Bass Coast Post
  • Home
    • Recent articles
  • News
    • Point of view
    • View from the chamber
  • Writers
    • Anne Davie
    • Anne Heath Mennell
    • Bob Middleton
    • Carolyn Landon
    • Catherine Watson
    • Christine Grayden
    • Dick Wettenhall
    • Ed Thexton
    • Etsuko Yasunaga
    • Frank Coldebella
    • Gayle Marien
    • Geoff Ellis
    • Gill Heal
    • Harry Freeman
    • Ian Burns
    • Joan Woods
    • John Coldebella
    • Jordan Crugnale
    • Julie Statkus
    • Kit Sleeman
    • Laura Brearley >
      • Coastal Connections
    • Lauren Burns
    • Liane Arno
    • Linda Cuttriss
    • Linda Gordon
    • Lisa Schonberg
    • Liz Low
    • Marian Quigley
    • Mark Robertson
    • Mary Whelan
    • Meryl Brown Tobin
    • Michael Whelan
    • Mikhaela Barlow
    • Miriam Strickland
    • Natasha Williams-Novak
    • Neil Daly
    • Patsy Hunt
    • Pauline Wilkinson
    • Phil Wright
    • Sally McNiece
    • Terri Allen
    • Tim Shannon
    • Zoe Geyer
  • Features
    • Features 2022
  • Arts
  • Local history
  • Environment
  • Bass Coast Prize
  • Community
    • Diary
    • Courses
    • Groups
  • Contact us

Any which way

9/3/2022

8 Comments

 
PictureHow Wonthaggi people get around
By John Coldebella
 
A QUESTION from my former high school woodwork teacher Bill Robertson caught me off guard, and his smile and the twinkle in his eyes suggested a 'gotcha' moment.  The question was this: how do you tell someone is a Wonthaggi local? I had always considered Bill to be a prominent local identity and knew that he was not born here so I was able to eliminate notions of birth in the local hospital or multiple generations buried in our cemetery.

I suggested a manner of speech used by locals of which I was not conscious till it was pointed out to me.  This involves situations where you know someone's surname but are unfamiliar with or have forgotten their first name.  They will be referred to as the bloke, lady, boy or girl 'of' Smith, Brown, Jones, etc.  I don't know if it's true but I've heard that this happens only in Wonthaggi.  I am speculating when I suggest that this adaption may have come about after an Italian immigrant attempted a direct translation from his or her mother tongue.  This is a common European speech pattern as seen in the German 'Von', the Dutch 'Van', the French 'Du', and the Italian 'De', 'Di' and 'Della' as part of family names which means of or from.
 
My answer wasn't what Bill had in mind but I was somewhere in the right paddock.  It had to do with a pattern of speech that 'locals' employ in relation to how they move about to places outside our town.  Although I also use this mode of speaking, again, I wasn't conscious of it till Bill pointed it out.  He named a series of towns in the district and region and asked me to express how I would tell someone I was going there or had been there.  As I gave my answers, Bill nodded with approval and his smile broadened.
 
What he had been getting at was that there are basically five ways of getting to places outside Wonthaggi: up, down, out, over and around to.  We go 'up to' anywhere north of the Princes Highway or Melbourne; up to Bendigo, Mildura, Walhalla, NSW, etc.  This is not exclusively a Wonthaggi trait.  If one is holding a map vertically, then it's a logical approach to take. But many newcomers to the town are surprised to learn that we go down to Melbourne.  More locally, we go 'up' to Blackwood Forest, Glen Alvie, Krowera, and Mirboo North.
 
We go 'out' to West Creek, Lance Creek, Archies Creek, Ryanston, South Dudley, Hicksborough, Cape Paterson, Harmers Haven, Cutlers Beach, Baxters Beach and Williamsons Beach, Kongwak, Dalyston and Kilcunda- unless you're one of the post-war Italian immigrants who go 'down' to Kilcunda.  From there, on the Bass Highway it's all 'down' to Anderson, Bass, Corinella, Grantville Lang Lang, and all the way to Melbourne as previously mentioned.  Down is also how we get to Inverloch (unless you go via Cape Paterson in which case you go around to), Tarwin Lower, Fish Creek, Walkerville, Sandy Point and Wilsons Promontory.
 
