Bass Coast Post
  • Home
    • Recent articles
  • News
    • Point of view
    • View from the chamber
  • Writers
    • Anne Davie
    • Anne Heath Mennell
    • Bob Middleton
    • Carolyn Landon
    • Catherine Watson
    • Christine Grayden
    • Dick Wettenhall
    • Ed Thexton
    • Etsuko Yasunaga
    • Frank Coldebella
    • Gayle Marien
    • Geoff Ellis
    • Gill Heal
    • Harry Freeman
    • Ian Burns
    • Joan Woods
    • John Coldebella
    • Julie Paterson
    • Julie Statkus
    • Kit Sleeman
    • Laura Brearley >
      • Coastal Connections
    • Lauren Burns
    • Liane Arno
    • Linda Cuttriss
    • Linda Gordon
    • Lisa Schonberg
    • Liz Low
    • Marian Quigley
    • Mark Robertson
    • Mary Whelan
    • Meryl Brown Tobin
    • Michael Whelan
    • Mikhaela Barlow
    • Miriam Strickland
    • Natasha Williams-Novak
    • Neil Daly
    • Patsy Hunt
    • Pauline Wilkinson
    • Richard Kemp
    • Sally McNiece
    • Terri Allen
    • Tim Shannon
  • Features
    • Features 2024
    • Features 2023
    • Features 2022
    • Features 2021
    • Features 2020
    • Features 2019
    • Features 2018
    • Features 2017
    • Features 2016
    • Features 2015
    • Features 2014
    • Features 2013
    • Features 2012
  • Arts
  • Local history
  • Environment
  • Nature notes
    • Nature notes
  • A cook's journal
  • Community
    • Diary
    • Courses
    • Groups
    • Stories
  • Contact us

It’s time we set the agenda

27/1/2022

9 Comments

 
PictureHartley Tobin and ‘Old Man Grass Tree’, one of the ancient giants of the Grantville grass tree forest. Photo: Meryl Brown Tobin
By Neil Daly

I WOULD like to thank two remarkable environmentalists, Meryl and Hartley Tobin, for giving me permission to use the photo of the “Old Man Grass Tree”, and for their tireless work in helping to preserve our natural environment.  
 
In our discussion, Meryl said “The Old Man Grass Tree has probably stood here since long before George Bass landed nearby at the mouth of the Bass River in 1798 and has seen our wildlife come and go for maybe 300-400 years or even longer.”  
 
The longevity of this amazing plant reminded me that Western Port and its region is an ancient and precious ecosystem dating back to long before George Bass started us on the road to European civilisation.

Since then and in recent times, particularly on its coastal fringes, Western Port has been under constant threat from “civilisation” and its unquenchable need for sustenance and expansion.  The attempt to turn this region into Victoria’s “Ruhr Valley”, to open a second container port for Melbourne at Hastings, and to install a gas import terminal at Crib Point are but three examples of a never-ending push to industrialise this fragile environment.
Each time the threat has appeared, local community action groups, often supported by some who holiday in the region, have fought off the industrialists and forced the government of the day to reassess its position.

But no sooner has one battle been won than another breaks out.

We now have the Save Western Port Woodlands group valiantly defending the “right of nature to survive”, for it would seem Melbourne’s appetite for infrastructure development and expansion to meet its growing population must be fed by sands from the Grantville region.  

There are currently 26 sand mining work authorities in the forest corridor between Nyora and Grantville – 19 current and seven under application.

If the planned expansion of sand mining is sanctioned by the State Government, it has the potential to destroy much of the Western Port woodlands, thus calling into question the role of the Marine and Coastal Act 2018 and the environmental credentials of the Andrew’s Government to protect this environment from further desecration.

In an attempt to redress the situation kindled by George Bass, I’m saying the time has come for the Western Port region to be freed from the constant pressure of having to repel corporate raiders and for governments (federal and state) to realise the social wellbeing and economic future of this region is in:
  • nurturing and developing its natural biodiversity;
  • enhancing regenerative agriculture practices, horticulture activities and farm gate enterprises;
  • promoting ecotourism and recreation pastimes; and
  • building a sustainable future less reliant on fossil fuels.  
 
To achieve this aim, I’ve asked the Andrew’s Government, the Coalition and the Victorian Greens to present a strategic management plan prior to this year’s state election.  To assist, I offered them my document: Western Port Strategic Management Plan – Starter Kit, August 2021.  In this case, the Western Port region comprises French Island, the four council areas bordering Western Port and Western Port itself.

The plan should be enshrined by an act of parliament and one that will thwart those seeking to industrialise and urbanise this environment.

It should be administered by one statutory authority.  Melbourne Water is best placed to undertake this task for it is now the sole authority responsible for catchment and waterways management across the Port Phillip and Western Port region.


*****
Calling for a strategic management plan is not new. Fifty years ago, the Save Western Port Coalition published a document titled The Shame of Western Port – Speculator’s Dream … Environmental Nightmare, July 1971.  You can order a copy through the West Gippsland Regional Library Corporation.

At the time, many were concerned about Western Port’s future, and their opening remarks in the document stated: “Sixteen organisations of the Save Western Port Coalition worked together to prepare this report.  We felt it was high time to reveal how the plan to destroy Western Port began, who will profit from it and how Australia will lose if it isn’t stopped.”

A legacy of this insightful statement is that one of the founding members of the coalition is still continuing its advocacy.  The Westernport & Peninsula Protection Council, which recently celebrated its 50th year, has published a chronological account of its environmental work. 
  
Unfortunately, despite the efforts of many, the never-ending struggle to protect this environment is still with us, and is likely to continue until such time as the people set the agenda.

