Bass Coast Post
  • Home
    • Recent articles
  • Federal Election 2025
  • News
    • Point of view
    • View from the chamber
  • Writers
    • Anne Davie
    • Anne Heath Mennell
    • Bob Middleton
    • Carolyn Landon
    • Catherine Watson
    • Christine Grayden
    • Dick Wettenhall
    • Ed Thexton
    • Etsuko Yasunaga
    • Frank Coldebella
    • Gayle Marien
    • Geoff Ellis
    • Gill Heal
    • Harry Freeman
    • Ian Burns
    • Joan Woods
    • John Coldebella
    • Julie Paterson
    • Julie Statkus
    • Kit Sleeman
    • Laura Brearley >
      • Coastal Connections
    • Lauren Burns
    • Liane Arno
    • Linda Cuttriss
    • Linda Gordon
    • Lisa Schonberg
    • Liz Low
    • Marian Quigley
    • Mark Robertson
    • Mary Whelan
    • Meryl Brown Tobin
    • Michael Whelan
    • Mikhaela Barlow
    • Miriam Strickland
    • Natasha Williams-Novak
    • Neil Daly
    • Patsy Hunt
    • Pauline Wilkinson
    • Richard Kemp
    • Sally McNiece
    • Terri Allen
    • Tim Shannon
  • Features
    • Features 2024
    • Features 2023
    • Features 2022
    • Features 2021
    • Features 2020
    • Features 2019
    • Features 2018
    • Features 2017
    • Features 2016
    • Features 2015
    • Features 2014
    • Features 2013
    • Features 2012
  • Arts
  • Local history
  • Environment
  • Nature notes
    • Nature notes
  • A cook's journal
  • Community
    • Diary
    • Courses
    • Groups
    • Stories
  • Contact us

The winds of change

25/3/2021

7 Comments

 
PicturePhoto: Catherine Watson
By Robyn Arianrhod
 
LIKE many Bass Coast residents I floated out of Gill Heal’s Looking for Wonthaggi feeling uplifted and a little teary, still humming “There’s a part of my heart in Wonthaggi”. What a history our town has! Gill and her cast and crew did it proud. And what natural treasures we have in Bass Coast – treasures brought lovingly to stage and screen in another recent showcase of local talent, the Coastal Connections concert.
 
Yet underneath the euphoria, the delight of publicly sharing in this feast of theatre and film about our precious part of the world, I felt uneasy. Another song was running amok in my mind: Joni Mitchell’s Big Yellow Taxi, with its haunting warning: “Don’t it always seem to go / That you don’t know what you’ve got / Till it’s gone / They paved paradise / And put up a parking lot.” I couldn’t help wondering: do enough of us realise what we’ve got here?

Will the 10,000 new residents our planning authorities reckon will move here in the next 15 years care about Wonthaggi’s inspiring history? Will they do their bit to ensure this spirit lives on, even if only by adding to the friendly smiles we “locals” relish as we greet friendly strangers passing in the street and on the beach? And will they love – and care for – our blue and green spaces the way those of us who feel “Coastally Connected” do?
PicturePhoto: Morgan Blackthorne
I ask these questions because this is a crucial time for Bass Coast residents, especially in Wonthaggi. The planning powers have long had their eye on us, and while growth can be good if it means better hospitals and other services, I hope it will be handled sensitively. I’m not wildly hopeful. In the last few years I’ve seen quite a bit of paving of paradise here, with plans for more already approved by the council or VCAT.
 
Elsewhere, too, I’ve seen places I love diminished by greed and/or insensitive planning. I witnessed it when I lived near Gembrook, a tiny village set amid some truly stunning scenery. When I moved there many years ago, I loved going into the old corner store, where the proprietors always had time for a yarn, and perhaps a game of chess if you were up for it. There were no roadside postal deliveries, so you picked up your mail at the post office, which also provided banking facilities and a newsagency. With everyone picking up mail and newspapers, you were bound to meet someone you knew. The post office was a meeting place – so much so that when residents were asked if we wanted street deliveries of mail, we said no thanks. We knew we had something special.
 
