences.
Pee Bee
Christine i really enjoyed your well written essay on days gone by on PI. It reminded me of my youth during the school holidays, going to work with my Dad Eric, who was a self employed iceman whose customers were the big hotels in Melbourne CBD. The Federal Hotel, Australia Hotel, Menzies Hotel are just a few of those long gone impressive posh hotels which needed broken up ice for the
drinks served.
How marvellous for you to remember and describe in so much detail your former jobs.
I always look at the remaining Chichory kilns and wonder what went on inside all those years ago.
Kay Setches
You create lovely word pictures, Christine. I was somewhere else, living a very different kind of life -- yet I feel a poignant nostalgia for the world you've created here. Some envy, too. Congratulations.
John Gascoigne
My memories of other places and different tasks in my young years was brought to life by Christine's stories. Well written, interesting and I think the word evocative fits.
As an apprentice 'cadet' in the British Merchant Navy, our first day at sea after perhaps a week in port, was spent tossing dunnage over the side. Great heaps went overboard.
Dunnage was a cheap grade of wooden plank used to keep cargo ventilated and apart from the steelwork at the bottom of a ship's hold to avoid condensation damaging valuable cargo. Any moisture would collect in the bilges and be pumped overboard.
Any dunnage which was damaged and rendered not reusable by the discharge of cargo was stacked on deck and jettisoned once the ship had cleared harbour. The dunnage on PI beaches was presumably from ships out of Melbourne.
Containerisation presumably saw an end to the practice.
Peter Brown
Thank goodness for Uncle Keith! I found that fascinating. Hard work out in the environment certainly shaped you Christine. Could WPPC please reproduce this?
Karri Giles
Thank you Christine. What a wonderful story about Phillip Island, capturing the vivid personal experience and the historical connections of the work on the island. My Aunty and Uncle lived at Ventnor and I have many holiday memories — of swimming at Red Rocks and cycling over to Summerland on quiet roads in the 1960s, 70s.
Julie Constable
What a beautifully written memoir Christine. Such a joy to read. The rich detail is a precious record of how these 'extinct' jobs were done and those shared moments toasting crumpets and honey while singing songs late into the night at the chicory kiln are marvellous, capturing a way of working from another time.
Linda Cuttriss
A wonderful, well written story Christine. As a latecomer to Phillip Island, I was fascinated by your evocation of a bygone era. Congratulations on winning the award - well deserved!
Marian Quigley
Lovely story, Christine evoking an era and life we can only wonder about. Well done and congratulations on your win.
Sally Bird
Memoir of bygone jobs takes top writing prize
February 10, 2020
Congratulations to you all! An outstanding outcome! Well done Phyllis for your inspiration and encouragement!
Carmen Bush
Congratulations Christine! And to other pirze winners and commendations.
Miriam Strickland
Congratulations to all involved.
Nicky Miller
Well done Christine and others!
I would love to read Jobs that no longer exist and Pittosporum flowering how does one do that please?
Karri Giles
Hi Karri. The prize winning and commended entries will be published in the Post. First up is Christine's work, which has been published, and Pittosporum Flowering will be published in the next issue of the Post.
Catherine Watson
Thank you for hosting such an inspiring event and Congratulations to the Winner - Christine Grayden and all nominees. We are blessed to have so many amazingly talented people in Bass Coast
Clare Le Serve
Congratulations Christine and everyone involved.
Peter Dann
It’s complicated
February 10, 2020
Congratulations to Pauline and Miriam. Thanks for sharing and thanks for your honesty about the ups and down. BCP doesn't allow comment emoticons and I would choose a raised glass of Champagne. Cheers!
Geoff Ellis
10/2/2020 09:46:37 pm
Ditto to Geoff's comments!
Nicky Miller
‘Blue poles’ director hailed from Wonthaggi
February 10, 2020
I caught up with James Mollison few years back (when mayor) to discuss the Robert Smith collection.
He left Wonthaggi when he was five. His uncle was the person who ok’d artist Noel Counihan to go into the mines to draw the series of prints which are now part of the Bass coast shire collection. It was very rare for artists to even go into the mines back in the day - in fact probable it was the first time.
James employed me a lifetime ago at the NGV - would you believe.
Jordan Crugnale, MP for Bass
A force of nature
February 10, 2020
Great to see Eulie's effort recognised and recorded in such an engaging article. Well done Terri.
Geoff Ellis
Keep it #$%@!!*& nice
January 25, 2020
My repertoire of wise old sayings includes “give them an inch and they take a mile”, along with something about people in glass houses, and “if you have nothing nice to say it is best to say nothing”.
It would be appalling if your Post and all the energy that has gone into it was to be corrupted to ruin by a few bad apples.
Dear Catherine, stay the course !
Tim Shannon
Thankyou Catherine for your journalistic experience and I support your decision to erase the personal criticism.
