Bass Coast Post
  • Home
    • Recent editions
  • News
  • Point of view
    • View from the chamber
  • Contributors
    • Anabelle Bremner
    • Anne Davie
    • Anne Heath Mennell
    • Bob Middleton
    • Bruce Phillips
    • Carolyn Landon
    • Catherine Watson
    • Christine Grayden
    • Daryl Pellizzer
    • Dick Wettenhall
    • Dyonn Dimmock
    • Ed Thexton
    • Etsuko Yasunaga
    • Frank Coldebella
    • Gayle Marien
    • Geoff Ellis
    • Gill Heal
    • Harry Freeman
    • Ian Burns
    • Joan Woods
    • John Coldebella
    • Julie Paterson
    • Julie Statkus
    • Kit Sleeman
    • Laura Brearley >
      • Coastal Connections
    • Lauren Burns
    • Liane Arno
    • Linda Cuttriss
    • Linda Gordon
    • Lisa Schonberg
    • Liz Low
    • Marian Quigley
    • Mark Robertson
    • Mary Aldred
    • Mary Whelan
    • Matt Stone
    • Meryl Brown Tobin
    • Michael Whelan
    • Mikhaela Barlow
    • Miriam Strickland
    • Natasha Williams-Novak
    • Neil Daly
    • Oliver Jobe
    • Patsy Hunt
    • Pauline Wilkinson
    • Richard Kemp
    • Rob Parsons
    • Sally McNiece
    • Terri Allen
    • Tim Shannon
  • Features
    • Features 2025
    • Features 2024
    • Features 2023
    • Features 2022
    • Features 2021
    • Features 2020
    • Features 2019
    • Features 2018
    • Features 2017
    • Features 2016
    • Features 2015
    • Features 2014
    • Features 2013
    • Features 2012
  • Arts
    • Arts
  • Local history
    • Local history
  • Environment
    • Environment
  • Nature notes
    • Nature notes
  • A cook's journal
  • Community
    • Diary
    • Courses
    • Groups
    • Stories
  • About the Post

Send her packing, again!

31/3/2026

23 Comments

 
PictureFormer independent MP Susan Davies
By Susan Davies
 
IN 1998 I was a rookie Victorian MP, elected as an Independent in a 1997 rural byelection protest vote. The then rampant Kennett government was trampling over rural communities and people were very cranky (as they are again now).
 
Pauline Hanson was crowing at the eight One Nation MPs who'd been elected in Queensland (before they started to abandon her party). Convinced she could make a dent at the coming federal election, she was planning to tour conservative rural Gippsland and beyond to make her mark in Victoria, as she is again now.
 
In those days Jeff Kennett had a spine and rejected her divisive, anti-migrant message (unlike now). I went beyond my own Gippsland West patch into central Gippsland with a message on WIN TV. "There is no kindness, care or community in Pauline Hanson's politics,” I said. “This is not us, this is not our communities, not rural Victoria. Send her packing.”

And Gippsland and the rest of rural Victoria largely did send her packing. Attendances in Gippsland were pretty poor and heckling was frequent. She never came back.
 
That message still stands all these years later. There is no kindness, care or community in Pauline Hanson's politics! 
PictureSenator Pauline Hanson: different target,
same sentinments
In those days she was mostly picking on Asian migrants, the very people from all parts of Asia and South East Asia who now form such a vital, active part of every Australian community. These days she mostly picks on Muslims. Same rubbish message.
 
We are so lucky as a country that people still want to come here. Yes, we all agree the numbers needed to be reduced from their post-covid highs, as they are being reduced. But developed countries who've traditionally rejected migration are now in serious trouble, with aging populations, and not enough young people to care for the old. We're lucky. People are still coming to fill the roles we need to be filled; to pay the taxes we need for services.
 
Rural people in this country look after each other. They volunteer in their communities. They work together. They are kind. They care about community. They build community. Good people, often doing it tough, but caring for each other. That's a good way to live! It's not Hanson's way. 
 
I urge those in rural Victoria particularly, but all over our state, not to be led by her fake outrage, her divisive messages, her fake orange hair, all so like Trump's divisive messages and similarly fake orange skin tones.

​If you want to change your vote, look for a good, sensible, caring member of your community who'll stand as an Independent and speak up for your region. Or get in there, join one of the existing parties and work to make them develop some decent policies and processes!  They're all desperately need new blood. Make them be better at governing, or at being an Opposition, because we need both.