In calling for this action, I am conscious of the fact that any “community resistance movement” relies on the dedication of a few to raise awareness of an issue, gather support and mount a campaign. 

I’m also aware that it’s so easy for a government, and for that matter the opposition, to sit on the fence and watch events unfold, only making a commitment if it’s politically expedient.   

But perhaps it is possible to change this endless cycle by empowering the community to state what it wants, set its policy agenda, and vote accordingly – and one organisation is showing the way.

Environment Victoria (EV) is conducting an online event known as “People Power Workshops”. So far, it has brought together a cohort of people from five regions across Victoria.  They are calling on their federal MPs and prospective candidates to initiate faster and fairer Australian climate action.

This political campaign is geared to effect change by building a community movement to address the issues of clean energy, cutting pollution and protecting the natural environment.   

Representing the Western Port region, the Western Port Climate Alliance is approaching businesses, community groups and individuals to sign their open letter.

Given Environment Victoria’s proactive approach to empowering the community, perhaps the Victorian National Parks Association (VNPA), now in the process of forming a new environmental group to protect the Western Port region, may like to consider the EV model.

At this stage, the group is made up of battle-hardened environmental veterans, including the Westernport & Peninsula Protection Council, the Save Westernport group and the Phillip Island Conservation Society.

It has formed a steering committee which is discussing the matter with the Western Port Biosphere Foundation, Save Western Port Woodlands, and Waterline community representatives and will soon announce a policy direction and a group name.

Once established, it is hoped the group will contact the councils bordering Western Port (Bass Coast, Cardinia, Casey and Mornington Peninsula) and also invite agricultural producers, local businesses and community associations to participate. It’s important that the policy platform is built on community-wide input and presents a united and a strategically orientated course of action.

Given that both Environment Victoria and the VNPA group are dealing with climate-related issues and are discussing the matter with the Bunurong Land Council Aboriginal Corporation, I hope they’ll find a way to work together and present a united front.
​
The more pressure that can be brought to bear on our political representatives, the less likely we are to lose another 50 years in securing what was once, and still is, an aspirational goal: “Western Port can be saved, in spite of all argument to the contrary.”  
9 Comments
Karri Giles link
27/1/2022 10:29:11 am

We do need to set the agenda. Preserving Westernport Woodlands achieves poliicies of The State Government, but they haven't acted yet. A Strategic Management Plan is a State Government tool that is in place for Port Phillip Bay, and that is achievable and desirable goal for we who are looking for consideration for WPBay.. Thank you Neil and Bass Coast Post. I encourage everyone to ask for one.

Reply
Jeff Nottle
28/1/2022 02:38:59 pm

Thanks Neil for highlighting the need to seek much better protections for Western Port. Defending such an important precinct from thought bubbles of exploitative industry and Government comes with a huge cost to the community. Strategic thinking for the best way forward is underway and community engagement will be a key component. Thanks again Neil and thanks to Bass Coast Post and your readers.

Reply
Neil Rankine
28/1/2022 10:31:31 pm

Thanks Neil, You really have your head screwed on correctly and a vision worth pursuing. If only our politicians would see the benefit and work in a bi-partisan manner to achieve this fundamental aim for our local area, Western Port and it's catchments.

Reply
Meryl & Hartley Tobin link
29/1/2022 10:50:10 pm

A thoughtful and positive approach to a huge environmental issue for not only residents of Bass Coast Shire and the rest of Western Port, but for other Victorians as well, Neil. Thank you. At last there seems some cause for optimism with many hundreds of people now standing up to be counted for the environment. Any politicians who hope to be re-elected at the next election are taking a big gamble if they think it safe to ignore the growing clamour to protect Western Port Bay and our precious and irreplaceable native flora and fauna, our other natural attractions and the biodiversity on which we depend for our own survival.

Reply
Anne Heath Mennell
31/1/2022 03:26:08 pm

Here here to all of the above comments. Thank you for your persistence, thoughtfulness and clear thinking, Neil. I'm hoping we are at a tipping point when concern for protecting this region will turn into action. With State and Federal elections this year we have to keep up the pressure - time is running out.

Reply
John Lippmann
1/2/2022 08:22:11 pm

Congratulations Neil on another well-measured and thought-provoking article highlighting the need for an appropriate strategic management plan for the protection of Westernport Bay. It is a unique and delicate ecosystem that can too easily be threatened by poorly planned, inappropriate development.

Reply
Meg
3/2/2022 03:27:13 pm

Wow Neil, a fabulous article. You have certainly nailed it. We need a tsunami of committed, passionate people dedicated to saving our precious Westernport environment, willing to "yell" at our politicians to take note of the urgency of the situation and put practical plans into action. Westernport has waited far too long and deserves a break; not to be sold out in the pursuit of the almighty dollar in the pretence of creating jobs and growth. The photograph of Hartley Tobin standing alongside that magnificent Old Man Grass Tree says it all. It's really insulting to people's intelligence if politicians think that by merely throwing a few empty dollars at a destroyed environment will "make it all better."

Reply
Julia Stockigt link
12/2/2022 02:54:50 pm

Thankyou for another wonderful article Neil. It highlights the need and local support for significant places like Westernport to have permanent protections under law, in the same way that people and even property are protected. Let’s hope the upcoming state election can be used to get some leverage for environmental protections in Victoria.

Reply
Julia
12/2/2022 03:10:27 pm

A pdf of the July 1971 Save Western Port Coalition publication titled ‘The Shame of Western Port – Speculator’s Dream … Environmental
Nightmare’ is available here:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1YLmnyxlbHfvnonmTd6mIQtrrFc2d19OR/view?usp=drivesdk

Reply



Leave a Reply.