I appreciate the literature and variety of topics you attract to The Post.
Marjorie Scott
Thank you for your perseverance and all the time you put into the Post. We always look forward to reading all the interesting articles and agree with your decision. Happy New Year Catherine.
Alison Ribush
Enjoyed every article as usual. Keep up the great work!
Michelle Graham
Not living "down there:" anymore, but keep up the good work Catherine,Love reading the (constructive) comments on things happening in Bass Coast
Kevin Chambers
Love the Bass Coast Post.
Thank you Catherine.
Jan Fleming
Gorgeous Catherine!
Without you people like me would not have a voice - we would be less informed - we would not be able to share in a safe environment.
Bullies can be awfully devious - and so destructive - so thank you for not allowing them to have a voice.
Liane Arno
Good decision - i fully support you and thanks for doing such a great job on the Post
Lesley Bretherton
Thank you Catherine for gifting us the Bass Coast Post. Respect is vital and support your decision to stop abuse. Just love reading the articles in the Post and whilst you may not always agree with some views, one often gains knowledge of the reasons for differing views in the written article. Thank you for all that you do.
Joy Button
I totally agree with Catherine and thank her for the outstanding development of a Post with principles
It is indeed unfortunate that journalism as an industry has deteriorated to sensationalism and distortion of the truth to the detriment of the profession.
Informed articles are the source of knowledge shared, with the Post leading in the dissemination of views and opinions without acrimony
Keep up the good work
Ian Samuel
I agree, civil discussion is desperately needed at a time when we seem to becoming more polarised. But abusive retorts achieve nothing but further separation. Keep up the good work Catherine, I so enjoy the Post.
Lorrie Read
Catherine, whilst your intentions are admirable, beware! I used to subscribe to a large national newspaper that permitted what I called "vigorous" debate (which were, to be honest, horrific during the SSM debate) then belatedly decided that they needed moderation. I had several comments (favourable mostly) "rejected" and there was to be no discussing the reasons why. Other readers of the newspaper made similar observations. Eventually it appeared that the rejections were more personal than ethical, so I decided to pull the plug. There will be no political correctness in my house! It is yet another form of censorship.
Everyone views a topic differently, so I believe it would be quite difficult to be impartial and eventually what one considers offensive, others would not.
Pamela Jacka
Hi Pamela. I certainly don’t want to censor readers’ views. The more the merrier! However, the Post has picked up a few trolls along the way and I need to deal with them. The personal criticism and abuse are a diversion from genuine debate. They also deter others from entering the discussion. Let’s see how we go!
Catherine Watson, editor
I'm with you on this one Pamela, You cannot write about topics in Bass Coast Post in a joking, entertaining manner at the expense of people who are working so hard to save their own environment and are struggling with potential unbearable loss (Newhaven Skate Park article) and expect people who are so distraught and emotionally devastated about that topic that is being joked about and not expect a reaction that is pure raw emotion and spelling out nothing but raw facts. The truth hurts unfortunately and the truth should not be deleted or edited. If that raw emotion is taken out then its just not genuine or real and the writing lacks soul of the person who is hurting and who put their real feelings into words.
Min Beaumont
I have so enjoyed reading bass coast post articles for many years, I would be disappointed if a few trolls ruined it for all.
Catherine, she's your baby & I fully support your editorial rights 💞
Kim Veness
This kind of has to work both ways and what has happened to freedom of speech as a reaction to a writers actions, that's what you are after isn't it, a reaction?
Min Beaumont
I totally agree with your right to edit the Post Catherine as you see fit.
That’s your job.
I also totally agree in using reasoned arguments which are based on facts.
Emotional language does not fix the issues.
Frank W Schooneveldt
There are comments on this post that certainly break the rules under which I operate several organisations' popular Facebook pages. Our rules are: No personal attacking of others or name calling in the post or in the comments. No comments which do not pertain to the principles of whichever group's FB page it is, as clearly set out on their websites, e.g. constitutions and forward planning documents agreed to by the members. No swearing - even mild swearing - under any circumstances. There is so much vitriol on the internet these days and it is totally unhelpful. All it does is make people angrier, and in fact curtails rational debate. Catherine your readers may have 'ownership' of your wonderful website, but it is actually YOUR website, and you are perfectly entitled to make your rules, especially after several years of operation have taught you the hard way that some people seriously need to be given clear firm rules to abide by. It is a waste of your valuable time having to moderate everything, but stay firm and eventually everyone will get the message and all behave in a civilised manner.
Christine Grayden
Forged by fire
January 25, 2020
Thank you Laura for your personal experience of the recent fires- such tragic and dramatic disasters continue to ripple long beyond the proverbial splash; the upheaval is unimaginable but then it happens. I hope this unparalleled summer of fire shifts the nation's focus and clarifies priorities. So pleased you and yours are safe.