‘Over to’ is how we arrive at San Remo, Phillip Island, Churchill Island, Loch, Korumburra, Leongatha and all the towns on the Princes Highway between Drouin and Traralgon, along with Thorpedale, and Foster, though some go down to Foster.  Giving someone directions to Sale from Wonthaggi will involve most of the above manoeuvring.  You go out on the Inverloch road down to Inverloch, over to Leongatha, up through Mirboo North and over to Morwell and then up the Princes Highway to Sale.  An alternative route is down to Inverloch, over to Koonwarra, down to Foster, Toora, Welshpool and Yarram, and up to Sale.
 
There are other nuances which take the form of abbreviations that are common to all towns and communities.  Wonthaggi people don't go to Cape Paterson, San Remo, Phillip Island, Harmers Haven, Wilsons Promontory, the Kilcunda pub or Caledonian hotel.  They go out to Cape, over to Sanny, over to the island, out to Harmers, down to the prom, out to the Killy pub and down to the Cally.  When going to the shops, they go down the street.  If you live on the south side of town, you go over (the railway tracks?) to North Wonthaggi.
 
At their most extreme, notions of who is a local and who is not can be a form of snobbery or even a class system that works outside the traditional socio-economic definition of the term.  Bill Robertson had no such intention or motive when he posed his question to me.  That's not who he was.  He was merely sharing an anthropological observation.  I must admit that I have two categories of locals.  There are those who have been around for as long as I can remember, those people who remember the town as it was in my earliest memories and remember events and characters from those days.  Then there are those who have arrived since then and have embraced the spirit of the place and have blended in as though they had always been here, contributing in various ways that enrich our community and help make it stronger.
 
One character in the Bass Coast Shire with a healthy sense of humour whom I only met this morning, and with whom I raised the subject of this article, had this to say of the kind of closed shop communities that would never accept him as a local regardless of how long he lived in the place where he resides or the social contribution he makes there.  His answer to people with such an attitude is "I don't want to be a local.  I don't want to marry my cousin. As much as I like her, I'm not attracted to her".  He had made the astute observation that such communities exist with an identity in a state of stagnation based on the past that doesn't allow for healthy forms of progress, renewal and evolution.
8 Comments
Shaz Green
9/3/2022 01:02:08 pm

Mind blown! So true and had never realised that - even though I have a post-grad linguistics qualification. GREAT piece.

Reply
John Coldebella
12/3/2022 01:19:00 pm

Hi Shaz. As a student of linguistics, you may also be interested in something I forgot to say in my article. When a family member, neighbour or friend asks whether you need anything down the street, they are offering to do some shopping for you.

Reply
Liz
11/3/2022 01:20:04 pm

I've noticed that born and bred 'Wonthaggians' pronounce Wonthaggi as W'nthaggi; ie, emphasis on the 'thaggi". It's been a useful observation.

Reply
Catherine Watson
11/3/2022 01:56:51 pm

My neighbour Jim, born in Wonthaggi in 1922 , always called it WUN-thaggi. Which actually makes sense when you think we pronounce "won" as "wun".
Though a recent immigrant to Wonthaggi (1996) I've often heard myself saying I've been down to Melbourne and could never work out why. Now I know I caught it off the locals.

Reply
Mark Robertson
11/3/2022 01:36:32 pm

Good one John, dad was always aware of not being "quite" a local, he only arrived in 1958! Any way I am off down the street, as we wonthaggians say.

Reply
Anne Heath Mennell
11/3/2022 03:18:14 pm

Brilliant, John! As a newcomer (2001) to Bass Coast I've always been bemused by talk of going 'down' to Melbourne. I come from a railway family in Yorkshire, in the north of England. The line going to the capital, London, was always the 'up' line so we went up to London, even though we were heading south/down on a map. I know Melbourne is only a State capital, but it is also north/up when you look at a map. I must confess, I hadn't picked up on the other directional terms but you are spot on.

Reply
Merle Elson
11/3/2022 03:56:32 pm

Fascinating observations John. I must admit I haven't really noticed yet - I only moved to Wonthaggi a few months ago. However I grew up in Kooweerup (when it was country) and I remember several similarities.
For example, we always went Down to town - Melbourne - and usually referred to family names even of married women with changed surnames. Kids were always Bill Smith's boy or Harry Jones' girl, Could have been the Italian influence there too.

Reply
John Coldebella
12/3/2022 01:32:20 pm

Welcome to Wonthaggi, Merle. Thanks for reminding me that we also go to town or down town - Melbourne. An enquiry about someone you haven't seen for a while might be answered with; 'They've moved down town or gone to live down town'.
If you move in 'knockabout' circles, Bill Smith's boy will be Bill Smith's young bloke.

Reply



Leave a Reply.