- Published on
The front runners: Renee Heath (Liberal), Melina Bath (National), Enver Erdogan (Labor), Clay Esler (One Nation) and Mat Morgan (Greens)
By Catherine Watson
FIVE members will be elected to represent Eastern Victoria in Victoria's Legislative Council, or Upper House. With a changed voting system and a different mix of candidates, this election presents a very different contest from 2022.
The result will be closely watched, not least because the balance of power in the Upper House could be at stake.
The September Roy Morgan poll put Labor on 21 per cent of the vote in Eastern Victoria, the Liberal-Nationals on 35 per cent, One Nation on 21.5 per cent and the Greens on 15 per cent. The Greens' Mat Morgan, currently a Bass Coast councillor, is hoping to take his place in Parliament at just 29.
The Post invited the lead candidates for Eastern Victoria to introduce themselves and outline their priorities for the region.
It’s a very different scenario from 2022, when Eastern Victoria returned two Labor members (Tom McIntosh and Harriet Shing), one Liberal (Renee Heath), one National (Melina Bath) and one Shooters, Fishers & Farmers member (Jeff Bourman).
While Renee Heath and Melina Bath look safe, the other three members are going or gone.
Going: Tom McIntosh (Labor), Harriet Shing (Labor) and Jeff Bourman (Shooters, Fishers and Farmers)
Shing announced her retirement from politics after Jacinta Allan was dumped as Premier. McIntosh has been moved to the Northern Metropolitan Region, where he is standing in the unwinnable second position on Labor's ticket.
Labor Minister Enver Erdogan has been given the top spot in Eastern Victoria.
On current polling, Labor’s second candidate, former Bass Coast councillor Leticia Quintana (formerly Leticia Laing) is unlikely to be elected.
The end of preference whispering
One of the biggest changes this election is the abolition of group voting tickets in the Upper House.
In 2022, Jeff Bourman was elected as the fifth member for Eastern Victoria with 13,860 first-preference votes, just 2.93 per cent of the vote. Under the old system, voters could simply mark a 1 above the line and their preferences would be distributed according to group voting tickets lodged by parties and candidates. These backroom preference arrangements became known as preference whispering.
That system was replaced in July, to bring it into line with other states. Voters must now number at least five boxes, either above the line for parties and groups or below the line for individual candidates. Their preferences will be distributed according to the numbers they have actually marked, rather than party-negotiated deals.
The change makes it harder for candidates such as Jeff Bourman, with a small primary vote, to be elected through preference arrangements.
The other big change is the rise of One Nation. In 2022, One Nation's Jeff Waddell attracted just 344 votes, or 0.07 per cent. This time the party has nominated Clay Esler, a former RAAF pilot and Gippsland businessman, as its lead candidate and it’s difficult to see him missing out.
There is also a big drop in the number of candidates, perhaps because of the changed electoral system. In 2022, 56 candidates representing 23 parties contested Eastern Victoria.
Coming at the end of Victoria's lockdowns, the ballot included a number of parties campaigning on anger and disaffection: the Freedom Party of Victoria, Angry Victorians Party, Sack Dan Andrews Restore Democracy and Derryn Hinch's Justice Party.
This time there are just 32 candidates from 11 parties and two independents.
Some parties have disappeared, including Health Australia, New Democrats, Fiona Patten's Reason Party, Companions and Pets Party and Transport Matters. Family First is not contesting the Upper House in Eastern Victoria.
Others are back, including Legalise Cannabis Victoria, Labour DLP, the Animal Justice Party and Victorian Socialists.
Sustainable Australia Party – Stop Overdevelopment / Corruption has returned under the name Affordable Housing Now – Sustainable Australia Party. The two independents are Antoinette Pitt, from Montrose, and Kate Coxall, from Warragul.