​Being cranky without doing something constructive is useless. Voting for Hanson's mob is useless. She can whinge, but she doesn't do much else … apart from take freebies from Gina Rinehart, the richest woman in Australia who's been sued by her own offspring for allegedly ripping them off.


"Being cranky without doing something constructive is useless. Voting for Hanson's mob is useless."
Apart from slandering migrants, the main other Hanson policy I've heard is her rejection of the current state and federal governments' net zero emissions policies. Rinehart’s profits grow with that denial. No matter the increasing number and severity of extreme cyclones, floods, fires and droughts which climate change is bringing down on our heads. And no matter the additional economic security we gain from increasing our reliance on clean renewable energy which we can generate within our own borders.
 
We can do better than Hanson. Think carefully, please, before you risk straying from our traditions of kindness, care and community.
 
My hair is its natural silver now, and much of my effort goes into being a useful nanna. But I still care about our communities and about our people. Look after yourselves and each other. We are stronger working together for the common good. That's us. That's not Hanson.
 
Susan Davies was the Independent MP for Gippsland West from 1997 to 2002. ​
23 Comments
Rob Parsons
1/4/2026 07:56:00 pm

It was Catherine Watson herself who once said to me: “Attack the issue, not the person.” It’s a principle worth holding onto — especially in times like these.
The recent contribution by Susan Davies departs from that standard. Readers were treated not just to criticism of Pauline Hanson’s policies, but to personal remarks about appearance and character, and sweeping dismissals of those who might consider voting for her.
We can, and should, debate policies. On migration. On energy. On climate. On the direction of the country. But when debate slips into ridicule or contempt, it risks doing something more damaging: It dismisses not just a political figure, but the Australians who support them. And those Australians are not a fringe. They are our neighbours, workmates, and community members. Many are not driven by division, but by frustration — about cost of living, about trust in institutions, about whether their voices are being heard.
Telling people their vote is “useless” is unlikely to persuade them otherwise. If anything, it deepens the divide. If we want to counter movements like One Nation, the answer is not personal attack. It is better arguments, better policy, and better engagement. And perhaps most importantly — respect. Respect for differing views. Respect for the people who hold them. Respect for the idea that in a democracy, disagreement is not something to be shut down, but worked through.
We can do better than this.

Reply
Catherine Watson, editor
2/4/2026 02:34:00 pm

A fair point, Rob. I should have edited out the comment on the red hair.

Reply
Linda
3/4/2026 09:11:27 pm

I agree Rob, this article should not have been even posted. Unfair attack, Pauline is not racist, does not have hatred for anyone, everything that is said is straight from one sided politics. We need discussion and not division. Australians are turning to One Nation because they are sick of all the promises of other parties that have not delivered those promises and One Nation supporters are growing fast. This attack will not stop the support she receives, but will stop the support of Susan Davies. How disrespectful of anyone who attacks their competition.

Reply
Jeni
4/4/2026 10:48:40 am

Hello Linda, I thought you were being satirical when stating that Pauline Hanson is not racist. Now I am wondering if you are one of the thousands of Bots on the internet purchased with Gina Rineharts money to dupe voters. I can say that I would not vote for a political party that seeks votes by saying they support battlers. When there voting record consistently votes against issues that would support the regular Australian.

Joan
4/4/2026 08:46:44 am

While In general, that is great advice, it is not always applicable. Do you really think arguments would have stopped Hitler, or today, stop Donald Trump? I doubt it.

Reply
Jeni
4/4/2026 10:57:15 am

In a political environment where minorities are scapegoated and voters are out right lied to. It is 'useless' to hold the moral high ground. Susan is spot on, voting for One Nation in the hopes that they will represent regular Australians is useless. Of no benefit and a waste of the voters time and money.

Reply
Linda
4/4/2026 12:20:36 pm

And all parties waste time and money, so which party do you think will help regular Australians, I do not see any of them going by history?

Linda
4/4/2026 12:19:14 pm

Jeni: Pauline is not racist, but has always been portrayed as racists by her competition and media. She believes in equal rights for all and every Australian treated the same, not singled out for extra attention. And which policies are you talking about that don't support Australians? All parties have let the ordinary Australian down, who are we suppposed to vote for?
Joan: What has my comment got to do with Hitler or Trump?