Today I’m not so sure. Gembrook is still a beautiful place. Its population is still only about 2500 (compared with around 700 when I moved there), and I’m sure many residents feel a sense of community. (The tourist brochures suggest there is more café culture than there was a decade or so ago!) But bizarrely, Gembrook, like so many once-rural towns, is zoned as part of Melbourne. Not surprisingly, then, some residents feel – or accept – that Gembrook is no longer a village but a suburb.
 
I hope we don’t give away Wonthaggi’s identity, and that of our other Bass Coast towns. The March 2020 Bass Coast Distinctive Areas and Lands Discussion Paper highlights the “village feel” of the region’s settlements, although it assumes Wonthaggi will become a regional hub. Right now, though, Wonthaggi still feels like a community, a big village. We certainly notice the difference during holiday periods – the sudden crowds and lack of parking, and the frosty indifference in response to our habitual happy “hellos”.
 
As for Gembrook, it had two general stores back then, and I loved the slow pace of life they represented. Though I found it difficult to boycott for long the IGA supermarket that opened up. It was a difficult balancing act, as change always is. On the plus side, the IGA proprietor was unusually sensitive to the village atmosphere, quickly learning our names and what particular products we wanted him to stock. The down side was the inevitable demise of the general stores, and the butcher and green grocer.
 
Unfortunately, poor planning compounded this loss. The council had mandated in its permit permission that the supermarket and several new adjacent shops be set back from the road to allow off-street car parking directly in front of the new stores. That might have been a good idea for a larger town, but in Gembrook’s tiny “CBD” it created an ugly streetscape. Aside from the car park, the new brick shops were designed in a style at odds with the old timber buildings that still remained.

Wonthaggi has suffered the same fate. Take away a town’s distinctive visual coherence and identity and you start to erode the sense of pride in it. You can see it in Melbourne, too. Many of us who call Bass Coast home have lived in and loved our capital, but these days there are precious few remains of the Marvellous Melbourne of old, while its suburban sprawl seems to know little of taste and bounds. ​

Picture
Kate Raworth: Downscaling the Doughnut to the City
Our times offer some awesome opportunities to make dramatic positive changes. With the help of Regen Melbourne, the City of Melbourne is investigating downscaled (city-size) “doughnut economics”, the brainchild of economist Kate Raworth
​The Victorian Government is aware of the problem, according to its planning website. They recognize that the COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted the need for urban green spaces, and they say they will increase protection of the city’s green wedges.  

​Still, there are troubling signs. For us in the regions, these signs include the offloading of urban population problems to regional towns such as Wonthaggi, which has been described by bureaucrats as an “overflow” area for Melbourne. How insulting!

​We can grow well only if we have visionary – and sensitive – planners, artists and architects. And despite the best of political intent, not even Melbourne’s green wedges are safe: the Green Wedge Coalition, in its November 2020 Bulletin, expressed concern at the growing number of approvals for developments that do not meet GW guidelines.
​
Closer to home, Western Port's last remaining coastal forest is under threat from a Victorian Government proposal to fast-track vast sand mines to feed Melbourne’s construction boom.  It will mean losing unique woodland habitat and the threatened fauna and flora it supports, and place at risk a fragile coastal ecology on the edge of Ramsar wetlands. Although the forest corridor is not in a green wedge area, it is a significant feature of the Bass Coast Distinctive Area and Landscape that has been officially recognised by the State Government.
 
A group of determined Bass Coast residents are fighting to save this precious disappearing forest. To its credit, our council has taken the fight to Spring Street. As our deputy mayor, Cr Michael Whelan, put it, “We can’t continue this schizophrenic approach of saying Bass Coast is an environmental sweet spot and a mining mecca at the same time.”
 
Of course, governments are always trying to balance competing interests. It is a difficult job. But we need to be engaged with our communities and our environments – to be aware of what we value, so that we can act and vote accordingly. Otherwise, “you won’t know what you’ve got till it’s gone …”
 
And if you never knew it existed, how can you protect it? That’s why projects such as “Looking for Wonthaggi” and “Coastal Connections” are so important for passing on our history and our love for our special places. 
 