Jeannie Haughton
Thank you Laura for sharing your story. And thank goodness you are all safe.
Your story certainly brings home what is important.
Caring for Country, caring for people, caring for community, caring for one and another and caring about the World we leave to our Grandchildren.
Frank & Mary Schooneveldt
Laura and Terry, we are very glad your family is safe. Best wishes,
Jan Fleming and John Adam
Thanks so much for sharing, Laura. When I saw and heard you at 'Heads in the Sand' I didn't get to talk to you. I had no idea about your family. I had no idea that the climate refugees I saw from Mallacoota were your grandchildren.
I'm glad that the family is safe. They will be scarred by their experience, but on the day I noted that they seemed such brave people, and from what you say, that is true. They may also become stronger people.
Much was learnt during the Black Saturday fires about safe behaviour at times of fires. If only the media and government could learn all the lessons about climate change that the world should have been acting on many years ago. I hope that the majority of people have learnt enough to insist that we change how we act. If not now, when? If not now, who will be left to decide? If not now, will anyone have any choice?
Bron Dahlstrom
Thanks for this piece Laura. So glad your family survived, and also that the house was saved. I believe Bob and I stayed in their airbnb last year, such a nice spot. We had no idea of their connection to you.
Jenny Skewes
Thank you so much for your kind words and for your understanding. They are truly appreciated.
Terry has just finished making a short film about the Climate Action held at Inverloch that I mention in the article.
Here is the link ... https://vimeo.com/387580606
I'm really grateful to be part of a community that is awake to the importance of climate justice and the need for action.
Laura Brearley
So moving to read your personal account especially after your Black Saturday experiences. Thank you. I am so pleased they can return home already even tho it is so shocking and the smoke and ash seems to stay for a long time.
It's a long haul cleaning up and rebuilding and a community that can put forward what it wants from agerncies and govt often fairs better in the long term reconstruction.
You and Terry are truly fantastic and such a wonderful support. These events call on all our resources and more.
I love the grandchildren taking action with their posters, a positive sign amongst the aftermath.
(Re climate refugees - I'm caring for three of the family 's non laying old chooks ! )
Neri Melsmith
Thank you for your story. My Niece's Fiance Nikolai Handsjuk's Mother's house burnt down at Mallacoota and his Grandmother's was about the only one left in the street.
Caroline Giles
Weighty words
January 25, 2020
Thank you all three for your wonderful work. There certainly seems to be much talent in Gippsland. I very much look forward to reading the winning entry.
Felicia Di Stefano
Sounds like there were many fabulous entries and a challenge Catherine just to establish a short list. Looking forward to the announcement on February 9. Will this announcement be open to the public as I cannot see time that it starts.
Joy Button
Fabulous! can't wait to find out who is the winner.
Clare Le Serve
Looks great Catherine; and I wonder, might it be worth publishing the best 10 or 15 as a book?
Max Richter
A blazing star
Jan 25, 2020
Far too young to leave us - I still try not to think about this but it was a life well lived and my friend for so much of his time in the Wonthaggi area. Ricardo entered some photographs in the Show that I help organise just before he passed. Thank you Merle for encouraging him. Well anyway he did very well and was so happy with his prizes That was the last I heard about him when Merle contacted me that fateful night.To me his joy of achieving something that I was part of made me smile as well as make me cry - Loved you Ricardo - A joy to know and call a friend
Rosemary Loughnan
Ricardo, Ricardo, Ricardo !!
My elderly mother used to say when she visited Garnham House in Wonthaggi once a week.
Then some years later, she was stunned when she and a few of the residents of Griffiths Point Lodge (in San Remo) were driven to his exhibition.
What a wonderful artist, photographer, writer and very special person who gave warmth to so many people who had the privilege of meeting you and being with you.
Vale, Ricardo, may you rest in peace
Phyllis Papps
Thrills and spills
Jan 25, 2020 –
This story deserves support and reflection.
Near death experiences - all survived - mostly cherished - by those who were lucky enough to have a childhood before helicopter parenting.
We learned a confidence and love of the wild parts of our world.
Peter Brown
I enjoyed this story and did similar stuff in the 70s and 80s
Caroline Giles
Oh my goodness Liz, what you write about climbing a tree is in exact detail of what the children of Newhaven at Phillip Island did in the Grayden's Memorial Park in the 70's. The cypress trees which still stand there today as part of Newhaven's unique history and green environment and were planted in a similar fashion as the ones down Thompson Avenue in Cowes are still the main characteristics of our much loved park and township. The cypress in the park was a haven for play when children were free to roam. We too could climb up the trunk by firstly pulling ourselves up via forked branches like monkey bars. I look at the tree now and wonder how we managed to pull ourselves up
Min BeaumontBeaches closed for EasterFast forward to 2022Councillors can marina plan