Reply
Joan
5/4/2026 08:20:28 am

Rational arguments, do not stop irrational people.

Nicky Miller
1/4/2026 08:32:36 pm

Great article, Susan. Lessons from history are more important than ever in the world today!

Reply
Linda
3/4/2026 09:16:31 pm

History is not always portrayed correctly and history can change and people change. Going over old ground does not solve any issues Australians are facing. Totally disrespectful article by Susan.

Reply
Joy Button
3/4/2026 05:44:37 am

A fabulous article Susan and totally agree with Nicky's comments.
It is true that Hanson has red hair and not quite sure that I understand the criticism about the reference to the hair color. It is important that lessons are learned from history especially taking into account what is happening in our world at present.

Reply
Aleta Groves
3/4/2026 05:49:21 pm

Articles like this don’t help the conversation. Instead of addressing why people feel frustrated or unheard, it resorts to personal attacks and broad generalisations.

You can disagree with someone’s politics, but suggesting their supporters lack care or community spirit is both inaccurate and unhelpful.

This is not a historical reflection—it’s the rant of someone out of touch who never left a significant mark on her political career.

Reply
Sarah
3/4/2026 07:56:37 pm

I understand your frustration, but I just want to point out that you mention you have an issue with the personal attacks in this piece and then state, "someone out of touch who never left a significant mark on her political career", seems like you might need to take your own advice.

Reply
Linda
3/4/2026 09:14:43 pm

I agree Aleta, attacking her supporters, instead of understanding why One Nation has Australians flocking to the party out of frustration, is totally disrepectful. Susan Davies will lose more supporters and not gain from this attack.

Reply
Jeni
4/4/2026 11:21:55 am

I do not agree that Susan is attacking One Nation's supporters. She is pointing out that there was little support for their racist style of politics back in the day and that the party has little value to voters here in Bass Coast. Your gaslighting is disappointing as is One Nation.

Linda
4/4/2026 12:25:01 pm

Jeni: I am not a gaslighter, use of that word is out of context. I am simply voicing my opinion. And which party do you think will help us in Bass Coast?, there has been no improvement in my life for years, only more struggle and hardship.

Maddy
5/4/2026 08:14:22 pm

Well done Susan.
Notwithstanding personal slights, you have managed to start a much needed community discussion about One Nation. The dramatic
shift in support for ON warrants a focus on its
policies, which
need to be interrogated to reveal her bias against 'the other' and her simplistic solutions to what are wicked problems.

Reply
Denis
6/4/2026 02:47:58 pm

she is a racist. don't pretend to be like trump ;over - dumb and deny the facts

Reply
Frank W Schooneveldt
8/4/2026 07:30:32 am

In this article and all the comments nobody is offering solutions.
I read in the AGE the other day that 20% of the British people are living in poverty.
We don’t want Australia to go this way.
Pauline Hanson has been given a voice because our society as moved to favouring the upper middle classes and not the lower middle classes.
It’s time to have a redistribution of wealth.
People earning $100k to 250k are paying far too much in tax. While the rich can structure their affairs in such a way as to not pay much tax.
This has to change.
I believe in introducing a Universal Basic Income for everyone over the age of 18 so nobody is living in poverty.
This could be funded my taxing assets rather than income.
Australia is one of the richest countries in the world so we can afford a fairer enlightened society for all.



Reply
Linda
8/4/2026 12:53:45 pm

No universal income would not solve anything in regards to poverty. It gives those who don't need it extra money for nothing. Australia's problem is far deeper than tax, we sell our resources off to overseas investors at bargain prices for a start. The solution in my opinion is to stop sending money to unelected bodies like WEF, WHO and UN for starters.

Reply
Frank W Schooneveldt
9/4/2026 06:05:31 pm

In Australia we have a number of social security benefits, like the pension, NDIS, unemployment benefits to name a few.
We are very close to already having a Universal Basic Income.
I see the introduction of negative tax rates. This means that any person below a certain income level gets a tax refund to bring them up to a minimum level of income. In order to fund this type of scheme we need to tax assets more. We need a redistribution of wealth. This will fix the poverty problems we have in Australia.

Reply
Linda
9/4/2026 06:28:36 pm

Thank makes more sense thank you.

Reply



Leave a Reply.