Let me end on a more positive – and thankful – note. In my experience as a relative newcomer to Wonthaggi, many long-time residents have responded to new arrivals in an unusually welcoming way. I see in this an echo of the old mining community spirit, and it makes me want to do my bit to keep it alive, and to be a part of this special place.
 
For if we take something for granted the best of it will surely slip away.

Our Bass Coast Our Future
What do you want for the future of Bass Coast? Your ideas will help shape the Council Plan 2021-25, Health and Wellbeing Plan 2021-25 long-term Community Vision and 10 Year Financial Plan. Opportunities to comment include drop-in sessions, an online survey and Facebook Q&A sessions. 
​
Picture
Baxters wetlands. Photo: Morgan Blackthorne
7 Comments
Neil Rankine
27/3/2021 09:19:15 am

I'm one of those submitting to and questioning at the Planning Panel set up by the government to advise the Minister on how he should decide the fate of a large chunk of the woodland corridor from Lang Lang to Grantville (our last woodland forest corridor). You have correctly stated that our Council has said what is proposed is unacceptable, we are not allowed to decide however, the Minister called it in. The state government have assured us that the Distinctive Areas and Landscape designation for Bass Coast will protect what's important here, however, at the Panel hearings the DAL as it's called cannot influence this area of sand recently added to a priority list of sand resource to build roads, bridges and overhead train lines for Melbourne. The Planning system is broken or our population policy is broken, maybe it's both.

Reply
rosemary loughnan
27/3/2021 09:59:12 am

The absolute neglect of Parks and Council and State government to preserve and promote the areas of the coal mining sites here is stunning. I am born and bred in Hicksborough and come from black coal mining here (both sides of my family) yet even though lives were lost and humans and animals worked under the most atrocious conditions I dont see the respect that they deserve...............Before we take off to be another suburb or the broader urban spread we need to rethink how it all began. PRESERVE WHAT IS LEFT, RESPECT AND EDUCATE

Reply
Michael Whelan
27/3/2021 10:44:04 am

Robyn You have your chance now to influence how Wonthaggi develops. Council deferred a decision on the Wonthaggi Activity Centre Plan at its last meeting it also sought further consultation. If I recall correctly the officers comments responded to just 39 submissions The attachments to the meeting agenda also include a report from Dr Elliot Fishman on active transport the discussion will be around how well the Activity Centre Plan picks up that work. The ball and the opportunity is in your court.

Reply
Joy Button
27/3/2021 10:49:38 am

Great article Catherine and so timely. Gill’s latest, Looking for Wonthaggi, was one of her best and would love to see it again!
I am also concerned at the rapid advancement of development in recent years and understand we need population growth to gain infrastructure, particularly library services in the Waterline townships, which have actually been reduced in 2020.
Libraries and librarians are a vital and necessary tool to encourage and develop reading and writing skills for future generations. Mental health and well being is important at present in our current generation.
A lot to weigh up but can we stop the rapid development …. I don’t think so but I dare to dream.

Reply
Linda Cuttriss
27/3/2021 02:55:10 pm

Great article Robyn. I don’t think Wonthaggi’s unique history and amazing human story is as widely known and appreciated as it could be. Thanks to Gill Heal for bringing those human stories to life on stage. I also left the theatre with a tear in my eye and a hope that the spirit of Wonthaggi will not be lost in a sea of suburban sprawl. I wonder what it takes for a place to grow yet still retain its character.

Reply
Neil Rankine
27/3/2021 03:39:54 pm

Commitment from its citizens I think Linda, and a determination to let the planners and decision makers know that commitment.

Reply
Robyn Arianrhod
10/4/2021 09:28:24 pm

Hear hear to Frank and all of the other comments here: now is our chance to make Wonthaggi really special, creating a vibrant, people-friendly centre in our town that will be great for locals, visitors and traders alike.

Reply



Leave a Reply.